A great wave of compelling dystopian glory
I have to say this dystopian story grabbed me almost straight away. It’s got a great premise I’ve not seen before (if you discount mermaids and Aquaman, and that is a stretch): post-human worlds where smart sea monsters inherit the remnants of our civilisation, upon which they will build their own world. There was a lot going on from the start: discovery, power struggles, disparate factions: I found it instantly gripping while being unpredictable. This book is a blend of adventure, politics, philosophy, and more, all bound together with a tension that kept the pages turning. I loved the way the stakes rose progressively and felt rewarded each time I picked it back up.
I was really impressed wiht the vividness of the setting, which brought this underwater society to life. I could hear the bustle of the cities, feel the pressure of the fathoms of water above, all while cephalopods struggled with morality and crabs plotted to gain power. It was a joy to understand characters like Motley and Crabiscus as they made their way through sea-creature ambitions, fears and struggles.
Beneath all of the spectacle (and it is terribly vivid), this book works as it holds up a mirror to our world, exploring the greed, corruption and inevitable environmental collapse (and any other of the myriad global issues). Charlie Trout ably manages themes like leadership, resource control and the fragility of civilisation throughout, prompting reflection on real-world problems. Some might feel a little heavy-handed, but they are always thoughtful, even if unsettling.
So in Oceantopia, we have a super mix of underwater world-building, sea-creature politicking and some pretty emotional stuff to boot, and it all crashes together in a great wave of compelling dystopian glory. This is strange, this is creative and awfully ambitious, and I loved it.