Media Justice is the third installment of Dennis Carstens’ Marc Kadella “Justice” series. In this chapter, criminal defense lawyer Kadella is engaged to defend Brittany, a 21-year-old accused of murdering her adorable 2-year-old daughter. Carstens sets up the circumstances of the case, while telling the reader up front that Brittany is innocent (not a spoiler), but the circumstances surrounding the little girl’s death certainly make her look bad. The real killer set things up well, although he could not have known in advance that Brittany would fail to report the abduction of her daughter to the police until ten days afterwards and would be caught on Facebook partying with her girlfriends, making it look like she was happy after her daughter was gone. The real point of the story, however, is not the investigation and ultimately the trial of Brittany, but rather the role of the sensationalistic tabloid media in fanning the flames of the public and convicting Brittany on television long before any evidence was presented in court, and then misrepresenting the events of the trial so that the public believed Brittany to be guilty no matter what.
Carstens brings back the familiar cast of characters from the prior books in this series, including his investigator, Maddy, in whose presence all males become slack-jawed teenagers; Tony, his PI friend and former cop, whose love interest is a wealthy socialite; Margaret, Marc’s love interest and a judge; and even a few minor characters from earlier books who provide some color. The story is interesting, although knowing that Brittany is innocent takes away much of the suspense (other than whether Marc will be able to induce a not guilty verdict or whether Brittany will be unfairly and unjustly convicted based on the bias of the media). The attack-job on the media sometimes goes a little too far and becomes a bit repetitive, but the point is made – don’t ever believe what you read or see on TV about legal cases.
Carstens’ stories are intricate and he sets up the situation here very well. The execution of the trial, which takes up the final third of the book, includes many elements that are a bit too convenient, including Marc’s ability to find the key evidence and key witnesses that the prosecution missed, even though it was fairly obvious. The incompetent police and prosecutors sometimes come off as buffoonish and make it easy for Kadella to be the hero. Then, the “surprise” ending sequence, like one of the earlier books, feels gratuitous and unnecessary as well as less believable than the rest of the story.
But, despite these flaws, the story is compelling and interesting to read, making the book worth the read. I will go on reading this series because of the characters and the stories, despite the problems.