What a neat surprise this was. There’s a bookstore in my office building, and one day I stopped in and Joe Salerno, who is a local author, was doing an event for this book and its predecessor, The Decision. Although Million Dollar Men is a sequel, I was much more sold on it as apparently more of a mystery than The Decision, and the author was adamant that he wrote Million Dollar Men to function as a standalone novel. While there are many references to what I assume to be the events of The Decision, it absolutely did stand on its own.
Million Dollar Men is, at least initially, a whodunit thriller about an arson that kills a family of four in an otherwise quaint Massachusetts suburb. When the local police assign a lazy, misogynistic, casually cruel detective to the case, he wastes no time following clearly planted clues to arrest ex-convict Brian MacMillan, who has motive, means, opportunity, a past arson conviction, and no alibi—but is passionate about his innocence. Enter our heroes, Brian’s public defender Walt and Walt’s friend MJ, an investigative reporter whom Walt is flirtatious with. Walt, MJ, and Brian together untangle a web of corruption that goes in some absolutely wild directions.
I really admire how fleshed out, flawed, and believable the characters are in this book. While some people are clearly worse than others, just about everyone in here is capable of both good and bad. MJ is a particularly fun character to root for. But Brian is the emotional core of the book, to me: an ex-convict whose teenage malfeasance landed him in prison for years, working hard to get his life on track as an adult but constantly beaten back from doing so by corrupt men in powerful positions. Brian is so damaged by the powers that be that he spends most of the book being skeptical that Walt or MJ can really help him or even that they care about him at all, even as Walt puts almost everything else in his life on hold to focus on Brian’s case.
This book is very good. My one criticism is that there are some literary devices that seem to exist for the sake of plot convenience—in particular, MJ relies multiple times on “the team,” a group of super-hackers who can apparently obtain any covert information of interest for her. The James Bond/Mission Impossible-esque nature of MJ’s interactions with “the team” is fun, but it bothered me that we essentially get nothing on how they operate or why they care about MJ or why MJ trusts them. I assume some of this is covered in The Decision—a book I now intend to also read.
If you like tense mysteries, believe that prisons don’t provide justice and that everyone deserves to live and have the opportunity to grow and do better for themselves and others, and can stomach some mildly gross plot twists, you’ll probably like this book a lot.