What do you think?
Rate this book
Unexpected
In the glittering world of 1895 Philadelphia, where reputations can shatter with a whisper, love may be the most unexpected risk of all.
Zella Capp has built her life on independence and a carefully guarded secret. When she’s offered the chance to lead an ambitious new fashion publication for Denwall Department Stores, Zella is thrust into the heart of Philadelphia’s elite, where every glance is a test, and every word could be a weapon. As she navigates dazzling society events and unpredictable printing presses, she finds herself drawn to the enigmatic Bert Walraven, a guarded executive who prefers numbers to notoriety and whose recent brush with danger has left him more protective than ever.
When anonymous threats and sabotage threaten Zella’s hard-won success, she and Bert must confront the pasts they’ve tried to bury. For Zella, that means facing the truth about who she really is. For Bert, it means learning that playing it safe may cost him more than he’s willing to lose.
In a world obsessed with appearances, can they risk everything for a love that’s real?
A story of romance, resilience, and the power of faith, Unexpected is filled with heart, wit, and the courage to step into the light.
Perfect for fans grumpy and sunshine dynamics, hidden identities, workplace rivals-to-lovers, maternal matchmakers, fiercely competent heroines
Part of a series but can be read as a stand-alone.
Zella Capp has built her life on independence and a carefully guarded secret. When she’s offered the chance to lead an ambitious new fashion publication for Denwall Department Stores, Zella is thrust into the heart of Philadelphia’s elite, where every glance is a test, and every word could be a weapon. As she navigates dazzling society events and unpredictable printing presses, she finds herself drawn to the enigmatic Bert Walraven, a guarded executive who prefers numbers to notoriety and whose recent brush with danger has left him more protective than ever.
When anonymous threats and sabotage threaten Zella’s hard-won success, she and Bert must confront the pasts they’ve tried to bury. For Zella, that means facing the truth about who she really is. For Bert, it means learning that playing it safe may cost him more than he’s willing to lose.
In a world obsessed with appearances, can they risk everything for a love that’s real?
A story of romance, resilience, and the power of faith, Unexpected is filled with heart, wit, and the courage to step into the light.
Perfect for fans grumpy and sunshine dynamics, hidden identities, workplace rivals-to-lovers, maternal matchmakers, fiercely competent heroines
Part of a series but can be read as a stand-alone.
246 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 23, 2025
14 people are currently reading
800 people want to read
About the author
Kimberly Keagan
6 books43 followersAt the age of thirteen, Kimberly Keagan discovered romance novels. Whenever possible, she ignored her chores in favor of a book she couldn't put down. In time, she earned a degree in accounting and enjoyed a brief career in investor relations, writing financial reports and press releases—terrific jobs, but not very romantic. By God's grace, she married her own handsome hero and raised two wonderful children. Now, she is following her long-held dream of penning historical romance. Her debut novel releases in 2025.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
September 28, 2025
This captivating and beautiful historical fiction novel is set against the backdrop of the 1890's Philadelphia. I for one was very impressed with how the story turned out and I enjoyed every minute of it. It is amazing how back then there were so many pressures put on women to discourage them from persuing "man only" opportunities and when they decided to follow through with their dreams they were publicly shamed for it. However, this follows the journey of one young woman who vows to overcome and make something of herself.
We are introduced to Zella who is hired at a department store to develop a new catalog. She has the most interesting work history such as writing articles and being well traveled. However, there are those who seek to ruin her because of their jealous nature. However, despite her enemies she manages to find friendship in kind young man named Bert. However, when the threats against Zella become worse it will take more than just friendship to put an end to the danger the lurks around.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and all opinions are of my own.
We are introduced to Zella who is hired at a department store to develop a new catalog. She has the most interesting work history such as writing articles and being well traveled. However, there are those who seek to ruin her because of their jealous nature. However, despite her enemies she manages to find friendship in kind young man named Bert. However, when the threats against Zella become worse it will take more than just friendship to put an end to the danger the lurks around.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and all opinions are of my own.
October 5, 2025
Very good!
Full review will be posted soon, God willing. :)
Full review will be posted soon, God willing. :)
Currently reading
July 19, 2025I'm thrilled to share that Unexpected is almost ready! I just submitted changes from the first line edit and am doing one final pass before it heads to the proofreader on July 29.
Want to be an early reader? I'm now accepting ARC requests:
👉 https://www.kimberlykeagan.com/arc-re...
Want to be an early reader? I'm now accepting ARC requests:
👉 https://www.kimberlykeagan.com/arc-re...
January 18, 2026
This is book 2 of Hearts on Display. Here's my review of book 1.
{232 print pages}
Genre: Romance, historical
Tropes: False identity, workplace tension, class difference
Setting: Gilded Age Manhattan
Writing style: Dual POV, except for a third POV in three chapters; 3rd person, past tense
Character- or plot-driven: Mostly character-driven
Romance: Yes
Clean level: 1 mouth kiss lightly described, 1 barely described, 1 with zero description. 1 instance of man rubbing circles on a woman's palm with his thumb. 1 instance “Although he didn't want to be caught staring at her chest.”
*This book has more explicitely Christian elements than the first. There are two Church sermons, one which mentions Jesus and one which includes a passage from the book of Isaiah. Another Hebrew Bible verse is mentioned and there is one other mention of “Christ.” On Christmas, which is referred to as “holiest of nights,” they read from the book of Luke (one line quoted) and sing Silent Night, Holy Night.
Favorite aspects of the book:
• The characters
• The richness in themes
Thoughts on main characters: It was a pleasure to get to know Zella and Bert more intimately. They have some good people around them who lend their wisdom to help each through their respective roadblocks.
There is a somewhat wild subplot towards the end that you won’t see coming.
The pairing of Zella and Bert in this book is intentional — they mirror each other in their fear of being inadequate in some way. Zella exudes confidence, but beneath the surface lies a deep-seated doubt, born from a lie she believed as a child, repeated over and over by one of the two people whose opinion held the most weight — her father. The author of the threatening letters she receives seems somehow to sense this insecurity and exploits it, causing her to interpret each act of sabotage as evidence of her own mistakes — feeding the very doubt that shakes her confidence.
Bert’s insecurity is of an entirely different nature, borne from a recent trauma. The mugging that landed him in the hospital in the first book shook him up profoundly. The powerlessness he experienced being caught off guard pushes him to overcorrect. Taking up boxing is a responsible way to build situational awareness and tighten reflexes, but instead of simply gathering such tools strategically to prevent a recurrence, he becomes emotionally distanced and begins trying to control every variable of his relationships.
At the heart of both Zella’s and Bert’s struggles is the fear that they aren’t equipped to succeed in the roles they try to play. Zella fears not only that she isn’t truly good enough to succeed in her field, but that she doesn’t even belong in the room to begin with. Bert, on the other hand, is haunted by the fact that he failed to stop something he believes he should have seen coming.
These doubts manifest in the same way: a need for total control. Zella tries to manage perception, performance, and outcomes in her job; while Bert focuses on controlling emotions, relationships, and every possible variable in his environment. Ultimately, both use control as a shield — Zella closing herself off from the possibility of finding a man she truly wants to build a life with, and Bert guarding his emotions and keeping others at a distance — making genuine connection difficult despite their developing need for each other.
Zella’s identity in the first book as a briefly married widow is revealed to be a sham — something even her niece and dearest friend is unaware of. This presents the moral complexity of a choice that, while technically wrong, carries a greater context that reshapes how the action reflects on Zella’s character. The automatic reaction of Bert and the greater society is that her deception makes her a dishonest person. But a couple characters demonstrate a deeper understanding of what truly motivated her actions — they recognize her drives for self-preservation, the need to be taken seriously, and the need for basic acceptance.
When the situation is taken out of Zella’s hands, one understanding character offers her a way to reclaim control — not by hiding from the backlash, but by owning her actions. Writing openly about how she came to make the choice she did, showing other women who are faced with similar challenges that they are seen and their struggles acknowledged. Offering those outside her experience a glimpse into the impossible situations women like her are often forced to navigate. Zella is given a rare kind of gift in this moment: accountability with support.
____________________________________
Yes! This is a really important point. A person has influences other than his parents, and ultimately he is his own person making his own choices.
Favorite Quotations:
• “And Max? Is that short for Maxwell? Honestly, I don’t recall a Maxwell among Victoria’s brood.” The room erupted in laughter, and Max shrugged a shoulder. “No, it’s just Max. I was named after my mother’s beloved childhood dog.”
• This wasn’t her first time presenting ideas to executives or having her work scrutinized like a bug under a magnifying glass.
• “You sing well.” Zella blinked. “Pardon?” “I could hear you in there,” he clarified. “You sing well.” “Thank you. And you sing with enthusiasm.” “Ah, yes. I’ve been asked several times to join the church choir.” Zella enjoyed Bert’s quick wit. “I’m sure you have.”
• “You’ve got dark circles under your eyes.” Zella straightened. “Thank you for that.” “It wasn’t an insult.” “Dark circles,” she said with mock offense, “are for elderly aunts and overworked matrons. I prefer to think of them as evidence of brilliance and industry.” “That sounds like something you’d embroider on a pillow,” [Bert] muttered.
• “You know,” she said dryly, “if we’re both spending New Year’s Eve working, we might be considered more tragic than industrious.”
• “Miss Donovan, although one of the loveliest young women in Philadelphia, has about as much intelligence as a turnip.” Bert let out a low whistle. “No holds barred there, my friend.” “I said she was lovely.” Max grinned his signature, female heart-breaker smile. “But I don’t enjoy conversations that feel like I’m teaching a lamb to read.”
• Zella turned and stared at Lena. Her new friend was like an onion, with layers that, when peeled back, just revealed more layers.
• As she moved to leave, Alix leaned in again. “If anyone orders you around one more time, I’ll stage a fainting spell and knock over several floral arrangements to cause a commotion. Just say the word.” “Tempting,” Zella murmured.
• “I see you as someone who belongs anywhere she wants to stand.”
• Zella found her resolve hardening. Someone wanted her to fail. But they had underestimated one crucial thing. She didn’t stand alone.
• “We don’t often like to admit when we’re brokenhearted,” the pastor continued. “Even less when we feel crushed. We’re proud creatures. Capable. Resilient. Especially those of us who’ve been told we have to be.” Zella’s fingers tightened slightly. “But God doesn’t measure worth by resilience. He doesn’t wait for us to come to Him strong. He comes close when we’re beaten down. He draws near when we’re unsure of our own value. And he sets us free.”
• “One must be ever so careful when climbing into society’s good graces. Such heights, after all, make any tumble quite the spectacle.”
• “Well,” she sputtered, “I’m just questioning whether this is the best place for Miss Abbott to dine.” “I would think it’s the perfect place for her to be. In fact, she’s probably better than this place deserves if you are any indication of its clientele.”
• He swung his legs up on the velvet cushions. “Make yourself at home,” Bert grumbled. Max grinned. “I always do.”
• Florence had always said Quentin was restless. “A beautiful disappointment,” she once called him, half laughing. “The kind of son who has the look of an angel while he waits for you to die so he can collect the silver.”
• “Penny for your thoughts?” Bert tapped Zella’s shoulder with his. “They’d cost more than that today.”
(I received a free ARC of this book via Booksprout and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)
{232 print pages}
Genre: Romance, historical
Tropes: False identity, workplace tension, class difference
Setting: Gilded Age Manhattan
Writing style: Dual POV, except for a third POV in three chapters; 3rd person, past tense
Character- or plot-driven: Mostly character-driven
Romance: Yes
Clean level: 1 mouth kiss lightly described, 1 barely described, 1 with zero description. 1 instance of man rubbing circles on a woman's palm with his thumb. 1 instance “Although he didn't want to be caught staring at her chest.”
*This book has more explicitely Christian elements than the first. There are two Church sermons, one which mentions Jesus and one which includes a passage from the book of Isaiah. Another Hebrew Bible verse is mentioned and there is one other mention of “Christ.” On Christmas, which is referred to as “holiest of nights,” they read from the book of Luke (one line quoted) and sing Silent Night, Holy Night.
Favorite aspects of the book:
• The characters
• The richness in themes
Thoughts on main characters: It was a pleasure to get to know Zella and Bert more intimately. They have some good people around them who lend their wisdom to help each through their respective roadblocks.
There is a somewhat wild subplot towards the end that you won’t see coming.
The pairing of Zella and Bert in this book is intentional — they mirror each other in their fear of being inadequate in some way. Zella exudes confidence, but beneath the surface lies a deep-seated doubt, born from a lie she believed as a child, repeated over and over by one of the two people whose opinion held the most weight — her father. The author of the threatening letters she receives seems somehow to sense this insecurity and exploits it, causing her to interpret each act of sabotage as evidence of her own mistakes — feeding the very doubt that shakes her confidence.
Bert’s insecurity is of an entirely different nature, borne from a recent trauma. The mugging that landed him in the hospital in the first book shook him up profoundly. The powerlessness he experienced being caught off guard pushes him to overcorrect. Taking up boxing is a responsible way to build situational awareness and tighten reflexes, but instead of simply gathering such tools strategically to prevent a recurrence, he becomes emotionally distanced and begins trying to control every variable of his relationships.
At the heart of both Zella’s and Bert’s struggles is the fear that they aren’t equipped to succeed in the roles they try to play. Zella fears not only that she isn’t truly good enough to succeed in her field, but that she doesn’t even belong in the room to begin with. Bert, on the other hand, is haunted by the fact that he failed to stop something he believes he should have seen coming.
These doubts manifest in the same way: a need for total control. Zella tries to manage perception, performance, and outcomes in her job; while Bert focuses on controlling emotions, relationships, and every possible variable in his environment. Ultimately, both use control as a shield — Zella closing herself off from the possibility of finding a man she truly wants to build a life with, and Bert guarding his emotions and keeping others at a distance — making genuine connection difficult despite their developing need for each other.
Zella’s identity in the first book as a briefly married widow is revealed to be a sham — something even her niece and dearest friend is unaware of. This presents the moral complexity of a choice that, while technically wrong, carries a greater context that reshapes how the action reflects on Zella’s character. The automatic reaction of Bert and the greater society is that her deception makes her a dishonest person. But a couple characters demonstrate a deeper understanding of what truly motivated her actions — they recognize her drives for self-preservation, the need to be taken seriously, and the need for basic acceptance.
When the situation is taken out of Zella’s hands, one understanding character offers her a way to reclaim control — not by hiding from the backlash, but by owning her actions. Writing openly about how she came to make the choice she did, showing other women who are faced with similar challenges that they are seen and their struggles acknowledged. Offering those outside her experience a glimpse into the impossible situations women like her are often forced to navigate. Zella is given a rare kind of gift in this moment: accountability with support.
____________________________________
Zella nodded slowly. A strange quiet settled inside her. Not peace, exactly. Relief warred with sadness. Sadness for Florence that her son would turn out to be such a wastrel. Not everything can be blamed on one’s parents. Some people were just rotten.
Yes! This is a really important point. A person has influences other than his parents, and ultimately he is his own person making his own choices.
Favorite Quotations:
• “And Max? Is that short for Maxwell? Honestly, I don’t recall a Maxwell among Victoria’s brood.” The room erupted in laughter, and Max shrugged a shoulder. “No, it’s just Max. I was named after my mother’s beloved childhood dog.”
• This wasn’t her first time presenting ideas to executives or having her work scrutinized like a bug under a magnifying glass.
• “You sing well.” Zella blinked. “Pardon?” “I could hear you in there,” he clarified. “You sing well.” “Thank you. And you sing with enthusiasm.” “Ah, yes. I’ve been asked several times to join the church choir.” Zella enjoyed Bert’s quick wit. “I’m sure you have.”
• “You’ve got dark circles under your eyes.” Zella straightened. “Thank you for that.” “It wasn’t an insult.” “Dark circles,” she said with mock offense, “are for elderly aunts and overworked matrons. I prefer to think of them as evidence of brilliance and industry.” “That sounds like something you’d embroider on a pillow,” [Bert] muttered.
• “You know,” she said dryly, “if we’re both spending New Year’s Eve working, we might be considered more tragic than industrious.”
• “Miss Donovan, although one of the loveliest young women in Philadelphia, has about as much intelligence as a turnip.” Bert let out a low whistle. “No holds barred there, my friend.” “I said she was lovely.” Max grinned his signature, female heart-breaker smile. “But I don’t enjoy conversations that feel like I’m teaching a lamb to read.”
• Zella turned and stared at Lena. Her new friend was like an onion, with layers that, when peeled back, just revealed more layers.
• As she moved to leave, Alix leaned in again. “If anyone orders you around one more time, I’ll stage a fainting spell and knock over several floral arrangements to cause a commotion. Just say the word.” “Tempting,” Zella murmured.
• “I see you as someone who belongs anywhere she wants to stand.”
• Zella found her resolve hardening. Someone wanted her to fail. But they had underestimated one crucial thing. She didn’t stand alone.
• “We don’t often like to admit when we’re brokenhearted,” the pastor continued. “Even less when we feel crushed. We’re proud creatures. Capable. Resilient. Especially those of us who’ve been told we have to be.” Zella’s fingers tightened slightly. “But God doesn’t measure worth by resilience. He doesn’t wait for us to come to Him strong. He comes close when we’re beaten down. He draws near when we’re unsure of our own value. And he sets us free.”
• “One must be ever so careful when climbing into society’s good graces. Such heights, after all, make any tumble quite the spectacle.”
• “Well,” she sputtered, “I’m just questioning whether this is the best place for Miss Abbott to dine.” “I would think it’s the perfect place for her to be. In fact, she’s probably better than this place deserves if you are any indication of its clientele.”
• He swung his legs up on the velvet cushions. “Make yourself at home,” Bert grumbled. Max grinned. “I always do.”
• Florence had always said Quentin was restless. “A beautiful disappointment,” she once called him, half laughing. “The kind of son who has the look of an angel while he waits for you to die so he can collect the silver.”
• “Penny for your thoughts?” Bert tapped Zella’s shoulder with his. “They’d cost more than that today.”
(I received a free ARC of this book via Booksprout and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)
September 29, 2025
I absolutely am loving this series by a new (to me) author! In "Unexpected", Zella and Bert knew each other because his brother and her niece were engaged to be married (see Book #1, "Perfect"). Bert came from a well-to-do family, and Zella had a long-hidden secret about her past. Her family was not wealthy, and she was living on her own by age 18. They say opposites attract, & Zella and Bert were as opposite as satin & fur. Yet feelings between the two begin to grow. Zella is hired to spearhead an ambitious new publication for Denwall Department Stores and is suddenly thrust into Philadelphia's high society among the gossiping high society ladies. With deadlines, office sabotage, and little time for rest, why is she drawn to Bert Walraven? The two work well alongside each other, but when a stranger comes in the night, bearing gifts for Zella, she senses something is off and goes to investigate, plunging herself into extreme danger. Will she escape with her life? And who is sabotaging her work at the office? Will Zella's long-kept secret come to exposure? And how will Bert respond when he finds out the truth?
I thoroughly enjoyed this book as well as this series with its cast of characters, suspense, and so much more! The supporting characters were wonderful. Lena was a good friend of Zella's, and Max's insight was encouraging for Bert. I highly recommend this clean gilded-age romance and am looking forward to reading the next book in the "Hearts on Display" series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and have voluntarily given my honest opinion in this review.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book as well as this series with its cast of characters, suspense, and so much more! The supporting characters were wonderful. Lena was a good friend of Zella's, and Max's insight was encouraging for Bert. I highly recommend this clean gilded-age romance and am looking forward to reading the next book in the "Hearts on Display" series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book and have voluntarily given my honest opinion in this review.
October 15, 2025
I love the Gilded Age and this book immerses you right in Philadelphia high society! Single woman Zella Abbot has been passing herself off as the widow of fictitious Jeremiah Capp so she can achieve her dream of being a female correspondent. She has achieved a level of fame writing fashion, interior decorating and New Woman pieces for major newspapers and magazines.
Bert Walraven is the chief financial officer for his family's expanding company of Denwall department stores. His younger brother is engaged to Zella's niece Ivy and his family has welcomed both Ivy and Zella into the fold. When a promotional magazine project is proposed for the department stores, Zella is tapped to head it up. Can she and Bert keep from coming to blows long enough to complete the project on time and within his stringent budget?
Bert and Zella are such a great couple! There is so much chemistry between them that neither wants to acknowledge. Everyone else knows they are perfect for each other, but they fight to the finish to stay single and unattached as each considers themselves married to their careers. There is a lot of action along the way with backstabbing both socially and in the corporate world. This was a really fun read and I hated to see it come to an end. I can't wait to read the rest of the series as the siblings of both Denwall families (the Walravens and Dennisons) get their shot at HEA.
I read an advance copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Bert Walraven is the chief financial officer for his family's expanding company of Denwall department stores. His younger brother is engaged to Zella's niece Ivy and his family has welcomed both Ivy and Zella into the fold. When a promotional magazine project is proposed for the department stores, Zella is tapped to head it up. Can she and Bert keep from coming to blows long enough to complete the project on time and within his stringent budget?
Bert and Zella are such a great couple! There is so much chemistry between them that neither wants to acknowledge. Everyone else knows they are perfect for each other, but they fight to the finish to stay single and unattached as each considers themselves married to their careers. There is a lot of action along the way with backstabbing both socially and in the corporate world. This was a really fun read and I hated to see it come to an end. I can't wait to read the rest of the series as the siblings of both Denwall families (the Walravens and Dennisons) get their shot at HEA.
I read an advance copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 2, 2025
Unexpected is the second book in Kimberly Keagan’s Hearts on Display series, set in the Gilded Age. I very much enjoy the setting in a time where life was a little simpler and honor was more valued. The world is well crafted and believable, and I liked getting to know the characters, watching them grow, and learning more about their background. I also appreciate the faith elements which felt natural and fitting for the situation.
In general, I also enjoyed the romantic interactions and watching the two balance each other and open up. I was a little disappointed to see the character’s lack of trust in each other after they had developed feelings. This somewhat undermines my feelings of their relationship. I also found one of the characters to be a little dense to not recognize the sabotage, or walking into a dangerous situation. These drop the rating slightly, I’d give it about a 4.5, so I’ll round up to 5.
Overall though, this was an enjoyable read. A good second book by the author, and I’m looking forward to seeing more of her work.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
In general, I also enjoyed the romantic interactions and watching the two balance each other and open up. I was a little disappointed to see the character’s lack of trust in each other after they had developed feelings. This somewhat undermines my feelings of their relationship. I also found one of the characters to be a little dense to not recognize the sabotage, or walking into a dangerous situation. These drop the rating slightly, I’d give it about a 4.5, so I’ll round up to 5.
Overall though, this was an enjoyable read. A good second book by the author, and I’m looking forward to seeing more of her work.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 19, 2025
Unexpected is a deeply compelling story that shines a light on the quiet but pervasive struggles women face when their choices are confined by societal limitations. Zella’s journey, in particular, highlights the way external expectations and class boundaries restrict opportunity and shape identity. The novel does an excellent job of illustrating how these pressures create both resilience and heartache, making Zella’s growth all the more moving.What stood out most to me was the contrast between the closeness of certain families and the isolation Zella had long experienced. This stark difference underscored not just the emotional weight of belonging, but also the sharp awareness gaps between classes—a subtle reminder of how privilege can blind one group to the hardships of another.This was a thoughtful, layered read that balances social commentary with engaging storytelling. My only wish was for certain threads to be explored more fully, which is why I place it at four rather than five stars. Still, it is a book that lingers in your mind after the last page.Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
August 4, 2025
Zella is being hired by DenWall department store to develop a new catalog. This is very unique for a woman to be put in charge of such a project. Her neice is marrying into one of the families of the DenWall department store. Zella is unususal as a career woman during that time period. She has written many articles and is well travelled. As an outspoken woman, there are many against her.
Bert is the son of one of the founders and loves dealing with numbers but not so much with people.
I love how fiesty Zella is but she is hiding a secret. It may come back to bite her. Bert has many hangups and needs time to work through them. His mother is very helpful along with a good friend. The family dynamics made this story even more of a pleasure to read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Bert is the son of one of the founders and loves dealing with numbers but not so much with people.
I love how fiesty Zella is but she is hiding a secret. It may come back to bite her. Bert has many hangups and needs time to work through them. His mother is very helpful along with a good friend. The family dynamics made this story even more of a pleasure to read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 16, 2025
A beautiful love story that surpassed my expectations! I enjoy historical fiction, and this one gives an uncommon glimpse into the Gilded Age world. It also shows the importance of family- both the imprinting of a father’s critical words, and the healing that comes with a mother’s words of wisdom. Bert and Zella are deeply interesting characters, and it’s clear from their initial sparks that this will be an unusual friendship. I love that eventually the masks and gloves come off! Can’t wait for the next gem in this series. I received a free copy of this book via BookSirens and was not required to post a review.
September 26, 2025
Love this story! Zella’s character is outwardly so strong, but the reader gets to see beneath the surface, to see the battles she is facing, due to hidden traumas brought about by a less than happy childhood.
Likewise, Bert is struggling with fears from an attack (which took place in the previous book). Bert is uncomfortable by how outspoken and opinionated Zella is, so the two of them are often at odds. So Zella is surprised when Bert comes to her defense when someone tries to sabotage her hard work at the company- and as feelings between them begin to grow, Zella is faced with having to be honest with everyone- including Bert and her own family- about her past, even knowing it means risking losing everything.
Likewise, Bert is struggling with fears from an attack (which took place in the previous book). Bert is uncomfortable by how outspoken and opinionated Zella is, so the two of them are often at odds. So Zella is surprised when Bert comes to her defense when someone tries to sabotage her hard work at the company- and as feelings between them begin to grow, Zella is faced with having to be honest with everyone- including Bert and her own family- about her past, even knowing it means risking losing everything.
September 29, 2025
This is the second book of the series and the first book I read from this author. I assume there are characters that overlap, but it can be read as a standalone. I thought it was a little bit of a slow build for the first part of the book, but it definitely picked up momentum about midpoint. I found the characters to be intriguing and engaging. It is a clean, wholesome romance with some Christian elements. I will definitely be checking out some of this authors, other books. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
September 30, 2025
This clean, historical romance is set in 1800s Philadelphia where Zella hides secrets that will be unearthed along with mysterious threats that try to up end her new work and the growing feelings towards the man she is drawn too.
Throughly enjoyed the characters as it is a standalone novel but possibly would be better to read the first book for a fuller reading experience (it sounds good too!).
Well researched and well rounded characters gives great depth to the story along with the emotions which carry the reader along with Zella and Bert.
Highly recommended!
Received this as an Advanced Reader Copy from BookSirens and this is my own opinion given voluntarily.
Throughly enjoyed the characters as it is a standalone novel but possibly would be better to read the first book for a fuller reading experience (it sounds good too!).
Well researched and well rounded characters gives great depth to the story along with the emotions which carry the reader along with Zella and Bert.
Highly recommended!
Received this as an Advanced Reader Copy from BookSirens and this is my own opinion given voluntarily.
August 14, 2025
Unexpected is Book 2 in the Hearts on Display by Kimberly Keagan. I thought the characters were authentic and I enjoyed reading this romance. Zella is vibrant and Bert is definitely enjoys numbers to people. Of course, the road to love is bumpy and both characters are reserved. Can they overcome obstacles to love? Unexpected is just the book to relax and escape. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
November 4, 2025
Another great book by Kimberly Keagan.
I received a free advance copy and am leaving a review voluntarily.
Book two in the series, Unexpected has some unexpected story tropes for a historical novel.
A MFC who is older than the MMC.
An independent MFC who lives alone and has a job.
A MMC who doesn't want a relationship.
All of these tropes combine into a delightful read that, while end as expected, leads the reader on an unexpected journey involving sabotage, scandal, and a swoon worthy rescue. Unexpected is a romantic read with enough mystery to keep any reader engaged.
I received a free advance copy and am leaving a review voluntarily.
Book two in the series, Unexpected has some unexpected story tropes for a historical novel.
A MFC who is older than the MMC.
An independent MFC who lives alone and has a job.
A MMC who doesn't want a relationship.
All of these tropes combine into a delightful read that, while end as expected, leads the reader on an unexpected journey involving sabotage, scandal, and a swoon worthy rescue. Unexpected is a romantic read with enough mystery to keep any reader engaged.
July 31, 2025
This is my voluntary review of a copy I was given.
These main characters seem so mismatched at the outset until you see the insecurity they are both hiding.
It takes an extreme situation for them to realize how they feel for the other, and a while longer before they get the nerve to declare their feelings.
The whole story was enjoyable.
These main characters seem so mismatched at the outset until you see the insecurity they are both hiding.
It takes an extreme situation for them to realize how they feel for the other, and a while longer before they get the nerve to declare their feelings.
The whole story was enjoyable.
September 23, 2025
Another good book in this series. Great strong female lead character who is a trailblazer in her time. Romance is not the main genre until the last half of the book. Great world building and believable characters. Look forward to the next book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 2, 2025
I loved this story, with Bert's quiet steadfastness and Zella's determination. I was rooting for them from the beginning and found the ending quite satisfying. There were many quotes I wanted to highlight and hold onto. Kimberly creates a world I felt in the middle of with her descriptions and witty dialogue. Highly recommend.
August 20, 2025
I have never read any of this authors books. I didn't realize it was book 2 & I have not read Book 1, but it wasn't too hard to follow this book. Near the end of the book I realized that some characters that play a minor role in this book were the main characters in Book 2, as this series follows a family (Book 1 was about Will & Ivy primarily. This Book 2 is about Bert & Zella).
I look forward forward to reading Book 1 now!
I enjoyed the book. It was well written & the characters were fun to get to know. I appreciated how clean the book was.
Thank you to the author & publisher for the ARC read. All opinions are my own.
I look forward forward to reading Book 1 now!
I enjoyed the book. It was well written & the characters were fun to get to know. I appreciated how clean the book was.
Thank you to the author & publisher for the ARC read. All opinions are my own.
August 22, 2025
Unexpected is the second book in the Hearts on Display series and follows the story of Bert and Zella.
I really enjoyed this book! The sweet romance and cozy vibes were carried through from book 1 with just a little bit of suspense to make you hold your breath.
*I received this e-arc from the author and BookSirens; all opinions are my own*✨
I really enjoyed this book! The sweet romance and cozy vibes were carried through from book 1 with just a little bit of suspense to make you hold your breath.
*I received this e-arc from the author and BookSirens; all opinions are my own*✨
September 24, 2025
I loved the book. Sometimes the back story seemed a little wordy. But over all great book, great story! I do want to read the next one for sure! I really like how this author tells a story! The characters are great and well developed.
November 9, 2025
This is a sequel to Perfect. There was so much story left to tell! You will want to read both. The focus in this book moves to Zella and Robert. They are both hiding from themselves. Zella is also facing unfair society expectations. This is a sweet story. I received an ARC and I am leaving a review voluntarily.
September 25, 2025
Unexpected was just that Unexpected. I loved revisiting the romance with Will and Ivy and their marriage. I loved the new twists and turns that were Unexpected in this book. Well written, romance, a little action and suspense to hold the attention. I recommend reading book one in this series before reading this one but this book could be read alone. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily. Happy reading.
Read
September 27, 2025"Unexpected" by Kimberly Keagan was a bit slow at first with so many names to remember. Once I got further in, it was a delight. The mentions of God were always gentle and biblical but not preachy. I love finding interesting stories that bring The Lord in as a main character. I highly recommend this book and I look forward to reading sequels. PJ Sterling
September 23, 2025
Grumpy/Sunshine
Workplace Rivals
Faith Themes
Closed Door Romance
This sweet romance drew me in with its heartfelt characters and the tender way their story unfolded. The chemistry builds slowly but beautifully, making the emotional payoff so satisfying. It is clean, uplifting, and filled with the kind of warmth that leaves you smiling.
Content Warnings:
-kisses only
-no language
*I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Workplace Rivals
Faith Themes
Closed Door Romance
This sweet romance drew me in with its heartfelt characters and the tender way their story unfolded. The chemistry builds slowly but beautifully, making the emotional payoff so satisfying. It is clean, uplifting, and filled with the kind of warmth that leaves you smiling.
Content Warnings:
-kisses only
-no language
*I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
October 26, 2025
Great story. Couldn’t put it down. The dialogue is so much fun. Bert shows up multiple times when it matters and I love him all the more from it. I love these types of romances.
September 13, 2025
Zella is portrayed as near perfection—kindhearted, steadfast, and a rock for Ivy. Bert, still haunted by past wounds, has vowed never to feel weak again. Yet Zella carries a life-changing secret, and Bert finds himself reliving the pain that once left him fighting for survival. Now, he must fight for his life once more—this time, not just for himself but for her.
The story picks up from the events of the first book, though no prior reading is necessary to enjoy it. Zella faces challenges rooted in her past, present, and even her future, all while navigating an upper-class society where she doesn’t quite belong. Through her character and virtues, however, she manages to fit seamlessly—though the looming question remains: will her past resurface to destroy everything? Will she and Bert find a way forward together, or will her new found friends on higher ground close the circle against her?
One of the most striking aspects of the book is how openly both characters’ flaws are put on display. Watching them face enormous obstacles—together and apart—was carefully and beautifully written. Their relationship is witty, initially antagonistic, yet playful and protective. The dialogue between them sparkles, drawing the reader in with ease.
The novel has everything: formidable enemies old and new, crime, suspense, romance, heartbreak, joy, humor, scandal, and even a Christmas celebration. The variety gives plenty of scope for future installments.
Supporting characters Laura and Max were a delight. Laura is gentle, wise, and grounding, while Max is playful and loyal—the best kind of friend. They truly brought the story to life, and I sense they will become even more pivotal in the next book. (I hope)
The antagonists were menacing and gave the story its thrilling edge, though I personally wished they had been featured more prominently.
The sudden arrival of the snow and Christmas setting caught me off guard. Perhaps, a timeline or seasonal progression early on might have smoothed that transition. That said, the Christmas and New Year section was powerful, and its emotional impact was worth the surprise.
What I loved most about Unexpected were the inspired moments—those perfectly placed words of wisdom that struck deeply and offered comfort. A few examples:
“God did not wait for things to be tidy or peaceful before stepping into the mess of it all,” Grandmother said. “He came as light into darkness. As peace into a world that had none. And He still does.”
“Of course it did. That’s the lie fear tells us—that being vulnerable once means we always will be.”
“She didn’t press him. Didn’t tell him to stop boxing. She’d let him keep his outlet—for now. But she prayed silently, as mothers do, that one day he’d find his refuge in love and not fists.”
These lines—and many more—spoke to me personally, offering strength for my own challenges. The book is far more than a historical Christian romance sprinkled with verses. It reads like a message to the soul, carrying truths about God’s love that linger long after the final page.
In short, Unexpected didn’t just meet my expectations—it exceeded them. It left me inspired, comforted, and anticipating more.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The story picks up from the events of the first book, though no prior reading is necessary to enjoy it. Zella faces challenges rooted in her past, present, and even her future, all while navigating an upper-class society where she doesn’t quite belong. Through her character and virtues, however, she manages to fit seamlessly—though the looming question remains: will her past resurface to destroy everything? Will she and Bert find a way forward together, or will her new found friends on higher ground close the circle against her?
One of the most striking aspects of the book is how openly both characters’ flaws are put on display. Watching them face enormous obstacles—together and apart—was carefully and beautifully written. Their relationship is witty, initially antagonistic, yet playful and protective. The dialogue between them sparkles, drawing the reader in with ease.
The novel has everything: formidable enemies old and new, crime, suspense, romance, heartbreak, joy, humor, scandal, and even a Christmas celebration. The variety gives plenty of scope for future installments.
Supporting characters Laura and Max were a delight. Laura is gentle, wise, and grounding, while Max is playful and loyal—the best kind of friend. They truly brought the story to life, and I sense they will become even more pivotal in the next book. (I hope)
The antagonists were menacing and gave the story its thrilling edge, though I personally wished they had been featured more prominently.
The sudden arrival of the snow and Christmas setting caught me off guard. Perhaps, a timeline or seasonal progression early on might have smoothed that transition. That said, the Christmas and New Year section was powerful, and its emotional impact was worth the surprise.
What I loved most about Unexpected were the inspired moments—those perfectly placed words of wisdom that struck deeply and offered comfort. A few examples:
“God did not wait for things to be tidy or peaceful before stepping into the mess of it all,” Grandmother said. “He came as light into darkness. As peace into a world that had none. And He still does.”
“Of course it did. That’s the lie fear tells us—that being vulnerable once means we always will be.”
“She didn’t press him. Didn’t tell him to stop boxing. She’d let him keep his outlet—for now. But she prayed silently, as mothers do, that one day he’d find his refuge in love and not fists.”
These lines—and many more—spoke to me personally, offering strength for my own challenges. The book is far more than a historical Christian romance sprinkled with verses. It reads like a message to the soul, carrying truths about God’s love that linger long after the final page.
In short, Unexpected didn’t just meet my expectations—it exceeded them. It left me inspired, comforted, and anticipating more.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
August 28, 2025
I absolutely loved this book! This is my third read by Kimberly Keagan, and in my opinion, it’s her best yet. She has truly outdone herself with this one.
What stood out most to me was Zella—so driven, witty, full of humor and yet, so vulnerable—and the wonderful side characters like Helena, Alix, and Ned who added extra sparkle to the story. Kimberly’s choice for the midpoint was brilliant: not a kiss, but a moment of acknowledgement and vulnerability. It was subtle, powerful, and far more meaningful.
One line that stayed with me came from Lena: “I think that solitude and loneliness aren't always the same thing. Some of us make peace with quiet. Others fear it.” Such a beautiful reflection.
I also loved the chemistry between the main characters. It was on point, and I appreciated how they challenged each other to grow, to heal, and to become better versions of themselves.
However, I would have liked to see more pushback from Bert. He often gave in too easily to Zella’s requests, both professionally and personally. A bit more resistance would have made him a stronger male lead, as well as a more compelling antagonist and love interest.
My only lingering question came at the end: it wasn’t clear who the next book would focus on—Max, Ned, or Caroline? Even the foreshadowing throughout the story and the epilogue left me unsure. I hope it’s Max, but I’ll wait patiently and see.
Still, the character arcs for both leads were spot on, the setting vivid, and the professional/work journey so well described. For me, this was a solid 4.5 — rounded to 5 on Goodreads.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
What stood out most to me was Zella—so driven, witty, full of humor and yet, so vulnerable—and the wonderful side characters like Helena, Alix, and Ned who added extra sparkle to the story. Kimberly’s choice for the midpoint was brilliant: not a kiss, but a moment of acknowledgement and vulnerability. It was subtle, powerful, and far more meaningful.
One line that stayed with me came from Lena: “I think that solitude and loneliness aren't always the same thing. Some of us make peace with quiet. Others fear it.” Such a beautiful reflection.
I also loved the chemistry between the main characters. It was on point, and I appreciated how they challenged each other to grow, to heal, and to become better versions of themselves.
However, I would have liked to see more pushback from Bert. He often gave in too easily to Zella’s requests, both professionally and personally. A bit more resistance would have made him a stronger male lead, as well as a more compelling antagonist and love interest.
My only lingering question came at the end: it wasn’t clear who the next book would focus on—Max, Ned, or Caroline? Even the foreshadowing throughout the story and the epilogue left me unsure. I hope it’s Max, but I’ll wait patiently and see.
Still, the character arcs for both leads were spot on, the setting vivid, and the professional/work journey so well described. For me, this was a solid 4.5 — rounded to 5 on Goodreads.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 17, 2025
Kimberly Keagan delivers a lovely Gilded Age romance with "Unexpected". The second in her Hearts on Display series, this book features Robert Walraven and Zella Capp, both of whom appeared in "Perfect".
In a time when women were still believed to be too incompetent and emotional for important leadership roles in business, Zella Capp is determined to prove them wrong. She is a complex character who displays considerable talent, yet there are some who expect her to fail. Someone sets out to actively sabotage her. With an intriguing backstory, this intrepid heroine is enthusiastic and energetic. By contrast, Robert "Bert" Walraven is rather staid and serious. The romance of this somewhat older couple really works. An unexpected villain shows up, but there are a pair of adorable dogs, too. The family dynamics are so pleasant. "Unexpected" is inspirational in tone, but it's the kind hearted and appropriate sort; the fire and brimstone threats are thankfully absent.
I really enjoyed this book. Keagan is a very talented writer. Her style is entertaining and descriptive, and her works are devoid of aggravating grammatical errors that take one out of a story. Characters are finely-drawn. There are a couple of younger Walravens, and there are several Dennisons, so I hope there are more installments of this engaging series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
In a time when women were still believed to be too incompetent and emotional for important leadership roles in business, Zella Capp is determined to prove them wrong. She is a complex character who displays considerable talent, yet there are some who expect her to fail. Someone sets out to actively sabotage her. With an intriguing backstory, this intrepid heroine is enthusiastic and energetic. By contrast, Robert "Bert" Walraven is rather staid and serious. The romance of this somewhat older couple really works. An unexpected villain shows up, but there are a pair of adorable dogs, too. The family dynamics are so pleasant. "Unexpected" is inspirational in tone, but it's the kind hearted and appropriate sort; the fire and brimstone threats are thankfully absent.
I really enjoyed this book. Keagan is a very talented writer. Her style is entertaining and descriptive, and her works are devoid of aggravating grammatical errors that take one out of a story. Characters are finely-drawn. There are a couple of younger Walravens, and there are several Dennisons, so I hope there are more installments of this engaging series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 10, 2025
The year is 1895 and the place is Philadelphia. Zella Capp has carved out a successful life for herself. An upcoming marriage of a niece brings Zella into the world of Denwall Department Stores. The owners want to hire her to promote the store with a glitzy magazine. She will have full control of its content and design. Someone, though, is sabotaging her efforts, and even worse, threatening to expose a secret that Zella has hidden for years and which could bring her downfall. It could also ruin her chance at romance with one of the sons of the owner. A sterling reputation means everything, and she just might lose everything because of a decision she made when she felt she had no other career choice. This excellent tale depicts the era in which it is set quite accurately. Women were expected to know their place and not compete with men. That Zella could shows her strong character and personality. The strong female protagonist is appealing, and yet, the author manages to show Zella’s vulnerability as well. The storyline is gripping, and some dangerous elements add to that intrigue. The secondary characters add depth to the tale. Christian values and beliefs also add much to story. It is a very entertaining and engaging story, and will appeal to readers of historical fiction.
I was given an advance copy for free through BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I was given an advance copy for free through BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews