An enjoyable collection of old Christmas-themed & Christmas-adjacent ghost stories (in a couple of cases, it slightly pushes the concept, but mostly is on point). As in all such semi-slapdash, hit-them-with-quantity collections, there a few that mumble more than shout, but overall this collection is strong (assuming you like Victorian/classic ghost stories, which often have their own particular flavor, because if you do not, this one will not necessarily endear you to the type). Contains works by a few well known names such as W.W. Jacobs, J.M. Barrie, Charles Dickens, and M.R. James. Depending on your reading habits, you might also know Elizabeth Glaskell, B.M. Croker, and S. Baring-Gould, and Charlotte Riddell. Maybe others. Even if you do not wig most of the folks behind the collection, there is a fair mix of types: some humorous, some dark, many slightly touching and fairly melodramatic. A lot take place in the upper to upper-middle crust, but a few swoop down to more common fellows.
The best is "A Story of a Disappearance and a Reappearance," M.R. James' late story about a missing man and the events that occur after his disappearance, with perhaps the most striking, shocking image of his whole oeuvre (told in a Punch-and-Judy themed dream, and featuring the smashing of heads and stark imagery). Others delight. B.M. Croker's "Number Ninety," is one of her best, overall, and still works on the reread. John Kendrick Bangs' "Thurlow's Christmas Story" is slight in-and-of-itself, but plays a bit of meta-horror (J.M. Barrie's "The Ghost of Christmas Eve" also has a tad "meta-" to it, though just a tad). "The Great Staircase at Landover Hall" is pure fluff, but Frank Stockton makes it a sweet tale. And while "Wolverden Tower" is easily twice as long as it need be, it carries a strong theme. Another over-long-for-what-it-is is Elizabeth Glaskell's "The Old Nurse's Story," but I enjoyed it and found the spook there to be largely effective. "What Was He?," Theo Gift's story, is either good or middling depending on your mood, but there is something in its...despair...that intrigues. It would probably fit better being rewritten in a more modern horror story mode better than its Victorian trappings.
There are two stories about ghostly pranks gone awry (the classic trope where someone pretends to be a ghost and is killed or frightened to death, or kills someone...a strangely moral point to which some of the old scribes stuck). The better of the two is probably W.W. Jacob's "Jerry Bundler" which has a tinge of humor and something like a twist.
Of historical interest, Charles Dickens' "The Story of the Goblins Who Stole a Sexton," features a proto-A Christmas Carol theme - a miserable man who detests Christmas is haunted by supernatural forces and watches the joys and tragedies of others from afar - and could easily be considered a fairly different first draft of that later, and better, story.
Of historical interest to folks like me might be H.B. Marriott Watson's "The Brazen Cross," that involves a scene of folks giving into pre-marital passion (probably just a strong hug, considering the source, but the author leaves it up to your imagination) and then getting horror'd. While it's a surely meant to be a moral tale about doing things proper, it's interesting to see it as an early example of the "have sex, die" kind of trope.
While only a few truly sing, essentially none hit a true sour note. The aforementioned "Wolverden Tower" is overlong enough (and its theme of female sacrifice might be rough enough, though derived from historical sources) that it comes close, but holds it mostly together. Likewise, assuming you can get by S. Baring-Gould's casual colonial racism in the Euros-among-Egypt "Mustapha," complete with the main character who "rises" above racism by considering the savages mostly noble, the human interest aspects of the end of the story are fairly timeless and strong. It is the story in this collection that least needed a ghost to feel complete, because really the ghost does nothing but offer something like retribution. Without it, it would have honestly been a more haunting story about the impact of cultural invasion.