What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lookout's Ghost
Reece West
I don’t believe in ghosts. I also don’t believe in cottage cheese as a main food group, but sometimes in life, we are forced to confront when we’re wrong.
Thankfully, I was only mistaken about the ghosts.
At thirty-four years old, I’m arguably too young to have a midlife crisis, but a life-changing diagnosis followed swiftly by a caustic breakup seems to have done the trick. Reeling, I’ve traveled home to Ponderosa, Idaho, Gateway to Nowhere, to spend the summer high above the forest in a remote fire lookout tower.
An escape from the maelstrom my life has become should be good for me, right? Except solitude is difficult to come by when you aren’t actually alone. Despite its name, the very last thing I expect to find living with me in Dead Man’s Lookout is, well, a dead man. Especially not one as shockingly kind, attractive, and funny as Charlie Randolph.
The only problem is, he’s maybe, probably, a serial killer. Or is he?
Suddenly, I’m thrust into a decades-old cold case involving six murdered hikers and one (not so) missing fire lookout. When history begins to repeat itself, falling for a ghost is the least of my concerns. But nothing is ever as it seems in Ponderosa, and I’m not sure if Charlie and I are strong enough to weather the truth when we realize Death isn’t lurking in the shadows—it’s already inside.
The Lookout’s Ghost is a heart-stopping paranormal romance with plenty of mystery and suspense to go around. Look out and watch your step if you dare enter the Gateway to Nowhere , or you just may come face-to-face with the cold-blooded killer who hunts there.
I don’t believe in ghosts. I also don’t believe in cottage cheese as a main food group, but sometimes in life, we are forced to confront when we’re wrong.
Thankfully, I was only mistaken about the ghosts.
At thirty-four years old, I’m arguably too young to have a midlife crisis, but a life-changing diagnosis followed swiftly by a caustic breakup seems to have done the trick. Reeling, I’ve traveled home to Ponderosa, Idaho, Gateway to Nowhere, to spend the summer high above the forest in a remote fire lookout tower.
An escape from the maelstrom my life has become should be good for me, right? Except solitude is difficult to come by when you aren’t actually alone. Despite its name, the very last thing I expect to find living with me in Dead Man’s Lookout is, well, a dead man. Especially not one as shockingly kind, attractive, and funny as Charlie Randolph.
The only problem is, he’s maybe, probably, a serial killer. Or is he?
Suddenly, I’m thrust into a decades-old cold case involving six murdered hikers and one (not so) missing fire lookout. When history begins to repeat itself, falling for a ghost is the least of my concerns. But nothing is ever as it seems in Ponderosa, and I’m not sure if Charlie and I are strong enough to weather the truth when we realize Death isn’t lurking in the shadows—it’s already inside.
The Lookout’s Ghost is a heart-stopping paranormal romance with plenty of mystery and suspense to go around. Look out and watch your step if you dare enter the Gateway to Nowhere , or you just may come face-to-face with the cold-blooded killer who hunts there.
346 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 23, 2025
56 people are currently reading
1026 people want to read
About the author
A. Knightley
5 books141 followersA. Knightley lives in the wilds of the Midwest with her dog. She loves to crochet, watch scary movies, and of course, write cozy and swoony paranormal romance stories. To stay up to date with what she’s working on next, you can connect on Instagram @author.aknightley.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 236 reviews
December 4, 2025
Wow, I could NOT put this down. What an absolutely unique story!
This book is such an interesting mix of genres: paranormal ghost story, a 40-year-old serial killer murder mystery that suddenly becomes relevant again as solo hikers start going missing, genuinely spooky and moody vibes - and especially a big ass ROMANCE at the center of it all. And it works. So well.
This was funny, heartfelt, spooky, full of suspense, and yet also so wholesome and profoundly romantic at the same time. The hurt/comfort, the touch-starved dynamics, the tenderness and heartbreak between the two leads… it radiated off the pages. They’re basically fated mates and you can feel it in every scene.
Reece himself was an amazing MC. Being in his head was such a joy - he made me laugh constantly. Tough and vulnerable, funny and tender, brave, strong, stubborn, soft - and he had a moustache. What more can you want? Ugh. Such a great guy 🥹
Also: The sense of place was INCREDIBLE. The lookout tower and forest setting were so vivid and atmospheric - I could see, hear, smell, feel everything Reece felt (which included absolute terror at some creepy af moments, ngl 😅).
And WOW was it hot. I absolutely did not expect a romance between a ghost and a human to be that spicy, but goddamn did they heat up their little lookout tower. The reverence, the praise, the worshipping, the dirty talk, the pet names - it all worked so, so well for me 🔥
I’ll admit I initially struggled with the beginning and with Reece’s MS diagnosis. It was written so very vividly, and chronic illness topics always spike my anxiety. But after taking a short break I was able to handle it better - and after reading the author’s note at the end, it made a lot of sense why it felt so real 💔
And even though the mystery kept me engaged and guessing along at every twist and turn, I was a biiit disappointed in the end with the ott resolution. I definitely wanted a bit more why and why now and not just who.
But other than that, I was completely enthralled by their story and sincerely hope the author comes back to this part of the world and maybe give us Tate and Sunglasses story. I can already feel it’s gonna be amazing!
4,5⭐️
This book is such an interesting mix of genres: paranormal ghost story, a 40-year-old serial killer murder mystery that suddenly becomes relevant again as solo hikers start going missing, genuinely spooky and moody vibes - and especially a big ass ROMANCE at the center of it all. And it works. So well.
This was funny, heartfelt, spooky, full of suspense, and yet also so wholesome and profoundly romantic at the same time. The hurt/comfort, the touch-starved dynamics, the tenderness and heartbreak between the two leads… it radiated off the pages. They’re basically fated mates and you can feel it in every scene.
Reece himself was an amazing MC. Being in his head was such a joy - he made me laugh constantly. Tough and vulnerable, funny and tender, brave, strong, stubborn, soft - and he had a moustache. What more can you want? Ugh. Such a great guy 🥹
Also: The sense of place was INCREDIBLE. The lookout tower and forest setting were so vivid and atmospheric - I could see, hear, smell, feel everything Reece felt (which included absolute terror at some creepy af moments, ngl 😅).
And WOW was it hot. I absolutely did not expect a romance between a ghost and a human to be that spicy, but goddamn did they heat up their little lookout tower. The reverence, the praise, the worshipping, the dirty talk, the pet names - it all worked so, so well for me 🔥
I’ll admit I initially struggled with the beginning and with Reece’s MS diagnosis. It was written so very vividly, and chronic illness topics always spike my anxiety. But after taking a short break I was able to handle it better - and after reading the author’s note at the end, it made a lot of sense why it felt so real 💔
And even though the mystery kept me engaged and guessing along at every twist and turn, I was a biiit disappointed in the end with the ott resolution. I definitely wanted a bit more why and why now and not just who.
But other than that, I was completely enthralled by their story and sincerely hope the author comes back to this part of the world and maybe give us Tate and Sunglasses story. I can already feel it’s gonna be amazing!
4,5⭐️
And accompanying all of it, like the percussion section uniting an orchestra as one, the trees. Tall and thick with minimal understory growth, this section of land was filled with groves of old-growth pine, conifer, juniper, and fir. The wind rustled their needles, a quiet shhhhh that made my shoulders drop from their permanently clenched position around my ears. Their broad trunks creaked and groaned as they swayed. Yeah, I’d accepted the lookout job for this. I needed sound that wasn’t noise. I could already feel my blood pressure lower the longer I listened.
*sigh*
🌲🌲🌲
“For so long, it felt like I couldn’t leave this lookout. It felt like I was trapped. Now, though, I wonder.”
“What do you wonder?” I whispered into the space between us.
“I wonder if I was only waiting.”
*Double sigh* 🥹
🔥🔥🔥
“Oh, pretty baby. Look at you. Did you like sucking me so much you made a mess all over yourself?”
He whimpered, fingers bunching in my shirt. “Yes.”
😮💨😮💨😮💨
October 13, 2025
⭐️ All the stars ⭐️
The Lookout’s Ghost was absolute perfection, all my favorite tropes and genres bundled into one beautiful story. A spooky mystery, paranormal themes, hurt/comfort, cute animal moments, gorgeous scenery, so so much emotion, and a once-in-a-lifetime kind of love.
What started as a spooky meet-scare, quickly became the sweetest love story I’ve read in a while. I loved the flirty banter, the sense of peace they felt with each other, just the overwhelming feeling of love that enveloped me when these two were together.
Not only were Reece and Charlie the cutest, they were also very very hot. It was passionate, sexy, loving. Like they’d been waiting their whole life (and afterlife) to meet. Like they’d were meant to be.
I gotta be honest, the mystery wasn’t jaw-droppingly twisty. I knew it was gonna throw a curveball out of nowhere in the end, a weird twist with little to no explanation.
But still, the vibes were immaculate, and the mystery gave me a bit of chill and thrill to break up the romantic moments.
So even if it wasn’t the best thought out mystery, I still loved the entire experience. If a book make me sob and makes my heart hurt (but in a good way), I know it’s one I’ll remember.
If you’re a fan of Firewatch, love stories that break the rules, light murder mysteries, cute raccoons that love hotdogs, cuddles by the fireplace, stories with a bit of unexplainable magic in them — then this is the perfect read for you.
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest review.
CW and NSFW info (spoilers):
- Violence/murder
- Chronic illness/disability rep
- Depression & anxiety
- Past cheating (not between MCs)
- Parental loss (past)
- Top/bottom
- Dry humping/coming with clothes on
- Coming hands-free
- HEA
I peered through the open window into the tower I’d call home. Only to find a man staring right at me.
The Lookout’s Ghost was absolute perfection, all my favorite tropes and genres bundled into one beautiful story. A spooky mystery, paranormal themes, hurt/comfort, cute animal moments, gorgeous scenery, so so much emotion, and a once-in-a-lifetime kind of love.
“You roasted a chicken for me?” “Spatchcocked and roasted.” His eyes danced. “You’ve gotta stop saying that.” I nudged him forward, crowding him toward the stove. “Go on and fix your plate before I spatchcock you.” He grinned over his shoulder.
“Don’t threaten me with a good time.”
What started as a spooky meet-scare, quickly became the sweetest love story I’ve read in a while. I loved the flirty banter, the sense of peace they felt with each other, just the overwhelming feeling of love that enveloped me when these two were together.
“That’s it,” he gasped.
“There.” “Mmhmm.”
“Smug isn’t your best look.”
“Squirming on my fingers is absolutely yours, though.”
Not only were Reece and Charlie the cutest, they were also very very hot. It was passionate, sexy, loving. Like they’d been waiting their whole life (and afterlife) to meet. Like they’d were meant to be.
“For so long, it felt like I couldn’t leave this lookout. It felt like I was trapped. Now, though, I wonder.” “What do you wonder?” I whispered into the space between us. “I wonder if I was only waiting.”
I gotta be honest, the mystery wasn’t jaw-droppingly twisty. I knew it was gonna throw a curveball out of nowhere in the end, a weird twist with little to no explanation.
But still, the vibes were immaculate, and the mystery gave me a bit of chill and thrill to break up the romantic moments.
It felt like Charlie was always meant to be tucked right next to me, curled into my warmth while the wind lashed sleet and snow against the windowpanes.
So even if it wasn’t the best thought out mystery, I still loved the entire experience. If a book make me sob and makes my heart hurt (but in a good way), I know it’s one I’ll remember.
“Hold me, Reece? Don’t let me disappear.”
If you’re a fan of Firewatch, love stories that break the rules, light murder mysteries, cute raccoons that love hotdogs, cuddles by the fireplace, stories with a bit of unexplainable magic in them — then this is the perfect read for you.
“Even if this is all we ever have, I’m happy we had it.”
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my honest review.
CW and NSFW info (spoilers):
- Violence/murder
- Chronic illness/disability rep
- Depression & anxiety
- Past cheating (not between MCs)
- Parental loss (past)
- Top/bottom
- Dry humping/coming with clothes on
- Coming hands-free
- HEA
December 9, 2025
Wonderful. Full of emotional depth and layers of conflict, well-developed characters, atmosphere, beautiful intimacy, and a unique fire-tower in a national part setting, this one delivers a riveting grumpy-sunshine-dynamic read.
The chemistry between the two heroes sings from the pages. I loved their near-death meet-cute, their banter, their ease with each other, their seemingly impossible situation.
Did I mention one is a ghost? Oh yeah, the title did that for me.
Step back. Reece is the grump, and he’s recently been both diagnosed with MS and gone through a breakup with a man who was cheating on him. Accepting his new reality isn’t going well, so accepting his father’s friend’s invitation to man an isolated fire tower that hasn’t been lived in for decades outside his hometown (I think? Or a town he’d spent a lot of time in as a child) of Ponderosa, ID, where his father still lives, seems a perfect way to have time to lick his wounds and be helpful while wrapping his head around his physical condition.
Charlie is…dead. He doesn’t know what happened or why he’s stuck at the fire tower he was living/working in the summer his life ended. Something about Reece feeds him energy and allows him to manifest more and more, as he appears to the lonely, grumpy man in the tower he’s haunted for decades.
These two are adorable together. Talk about meant to be! Fiery chemistry, compatible natures, grumpy-sunshine dynamic, emotional connection that makes each a safe space for the other to be themselves and realize they’re more than their personal challenges…check, check, check, check, all the checks.
Reece’s stay in the fire tower is shaping up to be dangerous, and not from the fires he’s been hired to watch for. Hikers have disappeared, and it seems a serial killer last active around the time Charlie mysteriously disappeared from his post at the tower decades ago may be active again.
Part spooky ghost story, part serial killer murder mystery, all against-all-odds romance, this story kept me engaged and kept on delivering satisfaction and heartwarming story, beat after beat.
I don’t know how/why Charlie was able to manifest, or why things worked out the way they did; the paranormal element is both visceral/tangible, and inexplicable. But that didn’t matter to me, I went along for the ride.
I didn’t understand what set off the serial killer again after all this time. Personal situation? Maybe? Seemed weird. And the Thing that happens around Reece’s tower that One Time…not sure how that would’ve worked. Seemed a lot of effort to go through, and why the warning? But the spooky, atmospheric sense of danger and the unknown added a spine-tingling layer to the read that enhanced the story exponentially, so…just don’t squint too hard.
I loved Reece’s relationships with his parents and friends, and SC Tate’s attempts to befriend him. I’d love to have Tate and Sunglasses’s story, maybe the author will gift us with another book set in this same timeframe? One can hope.
Randy the raccoon added perfect atmosphere and comic relief.
HEA (yes, for real! Again…don’t squint too hard.) Grumpy-sunshine, romantic suspense, ghost love story. No OM drama or action. Entirely safe and lovely for me. Tate seems to want to date Reece for a bit, but isn’t pushy, and his professional invasiveness (he’s police) added a strong layer of conflict. Highly recommended.
The chemistry between the two heroes sings from the pages. I loved their near-death meet-cute, their banter, their ease with each other, their seemingly impossible situation.
Did I mention one is a ghost? Oh yeah, the title did that for me.
Step back. Reece is the grump, and he’s recently been both diagnosed with MS and gone through a breakup with a man who was cheating on him. Accepting his new reality isn’t going well, so accepting his father’s friend’s invitation to man an isolated fire tower that hasn’t been lived in for decades outside his hometown (I think? Or a town he’d spent a lot of time in as a child) of Ponderosa, ID, where his father still lives, seems a perfect way to have time to lick his wounds and be helpful while wrapping his head around his physical condition.
Charlie is…dead. He doesn’t know what happened or why he’s stuck at the fire tower he was living/working in the summer his life ended. Something about Reece feeds him energy and allows him to manifest more and more, as he appears to the lonely, grumpy man in the tower he’s haunted for decades.
These two are adorable together. Talk about meant to be! Fiery chemistry, compatible natures, grumpy-sunshine dynamic, emotional connection that makes each a safe space for the other to be themselves and realize they’re more than their personal challenges…check, check, check, check, all the checks.
Reece’s stay in the fire tower is shaping up to be dangerous, and not from the fires he’s been hired to watch for. Hikers have disappeared, and it seems a serial killer last active around the time Charlie mysteriously disappeared from his post at the tower decades ago may be active again.
Part spooky ghost story, part serial killer murder mystery, all against-all-odds romance, this story kept me engaged and kept on delivering satisfaction and heartwarming story, beat after beat.
I don’t know how/why Charlie was able to manifest, or why things worked out the way they did; the paranormal element is both visceral/tangible, and inexplicable. But that didn’t matter to me, I went along for the ride.
I didn’t understand what set off the serial killer again after all this time. Personal situation? Maybe? Seemed weird. And the Thing that happens around Reece’s tower that One Time…not sure how that would’ve worked. Seemed a lot of effort to go through, and why the warning? But the spooky, atmospheric sense of danger and the unknown added a spine-tingling layer to the read that enhanced the story exponentially, so…just don’t squint too hard.
I loved Reece’s relationships with his parents and friends, and SC Tate’s attempts to befriend him. I’d love to have Tate and Sunglasses’s story, maybe the author will gift us with another book set in this same timeframe? One can hope.
Randy the raccoon added perfect atmosphere and comic relief.
HEA (yes, for real! Again…don’t squint too hard.) Grumpy-sunshine, romantic suspense, ghost love story. No OM drama or action. Entirely safe and lovely for me. Tate seems to want to date Reece for a bit, but isn’t pushy, and his professional invasiveness (he’s police) added a strong layer of conflict. Highly recommended.
March 12, 2026
Ok I guess I am officially reading everything this author writes. All the books have been so good. This one was amazing. It was so hard to put down. Loved both the romance and the mystery. And the setting!! I hadn’t heard of fire look out towers but that was such a cool setting for a book. Especially a haunted fire watch tower! So good!!
April 2, 2026
4.5 rounded up for these soulmates🥰
I've been spoiled by dual POVs so it's very hard for me to enjoy stories that don't offer that. I found myself pleasantly surprised at how much I actually enjoyed being in Reece's POV. He's such a great character🥺
Now, maybe i'm just stupid but I had a hard time keeping up with the timeline of the days passing.😵💫
Other than that I absolutely loved this! As soon as Charlie made his appearance I was hooked!
The paranormal aspect didn't really make sense to me but why would I try to look for something realistic in a ghost story?! Who cares that by the end so many seemed to accept the whole ghost thing so easily! The power of love saved the day and honestly that's what i'm here for, the way Reece and Chatlie love each other is everything, they have the type of love that i'll never tire reading about, the type of love i'm always searching for in these romance books🥺
The last half of the book had me on an emotional rollercoaster, poor baby Reece was really going through it😭All those twists had me speeding up my reading to try to get to the reveal faster😂
With all that being said, this was an amazingly fun time for me. The romance was perfect and the spooky vibes were so great.
This wouldn't be my review if I didn't end up complaining about wanting more of the MCs at the end. And I did! I really would've liked to see them fully settled after leaving the look out but I can appreciate ending the book where it all started. The epilogue was sweet and i'm glad Charlie got that in the end.
I really liked Tate and Sunglasses too, I would love to read their book if the author ever decides to write it. THO THE WHOLE IDENTITY THING FOR CHARLIE
Edited to fix typo 😒
I've been spoiled by dual POVs so it's very hard for me to enjoy stories that don't offer that. I found myself pleasantly surprised at how much I actually enjoyed being in Reece's POV. He's such a great character🥺
Now, maybe i'm just stupid but I had a hard time keeping up with the timeline of the days passing.😵💫
Other than that I absolutely loved this! As soon as Charlie made his appearance I was hooked!
The paranormal aspect didn't really make sense to me but why would I try to look for something realistic in a ghost story?! Who cares that by the end so many seemed to accept the whole ghost thing so easily! The power of love saved the day and honestly that's what i'm here for, the way Reece and Chatlie love each other is everything, they have the type of love that i'll never tire reading about, the type of love i'm always searching for in these romance books🥺
The last half of the book had me on an emotional rollercoaster, poor baby Reece was really going through it😭All those twists had me speeding up my reading to try to get to the reveal faster😂
With all that being said, this was an amazingly fun time for me. The romance was perfect and the spooky vibes were so great.
This wouldn't be my review if I didn't end up complaining about wanting more of the MCs at the end. And I did! I really would've liked to see them fully settled after leaving the look out but I can appreciate ending the book where it all started. The epilogue was sweet and i'm glad Charlie got that in the end.
I really liked Tate and Sunglasses too, I would love to read their book if the author ever decides to write it. THO THE WHOLE IDENTITY THING FOR CHARLIE
Edited to fix typo 😒
January 11, 2026
4⭐️ 2🌶️
📝 REVIEW & THOUGHTS:
The Lookout’s Ghost is an intriguing story. The plot was really engaging, hubby and I had fun reading this book. Especially trying to find out who the bad guy was.
The love blossoming is sweet and both characters are pretty adorable imo. The characters are well developed and the romance has good emotional depth.
I was so sure this was gonna be a dual POV book, unfortunately it was not, that probably reduced my own enjoyment a bit (personal preference), but in general it’s still worth to read it anyway.
🏷️ TROPES & TAGS (possible spoilers):
Genre/subgenre: paranormal romance, murder mystery
Pairing: MM
POV: 1st person, single
Angst: low
Burn: slow
Vibe/mood: spooky, moody, wholesome
Pet names: baby
Characters’ ages: 34/29 (really 69, but look-wise 29)
HEA: yes
Book type: novel
Series structure: standalone
Ghost x human
Hurt/comfort
Strangers to friends to lovers
Murder mystery
Small town vibes
Forced proximity
🌶️ SPICE & K!NKS (possible spoilers):
Strict top/bottom or versatile: top/bottom
Heat: 5 scenes, medium heat
Mastūrbation
Dry humping
Blōwjobs
Anāl sēx
Praise
⚠️ CONTENT WARNINGS (‼️possible spoilers‼️):
Dubcon: no
Noncon: no
Breakup: no
Cheating: no
Sharing: no
OM/OW: no
Illness (multiple sclerosis, migraine)
Cheating (one MC is cheated on in a past relationship, not between MCs)
Graphic descriptions of vıolence and mūrder
Brief, passing references to self-hārm/suıcide (not considered or committed by any characters in the story)
Descriptions of struggling with depression and anxiety
Brief description of vıolence against an animal (not pet, not graphic)
Parental loss (in the past, not on page)
😤 LITTLE RANT (‼️spoilers‼️):
I just wish the ending wasn’t so OTT in favor of the HEA. I dunno, it felt a bit far fetched. Still nice, but it lost us a bit when all that magic thingy happened (don’t wanna spoil it too much).
* Fyi about 🌶️ levels: I rate spice on a combination of quantity, quality, length, intensity and explicitness of the scenes. Kınks are listed separately and generally do not directly affect the steam level to keep it fair for non kınky books.
📝 REVIEW & THOUGHTS:
The Lookout’s Ghost is an intriguing story. The plot was really engaging, hubby and I had fun reading this book. Especially trying to find out who the bad guy was.
The love blossoming is sweet and both characters are pretty adorable imo. The characters are well developed and the romance has good emotional depth.
I was so sure this was gonna be a dual POV book, unfortunately it was not, that probably reduced my own enjoyment a bit (personal preference), but in general it’s still worth to read it anyway.
🏷️ TROPES & TAGS (possible spoilers):
Genre/subgenre: paranormal romance, murder mystery
Pairing: MM
POV: 1st person, single
Angst: low
Burn: slow
Vibe/mood: spooky, moody, wholesome
Pet names: baby
Characters’ ages: 34/29 (really 69, but look-wise 29)
HEA: yes
Book type: novel
Series structure: standalone
Ghost x human
Hurt/comfort
Strangers to friends to lovers
Murder mystery
Small town vibes
Forced proximity
🌶️ SPICE & K!NKS (possible spoilers):
Strict top/bottom or versatile: top/bottom
Heat: 5 scenes, medium heat
Mastūrbation
Dry humping
Blōwjobs
Anāl sēx
Praise
⚠️ CONTENT WARNINGS (‼️possible spoilers‼️):
Dubcon: no
Noncon: no
Breakup: no
Cheating: no
Sharing: no
OM/OW: no
Illness (multiple sclerosis, migraine)
Cheating (one MC is cheated on in a past relationship, not between MCs)
Graphic descriptions of vıolence and mūrder
Brief, passing references to self-hārm/suıcide (not considered or committed by any characters in the story)
Descriptions of struggling with depression and anxiety
Brief description of vıolence against an animal (not pet, not graphic)
Parental loss (in the past, not on page)
😤 LITTLE RANT (‼️spoilers‼️):
I just wish the ending wasn’t so OTT in favor of the HEA. I dunno, it felt a bit far fetched. Still nice, but it lost us a bit when all that magic thingy happened (don’t wanna spoil it too much).
* Fyi about 🌶️ levels: I rate spice on a combination of quantity, quality, length, intensity and explicitness of the scenes. Kınks are listed separately and generally do not directly affect the steam level to keep it fair for non kınky books.
October 26, 2025
Such an absolutely unique romantic swoony heartbreaking story. I highly recommend you read this story if you want to be swept off your feet. Filled to the brim with humour, romance, feeling, chemistry this story is one that’ll gripping you right off the bat and I found it impossible to put it down, even when real life came calling.
The chronic illness rep in the book is phenomenal, the spree murder mystery is fantastic as is the unique paranormal romance plot.
Reece is reeling with what life has thrown at him in the span of a day, with months of healing and recovery to pass he looks forward to taking the lookout post in Ponderosa forest but when he gets there missing hikers remind him of the devastation that rolled through the small town decades ago even though no one is acknowledging it. When he gets to his remote post he is saved (though to be fair he was first startled) by Charlie who may or may not be alive or is it Reece who is not alive - what is even happening - this part honestly made me chortle.
Together they form an unbreakable bond as they fight to save each other and solve the source of mortal fear that has rooted itself in the forest. I gasped, geared up, awwwd and generally fell in love with Reece and Charlie. The spiritual messages in the story weee beautiful, That ending was unbelievably spectacular satisfying and swoony and perfect abd I could not love it more.
Tate and Sunglasses ( Walker ) were hot, may I have more please 😄. Loved Bobby 🥹
The chronic illness rep in the book is phenomenal, the spree murder mystery is fantastic as is the unique paranormal romance plot.
Reece is reeling with what life has thrown at him in the span of a day, with months of healing and recovery to pass he looks forward to taking the lookout post in Ponderosa forest but when he gets there missing hikers remind him of the devastation that rolled through the small town decades ago even though no one is acknowledging it. When he gets to his remote post he is saved (though to be fair he was first startled) by Charlie who may or may not be alive or is it Reece who is not alive - what is even happening - this part honestly made me chortle.
Together they form an unbreakable bond as they fight to save each other and solve the source of mortal fear that has rooted itself in the forest. I gasped, geared up, awwwd and generally fell in love with Reece and Charlie. The spiritual messages in the story weee beautiful, That ending was unbelievably spectacular satisfying and swoony and perfect abd I could not love it more.
Tate and Sunglasses ( Walker ) were hot, may I have more please 😄. Loved Bobby 🥹
October 13, 2025
The Lookout’s Ghost is a MM paranormal mystery romance story about Reece and Charlie.
After Reece is diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, he escapes back home to Ponderosa to spend the summer at a remote fire lookout tower. What he is not expecting to find living there is the ghost of Charlie, a man that was presumed dead almost forty years ago. On top of that, history is repeating itself and hikers are going missing and possibly being murdered.
I liked so many aspects in this story from the romance to the mystery and suspense. I was not expecting to get so many emotions while reading it, and I admit there were a couple times I did get a little spooked reading it late at night. I thought Reece was going to be the only one who could see Charlie, but this wasn’t the case. It did make me feel like the other characters seemed to accept Charlie a little too easily.
Seeing Reece and Charlie’s connection and their love for each other was beautiful. I was so invested in Reece and Charlie’s story and I couldn’t wait to see how it all was going to play out. It didn’t end how I was expecting it to, but overall I really enjoyed it. This book was the perfect read for this spooky season.
I received an advanced copy of this book, and this is my honest review.
After Reece is diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, he escapes back home to Ponderosa to spend the summer at a remote fire lookout tower. What he is not expecting to find living there is the ghost of Charlie, a man that was presumed dead almost forty years ago. On top of that, history is repeating itself and hikers are going missing and possibly being murdered.
I liked so many aspects in this story from the romance to the mystery and suspense. I was not expecting to get so many emotions while reading it, and I admit there were a couple times I did get a little spooked reading it late at night. I thought Reece was going to be the only one who could see Charlie, but this wasn’t the case. It did make me feel like the other characters seemed to accept Charlie a little too easily.
Seeing Reece and Charlie’s connection and their love for each other was beautiful. I was so invested in Reece and Charlie’s story and I couldn’t wait to see how it all was going to play out. It didn’t end how I was expecting it to, but overall I really enjoyed it. This book was the perfect read for this spooky season.
I received an advanced copy of this book, and this is my honest review.
December 16, 2025
💅look guys I got a 5 star read!!! Isn’t that crazy? 💓✨
oh how I loved this book. How I loved what I felt reading this book. How I loved both the romance and plot equally and they were both fighting for my attention. How I loved the characters. How I loved that the mystery actually mysteri-ed✋ : I read scenes with all the side characters and kept mumbling ”oh yeah it’s definitely him, he’s the killer” for every character, that’s how you know the mystery is good 🤌✨
“Charlie was sharp and witty most of the time, but this version of him, soft and needy, might become my favorite.
Because it was mine.”
There is NOTHING bad I want to say about this other than - it felt weird reading the sex scenes because well, one of them is a ghost 👻🥴🥴. But the author did so well in creating this cozy atmospheric setting, it pulled me in easily from page one and everytime something absolutely bonkers happened, it was reasoned with so easily in my head. Like “ oh yeah, that makes sense. He’s absorbing the life force, duh” .
The plot was so unique!! I mean, reece is on a look out because a serial killer is killing hikers that matched the mo from decades ago and the cabin he’s stationed for the lookout is haunted by Charlie, who was presumed to be the serial killer for the previous kills - decades ago. !!!!. So did he do it or not???? 🫢🫢🫢
Like I said. I loved it. So much. 💗💓✨
oh how I loved this book. How I loved what I felt reading this book. How I loved both the romance and plot equally and they were both fighting for my attention. How I loved the characters. How I loved that the mystery actually mysteri-ed✋ : I read scenes with all the side characters and kept mumbling ”oh yeah it’s definitely him, he’s the killer” for every character, that’s how you know the mystery is good 🤌✨
“Charlie was sharp and witty most of the time, but this version of him, soft and needy, might become my favorite.
Because it was mine.”
There is NOTHING bad I want to say about this other than - it felt weird reading the sex scenes because well, one of them is a ghost 👻🥴🥴. But the author did so well in creating this cozy atmospheric setting, it pulled me in easily from page one and everytime something absolutely bonkers happened, it was reasoned with so easily in my head. Like “ oh yeah, that makes sense. He’s absorbing the life force, duh” .
The plot was so unique!! I mean, reece is on a look out because a serial killer is killing hikers that matched the mo from decades ago and the cabin he’s stationed for the lookout is haunted by Charlie, who was presumed to be the serial killer for the previous kills - decades ago. !!!!. So did he do it or not???? 🫢🫢🫢
Like I said. I loved it. So much. 💗💓✨
November 12, 2025
Holy fuck?! This was genuinely perfect. I have zero complaints. No notes. I have a racing heart and palpitations over how much I loved this oh my god.
This is easily one of my top reads of 2025. Actually this is one of my top reads ever. This was so up my alley and utterly wonderful. I don’t even know what else to say. Charlie and Reece were perfect. The plot was perfect. The pacing was perfect. Ahhhh!!! I’m so excited!!!!
This is easily one of my top reads of 2025. Actually this is one of my top reads ever. This was so up my alley and utterly wonderful. I don’t even know what else to say. Charlie and Reece were perfect. The plot was perfect. The pacing was perfect. Ahhhh!!! I’m so excited!!!!
October 30, 2025
THIS BOOK WAS SO GOOD. I went into The Lookout's Ghost mostly blind (are they looking for ghosts? is one of them a ghost? becomes a ghost? WHO KNOWS?!), and y'all, this might be one of my favorite paranormal romances I've read (that doesn't also include a shifter). If you want romantic suspense that's actually suspenseful AND romantic, A. Knightley does it INCREDIBLY well. Though the relationship between Charlie and Reece might take a teensy bit of suspension of disbelief, I was IN IT, and honestly had a hard time putting it down. What a way to end my Halloween group reads! HIGHLY recommend checking this one out!
Oh my goodness, Charlie and Reece were so freaking cute. I had NO idea how A. Knightley was going to make a romance between a ghost and a human work but she DID. Charlie is freaking adorable, I love his sweet golden retriever personality and my heart HURT for him for what he'd gone through. And Reece!! OMG, his journey with MS was so incredibly well done - you could tell it was personal for the author. I don't think I've ever read a romance with a character with MS before, but honestly, this book has some INCREDIBLE chronic illness rep that shows both Reece's struggles and his strength. If you love caretaking, hurt/comfort, forced proximity, you get it ALL here. AND THEN, there's the crazy murder mystery plot! There are tons of jump scares and crazy twists that legit had me on the edge of my seat. I had NO idea who the k!11er was going to be, and all the action at the end had me FLYING to try to finish. And while the book is a little bit scary, there's tons of humor, lighter moments, and swoon to balance everything out.
I had no idea what to expect from The Lookout's Ghost, but everything about it appealed to me and was so well done. I've never read a book set in a wildfire lookout, but OMG, what a PERFECT setting for a book like this? Bravo, A. Knightley, what a masterpiece! Do not sleep on this one my friends, romantic ghost story perfection.
Oh my goodness, Charlie and Reece were so freaking cute. I had NO idea how A. Knightley was going to make a romance between a ghost and a human work but she DID. Charlie is freaking adorable, I love his sweet golden retriever personality and my heart HURT for him for what he'd gone through. And Reece!! OMG, his journey with MS was so incredibly well done - you could tell it was personal for the author. I don't think I've ever read a romance with a character with MS before, but honestly, this book has some INCREDIBLE chronic illness rep that shows both Reece's struggles and his strength. If you love caretaking, hurt/comfort, forced proximity, you get it ALL here. AND THEN, there's the crazy murder mystery plot! There are tons of jump scares and crazy twists that legit had me on the edge of my seat. I had NO idea who the k!11er was going to be, and all the action at the end had me FLYING to try to finish. And while the book is a little bit scary, there's tons of humor, lighter moments, and swoon to balance everything out.
I had no idea what to expect from The Lookout's Ghost, but everything about it appealed to me and was so well done. I've never read a book set in a wildfire lookout, but OMG, what a PERFECT setting for a book like this? Bravo, A. Knightley, what a masterpiece! Do not sleep on this one my friends, romantic ghost story perfection.
October 2, 2025
This was brilliant, I loved it.
The writing was so good. There was humour, sadness, mystery, and new questions always popping up to keep you engaged. I predicted who it was at about 60%, but it did not change how much I enjoyed the story and having my guess proved right!
The two main characters, Reese and Charlie, were great from the start. Their meeting and the journey they went on were just so entertaining and unique. I wanted Charlie to stay so badly, but right until the end, I couldn’t see how the author could make it believable, but it really was!
I could not put this book down at all. I really hope she does go back to do Tate’s story too. I’m already excited.
Great book.
………………………………………………………….
I received an ARC from GRR, and this is my honest review.
The writing was so good. There was humour, sadness, mystery, and new questions always popping up to keep you engaged. I predicted who it was at about 60%, but it did not change how much I enjoyed the story and having my guess proved right!
The two main characters, Reese and Charlie, were great from the start. Their meeting and the journey they went on were just so entertaining and unique. I wanted Charlie to stay so badly, but right until the end, I couldn’t see how the author could make it believable, but it really was!
I could not put this book down at all. I really hope she does go back to do Tate’s story too. I’m already excited.
Great book.
………………………………………………………….
I received an ARC from GRR, and this is my honest review.
December 21, 2025
3.5 stars
This book was cute and had some truly romantic moments but I think perhaps my initial instinct was correct and the paranormal part of this just didn't connect for me.
The beginning of the book starts out really rough for MC Reece - he's given a lifechanging diagnosis and then pretty immediately breaks up with his long term boyfriend who has been having an affair. Reece's MS was hard to read about at times but it does serve as the catalyst for him moving back to his hometown to work at the lookout and leads to a complicated relationship with his parents (who mean well but are also struggling with the diagnosis). Reece was kind of a prickly asshole but it felt like he deserved to be so I went with it.
I really enjoyed everything surrounding the lookout job itself. The setting was great and the mystery had me intrigued. But while I loved Charlie as a character, I did find myself struggling with him being a ghost. If this were a typical paranormal book that had paranormal elements in the broader universe I probably could've coped, but it wasn't like that. We never know why Charlie is able to hang around, there's no indication that there are other ghosts out there, and the rules for how he interacts felt too arbitrary for me (and that's not mentioning the OTT ending).
Also, while I did think they had a good connection and I liked that this was slightly on the slower side of burn, I do think some of the romantic gestures and declarations were maybe a little premature/unearned. They were still very romantic and I did like a lot of the more domestic scenes of them together, it just seemed like maybe a little more development would've been nice for me.
This was a fun book but I think I should've trusted my gut that this type of setup doesn't really work for me. I would read more from this author though.
Pet names: baby
*
*
*
*
*
Safety (may contain spoilers)
SA/rape: None
Other person drama: None. The book starts with Reece breaking up with his shitty, cheating ex but otherwise there's no others.
This book was cute and had some truly romantic moments but I think perhaps my initial instinct was correct and the paranormal part of this just didn't connect for me.
The beginning of the book starts out really rough for MC Reece - he's given a lifechanging diagnosis and then pretty immediately breaks up with his long term boyfriend who has been having an affair. Reece's MS was hard to read about at times but it does serve as the catalyst for him moving back to his hometown to work at the lookout and leads to a complicated relationship with his parents (who mean well but are also struggling with the diagnosis). Reece was kind of a prickly asshole but it felt like he deserved to be so I went with it.
I really enjoyed everything surrounding the lookout job itself. The setting was great and the mystery had me intrigued. But while I loved Charlie as a character, I did find myself struggling with him being a ghost. If this were a typical paranormal book that had paranormal elements in the broader universe I probably could've coped, but it wasn't like that. We never know why Charlie is able to hang around, there's no indication that there are other ghosts out there, and the rules for how he interacts felt too arbitrary for me (and that's not mentioning the OTT ending).
Also, while I did think they had a good connection and I liked that this was slightly on the slower side of burn, I do think some of the romantic gestures and declarations were maybe a little premature/unearned. They were still very romantic and I did like a lot of the more domestic scenes of them together, it just seemed like maybe a little more development would've been nice for me.
This was a fun book but I think I should've trusted my gut that this type of setup doesn't really work for me. I would read more from this author though.
Pet names: baby
His shoulders fell. The cautious hesitance on his face melted away, like the weight of the world had been lifted. I marveled at the power of being seen, of being understood, even if it was by just one person.
“For so long, it felt like I couldn’t leave this lookout. It felt like I was trapped. Now, though, I wonder.” “What do you wonder?” I whispered into the space between us. “I wonder if I was only waiting.” I couldn’t vocalize the burning ache that bloomed in my chest at his words, but I could hold him close, and I could keep him warm. So I did. All night long. Because there was a part of me, one I was too afraid to even silently acknowledge, that wondered if I’d been waiting, too.
“I used to curse whatever it was that kept me here all those years. I don’t anymore. Not even a little. Even if this is all we ever have, I’m happy we had it.” Hot tears splashed my cheeks. “This isn’t all we have, Charlie,” I said, voice rough. “I don’t know how I know that, but I do. In my bones, I know that.”
If I could choose the face death wore as it lulled me into that peaceful goodnight, it would be his.
*
*
*
*
*
Safety (may contain spoilers)
SA/rape: None
Other person drama: None. The book starts with Reece breaking up with his shitty, cheating ex but otherwise there's no others.
October 30, 2025
Such a lovely book 🥹
• Mature main characters (finally!!)
• The whole “watchtower in the woods” vibe gave me serious The Canyon movie feelings 👀
• Great humor
• Friendship goals
• A touch of light mystery
• Of course, a bit of paranormal fun 👻
• And let’s not forget the spicy moments 😏🔥
• Bonus points for having a main character with a soft tummy — no abs, no perfect body, just real and adorable 🥹🥰
– The ending leaned a little too fantasy for my taste, but that’s okay.
P.S. Happy ending!! 💖
• Mature main characters (finally!!)
• The whole “watchtower in the woods” vibe gave me serious The Canyon movie feelings 👀
• Great humor
• Friendship goals
• A touch of light mystery
• Of course, a bit of paranormal fun 👻
• And let’s not forget the spicy moments 😏🔥
• Bonus points for having a main character with a soft tummy — no abs, no perfect body, just real and adorable 🥹🥰
– The ending leaned a little too fantasy for my taste, but that’s okay.
P.S. Happy ending!! 💖
October 16, 2025
I laughed, I cried, I had to watch funny videos before bed so I stopped thinking someone was watching me in the dark….
I loved every minute of The Lookout’s Ghost, even if it creeped out the wimp in me haha. It was so atmospheric it felt like I was right there with Reece and Charlie looking out at the dark forest.
If you’re after a spooky, thrilling, edge of your seat read, with the swooniest love story, and a side of bratty raccoon, look no further!
I’m not going to say too much about the actual story because I LOVED all the twists and turns so much that I don’t want to give anything away. Half the time I had no idea who to trust, and part of me was seriously worried how it was all going to end, but MY GOD it was so freaking good, and it ended perfectly!
I loved every minute of The Lookout’s Ghost, even if it creeped out the wimp in me haha. It was so atmospheric it felt like I was right there with Reece and Charlie looking out at the dark forest.
If you’re after a spooky, thrilling, edge of your seat read, with the swooniest love story, and a side of bratty raccoon, look no further!
I’m not going to say too much about the actual story because I LOVED all the twists and turns so much that I don’t want to give anything away. Half the time I had no idea who to trust, and part of me was seriously worried how it was all going to end, but MY GOD it was so freaking good, and it ended perfectly!
January 26, 2026
From the first page this book had me hooked. The prologue was so real, so raw and so heartbreaking. I have many friends and family members with chronic illness, many of them "silent" chronic illnesses and it's truly awful to see the lack of empathy of others when you can't "see" it.
Rant over... onto the book. Murder Mystery and a meet scare. Yep sign me up. Reece and Charlie's friendship is so genuine and endearing from the very beginning. The slow burn of their relationship is so beautiful and perfect. It was so authentic.
Of course the raccoons name is Randy.
I had so many theories, predictions, and just plain crazy thoughts. And all I will say is this book will keep you guessing until the last possible moment and I was here. For. Every. Second. It's been a long time since I sat and devoured a book in one sitting. That happened today. Thank you for a much needed escape into a wonderful world of possibilities. 🫶🏽🖤
10/10
5 stars
Come get your flowers @author.aknightley 💐
“You’re not the only one allowed to give everything for the people you love.”
Rant over... onto the book. Murder Mystery and a meet scare. Yep sign me up. Reece and Charlie's friendship is so genuine and endearing from the very beginning. The slow burn of their relationship is so beautiful and perfect. It was so authentic.
Of course the raccoons name is Randy.
I had so many theories, predictions, and just plain crazy thoughts. And all I will say is this book will keep you guessing until the last possible moment and I was here. For. Every. Second. It's been a long time since I sat and devoured a book in one sitting. That happened today. Thank you for a much needed escape into a wonderful world of possibilities. 🫶🏽🖤
10/10
5 stars
Come get your flowers @author.aknightley 💐
“You’re not the only one allowed to give everything for the people you love.”
October 9, 2025
“𝙸’𝚍 𝚎𝚗𝚍𝚞𝚛𝚎 𝚒𝚝 𝚊𝚕𝚕 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗, 𝚝𝚘𝚘, 𝚒𝚏 𝚘𝚗𝚕𝚢 𝚝𝚘 𝚖𝚎𝚎𝚝 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚊𝚐𝚊𝚒𝚗. 𝙰𝚕𝚕 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚒𝚗𝚓𝚞𝚜𝚝𝚒𝚌𝚎 𝚒𝚗 𝚖𝚢 𝚕𝚒𝚏𝚎 𝚌𝚊𝚗’𝚝 𝚌𝚘𝚖𝚙𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚘 𝚝𝚑𝚎 𝚐𝚒𝚏𝚝 𝚒𝚝’𝚜 𝚋𝚎𝚎𝚗 𝚝𝚘 𝚔𝚗𝚘𝚠 𝚢𝚘𝚞. 𝚃𝚘 𝚋𝚎 𝚕𝚘𝚟𝚎𝚍 𝚋𝚢 𝚢𝚘𝚞.”
This book had me in a chokehold! From the first page, I was completely drawn in by the haunting atmosphere and my heart was racing by the end of the first chapter.
A. Knightley delivers a story that’s as unsettling as it is romantic; an evocative blend of suspense, tenderness, heartbreak, and hope.
Reese, recently diagnosed with MS and dealing with the end of a long-term relationship, returns home to Ponderosa, Idaho to assist the Forest Service as a lookout during fire season. The solitude of the towers is familiar to him, comforting, even, until he learns he’s been assigned to Tower Seven, a structure that’s been abandoned for nearly forty years.
Locals know it by another name: Dead Man’s Lookout, the site of a decades-old mystery involving missing hikers and the unexplained disappearance of lookout Charles Randolph in 1986. Rumors branded Randolph a killer, but the truth was buried along with the past…or so everyone thought.
Determined to prove his independence and capability, Reese accepts the post, brushing off the ghost stories. But when he arrives, he’s forced to confront the impossible: Tower Seven isn’t as empty as it seems.
What follows is an unexpected and deeply human connection between Reese and the spirit who haunts the tower; a slow unraveling of grief, anger, and love that bridges the gap between the living and the lost.
The Lookout’s Ghost is a beautifully written story of resilience, courage in the face of the unknown, and a fight to not only survive, but to truly live.
5 spatchcocked stars!
This book had me in a chokehold! From the first page, I was completely drawn in by the haunting atmosphere and my heart was racing by the end of the first chapter.
A. Knightley delivers a story that’s as unsettling as it is romantic; an evocative blend of suspense, tenderness, heartbreak, and hope.
Reese, recently diagnosed with MS and dealing with the end of a long-term relationship, returns home to Ponderosa, Idaho to assist the Forest Service as a lookout during fire season. The solitude of the towers is familiar to him, comforting, even, until he learns he’s been assigned to Tower Seven, a structure that’s been abandoned for nearly forty years.
Locals know it by another name: Dead Man’s Lookout, the site of a decades-old mystery involving missing hikers and the unexplained disappearance of lookout Charles Randolph in 1986. Rumors branded Randolph a killer, but the truth was buried along with the past…or so everyone thought.
Determined to prove his independence and capability, Reese accepts the post, brushing off the ghost stories. But when he arrives, he’s forced to confront the impossible: Tower Seven isn’t as empty as it seems.
What follows is an unexpected and deeply human connection between Reese and the spirit who haunts the tower; a slow unraveling of grief, anger, and love that bridges the gap between the living and the lost.
The Lookout’s Ghost is a beautifully written story of resilience, courage in the face of the unknown, and a fight to not only survive, but to truly live.
5 spatchcocked stars!
October 26, 2025
Loved this one so much
November 21, 2025
This has been one of the strangest reads I got lately.
I didn´t dislike the book... but was not impressed by it either. And I think that´s due to two problems: One, the overexagerated YA tone (although all characters are 30+ yo). And two, the way the mystery´s solution.
So, this story is about Reece, a man who has been recently diagnosed with a chronic illness and accepts a job in the lookout tower of a national park.
In this tower he finds Charlie, a ghost of a man who died here many years prior and who... curiously looks and acts very similar to an alive person (hey, no complains here: It may be strange, yes, but I am not one to criticise since I´ve written about vegetarian vampires in my own stories. So to each their own).
That said, I give this a 3 because the romance was cute and the ambience was nicely done. If only I wish the threats of a murderer on the loose were a bit more obvious at times.
But anyway.
What I didn´t appreciate so much was the reveal of the murderer. A serial killer, who´s been unaliving people for decades (but no one caught them because... we wouldn´t have Charlie and Reece´s story if that was solved?).
Also, with the killer´s motive being: "I did this because I wanted to" and no explanation for the decades gap between killings, I´d say mystery wise this book is pretty bland.
So bland it got me annoyed at points (this was also contributed by some exagerated reactions of the main characters, who seem to behave like reckless 15 yo when emotions run too high).
Maybe that last bit is a me thing.
Whatever.
I do recommend this one if you´re looking for a wholesome paranormal romance (yes, it has a HEA, don´t worry). If you come here for the murder mystery... Please, don´t even try.
I didn´t dislike the book... but was not impressed by it either. And I think that´s due to two problems: One, the overexagerated YA tone (although all characters are 30+ yo). And two, the way the mystery´s solution.
So, this story is about Reece, a man who has been recently diagnosed with a chronic illness and accepts a job in the lookout tower of a national park.
In this tower he finds Charlie, a ghost of a man who died here many years prior and who... curiously looks and acts very similar to an alive person (hey, no complains here: It may be strange, yes, but I am not one to criticise since I´ve written about vegetarian vampires in my own stories. So to each their own).
That said, I give this a 3 because the romance was cute and the ambience was nicely done. If only I wish the threats of a murderer on the loose were a bit more obvious at times.
But anyway.
What I didn´t appreciate so much was the reveal of the murderer. A serial killer, who´s been unaliving people for decades (but no one caught them because... we wouldn´t have Charlie and Reece´s story if that was solved?).
Also, with the killer´s motive being: "I did this because I wanted to" and no explanation for the decades gap between killings, I´d say mystery wise this book is pretty bland.
So bland it got me annoyed at points (this was also contributed by some exagerated reactions of the main characters, who seem to behave like reckless 15 yo when emotions run too high).
Maybe that last bit is a me thing.
Whatever.
I do recommend this one if you´re looking for a wholesome paranormal romance (yes, it has a HEA, don´t worry). If you come here for the murder mystery... Please, don´t even try.
September 26, 2025
5/5⭐
How delightful! I can't stress enough how amazing this was. The vibes were immaculate. The book first caught my attention because of the fact that it's set at a lookout tower. For some reason those are my latest obsession, I just love the idea of isolation and cozy nature vibes. But boy the story exceeded my expectations.
I fell in love with Reece's character right in the beginning, he finds out he has multiple sclerosis and on top of that has to deal with his cheating boyfriend. I admired his strength so much and was happy for him when he decided to leave that life. Charlie stole my heart though. He was so sweet and kind-hearted, he really didn't deserve what happened to him. It was so joyful watching Reece and Charlie grow closer, becoming friends and then eventually something more. They had such a deep connection, it made me believe they were real soulmates. Tears were definitely shed over these two throughout the book.
The mystery plot was done so well, I had no idea who was the culprit until the very end when it was revealed. I think the author did a really good job with throwing breadcrumbs of suspicion on different people, so you really had no idea who was behind all the murders. The atmosphere was so good. I love suspense and we can feel the dread so clearly, it felt like we were in the lookout tower with them.
I wasn't sure about Tate's character in the beginning but by the end of the story he grew on me so much that I want to read his book now. I also wouldn't mind being back in Ponderosa again 🌲.
I kindly recieved an ARC of this book from the author and this is my honest review.
How delightful! I can't stress enough how amazing this was. The vibes were immaculate. The book first caught my attention because of the fact that it's set at a lookout tower. For some reason those are my latest obsession, I just love the idea of isolation and cozy nature vibes. But boy the story exceeded my expectations.
I fell in love with Reece's character right in the beginning, he finds out he has multiple sclerosis and on top of that has to deal with his cheating boyfriend. I admired his strength so much and was happy for him when he decided to leave that life. Charlie stole my heart though. He was so sweet and kind-hearted, he really didn't deserve what happened to him. It was so joyful watching Reece and Charlie grow closer, becoming friends and then eventually something more. They had such a deep connection, it made me believe they were real soulmates. Tears were definitely shed over these two throughout the book.
The mystery plot was done so well, I had no idea who was the culprit until the very end when it was revealed. I think the author did a really good job with throwing breadcrumbs of suspicion on different people, so you really had no idea who was behind all the murders. The atmosphere was so good. I love suspense and we can feel the dread so clearly, it felt like we were in the lookout tower with them.
I wasn't sure about Tate's character in the beginning but by the end of the story he grew on me so much that I want to read his book now. I also wouldn't mind being back in Ponderosa again 🌲.
I kindly recieved an ARC of this book from the author and this is my honest review.
September 26, 2025
I’d like some crispy chicken and twinkly lights, please!
The Lookout’s Ghost is spooky season perfect, it’s atmospheric, tense, and oh so romantic.
There’s a lot going on in this book but at no point did I feel like it was too much or the themes were fighting for attention. A Knightley seamlessly brought thriller, supernatural, and romcom together, and I was genuinely impressed by how well the plot came together at the end. I was kept guessing and on the edge of my seat until the last chapter!
The only reason this isn’t a five star for me is that I felt other characters accepted the supernatural too willingly. This was the only element of the plot that I felt wasn’t fully fleshed out, but I enjoyed the story so much it was easy to overlook while I was reading.
Thank you to the author for the ARC.
The Lookout’s Ghost is spooky season perfect, it’s atmospheric, tense, and oh so romantic.
There’s a lot going on in this book but at no point did I feel like it was too much or the themes were fighting for attention. A Knightley seamlessly brought thriller, supernatural, and romcom together, and I was genuinely impressed by how well the plot came together at the end. I was kept guessing and on the edge of my seat until the last chapter!
The only reason this isn’t a five star for me is that I felt other characters accepted the supernatural too willingly. This was the only element of the plot that I felt wasn’t fully fleshed out, but I enjoyed the story so much it was easy to overlook while I was reading.
Thank you to the author for the ARC.
October 26, 2025
I wasn't totally sure what to expect from this, but the premise sounded interesting. It blew me away! I loved Charlie and Reece and their romance. Then there was the mystery, which I was not able to predict ahead of time at all. This is so well done, and a definite reread.
March 9, 2026
I've been so excited to read this book ever since before it's release and my god it did not disappoint. Beautiful romance + captivating writing + an interesting and immersive plot with a perfect setting. I look forward to annotating this later!
October 5, 2025
I cried. I laughed. I gasped. I screamed.
I was on the edge of my seat when finishing this! The story is set up so well with the characters and the mystery. It could be anyone!
There was so much depth with each of these characters, especially Reece and Charlie. We have Reece whose life has just been turned upside down with his MS diagnosis. And then Charlie who is hit with finding out about his past.
Then we have side characters that are so nuanced. I truly loved the side characters and what they added to the story. I don’t want to say more because you need to form your own opinions but I will say, I could have read 200 more pages with more of them! There were so many humorous one liners!
I know A. Knightley was diagnosed with MS last year and I have to say, the insight into the disease was written with so much knowledge and care. It felt very raw and real.
You have to suspend disbelief with this story- it is paranormal and we don’t have answers for some things. But the mystery of Ponderosa was so well done.
This story is wildly unique. I’ve only read one other love story with a spirit.
I loved, loved! Thank you for this arc!
I was on the edge of my seat when finishing this! The story is set up so well with the characters and the mystery. It could be anyone!
There was so much depth with each of these characters, especially Reece and Charlie. We have Reece whose life has just been turned upside down with his MS diagnosis. And then Charlie who is hit with finding out about his past.
Then we have side characters that are so nuanced. I truly loved the side characters and what they added to the story. I don’t want to say more because you need to form your own opinions but I will say, I could have read 200 more pages with more of them! There were so many humorous one liners!
I know A. Knightley was diagnosed with MS last year and I have to say, the insight into the disease was written with so much knowledge and care. It felt very raw and real.
You have to suspend disbelief with this story- it is paranormal and we don’t have answers for some things. But the mystery of Ponderosa was so well done.
This story is wildly unique. I’ve only read one other love story with a spirit.
I loved, loved! Thank you for this arc!
October 21, 2025
4.5/5 ⭐
The Lookout’s Ghost is a standalone book by author A. Knightley. Here’s what you can expect from Reece and Charlie:
♥️ MM paranormal mystery and romance
♥️ First person single point of view
♥️ Guaranteed happily ever after
♥️ Open door spice
♥️ Murder mystery
♥️ Small town vibes
♥️ Chronic illness/disability representation (MS, migraines, Raynaud’s Syndrome)
♥️ Ghost main character
♥️ Slow burn
♥️ Forced proximity
♥️ Grumpy main character
♥️ Meet…scare?
Ensure you review the content and trigger warnings to decide if this book is right for you. Note this list of warnings may be incomplete. Please take care of yourself while reading.
I am a sucker for a book that combines my love of mystery thrillers and queer romance, so when I saw the blurb for this book (and the incredible cover) I knew I had to take a chance on it. And I’m so glad I did! I will say, you’re going to have to suspend your disbelief going into this one in order to fully enjoy it. One of the main characters is a ghost, and we don’t always fully know or understand why he’s interacting with the living the way he does. I found I wasn’t too bothered by this, but if you will be, this might not be the book for you.
Reece and Charlie were so sweet! Their romance truly is a slow burn under the most unique setting - a remote fire lookout deep in the woods. This book blends a decades-old cold case with a string of recent, missing and presumed dead hikers and I had a great time trying to figure out who the killer was. I also appreciated the chronic illness/disability representation the author infused into the story, and used their own experiences to shape Reece’s journey. There were some interesting side characters, and lots of humour and banter to offset some of the heaviness of the story. Overall, this was a great, unique book and if you’re up for something a little different, I’d definitely recommend checking it out!
I received an advanced review copy from Gay Romance Reviews and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The Lookout’s Ghost is a standalone book by author A. Knightley. Here’s what you can expect from Reece and Charlie:
♥️ MM paranormal mystery and romance
♥️ First person single point of view
♥️ Guaranteed happily ever after
♥️ Open door spice
♥️ Murder mystery
♥️ Small town vibes
♥️ Chronic illness/disability representation (MS, migraines, Raynaud’s Syndrome)
♥️ Ghost main character
♥️ Slow burn
♥️ Forced proximity
♥️ Grumpy main character
♥️ Meet…scare?
Ensure you review the content and trigger warnings to decide if this book is right for you. Note this list of warnings may be incomplete. Please take care of yourself while reading.
I am a sucker for a book that combines my love of mystery thrillers and queer romance, so when I saw the blurb for this book (and the incredible cover) I knew I had to take a chance on it. And I’m so glad I did! I will say, you’re going to have to suspend your disbelief going into this one in order to fully enjoy it. One of the main characters is a ghost, and we don’t always fully know or understand why he’s interacting with the living the way he does. I found I wasn’t too bothered by this, but if you will be, this might not be the book for you.
Reece and Charlie were so sweet! Their romance truly is a slow burn under the most unique setting - a remote fire lookout deep in the woods. This book blends a decades-old cold case with a string of recent, missing and presumed dead hikers and I had a great time trying to figure out who the killer was. I also appreciated the chronic illness/disability representation the author infused into the story, and used their own experiences to shape Reece’s journey. There were some interesting side characters, and lots of humour and banter to offset some of the heaviness of the story. Overall, this was a great, unique book and if you’re up for something a little different, I’d definitely recommend checking it out!
I received an advanced review copy from Gay Romance Reviews and am voluntarily leaving a review.
October 26, 2025
Oh my days. I know this was going to be good, having read the author's previous books, but damn! This story took me on a whole ride of emotions and suspense!
I instantly felt a kinship with Reece, as we start with his diagnosis, which my mum was diagnosed with at sixteen. It is life-changing and he understandably needed a change of pace. Taking a up a post at a Lookout Tower through the summer to help the forest service by his small home town is a no brainer. What he wasn't counting on was the recent missing hikers in the area. Or the ghost. Yehhhh....
I think a shock to the system is a good way to describe that one. Charlie is a total sweetheart, the only thing going against him is his lack of corporeal form. The two men get to know each other very well, growing closer and bonding but there are things happening down on the ground that is building the tension and danger levels for Reece. He has people from town worrying about him and his safety while the investigation amps up, especially his dad, his best friend, and the local police officer.
Some scary moments are dotted through the story to keep you on your toes. The scene setting and descriptions throughout this book are brilliant. I felt right there with the characters in the good times and the bad, but the atmosphere during those intense, scary times really amped things up. It's a very well written mystery. No clear indicators of who it might be but some good misleading moments.
Reece and Charlie are such a great couple together. There is a bond that quickly builds and only strengthens the more time they spend together. They have great chemistry and though there is the obvious barrier of one half of the couple being deceased, that doesn't stop them from growing closer in all ways.
I cannot recommend this book enough! A fantastic mystery/suspense and some amazing characters to enjoy. I really want to read more of Tate so I hope that is something that may come in the future. I am also really grateful for the epilogue as it felt like closure for the MC's in a certain regard.
I received an ARC and am happily giving a review.
I instantly felt a kinship with Reece, as we start with his diagnosis, which my mum was diagnosed with at sixteen. It is life-changing and he understandably needed a change of pace. Taking a up a post at a Lookout Tower through the summer to help the forest service by his small home town is a no brainer. What he wasn't counting on was the recent missing hikers in the area. Or the ghost. Yehhhh....
I think a shock to the system is a good way to describe that one. Charlie is a total sweetheart, the only thing going against him is his lack of corporeal form. The two men get to know each other very well, growing closer and bonding but there are things happening down on the ground that is building the tension and danger levels for Reece. He has people from town worrying about him and his safety while the investigation amps up, especially his dad, his best friend, and the local police officer.
Some scary moments are dotted through the story to keep you on your toes. The scene setting and descriptions throughout this book are brilliant. I felt right there with the characters in the good times and the bad, but the atmosphere during those intense, scary times really amped things up. It's a very well written mystery. No clear indicators of who it might be but some good misleading moments.
Reece and Charlie are such a great couple together. There is a bond that quickly builds and only strengthens the more time they spend together. They have great chemistry and though there is the obvious barrier of one half of the couple being deceased, that doesn't stop them from growing closer in all ways.
I cannot recommend this book enough! A fantastic mystery/suspense and some amazing characters to enjoy. I really want to read more of Tate so I hope that is something that may come in the future. I am also really grateful for the epilogue as it felt like closure for the MC's in a certain regard.
I received an ARC and am happily giving a review.
October 21, 2025
This book was beautiful. I could really tell while reading it that this story was a healing journey for the author. The way she wrote about MS and the struggles Reece faced with his diagnosis, but also in the way she wrote about Charlie and his relationship with Reece. The effect Reece had on Charlie.
I loved every moment of theirs story. It was scary, but also funny and sweet. Emotional and down right heartbreaking at points. But like I said, it was beautiful.
A lot of mystery romances have trouble walking that fine line between too much romance, but not enough mystery. Or too much mystery but the romance is seriously lacking. Not this book though, it walks that line perfectly.. where the chemistry between these two is off the charts, but you still have the spooky moments and mysterious elements along side it.
Definitely pick this up if you’re a fan of A. Knightley’s other books. If you haven’t read her before, I highly suggest you remedy that now by checking out this book!
I loved every moment of theirs story. It was scary, but also funny and sweet. Emotional and down right heartbreaking at points. But like I said, it was beautiful.
A lot of mystery romances have trouble walking that fine line between too much romance, but not enough mystery. Or too much mystery but the romance is seriously lacking. Not this book though, it walks that line perfectly.. where the chemistry between these two is off the charts, but you still have the spooky moments and mysterious elements along side it.
Definitely pick this up if you’re a fan of A. Knightley’s other books. If you haven’t read her before, I highly suggest you remedy that now by checking out this book!
September 27, 2025
♾️⭐️
🌶🌶🌶
This book is so well done! It’s definitely the best mystery/murder mystery I’ve read so far. And on top of that, it even comes with a beautiful HEA. The writing style, the story itself, the characters, and the constant new questions popping up made it impossible to put the book down.
At the beginning, I thought it might be kind of predictable – but nope, not at all. Everything I had pieced together in my head turned out to be completely wrong. The book took a whole different turn than I expected.
So if you’re still looking for a Halloween read, I can highly recommend this one!
🌶🌶🌶
This book is so well done! It’s definitely the best mystery/murder mystery I’ve read so far. And on top of that, it even comes with a beautiful HEA. The writing style, the story itself, the characters, and the constant new questions popping up made it impossible to put the book down.
At the beginning, I thought it might be kind of predictable – but nope, not at all. Everything I had pieced together in my head turned out to be completely wrong. The book took a whole different turn than I expected.
So if you’re still looking for a Halloween read, I can highly recommend this one!
October 21, 2025
This book is a warm hug.
There's mystery and danger and so much romance packed into the pages.
I adored both the characters. The plot was intriguing and the writing style beautiful.
So much love for this book.
There's mystery and danger and so much romance packed into the pages.
I adored both the characters. The plot was intriguing and the writing style beautiful.
So much love for this book.
October 28, 2025
This book absolutely blew me away!
The depth of feeling the author pours enrolment of this story left be breathless at time.
I screamed, I cried, I gasped!
The twists and turns kept me in the edge of my seat constantly and the love story was truly one of the most beautiful I’ve ever read.
A.Knightley is so good at delivering beautiful prose wrapped up in an evocative setting.
I really hope we get to revisit this world. The whole place felt so beautiful and otherworldly.
The depth of feeling the author pours enrolment of this story left be breathless at time.
I screamed, I cried, I gasped!
The twists and turns kept me in the edge of my seat constantly and the love story was truly one of the most beautiful I’ve ever read.
A.Knightley is so good at delivering beautiful prose wrapped up in an evocative setting.
I really hope we get to revisit this world. The whole place felt so beautiful and otherworldly.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 236 reviews