What do you think?
Rate this book
Death of a Stranger
1594, Bishopsgate Ward, London.
Within the walls and without, unease and uncertainty lurk beneath the noise and bustle of a smoky, teeming city.
Matthew Cutler, newly widowed and caring for two spirited daughters, takes his position as constable for the parish of Spitalfields very seriously. So when Paulo Brisco, a quiet Venetian perfumer is found brutally murdered in his own shop, Cutler throws himself into his first major crime, and one which threatens to set all Bishopsgate alight.
Being a humble parish constable, Matthew Cutler’s powers are slight – and yet he possesses a skill which most others do not. As a former actor he can employ disguise, to considerable effect and to his unique advantage...
Plunged into a treacherous world of notorious rakes, angry tradesmen and a community seething with anti-foreigner sentiment and suspicion, Cutler must decipher shattered clues and confront a killer whose motive remains a baffling mystery - until the very last.
Within the walls and without, unease and uncertainty lurk beneath the noise and bustle of a smoky, teeming city.
Matthew Cutler, newly widowed and caring for two spirited daughters, takes his position as constable for the parish of Spitalfields very seriously. So when Paulo Brisco, a quiet Venetian perfumer is found brutally murdered in his own shop, Cutler throws himself into his first major crime, and one which threatens to set all Bishopsgate alight.
Being a humble parish constable, Matthew Cutler’s powers are slight – and yet he possesses a skill which most others do not. As a former actor he can employ disguise, to considerable effect and to his unique advantage...
Plunged into a treacherous world of notorious rakes, angry tradesmen and a community seething with anti-foreigner sentiment and suspicion, Cutler must decipher shattered clues and confront a killer whose motive remains a baffling mystery - until the very last.
274 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 14, 2025
60 people are currently reading
75 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
October 22, 2025
Very enjoyable and cleverly plotted Elizabethan murder mystery set in London, 1594.
Our main character, Matthew Cutler is a widower from plague, and the impact of that on him and his family echoes through the book. He is a parish constable but fairly new to the role, as he was previously an actor, a rather looked-down-on job in those days. However his experience starts to come in handy as he investigates the murder of a Venetian perfumer. There are also a lot (though not an unmanageable number) of excellent side characters, and the various relationships are a core part of the story -- this isn't a one-man-show in any sense.
Highly readable, and with a strong sense of place and time without infodumping on the reader. Recommended!
This review is based upon a complimentary advance reading copy provided by the publisher.
Our main character, Matthew Cutler is a widower from plague, and the impact of that on him and his family echoes through the book. He is a parish constable but fairly new to the role, as he was previously an actor, a rather looked-down-on job in those days. However his experience starts to come in handy as he investigates the murder of a Venetian perfumer. There are also a lot (though not an unmanageable number) of excellent side characters, and the various relationships are a core part of the story -- this isn't a one-man-show in any sense.
Highly readable, and with a strong sense of place and time without infodumping on the reader. Recommended!
This review is based upon a complimentary advance reading copy provided by the publisher.
November 14, 2025
Death Of A Stranger, the first book in the Bishopsgate mysteries by John Pilkington, the story is about Matthew Cutler, who was once an actor in the theater but since his wife died he now stays home with his two daughters Katherine and Jane and his sister Margie. thanks to his father-in-law he is a constable which is beneath him but something he does to keep him honest dealing with house breakers and the like but on this day he is called because Paulo Briscoe the Italian perfumist has been found murdered. when he first gets to the man’s shop there is a particular cent in the air which puts him on the trail of that particular cent he finds it closer to home which leads him to a local brothel in Bishop’s gate but will not be the end of it they first blame foreigners and then learn of señor Briscoe‘s extra curricular activities with the finer ladies of the area which raises an eyebrow or two but where it ends is going to be further a foot and may even become an international incident. Thanks to Mr. Cutler and his close friend Margaret Fisher who seems to love investigating with him dawns the Lord and lady disguises but soon lives are on the line, seedy men give warnings to Cutler which has him sending his daughters and sister away only to bring them back when everything is safe but will he solve the murder without him being murdered as well? I really honestly loved this book Matthew Cutler totally reminded me of Matthew shardlake, whose books I love and only has me really anticipating the next bishop’s gate mystery historical fiction doesn’t get much better than this. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
January 18, 2026
This was a solid 4-star read for me, though the story unfolds slowly. It centres on Matthew Cutler, a new constable in the parish of Spitalfields, and his investigation into the death of Paulo Brisco, a quiet Venetian perfumer. The sense of place is outstanding and easily the book’s greatest strength. The mood and detailed descriptions make the setting feel immersive, as if you’re alongside Matthew Cutler throughout the investigation. It was very atmospheric. I’d recommend this when in the mood for a slow historical read rather than a fast-paced murder mystery.
Thanks to Netgalley and the authors for the e-arc.
Thanks to Netgalley and the authors for the e-arc.
November 5, 2025
1594. Paulo Brisco, perfumer and money lender is brutally murdered in his shop. Constable for the parish of Spitalfields, Matthew Cutler investigates. But the more he investigates the more dangerous and complicated it becomes.
An entertaining and well-written historical mystery with its cast of likeable and interesting characters. A good start to this new series.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
An entertaining and well-written historical mystery with its cast of likeable and interesting characters. A good start to this new series.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
October 14, 2025
3,5* rounded to 4*. A very pleasant mystery novel! The plot kept my attention from the startling beginning to the conclusion. Rather lighthearted in tone, the storyline did not bring up much tension, but the characters made up for it. I enjoyed Cluster's personality and his interesting sense of justice... Overall an easy but pleasant novel. I will keep on reading the series.
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
I received a digital copy of this novel from NetGalley and I have voluntarily written an honest review.
November 8, 2025
John Pilkington is an old hand when it comes to historical mysteries, with a number of series under his belt, among them the Thomas the Falconer series. Death of a Stranger takes us back to Elizabethan England in the first book featuring Matthew Cutler, a constable in the parish of Spitalfields. It’s 1594, when the murder of an Italian perfumer causes a need for answers, as well as anxiety among the other “strangers” or immigrants of the parish.
When a further threat against a French button maker occurs, the obvious conclusion is that someone is targeting the local “strangers”, either for being possible Papists or other reasons of their own. Matthew is fed assorted leads, a stonemason with a bitter nature since the loss of his daughter to the plague; a former acting friend of Matthew’s who had had a dispute with the perfumer. They’re all dead ends, but rather than dropping the matter as his employer, Alderman Skinner requests, Matthew determines to find justice for the dead man. Could someone be planting false clues?
What Matthew doesn’t yet know is how far his search for the truth will take him into the world of the movers and shakers of Elizabethan society, the perfumer having made house calls to favoured customers, some of them bored wives of powerful men. So there’s a lot to set the story going in interesting directions. Matthew hits wall after wall before he can convince his superiors that the case is worth pursuing.
As an investigator, Matthew is an interesting character. To begin with he’s educated, having fallen out with his magistrate father, and dropped out of his Cambridge studies after a year to become an actor. He lost his wife to the plague not long ago, and has two daughters in his care, his wife’s aunt living with them as housekeeper. He has come to the role of constable at the request of his gunmaker father-in-law.
As the story progresses, Matthew’s education and acting talent come in handy for questioning people of high public standing, an idea brought to him by Margaret Fisher, a comfortably off widow, friend and potential love interest. At first Matthew’s not convinced it’s a good idea – he’s used to being able to gain confessions from miscreants with the threat of the law and its grim punishments, but it’s a different story with the upper classes. I can imagine there will be plenty of potential for Matthew to don the clothes of Margaret’s late husband and the role of Sir Amos Gallett again in future books.
John Pilkington obviously knows his Elizabethan era well, for while Death of a Stranger is an entertaining story on its own, the period details make the story come alive. It was interesting to see a little of how humbler folk lived – so many historical novels concentrate on those at court – but I liked reading about the work of the gunsmith, the night watchman or the people at the local tavern, which doubles as a venue for the inquest.
Death of a Stranger is an enjoyable historical mystery, with John Pilkington writing in a style that sounds Elizabethan enough to add colour without being difficult for the modern reader. And Matthew Cutler is an engaging enough character for me to want to find out what he does next. I’ll certainly be on the look-out for the next book in the series. This first instalment is a four star read from me.
I read Death of a Stranger courtesy of Netgalley and Boldwood Books. The book is due for release on 14 November.
When a further threat against a French button maker occurs, the obvious conclusion is that someone is targeting the local “strangers”, either for being possible Papists or other reasons of their own. Matthew is fed assorted leads, a stonemason with a bitter nature since the loss of his daughter to the plague; a former acting friend of Matthew’s who had had a dispute with the perfumer. They’re all dead ends, but rather than dropping the matter as his employer, Alderman Skinner requests, Matthew determines to find justice for the dead man. Could someone be planting false clues?
What Matthew doesn’t yet know is how far his search for the truth will take him into the world of the movers and shakers of Elizabethan society, the perfumer having made house calls to favoured customers, some of them bored wives of powerful men. So there’s a lot to set the story going in interesting directions. Matthew hits wall after wall before he can convince his superiors that the case is worth pursuing.
As an investigator, Matthew is an interesting character. To begin with he’s educated, having fallen out with his magistrate father, and dropped out of his Cambridge studies after a year to become an actor. He lost his wife to the plague not long ago, and has two daughters in his care, his wife’s aunt living with them as housekeeper. He has come to the role of constable at the request of his gunmaker father-in-law.
As the story progresses, Matthew’s education and acting talent come in handy for questioning people of high public standing, an idea brought to him by Margaret Fisher, a comfortably off widow, friend and potential love interest. At first Matthew’s not convinced it’s a good idea – he’s used to being able to gain confessions from miscreants with the threat of the law and its grim punishments, but it’s a different story with the upper classes. I can imagine there will be plenty of potential for Matthew to don the clothes of Margaret’s late husband and the role of Sir Amos Gallett again in future books.
John Pilkington obviously knows his Elizabethan era well, for while Death of a Stranger is an entertaining story on its own, the period details make the story come alive. It was interesting to see a little of how humbler folk lived – so many historical novels concentrate on those at court – but I liked reading about the work of the gunsmith, the night watchman or the people at the local tavern, which doubles as a venue for the inquest.
Death of a Stranger is an enjoyable historical mystery, with John Pilkington writing in a style that sounds Elizabethan enough to add colour without being difficult for the modern reader. And Matthew Cutler is an engaging enough character for me to want to find out what he does next. I’ll certainly be on the look-out for the next book in the series. This first instalment is a four star read from me.
I read Death of a Stranger courtesy of Netgalley and Boldwood Books. The book is due for release on 14 November.
January 1, 2026
📚Death of a Stranger
✍🏻John Pilkington
Blurb:
1594, Bishopsgate Ward, London.
Within the walls and without, unease and uncertainty lurk beneath the noise and bustle of a smoky, teeming city.
Matthew Cutler, newly widowed and caring for two spirited daughters, takes his position as constable for the parish of Spitalfields very seriously. So when Paulo Brisco, a quiet Venetian perfumer is found brutally murdered in his own shop, Cutler throws himself into his first major crime, and one which threatens to set all Bishopsgate alight.
Being a humble parish constable, Matthew Cutler’s powers are slight – and yet he possesses a skill which most others do not. As a former actor he can employ disguise, to considerable effect and to his unique advantage...
Plunged into a treacherous world of notorious rakes, angry tradesmen and a community seething with anti-foreigner sentiment and suspicion, Cutler must decipher shattered clues and confront a killer whose motive remains a baffling mystery - until the very last.
My Thoughts:
Death of a Stranger introduces the reader to Matthew Cutler, a former player and now a widower, working as a constable of his parish, under the guidance of his father-in-law. Matthew is a likeable character as he navigates Elizabethan London. He has to contend with some quite tricky situations too, as well as trying to solve the mystery of who our killer is. He teams up with a widow with whom he has a past spark and together they try to unravel the motive. What Matthew doesn’t yet know is how far his search for the truth will take him into the world of the movers and shakers of Elizabethan society, the perfumer having made house calls to favoured customers, some of them bored wives of powerful men. So there’s a lot to set the story going in interesting directions. Matthew hits wall after wall before he can convince his superiors that the case is worth pursuing. I recommend to those that enjoy historical Fiction and Mystery.
Thanks NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Author John Pilkington for the advanced copy of "Death of a Stranger" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#BoldwoodBooks
#JohnPilkington
#DeathofaStranger
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✍🏻John Pilkington
Blurb:
1594, Bishopsgate Ward, London.
Within the walls and without, unease and uncertainty lurk beneath the noise and bustle of a smoky, teeming city.
Matthew Cutler, newly widowed and caring for two spirited daughters, takes his position as constable for the parish of Spitalfields very seriously. So when Paulo Brisco, a quiet Venetian perfumer is found brutally murdered in his own shop, Cutler throws himself into his first major crime, and one which threatens to set all Bishopsgate alight.
Being a humble parish constable, Matthew Cutler’s powers are slight – and yet he possesses a skill which most others do not. As a former actor he can employ disguise, to considerable effect and to his unique advantage...
Plunged into a treacherous world of notorious rakes, angry tradesmen and a community seething with anti-foreigner sentiment and suspicion, Cutler must decipher shattered clues and confront a killer whose motive remains a baffling mystery - until the very last.
My Thoughts:
Death of a Stranger introduces the reader to Matthew Cutler, a former player and now a widower, working as a constable of his parish, under the guidance of his father-in-law. Matthew is a likeable character as he navigates Elizabethan London. He has to contend with some quite tricky situations too, as well as trying to solve the mystery of who our killer is. He teams up with a widow with whom he has a past spark and together they try to unravel the motive. What Matthew doesn’t yet know is how far his search for the truth will take him into the world of the movers and shakers of Elizabethan society, the perfumer having made house calls to favoured customers, some of them bored wives of powerful men. So there’s a lot to set the story going in interesting directions. Matthew hits wall after wall before he can convince his superiors that the case is worth pursuing. I recommend to those that enjoy historical Fiction and Mystery.
Thanks NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Author John Pilkington for the advanced copy of "Death of a Stranger" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#BoldwoodBooks
#JohnPilkington
#DeathofaStranger
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
November 19, 2025
Elizabethan London with its dark and dangerous corners features in the mysterious and brutal death of Alessandro Brisco, a Venetian perfumer, who has his premises in Spitalfields. Matthew Cutler is a newly widowed, former actor with Pembroke’s Men, who has agreed to take on the office of constable, in lieu of his father-in-law, for the Bishopsgate Ward. Cutler takes his responsibilities seriously and he is respected, and occasionally feared, by some of the inhabitants who call this part of London home. Discovering who wanted the quiet perfumer dead will take all of Cutler’s considerable skills as he delves further and further into the mysterious life of Alessandro Brisco.
This is a really atmospheric and well written Elizabethan murder mystery which highlights the dangers of living in a time when neighbours were suspicious of neighbours and to be a stranger was to incite anger amongst those who felt threatened by their very presence in the neighbourhood. There’s an authenticity to both place and the people and I thought that the author did a great job of introducing us to the ordinary folk who inhabited Elizabethan London, the sights, sounds and smells of an overcrowded city are brought to life.
The author has created a likeable and engaging character in Matthew Cutler, I enjoyed getting to know him, learning about his family and the relationships he has with others all help to create a well rounded character who I am sure we will get to know well as the series progresses. The murder mystery at the heart of the story is done well, keeping the momentum of the investigation going without it ever becoming overly complicated.
Death of a Stranger gets this new Elizabethan murder mystery series off to a really strong start.
This is a really atmospheric and well written Elizabethan murder mystery which highlights the dangers of living in a time when neighbours were suspicious of neighbours and to be a stranger was to incite anger amongst those who felt threatened by their very presence in the neighbourhood. There’s an authenticity to both place and the people and I thought that the author did a great job of introducing us to the ordinary folk who inhabited Elizabethan London, the sights, sounds and smells of an overcrowded city are brought to life.
The author has created a likeable and engaging character in Matthew Cutler, I enjoyed getting to know him, learning about his family and the relationships he has with others all help to create a well rounded character who I am sure we will get to know well as the series progresses. The murder mystery at the heart of the story is done well, keeping the momentum of the investigation going without it ever becoming overly complicated.
Death of a Stranger gets this new Elizabethan murder mystery series off to a really strong start.
October 16, 2025
John Pilkington’s Death of a Stranger is a masterfully woven tale that immerses readers in the smoky alleys and simmering tensions of Elizabethan London. With lyrical prose and meticulous historical detail, Pilkington introduces Matthew Cutler — a widowed parish constable whose quiet resolve and theatrical past make him a uniquely compelling sleuth.
Set in 1594, the novel opens with the brutal murder of a Venetian perfumer, plunging Cutler into a labyrinth of shattered clues, xenophobic unrest, and dangerous secrets. Pilkington’s portrayal of Bishopsgate Ward is vivid and textured, evoking a city teeming with life, suspicion, and intrigue. Cutler’s ability to adopt disguises — a nod to his former life on stage — adds a clever twist to the traditional detective archetype.
What elevates this mystery is its emotional resonance. Cutler’s devotion to his daughters and his quiet grief lend the narrative a poignant undercurrent, while the supporting cast — from notorious rakes to wary tradesmen — enriches the tapestry of the story.
Elegant, gripping, and steeped in atmosphere, Death of a Stranger is a standout historical mystery that will delight fans of C.J. Sansom and S.J. Parris. Pilkington proves once again that the past holds endless secrets — and that the right storyteller can bring them thrillingly to life.
Thank you to John Pilkington, the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
Set in 1594, the novel opens with the brutal murder of a Venetian perfumer, plunging Cutler into a labyrinth of shattered clues, xenophobic unrest, and dangerous secrets. Pilkington’s portrayal of Bishopsgate Ward is vivid and textured, evoking a city teeming with life, suspicion, and intrigue. Cutler’s ability to adopt disguises — a nod to his former life on stage — adds a clever twist to the traditional detective archetype.
What elevates this mystery is its emotional resonance. Cutler’s devotion to his daughters and his quiet grief lend the narrative a poignant undercurrent, while the supporting cast — from notorious rakes to wary tradesmen — enriches the tapestry of the story.
Elegant, gripping, and steeped in atmosphere, Death of a Stranger is a standout historical mystery that will delight fans of C.J. Sansom and S.J. Parris. Pilkington proves once again that the past holds endless secrets — and that the right storyteller can bring them thrillingly to life.
Thank you to John Pilkington, the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
November 13, 2025
Death of a Stranger introduces the reader to Matthew Cutler, a former player and now a widower, working as a constable of his parish, under the guidance of his father-in-law. Matthew is a likeable character as he navigates Elizabethan London. He has to contend with some quite tricky situations too, as well as trying to solve the mystery of who our killer is.
We are treated to a depiction of Elizabethan London, after a resurgence of the pestilence, and with the memory of the Spanish Armada still fresh in everyone's mind. This is a time of unease and suspicion, alongside the rigid social strictures of the era.
The attempt to solve the mystery takes the reader on quite the journey through the Elizabethan underworld, as well as into high society, a society Matthew is effectively barred from, although there is an intriguing solution to it. At points, it feels as though anyone could be the murderer, from the lowest to the highest, and then many others in between. Matthew does not lack for suspects, but he does struggle to find the killer, even when someone is sent to effectively stop his investigation.
There is no doubt that I don't understand much about the Elizabethan justice system, and it's possible that some of the nuances may have passed me by, but I did enjoy this historical mystery, which contains the elements I'd expect from a story set in the era. An enjoyable read, and I look forward to reading more by the author.
We are treated to a depiction of Elizabethan London, after a resurgence of the pestilence, and with the memory of the Spanish Armada still fresh in everyone's mind. This is a time of unease and suspicion, alongside the rigid social strictures of the era.
The attempt to solve the mystery takes the reader on quite the journey through the Elizabethan underworld, as well as into high society, a society Matthew is effectively barred from, although there is an intriguing solution to it. At points, it feels as though anyone could be the murderer, from the lowest to the highest, and then many others in between. Matthew does not lack for suspects, but he does struggle to find the killer, even when someone is sent to effectively stop his investigation.
There is no doubt that I don't understand much about the Elizabethan justice system, and it's possible that some of the nuances may have passed me by, but I did enjoy this historical mystery, which contains the elements I'd expect from a story set in the era. An enjoyable read, and I look forward to reading more by the author.
November 4, 2025
Just finished Death of a Stranger by John Pilkington, and I’m still caught up in the fog and intrigue of 1594 London. The atmosphere alone is worth the read, smoky alleys, bustling markets, and whispers thick with danger. You can practically smell the spice and soot in every scene.
Our reluctant hero, Matthew Cutler, isn’t your usual swaggering detective. He’s a newly widowed constable trying to keep order in Bishopsgate while raising two lively daughters and when a Venetian perfumer is found murdered, he’s pulled deep into a web of secrets that stretch far beyond his quiet parish. What I loved most is that Cutler’s background as a former actor actually becomes his greatest tool; his knack for disguise turns this historical mystery into something smart, unpredictable, and a little theatrical.
Pilkington layers the story with moral weight and historical texture, fear of outsiders, the fragility of justice, and the loneliness of a man trying to do right in a world that keeps shifting under his feet. It’s both a vivid snapshot of Elizabethan life and a cleverly woven whodunit that kept me guessing until the final reveal.
✨️If you like your mysteries with grit, heart, and just a touch of stagecraft, this one’s a gem.
⚡️Thank you Rachel's Random Resources and John Pilkington for sharing this book with me!
Our reluctant hero, Matthew Cutler, isn’t your usual swaggering detective. He’s a newly widowed constable trying to keep order in Bishopsgate while raising two lively daughters and when a Venetian perfumer is found murdered, he’s pulled deep into a web of secrets that stretch far beyond his quiet parish. What I loved most is that Cutler’s background as a former actor actually becomes his greatest tool; his knack for disguise turns this historical mystery into something smart, unpredictable, and a little theatrical.
Pilkington layers the story with moral weight and historical texture, fear of outsiders, the fragility of justice, and the loneliness of a man trying to do right in a world that keeps shifting under his feet. It’s both a vivid snapshot of Elizabethan life and a cleverly woven whodunit that kept me guessing until the final reveal.
✨️If you like your mysteries with grit, heart, and just a touch of stagecraft, this one’s a gem.
⚡️Thank you Rachel's Random Resources and John Pilkington for sharing this book with me!
November 15, 2025
To cut short a long story, there was a mismatch in the reviews and I posted the one for The Ruffler's Child (Thomas the Falconer) instead of Death of a Stranger (Matthew Cutler).
As for other John Pilkington’s works, this one ranks high in my "sleep deprivation" and "one more chapter" charts. From the very first pages you find yourself immersed in the Tudor era, intrigued by the atmosphere and the characters.
The descriptions of London, the harsh reality of the poor, and the prejudice against foreigners (Italians were papists, Venetians were papists and trade competitors) are excellent. I think they are the most fascinating part, as John Pilkington creates a story that is not only a solid and intriguing mystery but also a detailed and realistic portrayal of society and the relationships between social classes and locals versus foreigners.
Matthew is the main character: a widower, a former actor skilled in disguises, and a clever constable. He is complex, trying to balance his role as family man and detective.
Bishopsgate Ward is shown as a place full of contrasts, bustling, noisy, and alive with trade, yet simmering with suspicion and danger. It becomes almost a non-human character, vivid and alive.
The plot is solid, one of those stories that captures your attention from the beginning and never stops making you turn the pages.
Well done. I hope to read a new one soon. Many thanks for this digital copy; all opinions are mine.
As for other John Pilkington’s works, this one ranks high in my "sleep deprivation" and "one more chapter" charts. From the very first pages you find yourself immersed in the Tudor era, intrigued by the atmosphere and the characters.
The descriptions of London, the harsh reality of the poor, and the prejudice against foreigners (Italians were papists, Venetians were papists and trade competitors) are excellent. I think they are the most fascinating part, as John Pilkington creates a story that is not only a solid and intriguing mystery but also a detailed and realistic portrayal of society and the relationships between social classes and locals versus foreigners.
Matthew is the main character: a widower, a former actor skilled in disguises, and a clever constable. He is complex, trying to balance his role as family man and detective.
Bishopsgate Ward is shown as a place full of contrasts, bustling, noisy, and alive with trade, yet simmering with suspicion and danger. It becomes almost a non-human character, vivid and alive.
The plot is solid, one of those stories that captures your attention from the beginning and never stops making you turn the pages.
Well done. I hope to read a new one soon. Many thanks for this digital copy; all opinions are mine.
December 12, 2025
1594, widower Matthew Cutler is acting as constable when a murder happens in his parish of Bishopsgate Ward. Was the man killed because he was a foreigner or had he made enemies...?
Death of a Stranger is the first book in a series of murder mysteries set in 1594 in Elizabethan London.
Matthew's wife recently died of the plague and he is keen to keep busy by solving this murder. An Italian perfumier is brutally murdered in his shop and initially there is no motive except the potential mistrust of foreigners. However, as Matthew investigates he discovers a whole host of secrets and suspects.
Readers are thrown into the Elizabethan era and the underworld of thieves and prostitutes. The historical elements are thoroughly explored including plague, church, a scathing attitude to theatre, the limitations of class and social norms. This book is set 6 years after the Spanish Armada and England is at war, leading to fears of papacy, foreign spies and treason.
I love the Tudor period so enjoyed the setting of the book. There are lots of details about life in Elizabethan England which does slow the plot a little. I also liked the personal side of the plot with Matthew's family and the woman who could heal his heart.
Death of a Stranger is a carefully plotted and well researched historical murder mystery.
Death of a Stranger is the first book in a series of murder mysteries set in 1594 in Elizabethan London.
Matthew's wife recently died of the plague and he is keen to keep busy by solving this murder. An Italian perfumier is brutally murdered in his shop and initially there is no motive except the potential mistrust of foreigners. However, as Matthew investigates he discovers a whole host of secrets and suspects.
Readers are thrown into the Elizabethan era and the underworld of thieves and prostitutes. The historical elements are thoroughly explored including plague, church, a scathing attitude to theatre, the limitations of class and social norms. This book is set 6 years after the Spanish Armada and England is at war, leading to fears of papacy, foreign spies and treason.
I love the Tudor period so enjoyed the setting of the book. There are lots of details about life in Elizabethan England which does slow the plot a little. I also liked the personal side of the plot with Matthew's family and the woman who could heal his heart.
Death of a Stranger is a carefully plotted and well researched historical murder mystery.
November 14, 2025
The first book of The Bishopsgate Ward Mysteries and a cracking start to this historical detective fiction series. It is 1594, two years since the plague died out and the area just inside the Bishopsgate of London, Spittlefields, is the ward of Constable Matthew Cutler. He is widowed with 2 daughters and has strict ideas about fairness and duty.
Briefly, when an Italian Perfumer is found brutally murdered life takes a sudden and dangerous turn for Matthew. His daily routine is turned upside down with his determination to find the killer. In his quest he is helped by a face from his past who is obviously carrying a candle for him. As he follows the trails he finds himself up against an extremely dangerous enemy and both he and his family are in deadly danger.
Matthew is an interesting character, from a wealthy family he gave up that life to tread the boards and uses his theatrical training to good effect in dealing with the upper classes. The period details are fascinating and the author clearly has done a lot of research. With some very clever work the reader is taken through life in the late 16th century whilst the Constable strives to complete his mission. An enjoyable and entertaining Elizabethan historical mystery.
Briefly, when an Italian Perfumer is found brutally murdered life takes a sudden and dangerous turn for Matthew. His daily routine is turned upside down with his determination to find the killer. In his quest he is helped by a face from his past who is obviously carrying a candle for him. As he follows the trails he finds himself up against an extremely dangerous enemy and both he and his family are in deadly danger.
Matthew is an interesting character, from a wealthy family he gave up that life to tread the boards and uses his theatrical training to good effect in dealing with the upper classes. The period details are fascinating and the author clearly has done a lot of research. With some very clever work the reader is taken through life in the late 16th century whilst the Constable strives to complete his mission. An enjoyable and entertaining Elizabethan historical mystery.
November 14, 2025
I thank NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an advance reader copy of Death of A Stranger. All opinions and comments are my own.
A righteous man uses deep intelligence, strength of character and even his old acting skills to uncover a devious murderer in Death of a Stranger, a new Elizabethan era series by seasoned historical mystery author John Pilkington. In this, we have Constable Matthew Cutler of Bishopsgate on the trail of a killer who has dispatched an Italian perfume seller.
Was it because the man was a foreigner, a “stranger” or, as Matthew wonders as the investigation takes strange and circuitous turns, are there darker forces at work? With help from friend Margaret Fisher (who wishes to be more than just a friend to widower Matthew), the constable goes “undercover” as a gentleman and his lady, seeking out clues and asking questions. Author Pilkington has captured the look and feel of Elizabethan London exceedingly well in the pages of this book, which highlights the plot.
Eventually, the story takes a turn, one that ratchets up the stakes. Readers may wonder if Matthew may find himself on notice for some interesting adventures, beyond those which occur just in the mean streets of Bishopsgate.
A righteous man uses deep intelligence, strength of character and even his old acting skills to uncover a devious murderer in Death of a Stranger, a new Elizabethan era series by seasoned historical mystery author John Pilkington. In this, we have Constable Matthew Cutler of Bishopsgate on the trail of a killer who has dispatched an Italian perfume seller.
Was it because the man was a foreigner, a “stranger” or, as Matthew wonders as the investigation takes strange and circuitous turns, are there darker forces at work? With help from friend Margaret Fisher (who wishes to be more than just a friend to widower Matthew), the constable goes “undercover” as a gentleman and his lady, seeking out clues and asking questions. Author Pilkington has captured the look and feel of Elizabethan London exceedingly well in the pages of this book, which highlights the plot.
Eventually, the story takes a turn, one that ratchets up the stakes. Readers may wonder if Matthew may find himself on notice for some interesting adventures, beyond those which occur just in the mean streets of Bishopsgate.
October 25, 2025
Death of a Stranger is one of those books that subtly draws you in to a place where you become so fully absorbed in the plot that you don't realise how mesmerising it is until you've finished reading and suddenly you feel its loss. I want more of Matthew Cutler's escapades!
Cutler is a quintessential gentleman in a time when social place and propriety forge character. He is relentless, though not in a threatening way, in his pursuit of rightfulness.
The author's grasp and knowledge of the times is commanding. and effectively transports the reader to the era. Add a truly intricate and masterful mystery plot that will have you guessing to the very end and you have a novel that is both enjoyable and rewarding.
Now I've found this author thanks too Net Gallery, I am off in search of his back catalogue where I know I won't be disappointed if Death of A Stranger is any comparison!
Highly recommended to lovers of historical mystery and those who just want a great read!
Cutler is a quintessential gentleman in a time when social place and propriety forge character. He is relentless, though not in a threatening way, in his pursuit of rightfulness.
The author's grasp and knowledge of the times is commanding. and effectively transports the reader to the era. Add a truly intricate and masterful mystery plot that will have you guessing to the very end and you have a novel that is both enjoyable and rewarding.
Now I've found this author thanks too Net Gallery, I am off in search of his back catalogue where I know I won't be disappointed if Death of A Stranger is any comparison!
Highly recommended to lovers of historical mystery and those who just want a great read!
November 15, 2025
Matthew Cutler is a constable in the parish of Spitalsfields in 1594. Widowed by the Plague, he lives with his two daughters and their aunt Margery.
Called upon to investigate the murder of an Italian perfumer Paulo Brisco, stabbed multiple times by a sword, Matthew is beset by well-meaning do-gooders keen to proclaim various people as the murderer. But Matthew's dogged pursuit of the truth leads him into darker secrets than he thought possible, and puts his own and his family's lives in danger.
I loved the historical details about this book. I work in the City of London, so mentions of place like Bishopsgate and Moorgate etc are places that I see all the time and made it doubly interesting, I even looked up a map of London at around this time to see how small London was and how areas that are now heavily built up were once fields. Loved the reference to Peckham Rye being in Surrey (I had to look that up to confirm that it would have been at that point).
However, historical detail aside, the mystery felt a little flat to me, Matthew's pursuit of potential culprits one after the other seemed to lack direction and although I know who killed Brisco there were so many motives flying around that I confess I don't really recall WHY.
This is only the first book in what looks to be a series, maybe Matthew's character will deepen and develop over time.
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
Available on Kindle Unlimited.
Bumped for release.
Called upon to investigate the murder of an Italian perfumer Paulo Brisco, stabbed multiple times by a sword, Matthew is beset by well-meaning do-gooders keen to proclaim various people as the murderer. But Matthew's dogged pursuit of the truth leads him into darker secrets than he thought possible, and puts his own and his family's lives in danger.
I loved the historical details about this book. I work in the City of London, so mentions of place like Bishopsgate and Moorgate etc are places that I see all the time and made it doubly interesting, I even looked up a map of London at around this time to see how small London was and how areas that are now heavily built up were once fields. Loved the reference to Peckham Rye being in Surrey (I had to look that up to confirm that it would have been at that point).
However, historical detail aside, the mystery felt a little flat to me, Matthew's pursuit of potential culprits one after the other seemed to lack direction and although I know who killed Brisco there were so many motives flying around that I confess I don't really recall WHY.
This is only the first book in what looks to be a series, maybe Matthew's character will deepen and develop over time.
I received an ARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
Available on Kindle Unlimited.
Bumped for release.
December 9, 2025
1594 London. An Italian perfume seller has been violently killed and, as Constable of the ward, Matthew Cutler is tasked with finding the murderer. With no clues from the scene of the crime or from the inquest Matthew is doubtful how he can make any progress. Some bits of gossip come his way together with anonymous letters suggesting names send him trudging through the streets gradually building up a picture of the dead man. When he's warned off continuing his investigation and his family is threatened then he realises he must be getting close. Matthew is a stubborn man and refuses to stop hunting for the killer, employing his skills as a former actor to get information. Full of red herrings, diversions, help and hindrance from his fellow constables, watchmen, petty villains and his friends and family make this an enjoyable tale with the streets of London brought to life
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
November 12, 2025
Mathew Cutler is a very smart parish Constable. He is taking care of his daughters while also mourning his wife. Italian perfumer Alessandro Brisco is found brutally killed in his shop, everyone seems to think they know who the killer is. Fingers are pointed at particular individuals of ill repute. Next, the button-maker Jean Meunier is attacked, luckily he survives. It is now up to Cutler to find out who is attacking these merchants before more bodies start to drop.
A very entertaining read with several intelligent side characters. Mathew was a fun read with the ingenious ways that he comes up with to solve the murder mystery. An enjoyable historical mystery read with the Elizabethan era in the background.
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
A very entertaining read with several intelligent side characters. Mathew was a fun read with the ingenious ways that he comes up with to solve the murder mystery. An enjoyable historical mystery read with the Elizabethan era in the background.
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
November 3, 2025
The first in a new series by John Pilkington. Set in London in 1594, Matthew Cutler is a former actor now working as the parish constable. The vicious murder of a local perfume seller proves a difficult case for Cutler to solve. Employing his acting skills to try to elicit information and with the help of his friends he is able to make some progress.
This is a light, easy to read story. The historical setting is vividly portrayed and the characters provide a warmth to the story. A quick and entertaining read.
I received a free review copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for my honest and unedited review.
This is a light, easy to read story. The historical setting is vividly portrayed and the characters provide a warmth to the story. A quick and entertaining read.
I received a free review copy of the book from the publisher in exchange for my honest and unedited review.
November 13, 2025
Matthew Cutler is a constable in Bishopsgate, outside the walls of London. When a stranger is found dead he sets about investigating to find the killer. This is a great little story following Matthew and his colleagues about the town. It's the 1500s and the skill with which the author brings it to life is superb. As Matthew trudges through the rain you can almost feel his discomfort. The characters are so well formed that you feel like you know them. I very much look forward to reading about them again.
With thanks to the author, Boldwood Books and Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book.
With thanks to the author, Boldwood Books and Netgalley for the opportunity to read this book.
December 11, 2025
London 1594 and Matthew Cutler, a former Player, works as a constable for the parish of Bishopsgate. When a local perfumer is found brutally murdered Cutler seeks to find the culprit but finds himself thwarted by his lowly status and threatened by people with power. He teams up with a widow with whom he has a past spark and together they try to unravel the motive. This proves to be bigger than they can imagine.
This is a pretty simple to read Tudor mystery which is rather enjoyable. The plot is straightforward, the writing none too complex and the characters have their own idiosyncracies. It's not the best I've read but it's also not the worst - a pretty decent effort.
This is a pretty simple to read Tudor mystery which is rather enjoyable. The plot is straightforward, the writing none too complex and the characters have their own idiosyncracies. It's not the best I've read but it's also not the worst - a pretty decent effort.
November 13, 2025
Set in Elizabethan London, this atmospheric murder mystery evokes the poverty and treachery of the time. Matthew Cutler, the parish constable, has to investigate the brutal killing of a Venetian perfumer and moneylender. Cutler, a recently bereaved family man, is determined to find the culprit despite facing a web of mistrust, prejudice and dark secrets. I enjoyed the immersive historical setting, the cast of characters that brought the story to life, and the twisty murder mystery.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
November 19, 2025
This was a new to me author. I like stories that are outside of the Regency, and the setting of 1594 fit the bill. A purfumer is murdered and Matthew Cutler has taken it upon himself to find the murderer. Cutler is a very enjoyable character, and steps on many toes during his process of poking into their business. I had no idea who did the deed. There were a few people along the way that certainly looked guilty to me. All in all, am enjoyable read!
Thank you to Boldwood for the copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
Thank you to Boldwood for the copy of this book. Opinions are my own.
October 20, 2025
Death of a Stranger by John Pilkington is a fun historical mystery in the tradition of C.J. Sansom's Matthew Shardlake books. This would be 3.75 stars if there was an option. Good characters, good tensions, a few twists. My main annoyance is that the constable doesn't seem especially smart, and he can't keep a secret (as soon as he says he will, he tells someone), but he IS determined to do what he needs to do to get an answer.
December 8, 2025
Oh, yes. Yes, I tell you, from my toes. I started this gem of a book yesterday, and I loved it. It's cleverly thought out and just as cleverly written indeed. I want to read more now, who wouldn't like to follow Cutler? It's as if you're right then and there in 1594. All the characters really comes to life and, you can't help to engage in the story. What a nice read, only too short. I want more.
(Please forgive my poor English, my excuse is I’m Swedish).
(Please forgive my poor English, my excuse is I’m Swedish).
October 27, 2025
I loved the mixing of social and political issues with murder in this book set in1594 London and featuring Matthew Cutler, a former actor, now employed as a Parish Constable. Great range of characters and the plot moves along at a brisk pace. I will definitely read more in this series.
December 21, 2025
Death of a Stranger by John Pilkington is an atmospheric and engaging historical mystery set in the tense streets of Elizabethan London. With a relatable hero, clever use of disguise, and simmering social unrest, it delivers a gripping whodunit that keeps readers guessing to the final page.
Read
December 10, 2025Ultimately not for me. DNF
December 30, 2025
DEATH OF A STRANGER - I enjoyed the historical details and the vocabulary. I found the investigation and bit slow. Otherwise, this story has good characters, interesting dialog, and interesting story lines. It does read like a Cozy mystery. Source: Netgalley. 3*
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews