What do you think?
Rate this book


928 pages, Hardcover
First published April 22, 1997
Loaned to me by a friend – this collection of Muir’s writings (Nature Writings: The Story of My Boyhood and Youth / My First Summer in the Sierra / The Mountains of California / Stickeen / Essays ) was a laborious but interesting read. Muir, probably the quintessential nature writer of the late 19th and early 20th centuries is at his best when describing some particular event (a snowstorm on Mt. Shasta; a bear attack on a sheep herd) and less so when expressing his personal connection to something or someplace. These efforts, while certainly heartfelt, reflect a 19th century style that – for this reader – was just too cumbersome.
Much has been said and written about John Muir’s dislike of indigenous people and that is certainly on display throughout this collection of writings (kudos to the editors at the Library of America for not trying to finesse this but instead presenting Muir’s words just as they are). John Muir’s disdain for the people and tribes he encounters is palpable and while it does not seem to manifest as hatred so much as total disregard, it is nevertheless striking. Not to justify it but again, a very typical 19th century – white person’s worldview of nature.
John Muir remains a central figure in the creation of the modern conservation movement and this Library of America edition is an excellent entry into his writings and his beliefs. The collection offers much to anyone who wants to try to understand Muir and his role in the creation of the environmental movement in America.