What do you think?
Rate this book
A Most Unsuitable Suitor
She must marry for her family's future. He must never marry at all.
Spring, 1805. Nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine is under pressure to choose a husband, but none of her suitors inspire her. Lord Milton is respectable but passionless, Sir Harry is charming but witless, and the dangerously handsome Mr Englishby has designs she cannot trust. The only man who truly interests her is Max Severin – cynical, scandal-shadowed, and not at all a suitable prospect.
But when a stolen kiss ignites a fire between them, Allegra realises she is in more danger from her heart than from society's gossip. Because Max carries a secret so perilous, it could ruin them both. And when long-buried truths about Allegra's family and Max's past come to light, the consequences threaten more than her reputation. Torn between duty and desire, Allegra must choose: a safe, sensible marriage… or risking scandal, ruin, and her very future for the only man she has ever truly loved.
Spring, 1805. Nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine is under pressure to choose a husband, but none of her suitors inspire her. Lord Milton is respectable but passionless, Sir Harry is charming but witless, and the dangerously handsome Mr Englishby has designs she cannot trust. The only man who truly interests her is Max Severin – cynical, scandal-shadowed, and not at all a suitable prospect.
But when a stolen kiss ignites a fire between them, Allegra realises she is in more danger from her heart than from society's gossip. Because Max carries a secret so perilous, it could ruin them both. And when long-buried truths about Allegra's family and Max's past come to light, the consequences threaten more than her reputation. Torn between duty and desire, Allegra must choose: a safe, sensible marriage… or risking scandal, ruin, and her very future for the only man she has ever truly loved.
322 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 28, 2026
136 people are currently reading
110 people want to read
About the author
Emma Orchard
12 books98 followersEmma Orchard was born in Salford. She studied English Literature at the Universities of Edinburgh and York, before working behind the scenes in publishing and television for many years. Her first job was at Mills & Boon, where she met her husband in a classic enemies-to-lovers romance. She now lives in North London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
March 7, 2026
Looking for Mr. Right
I really tried to get into this story but I kept leaving it and picking up something else.
The plot moved slowly, and my interest waned. Unusual, because normally I enjoy Emma Orchard’s titles.
Allegra Constantine has to choose a suitor. Her fancy alights on the unsuitable Max Severin. Her other suitors are like Goldilock’s porridge “just not right.” But Max?!
The two main characters figuring out if marriage was in the cards or not left me yawning and completely apathetic to their plight. They were quite commanding each in their own right, but together, the chemistry balked.
Even though the pace picked up in the last parts, I was just over it.
A Boldwood Boooks ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
I really tried to get into this story but I kept leaving it and picking up something else.
The plot moved slowly, and my interest waned. Unusual, because normally I enjoy Emma Orchard’s titles.
Allegra Constantine has to choose a suitor. Her fancy alights on the unsuitable Max Severin. Her other suitors are like Goldilock’s porridge “just not right.” But Max?!
The two main characters figuring out if marriage was in the cards or not left me yawning and completely apathetic to their plight. They were quite commanding each in their own right, but together, the chemistry balked.
Even though the pace picked up in the last parts, I was just over it.
A Boldwood Boooks ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
March 28, 2026
Nineteen year old Allegra Constantine is pressured by her mother to marry by the end of her second season. Three gentlemen prospects don't really spark her interest.The only gentleman who does, is the scandalous Max Severin. He's not a suitable prospect. Unfortunately, in spite of his reputation, he can't seem to stay away from Allegra and comes to her rescue on more than one occasion. Only he can't offer marriage and won't explain why. Allegra and Max's have surprising secrets. Good series!
Mild descriptive sex.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book from Netgalley.
Mild descriptive sex.
I voluntarily read and reviewed a copy of this book from Netgalley.
March 13, 2026
✧ 𝓟𝓻𝓮 𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭 ✧
Shout out to Boldwood books and NetGalley for the e-Arc🫶🏻
Just Finished Bridgerton part 1, and needed more of the regency vibes, And this seemed like the perfect choice while waiting for part 2!!!
✧𝓟𝓸𝓼𝓽 𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭 ✧
2.5✨
This definitely gave me the Victorian vibes, with the fancy balls and the beauty of that era,
But it’s was a-bit boring for me bcs of how slow it was, it took forever for me to get into it.
But aside from that,I liked the sister’s relationship and related quite to that.
And although I’m not a fan of the insta-love situation, I still enjoyed their story and how they made it work alas.
Easy fast read if you’re like me trying to fill the gap until part 2 is finally out😔🤝
Shout out to Boldwood books and NetGalley for the e-Arc🫶🏻
Just Finished Bridgerton part 1, and needed more of the regency vibes, And this seemed like the perfect choice while waiting for part 2!!!
✧𝓟𝓸𝓼𝓽 𝓻𝓮𝓪𝓭 ✧
2.5✨
This definitely gave me the Victorian vibes, with the fancy balls and the beauty of that era,
But it’s was a-bit boring for me bcs of how slow it was, it took forever for me to get into it.
But aside from that,I liked the sister’s relationship and related quite to that.
And although I’m not a fan of the insta-love situation, I still enjoyed their story and how they made it work alas.
Easy fast read if you’re like me trying to fill the gap until part 2 is finally out😔🤝
March 24, 2026
Gut rating: ⭐⭐
CAWPILE rating: 2.57
Spice: Open door
ARC publication date: February 28th 2026
DNF at 80%
Tropes: Dark secret, hidden identity, exploring heritage, secret liaisons, blackmail, multi POV, Napoleonic wars
My review:
If you're looking for a steamy Regency romp, this isn't the right book for you as the story is much more historical fiction than romance. While promising a fun, raunchy affair, the plot quickly lost its way, devolving into a dry exploration of heritage and family lineage.
The story remains trapped inside the characters' heads for most of the book, relying on internal dialogue that made the world feel stagnant and left me skimming most pages waiting for things to happen. While their secret histories are complex, the suspense never felt genuinely dangerous or tense.
My synopsis
In 1805 London, the marriage mart is far more daunting to the city's debutantes than the Napoleon wars raging abroad. Although deeply unwilling to follow her sisters into a loveless union, 19yo Allegra Constantine has found herself surrounded by eager suitors despite her short, plump stature and sharp tongue. Yet it is the mocking society outcast who she becomes inexplicably drawn to.
25yo Maximilian "Max" Severin is a man defined by a scandalous past and his mysterious Caribbean African heritage. Though he avoids marriage at all costs due to the dangerous secrets he harbours, he finds himself obsessed with Allegra, and she in turn craves a taste of passion before her fate is sealed. When snatching stolen moments in the shadows of garden parties turns to something deeper, Allegra and Max must work together to protect the secrets that threaten to destroy everything they hold dear.
With thanks to the Publishers and NetGalley for providing me with this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Trigger warnings: Sexual content, racism, abandonment, classism, infidelity, misogyny, homophobia, sexual harassment, colonisation, murder, alcohol, car accident, death, death of parent, slavery, war
CAWPILE rating: 2.57
Spice: Open door
ARC publication date: February 28th 2026
DNF at 80%
Tropes: Dark secret, hidden identity, exploring heritage, secret liaisons, blackmail, multi POV, Napoleonic wars
My review:
If you're looking for a steamy Regency romp, this isn't the right book for you as the story is much more historical fiction than romance. While promising a fun, raunchy affair, the plot quickly lost its way, devolving into a dry exploration of heritage and family lineage.
The story remains trapped inside the characters' heads for most of the book, relying on internal dialogue that made the world feel stagnant and left me skimming most pages waiting for things to happen. While their secret histories are complex, the suspense never felt genuinely dangerous or tense.
My synopsis
In 1805 London, the marriage mart is far more daunting to the city's debutantes than the Napoleon wars raging abroad. Although deeply unwilling to follow her sisters into a loveless union, 19yo Allegra Constantine has found herself surrounded by eager suitors despite her short, plump stature and sharp tongue. Yet it is the mocking society outcast who she becomes inexplicably drawn to.
25yo Maximilian "Max" Severin is a man defined by a scandalous past and his mysterious Caribbean African heritage. Though he avoids marriage at all costs due to the dangerous secrets he harbours, he finds himself obsessed with Allegra, and she in turn craves a taste of passion before her fate is sealed. When snatching stolen moments in the shadows of garden parties turns to something deeper, Allegra and Max must work together to protect the secrets that threaten to destroy everything they hold dear.
With thanks to the Publishers and NetGalley for providing me with this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Trigger warnings: Sexual content, racism, abandonment, classism, infidelity, misogyny, homophobia, sexual harassment, colonisation, murder, alcohol, car accident, death, death of parent, slavery, war
February 22, 2026
Wow this book was good I enjoyed it!!
scandalously spicy Regency romance
Spring, 1805. Nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine is under pressure to choose a husband, but none of her suitors inspire her. Lord Milton is respectable but passionless, Sir Harry is charming but witless, and the dangerously handsome Mr Englishby has designs she cannot trust.
scandalously spicy Regency romance
Spring, 1805. Nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine is under pressure to choose a husband, but none of her suitors inspire her. Lord Milton is respectable but passionless, Sir Harry is charming but witless, and the dangerously handsome Mr Englishby has designs she cannot trust.
March 17, 2026
What began as a mundane story (grouchy debutante vs smarmy admirer) turns into a surprising historical what if.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Thanks to Boldwood Books for the complimentary ARC of A Most Unsuitable Suitor.
Allegra Constantine is in the midst of her second season with no good prospects in sight. Her mother is determined to see her make a good match, much like her older sisters did, to secure the prospects of her three younger sisters who have yet to come out. Allegra has three men interested in her: Mr. Englishby, who has no income; Sir Harry, who has no brain; and Lord Milton, who has no passion. But with Allegra's unfashionable physique, lack of typical accomplishments, and Italian mother, she doesn't believe she can find anyone better, so she begins the process of whittling her suitors down. She starts by trying to kiss one of them to see if there is any kind of spark, but before she can even try, in swoops Mr. Max Severin—a very rich man with a very bad reputation—to put a stop to it.
Max was born in Martinique to an interracial couple. He was sent to England as a young boy and adopted by the wealthy, childless Severins. They gave Max a proper English education, loved him as their own, and he inherited their property and fortune when they died. Due to his race and French origin, he's been a bit of an outsider his whole life, and things only got worse when Napoleon started a war on the continent. Add in a youthful indiscretion, and Max's reputation is terrible. He's never wanted to marry and has never had any interest in debutantes, but he can't seem to keep his eyes off Allegra whenever she's in the room. But their relationship can never move forward because if anyone were to discover Max's true origins, it could spell death for him and his family.
I really didn't know what to expect from this book going in. I've had Emma Orchard on my TBR for a long time (I even own some of her books), but I hadn't read any of them. Then I got the link to the ARC, and it seemed like a great opportunity to dive into this author's work.
The conflict of this novel hinges on the challenges both women and those deemed non-white faced in English society in the early 19th century. Allegra does not feel a compulsion to marry. She's not particularly excited about the prospect of tying herself to some man she barely knows and becoming his property in the eyes of the law—especially since she's seen just what an unhappy marriage can do to a woman through her sister Viola's experience. But because Allegra comes from a family of modest means and is in a Protestant country, there aren't really any options for her outside of employment as a governess or paid companion, neither of which provides much of a living. Allegra spends much of this book trying to navigate her minimal options without losing her autonomy in the process.
Both Max and Allegra's mother deal with different forms of prejudice because of their ethnicities. Max doesn't know who his father is but knows he had to have been a Black man. And while people of color were not uncommon in 1805 London, they still faced racism, especially from high society. The only reason Max is invited to social gatherings is because he's so wealthy the ton can't exclude him. Allegra's mother, meanwhile, is Italian. Now, from today's lens, this doesn't seem like an issue—especially for Americans. But in the 19th century, Italians were not seen as on par with Northern Europeans. They were considered "Mediterranean" and were Catholic, so they were therefore lesser in the eyes of the ton. Allegra's mother maintains that her family were nobles, but no one can verify her claims, and she looks identifiably different from a typical English rose, so she and her daughters face discrimination. I thought the way Emma Orchard tackled both of these characters' backgrounds was interesting, historically informed, and also incredibly relevant to the way people view whiteness today.
I did enjoy the chemistry between Allegra and Max, especially their secret meetings. Where the romance lost me was in the huge jump from them being physically interested in each other to falling in love. These characters do not spend a lot of time on the page together in the first half of the book. That portion of the story was really devoted to Allegra's assessment of her other suitors. I didn't buy that they were actually in love with each other when they declared it. The emotional thread of their relationship needed to be woven into the plot earlier to make that work for me.
Overall, I liked the historical work done in this book, but the romance wasn't quite there for me. 3.5 stars.
Allegra Constantine is in the midst of her second season with no good prospects in sight. Her mother is determined to see her make a good match, much like her older sisters did, to secure the prospects of her three younger sisters who have yet to come out. Allegra has three men interested in her: Mr. Englishby, who has no income; Sir Harry, who has no brain; and Lord Milton, who has no passion. But with Allegra's unfashionable physique, lack of typical accomplishments, and Italian mother, she doesn't believe she can find anyone better, so she begins the process of whittling her suitors down. She starts by trying to kiss one of them to see if there is any kind of spark, but before she can even try, in swoops Mr. Max Severin—a very rich man with a very bad reputation—to put a stop to it.
Max was born in Martinique to an interracial couple. He was sent to England as a young boy and adopted by the wealthy, childless Severins. They gave Max a proper English education, loved him as their own, and he inherited their property and fortune when they died. Due to his race and French origin, he's been a bit of an outsider his whole life, and things only got worse when Napoleon started a war on the continent. Add in a youthful indiscretion, and Max's reputation is terrible. He's never wanted to marry and has never had any interest in debutantes, but he can't seem to keep his eyes off Allegra whenever she's in the room. But their relationship can never move forward because if anyone were to discover Max's true origins, it could spell death for him and his family.
I really didn't know what to expect from this book going in. I've had Emma Orchard on my TBR for a long time (I even own some of her books), but I hadn't read any of them. Then I got the link to the ARC, and it seemed like a great opportunity to dive into this author's work.
The conflict of this novel hinges on the challenges both women and those deemed non-white faced in English society in the early 19th century. Allegra does not feel a compulsion to marry. She's not particularly excited about the prospect of tying herself to some man she barely knows and becoming his property in the eyes of the law—especially since she's seen just what an unhappy marriage can do to a woman through her sister Viola's experience. But because Allegra comes from a family of modest means and is in a Protestant country, there aren't really any options for her outside of employment as a governess or paid companion, neither of which provides much of a living. Allegra spends much of this book trying to navigate her minimal options without losing her autonomy in the process.
Both Max and Allegra's mother deal with different forms of prejudice because of their ethnicities. Max doesn't know who his father is but knows he had to have been a Black man. And while people of color were not uncommon in 1805 London, they still faced racism, especially from high society. The only reason Max is invited to social gatherings is because he's so wealthy the ton can't exclude him. Allegra's mother, meanwhile, is Italian. Now, from today's lens, this doesn't seem like an issue—especially for Americans. But in the 19th century, Italians were not seen as on par with Northern Europeans. They were considered "Mediterranean" and were Catholic, so they were therefore lesser in the eyes of the ton. Allegra's mother maintains that her family were nobles, but no one can verify her claims, and she looks identifiably different from a typical English rose, so she and her daughters face discrimination. I thought the way Emma Orchard tackled both of these characters' backgrounds was interesting, historically informed, and also incredibly relevant to the way people view whiteness today.
I did enjoy the chemistry between Allegra and Max, especially their secret meetings. Where the romance lost me was in the huge jump from them being physically interested in each other to falling in love. These characters do not spend a lot of time on the page together in the first half of the book. That portion of the story was really devoted to Allegra's assessment of her other suitors. I didn't buy that they were actually in love with each other when they declared it. The emotional thread of their relationship needed to be woven into the plot earlier to make that work for me.
Overall, I liked the historical work done in this book, but the romance wasn't quite there for me. 3.5 stars.
April 8, 2026
Allegra Constantine is in her second London season with no promising matches in sight. Her mother is determined that she marry well, like her older sisters, in order to secure the futures of her younger sisters. The beginning of the book focuses on Allegra’s three current suitors, none of which seem right. Allegra doubts she can do any better than and begins narrowing her choices until the notoriously scandalous (and very wealthy) Max Severin intervenes.
Max’s background sets him apart from English society. Born in Martinique to an interracial couple and later adopted by a wealthy English family, he has always been treated as an outsider. Despite inheriting his adoptive family’s fortune, his reputation has suffered due to both prejudice and past mistakes. He has no intention of marrying, yet finds himself inexplicably drawn to Allegra.
What sets this book apart is its focus on the limitations placed on women and people of color in this era. I really enjoyed this aspect of the book. Allegra is not eager to marry, particularly given the legal and social realities that would strip her of independence. which she has seen through her sister’s experience with marriage and motherhood. Yet her options are extremely limited; without wealth or status, she faces a future as a governess or companion, neither of which offers much stability or freedom. Much of her journey involves trying to retain her autonomy within these constraints. The book also explores Max's experiences as a person of color during this time period.
I did enjoy the chemistry between Allegra and Max. However, the romance ultimately didn’t fully work for me. The transition from physical attraction to love felt rushed, especially since they spend relatively little time together in the first half of the book. That portion focuses more on Allegra evaluating her other suitors, which made their eventual emotional connection feel underdeveloped.
Overall, I appreciated the historical depth and thematic exploration, but the romance itself fell a bit short. I'd give it 3.5 stars.
Max’s background sets him apart from English society. Born in Martinique to an interracial couple and later adopted by a wealthy English family, he has always been treated as an outsider. Despite inheriting his adoptive family’s fortune, his reputation has suffered due to both prejudice and past mistakes. He has no intention of marrying, yet finds himself inexplicably drawn to Allegra.
What sets this book apart is its focus on the limitations placed on women and people of color in this era. I really enjoyed this aspect of the book. Allegra is not eager to marry, particularly given the legal and social realities that would strip her of independence. which she has seen through her sister’s experience with marriage and motherhood. Yet her options are extremely limited; without wealth or status, she faces a future as a governess or companion, neither of which offers much stability or freedom. Much of her journey involves trying to retain her autonomy within these constraints. The book also explores Max's experiences as a person of color during this time period.
I did enjoy the chemistry between Allegra and Max. However, the romance ultimately didn’t fully work for me. The transition from physical attraction to love felt rushed, especially since they spend relatively little time together in the first half of the book. That portion focuses more on Allegra evaluating her other suitors, which made their eventual emotional connection feel underdeveloped.
Overall, I appreciated the historical depth and thematic exploration, but the romance itself fell a bit short. I'd give it 3.5 stars.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Title: A Most Unsuitable Suitor
Author: Emma Orchard-I read A Gentleman's Offer & gave it 4🌟
Publication date: 2-28-26 | Read: 2-25-26
Format: e-Book 320 pgs.
Genre:
*Historical Romance
*Adult Fic
*Regency
Tropes:
*marriage market
*forbidden romance
*he makes the 1st move/he falls 1st
*haut ton
*secret/hidden identities
POV: 3rd person dual
TW: racism, prejudice, homophobia, patriarchy, classism
Setting: London 1805
Summary: Allegra is on the marriage market desperate to escape her mother's matchmaking. Max vows never to marry afraid his past may be exposed. When Allegra is on the road to ruin with one of her suitors, Max swoops in and kisses her. Allegra wants to experience pleasure before marrying, but will she want Max after learning about his past?
Heroine: Allegra Constantine-19, left-handed, not highly accomplished, not a great beauty
Hero: Maximillian "Max" Severin-26, of African descent-paternal grandmother was a slave, Max was adopted
Other Characters:
* Sabrina, Viola-21, Beatrice-15, Cecilia-12, Bianca-9-Allegra's sisters
*Mrs. Leontina Constantine-Allegra's mother with 6 daughters
*Lord Milton, Sir Harry Eager, and Mr.Englishby-Allegra's suitors
My Thoughts: The themes in this novel of identity and family kept me interested. Allegra and Max had great chemistry, and I rooted for them to be together against society's norms of what is right and proper. Mrs. Constantine had a secret of her Italian heritage. I loved the diversity represented in Max and Lord Milton in the ton. This was another excellent historical, and I can't wait for the next one!
Rating: 5/5🌟
Spice level: 3/5🔥
Thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for this ARC! I voluntarily give my honest review, and all opinions are my own.
Author: Emma Orchard-I read A Gentleman's Offer & gave it 4🌟
Publication date: 2-28-26 | Read: 2-25-26
Format: e-Book 320 pgs.
Genre:
*Historical Romance
*Adult Fic
*Regency
Tropes:
*marriage market
*forbidden romance
*he makes the 1st move/he falls 1st
*haut ton
*secret/hidden identities
POV: 3rd person dual
TW: racism, prejudice, homophobia, patriarchy, classism
Setting: London 1805
Summary: Allegra is on the marriage market desperate to escape her mother's matchmaking. Max vows never to marry afraid his past may be exposed. When Allegra is on the road to ruin with one of her suitors, Max swoops in and kisses her. Allegra wants to experience pleasure before marrying, but will she want Max after learning about his past?
Heroine: Allegra Constantine-19, left-handed, not highly accomplished, not a great beauty
Hero: Maximillian "Max" Severin-26, of African descent-paternal grandmother was a slave, Max was adopted
Other Characters:
* Sabrina, Viola-21, Beatrice-15, Cecilia-12, Bianca-9-Allegra's sisters
*Mrs. Leontina Constantine-Allegra's mother with 6 daughters
*Lord Milton, Sir Harry Eager, and Mr.Englishby-Allegra's suitors
My Thoughts: The themes in this novel of identity and family kept me interested. Allegra and Max had great chemistry, and I rooted for them to be together against society's norms of what is right and proper. Mrs. Constantine had a secret of her Italian heritage. I loved the diversity represented in Max and Lord Milton in the ton. This was another excellent historical, and I can't wait for the next one!
Rating: 5/5🌟
Spice level: 3/5🔥
Thanks to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for this ARC! I voluntarily give my honest review, and all opinions are my own.
March 3, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Ms. Orchard for the opportunity to read an ARC of this title. An honest review was requested but not required.
I meant to post this a couple days ago but my son’s birthday was right at the same time and the celebration(s) took up a lot of time!
I’ve read and enjoyed other books by Ms. Orchard and each time I am struck by the strong Georgette Heyer vibe. The authenticity of the characters, speech style, mannerisms, settings etc all seems very legitimate. Allegra, the third of six sisters (whew), needs to marry. Thanks to two (very) good marriages by her elder sisters, she is afforded a bit more lassitude than they had, but she still must show out well for herself considering (a) her family isn’t all that wealthy (b) there’s three more girls to go and (c) her heritage is not entirely foolproof in provenance. She is juggling three suitors, none of whom she’s particularly interested in for various reasons, and trying to resist an attraction to Max Severin. Mr. Severin, however, CAN’T marry, for reasons that until about 85% are a total mystery.
Unfortunately, that comprises the majority of the plot. There’s a blackmailer, and a secret grandpa, but very little actually happens other than some talking and some fooling around. I appreciated the discussion of race (particularly in light of the fact that both Allegra and Max were considered less than eligible parties at the time) but I would have liked a little more movement in the plot. Nonetheless, Emma Orchard’s writing is so good that I’ll definitely be back for more.
3.5 stars, rounding up for GR. ⭐⭐⭐1/2
I meant to post this a couple days ago but my son’s birthday was right at the same time and the celebration(s) took up a lot of time!
I’ve read and enjoyed other books by Ms. Orchard and each time I am struck by the strong Georgette Heyer vibe. The authenticity of the characters, speech style, mannerisms, settings etc all seems very legitimate. Allegra, the third of six sisters (whew), needs to marry. Thanks to two (very) good marriages by her elder sisters, she is afforded a bit more lassitude than they had, but she still must show out well for herself considering (a) her family isn’t all that wealthy (b) there’s three more girls to go and (c) her heritage is not entirely foolproof in provenance. She is juggling three suitors, none of whom she’s particularly interested in for various reasons, and trying to resist an attraction to Max Severin. Mr. Severin, however, CAN’T marry, for reasons that until about 85% are a total mystery.
Unfortunately, that comprises the majority of the plot. There’s a blackmailer, and a secret grandpa, but very little actually happens other than some talking and some fooling around. I appreciated the discussion of race (particularly in light of the fact that both Allegra and Max were considered less than eligible parties at the time) but I would have liked a little more movement in the plot. Nonetheless, Emma Orchard’s writing is so good that I’ll definitely be back for more.
3.5 stars, rounding up for GR. ⭐⭐⭐1/2
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Most Unsuitable Suitor is an absolute delight—elegant, witty, and just the right amount of scandalous. Emma Orchard captures everything readers love about Regency romance while giving it a fresh, spirited edge that makes the pages fly by.
Allegra Constantine is a wonderfully engaging heroine: bright, curious, and far too alive for the dull parade of suitors being pushed her way. Her world is full of expectations, but none of the men vying for her hand stir anything close to passion… until Max Severin enters the scene. Cynical, brooding, and wrapped in whispers of scandal, he’s exactly the sort of man she should avoid—and exactly the one she can’t stop thinking about.
Their chemistry is irresistible. From the moment that stolen kiss sparks between them, the story hums with tension—romantic, emotional, and social. Orchard balances the swoon‑worthy moments with a deeper thread of mystery, weaving in long‑buried secrets, family revelations, and the kind of danger that feels perfectly at home in a Regency setting.
The supporting cast adds charm and humour, the period detail feels lush without ever slowing the pace, and the romance itself is both tender and deliciously bold. It’s easy to see why readers of Bridgerton will fall head over heels for this one.
A captivating blend of desire, intrigue, and high‑society drama, A Most Unsuitable Suitor is a joy from start to finish—warm, romantic, and wonderfully escapist.
with thanks to Emma Orchard, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Allegra Constantine is a wonderfully engaging heroine: bright, curious, and far too alive for the dull parade of suitors being pushed her way. Her world is full of expectations, but none of the men vying for her hand stir anything close to passion… until Max Severin enters the scene. Cynical, brooding, and wrapped in whispers of scandal, he’s exactly the sort of man she should avoid—and exactly the one she can’t stop thinking about.
Their chemistry is irresistible. From the moment that stolen kiss sparks between them, the story hums with tension—romantic, emotional, and social. Orchard balances the swoon‑worthy moments with a deeper thread of mystery, weaving in long‑buried secrets, family revelations, and the kind of danger that feels perfectly at home in a Regency setting.
The supporting cast adds charm and humour, the period detail feels lush without ever slowing the pace, and the romance itself is both tender and deliciously bold. It’s easy to see why readers of Bridgerton will fall head over heels for this one.
A captivating blend of desire, intrigue, and high‑society drama, A Most Unsuitable Suitor is a joy from start to finish—warm, romantic, and wonderfully escapist.
with thanks to Emma Orchard, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Allegra and Max’s story is engaging, even if their romance leans toward instant love. Allegra is honest, direct, and deeply driven by passion—whether she’s standing her ground in an argument or surrendering to a romantic moment. While some readers may find her spoiled or childish, I saw her more as a sheltered young woman shaped by her time, raised in an era where women were closely guarded and rarely encouraged to develop academic independence.
Max’s story, on the other hand, is wrapped in mystery and marked by a dangerous past that has left him fearful of the very family life he secretly longs for. He presents himself as a lone wolf—intimidating, detached, and seemingly without roots—but he’s unaware that the secrets he carries could endanger not only his own life, but also that of any future wife or children. Everything changes when he crosses paths with Allegra, a woman whose passion and sincerity slowly unravel his carefully constructed walls. His attraction to her is unexpected and undeniable, even to himself.
When Allegra’s reputation—and life—are threatened by a villainous figure, Max steps in, only to uncover that her family is also entangled in secrets, and lies. What follows is a story of discovery, protection, and emotional growth.
In the end, this is a sweet historical romance about second chances, confronting the past, and finding a future with the family you choose rather than the one you’re born into.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and author for this ARC. This is my voluntary and honest review.
Max’s story, on the other hand, is wrapped in mystery and marked by a dangerous past that has left him fearful of the very family life he secretly longs for. He presents himself as a lone wolf—intimidating, detached, and seemingly without roots—but he’s unaware that the secrets he carries could endanger not only his own life, but also that of any future wife or children. Everything changes when he crosses paths with Allegra, a woman whose passion and sincerity slowly unravel his carefully constructed walls. His attraction to her is unexpected and undeniable, even to himself.
When Allegra’s reputation—and life—are threatened by a villainous figure, Max steps in, only to uncover that her family is also entangled in secrets, and lies. What follows is a story of discovery, protection, and emotional growth.
In the end, this is a sweet historical romance about second chances, confronting the past, and finding a future with the family you choose rather than the one you’re born into.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and author for this ARC. This is my voluntary and honest review.
February 28, 2026
Allegra Constantine is on the lookout for a marriage. Her mother is pushing her to marry a suitable man while her sister says to marry for love. Of the suitors available, there's a single possibility and that's not an ideal match in any way. While this is happening, she notices Max Severin on the sidelines of the social events she attends. He seems always to be watching her, and she doesn't know what to make of it. Then Max comes to her rescue when one of the suitors attempts to lead her astray. And instead of the unsuitable suitor being involved in a risky situation, it's Max that is filling her with passion. For both Allegra and Max, there are complications happening in the background of their found passion.
I wanted to like this a lot more than I did. I've read the writer's previous books and enjoyed them all thoroughly, but this one just doesn't quite hit the spot. I think it comes down to the fact that I don't feel any love between the characters. The whole thing seems to revolve around their attraction and lust for each other. That's all well and good, but it's not the basis for love. It just feels really tenuous at best, and I'd like to have more of a romance than is present. All that said, I didn't dislike this exactly either and it's a perfectly good read if you are looking for more of the attraction and less of the romantic stuff.
I'd like to thank Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing an advanced reader copy for free. I've provided my feedback voluntarily.
I wanted to like this a lot more than I did. I've read the writer's previous books and enjoyed them all thoroughly, but this one just doesn't quite hit the spot. I think it comes down to the fact that I don't feel any love between the characters. The whole thing seems to revolve around their attraction and lust for each other. That's all well and good, but it's not the basis for love. It just feels really tenuous at best, and I'd like to have more of a romance than is present. All that said, I didn't dislike this exactly either and it's a perfectly good read if you are looking for more of the attraction and less of the romantic stuff.
I'd like to thank Netgalley and Boldwood Books for providing an advanced reader copy for free. I've provided my feedback voluntarily.
January 28, 2026
Romance can feel repetitive, Regency romance maybe even more so but to my utter delight this book steered clear from trodden paths whilst, overall, still following a certain arc and meeting certain expectations that come with the genre.
Allegra isn’t tall, isn’t accomplished, isn’t a beauty per sé, and isn’t rich. She is fierce, and stubborn, and must marry. Her eldest sister is utterly unhappy with a Duke 30 years her senior and Allegra doesn’t want that. Doesn’t want any of her suitors, really.
In a reckless mood, she goes out into the garden, but is saved -in more ways than I can explain, because plot- by Mr Max Severin - NOT her suitor.
There’s intrigue that was genuinely intriguing, themes that might feel very ThisDayAndAge but are really of all days and ages, but mostly not addressed (Mr Severin is a Quadroon, for one. Love, whom we believe and who gets to say what are others) and it is all very well written. There were parts where we were in the heads of either Max Severin or Allegra Constantine that were mainly explaining, but it never felt like info dumping, or over-explaining, or underestimating the reader or even breaking the flow of the story.
There’s some spice - well written- but no smut, and I’d like to believe some men back in Regency times were as vocal and empathic about consent (who knows? Though I think… probably not, but it didn’t bother me that much).
Actual criticism for the Deux ex Machina, but to be fair: I was too enthusiastic about, and invested in, the story to really bother.
Reading the acknowledgements I nodded - of course the author mentioned Georgette Heyer and that’s another accolade.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and Boldwood books in return for my honest opinion
Out February 28
Allegra isn’t tall, isn’t accomplished, isn’t a beauty per sé, and isn’t rich. She is fierce, and stubborn, and must marry. Her eldest sister is utterly unhappy with a Duke 30 years her senior and Allegra doesn’t want that. Doesn’t want any of her suitors, really.
In a reckless mood, she goes out into the garden, but is saved -in more ways than I can explain, because plot- by Mr Max Severin - NOT her suitor.
There’s intrigue that was genuinely intriguing, themes that might feel very ThisDayAndAge but are really of all days and ages, but mostly not addressed (Mr Severin is a Quadroon, for one. Love, whom we believe and who gets to say what are others) and it is all very well written. There were parts where we were in the heads of either Max Severin or Allegra Constantine that were mainly explaining, but it never felt like info dumping, or over-explaining, or underestimating the reader or even breaking the flow of the story.
There’s some spice - well written- but no smut, and I’d like to believe some men back in Regency times were as vocal and empathic about consent (who knows? Though I think… probably not, but it didn’t bother me that much).
Actual criticism for the Deux ex Machina, but to be fair: I was too enthusiastic about, and invested in, the story to really bother.
Reading the acknowledgements I nodded - of course the author mentioned Georgette Heyer and that’s another accolade.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and Boldwood books in return for my honest opinion
Out February 28
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
London - 1805
Max Severin, 25, is wealthy and well educated but truly not acceptable in the ton. Is it because he is part African or because of his tarnished name? As a quadroon, he doesn’t expect to be accepted unless they want his money. He really isn’t interested in marriage, however, he is rather intrigued by Miss Allegra Constantine.
This is Allegra’s second season and as one of 6 sisters, she is expected to marry and soon. Allegra is short and rather plain with no real talents either. However, of the 3 men who show any interest in her, none of them truly appeal. When she sees Max Severin watching her at events with a bit of amusement on his face, it makes her more intrigued by him.
When Max rescues Allegra from a possible embarrassing gaffe at a soiree, she is drawn to him and he to her. They meet up privately a couple of times that could mean she would be ruined if found out. A threat by a man who could court her brings Max in to rescue her once again. However, the truth of his birth is such a huge secret that he doesn’t feel right about asking a woman to marry him although he is very attracted to Allegra. Is there a way he can get around his background to allow him to ask for Allegra’s hand?
This is an unusual story with a believe-it-or-not bit of history behind Max. I enjoyed the intrigue and was pleased with how well the author brought everything together. Enjoy.
Copy provided by NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Max Severin, 25, is wealthy and well educated but truly not acceptable in the ton. Is it because he is part African or because of his tarnished name? As a quadroon, he doesn’t expect to be accepted unless they want his money. He really isn’t interested in marriage, however, he is rather intrigued by Miss Allegra Constantine.
This is Allegra’s second season and as one of 6 sisters, she is expected to marry and soon. Allegra is short and rather plain with no real talents either. However, of the 3 men who show any interest in her, none of them truly appeal. When she sees Max Severin watching her at events with a bit of amusement on his face, it makes her more intrigued by him.
When Max rescues Allegra from a possible embarrassing gaffe at a soiree, she is drawn to him and he to her. They meet up privately a couple of times that could mean she would be ruined if found out. A threat by a man who could court her brings Max in to rescue her once again. However, the truth of his birth is such a huge secret that he doesn’t feel right about asking a woman to marry him although he is very attracted to Allegra. Is there a way he can get around his background to allow him to ask for Allegra’s hand?
This is an unusual story with a believe-it-or-not bit of history behind Max. I enjoyed the intrigue and was pleased with how well the author brought everything together. Enjoy.
Copy provided by NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
March 1, 2026
This book definitely gave me Bridgerton vibes, with the rules of the ton governed by reputation, family and class/wealth and those with any individuality or difference being treated with suspicion unless they are able to – at least outwardly – conform.
Both main characters, Allegra and Max, see themselves as outsiders and society definitely views Max suspiciously, if not Allegra. However, each has skeletons in their family closet that could completely destroy them and their family if they were to become public knowledge. As a result, the plot has plenty of excitement and suspense, which is only increased by the lovers taking some very risky opportunities for forbidden alone time!
The chemistry between them is certainly sizzling and – while there is an element of insta-love, with them having plenty of physical attraction but not a lot of chance to get to know each other properly – I was totally rooting for them to overcome their internal and external obstacles and be able to officially get together.
I found Allegra very relatable in her reluctance to marry without love but her weighing up the practicalities of her situation and trying to balance logic with desire. Thank goodness for a certain helpful and resourceful intervention at just the right moment to save her from the worst of her dilemma!
I’m really enjoying Regency-esque steamy romances at the moment and this book is a very good example of why, so I plan to check out more from Emma Orchard going forward!
Both main characters, Allegra and Max, see themselves as outsiders and society definitely views Max suspiciously, if not Allegra. However, each has skeletons in their family closet that could completely destroy them and their family if they were to become public knowledge. As a result, the plot has plenty of excitement and suspense, which is only increased by the lovers taking some very risky opportunities for forbidden alone time!
The chemistry between them is certainly sizzling and – while there is an element of insta-love, with them having plenty of physical attraction but not a lot of chance to get to know each other properly – I was totally rooting for them to overcome their internal and external obstacles and be able to officially get together.
I found Allegra very relatable in her reluctance to marry without love but her weighing up the practicalities of her situation and trying to balance logic with desire. Thank goodness for a certain helpful and resourceful intervention at just the right moment to save her from the worst of her dilemma!
I’m really enjoying Regency-esque steamy romances at the moment and this book is a very good example of why, so I plan to check out more from Emma Orchard going forward!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Miss Allegra Constantine has been encouraged to find a suitor, marry and not necessarily live life HEA.
Her two older sisters have married well and given out the required heir and a spare!
Allegra wants more and has been warned by her sister the Duchess to marry for love.
We also have Max Severin who has secrets that could be deadly if known or ever divulged.
Max is drawn to Allegra but knows his situation is beyond impossible as he feels he has a target on his back!
Allegra has suitors and has never even considered Max. He is wealthy but also of Caribbean and other descent. His life would be much more arduous to say the least if he was not an adopted and wealthy heir! He has said often he would never marry but he never met the force of Nature that is Allegra!
Lord Milton Allegra’s most prominent suitor also has a huge secret!
We find Allegra’s mother has secrets this story should be called “Too many secrets!”
There is always a solution to a problem if you search hard enough.
Allegra has a secret grandfather that aids the star crossed lovers in a solution. This is without revealing Max’s tangled past! That resolution was one of my favorite almost only on this story!
I have read several books by the author so I was surprised by how twisted and tangled Max’s secret was. There is a HEA and some steam!
I received an ARC copy from Netgalley for my unbiased opinion!
Her two older sisters have married well and given out the required heir and a spare!
Allegra wants more and has been warned by her sister the Duchess to marry for love.
We also have Max Severin who has secrets that could be deadly if known or ever divulged.
Max is drawn to Allegra but knows his situation is beyond impossible as he feels he has a target on his back!
Allegra has suitors and has never even considered Max. He is wealthy but also of Caribbean and other descent. His life would be much more arduous to say the least if he was not an adopted and wealthy heir! He has said often he would never marry but he never met the force of Nature that is Allegra!
Lord Milton Allegra’s most prominent suitor also has a huge secret!
We find Allegra’s mother has secrets this story should be called “Too many secrets!”
There is always a solution to a problem if you search hard enough.
Allegra has a secret grandfather that aids the star crossed lovers in a solution. This is without revealing Max’s tangled past! That resolution was one of my favorite almost only on this story!
I have read several books by the author so I was surprised by how twisted and tangled Max’s secret was. There is a HEA and some steam!
I received an ARC copy from Netgalley for my unbiased opinion!
April 25, 2026
This was such a fun and indulgent Regency romance! If you love a bit of drama, longing, and forbidden attraction, this one really delivers.
Allegra is a heroine you can easily root for—she’s stuck in that classic situation where she has to marry for security, yet none of her options feel right. I appreciated how clearly her inner conflict came through. You can feel her frustration with the “sensible” choices and her pull toward something more meaningful.
And then there’s Max. Brooding, complicated, and very much not the right choice—obviously the best kind of romantic lead. The chemistry between him and Allegra is immediate and intense, and that stolen kiss moment was definitely a highlight! Their relationship has that perfect mix of tension and emotional depth that keeps you turning pages.
The story balances romance with just enough scandal and secrets to keep things interesting. The stakes feel real, especially as past truths start to unravel and put everything at risk. It’s not just about love—it’s about what you’re willing to sacrifice for it.
Overall, this is a spicy, dramatic, and satisfying read. Perfect if you're in the mood for a Regency romance with heart, heat, and a touch of danger.
I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and Boldwood Books and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Allegra is a heroine you can easily root for—she’s stuck in that classic situation where she has to marry for security, yet none of her options feel right. I appreciated how clearly her inner conflict came through. You can feel her frustration with the “sensible” choices and her pull toward something more meaningful.
And then there’s Max. Brooding, complicated, and very much not the right choice—obviously the best kind of romantic lead. The chemistry between him and Allegra is immediate and intense, and that stolen kiss moment was definitely a highlight! Their relationship has that perfect mix of tension and emotional depth that keeps you turning pages.
The story balances romance with just enough scandal and secrets to keep things interesting. The stakes feel real, especially as past truths start to unravel and put everything at risk. It’s not just about love—it’s about what you’re willing to sacrifice for it.
Overall, this is a spicy, dramatic, and satisfying read. Perfect if you're in the mood for a Regency romance with heart, heat, and a touch of danger.
I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and Boldwood Books and am voluntarily leaving my review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest reveiw. I love to read historical romances and they don't seem as prevelant in the market as they used to be. Emma Orchard is a new to me author and I am looking forward to reading more by her.
This was a slow start. The style was different then books I have read before - the first 50% really only had two characters - Max and Allegra, with few interactions with anyone else. It took a while for me to get into it, I didn't feel like there was much of a plot to this point, really just Allegra trying to decide which of her three suitors to marry and Max watching from the sidelines.
Mid-point, there suddenly became a story and an interesting one at that. More characters became involved like Allegra's Mom and Grandfather, capturing my attention. I now wanted to know where this was going and how it would end.
On a side, I do love historical fiction that you also learn something from and this offered that. I went down an online rabbit hole re: diversity in regency England and learned alot. If anyone is interested, I recommend googling Sarah Forbes Bonetta, a goddaughter of Queen Victoria.
This was a slow start. The style was different then books I have read before - the first 50% really only had two characters - Max and Allegra, with few interactions with anyone else. It took a while for me to get into it, I didn't feel like there was much of a plot to this point, really just Allegra trying to decide which of her three suitors to marry and Max watching from the sidelines.
Mid-point, there suddenly became a story and an interesting one at that. More characters became involved like Allegra's Mom and Grandfather, capturing my attention. I now wanted to know where this was going and how it would end.
On a side, I do love historical fiction that you also learn something from and this offered that. I went down an online rabbit hole re: diversity in regency England and learned alot. If anyone is interested, I recommend googling Sarah Forbes Bonetta, a goddaughter of Queen Victoria.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I enjoyed this book. I’ve read the others in this series as well, but this could also be read as a stand alone (previous books’ main characters were mentioned, but were not an integral part of this story).
The story starts out with Allegra, unhappy with her suitors, but resigned to having to choose one as a husband, and frustrated with the little freedom she has as a woman of that time. Meanwhile, Max watches her at outings, dark and brooding, but doesn’t approach her. It took me a bit to appreciate and like these two main characters - for the first third of the book Allegra seemed to scowl at everyone and be in a foul mood, and we didn’t really learn much about Max besides he wasn’t liked by the rest of the ton and preferred to remain in the shadows. However, as the story progressed, we see more of the main characters’ personalities start to show, and their family histories and secrets are revealed. The author weaves a good story, and I enjoyed how the plot developed and their issues were resolved in the end.
Overall, I thought this was a good book and I’d recommend it. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this free advanced copy - this is my honest and voluntary review.
The story starts out with Allegra, unhappy with her suitors, but resigned to having to choose one as a husband, and frustrated with the little freedom she has as a woman of that time. Meanwhile, Max watches her at outings, dark and brooding, but doesn’t approach her. It took me a bit to appreciate and like these two main characters - for the first third of the book Allegra seemed to scowl at everyone and be in a foul mood, and we didn’t really learn much about Max besides he wasn’t liked by the rest of the ton and preferred to remain in the shadows. However, as the story progressed, we see more of the main characters’ personalities start to show, and their family histories and secrets are revealed. The author weaves a good story, and I enjoyed how the plot developed and their issues were resolved in the end.
Overall, I thought this was a good book and I’d recommend it. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this free advanced copy - this is my honest and voluntary review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Allegra Constantine needs to get married. There are three prospects that seem to be after her, but she isn't into them. She has taken her sister's advice to heart and will find someone out of love and not convenience. Her mother has married off her two oldest sister and expects the same for Allegra.
Max Severin is loaded, handsome and the members of the haut ton seem to stand him, barely. It may be because of his besmirched name or because of his part-African origin. Severin has set his eyes on Allegra. He has no desire to court her or make a child with her, he only wants to have fun. Allegra is very curious about Severin's past and he wants to get into her pants. They both want different things, how will their story end?
A fun and witty spicy romance. I really enjoyed the characters, specially Leontina Constantine. She has some funny and wise moments in the story. I also liked how it touched in the topics of biracial people and slavery. It is always something I think about when I read Regency novels. Both Allegra and Severin face different types of discrimination as they both come from non-English backgrounds. Overall a great read from one of my favorite Regency authors!
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
Max Severin is loaded, handsome and the members of the haut ton seem to stand him, barely. It may be because of his besmirched name or because of his part-African origin. Severin has set his eyes on Allegra. He has no desire to court her or make a child with her, he only wants to have fun. Allegra is very curious about Severin's past and he wants to get into her pants. They both want different things, how will their story end?
A fun and witty spicy romance. I really enjoyed the characters, specially Leontina Constantine. She has some funny and wise moments in the story. I also liked how it touched in the topics of biracial people and slavery. It is always something I think about when I read Regency novels. Both Allegra and Severin face different types of discrimination as they both come from non-English backgrounds. Overall a great read from one of my favorite Regency authors!
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
March 15, 2026
The season is dragging on in London and Allegra Constantine is feeling the pressure as she is expected to choose a husband, or have a man choose her as his bride. It is all rather tedious and stressful.
She often sees a man she is curious about Max Severn, a man who presents well, very well indeed but carries a hint or more than a hint of scandal about his person. She also has three suitors who dance attendance on her, but none even remotely tempt her to want to marry them. He seems to be interested in her as well, but from a distance.
So begins Emma Orchards latest foray into the marriage mart with A Most Unsuitable Suitor which sees the world of the Ton once again put under the spotlight as Allegra and Max begin to realize that they really do enjoy each other company, perhaps a little too much.
Max, a man who has a past that is shadowed to say the very least, does not wish to marry as he is aware that by doing so he could put both himself and his bride in danger as well as the mysterious woman who was his mother.
As the layers of Max’s life unfold and he and Allegra fall deeply in love, even though they should not, a most enjoyable and entertaining story captivates all readers who really do enjoy regency romance with a most intriguing plot.
She often sees a man she is curious about Max Severn, a man who presents well, very well indeed but carries a hint or more than a hint of scandal about his person. She also has three suitors who dance attendance on her, but none even remotely tempt her to want to marry them. He seems to be interested in her as well, but from a distance.
So begins Emma Orchards latest foray into the marriage mart with A Most Unsuitable Suitor which sees the world of the Ton once again put under the spotlight as Allegra and Max begin to realize that they really do enjoy each other company, perhaps a little too much.
Max, a man who has a past that is shadowed to say the very least, does not wish to marry as he is aware that by doing so he could put both himself and his bride in danger as well as the mysterious woman who was his mother.
As the layers of Max’s life unfold and he and Allegra fall deeply in love, even though they should not, a most enjoyable and entertaining story captivates all readers who really do enjoy regency romance with a most intriguing plot.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The book had a very fluid and addictive writing style — I didn’t notice the time passing while I was reading. I really liked our female protagonist, as she strays a bit from what was expected of women at that time and isn’t afraid to go after what she wants.
Our male protagonist won me over little by little, and his secret is intense, but as the story unfolded I managed to figure it out shortly before it was revealed.
In my opinion, I felt it needed just a little more tension, but even so I really enjoyed the book and can’t wait to follow the rest of this family.
O livro teve uma escrita muito fluída e viciante, não dei pelo tempo a passar enquanto lia. Gostei muito da nossa protagonista, uma vez que foge um bocadinho ao que é esperado das mulheres naquela época e não tem medo de ir atrás do que deseja. O nosso protagonista masculino foi-me conquistando aos bocadinhos e o seu segredo é intenso, mas com o desenrolar da história consegui desvendá-lo pouco antes de ser revelado. Na minha opinião, senti que precisava de um pouquinho mais de tensão, mas mesmo assim gostei imenso do livro e mal posso esperar para acompanhar o resto desta família.
Our male protagonist won me over little by little, and his secret is intense, but as the story unfolded I managed to figure it out shortly before it was revealed.
In my opinion, I felt it needed just a little more tension, but even so I really enjoyed the book and can’t wait to follow the rest of this family.
O livro teve uma escrita muito fluída e viciante, não dei pelo tempo a passar enquanto lia. Gostei muito da nossa protagonista, uma vez que foge um bocadinho ao que é esperado das mulheres naquela época e não tem medo de ir atrás do que deseja. O nosso protagonista masculino foi-me conquistando aos bocadinhos e o seu segredo é intenso, mas com o desenrolar da história consegui desvendá-lo pouco antes de ser revelado. Na minha opinião, senti que precisava de um pouquinho mais de tensão, mas mesmo assim gostei imenso do livro e mal posso esperar para acompanhar o resto desta família.
March 2, 2026
Title: A Most Unsuitable Suitor
Author: Emma Orchard
Genre: Regency Romance | Romance| BookTok Romance
Publisher: Boldwood Books | Boldwood Ever After
Pages: 317
Format I read: Digital
I love a good romance book but hadn’t ever read a regency romance which considering that I love watching Bridgerton and other dramas set in this time period is really surprising. I’m so glad I have now changed this and kicked it off with Emma’s book. Emma’s writing was really easy to navigate through and I found her characters really evolved. I enjoyed that this book tackles themes like race and class of the times. Im always intrigued about the Ton and how women were just expected to marry to make the families look good not really always what the women themselves actually wanted.
Allegra was a great FMC as well as Max as the MMC.
It was great story and kept me entertained throughout. I hope to read more of Emma’s books soon.
Jessica’s Bookshelf Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✨ Thankyou so much to @lovebookstours @emmaorchardbooks @boldwoodeverafter for my digital copy of the book via @netgalley in exchange for my honest review ✨
Author: Emma Orchard
Genre: Regency Romance | Romance| BookTok Romance
Publisher: Boldwood Books | Boldwood Ever After
Pages: 317
Format I read: Digital
I love a good romance book but hadn’t ever read a regency romance which considering that I love watching Bridgerton and other dramas set in this time period is really surprising. I’m so glad I have now changed this and kicked it off with Emma’s book. Emma’s writing was really easy to navigate through and I found her characters really evolved. I enjoyed that this book tackles themes like race and class of the times. Im always intrigued about the Ton and how women were just expected to marry to make the families look good not really always what the women themselves actually wanted.
Allegra was a great FMC as well as Max as the MMC.
It was great story and kept me entertained throughout. I hope to read more of Emma’s books soon.
Jessica’s Bookshelf Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✨ Thankyou so much to @lovebookstours @emmaorchardbooks @boldwoodeverafter for my digital copy of the book via @netgalley in exchange for my honest review ✨
March 3, 2026
A Most Unsuitable Suitor by Emma Orchard is an historical romance. England during the early 1800s was full of rules and expectations during the “season”. However, each of the main characters have a twist in their parentage that if known would destroy them and their family.
It is the second season for nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine. She knows she must wed this season. Money is tight and she has sisters who still need to have their season. Her mother is determined that all will have a chance to marry well (at least according to the tonne standards). She is going to be surprised by what she learns about her family.
Max Severin is always there - watching her. She finds herself watching him back. He is mysterious, but yet someone she is quite drawn to. Max has his own hidden parentage to protect. He keeps telling her he is not able to marry anyone, but is more than willing to kiss her again and again and again.
How to resolve this? Well unknown forces, a little deception and help from the true family. The book keeps you guessing until the end to see if true love wins. A Most Unsuitable Suitor by Emma Orchard was a good read.
It is the second season for nineteen-year-old Allegra Constantine. She knows she must wed this season. Money is tight and she has sisters who still need to have their season. Her mother is determined that all will have a chance to marry well (at least according to the tonne standards). She is going to be surprised by what she learns about her family.
Max Severin is always there - watching her. She finds herself watching him back. He is mysterious, but yet someone she is quite drawn to. Max has his own hidden parentage to protect. He keeps telling her he is not able to marry anyone, but is more than willing to kiss her again and again and again.
How to resolve this? Well unknown forces, a little deception and help from the true family. The book keeps you guessing until the end to see if true love wins. A Most Unsuitable Suitor by Emma Orchard was a good read.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Most Unsuitable Suitor was such a fun read with an extra dose of history added in! I have enjoyed reading Emma's books before and LOVE historical fiction. This book had me looking up more about Napoleon and the wars during his time and I really enjoyed that!
This book is about Allegra who is Viola from A Tale of Two Dukes younger sister. This book takes place kind of in the middle of A Tale of Two Dukes and is definitely a stand alone. Allegra is in London with her mother and three younger sisters for her second season and has three eligible suitors. Of course, she is drawn to Mr. Max Severin who is not eligible or ever looking to get married! I loved Allegra and Max's chemistry and that they always gifted each other with honesty.
This book has familial mysteries on both sides as well as suspense and of course loads of romance! It is such a blast and as always I am waiting to see what's Emma will write next! Highly recommend!
Thank you Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This book is about Allegra who is Viola from A Tale of Two Dukes younger sister. This book takes place kind of in the middle of A Tale of Two Dukes and is definitely a stand alone. Allegra is in London with her mother and three younger sisters for her second season and has three eligible suitors. Of course, she is drawn to Mr. Max Severin who is not eligible or ever looking to get married! I loved Allegra and Max's chemistry and that they always gifted each other with honesty.
This book has familial mysteries on both sides as well as suspense and of course loads of romance! It is such a blast and as always I am waiting to see what's Emma will write next! Highly recommend!
Thank you Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
** ARC REVIEW **
Thank you so much to Emma Orchard and NetGalley for giving me the chance to read this ARC!
I found this book genuinely interesting, especially with the subtle layer of mystery woven throughout the story—particularly surrounding Max Severin’s origins and Allegra Constantine’s maternal lineage. That intrigue added depth and kept me turning the pages.
Max was such a compelling hero. At times, he reminded me of Anthony Bridgerton—that commanding, duty-bound energy—but in other moments, he leaned more toward Simon Bassett, with his guarded nature and emotional restraint. That combination made him fascinating to read.
Allegra initially came across as a bit naive, but I appreciated how her character developed. As the story progressed, she proved she was far more than first impressions suggested, and I really grew to like her strength and quiet resilience.
Overall, this was a historical romance with just enough mystery to elevate it, and I enjoyed watching both characters unfold in unexpected ways.
Thank you so much to Emma Orchard and NetGalley for giving me the chance to read this ARC!
I found this book genuinely interesting, especially with the subtle layer of mystery woven throughout the story—particularly surrounding Max Severin’s origins and Allegra Constantine’s maternal lineage. That intrigue added depth and kept me turning the pages.
Max was such a compelling hero. At times, he reminded me of Anthony Bridgerton—that commanding, duty-bound energy—but in other moments, he leaned more toward Simon Bassett, with his guarded nature and emotional restraint. That combination made him fascinating to read.
Allegra initially came across as a bit naive, but I appreciated how her character developed. As the story progressed, she proved she was far more than first impressions suggested, and I really grew to like her strength and quiet resilience.
Overall, this was a historical romance with just enough mystery to elevate it, and I enjoyed watching both characters unfold in unexpected ways.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Allegra Constantine realises, for the sake of her family, that she must marry however, her current suitors do not inspire her to romantic thoughts of love but ever pragmatic, Allegra realises that love has nothing do do with her need to find an eligible marriage partner. And yet when she encounters the enigmatic Max Severin at the various social soirees Allegra is intrigued by his dark good looks, his air of detachment and his apparent cynicism of the social niceties.
There is much to enjoy in this deliciously passionate Regency romance, both Allegra and Max have their secrets and watching these unfold, together with their burgeoning, and at times, illicit relationship made me smile. The story is beautifully written in the style which this talented author has made her own and there's enough intrigue, innuendo and passion to ignite the pages and a real revelation I didn't see coming but which seemed entirely plausible.
A Most Unsuitable Suitor is another hugely entertaining and enjoyable Regency romance from one of my favourite writers of this genre.
March 3, 2026
A Most Unsuitable Suitor offers the story of Allegra Constantine, a debutante who is approaching the end of her second season on the marriage mart with three suitors on deck. Max Severin, adopted by an aristocratic couple from his home in Martinique, is intrigued by Allegra but can't count himself among her suitors for yet-to-be-named personal reasons.
Allegra is an interesting FMC. She is pragmatic, understanding her role/duty as a young woman in Georgian England, and thoughtful about how her choice of suitor may affect the reputation and options for her younger sisters. At the same time, she is strong-willed and passionate, and needs a suitor that can match her intensity.
Read this if you like: modern themes in HR (they're approached well in this book), family drama, and a FMC who holds people around her accountable for their actions
Series Note: Allegra is the younger sister of Viola, whose story is told in a previous book (A Tale of Two Dukes- read it!). Both books can be read as a stand alone, but reading both offers a deeper glimpse into the Constantine family dynamics.
Allegra is an interesting FMC. She is pragmatic, understanding her role/duty as a young woman in Georgian England, and thoughtful about how her choice of suitor may affect the reputation and options for her younger sisters. At the same time, she is strong-willed and passionate, and needs a suitor that can match her intensity.
Read this if you like: modern themes in HR (they're approached well in this book), family drama, and a FMC who holds people around her accountable for their actions
Series Note: Allegra is the younger sister of Viola, whose story is told in a previous book (A Tale of Two Dukes- read it!). Both books can be read as a stand alone, but reading both offers a deeper glimpse into the Constantine family dynamics.
March 4, 2026
Miss Allegra Constantine has three suitable suitors: Sir Harry Eager, Mr Englishby and Lord Milton. But as she’s not rich, not very accomplished and not beautiful she has no idea why they would want to marry her. She does have another man interested in her but, as he has a secret which means he cannot marry anyone, then he is a most unsuitable suitor! Secrets abound in this story, just about all the characters have one – some secrets are more dangerous than others, but all are problems.
I really enjoyed Allegra as a character; she’s feisty, shows her emotions and not afraid to speak her mind – a Constantine trait. Max Severin, the unsuitable suitor, was slow to develop as a character for me because he frequently dwelled on his conviction that if anyone found out who he really was, then they would kill him and anyone close to him. Seemed a little far-fetched but when his secret is revealed – it’s a big one.
Another winner from Emma Orchard
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
I really enjoyed Allegra as a character; she’s feisty, shows her emotions and not afraid to speak her mind – a Constantine trait. Max Severin, the unsuitable suitor, was slow to develop as a character for me because he frequently dwelled on his conviction that if anyone found out who he really was, then they would kill him and anyone close to him. Seemed a little far-fetched but when his secret is revealed – it’s a big one.
Another winner from Emma Orchard
Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews