**Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Adriana Allegri for an ARC of this book!**
"Although the world is full of suffering, it is also full of the overcoming of it." - Helen Keller
Allina Strauss doesn't have a cruel bone in her body...but unfortunately for her, a kind spirit and an inquisitive mind is no match for the horrors she is set to witness. It's 1939, and in her tiny German town, her friends are Jews and Catholics alike. She's quick to defend and protect the liberty of those around her, and spends most of her time with her friends and family, living a fairly quiet and simple life. But one night everything changes, and a flurry of soldiers take everyone she loves from her in one fell swoop. Amidst the chaos, Allina also discovers a closely guarded family secret: her mother was Jewish, and that makes Allina a "mischling", or a person of mixed Aryan and Jewish heritage...and Allina must now guard this secret with every ounce of her being, lest she end up losing everything she has left.
After the horrific invasion of her home, Allina wakes up to find herself part of a very different House of Horrors that she never imagined: she is stationed at Hochland House, one of many Lebensborn homes. The Lebensborn (which translates to "Font of Life") homes quite literally function as secret baby factories, where Aryan women are forced to mate with SS soldiers...and produce the next generation of Hitler youth. Although Allina is a nurse rather than a mother, she is aghast at what she sees. Rather than loving and nurturing care, babies are given the bare minimum to survive, and their pained cries are ignored for hours at a time, even if all they long for is a quick cuddle or a clean diaper. When she sees what happens on the upper levels, however, the infant room looks rosier: the toddlers who should be walking and talking are incredibly delayed in both physical and mental development, due in large part to the levels of neglect. Worse still, since so many of the children aren't 'up to snuff' they are removed and essentially marked for eventual execution.
Determined to try to help the children at all costs, Allina is at a loss, and despite her best efforts to remain solitary, she makes a couple of friends along the way. Her most unlikely ally, however, comes in the form of handsome SS solider, Karl. Although Allina bristles at the mere thought of being close to someone who could work as part of the Third Reich, she comes to learn that Karl isn't like the other soldiers...and they might have far more in common than she thought...including a shared interest in protecting the children from the horrific future that awaits. But once emotional bonds are formed and a romance begins to blossom, Allina and Karl's bevvy of secrets prove to be more than a mere liability...and could mean the difference between life and death. Will Karl and Allina's plan for escape and liberation for themselves and the children they care so deeply about come to fruition? Will they be able to also protect their OWN daughter, Katrine? Or will the terrors of the Third Reich dim their light...permanently?
It's been quite a while since I've delved into WWII historical fiction, and there are several good reasons behind that choice. For one, this type of historical fiction is practically GUARANTEED to be painfully heavy. From Lowry's Number the Stars to Hannah's Nightingale, each WWII HF book feels like a gut punch in many ways; after all, these books are essentially exploring genocide and the systematic destruction of an entire race and religion of people, with little motivation for such destruction other than a desire for power and a heavy dose of xenophobia. Being a pretty huge pacifist myself, I often struggle even reading about these atrocities at all. There's also the fact that this type of HF has practically become a genre in an of itself, due mostly to the LARGE proliferation of these types of stories. Although some are driven by tragic romance of one kind or another, others focus on the destruction of torn families, etc...but unfortunately, the fact that SO MANY of these stories have been told can make this type of book feel a bit 'been there, read that.'
But when it comes to this powerful and emotionally charged debut from newcomer Adriana Allegri, the focus of this particular tale on a completely new angle of WWII that so many have never heard of before was enough to make this painful and tragic tale stand out like the North Star in a crowded midnight sky.
For a debut, this is a book quickly grounds itself and once it sets focus, never loses sight of its endgame. Meticulously researched, Allegri takes a concept that seems particularly abhorrent but also completely unfamiliar and gets the reading audience up to speed entirely by about 20% in. Although Hochland House itself isn't real, it rings with such truth that you feel you are there...and as a mom especially, my stomach was in knots hearing about the neglect these children faced, not to mention their IMMEDIATE 'brainwashing from birth'. Although this story could have easily dipped into the sort of tired trope of "SS officer falls in love with someone diametrically opposed to his ideology", the extra layer and the common goal of extricating the innocent children sort of removed this one from predictability. There are several layers at play here, and the author also gives Allina AND Karl a voice throughout, keeping this book from falling into tired, too-often trodden tropes with surprises, twists, and turns throughout.
This is also technically a dual timeline story, but in many respects, you'll sort of forget this by the time Allina arrives at Hochland House. The second timeline (present day) only truly matters at the beginning and end of the book.
(Think Rose Dewitt-Bukater from Titanic, but with a far less important tie to present day...and no big fancy necklaces.)
It basically functions as a sort of metaphorical bookend, giving us just enough of a setup to have daughter Katrine questioning why and how her mother would have a box with a Nazi medal in it in her closet. Perhaps my only criticism of this is that the book's blurb seems to hint at more of a balanced timeline, and there truly isn't one: it's 90% Allina's recollections of her past. Which is not necessarily problematic, but if you go in expecting a Picoult-like tie in to present-day, it will feel a bit lacking. However, the author's note is everything you WOULD expect from a writer like Picoult, in that she has ALL of the research in hand, provides a very detailed description of what is drawn from reality vs. fictionalized aspects, and provides bountiful examples for further reading, should you feel so inclined...or have the fortitude to read more!
This moving story stands as a solemn reminder that although powerful, seemingly limitless forces may try to silence those who value intelligence, integrity, curiosity, and acceptance, it is only the house that stands united that has the capability to weather any storm.
And who knows...after enough rain, maybe a sunflower will still find a way to bloom.
🌻
4 stars
#TheSunflowerHouse #AdrianaAllegri #StMartinsPress #partner #smpearlyreader