Pride and Prejudice meets The Fast and the Furious in this rollicking, romantic Regency adventure in which a meticulous young woman must abandon the rules of propriety to save Britain—and perhaps even find love along the way. . . .
England, 1810. Lucy Elliot has often been described as fastidious, given her belief that there is an objectively correct and logical way to do things. And while she strives to be proper in every way, she does have one rather scandalous Lucy, the prim and gentle lady, is a frequent attendee of the entirely disreputable and illicit Night Races, where unchaperoned men and women from all social classes gather on dark country lanes to gamble on the outcomes of furiously fast carriage races.
But her secret might become more than just a danger to her reputation when her mysterious new neighbor, Captain Dashwood, begins partaking in the races. Lucy can’t help but feel there’s something more to the handsome Captain Dashwood than meets the eye, and she suspects that his arrival in the neighborhood in the midst of a spate of curious and alarming carriage robberies is no mere coincidence—something is most certainly afoot in the county, and it’s a mystery Lucy intends to solve.
Though Lucy prides herself on her preparedness, she never could have anticipated the web of lies, deceit, and espionage that she finds herself and Captain Dashwood entangled in; nor could she have known that the very fate of Britain would hang in the balance. But will her meticulous nature be the very thing that saves her, or will it be her—and England's—undoing?
I like to thank NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me a chance at reading the book.
I really, really enjoyed the plot of this. I love that it was a regency story where the girl was interested in cars... er, carriages? And I loved that she knew what she was talking about. On top of that, I love that she was paired with a gentleman who was just as into them as she was (and was akin to an undercover cop).
BUT THE ROMANCE. WHERE WAS IT? It was so hard to see it. Like sure, there was glances and brief touching, but there was literally no 'admittance' of feelings, flirting, hot moments of kisses (not asking for anything beyond that). It really sank the book down for me and given that she was a girl who was not quite following the rules and wanting to be unrefined in areas that most are not, I expected more. Since this co-labeled as a romance.
So if you go in thinking you're gonna get a romance you're really not. But if you like a clean story about a girl and a guy catching coach thieves, you'll get it.
The beginning is a lot of third person telling to set the stage and between that and the extremely short chapters, it felt like forever before anything happened. I almost gave up at %8. At some point, I just started skimming.
The concept is fun, but the third person dry narration was just too detached for me. I liked Lucy’s worldview and that she’s neurospicy coded. Her exactness and social challenges didn’t bother me. And while this is technically a romance in that they’re together happily at the end, there’s really no romance here. Carriage race descriptions? Yes? Interiority and chemistry? No.
This wasn’t for me, but if you like third person in a historical mystery and don’t want your romance to have romance, you might like this one
Lucy Elliot is different. Operating in her world means she needs guidelines to take her through social occasions. If all she had to do was fathom a mechanical problem or design a carriage, things would be fine. Walking into a ball has her heading to a quiet nook to acclimatize. By accident Lucy discovers the Night Races. The egalitarian event is held near to the village, once a month when the moon is full at midnight. Lucy’s life is changed. Two years later Lucy meets a cavalry Captain at the races. She’d already met the indisputable champions of the Night Races, Dante Torres and his crew. Captain James Dashwood had arrived in the neighbourhood to stay at one of his father’s properties, Ellsworth Manor. Lucy suspects he’s been sent here to avoid gambling debts or something else. Interestingly there’s been a series of government papers, coaches and men have gone missing. This quiet village has been dogged by thievery and other incidences! Something’s definitely afoot! Lucy and her sister Margaret are as different as chalk and cheese but supportive of each other. A quietly contained thrilling regency novel with the threat of Bonaparte’s actions overhanging all.
A Harper Perennial ARC via NetGalley. Many thanks to the author and publisher.
Thanks to Harper Perennial for the gifted copy. All opinions below are my own.
This story is billed as The Fast and the Furious meets Pride and Prejudice. I'd agree that it is about racing horse drawn coaches in the regency era. You're going to really struggle if you're reading this one for the angst, banter or romance of P & P though. It has a loose structure that mirrors an affluent character coming to town but that's about it. Dashwood is a military man and no where near as enigmatic as Darcy. Lucy is more like the character she's modelled after, she's a woman with thoughts, opinions and skills out of her time. I'd go as far as to say she's on the spectrum and obsessed with engineering and coaches. She and Dashwood team up to race and solve the mystery of some local bandits terrorizing the town.
I enjoyed this story but am not really sure who it is for from a marketing standpoint. It has zero romance other than they end up together at the end. It's much more about the stuffiness of regency society with a little mystery at its center. I liked reading it but think it will need to find its audience.
Dear Bookclub, I am so sorry but there is no way I would have finished this book without it being a Bookclub book because it was so boring. For the first part of the book I was really confused because I thought it was a Fast and Furious fan fiction like the sexy Shriek book “Get in my Swamp.”
Autistic gal meets her neighbor and they try to solve a crime of who is robbing coaches. I guessed who it was 40% in. The best part of the book was the fight scene with the jar of preserves.
This book is basically Fast and Furious fanfiction set in the Regency Era, and I'm 100% here for it! I realize the fandoms of both things may not necessarily overlap, but I am that niche demographic.
I loved how Caldwell balanced nods to Jane Austen characters (The Elliotts and Dashwood) and to multiple Fast and Furious movies from the franchise. I could distinctly pick out parallel scenes in the book to scenes in The Fast and The Furious, Fast Five, and Hobbs and Shaw. And the Regency version of NOS was bloody brilliant.
This book wasn't perfect--didn't love some of the "brutish" descriptions of Margaret--but it ended up being so much fun that I overlooked any anachronisms or slight historical inaccuracies.
Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Perennial for access to this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Although I loved the characters, storyline and Georgian era details I found the pacing to be incredibly slow. The novel is only 307 pages, but it felt far longer due to the pacing and lack of heightened tension throughout. It wasn't until the final few chapters things picked up and became engaging, and frankly a bit ridiculous. Just like the Fast and Furious movies it emulates.
While there's nothing inherently wrong with the plotline, which is actually quite good, the pacing made it somewhat of a lackluster slog. Moments of action lacked the sense of excitement and danger they needed in order to set the proper pace and I felt the flatness because of it.
I did love Lucy's neurodivergent character, her genius and the ways she loosened up as the novel progresses. Captain Dashwood's character compliments hers well and his appreciation for the way her mind works plus acceptance of her very specific requirements made it easy to see how their affection for one another grew.
Overall not a bad read, but not a great one either.
Thank you to NetGalley, Harper Perennial and Paperbacks | Harper Perennial, and R.M. Caldwell for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
What worked for me in this was definitely Lucy as a character. I loved that she was written with so many clearly neurodivergent traits, and I also loved having a regency era FMC whose special interests lie in engineering because hooray for women in STEM.
Despite the fact that I am sure nighttime racing of carriages, pulled by actual horses, at night on roads I am sure were not paved for speed is actually more dangerous than any kind of car racing, this just wasn't as exciting as I was hoping for it to be. The romance also wasn't really for me. This was well-written, though and is great if you are looking for a regency mystery.
This did a much better job at successfully making a book out of "The Fast and the Furious but make it Jane Austen"than I thought it would. It could have been more romantic, but I enjoyed it. Also, a shout out to the audiobook narrator who did a great job making it easy to differentiate the many characters' voices, and successfully tackling so may accents (including, briefly, a Welsh accent which seems nigh on impossible for most audiobook narrators to even get close to).
This book promised me ‘Pride and Prejudice’ meets ‘The Fast and the Furious’ (something I never knew I wanted)—and that is precisely what I got.
This was so much fun! Bonus that I wasn’t expecting but heartily welcomed: an incredibly autistic-coded FMC with a lovingly supportive family (her sister is THE LITERAL BEST) and an equally supportive found family. And you gotta love that Captain Dashwood.
The solo narration provided by Fiona Hardingham was as excellent as ever. An enjoyable read all around.
meh I had a hard time really caring about any of the characters. Lucy felt flat, James could have been so much more but nothing ever really happened the mystery part seemed like a by the moment and started to get a bit more interesting then it was over
Absolutely loved this story! A combination of my two favorite things: Jane Austen novels and Fast and Furious. A fun combination of contrasting stories that somehow works and gives you the properness of Austen and the edge and adventure of racing, with a lovely cast of versatile characters.
This was fun! A cross between The Fast & the Furious and Pride & Prejudice. Zero spice but more than one sweet romance sub-plot. Night Races and treason most foul! Plus some non-conformists living in an abandoned castle... Like I said: fun
This book really said, what if Jane Austen watched The Fast and the Furious once and thought, yes, but what if everyone had bonnets and suppressed emotions. And honestly? I respect the audacity.
Fast and Fastidious drops us into 1810 England with Lucy Elliot, our resident precision queen, who believes there is a correct way to do literally everything and will absolutely explain why your wheel axle alignment is flawed. Lucy is described as fastidious, but what that really means is she is operating on a different, sharper frequency than everyone around her. She loves order. She loves mechanics. She loves the exact science of carriage construction. And secretly, she loves attending illegal Night Races like a Regency Vin Diesel in a bonnet.
The Night Races are exactly what they sound like, chaotic underground carriage competitions where people from all classes gather to gamble and speed down dark country lanes. It is scandalous. It is reckless. It is deeply impractical for maintaining a respectable reputation. Naturally, Lucy is obsessed. And frankly, watching her calculate risk while clutching her propriety by a thread is half the fun.
Then Captain James Dashwood arrives, mysterious new neighbor, alleged gambler, suspiciously competent, and very clearly not just there to sip tea and admire the hedges. The timing of his arrival alongside a string of carriage robberies that may involve stolen government information is, as Lucy would say, statistically improbable. So obviously she decides to investigate. Because if there is one thing more intoxicating than racing at midnight, it is solving a puzzle no one else can see clearly.
Here is where the book absolutely shines. The espionage plot? Genuinely engaging. The slow unraveling of lies, the web of deceit, the sense that something much bigger than local highwaymen is unfolding? Delicious. The action sequences during the races are vivid and tense, especially when Lucy herself is directly involved. You can feel the wheels rattling. You can feel the stakes climbing. The final act goes a little gloriously unhinged in a way that feels spiritually aligned with the franchise it is nodding to.
And Lucy herself is such a specific, thoughtful character. She reads as neurodivergent coded in a way that feels intentional and compassionate. Her meticulous nature is not mocked. It is her strength. She sees patterns others miss. She cares about fairness and logic and structure in a society built on vague social expectations. Watching her family, especially her sister Margaret, support her quirks instead of trying to sand them down was genuinely lovely. The found family vibes with the racing crowd and eventually with Dashwood add warmth that keeps the story grounded.
Now. We need to talk about the romance. Because this is technically marketed as one. And listen, I am not asking for rakes ripping bodices in a hayloft. I do not need steam. But I do need vibes. I need longing. I need at least one moment where someone stares too long and then pretends they were looking at a hedge. The connection between Lucy and Dashwood is sweet and respectful. They admire each other’s intelligence. They become partners. They choose each other’s side. But the emotional chemistry is so subtle it occasionally felt like I was squinting at it through opera glasses.
It is very much a clean Regency mystery with romantic undertones rather than a swoony romance with a mystery subplot. If you go in expecting yearning, you might find yourself tapping your fan impatiently. If you go in wanting clever plotting, carriage mechanics, and a heroine who solves problems with logic instead of flirting, you will have a much better time.
The pacing at the beginning is a little slow, very third person, very proper, and then suddenly you are in a high stakes espionage plot with midnight races and potential national disaster. It is a tonal shift that mostly works, but it does require you to settle in before the chaos hits.
Overall, I had a genuinely good time. It is inventive. It is funny in a dry, restrained way. It gives us a heroine who is allowed to be exacting and brilliant without being punished for it. I just wanted about fifteen percent more romantic tension and maybe one slightly reckless confession.
I am landing at 3.5 stars. Rounded up in my heart for sheer originality and for Lucy Elliot, patron saint of properly balanced carriage wheels and emotionally reserved chaos.
Huge thank you to Harper Perennial and Paperbacks and NetGalley for the ARC. Truly nothing delights me more than illegal carriage racing, mild treason, and a heroine who could outthink half of Parliament before breakfast.
Fast and Fastidious by R. M. Caldwell is a refreshing, high-octane twist on the Regency romance genre. This debut novel manages to balance the delicate social structures of 1810 England with the grit and adrenaline of illicit carriage racing. It is a quick, well-written read that manages to be both a swoony historical romance and a compelling mystery, all while maintaining a lighthearted, romp feel that keeps the pages turning.
The story introduces us to Lucy Elliot, a protagonist who lives up to the "fastidious" of the title. Lucy is a meticulously organized, logic-driven young woman who finds comfort in the predictable mechanics of engineering and the correctness of how things should function. However, Lucy harbors a scandalous secret: under the light of the full moon, she escapes her prim life to attend the Night Races. Here, social hierarchies dissolve, and Lucy can indulge her passion for carriage design and speed. Lucy’s arc is wonderfully handled; she doesn't "fix" her meticulous nature to find happiness. Instead, she learns to integrate her need for order with the unpredictable chaos of life and love, realizing that her "fastidiousness" is actually her greatest strength in solving a mystery that threatens the very safety of Britain.
Then there is Captain James Dashwood, the mysterious new neighbor whose arrival at Elsworth Manor coincides with a string of alarming carriage robberies. Dashwood is the perfect foil for Lucy. While he initially appears to be just another handsome suitor, he is revealed to be a man of layers, deeply involved in the Night Races and potentially something much more dangerous. His arc involves moving from a man of secrets and solitary missions to someone who learns the value of a true partner. Watching him recognize and celebrate Lucy’s brilliance—not just her beauty—is a highlight of the romance. Their partnership evolves naturally from shared adrenaline to mutual trust, making their "smattering of romance" feel grounded and earned.
One of the most delightful elements of the book, however, is the relationship between Margaret (Meg) and Lucy. In a genre that often pits women against each other for the sake of drama, Caldwell chooses to showcase a bond defined by unwavering support. Meg acts as both a confidante and a tether for Lucy, and seeing them navigate their individual challenges while remaining fiercely loyal to one another adds a beautiful emotional layer to the story. Their friendship provides a sense of warmth that balances the colder elements of the espionage and mystery plots.
The mystery itself is well-integrated, revolving around the high-stakes world of carriage robberies and international espionage. It elevates the book from a standard comedy of manners to a legitimate page-turner. While the romance is sweet and understated (don't expect a lot of steam, but plenty of tension), the focus on character growth and the partnership between Lucy and Dashwood is incredibly satisfying.
Overall, Fast and Fastidious is a delightful debut. It’s a story about finding where you fit when you don't follow the "rules of propriety" and the thrill of finding someone who loves the gears and grease of your soul as much as your outward composure. If you’re looking for a historical romance that offers something a bit more adventurous and intellectually stimulating than the standard ballroom fare, this is a must-read. I'm already looking forward to seeing what R. M. Caldwell writes next.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the copy in exchange for an honest review.
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: Apr. 14, 2026
“Fast and Fastidious” by R.M. Caldwell is absolutely perfect for anyone looking for a mystery novel with Bridgerton vibes and a neurodivergent protagonist.
Lucy Elliott has always been described as meticulous and fastidious, a rule follower to the core. Due to this, she hasn’t always fit in in 1810 London society, until she finds out about The Night Races, clandestine carriage racing that takes place under the light of the full moon. Lucy has always had a fascination with carriages and she has a hard time saying no when her new neighbour, the elusive Captain Dashwood, asks Lucy to be his riding partner. Going against society is new for Lucy, but it’s fascinating and fast-paced, even more so because no one in her social circle knows about it. Then a group of unknown Highwaymen start robbing stagecoaches and Lucy decides to team up with Dashwood to find out who is behind the crimes.
“Fastidious” is a debut novel and it is fresh, smart and funny, with an admirable protagonist who readers can’t help but love. Lucy is accepted within her family unit, her loving parents and her older sister, but struggles to fit in outside of her estate, making it difficult for her to find a suitable marriage match. Then, of course, enter Lord Dashwood, and you can guess what happens next.
Caldwell’s novel has clandestine carriage races, uncommon romance and a band of murderous thieves, so there is something for everyone, and the fast pace kept me turning the pages. There are so many plot lines that are interconnected, but Caldwell blends them perfectly.
Obviously, the romantic aspect is predictable, but it is also delightful, and the other plot endings are unexpected and mysterious, making the final reveal a complete surprise. This particular novel wraps itself up perfectly, with no loose ends or questions, but I would not be surprised if we see Lucy Elliott again in future novels.
The neurodivergent protagonist is popular in many modern genres, but Caldwell puts a different spin on it, by bringing Lucy to the early nineteenth century. The mystery genre, too, is no stranger to women stepping out of societal expectations and roles placed on them to investigate a crime, but again, Caldwell’s story is a unique take.
“Fastidious” is a debut novel worth experiencing, and I hope to see more from Lucy in the future.
You know that moment when a book sounds so strange you pick it up purely because you need to know who approved the idea? That’s exactly how I ended up reading Fast and Fastidious by R.M. Caldwell.
Harper Perennial, thank you for the gifted copy.
A Regency novel inspired by both Jane Austen and The Fast and the Furious should not work nearly as well as it does. Yet somewhere between the midnight carriage races, suspicious neighbors, missing government documents, and one heroine who can probably identify a carriage wheel faster than I can find my reading glasses, I found myself completely invested.
Lucy Elliot was easily my favorite part of this book. She’s the sort of character who notices everything, remembers everything, and prefers logic over social niceties. While everyone around her is worried about behaving properly, she’s busy thinking about engineering, racing, and solving problems. Honestly, I spent half the book wanting to be her friend and the other half wishing I could borrow her brain for a day.
The story follows Lucy as she balances her respectable life with her secret love of the Night Races, illegal carriage races that bring together people from every level of society. When Captain James Dashwood arrives in town at the same time a string of robberies begins making everyone nervous, Lucy starts connecting dots that other people don’t even realize are there.
What I enjoyed most wasn’t the romance. In fact, if you’re expecting sweeping declarations and dramatic yearning, this probably isn’t that kind of book. The mystery and adventure take center stage here. The romance is quieter, built on trust, friendship, and mutual respect. James never tries to make Lucy smaller or less herself, and I appreciated that more than any grand romantic gesture.
There’s one line that stuck with me:
“Unorthodox was a word that gave Lucy cause to shudder.”
That sentence tells you almost everything you need to know about her.
I also loved Lucy’s family, especially her relationship with her sister Margaret. They felt real. Supportive without being perfect. Protective without being overbearing. Those moments ended up meaning just as much to me as the mystery itself.
The beginning took me a little while to settle into, but once the investigation gained momentum, I found myself reading “just one more chapter” far more times than I planned. Suddenly it was late, my tea was cold, and I needed answers.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This felt less like a traditional Regency romance and more like a historical adventure with a mystery at its heart. If you enjoy clever heroines, quirky characters, found family, and stories that take a familiar setting and do something unexpected with it, I’d definitely recommend giving this one a try.
And now I have to ask: what’s the strangest book mashup you’ve ever read that somehow ended up working?
This was a bit of a slow start as it took time to introduce and develop the characters for the plot. It held my interest though going back and forth between ballrooms and late night racing.
Propriety and social rules drove Lucy’s actions through the day but gave way whenever carriages were the main topic. It was an interesting combination.
Lucy’s character presented as neurodivergent through her being described as fastidious, having trouble detecting social nuances, and among other things.
There were times I didn’t understand the working of the carriages they were discussing but it was easy enough to follow and go along with it.
The plot slowly builds until you realize how each piece fits together and the last quarter of the story is filled with the promised danger and exciting action that made it hard to put down.
I enjoyed this and appreciate that a trad publisher took on a debut author writing in the Regency period. Tagged as Fast and the Furious meets Pride and Prejudice in a romantic adventure. Centering around illicit Night Races that ignores class differences every full moon and filled with detailed mechanical workings of carriages - I agree with it’s relating to Fast and the Furious. Having never read P&P though I can’t speak to that specifically but am an avid HR reader with an idea of the concept of P&P. However, using P&P and romantic adventure as a guideline, I expected a lot more romance. There is a HEA but the romance is more of an underlying thread to the storyline. Lucy spends some time thinking of her feelings and admiring Captain Dashwood’s form but their interactions barely gives an inclination to romantic intentions.
We never get Captain Dashwood’s POV and while it added to the mystery and intrigue, it hurt the romance aspect. The story is mainly told in third person from Lucy’s point of view but occasionally changed to other side characters towards the end.
Readers that like historical mystery with a twinge of romance would enjoy this the most.
Fast and Fastidous is a standalone historical mystery with a side of romance set during the Regency period. There is a HEA and zero kisses or intimate encounters.
This was a new to me author.
I received an advance reader copy from the publishers via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Thank you so much part@er @harperperennial for this gifted Arc!
The Book: 🎩
Lucy Elliot has often been described as fastidious, given her belief that there is an objectively correct and logical way to do things. And while she strives to be proper in every way, she does have one rather scandalous Lucy, the prim and gentle lady, is a frequent attendee of the entirely disreputable and illicit Night Races, where unchaperoned men and women from all social classes gather on dark country lanes to gamble on the outcomes of furiously fast carriage races. But her secret might become more than just a danger to her reputation when her mysterious new neighbor, Captain Dashwood, begins partaking in the races. Lucy can’t help but feel there’s something more to the handsome Captain Dashwood than meets the eye, and she suspects that his arrival in the neighborhood in the midst of a spate of curious and alarming carriage robberies is no mere coincidence -something is most certainly afoot in the county, and it’s a mystery Lucy intends to solve. Though Lucy prides herself on her preparedness, she never could have anticipated the web of lies, deceit, and espionage that she finds herself and Captain Dashwood entangled in; nor could she have known that the very fate of Britain would hang in the balance. But will her meticulous nature be the very thing that saves her, or will it be her-and England’s-undoing?
My Thoughts:👒
Friends, if you are a Jane Austen lover and fan of Fast and the Furious, then this book is the butter to your toast! I devoured and loved this story.
Lucy the main character in the story was marvelous. I was a fan of her rebellious character and fiercely independent investigative style.
If you’re down to sneak out at night to watch high speed carriage races and investigate the robberies of some of them you will love Fast & Fastidious!
QOTD: Which Fast and the Furious movie was your fave?
This book is incredibly funny and innovative! I’m a huge fan of period dramas, but this one offers a completely fresh perspective. We meet Lucy, who participates in underground carriage racing—can you imagine the SCANDAL that would cause back then? I absolutely adore Lucy; from the very first chapter, you truly understand her character and what drives her.
On another note, this is a "one-sitting" kind of read. The chapters are quite short, and before I knew it, I had already flown through 100 pages. Plus, I live for period-era gossip: the tea parties, the balls, and all the drama.
Then we have Captain Dashwood, who arrives to turn Lucy’s world upside down. He brings a mystery subplot that forces them together, and I loved watching their interactions unfold. And girl... by the end, he says something that left me absolutely swooning and head over heels for him!
Thanks to Harper Perennial for the advanced reader copy (ARC).
RESEÑA EN ESPAÑOL
Este libro es demasiado gracioso e innovador, yo disfruto demasiado los libros de época, pero este trae una propuesta totalmente distinta, donde Lucy quien participa en carreras de carruajes clandestina, imagínate el ESCANDALO de esto en esa época, amo a Lucy, desde el primer capitulo entendemos a su personaje, sus fijaciones.
Por otro lado, este libro se lee en una sentada porque los capítulos son bastante cortos, y yo sin saberlo ya llevaba 100 páginas leídas, y además amo el chisme de época todo lo relacionado con las fiestas de té, los bailes y los escándalos.
También tenemos al capitán Dashwood quien llega para alterar el mundo de Lucy, además con el viene una trama de misterio que los unirá mucho a el y a Lucy. Yo disfrute mucho leyendo sus interacciones y chica, ya al final hay una frase de el que me dejo loca y enamorada de este hombre.
Muchas gracias a Harper perennial por la copia anticipada del libro.