What do you think?
Rate this book
Looking Glass Theory
What would you change if you could live your life again—through a mirror’s reflection?
After the sudden death of her husband, Nora Hewitt moves to coastal North Carolina hoping to rebuild her life through starting her dream interior design firm. But when she acquires a stunning set of antique mirrors, eerie occurrences begin to shatter her reality. Whispers in the glass. Flickers of movement. A reflection that isn't her own.
As the mirrors pull her deeper into a haunting past, Nora befriends a skeptical ghost hunter who helps her uncover buried a string of disappearances, secret paranormal experiments, and her own family's mysterious legacy. When her sister vanishes without a trace, Nora must face what she’s always feared—that the past is not finished with her, and some mirrors were never meant to be looked into.
A southern gothic tale of grief, love, and the supernatural, Looking Glass Theory blends paranormal suspense with heart-wrenching mystery.
Perfect for fans of Simone St. James, Jennifer McMahon, and Sarah Addison Allen.
After the sudden death of her husband, Nora Hewitt moves to coastal North Carolina hoping to rebuild her life through starting her dream interior design firm. But when she acquires a stunning set of antique mirrors, eerie occurrences begin to shatter her reality. Whispers in the glass. Flickers of movement. A reflection that isn't her own.
As the mirrors pull her deeper into a haunting past, Nora befriends a skeptical ghost hunter who helps her uncover buried a string of disappearances, secret paranormal experiments, and her own family's mysterious legacy. When her sister vanishes without a trace, Nora must face what she’s always feared—that the past is not finished with her, and some mirrors were never meant to be looked into.
A southern gothic tale of grief, love, and the supernatural, Looking Glass Theory blends paranormal suspense with heart-wrenching mystery.
Perfect for fans of Simone St. James, Jennifer McMahon, and Sarah Addison Allen.
308 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 1, 2025
1 person want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
August 25, 2025
Thank you to the author and Book Sirens for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
=================================
The Looking Glass Theory is a eerie tale set in North Carolina. Nora moves to Wilmington after inheriting 4 million dollars from her late husband’s estate. But the historic home she is renovating has a jaded past. One that includes a creepy “death mirror” holding the spirits of those that passed before it.
The story begins with promise, but quickly leans too heavily on convenient plot devices. What do I mean by that? First, Nora discovers an antique, haunted mirror hanging in her new home. The very next day, she purchases three more mirrors at an open market; identical to one that once hung in her husband’s music studio in Nashville. Unsurprisingly, these mirrors are haunted too. Nora, unaware of their sinister nature, sends two of them to her sisters: one to Calista in Asheville who is "psychically-sensitive", and the other to Vicki, a behavioral research scientist in Durham.
But the coincidences don’t stop there. It turns out their late father had been secretly neglecting his own research to study haunted mirrors. Now, Vicki appears to be continuing his work. And if that weren’t enough, Nora befriends the granddaughter of the vendor who sold her the mirrors—who just happens to be a paranormal investigator with specialized knowledge of these very artifacts.
Any one or two of these elements could have been compelling on their own. But the sheer number of interconnected mirror-related revelations strains believability. Nearly every character Nora interacts with has a direct link to haunted mirrors, resulting in what can only be described as plot device fatigue. That said, the novel still delivers on atmosphere. Each disappearance and death surrounding Nora raises chilling questions: Are they all connected to the mirrors? Is her family cursed?
161 haunted mirrors and 35 years of bad luck later, I found myself confused about the book’s theme and genre. It begins as a ghost story, then shifts midway into a murder mystery with an obvious villain and little tension. It also attempts to present a psychoanalytical treatise on the Looking-Glass Self—the idea that we become the person we believe others perceive us to be. Then decides, that's all wrong as it's adversity that shapes us into something stronger. Ultimately, it wraps itself in a paranormal romance.
The story meanders without a clear thematic focus, and its supernatural elements flirt with magical realism but lack the internal logic to make them believable. Several narrative threads lead nowhere, and by the end, horror fans are left with a cozy tale of a soul-bonded couple rather than a truly haunting experience.
=================================
The Looking Glass Theory is a eerie tale set in North Carolina. Nora moves to Wilmington after inheriting 4 million dollars from her late husband’s estate. But the historic home she is renovating has a jaded past. One that includes a creepy “death mirror” holding the spirits of those that passed before it.
The story begins with promise, but quickly leans too heavily on convenient plot devices. What do I mean by that? First, Nora discovers an antique, haunted mirror hanging in her new home. The very next day, she purchases three more mirrors at an open market; identical to one that once hung in her husband’s music studio in Nashville. Unsurprisingly, these mirrors are haunted too. Nora, unaware of their sinister nature, sends two of them to her sisters: one to Calista in Asheville who is "psychically-sensitive", and the other to Vicki, a behavioral research scientist in Durham.
But the coincidences don’t stop there. It turns out their late father had been secretly neglecting his own research to study haunted mirrors. Now, Vicki appears to be continuing his work. And if that weren’t enough, Nora befriends the granddaughter of the vendor who sold her the mirrors—who just happens to be a paranormal investigator with specialized knowledge of these very artifacts.
Any one or two of these elements could have been compelling on their own. But the sheer number of interconnected mirror-related revelations strains believability. Nearly every character Nora interacts with has a direct link to haunted mirrors, resulting in what can only be described as plot device fatigue. That said, the novel still delivers on atmosphere. Each disappearance and death surrounding Nora raises chilling questions: Are they all connected to the mirrors? Is her family cursed?
161 haunted mirrors and 35 years of bad luck later, I found myself confused about the book’s theme and genre. It begins as a ghost story, then shifts midway into a murder mystery with an obvious villain and little tension. It also attempts to present a psychoanalytical treatise on the Looking-Glass Self—the idea that we become the person we believe others perceive us to be. Then decides, that's all wrong as it's adversity that shapes us into something stronger. Ultimately, it wraps itself in a paranormal romance.
The story meanders without a clear thematic focus, and its supernatural elements flirt with magical realism but lack the internal logic to make them believable. Several narrative threads lead nowhere, and by the end, horror fans are left with a cozy tale of a soul-bonded couple rather than a truly haunting experience.
August 17, 2025
Thank you to Booksirens and the author, Vivian Catfield, for the opportunity to read this book for an honest review.
The short of it, if I could do halves, this would be a 2.5 star, since I cannot I am more inclined to round up to 3 stars. There was so much to this book. I enjoyed the characters, however, the first 1/4th of the book I had wished the book had been told from Vickie’s POV. I did end up enjoying Nora. I think my biggest qualm with this book was that it was very heavy on exposition. A lot to telling, the author relied heavily on characters having massive info dumps to bring us to up to speed. While I enjoy detailed descriptions of scenery, I felt like there was too much in regard to Nora’s profession as an Interior Designer, to the point I found it distracting to the plot. This could be a case of reader preference, so take that for what it’s worth.
The long of it, I think this author is quite intelligent and it shows in her writing. I enjoyed her knowledge of history and her using genuine ghost stories from the area, I thought that was really fun. My hang up is that I feel like because of that she focused on adding SO much that the story kind of became lost in the chaos. Another reviewer stated that she leaned heavily on so many tropes at once, I am inclined to agree. My biggest complaint is that character's info dumped, to get into the ghost hunting, to the shady lawyer, to the monster in law. Then there were also some really unrealistic times like when the cop yells at Nora that her brother-in-law killed her sister, when there was no evidence or indication that she was killed, only her asshole mother insisting that's what happened. Which I feel like even if they suspected him, it would never ever be handled in that manner especially with the cop being a stranger to Nora and the family.
Overall, if I am being honest, I would give the author another try in the future, because there were SO many good things she could have done with the plot I think it just got a little lost because the author wanted to add so much to the stories of all the characters that no single trope or plot line got fully fleshed out.
The short of it, if I could do halves, this would be a 2.5 star, since I cannot I am more inclined to round up to 3 stars. There was so much to this book. I enjoyed the characters, however, the first 1/4th of the book I had wished the book had been told from Vickie’s POV. I did end up enjoying Nora. I think my biggest qualm with this book was that it was very heavy on exposition. A lot to telling, the author relied heavily on characters having massive info dumps to bring us to up to speed. While I enjoy detailed descriptions of scenery, I felt like there was too much in regard to Nora’s profession as an Interior Designer, to the point I found it distracting to the plot. This could be a case of reader preference, so take that for what it’s worth.
The long of it, I think this author is quite intelligent and it shows in her writing. I enjoyed her knowledge of history and her using genuine ghost stories from the area, I thought that was really fun. My hang up is that I feel like because of that she focused on adding SO much that the story kind of became lost in the chaos. Another reviewer stated that she leaned heavily on so many tropes at once, I am inclined to agree. My biggest complaint is that character's info dumped, to get into the ghost hunting, to the shady lawyer, to the monster in law. Then there were also some really unrealistic times like when the cop yells at Nora that her brother-in-law killed her sister, when there was no evidence or indication that she was killed, only her asshole mother insisting that's what happened. Which I feel like even if they suspected him, it would never ever be handled in that manner especially with the cop being a stranger to Nora and the family.
Overall, if I am being honest, I would give the author another try in the future, because there were SO many good things she could have done with the plot I think it just got a little lost because the author wanted to add so much to the stories of all the characters that no single trope or plot line got fully fleshed out.
August 3, 2025
Review to follow
August 30, 2025
This was an incredibly disappointing read, to be quite honest.
I had high hopes for this book, a southern Gothic novel based in North Carolina, my home state. Only for it to fall completely flat.
To start, this book is just...boring. And I wish it wasn't. The concept is there, the story is there, but there's SO MUCH EXPOSITION. The entire book read like "dialogue, event, 'oh no, another thing is happening' travel to event, dialogue, event. Wash, rinse, repeat. It doesn't make for a very exciting or compelling story.
For example, a few traumatic events happen in front of/to our character within a relatively short period of time, and yet we practically explore none of it. That kind of seems to be the case with this entire book. It is just event after event happening, and then dialogue to EXPLAIN what's happening directly to the reader; (maybe this author thinks the reader is stupid? I'm sorry, I don't want to be mean but the more I think about the things I disliked about this book, the angrier I get) we aren't reading this story, we are being TOLD this story. There's even a few moments in this book where a character does the whole "so let get me the facts right..." and then DIRECTLY explains everything that the reader should have put together themselves by this point. It feels condescending and insulting.
There was a moment that bothered me in particular in this book. Our main character had just learned a few major, LIFE-CHANGING facts about her father, mother, and husband; she is on a four hour road trip with her new bestie, and instead of having ANY kind of introspection during this time for her to reflect on learning these facts, she "sleeps dreamlessly" through most of the trip. I almost stopped reading right there and came to give this a scathing review just for that moment.
Because there is so much straight up exposition to this story, it feels like there is NO TONE to speak of. I spent the first half of this book trying to figure out how I'm supposed to be feeling throughout this book (especially since this IS a Gothic novel and I expect some darkness in the tone) and I finally realized why I couldn't figure it out - its because this author doesn't even know how she wants you to feel while reading this book. The few times she DOES actually give us a tone (which she does through a few graphic depictions of violence or gore) it throws the whole thing WAY off because there's this sudden seriousness to the tone that feels way out of place with the rest of the book.
There's NO resistance at all from any of the events happening. Everything that happens in this book happens quickly, easily, and conveniently. Way too conveniently. It's entirely unrealistic. This author wants absolutely no resistance in this story because they need to just seamlessly and easily move on to the next event or whatever, we need to just rush this story along. And there's SO MUCH HAPPENING that it's almost impossible to pinpoint a true climax.
Any time we start to delve further into a character's feelings or perspectives, it's either incredibly brief and brushed off almost immediately by another character, or Hazel is there to...explain it more directly to the reader for whatever reason. These characters feel so FLAT and undeveloped that they feel less like characters and more like plot devices. Just something there to move the story along. Not to mention, they all practically speak the exact same way too, there is no distinctive characterization or speech patterns to most of these characters. There's practically ZERO character development, unless you wanna count the last quarter or so of the book, where Nora finally allows herself to just feel the things she feels? Which is barely character development.
If it weren't for some of those fairly graphic depictions and the fact that all of our characters are in their 30s/40s I would almost want to assume this is a poorly written YA novel.
Two stars because I genuinely believe that if the author broke this book up into a series where EACH major event we saw happen in this book was the MAIN PLOT for EACH book, we'd have something to work with. It just feels like the author took as many tropes as they could for this kind of book and threw them at the wall to see what sticks. I'm so mad. I'm so disappointed.
I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I had high hopes for this book, a southern Gothic novel based in North Carolina, my home state. Only for it to fall completely flat.
To start, this book is just...boring. And I wish it wasn't. The concept is there, the story is there, but there's SO MUCH EXPOSITION. The entire book read like "dialogue, event, 'oh no, another thing is happening' travel to event, dialogue, event. Wash, rinse, repeat. It doesn't make for a very exciting or compelling story.
For example, a few traumatic events happen in front of/to our character within a relatively short period of time, and yet we practically explore none of it. That kind of seems to be the case with this entire book. It is just event after event happening, and then dialogue to EXPLAIN what's happening directly to the reader; (maybe this author thinks the reader is stupid? I'm sorry, I don't want to be mean but the more I think about the things I disliked about this book, the angrier I get) we aren't reading this story, we are being TOLD this story. There's even a few moments in this book where a character does the whole "so let get me the facts right..." and then DIRECTLY explains everything that the reader should have put together themselves by this point. It feels condescending and insulting.
There was a moment that bothered me in particular in this book. Our main character had just learned a few major, LIFE-CHANGING facts about her father, mother, and husband; she is on a four hour road trip with her new bestie, and instead of having ANY kind of introspection during this time for her to reflect on learning these facts, she "sleeps dreamlessly" through most of the trip. I almost stopped reading right there and came to give this a scathing review just for that moment.
Because there is so much straight up exposition to this story, it feels like there is NO TONE to speak of. I spent the first half of this book trying to figure out how I'm supposed to be feeling throughout this book (especially since this IS a Gothic novel and I expect some darkness in the tone) and I finally realized why I couldn't figure it out - its because this author doesn't even know how she wants you to feel while reading this book. The few times she DOES actually give us a tone (which she does through a few graphic depictions of violence or gore) it throws the whole thing WAY off because there's this sudden seriousness to the tone that feels way out of place with the rest of the book.
There's NO resistance at all from any of the events happening. Everything that happens in this book happens quickly, easily, and conveniently. Way too conveniently. It's entirely unrealistic. This author wants absolutely no resistance in this story because they need to just seamlessly and easily move on to the next event or whatever, we need to just rush this story along. And there's SO MUCH HAPPENING that it's almost impossible to pinpoint a true climax.
Any time we start to delve further into a character's feelings or perspectives, it's either incredibly brief and brushed off almost immediately by another character, or Hazel is there to...explain it more directly to the reader for whatever reason. These characters feel so FLAT and undeveloped that they feel less like characters and more like plot devices. Just something there to move the story along. Not to mention, they all practically speak the exact same way too, there is no distinctive characterization or speech patterns to most of these characters. There's practically ZERO character development, unless you wanna count the last quarter or so of the book, where Nora finally allows herself to just feel the things she feels? Which is barely character development.
If it weren't for some of those fairly graphic depictions and the fact that all of our characters are in their 30s/40s I would almost want to assume this is a poorly written YA novel.
Two stars because I genuinely believe that if the author broke this book up into a series where EACH major event we saw happen in this book was the MAIN PLOT for EACH book, we'd have something to work with. It just feels like the author took as many tropes as they could for this kind of book and threw them at the wall to see what sticks. I'm so mad. I'm so disappointed.
I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 29, 2025
In every reflection lies a choice..redemption, or a past that refuses to let go.🩶
Looking Glass Theory- by Vivian Catfield
🪞Blurb🪞
What would you change if you could live your life again
-through a mirror's reflection? After the sudden death of her husband, Nora Hewitt moves to coastal North Carolina hoping to rebuild her life through starting her dream interior design firm. But when she acquires a stunning set of antique mirrors, eerie occurrences begin to shatter her reality. Whispers in the glass. Flickers of movement. A reflection that isn't her own. As the mirrors pull her deeper into a haunting past, Nora befriends a skeptical ghost hunter who helps her uncover buried a string of disappearances, secret paranormal experiments, and her own family's mysterious legacy. When her sister vanishes without a trace, Nora must face what she's always feared-that the past is not finished with her, and some mirrors were never meant to be looked into.
🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️
Through the mirror lies the life she lost, the secrets she was never meant to find, and a past that refuses to let her go.
Looking Glass Theory is the perfect blend of cozy small-town mystery and paranormal mystery all wrapped into one.
As a past resident of North Carolina, specifically close to the setting of The Looking Glass Theory in Wilmington, North Carolina I was immediately hooked after reading the blurb.
A southern gothic, paranormal mystery set in a place I’ve spent years.. immediately sold.
Nora is coping, albeit struggling after the tragedy of losing her beloved husband. In the midst of this tragedy she delves into rebuilding her life, and comes across a set of Antique Mirrors that hold more than what they seem.
The idea of haunted antique mirrors immediately brought me back to episodes of Supernatural, and folklore of “Bloody Mary”, and had me hooked right away.
This novel reads like the perfect mix of ghostly stories, tragedy, mystery and horror.
An immediate must read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A big thank you to Booksirens, as well as the Author for allowing me to ARC read for you.
Looking Glass Theory- by Vivian Catfield
🪞Blurb🪞
What would you change if you could live your life again
-through a mirror's reflection? After the sudden death of her husband, Nora Hewitt moves to coastal North Carolina hoping to rebuild her life through starting her dream interior design firm. But when she acquires a stunning set of antique mirrors, eerie occurrences begin to shatter her reality. Whispers in the glass. Flickers of movement. A reflection that isn't her own. As the mirrors pull her deeper into a haunting past, Nora befriends a skeptical ghost hunter who helps her uncover buried a string of disappearances, secret paranormal experiments, and her own family's mysterious legacy. When her sister vanishes without a trace, Nora must face what she's always feared-that the past is not finished with her, and some mirrors were never meant to be looked into.
🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕯️
Through the mirror lies the life she lost, the secrets she was never meant to find, and a past that refuses to let her go.
Looking Glass Theory is the perfect blend of cozy small-town mystery and paranormal mystery all wrapped into one.
As a past resident of North Carolina, specifically close to the setting of The Looking Glass Theory in Wilmington, North Carolina I was immediately hooked after reading the blurb.
A southern gothic, paranormal mystery set in a place I’ve spent years.. immediately sold.
Nora is coping, albeit struggling after the tragedy of losing her beloved husband. In the midst of this tragedy she delves into rebuilding her life, and comes across a set of Antique Mirrors that hold more than what they seem.
The idea of haunted antique mirrors immediately brought me back to episodes of Supernatural, and folklore of “Bloody Mary”, and had me hooked right away.
This novel reads like the perfect mix of ghostly stories, tragedy, mystery and horror.
An immediate must read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A big thank you to Booksirens, as well as the Author for allowing me to ARC read for you.
September 1, 2025
I requested this book because I loved the blurb, and got to read it courtesy of BookSirens! It was as fantastic as I expected!
Looking Glass Theory by Vivian Catfield is an entertaining must-read for fans of ghost stories, time-bendy paranormal mysteries, and heartrending tales of love that transcends lifetimes weaving it all into a haunting yet comforting tapestry. The premise is delightfully spooky, with the imagery of characters slipping through mirrors to access memories. It’s not quite time travel, but a vivid exploration of the past that feels just as transporting and more personal. This concept alone hooked me, evoking a sense of wonder and unease that carried through every page. Sometimes turning dangerous, and other times bringing comfort to the characters.
Those characters are the heart of this story, and their relationships stand out. The depictions of the sisterly bonds, broader family ties, and ghostly figures are rich and complex. The evolving dynamics of the marriages woven throughout the narrative add another layer of intrigue, showcasing how choices ripple across time and relationships. The connections feel authentic and layered, every interaction resonates with emotional depth. Especially compelling was the theme of inheritance—not just of tangible things, but of history, memory, and the actions of those who came before us. The story beautifully illustrates how our lives are shaped by the choices of others, forming a kind of inherited legacy that binds us to the past, complimenting the mirror-memory mechanism.
Despite tackling heavy subject matter, the author maintains a soothing, heartwarming atmosphere. The ending is a sweet and satisfying resolution that filled with hope and warmth. The vivid imagery, especially of the mirror passages, is nothing short of fantastic, painting scenes that linger long after the book is closed.
It’s a beautifully crafted story that’s as thought-provoking as it is comforting.
Looking Glass Theory by Vivian Catfield is an entertaining must-read for fans of ghost stories, time-bendy paranormal mysteries, and heartrending tales of love that transcends lifetimes weaving it all into a haunting yet comforting tapestry. The premise is delightfully spooky, with the imagery of characters slipping through mirrors to access memories. It’s not quite time travel, but a vivid exploration of the past that feels just as transporting and more personal. This concept alone hooked me, evoking a sense of wonder and unease that carried through every page. Sometimes turning dangerous, and other times bringing comfort to the characters.
Those characters are the heart of this story, and their relationships stand out. The depictions of the sisterly bonds, broader family ties, and ghostly figures are rich and complex. The evolving dynamics of the marriages woven throughout the narrative add another layer of intrigue, showcasing how choices ripple across time and relationships. The connections feel authentic and layered, every interaction resonates with emotional depth. Especially compelling was the theme of inheritance—not just of tangible things, but of history, memory, and the actions of those who came before us. The story beautifully illustrates how our lives are shaped by the choices of others, forming a kind of inherited legacy that binds us to the past, complimenting the mirror-memory mechanism.
Despite tackling heavy subject matter, the author maintains a soothing, heartwarming atmosphere. The ending is a sweet and satisfying resolution that filled with hope and warmth. The vivid imagery, especially of the mirror passages, is nothing short of fantastic, painting scenes that linger long after the book is closed.
It’s a beautifully crafted story that’s as thought-provoking as it is comforting.
September 1, 2025
Let me start by saying I really loved the idea of ghosts trapped in mirrors, such an original take on ghost stories. The concept was great and full of promise, but as I kept reading, things got a bit chaotic, and the ending didn’t bring much closure.
Let me start with the elements I loved:
- The age of the characters. It’s refreshing to see adults, well into their lives, at the center of the story, thank you for that!!
- The ghosts, because who doesn’t love ghost stories really. They were great and I thought much more could have been said about them.
- The overall atmosphere. It was kinda gloomy, mixing time and worlds. It gave me strong urban fantasy vibes (and it’s rather hit or miss with me, a hit this time!).
What didn’t work for me:
- The story went everywhere and nowhere. So many things are mentioned but never explored, leaving us with many questions. I often felt lost, with all the different mirrors and side quests that led nowhere, such as Nora visiting Jasper's mom (won't say more, spoiler free). It was pointless and confusing, adding nothing to the story. I still don’t get it.
- Elements kept being added to the story for no reason. Explanations about the mirrors kept shifting when convenient, but they didn’t tie together.
- The girls’ mother. What a weird character, whose motivations were so far-fetched they pulled me out of the story. How is it believable? Divorce exists, you know…..
- The characters overall. They’re empty shells with little backstory, and no emotional depth. They’re surrounded by deaths, disappearances, but they behave as if nothing happens. You never know what they’re thinking and it’s a lot of tell instead of show…
So in short, a great idea, really. But bad execution.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Let me start with the elements I loved:
- The age of the characters. It’s refreshing to see adults, well into their lives, at the center of the story, thank you for that!!
- The ghosts, because who doesn’t love ghost stories really. They were great and I thought much more could have been said about them.
- The overall atmosphere. It was kinda gloomy, mixing time and worlds. It gave me strong urban fantasy vibes (and it’s rather hit or miss with me, a hit this time!).
What didn’t work for me:
- The story went everywhere and nowhere. So many things are mentioned but never explored, leaving us with many questions. I often felt lost, with all the different mirrors and side quests that led nowhere, such as Nora visiting Jasper's mom (won't say more, spoiler free). It was pointless and confusing, adding nothing to the story. I still don’t get it.
- Elements kept being added to the story for no reason. Explanations about the mirrors kept shifting when convenient, but they didn’t tie together.
- The girls’ mother. What a weird character, whose motivations were so far-fetched they pulled me out of the story. How is it believable? Divorce exists, you know…..
- The characters overall. They’re empty shells with little backstory, and no emotional depth. They’re surrounded by deaths, disappearances, but they behave as if nothing happens. You never know what they’re thinking and it’s a lot of tell instead of show…
So in short, a great idea, really. But bad execution.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 9, 2025
Many thanks to BookSirens and the author for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The Looking Glass Theory is a cozy, paranormal-tinged story that blends small-town charm with ghostly mystery.
As a North Carolina native, I loved the author’s vivid descriptions of Asheville, Durham, and Wilmington, NC, and the use of real places I’ve actually been to—it gave the setting an instant authenticity and warmth. The story follows interior designer Nora, who, after the death of her husband and receiving an inheritance, decides to move to Wilmington. While settling in, she discovers a set of mirrors that serve as doorways for the paranormal to slip in and out of the real world.
The characters—Nora and her two sisters—are likable, and the premise feels like a fresh twist on cozy fantasy, with the added intrigue of ghosts and supernatural happenings. It was an overall fun read, but I did sometimes feel the plot had a bit too much going on; trimming one storyline might have made it stronger and more focused.
If you’re in the mood for a light, atmospheric read with a dash of the paranormal, this could be a charming pick—especially since it will be available on Kindle Unlimited when it’s released on September 1!
The Looking Glass Theory is a cozy, paranormal-tinged story that blends small-town charm with ghostly mystery.
As a North Carolina native, I loved the author’s vivid descriptions of Asheville, Durham, and Wilmington, NC, and the use of real places I’ve actually been to—it gave the setting an instant authenticity and warmth. The story follows interior designer Nora, who, after the death of her husband and receiving an inheritance, decides to move to Wilmington. While settling in, she discovers a set of mirrors that serve as doorways for the paranormal to slip in and out of the real world.
The characters—Nora and her two sisters—are likable, and the premise feels like a fresh twist on cozy fantasy, with the added intrigue of ghosts and supernatural happenings. It was an overall fun read, but I did sometimes feel the plot had a bit too much going on; trimming one storyline might have made it stronger and more focused.
If you’re in the mood for a light, atmospheric read with a dash of the paranormal, this could be a charming pick—especially since it will be available on Kindle Unlimited when it’s released on September 1!
October 4, 2025
I received an ARC of The Looking Glass Theory through BookSirens in exchange for an honest review.
One of the standout elements of this novel for me was its incorporation of the dance world. As someone with a background in dance, I really appreciated how the author captured the physicality, discipline, and emotional complexity that come with performance. Those scenes felt especially vivid and authentic, adding a unique texture to the story.
The premise itself is intriguing, blending introspection, artistic ambition, and a touch of psychological mystery. The author’s writing style is descriptive and thoughtful, and there are moments where the narrative truly shines. However, there were times when the pacing felt uneven, and I found myself wishing for a bit more urgency or forward momentum in certain sections. A few of the supporting characters could also have been developed more fully to match the depth of the protagonist.
Overall, The Looking Glass Theory is a reflective and imaginative read that will appeal to readers who enjoy character-driven stories with artistic undertones. It’s not a fast-paced page-turner, but it offers meaningful themes and well-crafted moments that linger.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
One of the standout elements of this novel for me was its incorporation of the dance world. As someone with a background in dance, I really appreciated how the author captured the physicality, discipline, and emotional complexity that come with performance. Those scenes felt especially vivid and authentic, adding a unique texture to the story.
The premise itself is intriguing, blending introspection, artistic ambition, and a touch of psychological mystery. The author’s writing style is descriptive and thoughtful, and there are moments where the narrative truly shines. However, there were times when the pacing felt uneven, and I found myself wishing for a bit more urgency or forward momentum in certain sections. A few of the supporting characters could also have been developed more fully to match the depth of the protagonist.
Overall, The Looking Glass Theory is a reflective and imaginative read that will appeal to readers who enjoy character-driven stories with artistic undertones. It’s not a fast-paced page-turner, but it offers meaningful themes and well-crafted moments that linger.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 1, 2025
Vivian Catfield’s Looking Glass Theory is a southern gothic novel that feels both eerie and intimate. At its heart is Nora Hewitt, a woman whose attempt at rebuilding her life after tragedy is unsettled by a series of strange, mirror-bound disturbances. Instead of dwelling only on the supernatural spectacle, Catfield layers in themes of memory, loss, and the uncomfortable ways the past lingers no matter how far we try to move from it. The mirrors serve less as props and more as a gateway—into forgotten secrets, old experiments, and a legacy that Nora would rather not inherit.
What makes the story stand out is its balance: the creeping unease of whispered reflections is matched by the emotional pull of a sister suddenly gone missing. The addition of a pragmatic ghost hunter gives the narrative texture, allowing for skepticism and tension alongside Nora’s unraveling. With its rich coastal atmosphere and blend of suspense and heart, Looking Glass Theory reads less like a ghost story and more like an exploration of how grief can change what we see staring back at us.
What makes the story stand out is its balance: the creeping unease of whispered reflections is matched by the emotional pull of a sister suddenly gone missing. The addition of a pragmatic ghost hunter gives the narrative texture, allowing for skepticism and tension alongside Nora’s unraveling. With its rich coastal atmosphere and blend of suspense and heart, Looking Glass Theory reads less like a ghost story and more like an exploration of how grief can change what we see staring back at us.
September 1, 2025
Vivian Catfield’s Looking Glass Theory is a southern gothic novel that feels both eerie and intimate. At its heart is Nora Hewitt, a woman whose attempt at rebuilding her life after tragedy is unsettled by a series of strange, mirror-bound disturbances. Instead of dwelling only on the supernatural spectacle, Catfield layers in themes of memory, loss, and the uncomfortable ways the past lingers no matter how far we try to move from it. The mirrors serve less as props and more as a gateway—into forgotten secrets, old experiments, and a legacy that Nora would rather not inherit.
What makes the story stand out is its balance: the creeping unease of whispered reflections is matched by the emotional pull of a sister suddenly gone missing. The addition of a pragmatic ghost hunter gives the narrative texture, allowing for skepticism and tension alongside Nora’s unraveling. With its rich coastal atmosphere and blend of suspense and heart, Looking Glass Theory reads less like a ghost story and more like an exploration of how grief can change what we see staring back at us.
What makes the story stand out is its balance: the creeping unease of whispered reflections is matched by the emotional pull of a sister suddenly gone missing. The addition of a pragmatic ghost hunter gives the narrative texture, allowing for skepticism and tension alongside Nora’s unraveling. With its rich coastal atmosphere and blend of suspense and heart, Looking Glass Theory reads less like a ghost story and more like an exploration of how grief can change what we see staring back at us.
October 19, 2025
When dealing with the supernatural science has to be part of the equation. Some things cannot be explained but science cane become the ethical and hypotheses of situations to protect everyone involved. Once Nora and the crew had come upon what the mirrors were capable of; Hazel was the one who brought up how the experiments conducted could be used in a nefarious way. Some people believe fate should be the controller of a person’s destiny while others want to control who and why a person’s life must go. The idea of communication with loved ones who have died sounds like a good idea but is it? Especially if a spirit on the other side is angry or inherently evil. The possibilities of what could happen are too many to count. The historical value of the mirror to Nora was fascinating. She learned that sometimes things are better left alone. The book ending resolved the many questions that came up while reading this book. I found this book to be a well written horror fantasy novel.
October 26, 2025
I received an ARC of this book from the author and BookSirens in exchange for an honest review. Nora is a recent widow, who has a complicated family situation, complete with a vicious harpy for a mother and a father who died of suicide. When she finds an old mirror in her newly purchased home, Nora finds herself on a pathway to discovering her father’s paranormal research, the truth of his death, the truth of her husband’s death, and multiple stories of betrayal. The story’s premise is intriguing, and I think the looking glass theory is a fascinating concept. I think the story would benefit from focusing on one of the core mysteries instead of trying to incorporate all of the ideas into one story. Gallows Meg is an interesting character, and I would love to see the author tell her story in full. 2.5 stars.
August 19, 2025
There are so many fun things going on in this book! Everywhere you look, there’s something to grab your attention. The overall concept and premise of the book is interesting—combining everything from the paranormal and family drama to a good ole cozy mystery. At times it can almost be a little overwhelming, but in the end it’s all woven together to create Nora’s journey. Life is messy and disorienting at times, so this felt like it could contribute to providing the reader with a peek at Nora’s current chaos. However, there were other times where informational tidbits were just thrown in for your reading pleasure.
I appreciate BookSirens providing me with this ARC and the opportunity to voluntarily post this review. I will definitely read more from this author in the future!
I appreciate BookSirens providing me with this ARC and the opportunity to voluntarily post this review. I will definitely read more from this author in the future!
August 19, 2025
This book was a very pleasant surprise!
Books like this can often be super corny and eye roll inducing. Catfield managed to make it really enjoyable without an eye roll insight. The storyline was great, and the cast of characters all made sense. The author wrote this with enough detail as to where you could picture everything, but not so much as to make it boring and wordy. They wove a tale that I immediately jumped into and didn't want to end. This is my first time reading this author, but it won't be my last.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Books like this can often be super corny and eye roll inducing. Catfield managed to make it really enjoyable without an eye roll insight. The storyline was great, and the cast of characters all made sense. The author wrote this with enough detail as to where you could picture everything, but not so much as to make it boring and wordy. They wove a tale that I immediately jumped into and didn't want to end. This is my first time reading this author, but it won't be my last.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 29, 2025
I really wish I could give this book more than 5 stars.
I was hooked from the beginning an intriguing tale of mystery and love.
This is the first time in a longtime that I am completely enthralled, well written and addictive. The author makes the story feel real.
I went on a journey with Nora. I was with her every step of the way. I haven’t read a book like this in a while.
A ghost story, a friendship story, a widows story of life after Loss, of history, love, life and the mystery of soulmates.
Can’t wait to read more of Vivian’s work.
100% a fan.
Thank you.
I was hooked from the beginning an intriguing tale of mystery and love.
This is the first time in a longtime that I am completely enthralled, well written and addictive. The author makes the story feel real.
I went on a journey with Nora. I was with her every step of the way. I haven’t read a book like this in a while.
A ghost story, a friendship story, a widows story of life after Loss, of history, love, life and the mystery of soulmates.
Can’t wait to read more of Vivian’s work.
100% a fan.
Thank you.
August 22, 2025
Looking Glass Theory is a paranormal/cozy mystery novel. The story combines time travel, folklore, family drama, and even paranormal history. Vivian Catfield does a nice job weaving together multiple timelines past and present to form an interesting and mysterious story. Looking Glass Theory also addresses whether our lives are predetermined or are we able to change or determine our fate.
This story is fun, interesting, and even scary at times. It does get a bit chaotic, but Catfield sorts everything out nicely.
Thank you BookSirens and NetGalley for sending me this ARC!
This story is fun, interesting, and even scary at times. It does get a bit chaotic, but Catfield sorts everything out nicely.
Thank you BookSirens and NetGalley for sending me this ARC!
September 1, 2025
Wow! I read this book in one sitting because I couldn’t put it down. It was engrossing and enthralling, sucking you in until you become a part of the story. I loved the characters and how they were presented. One sided until you realize there is more to why they are the way they are. Brilliantly written. I loved the haunted mirrors as well as the travel through them. I am excited to read ANYTHING Vivian Catfield writes. This was FANTASTIC!
July 24, 2025
Outstanding! Combining mystery, paranormal, murder, love across ages and twists and turns I did not see coming and I could not put this book down. The author did an amazing job weaving story lines together seamlessly and I look forward to reading other work by her!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 14, 2025
I honestly didn't know what to expect from this book and i have to say it was unique and definitely worth picking.
Its a supernatural ghost mystery and was so well written.
I dont think ive read anything quite like it before it even had a touch of romance.
Very good read!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Its a supernatural ghost mystery and was so well written.
I dont think ive read anything quite like it before it even had a touch of romance.
Very good read!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Read
August 26, 2025Thank you to Booksirens for the Arc and the opportunity to read this book.
Mirrors, in general, though showing beauty can be dangerous. I will read anything that has to do with the supernatural.
"Looking Glass Theory" does not disappoint. There is the aspect of grief, and a missing sister. And something sinister in the mirrors.
Mirrors, in general, though showing beauty can be dangerous. I will read anything that has to do with the supernatural.
"Looking Glass Theory" does not disappoint. There is the aspect of grief, and a missing sister. And something sinister in the mirrors.
July 24, 2025
I do hope there is another book to carry on from this one, as the storyline was riveting….not your usual romance, evil mother, unrequited love or murder mystery, it’s all of the above!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
August 15, 2025
If I could rate this book 6 stars I would. This was hands down one of my favorite books this year. It was perfectly creepy, with the sweetest romance, and plot twists that I didn’t see coming. I can see Vivian Catfield becoming one of my favorite authors.
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews