What do you think?
Rate this book
The Dark Mage
A haunting adult fantasy about trauma, love, and rebellion—perfect for fans of character-driven magic.
"Captivating, vivid, and compelling." —BookLife Reviews (A-)
Ren'wyn has long heard the whispers of the dead. Trapped in an arranged marriage to a cruel lord - and secretly bound to forbidden magic - she walks a dangerous line between obedience and defiance. The ancient magics of her world still flicker beneath imperial rule, and her gift is feared most of all. Her only fleeting escape from increasing isolation is in the realm of the dead, where the shades call her by name.
When a chance at freedom comes, she flees into a fractured land on the brink of rebellion. Magic is stirring, calling to those with power over strength, earth, foresight - and death. As Ren'wyn encounters other gifted outcasts and a battle-scarred soldier with secrets of his own, she must decide who she dares to trust. Her magic could destroy her - or become the key to restoring a world that has forgotten what it means to be free.
"Captivating, vivid, and compelling." —BookLife Reviews (A-)
Ren'wyn has long heard the whispers of the dead. Trapped in an arranged marriage to a cruel lord - and secretly bound to forbidden magic - she walks a dangerous line between obedience and defiance. The ancient magics of her world still flicker beneath imperial rule, and her gift is feared most of all. Her only fleeting escape from increasing isolation is in the realm of the dead, where the shades call her by name.
When a chance at freedom comes, she flees into a fractured land on the brink of rebellion. Magic is stirring, calling to those with power over strength, earth, foresight - and death. As Ren'wyn encounters other gifted outcasts and a battle-scarred soldier with secrets of his own, she must decide who she dares to trust. Her magic could destroy her - or become the key to restoring a world that has forgotten what it means to be free.
432 pages, Paperback
Published September 9, 2025
5 people are currently reading
63 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
October 7, 2025
I recieved a free copy in exchange for an honest review so here it is!! I really enjoyed this story. I'm sure someone more experienced than me could comment on the technicals, I see tons of scholarly reviews, but I rate on the vibes and how much I personally enjoyed each adventure so that's what you get from me! This book will forever have a place on my shelf.
The Dark Mage is about a girl named Ren'wyn who was born with magic. Not just any magic, either, but death magic. The rulers of this land have decided magic is terrible and should be eradicated, so those with powers keep it hidden or else risk being turned in by neighbors. The story starts at a secret school for those with powers, but it quickly progresses into an adventure that changes Ren'wyn's life forever. Tired of being used, abused, lied to, and considered property, she discovers self worth and starts accepting who and what she is. Along the way she finds acceptance and a once in a lifetime love.
I really liked that the FMC got to be the wielder of Shadows! And she loves her magic and takes comfort in what she does. She can heal broken spirits and wreck destruction! The author's take on Ren'wyn's insecurities, and how she struggled with them throughout, even when she was getting better (because you can't heal that overnight), was so relatable it hurt sometimes. Some tough topics are addressed within these pages, including talk of SA and attempted SA on the FMC (not by the MMC!). Prejudice, mental health, different types of abuse, and a woman's place in the world - all very real and relevant and approached in a way I admired.
You guys should definitely check out the Dark Mage and see what you think yourselves! I'm dying for book two!!
The Dark Mage is about a girl named Ren'wyn who was born with magic. Not just any magic, either, but death magic. The rulers of this land have decided magic is terrible and should be eradicated, so those with powers keep it hidden or else risk being turned in by neighbors. The story starts at a secret school for those with powers, but it quickly progresses into an adventure that changes Ren'wyn's life forever. Tired of being used, abused, lied to, and considered property, she discovers self worth and starts accepting who and what she is. Along the way she finds acceptance and a once in a lifetime love.
I really liked that the FMC got to be the wielder of Shadows! And she loves her magic and takes comfort in what she does. She can heal broken spirits and wreck destruction! The author's take on Ren'wyn's insecurities, and how she struggled with them throughout, even when she was getting better (because you can't heal that overnight), was so relatable it hurt sometimes. Some tough topics are addressed within these pages, including talk of SA and attempted SA on the FMC (not by the MMC!). Prejudice, mental health, different types of abuse, and a woman's place in the world - all very real and relevant and approached in a way I admired.
You guys should definitely check out the Dark Mage and see what you think yourselves! I'm dying for book two!!
September 16, 2025
The Dark Mage is a breathtakingly written high fantasy that completely captivated me. I truly can’t believe this is a debut! The prose is vivid and elegant, instantly pulling me into a world that feels both magical and alive.
Ren’wyn’s character arc is masterfully crafted, beautifully portraying the complexities of healing from trauma and the constant battle against intrusive thoughts and self-doubt. The plot is brimming with adventure and magic, carrying all the comfort of a romantasy while delivering fresh, original twists. The pacing allows the story to unfold naturally, making every moment feel earned.
And let’s talk about the romance! The slow burn absolutely sizzles, and Fael has easily become one of my favorite MMCs of all time. The cliffhanger ending shattered me in the best possible way, and I cannot wait to see where this story goes next!
✨ If you love:
• Found family
• Lyrical, immersive prose
• A scorching slow burn
• Touch-her-and-die energy
…do yourself a favor and pick up this book!
Ren’wyn’s character arc is masterfully crafted, beautifully portraying the complexities of healing from trauma and the constant battle against intrusive thoughts and self-doubt. The plot is brimming with adventure and magic, carrying all the comfort of a romantasy while delivering fresh, original twists. The pacing allows the story to unfold naturally, making every moment feel earned.
And let’s talk about the romance! The slow burn absolutely sizzles, and Fael has easily become one of my favorite MMCs of all time. The cliffhanger ending shattered me in the best possible way, and I cannot wait to see where this story goes next!
✨ If you love:
• Found family
• Lyrical, immersive prose
• A scorching slow burn
• Touch-her-and-die energy
…do yourself a favor and pick up this book!
September 20, 2025
I read the Dark Mage in three days. I have read a lot of science fiction/fantasy novels over the years. This book captures the emotional side of the characters much better than most…. There is enough “magic” enter woven through out the book to keep the fantasy part going strong. But, for me, the added strength of this book was the author’s ability to build a strong connection to the reader for each of the characters. You feel like you know/understand them. Can even relate to them in someways.
I read all of Stephen Donaldson’s books in the Thomas Covenant series many years ago. I was reminded of that series when I read this book…. with the added benefit of The Dark Mage more relatable character development. I felt pained when characters suffered. I was drawn into the love story between characters that made me almost made me jealous of their commitment to each other under such terrible circumstances…. Highly recommend
I read all of Stephen Donaldson’s books in the Thomas Covenant series many years ago. I was reminded of that series when I read this book…. with the added benefit of The Dark Mage more relatable character development. I felt pained when characters suffered. I was drawn into the love story between characters that made me almost made me jealous of their commitment to each other under such terrible circumstances…. Highly recommend
August 18, 2025
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Many thanks for this!
The Dark Mage brought me back to my early years of reading when Gothic novels captured my interest. Daphne Du Maurier and Victoria Holt were authors I turned to, drawing me into their worlds of windswept landscapes, dark mansions, and a touch of the supernatural, each with a strong female character who found herself in a complicated romantic relationship.
The Dark Mage weaves together several of these elements into a genre better known as romantasy.
There is much to love about this book, in particular main character Ren'wyn. She is both strong and vulnerable, damaged by her past, yet fiercely independent. Her magic is dark but her methods are pure. This gives depth and integrity to her character.
I found the story itself to be truly engaging. As an infrequent reader of fantasy, I was intrigued by how the magical elements became integral to the plot and how the clash between good and evil has its parallels in the real world. I could relate to a government who wished to abolish those who were "different" and to the misconceptions that put labels on those who don't fit the norm.
Finally, let's talk about the writing. Descriptions of nature are lovely and detailed. Characters are well-drawn and distinct. I appreciated the pace of the story and a plot that was not predictable. At times the romance scenes seemed a little gratuitous, but the connections between characters felt genuine.
Overall, this is an impressive first novel. The cliffhanger at the end promises a sequel which readers will undoubtedly welcome.
The Dark Mage brought me back to my early years of reading when Gothic novels captured my interest. Daphne Du Maurier and Victoria Holt were authors I turned to, drawing me into their worlds of windswept landscapes, dark mansions, and a touch of the supernatural, each with a strong female character who found herself in a complicated romantic relationship.
The Dark Mage weaves together several of these elements into a genre better known as romantasy.
There is much to love about this book, in particular main character Ren'wyn. She is both strong and vulnerable, damaged by her past, yet fiercely independent. Her magic is dark but her methods are pure. This gives depth and integrity to her character.
I found the story itself to be truly engaging. As an infrequent reader of fantasy, I was intrigued by how the magical elements became integral to the plot and how the clash between good and evil has its parallels in the real world. I could relate to a government who wished to abolish those who were "different" and to the misconceptions that put labels on those who don't fit the norm.
Finally, let's talk about the writing. Descriptions of nature are lovely and detailed. Characters are well-drawn and distinct. I appreciated the pace of the story and a plot that was not predictable. At times the romance scenes seemed a little gratuitous, but the connections between characters felt genuine.
Overall, this is an impressive first novel. The cliffhanger at the end promises a sequel which readers will undoubtedly welcome.
August 8, 2025
Not gonna lie, I struggled to get into this one initially. It took a bit to get into and understand the world, but worth it! I was not expecting to get so invested. I was not expecting to be devastated and sobbing at one point.
I struggled with Ren'wyn's character being so self-depreciating all the time. BUT also recognized that those parts of her character are not something that anyone would get over in a year, possibly ever. Which I had to periodically remind myself of when I started to get annoyed.
There is character development and growth, but most of it seems to be focused on Ren'wyn. I get she's the main character, but the growth of the other characters seems to be limited to a change of opinion about her or in Fael's case, nothing. The guy is portrayed as near perfect, all of his growth seems to have happened before he entered the story. His anger points are completely justified and reasonable. His aggression points, again, completely justified and reasonable. Maybe we'll see more in the next book.
And the ending! I'm just not ok and did not see that revelation coming!
Solid slow burn that's not excruciating long, touch her and die.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I struggled with Ren'wyn's character being so self-depreciating all the time. BUT also recognized that those parts of her character are not something that anyone would get over in a year, possibly ever. Which I had to periodically remind myself of when I started to get annoyed.
There is character development and growth, but most of it seems to be focused on Ren'wyn. I get she's the main character, but the growth of the other characters seems to be limited to a change of opinion about her or in Fael's case, nothing. The guy is portrayed as near perfect, all of his growth seems to have happened before he entered the story. His anger points are completely justified and reasonable. His aggression points, again, completely justified and reasonable. Maybe we'll see more in the next book.
And the ending! I'm just not ok and did not see that revelation coming!
Solid slow burn that's not excruciating long, touch her and die.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 15, 2025
Relationships are the heart of this story. They’re true, honest, mostly healthy, growing and emotional! I’m newer to the fantasy genre having only read SJM. The Dark Mage is the right combo that brings you both the romance and relationships with new forms of magic. Erin dares explore the question what if death and darkness were not something to fear but befriend? Could it even be good? While there is a lot of traveling scenes you’ll want to hang on to the end… but no spoilers here! Can’t wait for book 2!
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
August 18, 2025
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Thank you to BookSirens and Erin Vander Stelt for the opportunity to read this ARC! <3
From the very first page, The Dark Mage felt like it was written with raw emotion. Erin Vander Stelt’s prose is stunning—poetic but accessible, brimming with feeling, like she’s bleeding straight onto the page.
Ren’wyn may be only 21, but her story is one of the saddest and most powerful I’ve read in romantasy: a father who despises magic, a mother broken by abuse, a cruel betrothal to a man who mistreats her, and the haunting presence of siblings lost in the Void. Her depression and grief are written with such accuracy and empathy that I found myself wanting to reach through the pages to hold her.
But this isn’t just a story about pain—it’s about strength and healing. Ren’wyn is capable, determined, and deeply magical, even when the world tries to strip that away. And when Fael enters her life, their friendship-turned-love feels organic, tender, and absolutely swoon-worthy. Their bond is grounded not in him rescuing her, but in him seeing her for who she is and trusting her even before she trusts herself. “Fael trusted her more than she trusted herself, and she worked to see herself through his eyes.” This is the beating heart of the book.
The romance was beautifully done. Fael and Ren’wyn’s connection grows from respect and companionship into something deeper, and when they finally cross that line, it isn’t smut for smut’s sake—it’s love, passion, and power combined. Their first time together was intimate and tender, written explicitly but without ever losing the sense of reverence and care between them. It felt healing more than anything else—two people finding strength and comfort in one another. And it’s made all the stronger by contrast: Esrin wants to claim and control her, while Fael sees her as an equal, a queen, someone to honor rather than possess. He doesn’t cage her power—he reminds her she has it. Honestly, he swooned me constantly simply by trusting her.
The fight scenes were beautifully executed. The clash with the imperial soldiers, in particular, read like a dance—fluid, brutal, and heartbreaking. Fael’s training came through in every movement, his rage controlled but devastating, while Ren’wyn’s raw power erupted alongside him. What I loved most was how realistic it felt—Fael wasn’t some untouchable warrior always perfectly prepared. He had to grab his weapons, string his bow, and fight through chaos to reach her. That grounded detail gave the scene weight. And then Ren’wyn—finding her own strength in the heat of battle, and later quietly cleaning up the corpses herself—showed resilience in both the extraordinary and the ordinary moments. It was brutal, yes, but also deeply human.
I adored the magical details, from sentient forests to voids filled with ghosts, and the emotional depth of moments like Ren and Fael helping a little boy find peace. That scene in particular hit me as a mother—it was devastating and beautiful all at once.
The ending left me reeling—in the best way. Subtle shifts in perspective, secrets revealed about Fael, and a twist that opens the door to something even bigger.
This book was healing. It didn’t leave me frayed and exhausted the way some high-stakes romantasy does—it let me ride the waves of emotion, deep and steady, alongside Ren’wyn. A beautiful, empowering, and unforgettable story. I cannot wait for part two.
Favorite Quotes:
“Ren’wyn still felt it every time she immersed herself in magic: an ache of ice against her bones, a soft encouragement to sleep without fear of waking, an errant tug of a ghostly hand made solid.”
“You are not a prize to win. You’re a fortress—a queen—and you choose who you let in.” – Fael
“I am neither fully good nor fully bad… I am good and gentle and strong and vicious, and I will fight for this world until my last breath.” – Ren’wyn
Thank you to BookSirens and Erin Vander Stelt for the opportunity to read this ARC! <3
From the very first page, The Dark Mage felt like it was written with raw emotion. Erin Vander Stelt’s prose is stunning—poetic but accessible, brimming with feeling, like she’s bleeding straight onto the page.
Ren’wyn may be only 21, but her story is one of the saddest and most powerful I’ve read in romantasy: a father who despises magic, a mother broken by abuse, a cruel betrothal to a man who mistreats her, and the haunting presence of siblings lost in the Void. Her depression and grief are written with such accuracy and empathy that I found myself wanting to reach through the pages to hold her.
But this isn’t just a story about pain—it’s about strength and healing. Ren’wyn is capable, determined, and deeply magical, even when the world tries to strip that away. And when Fael enters her life, their friendship-turned-love feels organic, tender, and absolutely swoon-worthy. Their bond is grounded not in him rescuing her, but in him seeing her for who she is and trusting her even before she trusts herself. “Fael trusted her more than she trusted herself, and she worked to see herself through his eyes.” This is the beating heart of the book.
The romance was beautifully done. Fael and Ren’wyn’s connection grows from respect and companionship into something deeper, and when they finally cross that line, it isn’t smut for smut’s sake—it’s love, passion, and power combined. Their first time together was intimate and tender, written explicitly but without ever losing the sense of reverence and care between them. It felt healing more than anything else—two people finding strength and comfort in one another. And it’s made all the stronger by contrast: Esrin wants to claim and control her, while Fael sees her as an equal, a queen, someone to honor rather than possess. He doesn’t cage her power—he reminds her she has it. Honestly, he swooned me constantly simply by trusting her.
The fight scenes were beautifully executed. The clash with the imperial soldiers, in particular, read like a dance—fluid, brutal, and heartbreaking. Fael’s training came through in every movement, his rage controlled but devastating, while Ren’wyn’s raw power erupted alongside him. What I loved most was how realistic it felt—Fael wasn’t some untouchable warrior always perfectly prepared. He had to grab his weapons, string his bow, and fight through chaos to reach her. That grounded detail gave the scene weight. And then Ren’wyn—finding her own strength in the heat of battle, and later quietly cleaning up the corpses herself—showed resilience in both the extraordinary and the ordinary moments. It was brutal, yes, but also deeply human.
I adored the magical details, from sentient forests to voids filled with ghosts, and the emotional depth of moments like Ren and Fael helping a little boy find peace. That scene in particular hit me as a mother—it was devastating and beautiful all at once.
The ending left me reeling—in the best way. Subtle shifts in perspective, secrets revealed about Fael, and a twist that opens the door to something even bigger.
This book was healing. It didn’t leave me frayed and exhausted the way some high-stakes romantasy does—it let me ride the waves of emotion, deep and steady, alongside Ren’wyn. A beautiful, empowering, and unforgettable story. I cannot wait for part two.
Favorite Quotes:
“Ren’wyn still felt it every time she immersed herself in magic: an ache of ice against her bones, a soft encouragement to sleep without fear of waking, an errant tug of a ghostly hand made solid.”
“You are not a prize to win. You’re a fortress—a queen—and you choose who you let in.” – Fael
“I am neither fully good nor fully bad… I am good and gentle and strong and vicious, and I will fight for this world until my last breath.” – Ren’wyn
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 25, 2025
The Dark Mage is a fast-paced adventure in an evil world, full of tender characters who are wrestling with the violent and frightening acts they have done to survive in it.
There is a lot of mention of sexual assault. I feel that needs to be said at the outset. The female main character is traumatized by verbal and physical abuse in her past. There is an SA scene (although it is interrupted before becoming graphic). The author does not shy away from the painful realities of prejudice, sexism, rape, or abuse. Nor does Vander Stelt romanticize them. Nor does she sensationalize them. They are present in the story, along with their human consequences. Readers will not feel coddled from harsh truths, nor will they feel bludgeoned by them.
Ren’wyn is a sympathetic main character. She's not a Mary Sue, by any means, and she endures tragedy with agency and emotion equally. She is strong in a way that feels earned and real and feminine. The men around her can sometimes feel one-dimensional, but their voices and actions are true to character, while also appropriately growing and changing.
The magic system is soft, tied to certain people inherently (think benders in ATLA or mutants in X-Men). There is a magic school, but so little time is spent there it's unclear what most of the magic education actually looks like. This isn't a bad thing. The story isn't about magical people mastering their power, necessarily. The story is about people doing what they can in an evil and broken world. Their magic is described vividly, emotively, and freely. If you're looking for specific spells or hard rules to magic, you won't find them here. You'll find people doing what they can.
Fans of the Supernatural series will enjoy Ren’wyn’s powers, I think. Her encounters with the Void are varied, evocative, and often cathartic. There are some horror elements described, but it's never grotesque or overwrought.
The romance in this book feels authentic. It's not smut, and the descriptions of intimate acts are not overly graphic or suggestive. The characters and the plot are usually in the foreground. And the intimacy is just as often about comfort and care as it is about release or recreation. There's no pornographic vocabulary or language.
Overall, I found myself caring about the characters as I was whisked through their adventure. Admittedly, the first several chapters were slower, full of vignettes to help us understand Ren’wyn’s painful life. The actual plot doesn't pick up until later. That being said, the author doesn't belabor her scenes or descriptions with extra details, and there was no purple prose to slow things down. The writing is clear and matter-of-fact, and her worldbuilding is novel enough to be exciting without being so complex as to need a separate wiki to keep up. And when I reached the end, I was surprised the book was over. There's still a lot of story left, several questions unanswered, and new complications and tension to keep readers hungry for the next one.
(I received an advanced copy of this book from the author for the purpose of this review, but my thoughts are my own.)
There is a lot of mention of sexual assault. I feel that needs to be said at the outset. The female main character is traumatized by verbal and physical abuse in her past. There is an SA scene (although it is interrupted before becoming graphic). The author does not shy away from the painful realities of prejudice, sexism, rape, or abuse. Nor does Vander Stelt romanticize them. Nor does she sensationalize them. They are present in the story, along with their human consequences. Readers will not feel coddled from harsh truths, nor will they feel bludgeoned by them.
Ren’wyn is a sympathetic main character. She's not a Mary Sue, by any means, and she endures tragedy with agency and emotion equally. She is strong in a way that feels earned and real and feminine. The men around her can sometimes feel one-dimensional, but their voices and actions are true to character, while also appropriately growing and changing.
The magic system is soft, tied to certain people inherently (think benders in ATLA or mutants in X-Men). There is a magic school, but so little time is spent there it's unclear what most of the magic education actually looks like. This isn't a bad thing. The story isn't about magical people mastering their power, necessarily. The story is about people doing what they can in an evil and broken world. Their magic is described vividly, emotively, and freely. If you're looking for specific spells or hard rules to magic, you won't find them here. You'll find people doing what they can.
Fans of the Supernatural series will enjoy Ren’wyn’s powers, I think. Her encounters with the Void are varied, evocative, and often cathartic. There are some horror elements described, but it's never grotesque or overwrought.
The romance in this book feels authentic. It's not smut, and the descriptions of intimate acts are not overly graphic or suggestive. The characters and the plot are usually in the foreground. And the intimacy is just as often about comfort and care as it is about release or recreation. There's no pornographic vocabulary or language.
Overall, I found myself caring about the characters as I was whisked through their adventure. Admittedly, the first several chapters were slower, full of vignettes to help us understand Ren’wyn’s painful life. The actual plot doesn't pick up until later. That being said, the author doesn't belabor her scenes or descriptions with extra details, and there was no purple prose to slow things down. The writing is clear and matter-of-fact, and her worldbuilding is novel enough to be exciting without being so complex as to need a separate wiki to keep up. And when I reached the end, I was surprised the book was over. There's still a lot of story left, several questions unanswered, and new complications and tension to keep readers hungry for the next one.
(I received an advanced copy of this book from the author for the purpose of this review, but my thoughts are my own.)
August 31, 2025
I received an advance review copy for free, and i am leaving this review voluntairly .
Thanks to booksirens and the author for this arc.
I loved this book. In a world full of magical creatures there we meet Ren’wyn. A young woman who is abused by her father and forced in an arranged marriage to a horrible monster. An evening she finds the courage and strenght to run.
And that point she meets Fael. He helps her en protects her. They find out their magic has a connection, even though she a dark mage and he a beserker. Together they go on a journey. They develop thrust and learn from each other that develops in a friendship. After a while they start to develop feelings for each other. I love their relationship. Its goes from trust to friendship and ends up in true love for them both.
Ren’wyn had a really difficult past, and because she is abused and told on repeat by her father she is nothing and not good enough. It is extremely difficult to believe youre enough when someone tells you day in day out your not good enough, and its worse when its a parent who should love you no matter what. Through out the book you see Ren’wyn struggels with it. She grows through the book, there are moment she does not believe in her self and how closer we get trough the book you see how she grows and starts to believe in her self. Her relationship with Fael makes her stronger, he loves her and he is her rock. He never shows fear and always believes in her. His strenght and love gives her the strenght and power to believe in her self.
I love that they find themself and founded family with other magical creatures who want to safe the world. I love how the bonds grow, how they do anything to protect each other. And that they want a different world, a world that is safe again for anyone with magic.
The ending?? What a twist! Secrets about Fael gets out in the open. What will happen now that he sacrificed himself to safe the others? The heartbreak that Ren’wyn had to go trough when they had to leave him behind.
I cant wait for the second book, i am counting down the days. This book is one of my favorite reads this year and i cant wait for more books written by the author.
Can i have book 2 right now ? 🫣
So if you love books about magic, the supernatural, touch her and die vibes? This is the book for you!
I am not great in writing long reviews, so i hope this is okay! ☺️
Thanks to booksirens and the author for this arc.
I loved this book. In a world full of magical creatures there we meet Ren’wyn. A young woman who is abused by her father and forced in an arranged marriage to a horrible monster. An evening she finds the courage and strenght to run.
And that point she meets Fael. He helps her en protects her. They find out their magic has a connection, even though she a dark mage and he a beserker. Together they go on a journey. They develop thrust and learn from each other that develops in a friendship. After a while they start to develop feelings for each other. I love their relationship. Its goes from trust to friendship and ends up in true love for them both.
Ren’wyn had a really difficult past, and because she is abused and told on repeat by her father she is nothing and not good enough. It is extremely difficult to believe youre enough when someone tells you day in day out your not good enough, and its worse when its a parent who should love you no matter what. Through out the book you see Ren’wyn struggels with it. She grows through the book, there are moment she does not believe in her self and how closer we get trough the book you see how she grows and starts to believe in her self. Her relationship with Fael makes her stronger, he loves her and he is her rock. He never shows fear and always believes in her. His strenght and love gives her the strenght and power to believe in her self.
I love that they find themself and founded family with other magical creatures who want to safe the world. I love how the bonds grow, how they do anything to protect each other. And that they want a different world, a world that is safe again for anyone with magic.
The ending?? What a twist! Secrets about Fael gets out in the open. What will happen now that he sacrificed himself to safe the others? The heartbreak that Ren’wyn had to go trough when they had to leave him behind.
I cant wait for the second book, i am counting down the days. This book is one of my favorite reads this year and i cant wait for more books written by the author.
Can i have book 2 right now ? 🫣
So if you love books about magic, the supernatural, touch her and die vibes? This is the book for you!
I am not great in writing long reviews, so i hope this is okay! ☺️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 11, 2025
I don't typically read a lot of fantasy, so it took me a couple of chapters to settle into the world Vander Stelt created. However, the psychic, physical, and emotional challenges faced by the main character, Ren'wyn, soon drew me in. The "strangeness" of her arcane power was a surprise and sometimes a challenge to reconcile with her tender nature. It was interesting to see how the author balanced those tensions in Ren'wyn. Likewise, the frenzied force dwelling in Ren'wyn's love interest (no spoilers) contrasted in unexpected ways to his care for her and other characters.
Initially, I found Ren'wyn's lover a little too understanding and Ren'wyn too emotionally fragile for my taste, but their backstories provide rationales for those tendencies, adding nice layering to the story. I thought the way the author knitted together their supernatural forces and personal struggles was especially creative.
I thoroughly enjoyed the varied landscapes and cultures the characters moved through. I also found the challenges they faced satisfyingly unpredictable and appropriately menacing. There were frequent nods to perennial themes of injustice woven through the narrative, but they didn't feel forced. (If the love scenes were less heated and violence less graphic, this would be a great YA read.)
I looked forward to spending time in Vander Stelt's world as I read and wasn't ready for the book to end. I applaud the author for a well written and engaging first book and look forward to reading more of her work.
I received an advance copy of this book from the author. This review is voluntary and honest.
Initially, I found Ren'wyn's lover a little too understanding and Ren'wyn too emotionally fragile for my taste, but their backstories provide rationales for those tendencies, adding nice layering to the story. I thought the way the author knitted together their supernatural forces and personal struggles was especially creative.
I thoroughly enjoyed the varied landscapes and cultures the characters moved through. I also found the challenges they faced satisfyingly unpredictable and appropriately menacing. There were frequent nods to perennial themes of injustice woven through the narrative, but they didn't feel forced. (If the love scenes were less heated and violence less graphic, this would be a great YA read.)
I looked forward to spending time in Vander Stelt's world as I read and wasn't ready for the book to end. I applaud the author for a well written and engaging first book and look forward to reading more of her work.
I received an advance copy of this book from the author. This review is voluntary and honest.
August 11, 2025
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Thank you, Erin!
This was a well written (I was impressed for a debut ARC that I only saw a couple continuity errors but nothing major) romantasy with an interesting magic system and intriguing characters that was an easy read. However, it wasn’t exactly my cup of tea. I think there will be lots of people out there who will love this book though!
For me, it was a little bit too romance heavy without enough stakes for the plot outside of the romance to keep me super interested (although the ending was wild, and I think it’s set up to have a good sequel). But if you love spicy, you will definitely love this. I was also frustrated by Ren’wyn quite a bit. You definitely see some growth in her confidence and strength throughout the book, but she is SO reliant on the men in her life and I was shouting the whole time for her to be a strong independent woman. I think she’s getting there though, and I liked how Fael encouraged it out of her. I also got confused by the magic system at times, but like I said I enjoyed the uniqueness of it and hopefully as the series progresses more understanding will come. I liked how the world building was done! Overall, I’m glad I got the chance to read it and would encourage those who like romance, magic (especially shadow magic), a traveling group, fight scenes and a smidge of a school setting in books to read it.
Content warnings: sexual assault, abuse, violence/death, open door explicit intimacy scenes
This was a well written (I was impressed for a debut ARC that I only saw a couple continuity errors but nothing major) romantasy with an interesting magic system and intriguing characters that was an easy read. However, it wasn’t exactly my cup of tea. I think there will be lots of people out there who will love this book though!
For me, it was a little bit too romance heavy without enough stakes for the plot outside of the romance to keep me super interested (although the ending was wild, and I think it’s set up to have a good sequel). But if you love spicy, you will definitely love this. I was also frustrated by Ren’wyn quite a bit. You definitely see some growth in her confidence and strength throughout the book, but she is SO reliant on the men in her life and I was shouting the whole time for her to be a strong independent woman. I think she’s getting there though, and I liked how Fael encouraged it out of her. I also got confused by the magic system at times, but like I said I enjoyed the uniqueness of it and hopefully as the series progresses more understanding will come. I liked how the world building was done! Overall, I’m glad I got the chance to read it and would encourage those who like romance, magic (especially shadow magic), a traveling group, fight scenes and a smidge of a school setting in books to read it.
Content warnings: sexual assault, abuse, violence/death, open door explicit intimacy scenes
October 9, 2025
The Dark Mage is a fantasy romance with a strong focus on the fantasy element, following the story of Ren, a dark mage in a world where magic is forbidden and those who wield it are hunted and killed.
This book feels like a long journey of growth, self-discovery, and empowerment. Ren possesses a rare and dangerous power—one feared even by other magical beings—that she tries to keep hidden and under control. But when circumstances force her hand, she must step up, fight for herself, and finally trust in her own strength and magic. Along the way, Fael—the soldier who steals her heart—helps her believe in herself.
A lot happens in this story, the pacing is quick, and it’s satisfying to watch Ren’s personal development unfold. The romance between her and Fael is sweet and reassuring, bringing a tender balance to the darker and heavier themes running through the plot. If you enjoyed Auren’s story in The Plated Prisoner Series, I think you’ll also appreciate this one.
At times, some of the dynamics and relationships felt a little youthful, but overall, I still enjoyed the characters. And that ending… wow. I really didn’t see it coming—it completely surprised me, and now I can’t wait to pick up the sequel.
Side note: Ren’s power is epic. Finally, a true Shadow Girl! The scenes where she unleashes her magic gave me chills—intense, graphic, and absolutely badass.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Tropes:
⚜️ Slow burn
⚜️ Morally grey
⚜️ Magic
⚜️ Found family
⚜️ Emotional trauma
⚜️ Protective MMC
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
This book feels like a long journey of growth, self-discovery, and empowerment. Ren possesses a rare and dangerous power—one feared even by other magical beings—that she tries to keep hidden and under control. But when circumstances force her hand, she must step up, fight for herself, and finally trust in her own strength and magic. Along the way, Fael—the soldier who steals her heart—helps her believe in herself.
A lot happens in this story, the pacing is quick, and it’s satisfying to watch Ren’s personal development unfold. The romance between her and Fael is sweet and reassuring, bringing a tender balance to the darker and heavier themes running through the plot. If you enjoyed Auren’s story in The Plated Prisoner Series, I think you’ll also appreciate this one.
At times, some of the dynamics and relationships felt a little youthful, but overall, I still enjoyed the characters. And that ending… wow. I really didn’t see it coming—it completely surprised me, and now I can’t wait to pick up the sequel.
Side note: Ren’s power is epic. Finally, a true Shadow Girl! The scenes where she unleashes her magic gave me chills—intense, graphic, and absolutely badass.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Tropes:
⚜️ Slow burn
⚜️ Morally grey
⚜️ Magic
⚜️ Found family
⚜️ Emotional trauma
⚜️ Protective MMC
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
August 28, 2025
Ughhh this book 😭😭
I’m not gonna lie, I struggled to get into it at first. It’s written in third person which I wasn’t prepared for. I find third person books a lot tougher to connect with the characters. BUT it’s my fault for not checking or researching the writing style! I did struggle with the first 20% of the book. So much happens and it’s a little difficult to follow at times, but I’m so glad I persevered 😭
Ren’wyn is such a beautiful character. I love that she’s flawed, we see the development that’s not picture perfect. It’s a little ugly, it’s not linear, there’s a lot of back and forth which is real. It’s how a lot of people grow and heal in the real world which is what drew me to her. I love her so much 😭
Ren’wyn’s romance with Fael was one of my absolute fave parts of this book. It’s slow, it’s relatable and it’s one that’s built on pure love and not lust. I love how Fael treats her and my heart was SWOONING 😭 I rooted for them so much. I love them.
The only part of the story that I found a little confusing after finishing was the magic academy. I feel like we don’t see enough of it and I’d love to know more about it!
Also, Erin - there had better be a book 2 because I NEEEEEED to know what happens next 😍
I received an advance reader copy of The Dark Mage from Booksirens and the author. All of these views are my own and this review is voluntary. Thank you Erin! 🖤
I’m not gonna lie, I struggled to get into it at first. It’s written in third person which I wasn’t prepared for. I find third person books a lot tougher to connect with the characters. BUT it’s my fault for not checking or researching the writing style! I did struggle with the first 20% of the book. So much happens and it’s a little difficult to follow at times, but I’m so glad I persevered 😭
Ren’wyn is such a beautiful character. I love that she’s flawed, we see the development that’s not picture perfect. It’s a little ugly, it’s not linear, there’s a lot of back and forth which is real. It’s how a lot of people grow and heal in the real world which is what drew me to her. I love her so much 😭
Ren’wyn’s romance with Fael was one of my absolute fave parts of this book. It’s slow, it’s relatable and it’s one that’s built on pure love and not lust. I love how Fael treats her and my heart was SWOONING 😭 I rooted for them so much. I love them.
The only part of the story that I found a little confusing after finishing was the magic academy. I feel like we don’t see enough of it and I’d love to know more about it!
Also, Erin - there had better be a book 2 because I NEEEEEED to know what happens next 😍
I received an advance reader copy of The Dark Mage from Booksirens and the author. All of these views are my own and this review is voluntary. Thank you Erin! 🖤
September 2, 2025
Romance, Magic, Female Empowerment--what more could you want from a new Romantasy? And, I do mean new.
Vander Stelt takes what is known of the popular romantasy genre and creates a new version of it, in a way that is fresh. In a formula-ridden genre, The Dark Mage is a breath of fresh air. Below are a few of my non-spoiler favorite quotes:
"Magic, in its rawest form, was woven into the fabric of the world, manifesting differently through those born with its power."
"...until fear, pain, and shame were drowned beneath purpose."
"A small, foreign voice whispered its contentment, but Ren'wyn smothered it, killing hope before it could endanger her safety."
"Nothing you believe about me will change who I am or what I'm worth. I am good and gentle and strong and vicious..."
And, my favorite: "Wounds, especially deep ones, change us. Sometimes they sharpen the edges of who we already are, making us truer versions of ourselves. Other times, we shatter completely. And when that happens, we're left piecing together what we can, filling the gaps with the new self we create."
I'm looking forward to book two!
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Vander Stelt takes what is known of the popular romantasy genre and creates a new version of it, in a way that is fresh. In a formula-ridden genre, The Dark Mage is a breath of fresh air. Below are a few of my non-spoiler favorite quotes:
"Magic, in its rawest form, was woven into the fabric of the world, manifesting differently through those born with its power."
"...until fear, pain, and shame were drowned beneath purpose."
"A small, foreign voice whispered its contentment, but Ren'wyn smothered it, killing hope before it could endanger her safety."
"Nothing you believe about me will change who I am or what I'm worth. I am good and gentle and strong and vicious..."
And, my favorite: "Wounds, especially deep ones, change us. Sometimes they sharpen the edges of who we already are, making us truer versions of ourselves. Other times, we shatter completely. And when that happens, we're left piecing together what we can, filling the gaps with the new self we create."
I'm looking forward to book two!
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
September 2, 2025
Ren’wyn is a Dark Mage, a reviled and misunderstood type of magic user, in a world where magic is persecuted and hunted down. She’s trapped between the small freedom of her school and an arranged marriage to an abusive man and, when one avenue of escape fails, she runs, encountering a strange man in the Dark Forest.
This book wasn’t for me. I had a brief moment of joy with Ren’wyn learning to control her magic by battling shades with her teacher at the beginning of the story but the rest felt strange. It isn’t exactly passive voice, but passive events? Things were happening but nothing impacted and Ren’wyn remained dependent on whichever man was closest to her right up until the end of the book. The prophecy was introduced too late for it to make any impact on the first book and the reveal was obvious from the character’s introduction. Ren’wyn is inconsistent with her reactions, showing superb skill in her herbal knowledge and abilities, but flying off the handle and becoming wracked with self doubt with no provocation.
The side characters’ impact were minimal, in that I couldn’t remember their names for longer than a few sentences. The addition of a lesbian couple after one of them had been raped and the other is assumed to have been raped prior to the story start is questionable, given that they’re the only queer characters in the book.
It is trying to do too much and ends with a variable pacing with some events glossed over in a few staggered sentences and others drawn out over chapters. The romance is solid, I’ll give the story that, but Ren’wyn as a lead failed to deliver.
Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the ARC.
This book wasn’t for me. I had a brief moment of joy with Ren’wyn learning to control her magic by battling shades with her teacher at the beginning of the story but the rest felt strange. It isn’t exactly passive voice, but passive events? Things were happening but nothing impacted and Ren’wyn remained dependent on whichever man was closest to her right up until the end of the book. The prophecy was introduced too late for it to make any impact on the first book and the reveal was obvious from the character’s introduction. Ren’wyn is inconsistent with her reactions, showing superb skill in her herbal knowledge and abilities, but flying off the handle and becoming wracked with self doubt with no provocation.
The side characters’ impact were minimal, in that I couldn’t remember their names for longer than a few sentences. The addition of a lesbian couple after one of them had been raped and the other is assumed to have been raped prior to the story start is questionable, given that they’re the only queer characters in the book.
It is trying to do too much and ends with a variable pacing with some events glossed over in a few staggered sentences and others drawn out over chapters. The romance is solid, I’ll give the story that, but Ren’wyn as a lead failed to deliver.
Thank you to BookSirens and the author for the ARC.
September 20, 2025
Spice Rating:🌶️🌶️🌶️
This is an excellent start to a fantasy series! It centers around a young woman with a rare death magic that lives in a world where magic is forbidden. After her father arranges her marriage to an abusive man, she finds the courage to run from the horribly oppressive life she has been living. She stumbles upon a powerful soldier who helps her get away and they make plans to help other magic people. The journey brings them closer together and they form friendships along the way, but it is not without tragedy.
I love all the characters and the different types of magic. I enjoyed the slow burn romance and loved that both characters helped each other grow. The FMC starts out timid but gains confidence and purpose during their journey. I felt this book provided the world building and character development needed for me to be invested in the series and cannot wait to continue it. The ending was so shocking and I absolutely did not see it coming!
TW: Off page assaults
💋 Kisses Only
🫑-🫑🫑🫑 Steamy/Closed Door
🌶️-🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Spicy/Open Door
This is an excellent start to a fantasy series! It centers around a young woman with a rare death magic that lives in a world where magic is forbidden. After her father arranges her marriage to an abusive man, she finds the courage to run from the horribly oppressive life she has been living. She stumbles upon a powerful soldier who helps her get away and they make plans to help other magic people. The journey brings them closer together and they form friendships along the way, but it is not without tragedy.
I love all the characters and the different types of magic. I enjoyed the slow burn romance and loved that both characters helped each other grow. The FMC starts out timid but gains confidence and purpose during their journey. I felt this book provided the world building and character development needed for me to be invested in the series and cannot wait to continue it. The ending was so shocking and I absolutely did not see it coming!
TW: Off page assaults
💋 Kisses Only
🫑-🫑🫑🫑 Steamy/Closed Door
🌶️-🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Spicy/Open Door
August 15, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ vibes | 🌶️ spice
Tropes: Forbidden Magic · Touch Her and Die · Found Family
Trigger Warnings: abuse, SA, mental health
I received a free ARC of this book via NetGalley. Thank you for the opportunity!
This was a strong start to a series — forbidden magic, immersive world-building, and a found family dynamic. The FMC begins as meek and fearful, but watching her grow into her strength and claim her power is incredibly satisfying.
I’ll be honest — the first three chapters tested my patience, and I nearly put the book down because of how frustrating I found the FMC’s initial passivity. But I’m so glad I stuck with it. The payoff was worth every page, and the character arc was beautifully executed.
The ending delivered an unexpected twist that hooked me completely, and now I’m counting the days until book two.
Tropes: Forbidden Magic · Touch Her and Die · Found Family
Trigger Warnings: abuse, SA, mental health
I received a free ARC of this book via NetGalley. Thank you for the opportunity!
This was a strong start to a series — forbidden magic, immersive world-building, and a found family dynamic. The FMC begins as meek and fearful, but watching her grow into her strength and claim her power is incredibly satisfying.
I’ll be honest — the first three chapters tested my patience, and I nearly put the book down because of how frustrating I found the FMC’s initial passivity. But I’m so glad I stuck with it. The payoff was worth every page, and the character arc was beautifully executed.
The ending delivered an unexpected twist that hooked me completely, and now I’m counting the days until book two.
August 9, 2025
I received an advance copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
The bones of this book is very interesting and was fun to read. This book is fast paced and engaging and an easy/bingeable read. I just felt like I needed more… the traumatic experiences for the characters were glossed over (we never have time to process or learn about the abuse they’ve been through), I wanted more depth from the characters and plot, and I wished for a little more information and understanding about the magic system. I think this will turn into a great series if it’s just a bit more fleshed out! Thank you to Erin for giving me a chance to read your hard work!
The bones of this book is very interesting and was fun to read. This book is fast paced and engaging and an easy/bingeable read. I just felt like I needed more… the traumatic experiences for the characters were glossed over (we never have time to process or learn about the abuse they’ve been through), I wanted more depth from the characters and plot, and I wished for a little more information and understanding about the magic system. I think this will turn into a great series if it’s just a bit more fleshed out! Thank you to Erin for giving me a chance to read your hard work!
August 22, 2025
I received an advanced copy for an honest review of this book. Thank you Erin! I enjoyed this whole book! However, there had better be a second one coming because I have to find out what happens next. I absolutely fell in love with Fael and Ren’wyn’s relationship and the whole crew. Each character was very well thought out and made me love each individual differently. My love for Esrin was a bit up and down though to be honest. Thank you for writing a book I thoroughly enjoyed reading! 5 stars! I will be buying a hard physical copy as well!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 28, 2025
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
WOW what a ride. This book was a beautiful story of our FMC Ren'wyn fighting for a life that was her own. Ren'wyn was raised by a horrible father who betrothed her to a horrible man. This story is about magic, love, female rage, a system that wants to rid the world of people who have magic. This is a beautiful love story that ends on an epic cliffhanger. I loved the journey of Ren'wyn, Erin and Fael and CANNOT wait for book 2!
WOW what a ride. This book was a beautiful story of our FMC Ren'wyn fighting for a life that was her own. Ren'wyn was raised by a horrible father who betrothed her to a horrible man. This story is about magic, love, female rage, a system that wants to rid the world of people who have magic. This is a beautiful love story that ends on an epic cliffhanger. I loved the journey of Ren'wyn, Erin and Fael and CANNOT wait for book 2!
August 13, 2025
I received an advanced copy of this book. It took me a while to become engaged but once I did it was hard to put down. I especially enjoyed the characters and it was Ren’wyn that drove my interest. Watching her grow through the story was the best part of this magical tale!
August 25, 2025
A girl who has been told she is worthless all her life, a prince who loves her but is terrified of her power, and a soldier who regrets the throne he works for.
Nicely set up for a very intriguing story line.
Arc reader
Nicely set up for a very intriguing story line.
Arc reader
October 18, 2025
I hope there’s a sequel coming soon, because I really came to care about these characters, their individual growth, and their joint mission, but the journey’s clearly not yet complete. Looking forward to their next adventures!
November 23, 2025
THAT. ENDING.
I had my suspicions, but nothing, absolutely nothing, prepared me for the way this story detonated in the final pages. The yearning, the angst, the delicious tension simmering through every chapter? Unmatched. And the found family dynamics? Easily one of the brightest highlights of the entire journey.
This book is the fierce transformation of a woman who has spent her life shrinking herself. Quiet, obedient, hidden away, only to discover she was never meant to be small. Watching her break out of the cage she didn’t even know she was in and step into her strength, her fire, her capability? it’s empowering, emotional, and inspiring.
It’s a story of becoming. Of finding herself, embracing every piece of who she is, and learning to love the woman she’s finally allowed to be. Allowing herself to own her powers, and what is she is regardless of the stigma and prejudice people have towards her.
And the love in this book? The sacrifice? The betrayal that slices through you when you least expect it? I’m still reeling. Just when you think things are finally starting to heal, when hope begins to bloom again, it’s ripped away.
So excited for book two!!
I had my suspicions, but nothing, absolutely nothing, prepared me for the way this story detonated in the final pages. The yearning, the angst, the delicious tension simmering through every chapter? Unmatched. And the found family dynamics? Easily one of the brightest highlights of the entire journey.
This book is the fierce transformation of a woman who has spent her life shrinking herself. Quiet, obedient, hidden away, only to discover she was never meant to be small. Watching her break out of the cage she didn’t even know she was in and step into her strength, her fire, her capability? it’s empowering, emotional, and inspiring.
It’s a story of becoming. Of finding herself, embracing every piece of who she is, and learning to love the woman she’s finally allowed to be. Allowing herself to own her powers, and what is she is regardless of the stigma and prejudice people have towards her.
And the love in this book? The sacrifice? The betrayal that slices through you when you least expect it? I’m still reeling. Just when you think things are finally starting to heal, when hope begins to bloom again, it’s ripped away.
So excited for book two!!
August 17, 2025
I received an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Overall, I really enjoyed the magic system and overall plot of the story. This is definitely a book for people who like romance set in a fantasy world.
The beginning of the book felt rushed and wish we had a bit more back story of some side characters and the general setting that the book starts in. The middle could have been shortened/structured a bit differently so all of the travel and time jumps flowed a bit better and so there was room for more world building/plot throughout the book.
I would have liked a bit more depth in the main characters to make them a bit more relatable and likable. I found myself getting annoyed at them throughout most of the book. I did like the twist at the end and maybe just didn’t see the foreshadowing, but wished there were more hints throughout so it wasn’t so out of left field. Or wish we had more time or buildup to experience that part of the story rather than it being right at the end.
Overall, I really enjoyed the magic system and overall plot of the story. This is definitely a book for people who like romance set in a fantasy world.
The beginning of the book felt rushed and wish we had a bit more back story of some side characters and the general setting that the book starts in. The middle could have been shortened/structured a bit differently so all of the travel and time jumps flowed a bit better and so there was room for more world building/plot throughout the book.
I would have liked a bit more depth in the main characters to make them a bit more relatable and likable. I found myself getting annoyed at them throughout most of the book. I did like the twist at the end and maybe just didn’t see the foreshadowing, but wished there were more hints throughout so it wasn’t so out of left field. Or wish we had more time or buildup to experience that part of the story rather than it being right at the end.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 27, 2025
I received an advanced copy for my honest review, Erin-- I am so glad to have been an ARC reader for you!
I absolutely devoured The Dark Mage. The world-building is imaginative and immersive, drawing you in so completely it feels like stepping into another reality. Instead of relying on heavy exposition, the story unfolds naturally through action, dialogue, and subtle detail, making it both vivid and compulsively readable.
The pacing strikes a perfect balance—moments of mystery, danger, and adventure are interwoven with quiet, reflective scenes that give the characters (and the reader) space to breathe. That rhythm makes the story feel grounded while keeping the pages turning.
Ren’wyn is a standout heroine. So often in fantasy, female protagonists are written as either naïve and untested or defined only by the men around them. Ren’wyn is neither. She enters the story already grounded in her power, confident in her identity, and capable of holding her own. Yet that doesn’t mean she is without struggle. She wrestles with the weight and the responsibility of her power, more importantly, with the search for greater purpose. That duality—strength paired with vulnerability—makes her not only believable but also deeply relatable. She’s not a character who needs rescuing—you root for her because you see pieces of yourself in her.
Her relationship with Fael only deepens this authenticity. Their love is breathtaking—timeless and intriguing, yet so grounded in truth that it feels utterly real. It adds an emotional richness to the story that makes the stakes even higher and the journey all the more unforgettable.
The supporting cast is equally well-drawn, each character distinct and memorable, their own individual powers woven seamlessly into the fabric of the world. The magic system feels natural and purposeful, adding intrigue without ever overwhelming the story. And the plot—full of twists and revelations—kept me guessing right up to the end, something few fantasy novels manage to do.
What stays with me most are the passages that linger long after reading, moments that feel both fresh and unforgettable. The Dark Mage is more than just a fantasy adventure—it’s a story that sweeps you up, stirs your heart, and makes you reflect on your own journey of identity and purpose. It’s the rare kind of book that entertains in the moment and resonates long after you’ve turned the last page.
I absolutely devoured The Dark Mage. The world-building is imaginative and immersive, drawing you in so completely it feels like stepping into another reality. Instead of relying on heavy exposition, the story unfolds naturally through action, dialogue, and subtle detail, making it both vivid and compulsively readable.
The pacing strikes a perfect balance—moments of mystery, danger, and adventure are interwoven with quiet, reflective scenes that give the characters (and the reader) space to breathe. That rhythm makes the story feel grounded while keeping the pages turning.
Ren’wyn is a standout heroine. So often in fantasy, female protagonists are written as either naïve and untested or defined only by the men around them. Ren’wyn is neither. She enters the story already grounded in her power, confident in her identity, and capable of holding her own. Yet that doesn’t mean she is without struggle. She wrestles with the weight and the responsibility of her power, more importantly, with the search for greater purpose. That duality—strength paired with vulnerability—makes her not only believable but also deeply relatable. She’s not a character who needs rescuing—you root for her because you see pieces of yourself in her.
Her relationship with Fael only deepens this authenticity. Their love is breathtaking—timeless and intriguing, yet so grounded in truth that it feels utterly real. It adds an emotional richness to the story that makes the stakes even higher and the journey all the more unforgettable.
The supporting cast is equally well-drawn, each character distinct and memorable, their own individual powers woven seamlessly into the fabric of the world. The magic system feels natural and purposeful, adding intrigue without ever overwhelming the story. And the plot—full of twists and revelations—kept me guessing right up to the end, something few fantasy novels manage to do.
What stays with me most are the passages that linger long after reading, moments that feel both fresh and unforgettable. The Dark Mage is more than just a fantasy adventure—it’s a story that sweeps you up, stirs your heart, and makes you reflect on your own journey of identity and purpose. It’s the rare kind of book that entertains in the moment and resonates long after you’ve turned the last page.
September 9, 2025
Thank you to #BookSirens and Erin Vander Stelt for the free digital ARC. I’m voluntarily leaving this honest review.
The Dark Mage had all the elements I usually look for in a romantasy:
- An underestimated FMC who comes into her own (potent) power
- An adoring MMC whose strength complements hers
- Intriguing magic
- Supportive side characters with strong relationships
- Formidable villains
- Solid premise
- A plot twist with a real cliffhanger
While I enjoyed the book, it felt underdeveloped and left me with a lot of questions. I wanted more backstory to give context to the story’s circumstances: the suppression of magic, what outsiders believe the school is, how it functions, and what became of it after the three friends parted ways. Overall, the world building felt thin.
I also struggled to connect with the characters. Without witnessing intimate moments, many of the relationships lacked depth. Too often I was told about conversations instead of experiencing them, which kept me at a distance. For example: “As they walked after breakfast, Fael mentioned his hope of… He believed the greatest change would come from…” This would have been more powerful as direct dialogue. Interactions often leaned on adjectives rather than immersive, sensory details. For instance: “His tongue was hot, wet, and slow as he softly bit her sensitive, pale skin.”
The beginning had a solid build-up, and the ending left me intrigued, but the middle felt stagnant.
All in all, the book has strong bones and a lot of potential as the story continues.
The Dark Mage had all the elements I usually look for in a romantasy:
- An underestimated FMC who comes into her own (potent) power
- An adoring MMC whose strength complements hers
- Intriguing magic
- Supportive side characters with strong relationships
- Formidable villains
- Solid premise
- A plot twist with a real cliffhanger
While I enjoyed the book, it felt underdeveloped and left me with a lot of questions. I wanted more backstory to give context to the story’s circumstances: the suppression of magic, what outsiders believe the school is, how it functions, and what became of it after the three friends parted ways. Overall, the world building felt thin.
I also struggled to connect with the characters. Without witnessing intimate moments, many of the relationships lacked depth. Too often I was told about conversations instead of experiencing them, which kept me at a distance. For example: “As they walked after breakfast, Fael mentioned his hope of… He believed the greatest change would come from…” This would have been more powerful as direct dialogue. Interactions often leaned on adjectives rather than immersive, sensory details. For instance: “His tongue was hot, wet, and slow as he softly bit her sensitive, pale skin.”
The beginning had a solid build-up, and the ending left me intrigued, but the middle felt stagnant.
All in all, the book has strong bones and a lot of potential as the story continues.
December 7, 2025
🕯For the ones who carry darkness gently and call it their own 🖤
There’s something so refreshing about a book that trusts its readers. One that lets you step into the story the same way the characters do: gradually, instinctively, and with your senses waking to its magic.
"The Dark Mage" by Erin Vander Stelt does exactly that. The magic, the longing, the shadowed world-building; it all unfolds at a pace that feels lived in, not performed. There’s a softness here that feels rare in romantasy as of late and it has been such a joy revisiting it.
We follow Ren’wyn, a heroine shaped by misunderstanding and harm, yet never defined by it. Her magic isn’t a spectacle - it is the Void itself: an ancient, aware presence woven through her body and memory. It recognizes her even when others don’t, teaching her that her strength has always come from within.
The romance moves with that same quiet confidence. No grand declarations or melodrama. Just presence, patience, and the slow realization of being seen. Love here is gentle, but never weak. It grows the way in which real connection often does: slowly, and then undeniably.
The emotional tone reminded me of Anne Bishop's writing. Stories where darkness has depth, magic feels sentient, and love shifts something inside the characters, not just around them.
If you’re craving a romantasy novel that takes its time, letting magic matter, and romance gather warmth, this is the story to sink into.
💬 Tell me in the comments below - what are you craving more of from romantasy these days?
There’s something so refreshing about a book that trusts its readers. One that lets you step into the story the same way the characters do: gradually, instinctively, and with your senses waking to its magic.
"The Dark Mage" by Erin Vander Stelt does exactly that. The magic, the longing, the shadowed world-building; it all unfolds at a pace that feels lived in, not performed. There’s a softness here that feels rare in romantasy as of late and it has been such a joy revisiting it.
We follow Ren’wyn, a heroine shaped by misunderstanding and harm, yet never defined by it. Her magic isn’t a spectacle - it is the Void itself: an ancient, aware presence woven through her body and memory. It recognizes her even when others don’t, teaching her that her strength has always come from within.
The romance moves with that same quiet confidence. No grand declarations or melodrama. Just presence, patience, and the slow realization of being seen. Love here is gentle, but never weak. It grows the way in which real connection often does: slowly, and then undeniably.
The emotional tone reminded me of Anne Bishop's writing. Stories where darkness has depth, magic feels sentient, and love shifts something inside the characters, not just around them.
If you’re craving a romantasy novel that takes its time, letting magic matter, and romance gather warmth, this is the story to sink into.
💬 Tell me in the comments below - what are you craving more of from romantasy these days?
September 27, 2025
3.5⭐️ rounded up
I enjoyed the overall story here, and the world Erin Vander Stelt created is really interesting. There’s a lot of potential in the magic system and the politics surrounding it, and the ending definitely managed to surprise me. I did not see that twist coming! I’m curious to see where things go from here and to how that twist will play out.
That said, Ren’wyn as a character did frustrate me at times. She has this immense power, but still sees herself as nothing throughout the entire book. Given her past, it makes sense, but after a while it wore on me. On the flip side, I really liked her relationship with Fael. He was a solid balance for her and their dynamic worked well. Their connection gave the book some much-needed warmth and heart.
Overall, while it leaned more YA in tone than I expected (aside from the spice), it still kept me interested. If you like YA fantasy with a dash of romance, found family, and a heroine finding her confidence, this one might be worth checking out.
Thank you to Erin Vander Stelt for sending me a copy!
I enjoyed the overall story here, and the world Erin Vander Stelt created is really interesting. There’s a lot of potential in the magic system and the politics surrounding it, and the ending definitely managed to surprise me. I did not see that twist coming! I’m curious to see where things go from here and to how that twist will play out.
That said, Ren’wyn as a character did frustrate me at times. She has this immense power, but still sees herself as nothing throughout the entire book. Given her past, it makes sense, but after a while it wore on me. On the flip side, I really liked her relationship with Fael. He was a solid balance for her and their dynamic worked well. Their connection gave the book some much-needed warmth and heart.
Overall, while it leaned more YA in tone than I expected (aside from the spice), it still kept me interested. If you like YA fantasy with a dash of romance, found family, and a heroine finding her confidence, this one might be worth checking out.
Thank you to Erin Vander Stelt for sending me a copy!
August 24, 2025
I received an early copy of The Dark Mage in exchange for an honest review, and I was pulled in from the start. Ren’wyn’s journey as a young woman hiding her forbidden magic while surviving an abusive arranged marriage is raw, emotional, and powerful. Ren’wyn’s growth from fearful to empowered felt authentic, and her relationships with Fael and Esrin added layers of tension and heart. The romance elements blended naturally with the darker themes of trauma, resilience, and identity, giving the story real emotional weight. Overall, The Dark Mage is a character-driven fantasy with dark magic, romance, and a heroine worth rooting for. A strong debut—I’m looking forward to what Erin Vander Stelt writes next.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews