Starred Review from Publishers Weekly. “This urgent work infuses hope and humanity into divisive politics without downplaying the devastating costs of gun violence.”
Starred Review from Booklist. “Deftly balancing facts and emotions, Kerwin bears illuminating haunting witness.”
A work of comics journalism around the stories of four kids who have died in the U.S. due to gun violence or gun negligence—the leading cause of death for minors since 2020, and dispelling myths of the history of gun culture in the U.S.
Who have we lost? How did we get here? Why do gun-lovers love their guns? These are the questions that people across America ask every time another news story broadcasts a death from gun violence.
With compassionate, thoughtful journalism, this graphic novel explores the lives of four kids and teenagers and the guns that ended their from incidents of gang violence to school shootings to suicide. These tragedies are presented alongside the history of gun culture and legislation, discussing the NRA, the legal system, and the racial imbalances in American gun violence.
Unforgettable graphic novel. Both sides of this divisive issue are treated with respect in this well researched and thoughtful book. No one becomes a caricature in this story. The 4 chosen victims, children of different ethnicities, become familiar through their charming peculiarities and humor. The heartbreak is in getting to know them. The words and touching drawings treat this most difficult of subjects with great empathy and dignity, And the background story of guns in America uncovers a surprising, and perhaps, hopeful perspective.
I was blown away by this thoughtful book. It did a beautiful job at discussing such a difficult topic and really speaking to the lives of the children and not just their final moments. Should be required reading.
Immensely moving. Beautifully written and illustrated, rigorously reported and researched. A remarkable book that I’ll be thinking about for years to come.
Remarkable. I bookmarked this on Edelweiss not entirely convinced--what could I learn from hearing, again, ad nauseum, about real children being shot and killed? Maybe Kerwin had the same thoughts, because this is not ONLY stories meant to tug at your heartstrings, but a wonderfully informative series of portraits of all sorts of people involved in the gun story of America. The modern children, but also wild west cowboys who perhaps weren't as gun-totin' as we think, NRA figureheads, atypical liberal gun owners, many figures wrapped up in history and the making of the future of guns. I learned a hell of a lot and my interest in the topic has been piqued.
A look into the world of guns, their history, and the results of violence. The author approaches the subject as someone whose stepfather was a gun owner and with whom she interacted. While it offers a mostly balanced look into the subject, the author leans left in some places.
I suspect that many readers may have a clear expectation of what they will find in Camila Kerwin’s new book Soft Targets: Guns in America and the Kids Caught in the Crossfire - a very personal study of guns and their child victims in America. But I think many will be surprised to find that the story is something other than what they expected. Soft Targets is a primarily a story about people; the millions of guns in America, as central as they are to the story, are actually in a way secondary.
The book takes an unexpected, heart wrenching (and somehow heartwarming) and very careful and disciplined path through a very complicated and painful topic.
The narrative is both personal and journalistic, following three paths as it explores the author’s own exposure to guns as a child (providing the roots of her connection to the story), the lives of four American children who died by guns - whether by homicide, suicide or accident, and the complex broader history of gun culture in America - a part of the story that is so full of surprising details that it may push readers to adjust their own positions on the difficult topic.
Maybe the most unexpected and welcome part of the book is how easily and closely we come to know those four children and several other individuals that together form the core of the story. The details of their lives, their families, their friends, their upbringing, and even their schools and neighborhoods are fully realized and almost novelistic. The tragically short lives of the four children are sketched especially deeply, and we come to know them so well and so quickly that one might welcome a book just about them.
By also fleshing out the details of the lives of some who are responsible for current institutions and gun policies, the book actually dispels many myths, and the twists and turns of the historical/cultural American story provide the wider, necessary and very clearly presented context of how we got to a place where more American children from ages one to seventeen die from guns than from anything else. This part of the story is driven deeply by evolution of the NRA - resulting in the massive and distorted problem that we suffer from today. But the author doesn’t limit her carefully balanced historical narrative to the NRA story alone, providing details about the earlier American gun story that will likely surprise you, elucidating the background of the famously murky phrasing of the Second Amendment, and clarifying how closely intertwined the lives of guns are in the experience of African Americans.
Soft Targets is a graphic narrative that couldn’t have been told any other way - the clever and beautiful drawings are essential to the experience. In its cinematic/graphic presentation, Soft Targets could easily be imagined as the basis for a documentary movie. As a unique choice, the author inserts herself gently throughout the story, depicting her own early experience with guns, as well as dramatizing her search for real information in her interviews with key figures in the more recent evolution of the gun story.
Soft Targets is a terrific addition to the growing genre of journalistic visual narrative, and brings to mind things like Maus, Persepolis, They Called Us Enemy and Palestine by Joe Sacco.
As someone who lives outside the United States but regularly follows the news, i am no stranger to the reality faced by thousands of people, especially children and teenagers, living there. I cannot imagine what it must be like to go to school, walk down the street, or simply spend time with a friend while knowing that your life could be threatened by a firearm.
This is a book that made me cry, made me laugh at times, and, above all, made me reflect. It is deeply unsettling to learn more about a reality that does not receive nearly enough attention. Through the stories of four children and teenagers whose lives were taken by gun violence, the book reminds us that behind every headline and every statistic, there is a human being with dreams, relationships, laughter, fears, and a future that was never given the chance to unfold.
By telling their stories, the book opens the door to a conversation that we should be having far more often. It is heartbreaking to think that children, from such an early age, have to come to terms with the idea that there is an object capable of ending their lives, whether in their own hands or someone else's.
I believe this is a book everyone should read. Although gun violence is an issue of enormous scale in the United States, no country should consider itself entirely removed from this reality. Unless we understand the history behind gun ownership, the lack of regulation, and the human stories behind these debates, we risk overlooking the conditions that could allow similar situations to emerge elsewhere.
Most importantly, I think we owe it to every person who has lost their life to gun violence to remember them as more than a victim or a statistic. Remember their names, their stories, and the lives they lived. Because remembering them, acknowledging what happened, and allowing their stories to be heard is also part of how we move forward and work towards a different future.
A remarkably well-researched and fascinating history of gun culture in the United States. Camila Kerwin shares historical facts and statistics, but centers the beauty of ordinary lives impacted by avoidable tragedy. Dynamic illustrations, heartbreaking details, and rich storytelling.
I wish we could hand this book out on street corners in Red States, and maybe to members of the NRA. In addition to depicting four racially diverse children killed by gun violence in beautiful, devastating detail, Kerwin shows that gun regulation has NOT always been a divisive issue, and doesn't have to stay one. In the Wild West, people checked their guns at the edge of town. The NRA was founded to help northerners become better shots, and was mostly a marksman club until the 1970s. And as with issues like abortion, most Americans are not as divided as the media and politicians would have us believe. Most people can agree that it makes sense to lock up guns and keep them away from children. Go figure.
This book is narrative non-fiction at its finest. It's clear that Kerwin dug deep into every aspect of the book: There's the surprising and little-known history of gun laws and cultures. There are perspectives from everyday people with varying views on guns. There's Kerwin's reflection on her own experience with guns. And of course, there are incredibly moving portraits of four kids killed by guns, told by their families. Kerwin has woven these threads together into a profound and impactful work of journalism and art. I'm recommending this book to everyone I know.