I read some of the negative reviews of The Wall by Jeff Long, and I know where people are coming from on some points like the ending. However I disagree with them. I give this book five stars. Here’s why:
First - the opening chapter was one of the…correction…it WAS the most gripping start to a book I have read.
Second - This story is original - at least it was for me. This is not a murder mystery, not a romance, not a fantasy, not a paranormal, not a let’s-blowup-the-White House (or such) for the hundredth time, not a medical drama, not a corrupt political or business drama, not a war movie, not a comedy, not a travelogue, not Sci-Fi and not literary.
It does have some mystery, romance, relationship struggles, and maybe…or maybe not…some paranormal aspects to it. My conclusion on that last one may be different than your conclusion. And, it definitely is not a travelogue. Except for flashbacks, it takes place almost exclusively on a vertical rock face on the side of a mountain. And yet it held my interest throughout. I knew nothing about mountain climbing, but it intrigued me, and still does. For me it was one of the most original stories I have read.
Third - I liked the characters and the premise. They were real and some were weird.
Fourth - It left me wanting more knowledge. It left me wanting to learn about climbing. I wanted to see actual pictures of how people sleep on the side of the mountain. It made me wonder what really propels people to attempt such feats, and to suffer such pain.
Fifth - It’s ending left me somewhat uncertain, questioning, yet strangely satisfied. This is where some other reviewers and I really part company. I don’t want this to be a spoiler. I’ll just say that after thinking about it, the ending was the only ending that was possible, or at least plausible - in my opinion. And that’s why the ending satisfied me. It made me question and think, after which, it made sense to me.