Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Afternoon Hours of a Hermit

Rate this book
A darkly funny and profoundly moving new novel by award-winning author Patrick Cottrell.

And who did I think I was, trying to teach the troubled youth how to write?...

I would say I was Dan Moran, a Korean adoptee, single, approaching forty, once plain-in-appearance as a woman, now ugly as a man, that’s who or what I thought I was.

Most importantly, I was no longer useless, I was a writer.

Five years after the death of his youngest brother, Dan Moran is now the published trans author of the autofictional novel Sorry to Disrupt the Peace. He is teaching fiction in Brooklyn and working on his next book–a psychological thriller–when a mysterious envelope arrives for him in the mail. Addressed to the wrong name, it includes a childhood photo of his deceased brother. But who would send such a thing, and why?

Against his better judgment, Dan returns to his childhood home on the eve of his brother’s memorial dinner. His estranged family is surprised to see him, but he ignores them. He drives around in his brother’s Honda Accord, believing he is a detective. He searches for a constellation of unidentified women who may have been involved with his brother, all while being mistaken for another man. He hopes his investigation will reveal exactly who he was to his brother, but in a series of unsettling and destabilizing encounters, what he discovers is the irrevocable distance between who we are and how we are perceived.

Afternoon Hours of a Hermit is Patrick Cottrell’s long-awaited second novel—an existential noir, an absurd comedy, a complex character study, and a heartbreaking inquiry into the paradox of identity, memory, and the very enterprise of writing fiction.

224 pages, Hardcover

First published April 21, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Patrick Cottrell

9 books250 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
103 (16%)
4 stars
143 (23%)
3 stars
218 (35%)
2 stars
108 (17%)
1 star
40 (6%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 157 reviews
Profile Image for Derek Driggs.
912 reviews95 followers
May 31, 2026
One of the more surprising books I’ve read all year, as I’d heard very little about it and picked it up somewhat randomly. But Cottrell seems to be the real deal, as they say. I loved his sentences and the way he constantly danced between tongue in cheek parody and real emotion. I liked the nods to more experimental postmodernists, especially Bernhard. I was really interested in the experience of being an international adoptee as well as a trans person and how deftly the narrator showed how his feelings around identity and perception and relationships were affected by his background. Cottrell somehow knows how to show emotion on a deep level without writing from an emotional place.

He also creates a quirky little noir-like mystery/psychological thriller that is meant to elude logic but is very attention-grabbing and also just fun.

It’s something special when a writer meticulously creates a narrator who feels so real in the way they struggle to process emotions, emotions which the writer has had to understand and process in order to foist them upon a character who is then able to convincingly struggle with those same emotions. It’s so easy to overplay the cards there, to tell the reader exactly what is being felt and why, to narrativize the feelings like we all do after the fact with big feelings. But instead we get a very in-the-moment, as-yet unprocessed and pre-narrativized character doing his best to just get by.

Yeah even though this was not prolonged enough for me to truly fall in love with it, for what it is it was fairly perfect. And also just so different from most of what I see in the literary young MFA adjacent world right now. Truly original. How rare is that??
Profile Image for Anna.
1,133 reviews886 followers
May 6, 2026
A frustrating read! Someone compared this to Evil Genius, but I’m missing that playful, seductive, identity-shifting energy. It’s almost the opposite. I don’t know what bothered me more: the static, self-centred voice, the lack of curiosity about others, or the need to control a shared narrative. Even the mystery (the brother, the women, the past) is about the protagonist, in contrast to Evil Genius, where the protagonist’s identity unfolds in relation to others and those others retain their opacity. The reveal and abrupt ending are flattened into another psychological loop. It’s like being talked at rather than being told a story.
Profile Image for Iris.
338 reviews338 followers
November 8, 2025
Actually exceptional, a damn find book to read.
Profile Image for Mayra Kalaora.
104 reviews
December 30, 2025
what an absurd book. and killer title. feeling cool and lucky to have gotten my hands on an advance copy. it was so strange. i loved the writing
Profile Image for Ellen Ross.
726 reviews97 followers
October 3, 2025
This book had the perfect amount of dark humor and the perfect amount of serious emotions to make it the ideal read. Dan was fascinating and complex and I was really rooting for him as he tried to get to learn more about his brother and the people that were in his life. This book put me right inside Dan’s brain. I swear I felt the emotions and confusion and the contemplations as if they were my own. Some parts had me puzzled and concerned while others left me snickering to myself. This is truly a unique and special book. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Lisa.
41 reviews1 follower
June 15, 2026
Darkly funny? I kept waiting for a funny part and then it was the end of the book.
Profile Image for Paul Fulcher.
Author 2 books2,180 followers
September 24, 2026
And I thought about how spiritually weak I was back then, long before I met and changed my life under the direction of Thomas Bernhard, the person who altered the course of my life, my writing salvation.

Wertheimer in Thomas Bernhard's Der Untergeher:
„Meine fortgesetzte Neugierde verhinderte meinen Selbstmord, so er, dachte ich.“
"My constant curiosity got in the way of my suicide, so he said, I thought." - in Jack Dawson's translation, echoed in this novel by Dan Moran.

Afternoon Hours of a Hermit is a meta-sequel to Patrick Cottrell's brilliant 2018 Republic of Consciousness Prize longlisted - Sorry to Disrupt the Peace - which also won the Best First Book – Fiction 2017 National Medal from the Independent Publisher Book Awards and Barnes & Noble’s 2017 Discover Award for Fiction, and earned the author a 2018 Whiting Award, the nomination reading; "Patrick Cottrell’s Sorry to Disrupt the Peace is a giddy, furious wallop of a novel. Casting the reader into the tense space between humor and horror, Cottrell engages deeply with repulsion, disgust, antipathy, and grief; he refuses entirely to resort to false transcendence. The bravery of this is astounding. His work opens up fresh lines of questioning in the old interrogations of identity, the politics of belonging, and the problem of other minds."

Re-reading Sorry to Disrupt the Peace in prep for this book, it struck me how, under the black humour and repulsive behaviour, how desperately sad, and in avoidance, the narrator was.

And Afternoon Hours of a Hermit opens, recounting the earlier events of Sorry to Disrupt the Peace, which was set after the suicide of the narrator's younger brother Kevin:

Five years ago I put on my detective hat and my existential black turtleneck in order to solve the mystery of his suicide. I mean the reasons my youngest brother killed himself and his thoughts leading up to his plan. The black turtleneck turned out to be a perfect fit and after sifting and sorting through his belongings, I closed my investigation with satisfactory re-sults. Although we were left with some lingering questions, a few loose ends, some wasted hours here and there, brief and average-length stretches of total mediocrity, paths leading no-where, mental and emotional cul-de-sacs, overall, everything regarding my investigation turned out okay, THE END.

For five years I believed it was over, and then out of the blue I received an envelope with a photo of my youngest brother from our childhood and nothing else.


I referred to this book as a 'meta-sequel'. The premise of Afternoon Hours of a Hermit is not that the protagonist, and first-person narrator, of the novel, Dan Moran, is the same protagonist/narrator as in Sorry to Disrupt the Peace, ____ Moran, but rather than he is the author of that novel, an auto-fictional take on events that happened to him. The ____ representing the deadname under which the original book was both written and also that of the character in the novel, both (fictional) author and character having since transitioned to Dan.

And Dan explains the adjustments made in the fictional treatment of the first work, including the complete omission of another sibling, Matthias, a third Korean adoptee (biologically all unrelated) into their White Catholic Milwaukee family.

In the end it had been easier for me, Dan Moran, to leave Matthias out, to emphasize my familial estrangement and solitude rather than to exploit the conflict between us, since I was already in the process of exploiting the tragedy of my youngest brother's suicide. I could deal with only one devastation at a time.
To put it plainly, I had to pretend someone who was living never existed in order to write a book about someone else who was dead.
I made other changes, too.
I changed the date of my youngest brother's death from September 28 to 30 to ensure that my novel was fictional and not a memoir.
I utilized a register of disgust instead of mourning, guilt, regret, etc.
I intensified my ugliness because I was suspicious of writers who insinuated their own physical beauty or sexual charisma.
I hid myself in the form of a menstruating woman, careful to tiptoe around the problem of my dysphoria, blissfully ignorant of the ones who might read the book to scrutinize its pages for clues to my dysphoria and subsequent transition, and subject me to some stupid psychoanalytic reading of my character, gender, writing, etc.
Other than that, almost everything was based on fact.
And since then, the more distance I've gained from my authorial decisions, the more I've realized what acts of avoidance they were.


Although as the novel unfolds, the attentive reader realises there are more omissions and alterations, ranging from borrowing one person's name, Zachary Moon, for another character, to the more fundamental revelation that Dan has had contact with his original Korean family and his biological sisters, discovering he was the fourth daughter, based on his assigned gender at birth, when the family were desperate for a first son, and hence given up for adoption. Whereas, Kevin had not, despite his wishes, been able to contact his family (in the first novel, Kevin is put in touch and even travels to Korea, but then avoids a meeting with his mother at the last minute). Dan's biological sister observes that perhaps his transition is somehow correcting the accident of his birth.

Although given the first book proved to be fictional, the reader might ask themselves why they feel this novel to be true.

Dan, now in his late 30s, first brings us up to date with his life, including his transition and the launch of his authorial career, and indeed his graduation from teaching 'troubled young people' from disadvantaged backgrounds to teaching equally troubled young people but now as an expensive arts college.

Who did I think I was, trying to teach the troubled youth how to write? If someone had asked, even though no one ever asked, I would say I was Dan Moran, a Korean adoptee, single, approaching forty, once plain in appearance as a woman, now ugly as a man, that’s who or what I thought I was.
Most importantly, I was no longer useless, I was a writer.
... During those five years, I pursued an MFA in creative writing, I wrote, I taught my troubled youth at a private arts college, I procrastinated, I philosophized, I transitioned, etc. While in graduate school, I transcribed into a book the initial discoveries I had made during the investigation of my brother's suicide: Sorry to Disrupt the Peace by ____Moran.
By publishing one book and four or five prose poems, I had transformed myself from no one into an active participant in a thriving intellectual and artistic community.


He is now attempting his second novel - having abandoned both a book called Afternoon Hours of a Hermit (the title from a comment his counsellor made to him), a record of his dreams; another novel, which he could not continue beyond 100 pages, about the epic journey of a defecating ladybird across a carpet; and is now attempting a psychological thriller.

But the arrival of the mysterious photo sends Dan back to the family home in Milwaukee (where he also hopes to work on the psychological thriller). He finds the family holding events to commemorate his brother's death, having not invited him (for rather obvious reasons for a reader of his first novel, although Dan seems sublimely unaware of the upset and chaos he sows), and the family, and their friends, mostly struggle to accept Dan's gender, using his deadname and the wrong pronouns. Although, in a small white suburb where all Koreans look alive to the locals, Dan has some fun when people mistake him for Matthias, and happily discusses with them, in the third person, the troubled ____/Dan.

Indeed rejection is a consistent heme, particularly of his ill-fated attempts to re-investigate his brother's suicide. Dan's father, when he first calls him, suggests he might be better served by finding his high-school yearbook, picking a name at random and attempting to find and contact them on LinkedIn if he wants support. And Dan's Korean adoptee counsellor, who also tries to avoid his calls, typically reacts to Dan's plans by asking him who exactly he thinks he is helping.

Wonderfully Dan has a mentor Thomas Bernhard, who seems to strongly resemble, and write the works of. the late author, but who Dan insists to the reader is a real live person (and Cottrell has said is based on a mentor/friend of his own - "I like to name-drop Bernhard as an inside joke; some of the Bernhard bros seem to appreciate it" - that would be me then!):

Years ago when I told him during office hours I had solved the mystery of my brother's suicide, he stared at a spot above my head and said a suicide is never over. Suicide is continuous, he warned me. Your brother's suicide is a small river that flows into a big river. Suicide is a river that will never dry up. And now I will tell you a joke, Thomas Bernhard said. He told me a joke, I remembered, but I didn't remember it.
If a mind can keep thinking, it will ruminate, reanimate, and bring back the same old story, adding new angles, fresh diversions, complexities, intrigues, etc. That's what the mind does, Thomas Bernhard said: it drives one mad until one is swaddled in bandages of solitude.


As with Sorry to Disrupt the Peace (the Patrick Cottrell not Dan Moran novel - if such a distinction makes sense), Afternoon Hours of a Hermit is a very funny book. But also a very moving one - with the interplay between Dan's historic gender dysphoria; his sense of alienation and rejection from both his biological family and his adopted one; and the revisiting of his brother's death.

Another extraordinary novel.

Resources

A review the author describes as long, thoughtful and inquisitive:
https://www.bookforum.com/print/3204/...

The author's notes from writing the book: https://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2...

Interviews (and - forgive me - ChatGPT's summary)

https://thetorontoreview.ca/patrick-c...

https://www.interviewmagazine.com/cul...

https://electricliterature.com/the-de...

https://therumpus.net/2026/04/21/inve...

https://zonamotel.substack.com/p/inte...

https://maddycourt.substack.com/p/tue...

https://thecreativeindependent.com/pe...

https://bombmagazine.org/articles/202...
Profile Image for Cindy.
2,052 reviews49 followers
March 24, 2026
I didn't find this darkly funny, just dark...and sad. A white, Catholic, Wisconsin couple adopts three unrelated Korean children, and they become a family. The youngest took his own life five years ago when he was in his late teens/early 20s. Since then, the middle child has transitioned to male, although many of his relatives still address him by his "dead name." In the audiobook, this name is spoken as "Blank" (which I found confusing at first). There's also the eldest brother with whom the MMC had minimal interactions. Bottom line, a dysfunctional family, mental health issues, gender dysmorphia, suicidal tendencies, and estrangements all discussed almost dispassionately by the middle child: a self-proclaimed "detective" and published author now in pursuit of his second book.
The audiobook was well narrated. I just needed more resolution from the story, not just a recounting of old wounds.
My thanks to the author, publisher, @HarperAudio, and #NetGalley for early access to the audiobook of #AfternoonHoursofaHermit for review purposes. Publication date: 21 April 2026.
Profile Image for Clara Peng.
91 reviews
June 3, 2026
“One day a very tall woman with excellent posture came into the store. She asked me what I wanted to do with my life. I said I wanted to go to as many Fiona Apple concerts as possible, I wanted to follow Fiona Apple around on tour. I was sixteen or seventeen. The tall woman looked me straight in the eye and told me that my dreams would come true if I joined the Marines because the Marines got to travel the world.”
Profile Image for Jacob Wren.
Author 16 books433 followers
October 4, 2025
A few short quotes from Afternoon Hours of a Hermit:


*


“Friendship has been a form of poison to me, I thought as I tried to picture my friends, especially my writer friends. I kept trying to picture them, my writer friends from the contemporary literature and adjunct scene in Brooklyn. No, the writer friends I pictured only reminded me of the palpable anxiety and awkwardness I felt whenever I interacted with them.”


*


“Perhaps part of the problem was I had surrounded myself with the fiction writers instead of the poets. I had chosen the wrong world to immerse myself in; the poets were nightclub docents of mourning and melancholia and the fiction writers were real estate agents.”


*


“I was ecstatic with joy whenever I had the opportunity to overhear what people said about me as if I weren’t there. Whenever I ran out of things to talk about during my creative writing workshop with the troubled youth, I would, without warning, get up from the conference table and wander out into the hallway, where, if I wasn’t careful, I could spend the rest of the class eavesdropping on my troubled youth, although they hardly ever said my name. I was nothing to them; they preferred to talk about debt, activism, gender, trauma, etc. I was disappointed when I didn’t hear my name come up.”


*


“A few years and nothing to show for all my troubles but the beginning of my psychological thriller, perhaps ten or twelve pages at most, the first ten or twelve pages are the easiest to write, I once said to Thomas Bernhard during office hours, the first ten or twelve pages are effortless, seamless, boundless, effortlessness; it’s the rest of it that’s completely insufferable. It never opens up the way I want it to, I explained to my mother and Aunt Sue. I only wanted to conjure a latticework of light and tranquility, but because of my limitations, I always end up suffocated in a broom closet of despair.”


*


“And some people might find it hard to believe I managed to write a book, a published one, knowing what they know about me, but during my time in graduate school, I learned it’s the most demented and mentally unwell writers who have the easiest time getting their books published, even the most awful, unhinged, stupid, and neurotic person can write and publish a book, then step into a roomful of strangers and talk about it and persuade them to buy it. Almost all my writer friends are suicidal in some way, I reflected, mostly in a soft, ambient way, their suicidal thoughts humming in the background like a refrigerator or a noise-machine, while others are openly suicidal, more suicidal forward.”


*
Profile Image for Melvin.
121 reviews5 followers
June 14, 2026
There's a few paragraphs of good prose in this, that's about it.
This book holds your hand throughout the entire length of it, in case you forgot who's a Korean adoptee or which one of the brothers is the youngest or the middle one, don't worry, the writer reminds you every 2 sentences. The cringiest, I'm-better-than-you, delusional main character. It's just a mess, but I think the writer could make something great in the future, there's definitely some gems in here.
Profile Image for Jan.
1,366 reviews29 followers
November 10, 2026
A low-key but fascinating novel that tells the story of a trans Korean-American writer investigating a sibling’s death by suicide five years earlier.
Profile Image for Kashaf Rafique.
288 reviews1 follower
June 29, 2026
It would have been such a huge favor if this book had never been written. Utterly pointless and more boring than looking at a dark pit. At least that has the potential to spark your imagination.
Profile Image for Andy Weston.
3,482 reviews258 followers
July 25, 2026
Dan Moran teaches writing skills to ‘troubled youth’ in Brooklyn. He receives mail containing a picture of his younger brother Kevin, who killed himself 5 years previously. Dan, Kevin, and their middle brother Matthias were born in Korea, separately, and adopted by their parents, who live in Milwaukee. The picture in the mail is one from childhood. He sees it as a mystery and starts an amateur investigation. Dan is a recently transitioned male.

He uncovers a new detail about Kevin’s suicide, the night his brother died, his mother says, he had written the names of “three women” on his hand, though she can’t recall who they were.
The book has many similarities to Cottrell’s stand-out first novel Sorry to Disrupt the Peace, in which the character Helen Moran returns home to the Milwaukee suburbs following a brother’s suicide. Though this is a sequel of sorts, it doesn’t break very much new ground.
In this, Dan has also written a book about his brother’s suicide, also called ‘Sorry to Disrupt the Peace’, and is writing a sequel.

The area of difference and potential interest here is Dan returning home to a community in which he grew up after transitioning, and how he is received. The inclusion of the autofictional aspect seems pointless and confusing. The element of mystery, which made STDTP so memorable and was a highlight of Cottrell’s writing is surprisingly underplayed here.
Profile Image for Judy Ballard.
162 reviews1 follower
June 19, 2026
After Hours of a Hermit was simply not the book for me. Instead of telling a compelling story, it felt like the author was talking at the reader for pages on end. There was very little plot to hold my attention, and the endless introspection quickly became repetitive rather than thought-provoking.

The overall tone was relentlessly melancholy and emotionally heavy. I don't mind books that explore loneliness, isolation, or the darker sides of life, but this one never offered enough balance or momentum to keep me invested. Rather than feeling moved by the narrator's reflections, I found myself waiting for something meaningful to happen.

I honestly think the only reason Goodreads recommends this title is because Goodreads itself is mentioned throughout the book. Beyond that connection, I'm struggling to see why it has found such an audience.

Unfortunately, this was a disappointing read from beginning to end. Instead of feeling immersed in a story, I felt trapped inside a long, gloomy monologue. It never resonated with me, and by the time I finished, I was relieved it was over.
Profile Image for zac carter.
151 reviews2 followers
June 16, 2026
we are all very lucky to have writers like patrick cottrell, who shows over and over that writing is and can be anything you want. his work gives me strength. it’s akin to wearing something outside your comfort zone or getting a new hairstyle and, despite uncertainties, choosing to present with full confidence. no doubt in sight, but mostly because no one is looking for it. a wonderful novel that is heartbreaking and restorative, hilarious and grim, and so beautifully meta (start with sorry to disrupt the peace if you know what’s good for ya).
Profile Image for Katie.
1,030 reviews5 followers
July 9, 2026
Thank you, NetGalley and HarperAudio Adult | Ecco, for the audiobook of this book, Afternoon Hours of a Hermit.

I didn't find this book funny at all. Just incredibly sad and dark. I'm also not sure what the point of the story is? Is it a transition story? Is it about the MMC's author plan and writing their book? Is this about the mystery of the weird happenings? Is it about the trauma of this family? I just feel like I was listening to someone rambling about their life and not about a specific story. It is also quite repetitive.
Profile Image for Virgowriter (Brad Windhauser).
778 reviews12 followers
June 1, 2026
Really wanted to appreciate this book more. Narrator is kinda a dick as are the members of his family. The story is set uo that he will investigate the events that led to his brother’s suicide, but he learns very little by story’s end—doesn’t even learn much about himself. You don’t really learn that much about the narrator
Profile Image for Kathryn.
153 reviews3 followers
April 12, 2026
've never read anything like this. Patrick Cottrell has based this work of fiction on his real life experiences. It is his second novel with the first being a precursor for Afternoon Hours of a Hermit. I will definitely be going back and reading his first publication. I found this to be an easy read with some heavy topics but Cottrell inserts some dark humor in it and I did giggle at points. All in all though, you are reading Dan's perspective in the book and it leaves you questioning how reliable he is as far as his perception of how others feel about him and his assumptions. Dan is a trans male and throughout the book you see how disconnected his family is from him, how they don't honor his transition and keep referring to the person he was born, the person he was, his dead name. It was sad to read. Then at the other end of the spectrum you see how obsessed he has become trying to get answers for his brother's "untimely death". While he does get some answers, they were not what he was expecting nor were they asked. all while being someone obsessed with approaching those investigations to his own resolution. How reliable is he really? Hhhmmm...then again, I feel his behaviors and actions and feelings are all justified...

As with a lot of literary fiction, you aren't going to get resolution or answers. This was more about the characters and having understood that I think this book resonated much better than if I was waiting to get to those resolutions.

In addition to the book, I listened to the audio. Leo Sheng narrates Afternoon Hours of a Hermit and really did a great job. Leo has a pleasant tone and truly brought to life Dan Moran. Leo's delivery hit when it was needed and stayed afloat throughout the book, he was not flat at all.

Go into this book not expecting answers, go into it to learn about the character and his stories and what brought him to where we are today. If you do that then I think you will be satisfied. I thoroughly enjoyed this!
1,331 reviews38 followers
May 21, 2026
A quirky short novel…there are some big ideas here (about being trans, being adopted, being Korean, being a writer, being depressed, being part of a dysfunctional family, etc.)—but all wrapped up in a pseudo mystery, heavy on the sardonic humor and introspective reflection. I sometimes felt I was on the outside of an inside joke…but it was entertaining enough to keep me reading.
Profile Image for Ella Grace.
54 reviews
August 23, 2026
I thought the prose was excellent and this book is highly thought-provoking, but I found the plot dissatisfying.
Profile Image for Cheryl.
100 reviews18 followers
June 4, 2026
Very mixed feelings about this book. But worthy of a 3-star rating b/c I did LIKE it, just didn’t love it. I certainly didn’t find it funny.

(I am a reunited adult adoptee, a decades long Adoptee Rights activist/advocate, the friend of several Korean adoptees, and the ADHD/Dyslexic mother of a Trans son who is also neurodivergent… so hopefully that is enough to explain my very mixed feelings)
Profile Image for Candice Stull.
18 reviews
March 27, 2026
I’m not entirely sure why this is a five-star read for me, which feels fitting for a novel that resists clarity at every turn.

Afternoon Hours of a Hermit is deeply disorienting—almost vertiginous. Being inside Dan’s mind feels claustrophobic: he fixates on his brother’s suicide, but even his grief turns inward, refracted through his own sense of self. I found myself constantly questioning him. Is he lying? Is he reliable? Does he even understand the world around him?

There’s a strange instability to everything—his job, his relationships, even reality itself. The novel hovers at the edges of something surreal without ever fully becoming it, which only deepens the unease. Dan is intensely introspective yet profoundly oblivious, so consumed with examining himself that he fails to truly see anything outside of him. Others treat him as if he’s barely there—and in some ways, he participates in that erasure.

It takes so long for his brother to even be named—Kevin—as if grief itself resists being fixed in language. And when clarity does come, it lands hard: “The person dissolves into nothingness, and you can’t bring them back.”

I didn’t always enjoy being in this book, but it stayed with me. There’s something quietly devastating about a character who observes everything and understands almost nothing—especially himself.

I closed it feeling unsteady, and somehow, that feels exactly right.
Profile Image for Christa.
843 reviews32 followers
June 17, 2026
It was advertised as "darkly funny and profoundly moving" but it was just...dark and absurd to me. The main character is trans in a family that refuses to recognize his identity, so he's constantly referred to as "blank" (dead name) with the wrong pronouns, and it was upsetting for me as the reader. The main character is also very...strange??? Delusional. THAT part was almost funny, but it came across as more sad (and then upsetting) to me. Such a weird book.
715 reviews29 followers
October 14, 2025
Thanks to Netgalley and Ecco for the ebook. Trans author Dan Moran is living a simple life as an author and teaching writing in Brooklyn, but as the five year anniversary of his younger brother’s suicide approaches, Dan gets an anonymous letter involving his brother that sends him back to his hometown, where most people still remember him as the depressed and angry daughter of the nice Christian couple who adopted three Asian children. Dan takes on the guise of a detective to try and learn if there was more to this suicide than anyone could have imagined.
Profile Image for Michelle.
723 reviews1 follower
June 20, 2026
I don't like to give a low rating because I know someone put in a lot of effort to write this, but this is just not my type of book. Read for a challenge, otherwise I wouldn't have finished it. And when I read the other critiques, maybe I missed something. About a trans man who returns home for the memorial of his younger brother who committed suicide. It claims to be funny and dark, but the main character just seems too selfish and does whatever they want with no regard for others. And I'm not sure of the point, and I definitely didn't get the ending.
Profile Image for AMBER ISON.
2 reviews
August 2, 2026
"My youngest brother" "Korean adoptee" "My mother" "Korean adoptee" "My youngest brother" "troubled youths" "My childhood home" "Korean adoptee" "My youngest brother" "Korean adoptee" "My youngest brother" remove those phrases & you'll remove half or more of the book. Repetitive. Rambling. MC has a very odd (not in an interesting way), self-centered way of going about things. Saying you're a detective & acting weird does not make one a detective. Over-explanitory. Dark, but not in a good way, with absolutely no humor.
Profile Image for Watty.
10 reviews2 followers
June 7, 2026
Not my type of book. It’s like someone reading their diary entries TO you instead of being sucked into a story. It’s one of those “all about me” stories and their POV. To Me, it feels like a high school English essay instead of a story that’s supposed to be a story of an almost 40 year old MC.

It was almost a DNF for me.
Profile Image for Brandi.
Author 20 books99 followers
June 30, 2026
I read this one in a day—couldn't stop. Loved this narrator and the way this second book expands the previous novel but also stands on its own entirely.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 157 reviews