What do you think?
Rate this book
Boston Bobcats #1
Ice Ice Baby
He's the plot twist she didn't see coming...
Maya Silver doesn’t believe in happily ever afters, nor does she want one. She’s too busy managing the Book Nook, a cozy Boston bookstore where romance novels fly off the shelves. After one too many disappointments, she’s learned that love is unpredictable, and most promises don’t last. So love in real life? That’s a story Maya’s shelved for good.
Enter Nicholas “Cole” Barrett, the Boston Bobcats’ star player. He’s built his whole life around the game, and it’s paid off. He’s got his routine perfected until Maya crashes into it with stories, sarcasm, and a smile he can’t stop thinking about. She’s not chasing a puck or a paycheck, and for once, he’s not thinking about the next practice or game, he’s thinking about her.
Maya’s not interested in being won over, but Cole is used to pursuing things worth winning. And as they spend more time together, the harder it is to ignore the fiery pull between them and the way their connection feels like something more. But having spent her whole life believing true love was only found in books, will Maya be brave enough to begin a love story of her own?
Maya Silver doesn’t believe in happily ever afters, nor does she want one. She’s too busy managing the Book Nook, a cozy Boston bookstore where romance novels fly off the shelves. After one too many disappointments, she’s learned that love is unpredictable, and most promises don’t last. So love in real life? That’s a story Maya’s shelved for good.
Enter Nicholas “Cole” Barrett, the Boston Bobcats’ star player. He’s built his whole life around the game, and it’s paid off. He’s got his routine perfected until Maya crashes into it with stories, sarcasm, and a smile he can’t stop thinking about. She’s not chasing a puck or a paycheck, and for once, he’s not thinking about the next practice or game, he’s thinking about her.
Maya’s not interested in being won over, but Cole is used to pursuing things worth winning. And as they spend more time together, the harder it is to ignore the fiery pull between them and the way their connection feels like something more. But having spent her whole life believing true love was only found in books, will Maya be brave enough to begin a love story of her own?
330 pages, ebook
Published November 6, 2025
325 people are currently reading
8885 people want to read
About the author
Carly Robyn
9 books342 followersCarly Robyn writes contemporary romances with heart, heat, and humor. When she's not writing or reading, you can find her spending time with her family, scrolling through TikTok, exploring Chicago's restaurant scene with friends, watching a Grand Prix, taking a million photos of her dogs Quincy and Owen, or binge-watching anything true-crime related while drinking Diet Coke.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 429 reviews
November 18, 2025
2.75 ✰
The premise of this book sounds like something I’ll enjoy reading… unfortunately it was not the case this time.
My biggest problem with this book is how the fmc’s whole personality is that she reads. Don’t get me wrong, that’s lowkey my only personality too but at least I don’t go around making all conversations about books and trying to change the topic all the time. Most of the times the fmc would make references to booktok and things I don’t really like to see in a book since it’s part of my daily life lol, so I think that definitely played a big role into why I couldn’t love this. Also the fact that he ghosted her for a month!?!?!? ummm no, thank you😭
I truly wanted to enjoy this book and i think it is a me problem tbh, it was very insta-love/lust, i just couldn’t get into their dynamic as friends and then a couple since everything happened so fast.
The premise of this book sounds like something I’ll enjoy reading… unfortunately it was not the case this time.
My biggest problem with this book is how the fmc’s whole personality is that she reads. Don’t get me wrong, that’s lowkey my only personality too but at least I don’t go around making all conversations about books and trying to change the topic all the time. Most of the times the fmc would make references to booktok and things I don’t really like to see in a book since it’s part of my daily life lol, so I think that definitely played a big role into why I couldn’t love this. Also the fact that he ghosted her for a month!?!?!? ummm no, thank you😭
I truly wanted to enjoy this book and i think it is a me problem tbh, it was very insta-love/lust, i just couldn’t get into their dynamic as friends and then a couple since everything happened so fast.
November 10, 2025
𝑻𝒉𝒆𝒓𝒆’𝒔 𝒏𝒐 𝒘𝒐𝒓𝒍𝒅, 𝒇𝒊𝒄𝒕𝒊𝒐𝒏𝒂𝒍 𝒐𝒓 𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒍, 𝒊𝒏 𝒘𝒉𝒊𝒄𝒉 𝑰’𝒎 𝒏𝒐𝒕 𝒆𝒏𝒂𝒎𝒐𝒓𝒆𝒅 𝒃𝒚 𝑪𝒐𝒍𝒆 𝑩𝒆𝒓𝒓𝒆𝒕𝒕.
Okay this was hella cuuuuteeeee 🥹💖 If you love romance, banter, and having the FMC be obsessed with books as we are, then definitely read this book 😍 Not to mention SPORTS 🏒!!! We got the team captain falling head over heels for the woman who “just wants to be friends” but let’s be real… we all know that doesn’t last 😏 WIIINK.
Maya Silver only reads about happily ever afters but doesn’t actually believe in them. Comes in Cole Bennett, who wants to win her over no matter how long he has to wait to convince her (SCREAMS) The banter and the black cat x golden retriever energy were so delicious! I especially loved how even though it’s all cute and games, you really get to see why Maya doesn’t come easy when it comes to love and also Cole's insecurities of trusting someone completely. Personally, I think that’s what hit close to heart while reading.
Love is not only expressed with words but also with actions💞 and there are so many scenes here outside of the spice (WHICH WAS HOT. BY. THE. WAY 🔥) that pulled at my heartstrings and made my reading experience amazing 🥹
We also can’t forget the hockey aspect of the book 🏒⛸️ I loved seeing Maya go from never watching a hockey game to being obsessed by the end 😂 Because let’s be honest just like Maya, we usually only read about the games, not actually go to them lol. Maya Silver was seriously so relatable that I think every book lover should read this book as a requirement into the book society lmao!! 💕
tropes
🏒 hockey romance
🏒 black cat x golden retriever
🏒 he falls first
🏒 slow burn
🏒 opposite attract
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for my eARC
⋆. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁⋆.⋆. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁⋆.
𝗽𝗿𝗲-𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗱 ꪆৎ ˚⋅ i need to be healed by a hockey romance
Okay this was hella cuuuuteeeee 🥹💖 If you love romance, banter, and having the FMC be obsessed with books as we are, then definitely read this book 😍 Not to mention SPORTS 🏒!!! We got the team captain falling head over heels for the woman who “just wants to be friends” but let’s be real… we all know that doesn’t last 😏 WIIINK.
Maya Silver only reads about happily ever afters but doesn’t actually believe in them. Comes in Cole Bennett, who wants to win her over no matter how long he has to wait to convince her (SCREAMS) The banter and the black cat x golden retriever energy were so delicious! I especially loved how even though it’s all cute and games, you really get to see why Maya doesn’t come easy when it comes to love and also Cole's insecurities of trusting someone completely. Personally, I think that’s what hit close to heart while reading.
Love is not only expressed with words but also with actions💞 and there are so many scenes here outside of the spice (WHICH WAS HOT. BY. THE. WAY 🔥) that pulled at my heartstrings and made my reading experience amazing 🥹
We also can’t forget the hockey aspect of the book 🏒⛸️ I loved seeing Maya go from never watching a hockey game to being obsessed by the end 😂 Because let’s be honest just like Maya, we usually only read about the games, not actually go to them lol. Maya Silver was seriously so relatable that I think every book lover should read this book as a requirement into the book society lmao!! 💕
tropes
🏒 hockey romance
🏒 black cat x golden retriever
🏒 he falls first
🏒 slow burn
🏒 opposite attract
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for my eARC
⋆. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁⋆.⋆. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁˖ . ݁⋆.
𝗽𝗿𝗲-𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗱 ꪆৎ ˚⋅ i need to be healed by a hockey romance
November 6, 2025
3.5 ⭐
I really enjoyed the book. Maya is super charismatic and fun, and Cole is a sweetheart. Plus, the slow burn was 🔥🔥🔥
My only issue with the book is that once they started getting together, it felt like it was almost one spicy scene after another, and the whole ending felt rushed.
But overall, I really liked the book.
I really enjoyed the book. Maya is super charismatic and fun, and Cole is a sweetheart. Plus, the slow burn was 🔥🔥🔥
My only issue with the book is that once they started getting together, it felt like it was almost one spicy scene after another, and the whole ending felt rushed.
But overall, I really liked the book.
November 6, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🤍hockey romance
🤍black cat x golden retriever
🤍slow burn
🤍he fall first
💋Dramatic Thoughts💋
If you thought Carly Robyn’s F1 romance era was fabulous, then you better lace up your skates because her hockey romance era is just as INCREDIBLE 😍
Let’s dive in!!! Cole fell first and HARD for his coffee loving, romance reading, selfless woman! Cole literally was so cute taking things at Maya’s pace and following her lead! Maya just has this quirky sense of humor - I was rolling every time she told someone her job description!! The banter between Maya and Cole was so much fun and I certainly cannot miss my opportunity to mention the SPICE SPICE BABY 🥵🥵
While obviously I adored the main characters, the side characters were fabulous too!! I’m super excited to continue this series and I’ll forever be a Carly Robyn fan!!
Thank you Carly for an ARC of this book!!
🤍hockey romance
🤍black cat x golden retriever
🤍slow burn
🤍he fall first
💋Dramatic Thoughts💋
If you thought Carly Robyn’s F1 romance era was fabulous, then you better lace up your skates because her hockey romance era is just as INCREDIBLE 😍
Let’s dive in!!! Cole fell first and HARD for his coffee loving, romance reading, selfless woman! Cole literally was so cute taking things at Maya’s pace and following her lead! Maya just has this quirky sense of humor - I was rolling every time she told someone her job description!! The banter between Maya and Cole was so much fun and I certainly cannot miss my opportunity to mention the SPICE SPICE BABY 🥵🥵
While obviously I adored the main characters, the side characters were fabulous too!! I’m super excited to continue this series and I’ll forever be a Carly Robyn fan!!
Thank you Carly for an ARC of this book!!
November 6, 2025
Ice Ice Baby by Carly Robyn is a multiple scene open door sports romance between a bookstore manager and a professional hockey player. I found it super relatable since the FMC is completely obsessed with books and can talk about tropes for hours. Same.
The story was really sweet. I loved that they met as strangers and became friends first. So many sports romances lean on best friend’s brother or coach’s daughter, so getting a real meet cute between two unconnected people felt refreshing. The FMC has zero ties to hockey and honestly, I loved that about her.
The MMC was sweet, steady, and really dedicated. The miscommunication trope is definitely strong in this one, so go in with your eyes open if that’s not your thing.
Overall, I liked the side characters, the chemistry, and how caring the MMC was. The FMC was fun to read, and I think this might kick off a Boston Bobcats series. If so, I’ll definitely be checking out the next one.
Thank you to Valentine PR and the author for a copy of this arc.
The story was really sweet. I loved that they met as strangers and became friends first. So many sports romances lean on best friend’s brother or coach’s daughter, so getting a real meet cute between two unconnected people felt refreshing. The FMC has zero ties to hockey and honestly, I loved that about her.
The MMC was sweet, steady, and really dedicated. The miscommunication trope is definitely strong in this one, so go in with your eyes open if that’s not your thing.
Overall, I liked the side characters, the chemistry, and how caring the MMC was. The FMC was fun to read, and I think this might kick off a Boston Bobcats series. If so, I’ll definitely be checking out the next one.
Thank you to Valentine PR and the author for a copy of this arc.
November 15, 2025
This was borderline 3.75-4 stars for me, but I leaned towards 4. It was a good intro to a new world of men that we get to watch meet their matches! I had a little bit of a challenge with the pacing and the chemistry. Everything was a little fast then slowed down all while their chemistry was slightly lacking in my opinion. With that being said, I liked the intro to our new world of hockey players. I liked Cole and Maya. I liked their meet cute- as a reader- I clicked with Maya. I have found myself reading not necessairly on my reader but definitely on my phone at things that I feel out of touch at haha. I liked how she didn't really know anything about hockey but after becoming "friends" with Cole she made an effort. I had a hard time with the beginning of the book BUT understood it after learning more about Cole and where his head was at. I liked how he made the deep dive and decided that he wanted to be with Maya and would go at her pace. He showed up for her. He listened. It was nice to have him show her his world while she was learning more about his. At the end of the day, these two were good together. The spice when it hit was GOOD. That's when the chemistry clicked. It was really fun watching these two finally lower their walls and give love a try.
Maya has one main focus- reading. She manages one of the local bookstores and loves her job. She doesn't really think anything about dating but then she meets Cole at a party. He kisses her after hanging out for the night, and it's a GREAT kiss. But then he ghosts her. She tries not to let it affect her, but when he comes back around for a second chance. She says they can only be friends. And so friends they are. Friends that talk. Friends that eat together. Friends that learn things about each other. Friends that think dirty thoughts about each other- wait that's not right. She shouldn't be thinking about Cole this way, but she can't help thinking about that kiss. She wants more. She knows he wants more. And so after a lot of teasing she gives in. And she is so glad that she did. She realizes that they have basically been dating but now there are additional benefits. They have a solid foundation. They have a great connection AND he is supportive in her dream of writing. She is starting to think of this long term when a wrench is thrown at them. Maya hopes she knows how to navigate. She hopes that the trust she has given Cole is not unfounded. Because she realizes life isn't fun with him not in it.
Cole has one thing that he is focused on. And that's hockey. Ever since tragedy hit his family three years ago, it's all he has known. But then he meets Maya at a party and gets distracted by her kiss. Distracted enough to drop the ball in hockey. He freaks and backs off but realizes that he can't only be about hockey. He WANTS to try with Maya. He knows he messed up but is hoping that she will give him another chance. She says no to anything romantic but yes to friends. Cole takes it with the hopes he can change her mind. And then he basically proceeds to fall in love with her. He learns her dreams, her wants, her challenges, what makes her smile, what makes her tick. He learns it all and gives her hints that he still wants more which he does. She when she finally gives in, it's like finding water in the desert. Glorious. And now he wants her all the time. They have a great foundation. He just wants to continue to be the best he can for her and support her how he can. But then a dream that he had with his brother comes into play. One that would change everything. And Cole finds himself wondering if his dreams haven't changed to involve a woman named Maya.
This was a pretty easy read. I enjoyed the overall plot and again getting to meet all of our future characters. I would recommend this if you want to start a new hockey series!
Thank you to Valentine PR and Carly for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
Maya has one main focus- reading. She manages one of the local bookstores and loves her job. She doesn't really think anything about dating but then she meets Cole at a party. He kisses her after hanging out for the night, and it's a GREAT kiss. But then he ghosts her. She tries not to let it affect her, but when he comes back around for a second chance. She says they can only be friends. And so friends they are. Friends that talk. Friends that eat together. Friends that learn things about each other. Friends that think dirty thoughts about each other- wait that's not right. She shouldn't be thinking about Cole this way, but she can't help thinking about that kiss. She wants more. She knows he wants more. And so after a lot of teasing she gives in. And she is so glad that she did. She realizes that they have basically been dating but now there are additional benefits. They have a solid foundation. They have a great connection AND he is supportive in her dream of writing. She is starting to think of this long term when a wrench is thrown at them. Maya hopes she knows how to navigate. She hopes that the trust she has given Cole is not unfounded. Because she realizes life isn't fun with him not in it.
Cole has one thing that he is focused on. And that's hockey. Ever since tragedy hit his family three years ago, it's all he has known. But then he meets Maya at a party and gets distracted by her kiss. Distracted enough to drop the ball in hockey. He freaks and backs off but realizes that he can't only be about hockey. He WANTS to try with Maya. He knows he messed up but is hoping that she will give him another chance. She says no to anything romantic but yes to friends. Cole takes it with the hopes he can change her mind. And then he basically proceeds to fall in love with her. He learns her dreams, her wants, her challenges, what makes her smile, what makes her tick. He learns it all and gives her hints that he still wants more which he does. She when she finally gives in, it's like finding water in the desert. Glorious. And now he wants her all the time. They have a great foundation. He just wants to continue to be the best he can for her and support her how he can. But then a dream that he had with his brother comes into play. One that would change everything. And Cole finds himself wondering if his dreams haven't changed to involve a woman named Maya.
This was a pretty easy read. I enjoyed the overall plot and again getting to meet all of our future characters. I would recommend this if you want to start a new hockey series!
Thank you to Valentine PR and Carly for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
November 8, 2025
I adored everything about this book! Maya is a romance loving bookstore manager who always has her nose in a book. Cole is an outgoing and swoon worthy NHL superstar and when he sets his mind to something he’s going make sure it happens. He’s instantly captivated by Maya and he’s determined to show her that happily ever afters do exist outside of romance novels.
I loved these two together and they make such an adorable couple. I loved Maya’s bit of grumpiness mixed with Cole. It was so fun being about to relate to Maya as a fellow book lover that’s introverted but always willing to discuss books. I also need to find myself a man like Cole that’s willing to read alien smut for me.
I love Carly’s writing style and she did an amazing job with this new hockey romance series. I was hooked from page one and enjoyed every minute of the book. I can’t wait to see what happens next in book two of the Boston Bobcats!
I loved these two together and they make such an adorable couple. I loved Maya’s bit of grumpiness mixed with Cole. It was so fun being about to relate to Maya as a fellow book lover that’s introverted but always willing to discuss books. I also need to find myself a man like Cole that’s willing to read alien smut for me.
I love Carly’s writing style and she did an amazing job with this new hockey romance series. I was hooked from page one and enjoyed every minute of the book. I can’t wait to see what happens next in book two of the Boston Bobcats!
November 1, 2025
4.5🌟, 3 🌶️
You know that book that just feels like a warm hug? Ice Ice Baby totally hit that spot for me.
It’s a charming sports romance between a book-obsessed bookstore manager and a pro hockey player, and I absolutely adored the FMC’s bookish, trope-loving vibes. Their stranger-to-lovers meet-cute felt so fresh and real—a nice break from the usual sports romance clichés.
Maya and Cole were both such great characters. I loved how they started as friends and built their connection slowly while still having great chemistry. Cole was patient, kind, and genuinely devoted, while Maya took her time to open up—but once she did, it was all in. There’s a bit of miscommunication in their story, but it fits naturally and adds to their connection.
The side characters added so much warmth and fun, giving the book that perfect found-family feel. Goose completely stole the show, and I’m really hoping we get to see more stories about the rest of the crew—they were so much fun to read about.
It was sweet, charming, and low on drama, with just the right touch of spice—a cozy, comforting read that I didn’t want to put down.
~~~~
Thank you, Carly Robyn and Valentine PR, for the ARC! 😍 All my bookish thoughts are completely my own. ✨
You know that book that just feels like a warm hug? Ice Ice Baby totally hit that spot for me.
It’s a charming sports romance between a book-obsessed bookstore manager and a pro hockey player, and I absolutely adored the FMC’s bookish, trope-loving vibes. Their stranger-to-lovers meet-cute felt so fresh and real—a nice break from the usual sports romance clichés.
Maya and Cole were both such great characters. I loved how they started as friends and built their connection slowly while still having great chemistry. Cole was patient, kind, and genuinely devoted, while Maya took her time to open up—but once she did, it was all in. There’s a bit of miscommunication in their story, but it fits naturally and adds to their connection.
The side characters added so much warmth and fun, giving the book that perfect found-family feel. Goose completely stole the show, and I’m really hoping we get to see more stories about the rest of the crew—they were so much fun to read about.
It was sweet, charming, and low on drama, with just the right touch of spice—a cozy, comforting read that I didn’t want to put down.
~~~~
Thank you, Carly Robyn and Valentine PR, for the ARC! 😍 All my bookish thoughts are completely my own. ✨
November 6, 2025
All the romance book lovers out there get ready because this is the book for us! 🤩
🐈⬛ black cat x golden retriever
🩵 he falls first & hard
🏒 hockey romance
📖 bookish heroine
This is literally perfect for anyone who doesn’t follow hockey in real life but loves to read sports romances about it (aka me lol)! Maya is truly a bookish heroine I think many people will relate to 🫶
Maya is a closed-off eldest daughter who’s always taken care of her siblings (ouch I’ve been targeted again), and she’s the type of FMC I can always get behind. And Cole is the golden retriever hockey player who falls first and hard for her! He really owns up to how much he likes her and is so respectful of her boundaries. I loved seeing them get to know each other on a real friendship level before becoming more serious. It was so sweet seeing Cole show up for Maya whenever she needed him especially since she’s never had that kind of stability from anyone else in her life 🥹
Overall, this was a really cute hockey romance read! It made me smile, and I ADORED the side characters in addition to Cole & Maya. I’m now super intrigued and excited for the rest of the series! This was my first Carly Robyn book, and it will definitely not be my last 💙
Thank you so much to Carly Robyn & Valentine PR for an ARC of this book! 💌
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
stop it rn this was so cute!! this one's truly for all the book lovers out there <3
🐈⬛ black cat x golden retriever
🩵 he falls first & hard
🏒 hockey romance
📖 bookish heroine
This is literally perfect for anyone who doesn’t follow hockey in real life but loves to read sports romances about it (aka me lol)! Maya is truly a bookish heroine I think many people will relate to 🫶
Maya is a closed-off eldest daughter who’s always taken care of her siblings (ouch I’ve been targeted again), and she’s the type of FMC I can always get behind. And Cole is the golden retriever hockey player who falls first and hard for her! He really owns up to how much he likes her and is so respectful of her boundaries. I loved seeing them get to know each other on a real friendship level before becoming more serious. It was so sweet seeing Cole show up for Maya whenever she needed him especially since she’s never had that kind of stability from anyone else in her life 🥹
Overall, this was a really cute hockey romance read! It made me smile, and I ADORED the side characters in addition to Cole & Maya. I’m now super intrigued and excited for the rest of the series! This was my first Carly Robyn book, and it will definitely not be my last 💙
Thank you so much to Carly Robyn & Valentine PR for an ARC of this book! 💌
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
stop it rn this was so cute!! this one's truly for all the book lovers out there <3
November 8, 2025
How is this her first hockey romance?! Carly was MADE to write hockey. This is every book lovers dream come true - meeting a hockey player at a bar where you’re hiding in the corner to read your kindle? Count me in.
Read this if you’re in the mood for…
- hockey romance
- he takes her out to skate
- meet cute
- he falls first
- found family
- banter texting
This was SO sweet and the perfect start to a new series! Can’t wait to see who gets their own book in the future.
Would I recommend? YES
Read this if you’re in the mood for…
- hockey romance
- he takes her out to skate
- meet cute
- he falls first
- found family
- banter texting
This was SO sweet and the perfect start to a new series! Can’t wait to see who gets their own book in the future.
Would I recommend? YES
September 3, 2025
I’m SUPER early. This was read for a content pull. Either way? It’s a top read of 2025 for me 🥹🫶🏼.
Oh. My. God.
This book gave me SOOO much life. Cole Berrett is a true book boyfriend. Their dynamic and relationship is INCREDIBLE. The side characters? Funny and charming. The banter? Immaculate. The angst and tension moments? I literally teared up from the feelings.
Oh. My. God.
This book gave me SOOO much life. Cole Berrett is a true book boyfriend. Their dynamic and relationship is INCREDIBLE. The side characters? Funny and charming. The banter? Immaculate. The angst and tension moments? I literally teared up from the feelings.
Currently reading
November 7, 2025Available now!
Download today or read for FREE with Kindle Unlimited
Amazon: http://bit.ly/4fbzGON
Goodreads: http://bit.ly/4odosxc
🩵 opposites attract
🩵 hockey romance
🩵 golden retriever + black cat
🩵 slow burn with spice
🩵 he falls first
🩵 bookstore manager + pro hockey player
🩵 nonstop banter
🩵 dual POV
Download today or read for FREE with Kindle Unlimited
Amazon: http://bit.ly/4fbzGON
Goodreads: http://bit.ly/4odosxc
🩵 opposites attract
🩵 hockey romance
🩵 golden retriever + black cat
🩵 slow burn with spice
🩵 he falls first
🩵 bookstore manager + pro hockey player
🩵 nonstop banter
🩵 dual POV
October 27, 2025
Awww, this was so my type of book!! So cozy and cute ☺️ loved all the bookish references 🤭
There could have been more dramatics but I just loved how true it felt, like there were no crazy unrealistic things going on. Both Maya and Cole were such great characters and I thought they had a depth to them as well. They were ADORABLE! 🥰
I really hope there will be more stories about the rest of the characters, they were so fun to read about and I loved them all together! Must also say that the spice was good spice 😏
There could have been more dramatics but I just loved how true it felt, like there were no crazy unrealistic things going on. Both Maya and Cole were such great characters and I thought they had a depth to them as well. They were ADORABLE! 🥰
I really hope there will be more stories about the rest of the characters, they were so fun to read about and I loved them all together! Must also say that the spice was good spice 😏
November 3, 2025
Very cute romance between bookshop worker Maya and hockey star Cole. This opposites attract novella is a fun read which manages to be lighthearted even while delving into serious topics like the loss of a twin brother.
I received an advance reader copy from Valentine PR, and I’m sharing my honest review.
I received an advance reader copy from Valentine PR, and I’m sharing my honest review.
October 28, 2025
ARC read:
Ughh perf!! I love love cole and maya so much!! This was my first hockey romance and i am in love hehe🥰
Ughh perf!! I love love cole and maya so much!! This was my first hockey romance and i am in love hehe🥰
October 25, 2025
ARC Review
- 𝑰𝒄𝒆 𝑰𝒄𝒆 𝑩𝒂𝒃𝒚 𝒃𝒚 𝑪𝒂𝒓𝒍𝒚 𝑹𝒐𝒃𝒚𝒏 🏒🩵
⭐️: 5/5
🌶️: 4/5
💭: This story was such a heartwarming surprise. I really connected with Maya and her mix of strength and vulnerability. Cole is the definition of a true book boyfriend—kind, steady. Their connection feels genuine and healing, with just the right balance of humor and heart. I also adored the loyal pup and the lovable side characters—hoping we get to see more of them in the future!
- opposites attract
- hockey romance
- golden retriever + black cat
- slow burn with spice
- he falls first
- bookstore manager + pro hockey player
- nonstop banter
- dual POV
𝑹𝒆𝒍𝒆𝒂𝒔𝒆𝒔 𝑵𝒐𝒗𝒆𝒎𝒃𝒆𝒓 𝟔 𝒐𝒏 𝑲𝒊𝒏𝒅𝒍𝒆 𝑼𝒏𝒍𝒊𝒎𝒊𝒕𝒆𝒅 🤍
- 𝑰𝒄𝒆 𝑰𝒄𝒆 𝑩𝒂𝒃𝒚 𝒃𝒚 𝑪𝒂𝒓𝒍𝒚 𝑹𝒐𝒃𝒚𝒏 🏒🩵
⭐️: 5/5
🌶️: 4/5
💭: This story was such a heartwarming surprise. I really connected with Maya and her mix of strength and vulnerability. Cole is the definition of a true book boyfriend—kind, steady. Their connection feels genuine and healing, with just the right balance of humor and heart. I also adored the loyal pup and the lovable side characters—hoping we get to see more of them in the future!
- opposites attract
- hockey romance
- golden retriever + black cat
- slow burn with spice
- he falls first
- bookstore manager + pro hockey player
- nonstop banter
- dual POV
𝑹𝒆𝒍𝒆𝒂𝒔𝒆𝒔 𝑵𝒐𝒗𝒆𝒎𝒃𝒆𝒓 𝟔 𝒐𝒏 𝑲𝒊𝒏𝒅𝒍𝒆 𝑼𝒏𝒍𝒊𝒎𝒊𝒕𝒆𝒅 🤍
November 6, 2025
4/4.5 ⭐️
This was such a fun read and added to my love for hockey romance!
I thought the characters were beautifully written and the character development was great! The banter between Cole and Maya had me giddy and the fact he falls first had me swooning! Love a yearning man! The side characters also played such an important role and can’t wait to see how the rest of the series plays out.
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly for the ARC 🩵🏒 thankful to get the chance to read this gem!
This was such a fun read and added to my love for hockey romance!
I thought the characters were beautifully written and the character development was great! The banter between Cole and Maya had me giddy and the fact he falls first had me swooning! Love a yearning man! The side characters also played such an important role and can’t wait to see how the rest of the series plays out.
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly for the ARC 🩵🏒 thankful to get the chance to read this gem!
November 4, 2025
Thank you so much to Valentine PR & Carly Robyn for the advance copy of this book!
This book will be out on November 6th.
If you have not read a Carly Robyn book, what are you waiting for?! I didn’t think I could love her writing or her books more but this one – chef’s kiss! I was first introduced to Carly’s work via her series on Formula One so when I saw she was doing a hockey series next, I was ready.
And this one was soooo good! I ate this one up from start to finish. I haven’t read a book with my eyes this fast in so long and boy it felt good. Did I go into her DMs screaming about our MMC Cole? Why yes I did. We love a man who knows what he wants and goes after it. I am notorious for not liking slow burns but I never have to worry when it comes to Carly’s slow burns because she gives me everything I need. There is so much banter and flirting that just makes me want to giggle, scream, kick my feet and gasp sometimes all at the same time.
“Thanks for making me talk.”
“Thanks for making my happy.”
Maya is labeled as a black cat which I totally can see how she can be but its never in a malicious way. She is just very cautious about what she gets wrapped up in. She never really does stuff for herself after years of being a caretaker for her younger siblings. And there was a moment (actually the moment when I went into the author’s DMs) where Cole is with Maya when she has dinner with her mom and siblings and gahhh my heart. I love a protective man who would do anything for the woman he loves. Cole was never shy about his feelings for her. And one thing I love that the author did with the characters, is that she made them talk. When someone was scared, they said it. “I’ve already fallen for you. And I’m scared, too. …I’m only human. So yeah, what I feel for you scares me, but I’m willing to give it a shot.” GAHHHHHH!
There was a plot point that I won’t spoil but I was nervous on how it was going to play out on page. I trust anything Carly does so I knew it would all be okay plus it’s a romance so we know there was going to be a HEA.
If you read other reviews for sport romances, you know I love when I see the sport on played out on page. And I am happy to report that we do get to see hockey played! We even get to see a little of the fan interaction that the games have *wink* Besides our FMC & MMC, I also loved seeing the side romance between Maya’s brother Elliott and Cole’s teammate Logan. I feel like that could be a fun novella. I love how Carly introduced us to all these different characters without it feeling like it was too much. We were able to see how our MCs interacted with their friends and a tease of their personalities as well.
I wish I could re-read this again. It was just so much fun! I am already ready for the next book. I *think* I know who it is going to be about. And if it is who I think it is, it will be a fun time!!!!
I highly recommend if you are looking for your next hockey or sports romance series !
Bonus: There is an adorable chocolate lab name Goose who is the perfect companion for our MMC! And who equally falls for our leading lady.
This book will be out on November 6th.
If you have not read a Carly Robyn book, what are you waiting for?! I didn’t think I could love her writing or her books more but this one – chef’s kiss! I was first introduced to Carly’s work via her series on Formula One so when I saw she was doing a hockey series next, I was ready.
And this one was soooo good! I ate this one up from start to finish. I haven’t read a book with my eyes this fast in so long and boy it felt good. Did I go into her DMs screaming about our MMC Cole? Why yes I did. We love a man who knows what he wants and goes after it. I am notorious for not liking slow burns but I never have to worry when it comes to Carly’s slow burns because she gives me everything I need. There is so much banter and flirting that just makes me want to giggle, scream, kick my feet and gasp sometimes all at the same time.
“Thanks for making me talk.”
“Thanks for making my happy.”
Maya is labeled as a black cat which I totally can see how she can be but its never in a malicious way. She is just very cautious about what she gets wrapped up in. She never really does stuff for herself after years of being a caretaker for her younger siblings. And there was a moment (actually the moment when I went into the author’s DMs) where Cole is with Maya when she has dinner with her mom and siblings and gahhh my heart. I love a protective man who would do anything for the woman he loves. Cole was never shy about his feelings for her. And one thing I love that the author did with the characters, is that she made them talk. When someone was scared, they said it. “I’ve already fallen for you. And I’m scared, too. …I’m only human. So yeah, what I feel for you scares me, but I’m willing to give it a shot.” GAHHHHHH!
There was a plot point that I won’t spoil but I was nervous on how it was going to play out on page. I trust anything Carly does so I knew it would all be okay plus it’s a romance so we know there was going to be a HEA.
If you read other reviews for sport romances, you know I love when I see the sport on played out on page. And I am happy to report that we do get to see hockey played! We even get to see a little of the fan interaction that the games have *wink* Besides our FMC & MMC, I also loved seeing the side romance between Maya’s brother Elliott and Cole’s teammate Logan. I feel like that could be a fun novella. I love how Carly introduced us to all these different characters without it feeling like it was too much. We were able to see how our MCs interacted with their friends and a tease of their personalities as well.
I wish I could re-read this again. It was just so much fun! I am already ready for the next book. I *think* I know who it is going to be about. And if it is who I think it is, it will be a fun time!!!!
I highly recommend if you are looking for your next hockey or sports romance series !
Bonus: There is an adorable chocolate lab name Goose who is the perfect companion for our MMC! And who equally falls for our leading lady.
October 27, 2025
Thank you for the ARC!
Overall rating: 4
HEA/HFN: HFN
POV: 1st dual
Emojis to describe MMC: 🏒🦮🔥
Emojis to describe FMC: 🐈⬛ 💂💪🏼
Emojis to describe story as a whole: ❤️😍👏🏼🔥
What I liked: This was a super cute and easy read. There was a bit of angst and Maya was enough of a black cat to push back, but not come off as obnoxious.I can’t stand FMCs who are just straight up bitchy and unlikeable. Maya had her reasons for being standoffish. I liked the minor betrayal by the MMC (withheld truth). He felt bad and apologized, but the grand gesture actually came from her. I usually don’t like that but I didn’t mind it because she really made him work for it for about 50% of the book. Loved that we didn’t really have to hear about their love life before each other.
What I didn’t like: I didn't like that Cole ghosted her after their first time really hanging out. She really didn't seem to give him enough crap for it either. I understood why he did, but it didn't exactly fit with the rest of the vibe of the story. He did work to get her to give him a chance but he would have had to regardless because she was so guarded anyway.
Safety: Safe
OW/OM drama: There was a woman who jumped on Cole’s lap and forced a kiss on him at a club. Of course a camera caught it and it upsets Maya but she believes him when he explains what happened.
Cheating: None
3rd act breakup: Not really–there’s an argument but they aren’t apart long enough to count as a breakout IMO.
Celibate: Since meeting, yes. Cole mentioned he hasn’t been with anyone in a long time and it is implied that it was before his brother died (a few years ago). Not sure though. She just broke up with an ex who cheated on her.
Overall rating: 4
HEA/HFN: HFN
POV: 1st dual
Emojis to describe MMC: 🏒🦮🔥
Emojis to describe FMC: 🐈⬛ 💂💪🏼
Emojis to describe story as a whole: ❤️😍👏🏼🔥
What I liked: This was a super cute and easy read. There was a bit of angst and Maya was enough of a black cat to push back, but not come off as obnoxious.I can’t stand FMCs who are just straight up bitchy and unlikeable. Maya had her reasons for being standoffish. I liked the minor betrayal by the MMC (withheld truth). He felt bad and apologized, but the grand gesture actually came from her. I usually don’t like that but I didn’t mind it because she really made him work for it for about 50% of the book. Loved that we didn’t really have to hear about their love life before each other.
What I didn’t like: I didn't like that Cole ghosted her after their first time really hanging out. She really didn't seem to give him enough crap for it either. I understood why he did, but it didn't exactly fit with the rest of the vibe of the story. He did work to get her to give him a chance but he would have had to regardless because she was so guarded anyway.
Safety: Safe
OW/OM drama: There was a woman who jumped on Cole’s lap and forced a kiss on him at a club. Of course a camera caught it and it upsets Maya but she believes him when he explains what happened.
Cheating: None
3rd act breakup: Not really–there’s an argument but they aren’t apart long enough to count as a breakout IMO.
Celibate: Since meeting, yes. Cole mentioned he hasn’t been with anyone in a long time and it is implied that it was before his brother died (a few years ago). Not sure though. She just broke up with an ex who cheated on her.
November 5, 2025
4.5⭐️
Absolutely LOVED Ice Ice Baby.
Carly's writing is downright incredible. She literally had me laughing out loud during the first chapter and feeling the heat already between Maya and Cole.
Our FMC, Maya, always has her nose in a book. In fact, she even works at a bookstore. She adores reading romance, but she's convinced HEAs are only meant for works of fiction.
Our MMC, Cole, is an NHL star with an outgoing personality and a smile that could melt the panties off of anyone. Cole's determination isn't limited to hockey - no, when he has his sights set on something, or rather someone (aka Maya), he goes for it. And Cole is bound and determined to show Maya that HEAs don't just exist in books and she deserves to have it all.
The deadpan humor in Carly's books is always some of my favorite. It's so lighthearted and often relatable that you can't help but let loose a loud laugh.
I literally could not keep the silly grin off my face the entire book. These two were so freaking cute together with their banter, sarcasm, and flirting.
Just like I ate up Carly's F1 series, I'm so excited to devour the rest of the Boston Bobcats books as they release because I just know I'll love them!
Thank you so much to Carly and VPR for my eARC!
Highly recommend Ice Ice Baby for lovers of:
- hockey romance
- opposites attract
- black cat x golden retriever
- bookworm x NHL player
- slow burn
- he falls first
- banter
Absolutely LOVED Ice Ice Baby.
Carly's writing is downright incredible. She literally had me laughing out loud during the first chapter and feeling the heat already between Maya and Cole.
Our FMC, Maya, always has her nose in a book. In fact, she even works at a bookstore. She adores reading romance, but she's convinced HEAs are only meant for works of fiction.
Our MMC, Cole, is an NHL star with an outgoing personality and a smile that could melt the panties off of anyone. Cole's determination isn't limited to hockey - no, when he has his sights set on something, or rather someone (aka Maya), he goes for it. And Cole is bound and determined to show Maya that HEAs don't just exist in books and she deserves to have it all.
The deadpan humor in Carly's books is always some of my favorite. It's so lighthearted and often relatable that you can't help but let loose a loud laugh.
I literally could not keep the silly grin off my face the entire book. These two were so freaking cute together with their banter, sarcasm, and flirting.
Just like I ate up Carly's F1 series, I'm so excited to devour the rest of the Boston Bobcats books as they release because I just know I'll love them!
Thank you so much to Carly and VPR for my eARC!
Highly recommend Ice Ice Baby for lovers of:
- hockey romance
- opposites attract
- black cat x golden retriever
- bookworm x NHL player
- slow burn
- he falls first
- banter
November 3, 2025
Ice Ice Baby
Author: Carly Robyn
ARC Review: ⭐⭐⭐⭐/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️.5
Tropes:
- Sports Romance
- Black Cat × Golden Retriever
- He's obsessed with her
- Slow Burn
- Strangers to Lovers
- Opposites attract
- Book Manager × Hockey player
- Banter
- Dual POV
Ice Ice Baby felt like a warm comforting blanket which I'd turn to after a long stressful day. The story is slow paced, slow burn romance that starts with simmering tension with constant push and pull between Maya and Cole.
Maya is a bookstore manager who is a hopeless romantic by heart but believes real love does not exist in real life, at least for her. In true black cat personality sense, she seems closed off at first but for people she loves, she's fiercely protective.
Nicholas "Cole" Berett is the captain of Boston Bobcats, dedicating his life to hockey and making his dreams true — until his eyes landed on Maya, who happens to be least interested in hockey. Instantly enamored by her candor and passion for books, he is on a mission to make her fall in love with him.
With Maya's hyperindependency and apprehension towards Cole, Cole is determined to prove he is her happily ever forever!
With their constant back and forth banter, simmering chemistry and unfurling of the complexity of their characters the story paints a beautiful picture of their struggle of finding each other. I absolutely adored Maya's character development, it made me fall in love with the characters all over again.
The book also touches the topic of off page death of a sibling, abandonment issues and absent parent.
If you love a sports romance with multilayered characters and amazing friendships, get this book!
Author: Carly Robyn
ARC Review: ⭐⭐⭐⭐/5
Spice: 🌶️🌶️.5
Tropes:
- Sports Romance
- Black Cat × Golden Retriever
- He's obsessed with her
- Slow Burn
- Strangers to Lovers
- Opposites attract
- Book Manager × Hockey player
- Banter
- Dual POV
Ice Ice Baby felt like a warm comforting blanket which I'd turn to after a long stressful day. The story is slow paced, slow burn romance that starts with simmering tension with constant push and pull between Maya and Cole.
Maya is a bookstore manager who is a hopeless romantic by heart but believes real love does not exist in real life, at least for her. In true black cat personality sense, she seems closed off at first but for people she loves, she's fiercely protective.
Nicholas "Cole" Berett is the captain of Boston Bobcats, dedicating his life to hockey and making his dreams true — until his eyes landed on Maya, who happens to be least interested in hockey. Instantly enamored by her candor and passion for books, he is on a mission to make her fall in love with him.
With Maya's hyperindependency and apprehension towards Cole, Cole is determined to prove he is her happily ever forever!
With their constant back and forth banter, simmering chemistry and unfurling of the complexity of their characters the story paints a beautiful picture of their struggle of finding each other. I absolutely adored Maya's character development, it made me fall in love with the characters all over again.
The book also touches the topic of off page death of a sibling, abandonment issues and absent parent.
If you love a sports romance with multilayered characters and amazing friendships, get this book!
November 8, 2025
⋆.𐙚 ̊ ᴀʀᴄ ʀᴇᴠɪᴇᴡ ⋆.𐙚 ̊
ɪᴄᴇ ɪᴄᴇ ʙᴀʙʏ ʙʏ @carlyrobynauthor
4.5★
ᴍʏ ᴏᴘɪɴɪᴏɴ -
Carly has done it again and oh my I absolutely loved these two and the slow burn!? These two had me laughing, crying, and twirling my hair
Cole Barrett is the hockey captain and oh how I love him he’s so amazing and has golden retriever energy written all over him and he’s also a dog daddy! I love me some goose
Their chemistry and banter is just so amazing these two like each other but is just “friends” yeahhhh okay loll
I love me a good hockey romance and this one was no different I devoured it in one sitting I couldn’t get enough of these two
Maya is a book store manager and I love her so. She’s so me I get her so much. She doesn’t believe in happy ever after only the one in the books but then a certain someone proves her wrong so fast
The went from strangers who didn’t even know each other to something so much more and I loved seeing it happen how they both just opened up and just fall in love it was amazing
I can’t wait for the next book in the series I just know it’s going to be amazing!
📚🏒 what to expect
-Black cat x Golden Retriever
-Dog Daddy
-Found Family
-Hockey Romance
-Bookish FMC
-Slow burn
-Banter Banter Banter
-Strangers to lovers
-Opposites Attract
-He Falls First
Thank you @carlyrobynauthor for giving me this arc ⭐️
ɪᴄᴇ ɪᴄᴇ ʙᴀʙʏ ʙʏ @carlyrobynauthor
4.5★
ᴍʏ ᴏᴘɪɴɪᴏɴ -
Carly has done it again and oh my I absolutely loved these two and the slow burn!? These two had me laughing, crying, and twirling my hair
Cole Barrett is the hockey captain and oh how I love him he’s so amazing and has golden retriever energy written all over him and he’s also a dog daddy! I love me some goose
Their chemistry and banter is just so amazing these two like each other but is just “friends” yeahhhh okay loll
I love me a good hockey romance and this one was no different I devoured it in one sitting I couldn’t get enough of these two
Maya is a book store manager and I love her so. She’s so me I get her so much. She doesn’t believe in happy ever after only the one in the books but then a certain someone proves her wrong so fast
The went from strangers who didn’t even know each other to something so much more and I loved seeing it happen how they both just opened up and just fall in love it was amazing
I can’t wait for the next book in the series I just know it’s going to be amazing!
📚🏒 what to expect
-Black cat x Golden Retriever
-Dog Daddy
-Found Family
-Hockey Romance
-Bookish FMC
-Slow burn
-Banter Banter Banter
-Strangers to lovers
-Opposites Attract
-He Falls First
Thank you @carlyrobynauthor for giving me this arc ⭐️
November 9, 2025
After not reading anything for 2 months this book was the perfect story I needed to ease back into reading!! I loved everything about Cole & Maya!! They were so fun to read!! I love how quickly these characters bonded. It was very easy and their flow was so effortless! I love how the banter was written and how it started off of them being friends first and Cole slowly winning Maya over! This couple had so many good friendship moments and romantic moments and I loved seeing them slowly blend together as you read! Reading about Cole really was my favourite thing becuase Cole was almost cocky in a way but also grounded. I loved reading his pov he was a very funny character. He had a lot of sarcasm to him that was really fun to read. He was always so forward with Maya but also gentle and so so sweet and attentive. Maya was very sweet and shy. I think due to personal stuff going on with me right now I really related to Maya’s character and her story more than I normally would. Normally I’m not the biggest fan of hockey romances but Carly delivers every-time!!! I loved this story so much!!!
November 2, 2025
I've loved all of Carly Robyn's other books, but this one may be my favorite so far! I live for a hockey romance, and the chemistry between Maya and Cole was top-tier. The bookstore manager aspect was great, too, and I saw a lot of myself in her character, especially as the eldest child and daughter. I liked watching their relationship go from friends to lovers. It was so sweet, and Cole definitely hit the mark as a new book boyfriend (IYKYK). The spice was a fun addition, but didn't take over the sweet moments of the love story, and I thought everything was so well done. I enjoyed the quick cameo from Ella on the podcast. I'll be thinking about these characters for a while, and I really loved reading this one. I hope Carly Robyn continues the series! Thank you to Valentine PR for the eARC to read and review!
November 6, 2025
[arc review]
i think i might be entering my hockey (or as my friends call it, the boy aquarium) era. i know absolutely nothing about the sport but the world that carly has created for maya and cole has been so fun to read.
i love maya and cole. they’re a gorgeous couple (hello have you seen the cover) and i think carly has built them perfectly. their banter has not failed to make me smile and i giggled at all of maya’s comments to cole. she has an asshole of an ex, who doesn’t seem to understand the word no so it makes sense that she’s protective of her heart and who she allows in. she wants a book-worthy romance and she deserves nothing less than that.
cole fell in love at first sight and just like goose, he’s a cutie. he was confident and outspoken about his feelings for maya. he’s also sweet, observant and so caring. he doesn’t even really have to try because even i fell in love with him so fast and he’s just UGH so great.
honorable mention for goose because you’re gonna find me on the floor playing with him.
i think i might be entering my hockey (or as my friends call it, the boy aquarium) era. i know absolutely nothing about the sport but the world that carly has created for maya and cole has been so fun to read.
i love maya and cole. they’re a gorgeous couple (hello have you seen the cover) and i think carly has built them perfectly. their banter has not failed to make me smile and i giggled at all of maya’s comments to cole. she has an asshole of an ex, who doesn’t seem to understand the word no so it makes sense that she’s protective of her heart and who she allows in. she wants a book-worthy romance and she deserves nothing less than that.
cole fell in love at first sight and just like goose, he’s a cutie. he was confident and outspoken about his feelings for maya. he’s also sweet, observant and so caring. he doesn’t even really have to try because even i fell in love with him so fast and he’s just UGH so great.
honorable mention for goose because you’re gonna find me on the floor playing with him.
November 12, 2025
Arc Review
HELLO CARLY AND WELCOME TO THE HOCKEY ROMANCE WORLD!!!!!
I absolutely loved this book. If you are a book girlie that is obsessed with hockey romances this book is for you!!! I loved the FMC, Maya. She's a romance reader to her core, but would rather read about characters falling in love that allow herself to ever fall in love to only experience heartbreak. She was essentially a single guardian her entire life because her parents couldn't stick around. I loved that Nicolas fell first and just constantly showed up for Maya. Even when she repeatedly stuck him in a "friends only" box. He took what she could give, and he just waited patiently for her to be ready for all the love that she deserved.
These two were just so precious and I couldn't put the book down once I started it!
HELLO CARLY AND WELCOME TO THE HOCKEY ROMANCE WORLD!!!!!
I absolutely loved this book. If you are a book girlie that is obsessed with hockey romances this book is for you!!! I loved the FMC, Maya. She's a romance reader to her core, but would rather read about characters falling in love that allow herself to ever fall in love to only experience heartbreak. She was essentially a single guardian her entire life because her parents couldn't stick around. I loved that Nicolas fell first and just constantly showed up for Maya. Even when she repeatedly stuck him in a "friends only" box. He took what she could give, and he just waited patiently for her to be ready for all the love that she deserved.
These two were just so precious and I couldn't put the book down once I started it!
November 25, 2025
—— 4.5 ★
⤿〝 When people are down, they want comfort. When they’re happy, they want something that amplifies that joy. Books meet you where you are. 〞
! Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for the copy and the opportunity to read the arc of this book !
⤷ I'm going to be very honest with this and I loved every moment from the first chapter. This book is how I wanted my life to be if I could, I mean, owner of my own bookstore and the captain of the city's hockey team falls in love with me??? SIGN ME UP FOR THAT LIFE. I sincerely feel that this book represents what any sport romance reader wanted to experience. In addition to the fact that there is no trait of toxicity in their relationship and it is something that I have missed lately. One of my favorite readings of the month without hesitation 🙂↕️🙂↕️🙂↕️
⤷ characters .ᐟ
⋆˙⟡ Maya
she’s me, i’m she, I've seen myself so reflected in her that she's a character who right now is under my skin, I love her character and her way of being and how her insecurities and feelings are shown and how she manages them
❝ “If you think I don’t feel the same way about you, then you took a few too many hits to the head last period.” I laugh, leaning against him. “For the first time in my life, I don’t want to disappear into my books so I can live another person’s love story. Because you’re not only who I want, but who I need.” ❞
⋆˙⟡ Cole
He is a golden retriever from head to toe, the way he has been so patient with Maya has been everything. But what I have loved most about him is that despite the possible insta love, the insecurity on his part is shown at the beginning which fits very well with his character and how he works that while trying to conquer Maya. Honestly, he's a first-class book boyfriend .🙂↕️ Plus he asked her for her favorite book so he can read it and talk about it with her even though he doesn’t like to read that much 🥹
❝ I have no nefarious intentions. All I want is to make her happy. Happily ever afters exist outside of books, you know. ❞
⤿〝 When people are down, they want comfort. When they’re happy, they want something that amplifies that joy. Books meet you where you are. 〞
! Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for the copy and the opportunity to read the arc of this book !
⤷ I'm going to be very honest with this and I loved every moment from the first chapter. This book is how I wanted my life to be if I could, I mean, owner of my own bookstore and the captain of the city's hockey team falls in love with me??? SIGN ME UP FOR THAT LIFE. I sincerely feel that this book represents what any sport romance reader wanted to experience. In addition to the fact that there is no trait of toxicity in their relationship and it is something that I have missed lately. One of my favorite readings of the month without hesitation 🙂↕️🙂↕️🙂↕️
⤷ characters .ᐟ
⋆˙⟡ Maya
she’s me, i’m she, I've seen myself so reflected in her that she's a character who right now is under my skin, I love her character and her way of being and how her insecurities and feelings are shown and how she manages them
❝ “If you think I don’t feel the same way about you, then you took a few too many hits to the head last period.” I laugh, leaning against him. “For the first time in my life, I don’t want to disappear into my books so I can live another person’s love story. Because you’re not only who I want, but who I need.” ❞
⋆˙⟡ Cole
He is a golden retriever from head to toe, the way he has been so patient with Maya has been everything. But what I have loved most about him is that despite the possible insta love, the insecurity on his part is shown at the beginning which fits very well with his character and how he works that while trying to conquer Maya. Honestly, he's a first-class book boyfriend .🙂↕️ Plus he asked her for her favorite book so he can read it and talk about it with her even though he doesn’t like to read that much 🥹
❝ I have no nefarious intentions. All I want is to make her happy. Happily ever afters exist outside of books, you know. ❞
November 18, 2025
Thank you Carly Robyn and Valentine PR for the ARC!
This actually started out okay for me. I loved the way they met, and I was really excited for the story. And though I still enjoyed some parts of this book, like the way grief was represented and the eldest sister dynamic Maya had with her siblings, it just ended up falling a little flat for me at the end.
One thing that really confused me was that these characters were supposed to be in their late twenties, yet they read like teenagers/young adults. And the whole thing with her being a book lover just got a little too much to the point that it was cringe. The relationship also got so cheesy at some point and the nicknames, oh my god! I couldn’t deal with them.
Anyways, this was overall a very easy and quick read but it just wasn’t for me.
This actually started out okay for me. I loved the way they met, and I was really excited for the story. And though I still enjoyed some parts of this book, like the way grief was represented and the eldest sister dynamic Maya had with her siblings, it just ended up falling a little flat for me at the end.
One thing that really confused me was that these characters were supposed to be in their late twenties, yet they read like teenagers/young adults. And the whole thing with her being a book lover just got a little too much to the point that it was cringe. The relationship also got so cheesy at some point and the nicknames, oh my god! I couldn’t deal with them.
Anyways, this was overall a very easy and quick read but it just wasn’t for me.
November 17, 2025
I love Cole & Maya 🥹💙
I love a good he falls first and Cole fell first and HARD. 😮💨 Maya was so funny and she made me laugh multiple times. She is quirky and here for a good time. They are so cute together and their banter was delicious. And the spice? Also delicious. I loved that the characters became friends before lovers and they did it so good. It was a great start to the series and I can’t wait for more!!
Tropes:
hockey romance
he falls first
slow burn
black cat x golden retriever
opposites attract
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for the advanced copy 🫶🏼
I love a good he falls first and Cole fell first and HARD. 😮💨 Maya was so funny and she made me laugh multiple times. She is quirky and here for a good time. They are so cute together and their banter was delicious. And the spice? Also delicious. I loved that the characters became friends before lovers and they did it so good. It was a great start to the series and I can’t wait for more!!
Tropes:
hockey romance
he falls first
slow burn
black cat x golden retriever
opposites attract
Thank you Valentine PR and Carly Robyn for the advanced copy 🫶🏼
October 27, 2025
Maya and Cole had such a sweet slow burn. How they went from strangers to friends to lovers, it was so beautiful.
They had such a sweet meet cute, and while they both were a little apprehensive about each other, but how they built a friendship which formed such a beautiful relationship.
And the spice, wow. Her romance reader status definitely brought some hawt d!rty talk ;)
Thank you Carly and Valentine PR for an advanced copy.
They had such a sweet meet cute, and while they both were a little apprehensive about each other, but how they built a friendship which formed such a beautiful relationship.
And the spice, wow. Her romance reader status definitely brought some hawt d!rty talk ;)
Thank you Carly and Valentine PR for an advanced copy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 429 reviews