What do you think?
Rate this book
Someday Perfect
In this beautiful graphic novel, a teen is tested when she falls for another camper at a Christian sleepaway camp, sparking feelings she was taught to suppress. As she grapples with the rigid expectations of her faith, she embarks on a journey of self-discovery that challenges her deepest beliefs.
Summer camp is supposed to be a place to find yourself, but when you're sent to a Christian sleepaway camp, that can be hard to do. Hemmed in by how she presents herself at school, and the expectations of her pastor father, Meg finds it hard to know just how she feels about herself... let alone how others feel about her.
When Meg runs into Danny, a soft and charming boy who also comes to the camp every summer, her feelings start to flourish. Unfortunately, with these feelings come questions. How is she supposed to fulfill the role she is supposed to play when her heart and her faith are both questioning?
This gorgeously illustrated graphic novel speaks to complexity of faith, while also exploring the power of first loves and the complicated feelings they can bring.
Summer camp is supposed to be a place to find yourself, but when you're sent to a Christian sleepaway camp, that can be hard to do. Hemmed in by how she presents herself at school, and the expectations of her pastor father, Meg finds it hard to know just how she feels about herself... let alone how others feel about her.
When Meg runs into Danny, a soft and charming boy who also comes to the camp every summer, her feelings start to flourish. Unfortunately, with these feelings come questions. How is she supposed to fulfill the role she is supposed to play when her heart and her faith are both questioning?
This gorgeously illustrated graphic novel speaks to complexity of faith, while also exploring the power of first loves and the complicated feelings they can bring.
288 pages, Paperback
First published April 21, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
May 4, 2026
Very subtle, very interesting, very unresolved—but is that a problem? I get the sense this is intended for young readers questioning Christianity but not yet fully outside of it, and I can't fault the author for not having a full religious epiphany take place in the third act. It can be a little difficult to read something that is essentially just a play-by-play of all the struggles of young women in Christian camps—of which there are many!—but it also worked for the story without having to all be tied up in a neat little bow. Not the transcendent experience that is
This One Summer,
but didn't leave me wanting too badly.
December 7, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an e-copy in exchange for an honest review.
Meg is struggling with her faith, which is something I think many people can relate to. When difficult things happen in life, it’s natural to question why a loving God would allow them. While I wouldn’t say I loved this story, I do think it had a clear focus on Meg’s internal conflict with religion and belief.
The narrative heavily centers on faith, particularly highlighting the hypocrisy often found in spaces like Bible camp. I appreciated how the story pointed out the double standards placed on women, who are criticized for the smallest things while men are frequently praised or excused. That commentary felt honest and relevant.
Religion has always been a complicated topic for me personally, so this book resonated in some ways even if it didn’t fully deliver what I was hoping for overall.
Still, I think it’s a worthwhile read and one I would recommend, especially for readers interested in stories that explore faith, doubt, and institutional hypocrisy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 8, 2025
Meg is conflicted. She knows she is supposed to remain pure, and adhere to the teachings at the Bible Camp that she is working at, but it is hard to do, now that she has gone to public school, and seen things outside of her religion, such as nude statues at the museum.
She tries to be good, trying to dress modestly, frustrated that the boys don’t have the same rules. Then she falls for Danny, and she wonders if he is the “one” that she is meant to fall in love with. She gets herself all caught up in what she thinks love should be about, not realizing that it really isn’t.
An interesting journey where she had to work with what she had. Beautifully illustrated, especially when she let her rage come out, and you see her growing taller and taller.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review. This book is being published on the 21sth of April 2026.
She tries to be good, trying to dress modestly, frustrated that the boys don’t have the same rules. Then she falls for Danny, and she wonders if he is the “one” that she is meant to fall in love with. She gets herself all caught up in what she thinks love should be about, not realizing that it really isn’t.
An interesting journey where she had to work with what she had. Beautifully illustrated, especially when she let her rage come out, and you see her growing taller and taller.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review. This book is being published on the 21sth of April 2026.
November 13, 2025
beautiful
May 12, 2026
Set at a Christian summer camp, Someday Perfect follows a teen girl’s coming-of-age as she grapples with issues of faith, purity culture, and first love. Our protagonist, Meg, is returning to her summer camp as a counselor, where she is expected to set an example for the other campers by behaving and dressing modestly. Although she enjoys spending time with her friends and working at the camp, she finds herself struggling with her faith and how her beliefs align with the strict edicts set for her and the other camp members. For example, while the male campers are allowed more freedom with their dress code, the female campers are expected to wear clothes with longer hem lines, one-piece swimsuits, and cover-ups any time they’re not swimming in the lake. Counselors must also keep at least six inches of space between each other, which proves to be difficult as the teens naturally want to explore their feelings with one another. Meg hopes that she won’t succumb to these desires like some of her friends, but finds that she can’t fight her feelings for fellow camper, Danny, whom she has had a crush on for the past few years. What ensues is a summer of discovery as Meg learns what it means to stick up for what she believes in, while also not being afraid to question everything she has ever known. Main characters cue as white, with more racial diversity being present in supporting characters.
I found this book to be a very thoughtful portrayal of one teen’s journey of self-discovery, which was helped by Kat Schneider’s use of soft colors in her illustrations. Meg is a very subtle main character, but her quiet nature doesn’t detract from her relatability. She still experiences quite a lot of emotions, expressed through tears, anger, blushing, etc., which all comes together at the end of the novel when she experiences a betrayal from someone close to her. I loved how this scene showed Meg’s strength and power, not only through her words (“I deserve honesty. I deserve the truth”), but through Schneider’s illustrations, which show Meg growing larger and larger as her confidence grows, until she is tall enough to break through the trees. The novel has these metaphorical drawings sprinkled throughout so that the artwork adds to the story without depending on dialogue. Schneider does not shy away from showing Meg having critical thoughts toward the beliefs of her church and faith, but she also does not have her condemn Christianity completely. I found the scene in which Meg reassures another camper that “God is real, Kay. I promise”, while also pondering the idea that “I know that none of us can ever truly be perfect, but is that God’s standard, or a man-made standard?” very powerful. I think a lot of readers will find comfort in the fact that Meg doesn’t completely abandon her faith in this situation, but instead chooses to adapt her beliefs to fit her lifestyle. Link to complete review: https://ysbookreviews.wordpress.com/2...
I found this book to be a very thoughtful portrayal of one teen’s journey of self-discovery, which was helped by Kat Schneider’s use of soft colors in her illustrations. Meg is a very subtle main character, but her quiet nature doesn’t detract from her relatability. She still experiences quite a lot of emotions, expressed through tears, anger, blushing, etc., which all comes together at the end of the novel when she experiences a betrayal from someone close to her. I loved how this scene showed Meg’s strength and power, not only through her words (“I deserve honesty. I deserve the truth”), but through Schneider’s illustrations, which show Meg growing larger and larger as her confidence grows, until she is tall enough to break through the trees. The novel has these metaphorical drawings sprinkled throughout so that the artwork adds to the story without depending on dialogue. Schneider does not shy away from showing Meg having critical thoughts toward the beliefs of her church and faith, but she also does not have her condemn Christianity completely. I found the scene in which Meg reassures another camper that “God is real, Kay. I promise”, while also pondering the idea that “I know that none of us can ever truly be perfect, but is that God’s standard, or a man-made standard?” very powerful. I think a lot of readers will find comfort in the fact that Meg doesn’t completely abandon her faith in this situation, but instead chooses to adapt her beliefs to fit her lifestyle. Link to complete review: https://ysbookreviews.wordpress.com/2...
May 14, 2026
Someday Perfect is a graphic novel by Kat Schneider about a girl named Meg, whose father is a pastor, and who is spending the summer at a Christian sleep-away camp. Meg’s friends at camp start bending the rules, and she starts crushing on a boy, named Danny, and suddenly she’s not sure what to believe: the teachings of her father and her church or what her friends and her heart want her to do.
The illustrations were eye-catching, engaging, and help the reader move back and forth in time as she reflects on her previous school year at her first non-denominational school and her present-day experiences at camp; the illustrations from the previous year are always in blue, unlike the scenes that take place in the present day. When Meg’s mind wanders during meetings or sermons, the illustrations blur the words so they fall into the background for the reader as well.
Some aspects of this book could be triggering for some readers, especially those who might struggle to read about sexism or religious trauma. For example, we see how much the camp leaders focus on the girls being modest, criticize their choices, make them serve the males at the camp, and shame them for any perceived mistakes or immodesty. The tension between the teachings of the camp and Meg and the other girls’ inner voices is the main conflict in the book. While it’s published as about a summer crush, a lot of the book is really about the damage these religious teachings can do; several of the girls demonstrate struggles with their mental health. This would be a good fit for readers who appreciate graphic novels, want a window into someone else’s experience, or who liked Gaytheist. Readers who are already struggling with their mental health or beliefs might be better served by a read that reinforces their worth and value; while Schneider presents some potentially harmful beliefs, this isn’t balanced by any of the characters affirming their self-worth. This was a three-star read for me.
The illustrations were eye-catching, engaging, and help the reader move back and forth in time as she reflects on her previous school year at her first non-denominational school and her present-day experiences at camp; the illustrations from the previous year are always in blue, unlike the scenes that take place in the present day. When Meg’s mind wanders during meetings or sermons, the illustrations blur the words so they fall into the background for the reader as well.
Some aspects of this book could be triggering for some readers, especially those who might struggle to read about sexism or religious trauma. For example, we see how much the camp leaders focus on the girls being modest, criticize their choices, make them serve the males at the camp, and shame them for any perceived mistakes or immodesty. The tension between the teachings of the camp and Meg and the other girls’ inner voices is the main conflict in the book. While it’s published as about a summer crush, a lot of the book is really about the damage these religious teachings can do; several of the girls demonstrate struggles with their mental health. This would be a good fit for readers who appreciate graphic novels, want a window into someone else’s experience, or who liked Gaytheist. Readers who are already struggling with their mental health or beliefs might be better served by a read that reinforces their worth and value; while Schneider presents some potentially harmful beliefs, this isn’t balanced by any of the characters affirming their self-worth. This was a three-star read for me.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Netgalley for the free arc! This graphic novel was okay. I like to read graphic novels as windows into experiences that I have never had and want to learn more about. I was intrigued by the topic of a teen going to a Christian sleepaway camp as she grapples with feelings that she has about a boy with expectations of how she is supposed to behave as a good Christian. Ultimately, this story seemed to lack much plot and since I had never experienced this before, I felt it was a bit difficult to relate. Perhaps people who have gone to Christian sleepaway camp were able to connect more with this story.
In this beautiful graphic novel, a teen is tested when she falls for another camper at a Christian sleepaway camp, sparking feelings she was taught to suppress. As she grapples with the rigid expectations of her faith, she embarks on a journey of self-discovery that challenges her deepest beliefs.
Summer camp is supposed to be a place to find yourself, but when you're sent to a Christian sleepaway camp, that can be hard to do. Hemmed in by how she presents herself at school, and the expectations of her pastor father, Meg finds it hard to know just how she feels about herself... let alone how others feel about her.
When Meg runs into Danny, a soft and charming boy who also comes to the camp every summer, her feelings start to flourish. Unfortunately, with these feelings come questions. How is she supposed to fulfill the role she is supposed to play when her heart and her faith are both questioning?
This gorgeously illustrated graphic novel speaks to complexity of faith, while also exploring the power of first loves and the complicated feelings they can bring.
In this beautiful graphic novel, a teen is tested when she falls for another camper at a Christian sleepaway camp, sparking feelings she was taught to suppress. As she grapples with the rigid expectations of her faith, she embarks on a journey of self-discovery that challenges her deepest beliefs.
Summer camp is supposed to be a place to find yourself, but when you're sent to a Christian sleepaway camp, that can be hard to do. Hemmed in by how she presents herself at school, and the expectations of her pastor father, Meg finds it hard to know just how she feels about herself... let alone how others feel about her.
When Meg runs into Danny, a soft and charming boy who also comes to the camp every summer, her feelings start to flourish. Unfortunately, with these feelings come questions. How is she supposed to fulfill the role she is supposed to play when her heart and her faith are both questioning?
This gorgeously illustrated graphic novel speaks to complexity of faith, while also exploring the power of first loves and the complicated feelings they can bring.
May 20, 2026
“Someday Perfect is a deeply tender and emotionally honest graphic novel that thoughtfully explores faith, identity, self discovery, and first love with remarkable compassion and nuance. Kat Schneider creates a story that feels intimate and emotionally authentic, capturing the confusion, vulnerability, and longing that can accompany adolescence especially when personal feelings begin to challenge deeply ingrained expectations surrounding religion, family, and belonging.”
“What stood out most was the emotional realism behind Meg’s internal conflict. Her struggle is never simplified into easy answers or dramatic extremes; instead, the novel carefully explores the quiet emotional tension between faith, personal truth, family expectations, and the fear of disappointing the people she loves. The developing relationship between Meg and Danny feels gentle, sincere, and emotionally grounded, allowing their connection to unfold naturally through small moments of trust, curiosity, and emotional vulnerability. The summer camp setting also adds a fascinating emotional backdrop, creating an environment where community, spirituality, pressure, and self-exploration constantly intersect. The artwork beautifully reinforces the emotional atmosphere of the story, balancing softness, introspection, warmth, and emotional ache in ways that make the narrative feel deeply immersive. Thoughtful, compassionate, and emotionally resonant, Someday Perfect is a powerful coming-of-age graphic novel about questioning expectations, listening to one’s inner voice, and learning that identity and faith are often far more complicated than simple binaries allow.”
“What stood out most was the emotional realism behind Meg’s internal conflict. Her struggle is never simplified into easy answers or dramatic extremes; instead, the novel carefully explores the quiet emotional tension between faith, personal truth, family expectations, and the fear of disappointing the people she loves. The developing relationship between Meg and Danny feels gentle, sincere, and emotionally grounded, allowing their connection to unfold naturally through small moments of trust, curiosity, and emotional vulnerability. The summer camp setting also adds a fascinating emotional backdrop, creating an environment where community, spirituality, pressure, and self-exploration constantly intersect. The artwork beautifully reinforces the emotional atmosphere of the story, balancing softness, introspection, warmth, and emotional ache in ways that make the narrative feel deeply immersive. Thoughtful, compassionate, and emotionally resonant, Someday Perfect is a powerful coming-of-age graphic novel about questioning expectations, listening to one’s inner voice, and learning that identity and faith are often far more complicated than simple binaries allow.”
August 8, 2025
Subtle, emotional, and beautiful, Someday Perfect is an absolute triumph of teen literature.
Whether you grew up in organized religion or not, you’ll see yourself in Meg’s story. Her desire to understand the systems set in place around her while also searching for acceptance and a feeling of belonging is so inherently human. Kat handles potentially sensitive subject matter with care, never once telling the reader how they “should” feel, instead just asking questions any teen girl would ask. “Why am I thinking about boys so much if it’s wrong?” “This skirt is comfortable - why can’t I wear it?” Understanding and unpacking trauma related to organized religion is rarely one single “aha” moment, it’s years of asking questions and having experiences that help you solidify your beliefs on your own terms. For Meg, this is just the beginning. I predict Someday Perfect will be that beginning for many readers, too. It’s not just a graphic novel, it’s a place to find solace when nothing else makes sense; a place to be accepted for exactly who you are.
Also, the mid-2000s cell phone representation is incredible. A Pink Razr AND a blue LG chocolate? My middle school self feels so seen <3
Whether you grew up in organized religion or not, you’ll see yourself in Meg’s story. Her desire to understand the systems set in place around her while also searching for acceptance and a feeling of belonging is so inherently human. Kat handles potentially sensitive subject matter with care, never once telling the reader how they “should” feel, instead just asking questions any teen girl would ask. “Why am I thinking about boys so much if it’s wrong?” “This skirt is comfortable - why can’t I wear it?” Understanding and unpacking trauma related to organized religion is rarely one single “aha” moment, it’s years of asking questions and having experiences that help you solidify your beliefs on your own terms. For Meg, this is just the beginning. I predict Someday Perfect will be that beginning for many readers, too. It’s not just a graphic novel, it’s a place to find solace when nothing else makes sense; a place to be accepted for exactly who you are.
Also, the mid-2000s cell phone representation is incredible. A Pink Razr AND a blue LG chocolate? My middle school self feels so seen <3
April 26, 2026
Meg, the protagonist in this graphic novel, has mixed feelings about spending part of her summer at Christian camp. The daughter of a pastor, she's been taught right from wrong, but sometimes the expectations of her church seem rigid and unrealistic. Her recent experiences at a public school have left her questioning some of those rules, something she continues to do at camp. There, she reunites with camp friends, who seem to have become boy crazy, and spends time with Danny, a charming boy who flirts with her and on whom she's crushing. Still, she's troubled by the different expectations for boys and girls, including clothing and behavior. Nothing seems clearcut, and when she learns the truth about Danny and then hears the confessions of Kayla, a friend who's been involved with another boy, her world is rocked. The artwork in this graphic novel is impressive, filled with light colors and the wonder of Meg's questions and discoveries. Many teen readers will see themselves in Meg who expresses herself through art and who is judged by the length of her clothing.
December 12, 2025
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for an arc of this copy!
I'm a little biased because my love for graphic novels started my reading journey from a young age so this was automatically going to be a hit. But the Christian elements elevated this book even more for me! I loved this book and it was very easy to fly through this.
What is this book about: Meg goes to a Bible study camp for the summer, and she is doubting what she wants vs. God's plans for her. She's dealing with friendship and relationship troubles as well as the Bible camps old teachings. This book delves into the teenage experience with faith of feeling kind of ashamed to tell people about him and also just confused with his word.
I recommend this to all teens who wants faith filled themes in trusting God's word and not following outdated teachings would not make God love you any less. This book also has self worth themes for relationship which is great to read at this day and age. I absolutely love the art style and I'm thankful for reading this book 💕
I'm a little biased because my love for graphic novels started my reading journey from a young age so this was automatically going to be a hit. But the Christian elements elevated this book even more for me! I loved this book and it was very easy to fly through this.
What is this book about: Meg goes to a Bible study camp for the summer, and she is doubting what she wants vs. God's plans for her. She's dealing with friendship and relationship troubles as well as the Bible camps old teachings. This book delves into the teenage experience with faith of feeling kind of ashamed to tell people about him and also just confused with his word.
I recommend this to all teens who wants faith filled themes in trusting God's word and not following outdated teachings would not make God love you any less. This book also has self worth themes for relationship which is great to read at this day and age. I absolutely love the art style and I'm thankful for reading this book 💕
April 30, 2026
An interesting look into the complexities of coming of age within a religious mindset. The narrative does an effective job showcasing how conflicting emerging romantic emotions can be with what faith has taught these characters to believe is morally right. It's some of the first times that these kids are getting to experience what the text they've been taught looks like in reality and how that ideal doesn't necessarily manifest how you'd expected it to. The exploration of religion's innate misogyny was also well done. I do think that the graphic novel would've been more successful with its intentions if it either leaned more into slice of life territory or added a bit more plot into the mix, because currently it's in a bit of a frustrating middle ground. Truly a lovely art style that I'd definitely seek out more in the future.
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Graphic for the arc!
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Graphic for the arc!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This graphic novel is about a girl trying to find herself. She’s spending two weeks as a volunteer maid or cafeteria worker at a religious summer camp. But even though she was raised in this religion, she’s finding some of its morals and rules to be suffocating. She’s having a hard time finding herself and who she should be and where she fits in. This book is in a look at a girl’s internal struggle between what society thinks she should be, and what she knows she should be. This book is well done, and I love how the author illustrated the difference between the past and present. The story flows very well, and it is an interesting read. It’s not one I would read again. I would put it in my library, but it is not a go-to recommendation and I unless I knew a kid was having some of the same issues.
Read
May 5, 2026In contrast to Blankets, this engages with Christianity in a wishy-washy kinda, noncommittal way. The main character questions things about her religion but doesn't dig past surface-level questions.
What it does do well though, is provide a snapshot of a girl's life in the throes of that religion. Where it lacks depth in questioning the Bible, it pulls no punches in what the questionable parts of the Bible do to teenage girls, both directly and indirectly by proxy of others enforcing unfair standards on them. I enjoyed it for how it didn't shy away from how unfair it is to be a girl in the church, and I felt like this book got close to really getting introspective about that. But at the end of the day, it kinda just lands on "I guess I'll stick it out and go along with the Bible in my own way," conclusion, which I found sorely disappointing.
What it does do well though, is provide a snapshot of a girl's life in the throes of that religion. Where it lacks depth in questioning the Bible, it pulls no punches in what the questionable parts of the Bible do to teenage girls, both directly and indirectly by proxy of others enforcing unfair standards on them. I enjoyed it for how it didn't shy away from how unfair it is to be a girl in the church, and I felt like this book got close to really getting introspective about that. But at the end of the day, it kinda just lands on "I guess I'll stick it out and go along with the Bible in my own way," conclusion, which I found sorely disappointing.
May 9, 2026
This is the second book I have read this year that explores questioning Christianity. What is interesting is that I have had my own detangling journey which has come out stronger in a lot of areas. And the legalism has been removed in a lot of others. SOMEDAY PERFECT doesn't land in that there isn't a religious epiphany or a decision to walk away from faith.....but it does land in truly describing the experience many Christian girls have had themselves in terms of romance, sex, modesty, and accountability.
I could see myself, or rather my own mind, as I read. I grew up with how it's the girl's responsibility to protect a guy from stumbling. How to have crushes was being unfaithful to your spouse. How women were to be meek and second fiddle. I'm not there anymore. But I still have my faith. I guess I was hoping that SOMEDAY PERFECT would get to that understanding and it didn't....
I could see myself, or rather my own mind, as I read. I grew up with how it's the girl's responsibility to protect a guy from stumbling. How to have crushes was being unfaithful to your spouse. How women were to be meek and second fiddle. I'm not there anymore. But I still have my faith. I guess I was hoping that SOMEDAY PERFECT would get to that understanding and it didn't....
May 18, 2026
This feels like a cross between a slice of life comic and a problem novel. Main character Meg is spending her summer at a very conservative Christian camp, with extremely regressive views on women. For example, Meg gets in trouble for wearing a skirt that only comes down to her knees. Schneider makes the interesting choice to mostly observe this setting, without a definitive outcome for any of the characters. Meg spends her summer questioning, but doesn't fully answer her own questions. This is a realistic outcome for her age and for the level of indoctrination she's experienced throughout her life. I think this book will be enjoyed most by readers who are at the same place Meg is: they've begun to realize something isn't right in their lives, but aren't entirely decided on what that is or what to do about it.
December 9, 2025
Thank you to Random House Graphic for giving me an ARC of this book via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review!
I really enjoyed this book! This really spoke to me as a Christian who has also attended Christian summer camps. I actually had wonderful camp experiences, but the topics and themes brought up in this novel hit me hard. I've definitely had a thought of the thoughts that Meg has over the course of my life, so I really enjoyed reading because the characters were relatable.
I would definitely recommend this book. It is a fairly quick read, and it is also seriously gorgeous. The illustrations were amazing. The plot was chill but not slow or boring. It was fun but thought-provoking at the same time. I'm very glad I read this book!
I really enjoyed this book! This really spoke to me as a Christian who has also attended Christian summer camps. I actually had wonderful camp experiences, but the topics and themes brought up in this novel hit me hard. I've definitely had a thought of the thoughts that Meg has over the course of my life, so I really enjoyed reading because the characters were relatable.
I would definitely recommend this book. It is a fairly quick read, and it is also seriously gorgeous. The illustrations were amazing. The plot was chill but not slow or boring. It was fun but thought-provoking at the same time. I'm very glad I read this book!
December 29, 2025
Overall, the setting and the story were enjoyable. The illustrations were beautiful and suited the narrative.
The conflict is realistic, in that it is a common one for children raised in Christian faith. Wanting to be obedient is a difficulty that many youth encounter and this was particularly evident in the manner of attire and behaviour. Another conflict that Meg deals with, is that she hides her faith from her friends at school and notices that their beliefs are very different from her own.
The main drawback of the story was that the ending didn’t offer a particularly satisfying resolution.
Many thanks to Random House Children’s Books and NetGalley for a digital review copy of this graphic novel. The opinions expressed are given freely and are honest and my own.
The conflict is realistic, in that it is a common one for children raised in Christian faith. Wanting to be obedient is a difficulty that many youth encounter and this was particularly evident in the manner of attire and behaviour. Another conflict that Meg deals with, is that she hides her faith from her friends at school and notices that their beliefs are very different from her own.
The main drawback of the story was that the ending didn’t offer a particularly satisfying resolution.
Many thanks to Random House Children’s Books and NetGalley for a digital review copy of this graphic novel. The opinions expressed are given freely and are honest and my own.
April 23, 2026
Someday Perfect is a beautifully illustrated YA graphic novel that explores identity, faith, and the emotional complexity of first love.
Kat Schneider tells a sensitive coming-of-age story centered on Meg, a teenager navigating strict expectations and her own emerging feelings during a Christian summer camp experience. The emotional tension between personal desire and external belief systems is handled with care and nuance.
What stands out most is the visual storytelling paired with emotional depth. The illustrations enhance the tone of introspection, making Meg’s internal conflict feel immediate and expressive.
Tender, reflective, and emotionally layered, Someday Perfect is a meaningful read for fans of YA graphic novels that explore identity, faith, and self-discovery.
Kat Schneider tells a sensitive coming-of-age story centered on Meg, a teenager navigating strict expectations and her own emerging feelings during a Christian summer camp experience. The emotional tension between personal desire and external belief systems is handled with care and nuance.
What stands out most is the visual storytelling paired with emotional depth. The illustrations enhance the tone of introspection, making Meg’s internal conflict feel immediate and expressive.
Tender, reflective, and emotionally layered, Someday Perfect is a meaningful read for fans of YA graphic novels that explore identity, faith, and self-discovery.
October 31, 2025
Hm, I don’t really have many feelings about this. Going into it I anticipated something more obstinate to Christian faith. But that’s not really what this was. It was teenagers being teenagers at a Bible camp. I think it’s normal to question your faith especially in a time in your life where you are questioning everything and figuring out who you are. I swear there was a nazi symbol which if that was intentional, not cool. I’m glad in the end she felt less shame to say she actually went to Bible camp but I really don’t get what the message was supposed to be. There really wasn’t anything special about the story although I did enjoy the art style.
November 22, 2025
Thank you netgalley for this graphic novel this was a quick read and this novel follows a bible camp and basically shows us what alot of people growing up in religion have to deal with and society standards and things around us and we see our main character navigate friendships and a crush on one of the campers but then finding out something about him i liked the message behind this novel about putting ourselves first and navigating things we go through when people put all these pressures on people.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Meg loves going to Bible camp every summer and is excited to reconnect with friends. When she starts having feelings for a boy at camp, Danny, Meg doesn't know how to feel about it. How can she reconcile who she wants to be, how she wants to present herself, and who her family expects her to be?
Someday Perfect has the potential to be a solid story about growth and faith. It loses the reader in it's lack of action and plot development. The ending is a little abrupt, and I really just wanted more depth from the story in general.
I read an ARC from NetGalley.
Someday Perfect has the potential to be a solid story about growth and faith. It loses the reader in it's lack of action and plot development. The ending is a little abrupt, and I really just wanted more depth from the story in general.
I read an ARC from NetGalley.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
Simple, but it has deep questions. Lovely illustrations. Not for everyone (due to the religious aspects) but most can find something to enjoy. I would say at least 12 and up, but younger children could handle it if they are strong readers. There is some talk of sexual activities, the use of the word sl-t and the body shaming that comes with a patriarchal philosophy. But overall, it was tastefully done. It wasn't a 'WOW' for me, but the right reader will definitely enjoy it.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Someday Perfect tells the story of Meg working at a church camp in the summer. This graphic novel perfectly captures the complicated issues that occur during a teenager's life. It grapples with friendship, relationships and her relationship with her religion.
I thought this graphic novel did a good job of grappling with complicated teenagers.
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to review this graphic novel. All opinions are my own.
I thought this graphic novel did a good job of grappling with complicated teenagers.
Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to review this graphic novel. All opinions are my own.
February 24, 2026
I received a digital advance copy from Penguin Teen Canada and NetGalley.
I enjoyed the art style in this graphic novel.
This graphic novel tackles a number of different issues that faced teenagers with the added pressure of Christian guilt and misogyny in religion. I do wish that there had been a slightly more cohesive plot line, but overall this was pretty good.
I enjoyed the art style in this graphic novel.
This graphic novel tackles a number of different issues that faced teenagers with the added pressure of Christian guilt and misogyny in religion. I do wish that there had been a slightly more cohesive plot line, but overall this was pretty good.
December 9, 2025
As much as I wanted to read this book, it wouldn't send to my Kindle, so I was unable to read it. :( Here's 5 stars for letting me have it even though I couldn't read it! Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A beautiful graphic novel with beautiful art about a young girl finding out who she truly is, a summer love with some bitter sweet moments and the pressure some adults and groups of people put on young girls.
I really liked it.
I really liked it.
May 11, 2026
A very realistic and touching look at the confusing times of being a teenage counselor at a Christian summer camp. Societal pressures and religious expectations clash with developing emotions and the tug of war with friends
November 25, 2025
The blurb and the cover made me believe this was going to be more of a “burgeoning romance” than it was, so I feel a bit misled. Other than that!!
April 29, 2026
I have been a HUGE fan of Kat’s work for years now and I knew her novel would not disappoint. Big fan, everything is beautifully illustrated and relatable. Selfishly, I wish it was longer.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews