Where We Belong: An Orphan Train Novel

by Kim Vogel Sawyer

Four lives from Kansas and New York cross paths in a joyful novel of love, determination, and the unbreakable bonds of family—from the beloved and bestselling author of Hope's Enduring Echo.

The life of Hester Haak, a widow with no children of her own, takes an unexpected turn when she opens her Kansas home to children from the bustling streets of New York City. The orphan asylum has entrusted her with two sisters and a young boy, and Hester is determined to provide a safe and loving environment for them. Despite the looming uncertainty of their stay, she rises to the challenge, embracing the opportunity to make a difference in their lives.

Meanwhile, Callum Holbrook is grappling with the loss of his wife and the despair that followed. Unable to provide for his family, he made the heart-wrenching decision to place his daughters in an orphanage, promising it was only temporary. Now, with a stable job and a renewed sense of purpose, Callum is horrified to learn that his daughters have been sent halfway across the country. Fueled by determination and love, he embarks on the difficult journey to bring them back.

Through their struggles and triumphs, Hester and Callum discover that family and love can be found in the most surprising places—and that the journey home is paved with hope.

Genres: Historical Fiction, Christian Fiction, Christian, Historical, Christian Historical Fiction

Kindle Edition

Expected publication April 21, 2026

About the author

Award-winning, bestselling author Kim Vogel Sawyer told her kindergarten teacher that someday people would check out her book in the library. The little-girl dream came true in 2006 with the release of Waiting for Summer's Return. Kim's titles now exceed 1.5 million copies and are available in six different languages. A former elementary school teacher, she now enjoys a full-time writing and speaking ministry. Kim's passion lies in writing stories that point the reader to a deeper, more intimate relationship with God. When Kim isn't writing, you'll find her traveling with her retired military hubby, spoiling her granddarlings, petting the cats, quilting, or--as time allows--participating in community theater. You can learn more about Kim's writing and speaking ministries at her website, KimVogelSawyer.com.

Reviews

[theliterateleprechaun · Rating 5 out of 5]

Within a few pages, I knew that I held a masterpiece in my hands. Not only was the narrative captivating and propulsive, but the characters were endearing and life-like, and the writing style was inviting. I found it difficult to set this book down. In fact, this is one for the forever shelf.

New-to-me author Kim Vogel Sawyer writes to highlight the power of love, to remind us that God doesn’t always answer in the way we think He will, that He often puts people in our lives to help guide us in His will, and that roadblocks can be God’s means of redirection. Sawyer’s faith thread is gentle yet impactful.

Sawyer’s character development is absolutely AMAZING. Seven-year-old Marion Guy Sadler won my heart with his mispronunciations (Flippastines) and his soft heart. I was impressed with Callum and his 12-year-old daughter, Evelyn’s, transformations, which reminded me of the power of love. Hester Haak is a wonderful soul, and I hope we get to read more about her in future books.

I’m so glad I took a chance on this powerful story, as it will rank up there with my favourites of 2025.

I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.

[Hannah]

5 stars

An absolutely lovely story of a woman who opens her home to needy children during the Great Depression. Her heart for the kids shines through the pages so well and I felt invested in what happened to her within the first few pages. There's less of Callum, Evelyn, and Scotty's stories, but I enjoyed all of them also. Honestly, I'd be perfectly satisfied to be plopped down in old Kansas and become friends with all of them!

For a fairly quiet story, there were a bunch of plot twists I didn't see coming, and it kept me flipping pages as a reader and genuinely worried a few times that I'd ever see everyone happy on the Kansas prairie.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free reading copy. A favorable review was not required.

[Sarah ⚘ · Rating 5 out of 5]

《 five stars 》

It's been a while since I read a book that drew me in as quickly as Where We Belong did. Within the first few chapters, I had already fallen in love with the characters, with the setting, with the storytelling, everything. Something about Sawyer's writing is just so beautiful and tender, and speaks to the soul in the same way old favorites do, even though the language is simple.

Though it is a quieter story, the stakes were high enough that I simply had to keep reading in order to find out what would happen next, if it really would all turn out right in the end. And when that ending did come? Well, I'm not ashamed to admit I may have shed a tear, despite the smile I know was on my face.

Sawyer has crafted a masterpiece, here, and it is one I look forward to placing on my shelves. If you are a historical fiction reader with a love for intimate, heartwarming, and, quietly compelling stories, then I would highly recommend giving Where We Belong a try. 💕

ˏˋ°•*⁀➷ a note regarding content: mentions of losing loved ones (spouses, parents), familial separation, runaways, and stealing. Light romantic tension, some hugs, & a kiss. A side character is pregnant out of wedlock. Characters pray, read the Bible, quote Scriptures, and attend church, in a manner woven into their daily life.

Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own.

[Karen R · Rating 5 out of 5]

A wonderful heartfelt story set mainly in 1931, Kansas.
During the early days of the Depression, a younger childless widow feels led to adopt a child from the last Orphan Train out of New York City. Her life is about to change in more ways than she could ever imagine.

An absolutely heart tugging story with an array of characters who come together because of their love for children who need a home. The writing draws in multiple perspectives, with their colliding paths causing an ethical dilemma. There is a solid Christian message woven in that is an important redemptive theme in the end. I couldn't read it fast enough to see what happened.

Hester is an amazing person, living out her faith with kindness, patience, love and tender care, taking in children who bring many new challenges into her quiet life. Any new mom will relate to her struggles to manage a business and home life with not just one, but multiple children. She is inspiring in her devotion to help them, and rises to the challenge, even when faced with the possibility of losing them. I loved her sweet persevering nature, and her fun relationship with 'Uncle Scotty'.

Highly recommend this to fans of historical Christian fiction who love a good character driven story. A new one to add to my favorites list. Terrific! 5 stars

(An ebook was provided by the publisher via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own.)

[Lisa M. · Rating 5 out of 5]

As soon as I saw the words "Orphan train" I knew I wanted a chance to read this book. I have a special love for the history of the orphan trains--but that's a story for another day.

This is a rich a beautiful story about the power of a mother's love. There are four (if I remember right) POV: Hester Haak (our 38ish widow), Callum Holbrook (40ish widower), a 14 yearold girl, and Uncle Scotty (old bachelor).

I simply loved Hester's heart. She had a passion for children and believed that with her love paired with God's help--she could move mountains. I love how she fought hard for the children and left everything in God's hands in how it was all going to work. The way she loved the oldest girl through her difficulty. <3

Callum was so passionate in feeling he knew what was best for his girls and seeing him fight for them--yet still arguing with God...and then seeing his growth. It was great.

Uncle Scotty was my favorite. The sweet man. <3

Lots of lessons about how With God All things are Possible, as well as his promises that He has a future and hope for us all.

5 STars because I really didn't want to ever put it down.

*Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for an ARC of this book. All opinions are 100% my own.

[Linda Galella · Rating 5 out of 5]

It’s been a long time since I read an orphan train book. They were so popular for a few years that I had O D’d on them. Happily, I decided to take a trip with Kim Vogel Sawyer’s orphans on this last train from NYC that ends in Kansas.

Sisters, Evelyn and Winnie, (Edwina), are taken to the orphanage by their father, Callum. He’s newly widowed and unable to care for his girls while desperately seeking employment and housing that’s appropriate for them all. He’s clear with the orphanage director that this is temporary, he’s NOT giving up his children for adoption and will come back for them asap.
As the Depression deepens, it becomes more and more difficult to achieve that goal.

Eventually, the orphanage is no longer able to secure funding and is forced to close. All the children not adopted in NYC or locally nearby have been shipped out to the western states on orphan trains with the hope that farmers needing extra hands would take these youngsters in and “adopt them” for incremental help, if nothing else. Callum’s girls and a young boy, Guy, are among the children riding this final train.

Callum has no idea the orphanage has closed and his daughters were relocated, until he went for a visit. Desperate to find them, he manages to squeeze a name and address of who might have adopted them. He’s finally secured a decent job and is so close to being able to put his family back together but not if he takes time off and spends money to cross the country to look for them. What should he do? Wait longer? He needs help!

Waiting in Kansas is Hester Haak. Her husband died suddenly and for the last three years she’s been running the town market and filling station with the help of Scotty, a simple, big hearted, glorious character. Hester is a godly woman whose deepest desire is to be a mother; provide a loving home and family for needy children. Bucking all rules and traditions, Hester brings all three children home to her 1 bedroom house and the story is off and running.

City kids learning about being in the country provide lots of humorous moments for readers. Character development is wonderful and highly individualized. I fell in love with everyone, even when they were being awful. These folks lived hard, fought hard, grew, changed and loved even harder. Bible based faith provided strength, comfort and guidance. It’s woven into the story thru the daily lives of Hester, Scotty and their various friends from town.

Callum is disillusioned with God. His journey to find and reclaim his daughters is also his search for the God he knew; the God that loved and cared for him; the God that allowed his wife’s tragedy. The development of this storyline is exceptional. Often, I find these to be formulaic, a bit like a recipe - 3 ingredients, add water, 350 degrees and bam, you’re restored, saved, etc. In WHERE WE BELONG, KV Sawyer allows her characters to find their places; not only with each other, but also within themselves and with their God.

There’s no mention of a second volume for these characters but I could see it happening very easily. The town building, characters, historical time; it’s all ripe for multiple stories and visits with these fine folks and their stated aspirations. Recommended for readers 12+ who enjoy faith based, saga in waiting, historical fiction, family fiction that features strong women, resilient children and secondary characters you will remember for a long time📚

I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read & Reviewed from a NetGalley eARC via Kindle with thanks to the publisher and author.

[Story enthusiast (●´⌓`●) · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved this book!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Summary:
Upon experiencing a devastating loss, Callum Holbrook is put into a position where he's forced to place his daughters in an orphanage located in New York temporarily, only to find out a couple of days later that they were sent away on an orphan train. In Kansas, a widow with no children, Hester Haak, opens her home and heart to two sisters and a young boy, determined to provide them with the steadiness they lack and to give them a home filled with love and faith. So while Hester starts to build a new sense of family with the children, Callum, on the other hand, searches for a stable job and sets out to find and bring his daughters home. The narrative follows their mutual conflicts as Callum fights to bring his daughters home and reunite with them, and Hester faces the potential heartbreak of caring for children she may lose. Nonetheless, both characters have to navigate a path brimming with hope, trust, grief, uncertainty, and sacrifice to truly uncover where they belong, where home lies.


Review:
This novel is beautifully crafted, well-written, and faith-filled. It centers on the powerful theme of “found family.” I absolutely loved the children and enjoyed getting to know them. I especially liked Evelyn, one of Callum's daughters. Her struggle to accept adoption and not lose hope in reuniting with her father moved me deeply. Her individual growth stands out, especially against the backdrop of the historic orphan train movement. During this era, children often faced unpleasant experiences, making the author's use of this backdrop particularly interesting and well done. I loved Hester, an inspiring woman whose devotion and heart for the displaced children amazed me. In a time when thousands of children were sent West in search of homes, she anchored the story. Callum, though flawed, impressed me with his realistic journey to reclaim his daughters, traveling from New York to Kansas. His raw, honest internal struggle with faith added depth to his transformation—from a grieving father to a man of renewed faith. Watching him confront the orphan train system while striving for a better future made his growth feel earned. Overall, this novel offers a touching exploration of grace and a poignant look at a unique character finding hope and belonging. Highly recommend!

Content ‼️ warnings:
Death of a parent
Child Abandonment
Grief

[Catherine Graham · Rating 5 out of 5]

Where We Belong is a heartwarming read that takes us on the journey from orphan train to homecoming not only for the orphans but their adoptive mother, 'Uncle' and community. This book had multiple different characters telling us their story, all convincingly and passionately, and the author has done a wonderful job of weaving these story threads into a wonderfully complete story at the end.

Hester Haak is a widow in a small Kansas town. Knowing she cannot have children she decides to do the next best thing and adopt a little girl from the orphan train. She certainly never intended to come home with three children but with God's gentle nudging that is exactly what happens. But we all know that children aren't always easy, especially 13 year old's who don't want to be with you. Hester, and friend 'Uncle Scotty' have their work cut out for them keeping up with the children, but they love it and know that while it can cost them to love, it is worth the cost.

Callum is the father of the two girls who ended up being adopted by Hester - not that they should have been on the train as he was coming to take them back now that he has a job again. Through a miracle he is able to raise the funds to come and get them ... except nothing seems to go to plan. They are settled in a new home and with deadlines approaching to get back to New York there seems to be delays after delays.

I loved how Hester rested in God's strength, there was a maturity and trusting that God was with her, and was holding her through everything that was going on. This story was filled with the character's heartfelt longing & emotion and there was real beauty in the way they all began to merge together. I really enjoyed lots of little moments when we saw the characters grow, or the way the community supported Hester. We saw that people and relationships became more important than a place. I really enjoyed reading this book and regretted it each time I had to put it aside to do my normal life. This is an author to follow!

I received an ARC of this book through the publisher and Netgalley. All opinions are my own.

[Victoria Baldin · Rating 5 out of 5]

Where We Belong by Kim Vogel Sawyer

Its March 1931, Hesta Haak has always wanted a child but since her husband, Dale passed away she thought there was no hope of her ever being a mother. Then she found out the last Orphan Train was coming and Kansas where she lives will be the last stop. Hesta asks Scotty to watch the store while she goes to meet the train and she takes in not one but three orphans; two sisters Evelyn (Evvie) fourteen years of age, Edwina (Winnie) four years of age and a little boy, Guy who is eight years of age.

Evvie can not believe The Mission Church Home in New York City put her and her little sister Winnie on the Orphan train, they were not orphans. Their mother passed away while giving birth to Winnie and their dad placed them in the Mission Church Home for Orphans just until he gets back on his feet then he will be collecting them. Now her mission is to save up enough money to take a train back to New York City with Winnie to find her dad and finally be reunited with him. After all who does Hesta think she is taking them in.

Callum is so excited he can now collect his two girls, Evvie and Winnie. He finally has a good job and a furnished apartment for them to live in but as he walks in to the Mission Church Home for Orphans in New York City all his hopes are dashed. The home is closing; there are no children there at all, they have put his girls on the Orphan train. Now he must take time off from his job and take a train to Kansas to pick up his girls and bring them back but it may seem like a simple mission nothing goes to plan.

This book is written from Hesta’s, Evvie’s and Callum’s points of view.

A wonderful book that portrays that Gods plans are infinitely better than anything we may have planned and that God’s Love for us is everlasting.

I would like to thank Net Galley and Penguin Random House Christian Publishing / WaterBrook Publishers for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review

[Anna Christodoulou-Vega · Rating 4 out of 5]

✨📖 ARC Review: Where We Belong
by Kim Vogel Sawyer 💛🏡

Where We Belong is a tender, heart-deep story about love found through loss, courage born from grief, and the beautiful, unexpected ways family can take shape. Kim Vogel Sawyer once again delivers a story that feels gentle yet powerful, wrapping the reader in hope from the very first page.

Hester Haak is a quietly strong heroine—a widow whose lonely Kansas home is suddenly filled with life when she opens her doors to children from New York City. Watching her step into motherhood with grace, faith, and determination was incredibly moving. Her willingness to love deeply despite uncertainty is the emotional heartbeat of this novel. 💕🌾

On the other side of the story, Callum Holbrook’s journey is equally compelling. His anguish over being separated from his daughters is palpable, and his determination to bring them home makes for an emotionally charged, page-turning arc. The parallel journeys of Hester and Callum beautifully highlight themes of sacrifice, redemption, and the unbreakable bonds of family. 👨‍👧‍👧✨

This novel shines in its quiet moments—the small acts of kindness, the steady growth of trust, and the reminder that “home” isn’t always a place, but the people who love us. With its faith-forward themes and deeply human characters, Where We Belong is both comforting and inspiring.

🌟 Perfect for readers who love:

Historical fiction with heart

Found family & second chances

Faith-centered stories of hope

Emotionally rich, character-driven novels

Thank you to Kim Vogel Sawyer for this beautiful, soul-stirring story. Where We Belong truly lives up to its title—this one will stay with you long after the final page. 💛📚

[Debbie · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Where We Belong" is a Christian historical set in 1931 Kansas. Hester's a widow running a store in a small town with an illiterate, elderly man helping her. She longs for children of her own and hears that an orphan train is stopping nearly, so she goes intending to adopt a school age girl. Though she lives in a small, 1 bedroom house, she bafflingly doesn't figure out where she's going to put this child let alone the three children that she returns with. (Luckily, her helper is handy at carpentry as, by the end, there are 8 people living in that house.)

Callum goes to get his two girls from the orphanage only to learn that it has closed down and his girls were sent out on an orphan train. It's his fault: they tried to contact him, but when he never responded or came to visit, they had to assume he was dead or didn't want the girls. He has to find the money to go after them, but even then, how can he leave the best job he's going to get during these hard economic times?

Hester and Callum don't even meet for over half of the book, so it's not really a romance. Most of the story was about Hester trying to raise her new children. Callum's eldest is determined to return to New York City to find her father. Hester's patience and love and the friendships formed with time cause the children to form ties locally. Callum can see that Hester loves the children, but his life is in NYC. She appreciates that he's kind, hardworking, and good with the children.

Several Christian characters helped Callum and his eldest daughter find their relationship with God again and trust Him with their future. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable historical novel.

I received a free ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.

[Francis Tapon · Rating 5 out of 5]

Kim Vogel Sawyer has crafted a deeply moving historical narrative in "Where We Belong" that beautifully explores the complexities of the Orphan Train era.

I found the dual perspectives between the Kansas plains and the crowded streets of New York to be a highly effective way to showcase the desperation and hope of the late 19th century.

In my opinion, the character of Hester Haak is a standout, as her journey from a lonely widow to a protective maternal figure feels both authentic and earned. I believe the most heart-wrenching aspect of the story is Callum Holbrook’s struggle to reclaim his daughters, which highlights the tragic impact of poverty on family bonds.

I think the author handles the spiritual themes with a gentle hand, allowing the message of faith and redemption to flow naturally from the characters' hardships. While I noticed the pacing slows down slightly in the middle sections, I feel the emotional stakes remain high enough to keep the reader fully invested in the outcome. I believe Sawyer’s descriptive prose vividly brings the historical setting to life, making the children's transition from the city to the frontier feel visceral.

I think the central message—that home is defined by where you are loved rather than where you were born—is a powerful and timeless theme.

Overall, I found this to be a poignant look at "found family" that successfully balances historical accuracy with a heartwarming resolution. I would highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys faith-based historical fiction that prioritizes character growth and emotional resonance.

[Nora St Laurent · Rating 4 out of 5]

Hester was overjoyed when the board decided to allow a widow to adopt these orphaned children. She was ecstatic. She had always wanted kids. Taking care of multiple children was going to be both difficult and immensely fulfilling.

When his wife died, Callum Holbrook, a father of two young daughters in New York, did the unimaginable and placed them in an orphanage. It was only going to be temporary. Who would have thought it would take years to prepare for their return? When Callum was ready to pick up his girls, he learned they both had been sent far away. Callum was driven by love and determination; he would stop at nothing to win his girls back.

Hester and Callum discover through their struggles and triumphs that love and family can be found in the most unlikely places.

This beautiful, strong, faith-filled historical centers on a compassionate Kansas village and a kind widow named Hester who had a lot of love to give the children brought to them via the orphan train. This story reminded me of the Little House on the Prairie TV and book series. I enjoyed this story and the characters.

Disclosure of Material Connection: I requested and received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog https://psalm516.blogspot.com

[Lyndsie · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved this sweet, tender novel from the very first page to the last. It’s a moving story of found family, the quiet power of prayer, and learning to trust God’s plan—even when it looks different than we imagined.

Set in Kansas during the Great Depression, the story follows Hester Haak, a widow longing for a child of her own. With no children and a heart full of hope, she plans to adopt a little girl from the orphan train. But when two young sisters unexpectedly capture her heart, Hester finds herself on a journey she never anticipated—one that stretches her faith and reshapes her dreams.

Kim Vogel Sawyer’s novels aren’t fast-paced or filled with dramatic cliffhangers. Instead, they unfold gently and thoughtfully. Yet I always find myself completely drawn in, unable to put them down. Just when I think I know where the story is headed, she surprises me.

The characters are beautifully woven together—from a weary old hobo to a wounded and bitter orphan girl—each one adding depth to this tender story of grace, healing, and what it truly means to belong.

Where We Belong brought tears to my eyes and reminded me that God’s blessings often exceed our expectations—if only we are willing to open our hearts to His will.
I received an advance copy of this book through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

[Christine Barth · Rating 4 out of 5]

This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the March 2026 issue of Library Journal.

After being hit hard by the Great Depression and his wife's death, Callum Holbrook is finally back on track and ready to get his daughters back from a New York orphanage, but when he arrives to collect them, he finds they have been sent west on an orphan train.
Determined to stick together and get back home, Evelyn and Winnie Holbrook behave outrageously at every train stop until they are the last kids left.
Widower Hester Haak is desperate to realize her dream of raising children and takes the girls in, although the orphanage insists it's only temporary due to her single status. As they experience the growing pains of family, hearts gradually change, but no one is sure where they belong.
VERDICT: Sawyer (Hope's Enduring Echo) delivers a beautiful story of found family and hard-working people caught in an impossible situation in a country still recovering from the Great Depression. For more on the book's subject, check out Jody Hedlund's "Orphan Train" series and Christina Baker Kline's novel, Orphan Train.

[Scott County Library System · Rating 4 out of 5]

This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the March 2026 issue of Library Journal.

After being hit hard by the Great Depression and his wife's death, Callum Holbrook is finally back on track and ready to get his daughters back from a New York orphanage, but when he arrives to collect them, he finds they have been sent west on an orphan train.
Determined to stick together and get back home, Evelyn and Winnie Holbrook behave outrageously at every train stop until they are the last kids left.
Widower Hester Haak is desperate to realize her dream of raising children and takes the girls in, although the orphanage insists it's only temporary due to her single status. As they experience the growing pains of family, hearts gradually change, but no one is sure where they belong.
VERDICT: Sawyer (Hope's Enduring Echo) delivers a beautiful story of found family and hard-working people caught in an impossible situation in a country still recovering from the Great Depression. For more on the book's subject, check out Jody Hedlund's "Orphan Train" series and Christina Baker Kline's novel, Orphan Train.

[Vicki F · Rating 5 out of 5]

Praises for Kim Vogel Sawyer's "Where We Belong: An Orphan Train Novel". Great research went into writing this moving novel. My heart broke for Callum who became a single father when his wife died giving birth to their second child. Unable to care for them and work, he did what many had to do in that era - take them to the orphanage until they were older and he was situated better financially. Hester earned my great admiration for her willingness as a widow to take in the last children on the last orphan's train.

I can relate to Callum's situation. My paternal grandmother had also been left in an orphanage when her father could not raise her. She was separated from her sister and never knew what happened to her. My grandmother was not placed on an orphan train but was raised in that era.

Attention to details is always a trademark of Sawyer's writings. Characters that are worthy of admiration and empathy is a strong component of her works. A fantastic read.

Releases Apr. 21st. I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

[Hannah · Rating 4 out of 5]

'Where We Belong' was my second Kim Vogel Sawyer novel, and I continue to enjoy her fresh, faith-centered approach to historical romance. I especially liked the focus on a blended family through adoption. Each child adds something distinct, and it was sweet to watch Hester grow into motherhood as the family found its new normal. The Great Depression setting also adds depth, especially in showing the challenges facing orphanages and families trying to get by.

The pacing does slow in the middle, and with several points of view, a few sections held my attention less than others. Even so, the conclusion is deeply heartfelt and left me thinking about vulnerable children in a new way. I appreciate stories that stir the reader's compassion and strengthen trust in God alongside the characters. Readers who enjoy historical fiction centered on family, faith, and character growth rather than a romance-driven plot will find a lot to appreciate.

Special thanks to WaterBrook and NetGalley for providing an advance review copy. I received this book for free and am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions expressed are completely my own.

[Lori Parrish · Rating 5 out of 5]

Another favorite from one 9f my favorite authors. When I saw this I knew I had to have this story.
One of my favorite historical themes is the orphan trains that were sent West to find children new homes. Some homes worked and some didn't.
This is the story of the last orphan train ride that was sent West. A story that I dearly loved and couldn't put down.
For someone who is given the opportunity to have a home to come to Evelyn didn't appreciate it nor did I like her for that reason.
My favorite part was to read about how these characters grew and became the people they were meant to be.
Sawyer has done well with this story of finding one's place in this big old world.
This one will be placed on my shelf of favorites.
She's my auto go to buy and read.! I can't wait for more by her!
5 stars for keeping my interest all the way through and for showing us that family isn't always blood.
Thanks for the opportunity to read and review. I loved every minute of it. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine

[Helen · Rating 5 out of 5]

Where We Belong by Kim Vogel Sawyer is a Christian orphan train novel. Callum’s wife dies in childbirth and he is forced to take his daughters to a home until he can care for them. When the home is forced to close and can’t reach him, his daughter are taken on the orphan train with the rest of the children. At the very last stop, Hester hopes to get one young daughter but adopts the 3 remaining children.
This story is so good. I love how caring Hester is with taking in three children and makes room for them in her small home. While the oldest daughter is a constant struggle, Hester continues to show her love. I enjoy how visible God’s hand in the situation is. When Callum finally gets a steady job and can care for his daughters, he has to travel across country to take them home. When the trip turns out to take much longer, doors open for him to have a place to live and be close to his girls. This is a wonderful story that held my attention to the very end.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book; this is my honest review.

[Cover Lover Book Review · Rating 4 out of 5]

Where We Belong is such a beautiful redemption story based on the Orphan Train Movement in the mid-1800s to early-1900s. It drew me in right away and the characters felt real and familiar. Hester is a strong woman, and my heart went out to Callum. I especially appreciate the messages of faith and how God’s guidance is gently woven throughout the story.

The story moves at a steady pace and focuses on love, sacrifice, loss, family and second chances—one of my favorite tropes. It shows how good can come from hard situations, even when life feels overwhelming.

If you enjoy uplifting stories of faith, hope, and unique family connections, this book is a good choice. This heartfelt story will stay with you.

First Line: The subway car hissed to a stop, and Callum found himself jostled to and fro by those hurrying to exit while others hurried to board.
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Kim Vogel Sawyer
Page Count: 368

#CoverLoverBookReview received a review copy of this book. Opinions are my own.

[Maureen Timerman · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is such a warmhearted read, from beginning to end I was page turning for answers!
With the last orphan train coming, widow Haak decides she would like to adopt a daughter. We are with her as she arrives and their are three children left a boy, and two girls. There is a problem, she is single and they would rather the children go to the Poor Farm. Rules are rules, and with the orphanage closing in NYC, they let her take the children, all three, but will let her know.
The girls are four and thirteen, and what a handful the thirteen year old is, but is she wrong, she knows the truth!
The cast of characters here are so inspirational, they all rally to help, and are a bit not happy when the girls father, Callum arrives to take his girls.
I loved how this story evolved, and wish I could have continued here with this faith based book!
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Penguin Random House Christian Publishing, and was not required to give a positive review.

[Danielle Turko · Rating 4 out of 5]

When Hester's husband Dale passed away, she felt her dream of having a houseful of children died right along with him. When she hears about an orphan train stopping 8 miles away, she decides to go see if she find herself a little girl. Instead she finds herself coming home with 3 children, a pair of sisters and a little boy. She learns the sisters still have a father, one who the orphanage tried to contact but couldn't. When he unexpectedly turns up, Hester is heartbroken to think the girls she had instantly thought of as her needing to leave, but she won't stand in the way of their dad taking them home. With one delay after another happening, she finds herself almost as heartbroken at the idea of him leaving as she is as his girls leaving.
This was a very sweet story that clearly displayed God's blessing in peoples lives. It did get a little hard when it bounced between 4 different POVS but they did clearly label it, so as long as you pay attention you'll be fine.

[Tamara · Rating 4 out of 5]

Hester Haak is a widow with no children of her own, takes an unexpected turn when she opens her Kansas home to children from the bustling streets of New York City. Hester is determined to provide a safe and loving environment for two sisters and a young boy.

Meanwhile, Callum Holbrook is grappling with the loss of his wife and the despair that followed. Unable to provide for his family, he places his two daughters in an orphanage, promising his girls it was temporary.

This was a sweet story of family, not the conventional kind, but the kind that only God can and will put together. It was slow-paced, but what I have come to expect from Kim Vogel Sawyer. Recommended.

My gratitude to Netgalley and Penguin Random House Christian Publishing/WaterBrook. All opinons are mine and honest.

[Amber · Rating 5 out of 5]

This story was absolutely beautiful. Hester has always wanted to be a mother but lost her husband and is now in her late 30s with neither husband or children. Eviee and her little sister Winnie end up on an orphan train going west. They end up meeting Hester and suddenly the woman who wanted to adopt one child, ends up with a house full. What follows is an endearing story of perseverance, love and community. Hester and her little unconventional family end up going through many hardships, culminating in the arrival of the girls’ father Callum. I really enjoyed the character development in this story and the reminder that God always does things with a purpose. I highly recommend this beautifully written story and thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. The enthusiastic opinions are solely mine.

[Lisa Dyck · Rating 5 out of 5]

A beautiful heartwarming story set in the early Great Depression. What a joy it was to read a story with such a wonderful perspective of raising children in a dark time. Loved the plot and how the storyline played out, with a hint of a romantic twist. The characters are so well written.
I definitely also felt that the topic of grief and faith was so well done and was incredibly inspiring.

The book was interestingly life giving in a way fiction books not often are. I shed a few tears and smiled many a smile as I read this book.

What a refreshing book in that it was an unpredictable and unique story in the genre of Christian historical fiction.

Picked it up and finished it in one sitting!

Advanced copy provided by NetGalley. Opinions are entirely my own.

[Lotta Z (Not active due to sickness) · Rating 3 out of 5]

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House Christian Publishing for this ARC! All thoughts are my own!

Ok, soooo I must make a confession.... I read over half of this book and then decided to DNF it. I just can't force myself right now! I'm just so not into straight historical fiction. It just does not excite me at all. I'm so sorry!

What I can say though to the positive is that this author is a skilled writer. I love how she phrases things and she clearly has a great eye for details and understands her characters well. This is a good book. It is just not for me personally. If you are someone who enjoy Christian historical fiction this is the book for you! I'm just not the right audience for this book unfortunately.

Thank you all for reading!
🤍🤍🤍

[Staci · Rating 4 out of 5]

1931 Kansas

The orphan trains that traveled from the east coast to the Midwest are so fascinating. Hester and her husband weren't able to have children and then he tragically passed away. Hester's greatest desire is to become a mother. When she shows up at the last stop for the orphan train, the coordinators agree to give her temporary custody.

Meanwhile, back in New York, the father of the children she's just been granted temporary custody of has secured a way to care for them again. Heartache is surely ahead, but in Kim Vogel Sawyer fashion, hearts are warmed as well.

My gratitude to publisher Waterbrook for a complimentary NetGalley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.

[Natalie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Kim Vogel Sawyer broke and mended my heart all in one book!

Kim Vogel Sawyer has become one of my very favorite authors and her new release always becomes one of my most anticipated of the year. I’m so excited I got to read her new one early! (Thank you to the publisher, WaterBrook Multnomah, and NetGalley for the advanced copy!)

This was such a sweet story! Right off the bat, it was so sad with Callum losing his daughters. I loved his determination to get them back. I also loved Hester. She was such a wonderful character. She never lost her faith, and her love for the children never wavered. Even when Evelyn was acting out, Hester always treated her with respect and kindness. She was such an inspiration.

I liked seeing God work in Callum’s life as well. I was truly torn in wondering who would be better for the children.

I truly loved all the characters, especially Scotty. He was such a sweet man (if a little rough around the edges). He was so faithful and hardworking and loving to those around him. His relationship with Hester was very sweet.

There is very little romance in this book, which I found refreshing. There’s definitely no instalove either.

I just love Kim Vogel Sawyer’s writing style as well. Her books have such an easy to read writing style, the dialogue feels natural and authentic to the time period, and the time period really comes to life for me.

Highly recommend this one if you want a heartbreaking (in spots) but also hopeful read. I loved it!!

[Terry Felix · Rating 5 out of 5]

Where We Belong is such a fitting name for this beautiful, engaging tale surrounding children from the Orphan Trains out of New York City during the depression. The book and the cast of characters are well developed and inspirational. The central character Hester is a strong, resilient, faith-filled, remarkable woman. Her belief and willingness to follow God's plan changes the lives of some children who need her as much as she needs them. Uncle Scotty is also just a delightful character who adds good depth to the story. The whole book is captivating and emotional and a delight to read.
Thank you to Net Galley and Penguin Random House Christian Publishing/WaterBrook Publishers for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my honest review.