LONGLISTED FOR THE 2026 GILLER PRIZE • From award-winning, bestselling author Wayne Johnston comes a boisterous, sweeping tragicomic saga of faith, loyalty, and family secrets that refuse to stay buried
At twenty-eight, Vivvy Holloway is nearly the same height as when she was five. Though she hides her face behind a veil, a different colour and fabric for each day of the week, she brandishes an acerbic wit that far outweighs her small stature. Having just spent eight years of the 1930s in a convent failing to become a nun, Vivvy is now returning to Holloway Hall, the largest private dwelling in Newfoundland and the crumbling seat of her formidable family.
Vivvy’s sister Freda, a doctor, now rules the estate and its fortune. She is also its sole occupant, save for the five-year-old “special member of the family” known as Ivan, who came home with Freda after her failed marriage in the Congo, where she and her husband were missionaries until tragedy struck. Tasked with caring for the boy while Freda works long shifts—and displays increasingly erratic behaviour—Vivvy begins to suspect that something is dangerously amiss in Holloway Hall.
Over the course of a single turbulent week, Vivvy faces off against her domineering sister, her ten cleric brothers, and a host of meddling hangers-on, unearthing long-buried secrets that threaten not only her and Ivan’s place in the family, but the fate of the entire Holloway name.
Wayne Johnston was born and raised in Goulds, Newfoundland. After a brief stint in pre-Med, Wayne obtained a BA in English from Memorial University. He worked as a reporter for the St. John's Daily News before deciding to devote himself full-time to writing.
En route to being published, Wayne earned an MA in Creative Writing from the University of New Brunswick. Then he got off to a quick start. His first book, The Story of Bobby O'Malley, published when he was 27 years old, won the WH Smith/Books in Canada First Novel award for the best first novel published in the English language in Canada in that year. The Divine Ryans was adapted to a film, for which Wayne wrote the screenplay. Baltimore's Mansion, a memoire dealing with his grandfather, his father and Wayne himself, won the Charles Taylor Prize. Both The Colony of Unrequited Dreams and The Navigator of New York were on bestseller lists in Canada and have been published in the US, Britain, Germany, Holland, China and Spain. Colony was identified by the Globe and Mail newspaper as one of the 100 most important Canadian books ever produced.
This is a strange book with strange characters and it left me with more questions than answers. That said, the storytelling was stellar and it kept me listening (audiobook version) long after I should have pressed pause. I’m still wondering what the heck was up with these people but I like how the author didn’t lay it all out and let the reader draw their own conclusions. The audiobook narrator has a wonderful Newfoundland accent that made the listening even more enjoyable.
This was hard to get into, hard to pick up characters and Vivy reminded me of John Irvings book A Prayer for Owen Meany. I couldn't get past that and the religious, weird stuff. Made it as far as the 2nd day but it was very slow
Not my favourite Wayne Johnston book but I did love the character of Vivvy and the humor Johnston breathes into most of his books. I did feel I was left a bit confused and with more questions than answers.
I don't pay attention to people who go around spreading rumours. It's the ones who go around spreading the truth that I worry about. p142
But wouldn't you be terrified if out of nowhere, a crowd of strangers dressed from head to toe in black, showed up at your house and said, "We're here to help you. " p5
The Holloways of Newfoundland did missionary work in the Congo. How this reconciled with their monopoly of power and wealth is briefly outlined here but by the time the novel opens, the focus is on the crisis facing the current generation for lack of a suitable heir. There was no lack in secrets, and its outcasts were well known.
Half the family took a vow of poverty. The other half took a vow of luxury. pp141
What I'd seen as vivaciousness I came to realize was just an eagerness to please. p180
Divided minds have never accomplished anything worthwhile. p258
A long time admirerer of Wayne Johnston, I found this latest novel somewhat of a departure. With the same propulsive style and marvelous empathy, it seems to me more dense and convoluted; less generous and more cynical, although there is still some generosity and a bit of hope to grab on to.
All of history was nothing but a false start. We might get it right next time. p209
To be graceful in victory is one thing. To be so in defeat is infinitely more. p180
How could there not be hope, even for me, beneath a sky of such perfection? p201
I thought the setup was very cool-Vivvy's veils, the looming presence of the Catholic Church, the strange rooms of the manor and Newfoundland's general gloom and cold. I did find it more tell than show (all answers revealed in letters or told bluntly face-to-face in long monologues) and there was a lot to pack in in the end there, with the revelation of Annette. Would've liked to go more into that history, especially w the real world issues of the Church and its hidden promiscuities. I'm assuming the Holloway's were funding the Nazis, and that Ivan is half Jewish?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I’ve read and loved many of Wayne Johnston’s novels so I was pleased to receive a copy of his latest. It did not disappoint.
This family drama is set in St. John’s, Newfoundland, over the course of a week in September of 1947. Twenty-eight-year-old Vivvy Holloway is of small stature because she hasn’t grown since she was five years old. After eight years in a convent, she returns to her family home, Holloway Hall, the largest private dwelling in Newfoundland. Vivvy is the youngest in a formidable family which has ten cleric brothers.
Freda, Vivvy’s only sister, is in charge of the family estate and fortune. She is the sole occupant of Holloway Hall, except for Ivan Bradford, a five-year-old boy she brought back from the Congo where she once worked as a missionary doctor. Vivvy is tasked with caring for Ivan since Freda works such long hours. The two sisters clash because of Freda’s domineering personality but it’s her increasingly erratic behaviour that is disconcerting and has Vivvy worrying about Ivan’s safety. The arrival of all the Holloway brothers inspires people to come forward and begin the unearthing of long-buried family secrets which threaten the reputation and fate of the entire Holloway clan.
Vivvy is a memorable character. Something happened on her first day of school that changed her life forever. She hides her face behind a veil, a different colour and fabric for each day of the week. It is her acerbic wit that I loved, though it certainly does not endear her to her siblings who think of her as “an insufferable, subversive, heretical nuisance.” Vivvy herself acknowledges being “nonconforming, acerbic, ironic, voluble.” She makes observations like small-town rumours traveling “faster than the speed of spite” and describes her brothers’ reactions to Freda being made the sole heir: “If Freda had been wearing a ring, they might have all lined up to kiss it, but they had to settle for her backside.” Few people escape her jabs; when looking at a portrait of her mother, Vivvy comments that “she wasn’t as cheerful as that scowl might make you think. When it came to persuasiveness, she had a higher success rate than a thumbscrew.”
Another character who is memorable is Smack though he never actually appears in the novel. He is Ivan’s older friend who says things he has heard from his parents. Ivan then repeats Smack’s comments in conversations with Vivvy. When Maynard, a cardinal and Vivvy’s oldest brother, is coming for a visit, Ivan says, “’Smack said Maynard’s not here to see the sights . . . He’s seen both of them. Too late in the year for icebergs, and thank God for that. The Basilica, a.k.a. Small Potatoes Chapel. Once you’ve seen Signal Hill. And once is once too often for Cape Spear . . . So why is the Cardinal here? To say Mass. Bring out a big crowd. Cheer them up. Rub the Anglicans’ noses in it. . . . But local boy makes good only goes so far. Something must be off the rails. Enter Cardinal Cavalry.’”
The novel’s pace is slow at the beginning, but my interest was maintained by hints about past events. What happened that resulted in Vivvy’s hiding her face? Then there are strange behaviours which leave the reader questioning: Why did Freda bring Ivan home but refuse to adopt him or even have him baptized?
The book emphasizes the control that the wealthy and the Catholic Church had over society in Newfoundland. The wealth and status of the Holloway family has allowed them to hide shameful truths, and it is suggested that the Church does so as well. Knowing about the sexual abuse eventually uncovered at the Mount Cashel Boys’ Home, the references to the Christian Brothers left me feeling unsettled. Often the Holloways and the church work together for their own purposes; in neither case is their concern the welfare of the poor.
As a former English literature teacher, I really enjoyed the literary allusions; the writings of Oscar Wilde, Emily Dickinson, Charles Dickens, William Shakespeare, Mary Shelley, and many others are mentioned. I love that my knowledge of vocabulary was challenged: I had to check on the definitions of words like enisled, chthonic, and borborygmi. And then there’s the wordplay. When Ivan has chicken pot pie for dinner, Vivvy jokes that if they went by their respective ages, she should have “’pterodactyl pot pie. Or why not a pteroanapest pot pie? Poor Anna. She’s the most ignored of all the pests. How about Budapest pot pie. Ivan is so Hungary.’”
This book is a mix of drama, mystery and comedy and a great read.
Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
A strange book, but in a good way. The Novice of Holloway Hall by Wayne Johnston is an eccentric mix of family saga, dark humour, mystery and a rather damning look at the power of the Catholic Church in Newfoundland. It took me a little while to get into its world, but Vivvy won me over with her acerbic wit and wonderfully sharp observations.
“If Freda had been wearing a ring, they might have all lined up to kiss it, but they had to settle for her backside.” Reminds me of someone. I particularly enjoyed Vivvy’s irreverence and her refusal to toe the line, especially in a family where her ten cleric brothers seem to have rather a lot to say about how everyone else should behave.
Beneath the eccentricity and humour, there is a much darker story about the control the Church had over society, and the way religious authority, family wealth and social standing could be used to protect powerful people and conceal some pretty unpleasant truths. The Holloways and the Church are closely intertwined, with appearances and reputations seemingly far more important than the welfare of ordinary people. Johnston manages to explore all this without losing the book’s wonderfully odd sense of humour.
This was longlisted for the 2026 Giller Prize, and I’m very surprised it didn’t make the shortlist. I’ve now almost completed the longlist, with just one book left to read, and I have to say I’m not particularly impressed with the judges’ choices this year. This is exactly the sort of distinctive, unconventional novel I would have liked to see recognised. Strange, certainly, but all the better for it.
Thank you to Penguin Random House and Knopf Canada for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Vivian Holloway faces the secrets of her family and its ancestral home while still uncovering the truth about herself and the veil blinding her from the truth.
I am not sure where to start with this book because I think it somewhat outsmarted me. It is an interesting discussion around traditions, religion, and capitalism and what lengths we will go to to protect wealth. I have felt as confused and enraged as let down during this reading.
The first half of the book felt very uneventful, and the build-up was so slow I didn't think I was going to make it. But the second half got to me. This book's ambiance and setting are probably the best part. When I first read the page, I was like, "Welcome home.” Johnston has an incredible way to write about nature and weather; I could really place myself in Canada because I could recognize the environment so easily. The same goes with Holloway Hall; the descriptions really make the house come alive, and I love books that are able to personify a house to be part of the characters.
Speaking of characters, they are all unique and distinct, making their stories and discoveries much more engaging. The lack of agency held towards women is infuriating, but it makes their decisions, lacks and wins all more interesting.
Nevertheless, I felt the plot was quite predictable and my interest in the characters is what made me sit down with this book every time. To be honest, I just love books that unveil the truth about men.
The Novice of Holloway Hall by Wayne Johnston has been short-listed for this year’s prestigious Giller Prize. A work of historical fiction with elements of mystery, Johnston takes his readers back in time to a convent in the Newfoundland of 1947 when a 28 year-old Vivvy leaves her role as a somewhat dubious novitiate to return home. Vivvy’s wealthy family consists of ten brothers all highly placed in the church, some in the Vatican, and a widowed sister who was a former missionary and now practices medicine while also managing the substantial Holloway fortunes. During the course of one week, we learn that the rebellious Vivvy, who suffers from an unnamed affliction, is angry and outspoken in her unorthodox positions about the Catholic faith. Family secrets and animosity play out as Vivvy becomes attached to five year-old Ivan who lives in the house as a ward of the family. Johnston unspools his tale of corruption and hypocrisy within the Church with his usual mastery in the creation of unforgettable characters, wonderful wordsmith and the development of vivid scenes laden with haunting passion and a touch of wit. Utterly mesmerizing! Highly recommended.
This book is not your average book. It is a strange story set in 1947, with bizarre characters that nevertheless pull you in gradually so that you become invested in their story. It is the tale of the Holloway family, a wealthy Newfoundland Catholic family. There is Vivvy, 28, s very short woman who wears a veil because of a childhood facial injury, her sister Freda, a paediatrician, and financial head of the family, Ivan, 5, her “son” although he is not a blood relative, their ten brothers most of whom are clerics of varying success. It is part history, part mystery, and examines many different themes with humour thrown in. I sometimes finish a book and can’t really remember much about the story a week later but this one will stick with me. My only complaint was that the print in the edition I read is very tiny!!
A pretty funny dark novel about the power and corruption of both the church and money. I didn't love the writing as much as I loved Son of a Certain Woman, but I appreciate the humour and puns. It was funnier and more offbeat than a novel about such dark subjects has any business being. Humour kept Vivvy and Ivan from ending up like the rest of the sombre, bigoted and racist family. Of course they both have to suffer as innocent children for the sins of their family (in Ivan's case, not even his family). Ivan never knows his mother's name and then eventually Vivvy stands in for his mother.
Intertwining of church and corporation, pursuing corporate values thru religion, and a lot of violence and justification of violence.
Strange, almost surreal, but witty and clever. Johnston creates vivid characters - especially Vivvy. Vivvy's a 4'6" veiled woman, and the reason for her disfigurement on her first (and only) day of school is not unveiled until the very end of the book. Vivvy has virtually no social filter, and just says whatever she thinks.
The book raised so many questions, and tied together all the loose ends by the end. (Although I was still left wondering why Ivan spoke like a much older person than a five-year-old. And what was the story with Smack? For a long time I thought he was Ivan's imaginary friend, and maybe he was.)
Johnston's prosody comes in full force but there's more than a few complications elsewhere. Major deductions for referencing "scrote malone—" whoever that is. Ew!! Feels very much like two books. One that's too slow in the first 65% and the rest too fast. When it started kicking off my ears perked up but then I realized the brake lines were cut. Not a lot of meaningful resolution, perhaps a consequence of wandering setups. Will read some other Johnston: if there's a work of his with this writing proficiency and a plot I can give a hoot about I'll get at it.
I enjoyed this book in the beginning. I like the rich family with secrets and baggage story. I like the quirky writing style. I really like Vivian and her really, really quirky behaviour.
I like that the author didn’t spell everything out for the reader. There are a lot unsaid, lots of inferencing needed.
As the book continued, and it became more and more predictable, I found my interest waning. It became quite boring in fact. I did finish it, but was less interested in what would happen to Vivvy, Frieda and Ivan.
So normally I really like Wayne Johnston’s books. But this was a ‘gothic’ novel (not a genre I enjoy) and just too weird for me. It’s true, that the ending really helps to make the book ‘make sense’ but that means that for 90% of the book I did not know what was going on and did not enjoy it (if not for the ending, it would be a 1*). I did listen to a lecture Johnston gave on the book, and again that helped some of the interpretation of the novel (referencing Emily Dickinson and Oscar Wilde), but it did not help my enjoyment of the book/
A momentous and beautifully orchestrated book. Johnston’s command of language is that of a master, and reading his latest felt like a playful masterclass. Such tender and complex range in each of his characters, even the minor ones. His stamp on place lingers for ages. He gives us texture and lighting, comedy and tragedy, rooms and wind and dark, ugly secrets. What a giant! An immense pleasure to engage with his latest work.
The story of the one big rich family in a small town. The book is packed with kooky characters, starting with the narrator Vivvy. I laughed out loud with her comments and word play. The book takes on tough subjects and the humour of Vivvy guiding you through shines strongly. A masterpiece. Recommend
The first part felt like Johnston was experimenting with creating his characters. It wasn't until at least halfway that the beginning of a storyline began to emerge. I was so confused! I spent too much time wondering what was going on. Still had questions after I finished reading. Johnston is an amazing writer, but a lot of the book was beyond me.
I found this book depressing and disturbing. The Catholic Church had (has?) such a profound hold on the people of Newfoundland, much as it did in Ireland, and the abuses of power, particularly over women, were appalling. I really wish I had not devoted the time to finishing the book.
I was distracted by the protagonist always wise cracking. I almost didn’t finish the book because the characters were such weirdos, and not in a quirky way. It was a strange book and I didn’t care for it all that much. The big reveal was very underwhelming and implausible.
Nazi sympathizers. Catholic zealots. Rapists and adulterers. A disfigured woman. A special child. Vengeful victims. There's a lot packed into this novel, not always plausibly or successfully.
I’m definitely a fan of his work. I ran a little hot and cold with this one, maybe too much church for me, but who knows Newfoundland in the 1940s I wasn’t around. Still a good read.