What do you think?
Rate this book
The Val & Arbie Mysteries #3
A Dangerous Train of Thought
Listening Length: 7 hours and 59 minutes
Yorkshire, 1926. Gentleman ghost-hunter Arbuthnot 'Arbie' Swift and his old friend Val arrive at Cleeves Lea Manor, looking forward to the promise of a lavish weekend party.
The lady of the house, an avid reader of Arbie’s books, is eager to show him off to her distinguished guests. Amidst the festivities, Arbie is also tasked with investigating rumours of a ‘ghost train spitting fire’ for the third instalment of the increasingly popular (to Arbie’s great surprise) Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost-hunting.
But when the guests start dying, Arbie instead finds himself thrust into the middle of a murder investigation. With time running out, will he and Val be able to uncover the truth?
Yorkshire, 1926. Gentleman ghost-hunter Arbuthnot 'Arbie' Swift and his old friend Val arrive at Cleeves Lea Manor, looking forward to the promise of a lavish weekend party.
The lady of the house, an avid reader of Arbie’s books, is eager to show him off to her distinguished guests. Amidst the festivities, Arbie is also tasked with investigating rumours of a ‘ghost train spitting fire’ for the third instalment of the increasingly popular (to Arbie’s great surprise) Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost-hunting.
But when the guests start dying, Arbie instead finds himself thrust into the middle of a murder investigation. With time running out, will he and Val be able to uncover the truth?
8 pages, Audible Audio
First published January 15, 2026
279 people are currently reading
210 people want to read
About the author
Faith Martin
98 books997 followersFaith Martin is a pen name of English author Jacquie Walton, who is best known for her popular detective series, starring Detective Inspector Hillary Greene.
As Joyce Cato, she writes more classically-inspired 'cosy' murder mysteries, such as the Monica Noble mystery series.
As Maxine Barry, her latest romance novels are now available from Corazon Books.
As Jessie Daniels, her 'spooky' crime novel, The Lavender Lady Casefile came out in November 2017.
As Joyce Cato, she writes more classically-inspired 'cosy' murder mysteries, such as the Monica Noble mystery series.
As Maxine Barry, her latest romance novels are now available from Corazon Books.
As Jessie Daniels, her 'spooky' crime novel, The Lavender Lady Casefile came out in November 2017.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews
January 8, 2026
When I heard that there was a third book in this series, I was intrigued to give it a read. I thoroughly enjoyed the first book. The second book lost a little of the magic for me, but having read and enjoyed most Ms Martins books, I was willing to give this one a read, so I was pleased to be offered the opportunity to read an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I was not disappointed, book 3 is every bit as good as the first one, capturing the atmosphere and essence of 1926 Yorkshire. Arbie Swift is once again ably assisted by the vicars, daughter, who is still not taking any nonsense, from anybody.
Overall, another engaging story, that will keep you guessing from start to finish. Very happy to report the series is back on course again. Looking forward to book 4.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher HQ, not forgetting Ms Martin for another jolly good read.
I was not disappointed, book 3 is every bit as good as the first one, capturing the atmosphere and essence of 1926 Yorkshire. Arbie Swift is once again ably assisted by the vicars, daughter, who is still not taking any nonsense, from anybody.
Overall, another engaging story, that will keep you guessing from start to finish. Very happy to report the series is back on course again. Looking forward to book 4.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher HQ, not forgetting Ms Martin for another jolly good read.
January 23, 2026
Big thanks to Harlequin for sending us a copy to read and review.
The gentry, the tranquil English countryside and a best selling author are the main features of a weekend party at the Cleeves Lea Manor hosted by Lady Sybil.
Oblivious that murder was to taint the joys and atmosphere.
Careful attention to the guest list and a celebrity draw card was the responsibility of Lady Sybil.
Her author friend Arbie Swift was keen to attend as the mystery of a ghost train in that part of the countryside may provide fodder for his next book.
The discovery of a body ruffled the guests and the sleuthing began.
A note indicative of suicide was found but a sinister energy and clues illuminate the truth.
Arbie and his assistant take some time to investigate the ghost train and unravel some of the mystery surrounding it.
An action packed weekend where all guests and host are treated as suspects in a cosy murder mystery that will leave you guessing.
Downtown Abbey meets Agatha Christie in this saga that is the third in the series.
The gentry, the tranquil English countryside and a best selling author are the main features of a weekend party at the Cleeves Lea Manor hosted by Lady Sybil.
Oblivious that murder was to taint the joys and atmosphere.
Careful attention to the guest list and a celebrity draw card was the responsibility of Lady Sybil.
Her author friend Arbie Swift was keen to attend as the mystery of a ghost train in that part of the countryside may provide fodder for his next book.
The discovery of a body ruffled the guests and the sleuthing began.
A note indicative of suicide was found but a sinister energy and clues illuminate the truth.
Arbie and his assistant take some time to investigate the ghost train and unravel some of the mystery surrounding it.
An action packed weekend where all guests and host are treated as suspects in a cosy murder mystery that will leave you guessing.
Downtown Abbey meets Agatha Christie in this saga that is the third in the series.
January 31, 2026
Review to follow
January 15, 2026
This is third book in this cozy mystery series, with Arbie Swift and Val Coulton-James. Being on the blog tour for this one, I had to buy and read the first two books in this series, I like to watch the characters grow. Although this can easily be read as a stand alone novel.
This one begins around 7 months after their last adventure. It’s April 1926.
Arbie and Val are invited to Cleaves Lea Manor for a weekend party hosted by Sir Bayard Cherville and his wife, Lady Sybil. Arbie is particularly excited about the invitation, as rumours surround the nearby railway line, tales of a ghostly signalman and a phantom train that roars through the night wreathed in flames. These stories would be perfect material for his third book, The Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost Hunting.
Val is now officially Arbie’s assistant, the two have known each other since childhood, having grown up in the same village. Val’s father is the local vicar, while Arbie was raised by his uncle, a lovable rogue who is always skating on thin ice with his various inventions and schemes, leaving Arbie worrying that one day his uncle will finally get caught out.
Lady Sybil has carefully selected the guest list, but on the very morning the guests are due to arrive, she discovers that her husband has secretly invited William (Bill) Endicott. According to Lady Sybil, this one guest threatens to upset everything. Why has Bayard invited him, and what trouble could his presence cause?
The guests are an intriguing mix: a mother and daughter, a nervous but wealthy spinster, a self-made man and his wife, Arbie and Val, and Bill Endicott. As they arrive and get acquainted, Arbie and Val quickly sense an underlying tension, though the cause is unclear. After dinner, the guests separate for a time before reuniting for drinks and bridge, eventually retiring for the night.
The following morning, Arbie is the first awake and heads to the library to search for books that might reference the local hauntings. As he draws back the curtains, he realises he is not alone. One of the guests is dead. Nearby lies a note, a suicide note, or so it appears.
All the guests are asked to remain at the manor until after the inquest on Monday. But was it really suicide, or is something more sinister at play? If someone wanted this person dead, why? The spinster invites her goddaughter to come and stay, to go to the inquest with her.
During the weekend, Arbie and Val take the opportunity to speak with the locals about the ghostly signalman and the phantom train. While villagers are happy to discuss the signalman, no one will say a word about the train. Naturally, this only deepens Arbie and Val’s suspicions.
This is another engaging instalment in the series, full of atmospheric ghost hunting and mystery. There’s also a surprise visitor for Val, Geraint, a suitor who has proposed to her. He arrives determined to make sure Arbie isn’t taking advantage of her, much to Arbie’s amusement, as he keeps trying (unsuccessfully) to get Val to go home. Saying this line of work is not suitable.
Arbie likes to present himself as brave and unflappable, but there’s a moment in this story that had me laughing out loud. I love how the author weaves gentle humour into the narrative. As events unfold, Arbie becomes convinced there’s more going on in the village than meets the eye and invites his uncle to investigate, just in time for another murder. The officer in charge, familiar with Arbie’s previous escapades, asks for his help.
Arbie and Val work wonderfully together. Arbie quietly absorbs information, even though he claims to want nothing more than a peaceful life, while Val is far more inclined to jump straight in and get things done. Their contrasting personalities make them an excellent team. In the first book, I wondered if there might be romance between them, but now I’m less certain. Arbie is protective of Val, though it feels more brotherly than romantic, but who knows what the future may hold?
This book is perfect for fans of Agatha Christie: full of red herrings, strong characters, a well-plotted mystery, and a satisfying conclusion. But will you guess the culprit? I certainly didn’t. I read this in one sitting, completely engrossed, and I highly recommend not only this book but the other two in the series as well—especially if you enjoy a good cosy crime mystery.
This one begins around 7 months after their last adventure. It’s April 1926.
Arbie and Val are invited to Cleaves Lea Manor for a weekend party hosted by Sir Bayard Cherville and his wife, Lady Sybil. Arbie is particularly excited about the invitation, as rumours surround the nearby railway line, tales of a ghostly signalman and a phantom train that roars through the night wreathed in flames. These stories would be perfect material for his third book, The Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost Hunting.
Val is now officially Arbie’s assistant, the two have known each other since childhood, having grown up in the same village. Val’s father is the local vicar, while Arbie was raised by his uncle, a lovable rogue who is always skating on thin ice with his various inventions and schemes, leaving Arbie worrying that one day his uncle will finally get caught out.
Lady Sybil has carefully selected the guest list, but on the very morning the guests are due to arrive, she discovers that her husband has secretly invited William (Bill) Endicott. According to Lady Sybil, this one guest threatens to upset everything. Why has Bayard invited him, and what trouble could his presence cause?
The guests are an intriguing mix: a mother and daughter, a nervous but wealthy spinster, a self-made man and his wife, Arbie and Val, and Bill Endicott. As they arrive and get acquainted, Arbie and Val quickly sense an underlying tension, though the cause is unclear. After dinner, the guests separate for a time before reuniting for drinks and bridge, eventually retiring for the night.
The following morning, Arbie is the first awake and heads to the library to search for books that might reference the local hauntings. As he draws back the curtains, he realises he is not alone. One of the guests is dead. Nearby lies a note, a suicide note, or so it appears.
All the guests are asked to remain at the manor until after the inquest on Monday. But was it really suicide, or is something more sinister at play? If someone wanted this person dead, why? The spinster invites her goddaughter to come and stay, to go to the inquest with her.
During the weekend, Arbie and Val take the opportunity to speak with the locals about the ghostly signalman and the phantom train. While villagers are happy to discuss the signalman, no one will say a word about the train. Naturally, this only deepens Arbie and Val’s suspicions.
This is another engaging instalment in the series, full of atmospheric ghost hunting and mystery. There’s also a surprise visitor for Val, Geraint, a suitor who has proposed to her. He arrives determined to make sure Arbie isn’t taking advantage of her, much to Arbie’s amusement, as he keeps trying (unsuccessfully) to get Val to go home. Saying this line of work is not suitable.
Arbie likes to present himself as brave and unflappable, but there’s a moment in this story that had me laughing out loud. I love how the author weaves gentle humour into the narrative. As events unfold, Arbie becomes convinced there’s more going on in the village than meets the eye and invites his uncle to investigate, just in time for another murder. The officer in charge, familiar with Arbie’s previous escapades, asks for his help.
Arbie and Val work wonderfully together. Arbie quietly absorbs information, even though he claims to want nothing more than a peaceful life, while Val is far more inclined to jump straight in and get things done. Their contrasting personalities make them an excellent team. In the first book, I wondered if there might be romance between them, but now I’m less certain. Arbie is protective of Val, though it feels more brotherly than romantic, but who knows what the future may hold?
This book is perfect for fans of Agatha Christie: full of red herrings, strong characters, a well-plotted mystery, and a satisfying conclusion. But will you guess the culprit? I certainly didn’t. I read this in one sitting, completely engrossed, and I highly recommend not only this book but the other two in the series as well—especially if you enjoy a good cosy crime mystery.
Want to read
December 14, 2025Book three in this quaint and so typically British cosy crime series, part Agatha Christie and part Bertie Wooster.
Set in 1926, Arbie Swift, author of the Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost Hunting, and his assistant, Val, have been invited to Cleeves Lea Manor for a party weekend with other guests. Their hosts are Sir Bayard Cherville and his wife Lady Sybil.
Upon arrival, Arbie and Val detect an atmosphere, perhaps the wrong mix of guests? They both decide to investigate rumours of a ghostly signalman for the next book, apparently, death follows a sighting of the ghost. The local villagers tell of a ghost train, it reveals itself by a Fire in the Sky, the chimney belches forth Hellfire.
The next morning a guest is found dead in the library behind a locked door. The Doctor is called, a note is found and the Police are called. Inspector Battle is uneasy about the death, there seems to be too many clues,,do they point to the wrong conclusion?
When a second guest also winds up dead, this prompts an investigation into both tragedies.
This is at first a straightforward novel, the mystery of the train is easily solved, and the reasons behind it likewise. What this series of books does best is in analysing people, their weaknesses, strengths, all done in a compassionate and non judgemental manner.
Arbie and Val have a really good understanding of their abilities and they really bounce off each other in solving crimes.
The conclusion to this story is startling, surprising, and very clever. I never stood a chance of guessing this one! Wonderfully constructed, it was amazing how all these threads were woven together, it was a tricky puzzle and a locked room classic in the making.
I gave this a five star rating. My thanks to Netgalley and HQ, publishers, for my advance copy, freely given in exchange for my honest review.
I will copy this to Goodreads and Amazon later.
Set in 1926, Arbie Swift, author of the Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost Hunting, and his assistant, Val, have been invited to Cleeves Lea Manor for a party weekend with other guests. Their hosts are Sir Bayard Cherville and his wife Lady Sybil.
Upon arrival, Arbie and Val detect an atmosphere, perhaps the wrong mix of guests? They both decide to investigate rumours of a ghostly signalman for the next book, apparently, death follows a sighting of the ghost. The local villagers tell of a ghost train, it reveals itself by a Fire in the Sky, the chimney belches forth Hellfire.
The next morning a guest is found dead in the library behind a locked door. The Doctor is called, a note is found and the Police are called. Inspector Battle is uneasy about the death, there seems to be too many clues,,do they point to the wrong conclusion?
When a second guest also winds up dead, this prompts an investigation into both tragedies.
This is at first a straightforward novel, the mystery of the train is easily solved, and the reasons behind it likewise. What this series of books does best is in analysing people, their weaknesses, strengths, all done in a compassionate and non judgemental manner.
Arbie and Val have a really good understanding of their abilities and they really bounce off each other in solving crimes.
The conclusion to this story is startling, surprising, and very clever. I never stood a chance of guessing this one! Wonderfully constructed, it was amazing how all these threads were woven together, it was a tricky puzzle and a locked room classic in the making.
I gave this a five star rating. My thanks to Netgalley and HQ, publishers, for my advance copy, freely given in exchange for my honest review.
I will copy this to Goodreads and Amazon later.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Thank you to HQ stories for my early copy of this new Faith Martin book. I rated it 4.5 stars so I've rounded up.
This is my first foray into works by this author and I instantly felt comfortable with the writing style. Set in the 1920s she was able to invoke the feeling of that era with the language the characters used, especially the bright young things and with the references to the fashion of the day, all done in a natural way as the plot unfolded.
This is the third installment in this series but can be read as a standalone very easily. It follows the celebrated author Artbuthnot Swift as he and his companion Val are asked to join a weekend house party in Yorkshire. The other guests are an interesting mixed bunch with a last minute addition thrown in to upset the proceedings. Arbie writes books about ghost hunting and there is talk of a local railway signalman being spotted when danger appears as well as a mystery devil train. An unexpected death of one of the weekend guests sets off the adventure and Arbie tries desperately not to get involved but circumstances mean he gets dragged in.
There is honestly so much packed into this story but it never feels overwhelming at any point and it's enough for you to pick up each thread as it teases its way to the end. The plot is clever, twisting, suspenseful and heartbreaking all at the same time.
As a massive Agatha Christie fan I was eager to give this book a try and I've not been disappointed at all. In fact I now have a new author to follow and will be catching up on the previous adventures.
This is my first foray into works by this author and I instantly felt comfortable with the writing style. Set in the 1920s she was able to invoke the feeling of that era with the language the characters used, especially the bright young things and with the references to the fashion of the day, all done in a natural way as the plot unfolded.
This is the third installment in this series but can be read as a standalone very easily. It follows the celebrated author Artbuthnot Swift as he and his companion Val are asked to join a weekend house party in Yorkshire. The other guests are an interesting mixed bunch with a last minute addition thrown in to upset the proceedings. Arbie writes books about ghost hunting and there is talk of a local railway signalman being spotted when danger appears as well as a mystery devil train. An unexpected death of one of the weekend guests sets off the adventure and Arbie tries desperately not to get involved but circumstances mean he gets dragged in.
There is honestly so much packed into this story but it never feels overwhelming at any point and it's enough for you to pick up each thread as it teases its way to the end. The plot is clever, twisting, suspenseful and heartbreaking all at the same time.
As a massive Agatha Christie fan I was eager to give this book a try and I've not been disappointed at all. In fact I now have a new author to follow and will be catching up on the previous adventures.
January 15, 2026
A Dangerous Train of Thought takes readers on a thrilling ride back to Yorkshire in 1926, where the charming Arbuthnot 'Arbie' Swift, a gentleman ghost-hunter, finds himself entangled in a web of intrigue at Cleeves Lea Manor. The atmosphere is palpable from the start, with the promise of a lavish weekend party quickly overshadowed by a series of mysterious deaths among the guests.
The author's vivid descriptions bring the setting to life, immersing readers in the opulence of the manor while also capturing the eerie undertones of a ghostly legend. Arbie’s character is delightful—his blend of skepticism and curiosity makes him a relatable protagonist, especially as he navigates the expectations of his fans and the unexpected chaos that unfolds.
The plot is well-paced, skillfully weaving together elements of humor and suspense. The initial focus on the ghost train adds a whimsical yet sinister touch, drawing readers into Arbie's investigation with genuine intrigue. As the body count rises, the stakes escalate, making it hard to put the book down.
In summary, A Dangerous Train of Thought is a captivating read for fans of historical mysteries and supernatural tales alike. With its engaging plot, charming characters, and a perfect mix of humor and suspense, it earns a solid four stars. If you enjoy a good ghost story with a clever twist, this book should definitely be on your reading list!
The author's vivid descriptions bring the setting to life, immersing readers in the opulence of the manor while also capturing the eerie undertones of a ghostly legend. Arbie’s character is delightful—his blend of skepticism and curiosity makes him a relatable protagonist, especially as he navigates the expectations of his fans and the unexpected chaos that unfolds.
The plot is well-paced, skillfully weaving together elements of humor and suspense. The initial focus on the ghost train adds a whimsical yet sinister touch, drawing readers into Arbie's investigation with genuine intrigue. As the body count rises, the stakes escalate, making it hard to put the book down.
In summary, A Dangerous Train of Thought is a captivating read for fans of historical mysteries and supernatural tales alike. With its engaging plot, charming characters, and a perfect mix of humor and suspense, it earns a solid four stars. If you enjoy a good ghost story with a clever twist, this book should definitely be on your reading list!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Thank you to HQ for an ARC in exchange for a review.
A ghost-hunting/locked-door murder mystery set in 1920s Yorkshire? Um, yes please!
I really enjoyed this, the 3rd book in a series about ghost/hunter Arbie Swift and his literary assistant Val. I’ve not read the others in the series but it didn’t spoil anything and I’d definitely like to go back and read the others to get the full backstory of the two main characters!
A Dangerous Train of Thought sees Arbie invited to a lavish social gathering at Cleeves Lea Manor somewhere in Yorkshire (can’t figure out where - it said South Yorkshire but also 5 miles from the coast? So, East Yorkshire? Or North-East Lincolnshire? 🤷♀️)
The guest list has been expertly tailored for maximum entertainment. But when Arbie and Val arrive, the atmosphere is tense and odd rather than jovial.
Whilst they’re here, Arbie and Val are investigating rumours of a ghost train and accompanying spectre, for Arbie’s next ghost tourism book. But when he finds one of the guests dead in the morning, he finds himself part of a murder mystery!
I loved the 1920s setting, with all the outfits and language of the era! The characters and their dynamics were intriguing and suspenseful, with witty dialogue. The narrative style of shifting constantly from one character’s perspective to another kept it quick-paced and fun to read.
A ghost-hunting/locked-door murder mystery set in 1920s Yorkshire? Um, yes please!
I really enjoyed this, the 3rd book in a series about ghost/hunter Arbie Swift and his literary assistant Val. I’ve not read the others in the series but it didn’t spoil anything and I’d definitely like to go back and read the others to get the full backstory of the two main characters!
A Dangerous Train of Thought sees Arbie invited to a lavish social gathering at Cleeves Lea Manor somewhere in Yorkshire (can’t figure out where - it said South Yorkshire but also 5 miles from the coast? So, East Yorkshire? Or North-East Lincolnshire? 🤷♀️)
The guest list has been expertly tailored for maximum entertainment. But when Arbie and Val arrive, the atmosphere is tense and odd rather than jovial.
Whilst they’re here, Arbie and Val are investigating rumours of a ghost train and accompanying spectre, for Arbie’s next ghost tourism book. But when he finds one of the guests dead in the morning, he finds himself part of a murder mystery!
I loved the 1920s setting, with all the outfits and language of the era! The characters and their dynamics were intriguing and suspenseful, with witty dialogue. The narrative style of shifting constantly from one character’s perspective to another kept it quick-paced and fun to read.
March 24, 2026
I have not read the previous two in this series but you don't need to in order to work out who these people are and what is going on. Our main crime solving duo are a delight and add in the ghost hunting, and the promise of an actual ghost train and you have all the makings of a really fun time.
The plot jumps around the characters, offering a brief glimpse into all their lives, including (although we don't know it at the time) the murder. It rather reminds of an Agatha Christie in a way, its easy to read, engaging characters that leap off the page despite not a lot of time spent on them. Even the murder is a step up and I was right as to who, but really enjoyed the journey. It all made sense and you could follow the train (no pun intended) of logic to see who, what and why. Very entertaining.
I was pleasantly surprised by this book and have already reserved book one in the series at my local library and will be reading them both. As for this one, it is a worthy addition to the genre. I've read a lot of cosy mysteries and this ranks as one of the better - it has a ghost train for goodness sake, what more could you need to want to read it?
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
The plot jumps around the characters, offering a brief glimpse into all their lives, including (although we don't know it at the time) the murder. It rather reminds of an Agatha Christie in a way, its easy to read, engaging characters that leap off the page despite not a lot of time spent on them. Even the murder is a step up and I was right as to who, but really enjoyed the journey. It all made sense and you could follow the train (no pun intended) of logic to see who, what and why. Very entertaining.
I was pleasantly surprised by this book and have already reserved book one in the series at my local library and will be reading them both. As for this one, it is a worthy addition to the genre. I've read a lot of cosy mysteries and this ranks as one of the better - it has a ghost train for goodness sake, what more could you need to want to read it?
~Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in return for an honest review~
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Yorkshire, 1926. Gentleman ghost-hunter Arbuthnot 'Arbie' Swift and his old friend Val arrive at Cleeves Lea Manor, looking forward to the promise of a lavish weekend party. The lady of the house, an avid reader of Arbie’s books, is eager to show him off to her distinguished guests. Amidst the festivities, Arbie is also tasked with investigating rumours of a ‘ghost train spitting fire’ for the third instalment of the increasingly popular (to Arbie’s great surprise) Gentleman’s Guide to Ghost-hunting.
Then the guests start dying, Arbie instead finds himself thrust into the middle of a murder investigation.
The third outing for Arbie & Val & another well written engrossing murder mystery. I growing to like Arbie & Val more with each book in the series. The mystery is intriguing with plenty of twists, turns & red herrings. There’s also a good array of suspects, some I liked & some I didn’t, I really liked how Arbie & Val bring out the best in each other & they are now bouncing ideas & theories off each other, the dynamics between them is definitely changing
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
Then the guests start dying, Arbie instead finds himself thrust into the middle of a murder investigation.
The third outing for Arbie & Val & another well written engrossing murder mystery. I growing to like Arbie & Val more with each book in the series. The mystery is intriguing with plenty of twists, turns & red herrings. There’s also a good array of suspects, some I liked & some I didn’t, I really liked how Arbie & Val bring out the best in each other & they are now bouncing ideas & theories off each other, the dynamics between them is definitely changing
I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
November 28, 2025
Fresh off the success of his second volume featuring charmingly haunted holiday spots in the British Isles, Arbie and his beautiful, feisty, self-appointed sidekick Val are to be found at Cleeves Lea Manor this time, enjoying a weekend retreat with an interesting and diverse group of people - several of whom are keeping secrets of their own, held tightly to their chests.
All is fun and frolic until someone inevitably cops it. And now, Arbie finds himself once again in the unwilling role of detective (one that is, of course, relished by the lovely Val!)
Martin has delivered a worthy third book in the series featuring our favourite detective duo. Set in the 1920s, this atmospheric and entertaining series is not to be missed, especially by lovers of Golden Age mysteries. It gets 4.5 stars.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
All is fun and frolic until someone inevitably cops it. And now, Arbie finds himself once again in the unwilling role of detective (one that is, of course, relished by the lovely Val!)
Martin has delivered a worthy third book in the series featuring our favourite detective duo. Set in the 1920s, this atmospheric and entertaining series is not to be missed, especially by lovers of Golden Age mysteries. It gets 4.5 stars.
I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A new book by Faith Martin is always a delight to read and A Dangerous Train of Thought sees the welcome return of Arbie and Val, ghost hunters extraordinaire. This is book three in the series and it is a book full of fun and delightful quips. The pair have been invited to a weekend houseparty and immediately start investigating rumours of ghostly goings on. One of the guests is found dead the next morning in the library and the police are called in to investigate the murder with a few too many clues. A second murder follows and Arbie and Val find themselves in the midst of the intrigue.
I love these characters, they are beautifully written and believable. The setting seems very authentic for the 1920’s and gives a real feel of the time.
Very enjoyable and long may this series continue.
I love these characters, they are beautifully written and believable. The setting seems very authentic for the 1920’s and gives a real feel of the time.
Very enjoyable and long may this series continue.
January 16, 2026
A Dangerous Train of Thought by Faith Martin
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Book 3 in The Val and Arbie Mysteries, and it's just as charming as the first two.
A great cosy mystery set in the 1920's, well written with lots of detail so you feel like you're actually there.
This reads as a standalone, you don't have to have read the first two but they are a good read too so why wouldn't you.
I love Val and Arbie and the relationship they have, she doesn't take any nonsense from him 😂
The ghost mystery and the murder mystery are both a fun read and I enjoyed reading how they both unfolded.
I'm looking forward to seeing if they're be further Val and Arbie books and if Uncle has more involvement.
I received a gifted copy of this book. This is my honest review.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Book 3 in The Val and Arbie Mysteries, and it's just as charming as the first two.
A great cosy mystery set in the 1920's, well written with lots of detail so you feel like you're actually there.
This reads as a standalone, you don't have to have read the first two but they are a good read too so why wouldn't you.
I love Val and Arbie and the relationship they have, she doesn't take any nonsense from him 😂
The ghost mystery and the murder mystery are both a fun read and I enjoyed reading how they both unfolded.
I'm looking forward to seeing if they're be further Val and Arbie books and if Uncle has more involvement.
I received a gifted copy of this book. This is my honest review.
February 25, 2026
A Ghost train, a house party, and, of course, a murder.
Arbie and his friend Val are invited to a house party. The carefully balanced crowd is thrown off whack when Sir Beyard Charville invites his own guest. When that guest turns up dead it up to Arbie and Val to try to work out what happened. Also to find out why a ghostly train has been seen appearing on the rails at the dead of night.
This is number three in a series and I hadn’t read any of the others. It is a very funny cosy series which it is possible to pick up halfway through. Having done this and enjoyed it so much I will of course go back and read the first two. It’s always so great to find a brilliant series that is new to you.
Thank you to the publisher for a review copy of this book.
Arbie and his friend Val are invited to a house party. The carefully balanced crowd is thrown off whack when Sir Beyard Charville invites his own guest. When that guest turns up dead it up to Arbie and Val to try to work out what happened. Also to find out why a ghostly train has been seen appearing on the rails at the dead of night.
This is number three in a series and I hadn’t read any of the others. It is a very funny cosy series which it is possible to pick up halfway through. Having done this and enjoyed it so much I will of course go back and read the first two. It’s always so great to find a brilliant series that is new to you.
Thank you to the publisher for a review copy of this book.
March 9, 2026
book is set in 1926 in Cleeves Lea Manor House where ghost writer Arbie Smith and his assistant Val are invited for a weekend house party. There are a lot of people in this book staying at the manor house and on his first morning he finds a body in the library. With suspects galore and a pretty good police inspector Arbie sets out to find the murderer, but everyone is a suspect, and then the body count rises. He also finds himself getting involved with finding out about a ghost train which runs through a red light and the locals are worried about it, although it was fairly predictable what was happening there so that bit wasn't so hard to figure out. This is the second of the Arbuthnot mysteries and it's not a bad read!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I enjoyed reading this book, set in 1920s England Arbie and Val are invited to a weekend party in the country. Ghost hunter Arbie writes books and Val is his Literary assistant. For them the purpose of the visit is to investigate the nearby ghost who appears on the railway line waving his red lantern.
There is a disparate group of visitors for the party, one is unexpected by the hostess and not welcomed by some of the other guests.
All goes well until the next morning when Arbie discovers a body in the library.
With a few twists and interesting side stories, a good book and my thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc.
There is a disparate group of visitors for the party, one is unexpected by the hostess and not welcomed by some of the other guests.
All goes well until the next morning when Arbie discovers a body in the library.
With a few twists and interesting side stories, a good book and my thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc.
February 21, 2026
Faith Martin is one of my favorite mystery Writers. Her Hillary Greene series is one of my top two favorite British mysteries, and her Ryder and Loveday series is excellent. And she has many more excellent books and interesting characters.
This series was unfortunate. The two lead players are like fifth grade children, and they never develop. I was willing to put up with it for one book, thought my way through the second, but gave up on the third.
But if you are new to Faith Martin’s writing, don’t give up! She has many wonderful books and is an excellent author. Check out one of her other titles and enjoy!
This series was unfortunate. The two lead players are like fifth grade children, and they never develop. I was willing to put up with it for one book, thought my way through the second, but gave up on the third.
But if you are new to Faith Martin’s writing, don’t give up! She has many wonderful books and is an excellent author. Check out one of her other titles and enjoy!
February 13, 2026
Arbie and Val return in a fact-finding mission for the next instalment of Arbie’s paranormal tour guide but as keeps happening to them, murder is the real issue they have to deal with. Despite outward appearances, Arbie has a sharp and astute mind, never missing a trick makes him an essential acquaintance of any police force.
A light and entertaining murder mystery which has strong characterisation of its protagonists although many of the other characters feel quite under developed. Some plot points were a little see through but on the whole a fairly enjoyable novel.
A light and entertaining murder mystery which has strong characterisation of its protagonists although many of the other characters feel quite under developed. Some plot points were a little see through but on the whole a fairly enjoyable novel.
December 9, 2025
A Dangerous Train of Thought is book 3 in Faith Martin’s Val & Arbie Mysteries series but it stands well on its own.
Set in Yorkshire 1926, it is an enjoyable and engaging read. The plot kept my interest throughout, the characters are fun and the witty dialogue is entertaining.
Overall, it’s a solid, well-told cosy mystery. 4.5*
Set in Yorkshire 1926, it is an enjoyable and engaging read. The plot kept my interest throughout, the characters are fun and the witty dialogue is entertaining.
Overall, it’s a solid, well-told cosy mystery. 4.5*
January 22, 2026
Interesting
I have to admit this wasn’t quite as interesting as the previous two. Nonetheless I did enjoy it. I will admit that for once I very quickly knew who the murderer was well before the ending and turned out to be correct. I’m looking forward to the next one in this series.
I have to admit this wasn’t quite as interesting as the previous two. Nonetheless I did enjoy it. I will admit that for once I very quickly knew who the murderer was well before the ending and turned out to be correct. I’m looking forward to the next one in this series.
January 25, 2026
I love this series and the audible narrator, John Hopkins, but I felt it did flag slightly at the end. It is a lot of fun, though, in a P G Wodehouse meets Dorothy L Sayers way. It's a golden-age crime with a ghost hunt twist. Faith Martin's other series, I find, twee and annoying but, as characters, Val and Arbie avoid that here.
February 5, 2026
This is the third outing for Val and Arbie and it’s every bit as good as the last two! This time the pair are ensconced in a country house when an apparent suicide occurs.
I very much enjoy the humour of these books and love the relationship between the main pair. I look forward to (hopefully) another outing between them.
I very much enjoy the humour of these books and love the relationship between the main pair. I look forward to (hopefully) another outing between them.
February 16, 2026
I've enjoyed this young series. This installment has a fine mystery, plenty of plot, and the expected mix of characters. Some scene-setting is particularly outstanding imo - e.g. the encounter with the wood pigeon. However, I'd have liked to have had a bit more Val AND Arbie and a bit less Arbie on his own.
Oh, and one glaring editorial mistake!
Oh, and one glaring editorial mistake!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 17, 2026
Arbie and Val Are Always Fun
Ghost hunting leads to murder as per Val & Arnie’s usual adventures. This ghost has a train, everyone but our ghost writing duo has a motive. The clues are all there and suitably obscured. I was hoping the romance would have been advanced but you can’t have everything. I love a mystery that makes me laugh out loud.
Ghost hunting leads to murder as per Val & Arnie’s usual adventures. This ghost has a train, everyone but our ghost writing duo has a motive. The clues are all there and suitably obscured. I was hoping the romance would have been advanced but you can’t have everything. I love a mystery that makes me laugh out loud.
March 14, 2026
I love the Author!!
I love Faith Martin and read all of her books. Val & Arbie are hard to like. She is a hard character to like and Arbie is equally unlikable!!! The story was good, and as usual Faith Martin gives clues to help you figure it out. I will read #4, but I hope Val and Arbie’s relationship moves along.
I love Faith Martin and read all of her books. Val & Arbie are hard to like. She is a hard character to like and Arbie is equally unlikable!!! The story was good, and as usual Faith Martin gives clues to help you figure it out. I will read #4, but I hope Val and Arbie’s relationship moves along.
March 15, 2026
Fun, Christie-like mystery! Faith Martin’s writing skills are on display in the latest Val & Arbie mystery. They are both at a country estate for a weekend party, and to investigate a so-called ghost train. No one at the party is what they seem, and the unraveling of it all is a treat. Highly recommend this series to anyone who enjoys cozy mysteries in the style of Agatha Christie.
March 22, 2026
I am not usually a murder mystery kind of girly but this story was engaging and kept me guessing until the very end!!! It definaltey felt like Detective Poirot but on steriods!! I cant wait to go back and read the rest of the series and try and patiently wait for more
~ 📖 IF YOU LOVE ~
☕ Cozy mysteries
🕵♀️ Female detectives
😱 Twists
🇬🇧 British crime
📜 Historical fiction
~ 📖 IF YOU LOVE ~
☕ Cozy mysteries
🕵♀️ Female detectives
😱 Twists
🇬🇧 British crime
📜 Historical fiction
January 28, 2026
(3.5 stars)
i love this series. its so cosy and the characters are a joy. i love the old english setting, as it reminds me of agatha christie books. unfortunately this one, i did guess the killer quite early on so it lacked the twisty element that i enjoyed in the last two books. not quite as brilliant as the previous two, but still a wonderful read. i will continue to read any future releases in this series!
i love this series. its so cosy and the characters are a joy. i love the old english setting, as it reminds me of agatha christie books. unfortunately this one, i did guess the killer quite early on so it lacked the twisty element that i enjoyed in the last two books. not quite as brilliant as the previous two, but still a wonderful read. i will continue to read any future releases in this series!
January 26, 2026
This was another fabulous book from Faith Martin. It was a relatively easy read and written with a good pace through out. The book had a well developed period setting and contained plenty of red herrings and twists that kept me guessing.
This is a series that I am really enjoying.
This is a series that I am really enjoying.
February 13, 2026
Predictable and kind of misogynist
I don’t think this author likes her main female character very much, and makes the main male character extremely condescending towards her. Also, you can see the solution coming very early in the story.
I don’t think this author likes her main female character very much, and makes the main male character extremely condescending towards her. Also, you can see the solution coming very early in the story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews