“Israelis are not free. They are trapped within an ever-accelerating cycle of violence that they must perpetuate to keep their supremacy intact, All of their children are forced to serve in the IOF and become killers. Compulsory military service is not a hallmark of a free society. Israeli media is some of the most heavily censored on earth, to prevent any non-Zionist, liberatory ides from getting through to its citizens. Even the most tepid criticism of the government within Israel is met with brutal violence, arrests, and suppresion. It's Israelis who live trapped within the barbed-wire cages they erect to keep Palestinians out of their settlements in the West Bank. So Israelis are not Jews who got free of empire. They're Jews who became the foot soldiers of empire.”
3.5/5 rounded up mostly to push this book higher in the Goodreads rankings so people who normally wouldn’t pick it up would see it as artificially inflated lol. If I were to critique this on a literary level, based on the expectations I had for it, I would say it was lacklustre. If I was really being honest, I’d say it read like a long-form TikTok. But was that a flaw of the writing, or a feature? Given the background of the author as a primarily social media influencer/political commentator, I cannot say this style is unusual. However, I will say that the narrative voice got too pop-culture-y, to the point where it felt distracting. While all mediums for communicating information are essential, each one does come with a unique set of ‘rules’. Writing a political book, then, usually wouldn’t involve the same level of side tracks, comedic interventions, and celebrity references, as making an online video. This structure made it difficult for me to focus on the subject matter, because I felt as though I was being patronized and talked down to. HOWEVER- would this be a good introduction for a lay person? Maybe. Although it isn’t the first book I’d recommend. I also felt that the author missed a lot of cultural and historical context, barely mentioning the six day war, the Balfour declaration, the nakba, etc. So in a pseudo way, this book was at once a great one for beginners language wise, but not content wise.
It did, of course, have its positives. I choose to align myself with pro Palestinian sentiments, regardless of who is saying them. I staunchly oppose the identity politics and over-individualizations of the movement, separating what is at its core a humanitarian crisis into a division of faction. The word ‘traitor’ is thrown around too easily, and I enjoyed the comments the author made on this particular topic, referencing the ingenious Táíwò’s takes on identity politics. Here are some excerpts I found to be particularly illuminating:
“ And we live in a world where people are marginalized for all kind of identities so how do you know which oppressed group to prioritize over another? What’s more, there are paid infiltrators in these streets! Particularly in the social media streets! CIA, Hasbara, and neo-Nazi operatives are here, using sock puppet accounts on social media to turn us against each other. And for every one of them, there's a bunch more well-intentioned leftists who do the same work of empire, eating the left from within because they're naïve, or ego-driven, or misguided, or simply too exhausted to learn new ways of relating. So in deciding who to listen to, you're going to have to employ some critical thinking. Here are some helpful questions to ask:
Is this person building community, or tearing it apart?
Is this person more focused on building power, or on appearing morally pure? Is this person prioritizing life-and-death issues, or are they prioriting feelings, wording, and symbolic victories? Is this person focusing on radical transformation, or on preserving be status quo?”
I found it interesting that they even take it a step further:
“ I couldn’t care less how pure your intentions are. I can't know and don't care whether you're motivated by guilt or rage or the noblest of ideals. Call for a Free Palestine because it's cool. Wear a keffiyeh because you look great in one. Dunk on Zionists because you don't want to be associated with them. Say “Free Palestine" because Macklemore and Kehlani said so. Shout "Genocide bad!" over and over and over again—for clout, for followers, for fame, or for deep moral conviction—it's all the same to me. Act out of sacred self-interest. Organize against empire because you yourself want to be free, and you recognize that your freedom is bound up with the freedom of Palestinians, and all people, and all life on earth. Find whatever reason you can to keep showing up. You won't be alone.”
Honestly, when public opinion is one of the threaders of the needle, I am inclined to agree with this take. The author also references great Black Marxist literature and continues to flesh out the connections between racism, capitalism, and oppression. They provide a useful resource into the changing definition of whiteness, a term used to denote not only race but also proximity to wealth and class.
Interesting read but not the best of its kind.