This is such a deligthful debut from Luke Boswell. It has so much about fantasy books that I like: its got some great POV characters, a really fun story, familiar tropes, worldbuilding that feels simple enough to understand, and I just breezed through it in a day. I do have a few issues with it, but overall this is a really well done book!
To start with, the book has a simplicity to the writing style and the world-building that I really enjoyed. It starts with a worldbuilding chapter (which made me a bit apprehensive, but after that the rest of the book really just tells the story of Ezvin and Oren. You might be forgiven if in the first 75 pages you forget that this is a fantasy novel, as it almost feels as if it could have occured in our world at some point in our past. The first 75 pages of the book are fairly slow, and we really get to know not only Ezvin and Oren, but we get to see Ezvin's new role at the Lighthouse in Edgewood, and we also get to know the Lighthouose Keeper, Wyndel Stringfellow (who is delightfully written and was my favorite character to read-personally I pictured Philip Baker Hall in my head).
The story really picks up in chapter 10 (about 60 pages in), and I thought it continued well from then. The story is very simple and straightforward, but I enjoyed it nonetheless. Because of its simplicity, it really reminds me of classic fantasy books. But because of the ages of our protagnoists (11 for Oren and 15 for Ezvin), it really made it feel like a middle grade (possibly YA, but more likely middle grade) "Boys Adventure Novel" that one might find with Raconteur Press now.
I do have a few issues with the book. I really think it's missing a hook at the beginning to jumpstart the story before we go into the "Cozy" portion of the story. I think perhaps a prologue with some action, setting the stage without revealing too much would have helped the book tremendously.
Also the final climax of the book happens late in the final chapter, and so there isn't much of a denoumont (granted, this is book 1 of a series, but still could have used more space between).
Otherwise, I really enjoyed the book, and thought that it was a delightful read throughout. It's a book that I as an adult really enjoyed, but is wholly appropriate that I could give it to my 9 year old nephew if I wanted to. For a debut, this is most excellent, and I cannot wait to read more books from Luke Boswell. I'll give this book a 8.5 out of 10!