Casual Felonies by Kelly Fox is a chaotic and fun start to her second-generation series, continuing the world of Wrecked: Guardians series, which is a joy in itself. That said, I feel the multiple POVs and many returning faces can be confusing if you haven’t read the earlier books. I wouldn’t recommend this as a standalone, but I’ll let you be the judge of that.
Rami is a smart but naïve young man from a wealthy (and, unbeknownst to him, vigilante) family. Truett, his barber and part-time vigilante, is attracted to Rami but in fear of Rami’s formidable dads. Their romance starts off slowly. There are misunderstandings and, let’s not forget, Rami’s really bad attempts at “stalking”. Luckily for our MCs, that eventually leads into a steamy and passionate relationship, but while they have great chemistry, the romance itself feels rushed and underexplored.
Everyone familiar with the original series will enjoy the cameos and POV chapters from Rami’s dads, Anders and Omar. But although these chapters add insight to the family dynamics, they also add to the messy feel of the book since the narrative switches from the MCs’ first-person POV to the dads’ third-person POV.
The world-building is still strong, but it does veer lightly into sci-fi in the second half...this is not bad in my book, but worth mentioning.
I would also say that the large cast of cousins, friends, and both new and old characters brings plenty of variety and humour, but all of this sometimes overshadows Rami and Truett, and it feels like the side characters steal the spotlight.
As always with Kelly’s books, the story mixes dark elements with humour, lighthearted chaos, and strong family bonds. The Wildlings are chaotic, protective, and full of love for each other. There’s action, violence (with purpose), intrigue, and moral greyness, but also loyalty, and hope…and a surprisingly warm undercurrent beneath all that chaos.
What I really struggled with came up in just a couple of sentences, a detail about Anders and Omar. They’ve always been my favourite of Kelly’s characters, and I reread their story regularly.
In their original story, Anders jokes about being sandwiched between Omar and some other good-looking person, but it’s made clear Omar isn’t interested in sharing. There’s even a (bonus?, I can't remember where the scene is from) scene where Omar dances between a couple, and Anders realizes he isn’t okay with sharing Omar either.
So reading here that they occasionally have a play partner felt inconsistent and jarring. It unsettled me enough that I had to pause the book for a few days…a first for me.
While the book overall had its messy moments and other issues, it is a really entertaining book, but this change is the main reason I know I won’t be rereading it.
That said, Casual Felonies is a fun, and sometimes chaotic, start to a new series. The romance itself could have used more development, and the plot feels a bit overcrowded at times, but long time readers of Kelly’s worlds, like myself, will find plenty to enjoy. New readers may want to start with the original series to get the full picture, but anyone who loves quirky characters, murder swoon, humour, and vigilante action will likely have a good time.
I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews, and this is my unbiased review.