What do you think?
Rate this book
Mage Maker #1
Of Mages and Makers
Of Mages and Makers, the debut novel from author Rel Carroll, is a gaslamp romantic fantasy set in a vibrant world with magic, manners, witty banter, some lighthearted thievery, and a swoon-worthy scarlet pimpernel!
Mr. Art Keays has one goal in to appear as useless as possible. But when his sister recklessly unveils a dangerous new invention at the Maker Exhibitions, an elite competition for the coveted title of maker, and her blueprints are stolen, Art is forced to intervene or risk losing everything he pretends not to care about. With an unwelcome mage looking over his shoulder and a looming timeline to find and return the blueprints to the queen, all clues point to a suspicious carriage conveying a most delightful obstacle.
Miss Audrey Clune longs to be Robin Renegade, the fearless heroine from the old adventure stories. In real life, however, her choices are rather limited. Before accepting a sudden proposal from the man of her grandmother’s choosing, Audrey sets out on one last journey to visit her beloved aunt. But when her carriage is ambushed by two mysterious highwaymen, she embraces a novel world of industry and magic with opportunity for adventure far greater than she imagined.
As both Audrey and Art playact different roles in society, the “honest truth” is a precious commodity, especially when dangerous secrets come to light and power has terrible consequences.
Of Mages and Makers by Rel Carroll is perfect for fans of Patricia C. Wrede and Caroline Stevermer's Sorcery and Cecilia or The Enchanted Chocolate Pot and Charlie N. Holmberg’s The Paper Magician series.“A delightful debut packed with airship pirates, untrustworthy mages, stolen inventions, and just the right touch of sweet romance. This cozy blend of steampunk and magic with original worldbuilding and an engaging cast of characters had me hooked.” — Jacquelyn Benson, author of Empire of Shadows
"The perfect ratio of romance to mystery. Chef's kiss!" — Kiri Case, Studio C writer and author of The Hollywood Dropout
Mr. Art Keays has one goal in to appear as useless as possible. But when his sister recklessly unveils a dangerous new invention at the Maker Exhibitions, an elite competition for the coveted title of maker, and her blueprints are stolen, Art is forced to intervene or risk losing everything he pretends not to care about. With an unwelcome mage looking over his shoulder and a looming timeline to find and return the blueprints to the queen, all clues point to a suspicious carriage conveying a most delightful obstacle.
Miss Audrey Clune longs to be Robin Renegade, the fearless heroine from the old adventure stories. In real life, however, her choices are rather limited. Before accepting a sudden proposal from the man of her grandmother’s choosing, Audrey sets out on one last journey to visit her beloved aunt. But when her carriage is ambushed by two mysterious highwaymen, she embraces a novel world of industry and magic with opportunity for adventure far greater than she imagined.
As both Audrey and Art playact different roles in society, the “honest truth” is a precious commodity, especially when dangerous secrets come to light and power has terrible consequences.
Of Mages and Makers by Rel Carroll is perfect for fans of Patricia C. Wrede and Caroline Stevermer's Sorcery and Cecilia or The Enchanted Chocolate Pot and Charlie N. Holmberg’s The Paper Magician series.“A delightful debut packed with airship pirates, untrustworthy mages, stolen inventions, and just the right touch of sweet romance. This cozy blend of steampunk and magic with original worldbuilding and an engaging cast of characters had me hooked.” — Jacquelyn Benson, author of Empire of Shadows
"The perfect ratio of romance to mystery. Chef's kiss!" — Kiri Case, Studio C writer and author of The Hollywood Dropout
264 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 30, 2025
About the author
Rel Carroll
2 books10 followersRel Carroll is passionate about creating characters on the stage and the page. A former student of Brandon Sanderson and Orson Scott Card, she writes a blend of fantasy genres including the Mage Maker series. Between storytelling, you can usually find her in the middle of a dance floor, trying on new accents, or dreaming up more adventures—real and imagined—with her husband, son, and beloved zoo of rescue animals. Connect with the author-actress-activist @relcarroll or visit www.relcarroll.com to join her newsletter for updates and giveaways.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
Read
July 1, 2026This is one of the 10 finalists in the 11th annual SPFBO contest.
Each year 300 books enter the Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off and are judged by ten teams.
300 entries becomes ~50 semi-finalists, then 10 finalists, and then one champion!
Each year 300 books enter the Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off and are judged by ten teams.
300 entries becomes ~50 semi-finalists, then 10 finalists, and then one champion!
June 15, 2026
My rating 4.25
Fabulous read!
Read for SPFBO XI this is only my personal opinion, group verdict might differ widely!
I love a good gaslamp/steampunk/gilded age vibe and the author does that very well. The characters are sweet and smart, I especially liked Aunt Emma. All our main players were well written and interesting in and of themselves, rather than just as a team. The twists and turns really remind me of those penny dreadful stories, in the best way! The slow burn, gentle coming together of our two romantic leads is so sweet, combining sharp banter and flirting but also hesitation and a gradual awakening to love. The villains are just mean enough to give us tension and someone to dislike. I really loved the descriptions of the world itself, the glory and sparkle. The world is unique and interesting. It’s very sweet but enough “danger” to be compelling. Very happy with this overall, and would read something else in this world.
Fabulous read!
Read for SPFBO XI this is only my personal opinion, group verdict might differ widely!
I love a good gaslamp/steampunk/gilded age vibe and the author does that very well. The characters are sweet and smart, I especially liked Aunt Emma. All our main players were well written and interesting in and of themselves, rather than just as a team. The twists and turns really remind me of those penny dreadful stories, in the best way! The slow burn, gentle coming together of our two romantic leads is so sweet, combining sharp banter and flirting but also hesitation and a gradual awakening to love. The villains are just mean enough to give us tension and someone to dislike. I really loved the descriptions of the world itself, the glory and sparkle. The world is unique and interesting. It’s very sweet but enough “danger” to be compelling. Very happy with this overall, and would read something else in this world.
July 12, 2026
3.5/5
Of Mages and Makers won't make you to rethink the genre, but it'll allow you to spend a few evenings with likable people. I would describe it as a cozy-ish gaslamp fantasy with a dash of romance, a touch of mystery, some light political intrigue, and enough witty banter to keep the pages turning.
Art is a good lead. His carefully cultivated image as an utterly useless aristocrat is entertaining from the very first page, especially because everyone, including the reader, quickly realizes it's an act. Beneath the sarcasm and theatrical laziness is someone observant, intelligent, and determined to help those who can't protect themselves. He's funny without trying too hard, and his narration gives the novel much of its personality.
Audrey makes an equally enjoyable counterpart. She's curious, practical, and refreshingly proactive. Their relationship develops without relying on endless misunderstandings or unnecessary drama. I'm not usually drawn to romantic fantasy, but I found myself rooting for the two of them.
The world is another pleasant surprise. The mix of gaslamp fantasy, steampunk inventions, social etiquette, and magic feels cohesive and is nicely introduced without pages and pages of exposition. Airships, makers, mages, mechanical inventions - it all fits together naturally and creates a setting that's easy to sink into.
More than anything, though, this book is simply pleasant. It's funny, warm, well written, and consistently entertaining. I never felt bored, and I finished it remarkably quickly. Ironically, that's also where my biggest criticism lies.
The stakes never truly felt high. Whenever things went wrong, I never really doubted that everything would work out in the end. That sense of comfort is obviously intentional, and for many readers, it'll be exactly what they're looking for, but it also meant I rarely felt genuine tension. I enjoyed the journey, but I was never on the edge of my seat.
As a result, I suspect this will be one of those books I'll remember fondly without remembering many specifics a year from now. Nothing about it frustrated me, but very little stayed after I turned the final page. Still, not every fantasy needs to be dark, emotionally exhausting, or relentlessly epic. Sometimes charm is enough.
If you're looking for a light, well-written fantasy with good leads, enjoyable banter, likable heroes, and just enough romance to warm the story without overwhelming it, Of Mages and Makers is an easy recommendation. It may not be especially memorable, but it's undeniably fun while it lasts.
Of Mages and Makers won't make you to rethink the genre, but it'll allow you to spend a few evenings with likable people. I would describe it as a cozy-ish gaslamp fantasy with a dash of romance, a touch of mystery, some light political intrigue, and enough witty banter to keep the pages turning.
Art is a good lead. His carefully cultivated image as an utterly useless aristocrat is entertaining from the very first page, especially because everyone, including the reader, quickly realizes it's an act. Beneath the sarcasm and theatrical laziness is someone observant, intelligent, and determined to help those who can't protect themselves. He's funny without trying too hard, and his narration gives the novel much of its personality.
Audrey makes an equally enjoyable counterpart. She's curious, practical, and refreshingly proactive. Their relationship develops without relying on endless misunderstandings or unnecessary drama. I'm not usually drawn to romantic fantasy, but I found myself rooting for the two of them.
The world is another pleasant surprise. The mix of gaslamp fantasy, steampunk inventions, social etiquette, and magic feels cohesive and is nicely introduced without pages and pages of exposition. Airships, makers, mages, mechanical inventions - it all fits together naturally and creates a setting that's easy to sink into.
More than anything, though, this book is simply pleasant. It's funny, warm, well written, and consistently entertaining. I never felt bored, and I finished it remarkably quickly. Ironically, that's also where my biggest criticism lies.
The stakes never truly felt high. Whenever things went wrong, I never really doubted that everything would work out in the end. That sense of comfort is obviously intentional, and for many readers, it'll be exactly what they're looking for, but it also meant I rarely felt genuine tension. I enjoyed the journey, but I was never on the edge of my seat.
As a result, I suspect this will be one of those books I'll remember fondly without remembering many specifics a year from now. Nothing about it frustrated me, but very little stayed after I turned the final page. Still, not every fantasy needs to be dark, emotionally exhausting, or relentlessly epic. Sometimes charm is enough.
If you're looking for a light, well-written fantasy with good leads, enjoyable banter, likable heroes, and just enough romance to warm the story without overwhelming it, Of Mages and Makers is an easy recommendation. It may not be especially memorable, but it's undeniably fun while it lasts.
October 3, 2026
Utterly delightful. As a Scarlet Pimpernel fan since childhood, this was absolutely my type of book. I loved it!
Full SPFBO review to come on Fanfiaddict!
Full SPFBO review to come on Fanfiaddict!
April 26, 2026
Read for SPFBO, this is my personal opinion, group verdict might differ widely!
Of Mages and Makers by Rel Carroll is a romp. A genuinely fun, breezy, gaslamp romp with witty banter, lighthearted thievery, and a slow-burn romance that even I, someone who usually could do without romance entirely, didn't mind one bit. For me, that's already saying something.
Art and Audrey are engaging leads. Not especially deep, but competent, fun to follow, and genuinely delightful together. Their dynamic carries the book, and the banter is sharp enough to make you smile without feeling forced.
The world has charm and the steampunk-meets-manners atmosphere is well-executed. The stakes are there on paper, but they rarely feel urgent. Whenever our characters find themselves in a tight spot, a convenient exit tends to materialise. The book resolves its tensions cleanly, sometimes a little too cleanly.
This is comfort reading. It leaves you warm and hopeful, not contemplative. A cosy, charming debut with two leads who are a genuine pleasure to spend time with. Go in for the banter, stay for the warm ending. Just don't expect a deep read.
Of Mages and Makers by Rel Carroll is a romp. A genuinely fun, breezy, gaslamp romp with witty banter, lighthearted thievery, and a slow-burn romance that even I, someone who usually could do without romance entirely, didn't mind one bit. For me, that's already saying something.
Art and Audrey are engaging leads. Not especially deep, but competent, fun to follow, and genuinely delightful together. Their dynamic carries the book, and the banter is sharp enough to make you smile without feeling forced.
The world has charm and the steampunk-meets-manners atmosphere is well-executed. The stakes are there on paper, but they rarely feel urgent. Whenever our characters find themselves in a tight spot, a convenient exit tends to materialise. The book resolves its tensions cleanly, sometimes a little too cleanly.
This is comfort reading. It leaves you warm and hopeful, not contemplative. A cosy, charming debut with two leads who are a genuine pleasure to spend time with. Go in for the banter, stay for the warm ending. Just don't expect a deep read.
Read
July 4, 2026Read for SPFBOX | Finalist Round
Top pick from the Fantasy Fraction group/
I’m part of team Before We Go Blog
RTC
Top pick from the Fantasy Fraction group/
I’m part of team Before We Go Blog
RTC
Read
July 15, 2026Read for SPFBO, RTC
September 24, 2025
This review was originally published on Reedsy Discovery.
No one knows the real Art Keyes, and he is more than happy to keep it that way. But when his sister shares her new, terribly dangerous creation at the annual Maker Exhibition, he is forced to step in and risk everything to save the person he most cares about.
Audrey Clune is trapped in a life of duty and strict rules, dreading the moment she will have to accept the proposal of a man she dislikes but is being forced to marry. She longs for a life of adventure like that of the famous heroine Robin Renegade, and she may just get her wish when her carriage is attacked by highwaymen during her last journey before the dreaded engagement.
As Art and Audrey have to navigate high society and a thick web of lies, it is hard to know whom to trust when the stakes are so high and the "honest truth" becomes a precious commodity.
Of Mages and Makers is a delightful gaslamp fantasy novel brimming with rich, full characters and adventure at every turn. The book features a slow-burn romance that is an absolute joy to watch unfold. Readers looking for spice will not find it here, but anyone seeking a tender romance based on mutual trust and respect won't be disappointed.
The world is described vividly and built so that, after an initial disorientation due to the complex social structure, it feels easy to understand the politics and (im)balances of power at play. The entire cast is characterised extremely well, with even the secondary characters being easy to love (or despise, depending on the case), feeling essential to the story and entirely unforgettable.
The two main characters of course steal the show. I particularly loved the journey of self-discovery and acceptance that Audrey goes on, and reading in the author's final note that it is inspired by the experience of living with chronic pain made it even more touching. The romance is beautifully constructed, never coming across as forced. Although a few passages felt slightly too repetitive in their attempts to reiterate the characters' emotions or thoughts process, the banter is witty and sharp and the writing flows easily. Any (very minor) flaws are entirely forgiven with that near-perfect epilogue.
Overall, Of Mages and Makers is the perfect novel to kickstart autumn and cosy reading season with a sweet, swashbuckling romance that is never banal.
I received an e-arc of this book for free via Reedsy Discovery. This did not affect my opinion of the book in any way.
For more reviews, visit Book for Thought.
No one knows the real Art Keyes, and he is more than happy to keep it that way. But when his sister shares her new, terribly dangerous creation at the annual Maker Exhibition, he is forced to step in and risk everything to save the person he most cares about.
Audrey Clune is trapped in a life of duty and strict rules, dreading the moment she will have to accept the proposal of a man she dislikes but is being forced to marry. She longs for a life of adventure like that of the famous heroine Robin Renegade, and she may just get her wish when her carriage is attacked by highwaymen during her last journey before the dreaded engagement.
As Art and Audrey have to navigate high society and a thick web of lies, it is hard to know whom to trust when the stakes are so high and the "honest truth" becomes a precious commodity.
Of Mages and Makers is a delightful gaslamp fantasy novel brimming with rich, full characters and adventure at every turn. The book features a slow-burn romance that is an absolute joy to watch unfold. Readers looking for spice will not find it here, but anyone seeking a tender romance based on mutual trust and respect won't be disappointed.
The world is described vividly and built so that, after an initial disorientation due to the complex social structure, it feels easy to understand the politics and (im)balances of power at play. The entire cast is characterised extremely well, with even the secondary characters being easy to love (or despise, depending on the case), feeling essential to the story and entirely unforgettable.
The two main characters of course steal the show. I particularly loved the journey of self-discovery and acceptance that Audrey goes on, and reading in the author's final note that it is inspired by the experience of living with chronic pain made it even more touching. The romance is beautifully constructed, never coming across as forced. Although a few passages felt slightly too repetitive in their attempts to reiterate the characters' emotions or thoughts process, the banter is witty and sharp and the writing flows easily. Any (very minor) flaws are entirely forgiven with that near-perfect epilogue.
Overall, Of Mages and Makers is the perfect novel to kickstart autumn and cosy reading season with a sweet, swashbuckling romance that is never banal.
I received an e-arc of this book for free via Reedsy Discovery. This did not affect my opinion of the book in any way.
For more reviews, visit Book for Thought.
January 19, 2026
7/10 Read as a judge for SPFBOXI - rating is my own
RTC
RTC
Read
August 7, 2026This is a finalist in the 11th Self-Publishing Fantasy Blog Off, which I read as one of the judges for the Fantasy-Hive's reviewing team.
Our full collaborative reviews for the finalists will be posted on the Hive from late September onwards and I will update this review then with a link to the review and a rating.
In the meantime you can read more about SPFBO11 and access other reviews here
Our full collaborative reviews for the finalists will be posted on the Hive from late September onwards and I will update this review then with a link to the review and a rating.
In the meantime you can read more about SPFBO11 and access other reviews here
September 30, 2025
“If Brandon Sanderson Wrote in a Victorian Gaslamp World…”
To start, this isn’t normally my genre—but I was hooked from the first chapter. The story pulled me in with its immersive worldbuilding, vivid details, and characters that felt alive and real. There’s a freshness to the writing style that made me want to keep turning the pages.
I once heard a podcaster describe her book on the Anyhow, Anyway podcast as “what it would be like if Brandon Sanderson wrote in a Romantic Gaslamp Victorian era.” That comparison is spot on. The book blends the best of gaslamp fantasy and romantic Victorian adventure, balancing imaginative magic with atmosphere, charm, and emotional depth in a way that’s both fun and meaningful.
What stood out most to me:
The Worldbuilding – layered, immersive, and easy to picture without being overwhelming.
The Characters – quirky, creative, and distinct. Each one feels like they have their own story.
The Tone – that rare mix of whimsy and weight, where lighthearted moments sit right beside tension and drama.
Even as someone outside the typical target audience, I found myself completely absorbed. It reminded me of the whimsy of Susanna Clarke (Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell) and the scope of Brandon Sanderson, while still feeling fresh and unique.
Highly recommend to anyone who loves fantasy with heart, atmosphere, and originality—especially fans of gaslamp fantasy, gothic romance, and magical Victorian adventures.
To start, this isn’t normally my genre—but I was hooked from the first chapter. The story pulled me in with its immersive worldbuilding, vivid details, and characters that felt alive and real. There’s a freshness to the writing style that made me want to keep turning the pages.
I once heard a podcaster describe her book on the Anyhow, Anyway podcast as “what it would be like if Brandon Sanderson wrote in a Romantic Gaslamp Victorian era.” That comparison is spot on. The book blends the best of gaslamp fantasy and romantic Victorian adventure, balancing imaginative magic with atmosphere, charm, and emotional depth in a way that’s both fun and meaningful.
What stood out most to me:
The Worldbuilding – layered, immersive, and easy to picture without being overwhelming.
The Characters – quirky, creative, and distinct. Each one feels like they have their own story.
The Tone – that rare mix of whimsy and weight, where lighthearted moments sit right beside tension and drama.
Even as someone outside the typical target audience, I found myself completely absorbed. It reminded me of the whimsy of Susanna Clarke (Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell) and the scope of Brandon Sanderson, while still feeling fresh and unique.
Highly recommend to anyone who loves fantasy with heart, atmosphere, and originality—especially fans of gaslamp fantasy, gothic romance, and magical Victorian adventures.
October 22, 2026
superstardrifter.com
Of Mages and Makers is the story of Arthur Keays, who is more than he appears to be. Art would love everyone to think that he is an utterly useless aristocrat, when the truth is that he is anything but. As the other main character, Audrey Clune comes on the scene, you can instantly feel a connection between the two. Before Audrey agrees to marry the man that her strict grandmother wants here to, it is time for Audrey to have one last adventure as the Robin Renegade she has always dreamed of being. Someone has stolen no only the blueprints for Art's sister's ingenious make, they've stolen the whole sister as well, and it is up to Art and Audrey to save her!
I enjoyed this one a lot. It definitely felt like a cozy mystery with fantasy elements included. It's a bit gaslamp, or a bit steampunk (or both really, as they are adjacent). There is just enough romance that it satisfied the romance reader in me, but not so much that the romance subplot overshadowed the rest of the story and the mystery elements of it.
The mystery was suitably mysterious throughout the story, and while my inklings were more or less correct, the way that the mystery resolved was presented in a way that I didn't expect, which honestly, is usually more than enough for me.
The worldbuilding was well done. I thought that this world of steampunk inventions and magical shenanigans that combined itself with a bit of fantasy of manners-esque world of the intricacies of social etiquette was easy for me to imagine and immerse myself in.
All told, I had 8/10 stars of fun with Of Mages and Makers. I hope that I can one day read the next book in the series, which I believe is based around the aforementioned ingenious sister.
Of Mages and Makers is the story of Arthur Keays, who is more than he appears to be. Art would love everyone to think that he is an utterly useless aristocrat, when the truth is that he is anything but. As the other main character, Audrey Clune comes on the scene, you can instantly feel a connection between the two. Before Audrey agrees to marry the man that her strict grandmother wants here to, it is time for Audrey to have one last adventure as the Robin Renegade she has always dreamed of being. Someone has stolen no only the blueprints for Art's sister's ingenious make, they've stolen the whole sister as well, and it is up to Art and Audrey to save her!
I enjoyed this one a lot. It definitely felt like a cozy mystery with fantasy elements included. It's a bit gaslamp, or a bit steampunk (or both really, as they are adjacent). There is just enough romance that it satisfied the romance reader in me, but not so much that the romance subplot overshadowed the rest of the story and the mystery elements of it.
The mystery was suitably mysterious throughout the story, and while my inklings were more or less correct, the way that the mystery resolved was presented in a way that I didn't expect, which honestly, is usually more than enough for me.
The worldbuilding was well done. I thought that this world of steampunk inventions and magical shenanigans that combined itself with a bit of fantasy of manners-esque world of the intricacies of social etiquette was easy for me to imagine and immerse myself in.
All told, I had 8/10 stars of fun with Of Mages and Makers. I hope that I can one day read the next book in the series, which I believe is based around the aforementioned ingenious sister.
August 27, 2026
Ms. Carroll has written a wonderful debut fantasy novel. This book was recommended to me by a friend, and I enjoyed every page.
Art is our MMC. He lives a fairly carefree life, appearing as useless as possible. However, when his sister Cecily discovers a new make, and it is stolen, he realizes Cecily is in great danger. The Queen keeps her as prisoner of the palace, keeping her safe from the Mages who rule all of the magic in the kingdom. The Queen gives Art an ultimatum, find the blueprints and the make and bring them back to the Queen. She will then keep Cecily safe. So as Art starts out on this dangerous quest, he realizes he might have a way to solve everything.
Audrey has been kept in a very strict lifestyle with her grandmother. Her grandmother wants her to marry someone that could benefit their lives. However, Audrey has no intentions of relinquishing her freedom to this man. She's always been close to her Aunt Emma and tries to visit her whenever she can. It is on her trip to visit her aunt that she meets Art. And its not a happy meeting either.
I loved the banter between Audrey and Art. Their chemistry shows very early in the book. Audrey convinces Art that she must help him on his quest to find the blue prints for the make. And it doesn't take long for Aunt Emma to join in. She is such an enjoyable character and her love for Audrey shows throughout the story. At one point Audrey makes a discovery that changes her life and makes her question Aunt Emma about her past.
This book is a pretty quick read that will keep you turning the pages. I can't wait to read more about Audrey and Art, and I'm hoping that we will hear more from some of the other characters in the story. I think Cecily needs her own story.
Art is our MMC. He lives a fairly carefree life, appearing as useless as possible. However, when his sister Cecily discovers a new make, and it is stolen, he realizes Cecily is in great danger. The Queen keeps her as prisoner of the palace, keeping her safe from the Mages who rule all of the magic in the kingdom. The Queen gives Art an ultimatum, find the blueprints and the make and bring them back to the Queen. She will then keep Cecily safe. So as Art starts out on this dangerous quest, he realizes he might have a way to solve everything.
Audrey has been kept in a very strict lifestyle with her grandmother. Her grandmother wants her to marry someone that could benefit their lives. However, Audrey has no intentions of relinquishing her freedom to this man. She's always been close to her Aunt Emma and tries to visit her whenever she can. It is on her trip to visit her aunt that she meets Art. And its not a happy meeting either.
I loved the banter between Audrey and Art. Their chemistry shows very early in the book. Audrey convinces Art that she must help him on his quest to find the blue prints for the make. And it doesn't take long for Aunt Emma to join in. She is such an enjoyable character and her love for Audrey shows throughout the story. At one point Audrey makes a discovery that changes her life and makes her question Aunt Emma about her past.
This book is a pretty quick read that will keep you turning the pages. I can't wait to read more about Audrey and Art, and I'm hoping that we will hear more from some of the other characters in the story. I think Cecily needs her own story.
October 3, 2025
I LOVED this book. I'd been aching for an Austen style romance where a twitch of Mr. Darcy's hand can send you into conniptions and this book 100% delivered. The chemistry between our mains is undeniable and I was squealing and putting my head in my head by turns as their relationship took shape around me.
Art is an absolute RAKE. I love him. And he is precisely the kind of scoundrel with a heart of gold that would get me in actual trouble if I were ever to encounter him in real life. Honestly the book would be worth a read just for him, but luckily our leading lady doesn't disappoint. Audrey is audacious and bodacious, refreshing in her depth. And even the side characters manage to assert themselves as more than just filler or background noise.
The world itself is a treat, especially if you're like me and are new to gaslamp fantasy. The technology and the mix of science and magic is a lovely patina that coats every inch of the story. As a newbie in the genre, I appreciated that things remained approachable and the story never got lost in heavy explanations or overly complicated technological discussions. The world building does some serious heavy lifting here, but is seamlessly introduced to readers via the plot and characters and avoids the dreaded "info dump" that makes you feel like you're reading a how-to manual.
Overall this book is worth a read. It's just plain fun. I felt like it rewarded my time and attention by sweeping me away on a hot air balloon. If you like romance and action, you won't be disappointed.
Art is an absolute RAKE. I love him. And he is precisely the kind of scoundrel with a heart of gold that would get me in actual trouble if I were ever to encounter him in real life. Honestly the book would be worth a read just for him, but luckily our leading lady doesn't disappoint. Audrey is audacious and bodacious, refreshing in her depth. And even the side characters manage to assert themselves as more than just filler or background noise.
The world itself is a treat, especially if you're like me and are new to gaslamp fantasy. The technology and the mix of science and magic is a lovely patina that coats every inch of the story. As a newbie in the genre, I appreciated that things remained approachable and the story never got lost in heavy explanations or overly complicated technological discussions. The world building does some serious heavy lifting here, but is seamlessly introduced to readers via the plot and characters and avoids the dreaded "info dump" that makes you feel like you're reading a how-to manual.
Overall this book is worth a read. It's just plain fun. I felt like it rewarded my time and attention by sweeping me away on a hot air balloon. If you like romance and action, you won't be disappointed.
July 16, 2026
Steampunk, chicanery, and robbery all collude to deliver a romance that is lighthearted, but which emphasizes a lesson in consent.
The characters themselves are delightful. The marginal players have personalities of their own, even the snorty little pug Sweet-Pea. Villains in this sort of story can be overblown, but Carroll tamps that down to a believable web of deceits.
The world-building in such a short book is quite remarkable. Diadem, the city; Parure, the monarchy— both combine the glitter of the gilded age with magic, steam inventions, and the rustle of fine silk. Magic has been invented in such as way as to give access to the populace, yet restrict it to a group of nobles who stand in competition with the monarch.
Then there is a young woman who has been overshadowed by her imposing (and verrry rich grandmother), made to feel a burden, and whom is being forced into a marriage she doesn’t want. On a last visit to her aunt before her engagement, her carriage is waylaid at gunpoint by the dashing hero she’s read about … Robin the Renegade. Her life will never be the same. Come to that, neither will his.
There is a short story addendum available, but I think there should be an entire novel-length series of adventures.
As a judge for Fantasy Faction, I must add that this is my opinion of the book and will it be a reflection of the entire group.
The characters themselves are delightful. The marginal players have personalities of their own, even the snorty little pug Sweet-Pea. Villains in this sort of story can be overblown, but Carroll tamps that down to a believable web of deceits.
The world-building in such a short book is quite remarkable. Diadem, the city; Parure, the monarchy— both combine the glitter of the gilded age with magic, steam inventions, and the rustle of fine silk. Magic has been invented in such as way as to give access to the populace, yet restrict it to a group of nobles who stand in competition with the monarch.
Then there is a young woman who has been overshadowed by her imposing (and verrry rich grandmother), made to feel a burden, and whom is being forced into a marriage she doesn’t want. On a last visit to her aunt before her engagement, her carriage is waylaid at gunpoint by the dashing hero she’s read about … Robin the Renegade. Her life will never be the same. Come to that, neither will his.
There is a short story addendum available, but I think there should be an entire novel-length series of adventures.
As a judge for Fantasy Faction, I must add that this is my opinion of the book and will it be a reflection of the entire group.
September 2, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this unexpectedly fast-paced read that still manages to capture wonderfully cozy vibes. The historical fantasy aspect, and particularly the worldbuilding, fascinated me and gave the story a solid backdrop from which to unfold. The characters were great fun and capture that limitless spirit of adventure so common for 19th century reads. Audrey and Art also make for a cute couple. I liked how the author made things difficult for their budding romance, while also keeping things lighthearted and fun.
My only quibble is over the choice to use French as the foreign language. It created some incongruous moments in the flow of the narration that threw me out of the story because the incorrect word form was used for the grammar of the sentence or phrase. I would have also liked to have seen the first song Audrey performed structured better and with a more easily identifiable rhythm. It was presented just as prose, which I felt detracted from the experience.
All in all, I’m enthralled and can’t wait to find out what these characters will get up to next.
My only quibble is over the choice to use French as the foreign language. It created some incongruous moments in the flow of the narration that threw me out of the story because the incorrect word form was used for the grammar of the sentence or phrase. I would have also liked to have seen the first song Audrey performed structured better and with a more easily identifiable rhythm. It was presented just as prose, which I felt detracted from the experience.
All in all, I’m enthralled and can’t wait to find out what these characters will get up to next.
October 27, 2025
Rel Carroll delivers a STRONG story with Of Mages and Makers, and I enjoyed every bit of it! She breathed life into this tale like aether in the lungs, and I am so excited to see what words she weaves together next!
As a reader who often can see where the plot threads are going, I am thrilled with the number of times Carroll 'uno reversed' into something unexpected, but still utterly believable that cemented the realism of her world and the stakes her misfit team of characters had to face. Seriously, BRAVO!
And speaking of characters: each carried depth and charisma, without being overbearing. They were each fully realized and motivated as individuals, adding their strengths and weaknesses to the plot. I loved the intersection of steam punk, gas lamp, and magical elements that made this world so rich. The romance was sweet and our MCs shared some well-earned kisses without getting spicy. DO NOT sleep on this offering!
As a reader who often can see where the plot threads are going, I am thrilled with the number of times Carroll 'uno reversed' into something unexpected, but still utterly believable that cemented the realism of her world and the stakes her misfit team of characters had to face. Seriously, BRAVO!
And speaking of characters: each carried depth and charisma, without being overbearing. They were each fully realized and motivated as individuals, adding their strengths and weaknesses to the plot. I loved the intersection of steam punk, gas lamp, and magical elements that made this world so rich. The romance was sweet and our MCs shared some well-earned kisses without getting spicy. DO NOT sleep on this offering!
April 21, 2026
Miss Audrey Clune longs to be Robin Renegade, the fearless heroine from the old adventure stories, but in real life her choices are rather limited...
A whirlwind of adventure and romance! I definitely enjoyed the gaslamp/steampunk vibes. Loved the hidden identities and mystery of the missing invention. Art and Audrey and were two interesting characters to follow and I was rooting for them throughout. I did feel the pace was a little bit rushed as I was continually left thinking, "wait, what?". Strong world building here but I would have liked it explained a bit more at the beginning. Overall a world I would enjoy entering again.
Note: the author does classify the book as "mild-spice" but the author must be counting kissing as spice as there was nothing more than that.
Genre: Fantasy romance (no spice)
Mage Maker Book 1
Favorite character: Aunt Emma (side character)
Favorite scene: off to the Gala
A whirlwind of adventure and romance! I definitely enjoyed the gaslamp/steampunk vibes. Loved the hidden identities and mystery of the missing invention. Art and Audrey and were two interesting characters to follow and I was rooting for them throughout. I did feel the pace was a little bit rushed as I was continually left thinking, "wait, what?". Strong world building here but I would have liked it explained a bit more at the beginning. Overall a world I would enjoy entering again.
Note: the author does classify the book as "mild-spice" but the author must be counting kissing as spice as there was nothing more than that.
Genre: Fantasy romance (no spice)
Mage Maker Book 1
Favorite character: Aunt Emma (side character)
Favorite scene: off to the Gala
June 29, 2026
The story immediately captured my interest!
In a Gaslamp world, Art is a bit of useless dandy although we get hints from the beginning that he may not be just as he seems. When his cousin, Cecily, is caught up in danger of her own making, Art has to decide if he’ll shed his persona to help her.
Meanwhile Audrey is also playing a role, daughter of an actress, but granddaughter of a Gem of high society, she is intended to be less than happily affianced to Maker Malowney at her grandmother’s demand.
This is a rollicking read - highwaymen, airships, high society, balls, and magic. Art and Audrey are a wonderful couple with great banter. There’s a Scarlet Pimpernel type character (my favorite retelling!) and a happily for now ending with the possibility of more books with the team that Audrey and Art have assembled.
Fans of Liz Delton's Soldark will appreciate the Gaslamp setting and the sweet romance.
July 6, 2026
Read and rated for SPFBO! Find our team's reviews here: https://beforewegoblog.com/spfboxi-re...
Of Mages and Makers is a secondary world, steampunk romance full of hijinks and featuring a lively cast of characters.I usually try to stay away from more generalized recommendations (e. g. “fans of fantasy will enjoy this”), but in the case of Rel Carroll’s finalist I would recommend it most to steampunk fans, as well as anyone looking for a light fantasy romp that doesn’t take itself (or its themes) too seriously. It’s been billed as Regency steampunk, though I would caution fans of historical fantasy not to go in expecting a detailed historical feel, or, indeed, a regent. For me, there wasn’t much to distinguish it from more general steampunk settings (though perhaps the intention is simply meant to indicate to the reader that we should be picturing empire waists and bonnets). There’s nothing wrong with this more general approach, but I mention the fact so that it’s easier for the right readers to find the book.
Mages focuses on two romantic leads–Art and Audrey–as they pursue a stolen set of blueprints that could either upend their society’s formal class system, or be modified to create a devastating weapon. Even worse, the blueprints originally belonged to Art’s inventor sister, Cecily. Cecily is at risk of execution for overstepping her own class expectations and for her creations’s capacity to allow those not naturally blessed with magic to be able to produce it. Audrey–a would-be stage actress living in her dead mother’s shadow–is engaged to the chief suspect in the blueprints’ theft, a fact that makes her instant attraction to self-described rake, Art, just a tad problematic. For Art’s part, he’s shocked to find himself employed by the queen and working alongside Harland–an enigmatic mage assigned to help with the recovery.
Carroll crafts a charming story in Mages. It’s light and breezy, hitting some popular romantic storylines and archetypes (a dashing thief, a hyperfocused if frazzled engineer, and a would-be starlet with secrets). I’m always a sucker for a roguish highwayman lead, so there were aspects of that part of the story that especially worked for me, and without giving away specifics, I enjoyed how Carroll plays with gender expectations in that context as the novel progresses into its final act. There’s also plenty of action in Mages–enough that I’m tempted to compare it with a Marvel movie, but set in a fantastical nineteenth-century and with a solid helping of romance to bring more heart.
That said, despite readable prose and likeable characters, Mages stumbles at the structural level. While Art and Audrey are easy to root for, I was rarely compelled by them. A large part of the reason why is that for the majority of the book the stakes aren’t really Audrey or Art’s–they belong to Cecily and to the lower classes. The stakes are also seemingly very high–the possibility of Cecily’s execution is floated in the opening, and if her invention is made accessible, it will completely revolutionize the state (and possibly also lead to a real revolution, I would think). Yet the majority of the cast more or less brush this element aside. This reaction (or lack thereof) just doesn’t feel believable, even in the context of a light romance, and it unfortunately limited my ability to connect with the protagonists, story, or world. There’s some lip service paid to the idea that Art and his family are themselves from a lower class, yet they move quite fluidly in wealthy spaces and seem anything but underprivileged. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this–plenty of compelling stories involve a protagonist who’s clawed their way up the social ladder in face of bigotry or poverty–yet Art never feels genuinely impacted by his background, with the result that he never seems invested in the possibility promised by Cecily’s invention. In fact, with a couple of significant exceptions, the lower class people we do meet are generic thugs, described in unflattering terms. None of this would necessarily be a problem, if it didn’t flatten the stakes as they pertain to Art. Even the possibility of Cecily’s execution is never something we really feel on page, and since Cecily disappears from the narrative very early and for most of the book, it left me wondering throughout why we were specifically following Art and Audrey.
There are a number of late-stage reveals that tease a richness of character and plot that I wish so badly had been seeded earlier so they were more impactful. More than one significant character detail comes seemingly out of nowhere in the final quarter. These are treated as plot points the audience is expected to already know (and we should know, given that we’re in Art and Audrey’s POVs). Several times, I found myself thinking I must have missed a critical detail earlier in the book, only to reread or consult a fellow judge, and find that I hadn’t. It’s genuinely a shame, because the elements that do get introduced later on are potentially powerful and would have deepened the character work as well as Art and Audrey’s individual investments in the world around them.
Though I did have major issues with the structure and focus of Mages, the book does pick up steam (hah!) in its final act. You can tell Carroll’s having fun and it’s easy to have fun with her. One of the plot elements that comes into focus as Mages concludes is the mystery surrounding Art’s companion, Harland. Throughout, I found that Carroll did a wonderful job giving the reader just enough information about him to intrigue, and it was this storyline that kept my attention throughout.
Rel Carroll is a talented writer and Mages has a lot going for it. I think, with some better interweaving of its plot threads and a stronger sense of where its focus lies, it would also have a good chance of making a huge splash.
Of Mages and Makers is a secondary world, steampunk romance full of hijinks and featuring a lively cast of characters.I usually try to stay away from more generalized recommendations (e. g. “fans of fantasy will enjoy this”), but in the case of Rel Carroll’s finalist I would recommend it most to steampunk fans, as well as anyone looking for a light fantasy romp that doesn’t take itself (or its themes) too seriously. It’s been billed as Regency steampunk, though I would caution fans of historical fantasy not to go in expecting a detailed historical feel, or, indeed, a regent. For me, there wasn’t much to distinguish it from more general steampunk settings (though perhaps the intention is simply meant to indicate to the reader that we should be picturing empire waists and bonnets). There’s nothing wrong with this more general approach, but I mention the fact so that it’s easier for the right readers to find the book.
Mages focuses on two romantic leads–Art and Audrey–as they pursue a stolen set of blueprints that could either upend their society’s formal class system, or be modified to create a devastating weapon. Even worse, the blueprints originally belonged to Art’s inventor sister, Cecily. Cecily is at risk of execution for overstepping her own class expectations and for her creations’s capacity to allow those not naturally blessed with magic to be able to produce it. Audrey–a would-be stage actress living in her dead mother’s shadow–is engaged to the chief suspect in the blueprints’ theft, a fact that makes her instant attraction to self-described rake, Art, just a tad problematic. For Art’s part, he’s shocked to find himself employed by the queen and working alongside Harland–an enigmatic mage assigned to help with the recovery.
Carroll crafts a charming story in Mages. It’s light and breezy, hitting some popular romantic storylines and archetypes (a dashing thief, a hyperfocused if frazzled engineer, and a would-be starlet with secrets). I’m always a sucker for a roguish highwayman lead, so there were aspects of that part of the story that especially worked for me, and without giving away specifics, I enjoyed how Carroll plays with gender expectations in that context as the novel progresses into its final act. There’s also plenty of action in Mages–enough that I’m tempted to compare it with a Marvel movie, but set in a fantastical nineteenth-century and with a solid helping of romance to bring more heart.
That said, despite readable prose and likeable characters, Mages stumbles at the structural level. While Art and Audrey are easy to root for, I was rarely compelled by them. A large part of the reason why is that for the majority of the book the stakes aren’t really Audrey or Art’s–they belong to Cecily and to the lower classes. The stakes are also seemingly very high–the possibility of Cecily’s execution is floated in the opening, and if her invention is made accessible, it will completely revolutionize the state (and possibly also lead to a real revolution, I would think). Yet the majority of the cast more or less brush this element aside. This reaction (or lack thereof) just doesn’t feel believable, even in the context of a light romance, and it unfortunately limited my ability to connect with the protagonists, story, or world. There’s some lip service paid to the idea that Art and his family are themselves from a lower class, yet they move quite fluidly in wealthy spaces and seem anything but underprivileged. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this–plenty of compelling stories involve a protagonist who’s clawed their way up the social ladder in face of bigotry or poverty–yet Art never feels genuinely impacted by his background, with the result that he never seems invested in the possibility promised by Cecily’s invention. In fact, with a couple of significant exceptions, the lower class people we do meet are generic thugs, described in unflattering terms. None of this would necessarily be a problem, if it didn’t flatten the stakes as they pertain to Art. Even the possibility of Cecily’s execution is never something we really feel on page, and since Cecily disappears from the narrative very early and for most of the book, it left me wondering throughout why we were specifically following Art and Audrey.
There are a number of late-stage reveals that tease a richness of character and plot that I wish so badly had been seeded earlier so they were more impactful. More than one significant character detail comes seemingly out of nowhere in the final quarter. These are treated as plot points the audience is expected to already know (and we should know, given that we’re in Art and Audrey’s POVs). Several times, I found myself thinking I must have missed a critical detail earlier in the book, only to reread or consult a fellow judge, and find that I hadn’t. It’s genuinely a shame, because the elements that do get introduced later on are potentially powerful and would have deepened the character work as well as Art and Audrey’s individual investments in the world around them.
Though I did have major issues with the structure and focus of Mages, the book does pick up steam (hah!) in its final act. You can tell Carroll’s having fun and it’s easy to have fun with her. One of the plot elements that comes into focus as Mages concludes is the mystery surrounding Art’s companion, Harland. Throughout, I found that Carroll did a wonderful job giving the reader just enough information about him to intrigue, and it was this storyline that kept my attention throughout.
Rel Carroll is a talented writer and Mages has a lot going for it. I think, with some better interweaving of its plot threads and a stronger sense of where its focus lies, it would also have a good chance of making a huge splash.
September 29, 2025
I absolutely loved Of Mages and Makers by Rel Carroll! The story follows Audrey, who has spent her life under her grandmother’s strict rules, and Art, a man who acts detached but is fiercely loyal to those he loves. Together, they navigate challenges, uncover family secrets, and fight for what’s right, all while discovering themselves and each other. The world-building is immersive, the characters feel real, and the story kept me turning pages late into the night. It’s full of adventure, heart, and romance without ever feeling rushed. I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves fantasy, strong characters, and a story that keeps you hooked from start to finish!
September 30, 2025
Some of the best enemies-to-lovers banter and dialogue I’ve read in a while! Ugh, I love the two main protagonists and their relationship so much! I’ve always been a fan of the Scarlet Pimpernel, and this book really captured that same feeling, with a hint of magic to boot. I really liked the magic system and how many twists and turns there were. Just when I thought I had things figured out, something surprising would happen. A really fun read overall, and I highly recommend the companion novella, but make sure you read this book first. The novella has a different kind of romance that pairs well with this one. I’m excited to see what this author does next!
November 6, 2025
I give this book 4.5 stars. It is a fantastically fun plot. I enjoy the main characters, though I wish we saw more depth to the relationship to take it to the next level. The setting and magic system are fun. The book ended at a perfect cliff hanger. I'm not mad at the author for how it ended, yet still eagerly awaiting a second book in the series to know what happens next. I knocked it down .5 stars because it took the author the first few chapters to find her voice and cadence in the book.
August 29, 2026
Amazing!
This steampunk/ gaslamp fantasy is a truly gripping story of love, adventure, justice, secrets, and manipulation. It follows the two main characters, Arthur and Audrey, on their separate journeys until their paths cross - and the real adventure begins. The world building has a lot of charm, the characters are easy to connect with, and the world of magic is full of surprises. There are many secrets in the story, and uncovering them brings great plot twists. I had a lot of fun with this book!
This steampunk/ gaslamp fantasy is a truly gripping story of love, adventure, justice, secrets, and manipulation. It follows the two main characters, Arthur and Audrey, on their separate journeys until their paths cross - and the real adventure begins. The world building has a lot of charm, the characters are easy to connect with, and the world of magic is full of surprises. There are many secrets in the story, and uncovering them brings great plot twists. I had a lot of fun with this book!
September 30, 2025
Ok, I care way too much about these characters. This book is a great blend of adventure, suspense, and romance that kept me hooked all the way through. The world building is vibrant and tangible with an interesting magic system. I would highly recommend this book for any fans of romantasy… or just romance… or just fantasy! Romance isn’t usually my go-to book pick, but I might have to change that now. I am excited to see what the author writes next; this was a fantastic debut.
October 16, 2025
I absolutely love the voice of this book! It’s so vivid that it plays like a movie in my head. The writing is witty and seamlessly blends fantasy, steampunk, and romance. Within the first chapter, the characters are so well written that you immediately understand who they are. The humor has a delightful Victorian/ Regency flair, with a touch of sophisticated, clever, and amusing charm that makes it enjoyable to read.
January 24, 2026
The thought that kept going through my mind reading the book was, "This author can write!"
So many rich details make this world of zeppelins, heroines, and magic believable. Told from the perspectives of two people who become intertwined, I felt as effortlessly in one mind as the other.
The deeper message, that a disability can be its own kind of strength, despites its downsides, really resonated with me. Highly recommended!
So many rich details make this world of zeppelins, heroines, and magic believable. Told from the perspectives of two people who become intertwined, I felt as effortlessly in one mind as the other.
The deeper message, that a disability can be its own kind of strength, despites its downsides, really resonated with me. Highly recommended!
October 8, 2025
I absolutely adored reading this book! I love the immersion that is offered through beautiful, vivid description and the variety of Interesting and complex characters. It is a wonderful mix of steampunk and magic which I have rarely read anything similar to. The world and writing just seems to pull you in.
November 2, 2025
Very Interesting Universe
If this is your first time reading the "Mage Maker" series (as I did) you need a little time to slide into it, but the story gets more exciting the more you read! Art of course reminds me of "The Scarlet Pimpernel".
And something important for Audrey: Don't bend too much for others or you'll lose yourself!
Hopefully the next book will not take too long...
If this is your first time reading the "Mage Maker" series (as I did) you need a little time to slide into it, but the story gets more exciting the more you read! Art of course reminds me of "The Scarlet Pimpernel".
And something important for Audrey: Don't bend too much for others or you'll lose yourself!
Hopefully the next book will not take too long...
January 16, 2026
I'm slowly reading this book and the whimsy and characters are always such a treat. I love when I have time to take a break from real-world tasks and concerns and escape into Art and Audrey's lives! I am excited for the sequel!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews