What do you think?
Rate this book
Once Upon A Song
Not yet published
Expected 23 Jan 26Welcome to the Hôtel de Neige. Let yourself be swept away by its grandeur and glamor, but beware…the cold may swallow you whole. When lonely waitress Ana lands a job as a singer at the prestigious Hôtel de Neige, she believes it to be the beginning of her fairytale. Yet she soon finds that in those eerie halls, the line between Cinderella story and Gothic nightmare blurs. Sinister dreams cause her to sleepwalk, a ballerina makes ominous threats, and a phantom in white haunts the hotel—and Ana. As Ana discovers that the hotel’s last singer lost his life under mysterious circumstances, she needs to decide if happily-ever-after is worth it. She knows she cannot trust her secretive colleagues or the charming but elusive hotel manager, Dimitri. All Ana ever wanted was to belong, but at the Hôtel de Neige, that may mean never leaving again…
274 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication January 23, 2026
222 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews
January 10, 2026
I totally picked this up because the author described it as Anastasia meets Phantom of the Opera and I could definitely see some of the inspiration from the two throughout the novel!
I absolutely loved the atmospheric world building and found family element. I could perfectly picture the setting with its snowy, cold surroundings! I also enjoyed the mystery, it created a lot of tension and helped move the story forward.
Although it’s categorized as a gothic fantasy with some mystery and romance elements, for me it felt mostly like a gothic mystery. The fantasy aspects were there but could’ve been built upon more-there were things that could’ve had more explanation in terms of how the Hotel worked especially once things become revealed. And the romance was meh, I didn’t totally believe it and feel like Ana went from hate to love way too fast. And the spicy scene felt like it came out of nowhere. I wasn’t expecting it and was slightly thrown but it wasn’t terrible, I’ve definitely read worse, I just typically don’t enjoy books with spice for the most part unless I know it’s coming 😂
I found the dialogue a bit unnatural and choppy (like the constant decision to not use contractions; ie it is instead of it’s or should have instead of should’ve). It made every conversation feel robotic. Also why did the FMC have so many nicknames (It’s two but still her name is short enough as it is!!)? I hated every time Bahar called her Angie 🙄
The twist was a fun surprise towards the end and I didn’t see most of it coming! I do think the ending was rushed though-I needed more answers! It felt so abrupt and I wished we would’ve gotten more answers in terms of the fantasy elements (which is why is said earlier that it felt more appropriate to be labeled as a gothic mystery).
My final gripe was how annoying it was having the characters constantly avoiding revealing things with each other. Those conversations got dragged on only to add nothing extra to the tension or character development. I was over it in the last third, at that point either don’t allude to things at all or share the secrets already-PUT UP OR SHUT UP!!
Overall there were things that could’ve worked better had the book been just a bit longer and had more time to marinate. But it was still an enjoyable story and I look forward to reading whatever Bells writes next!
Thank you to NetGalley and Quill & Crow for the earc.
I absolutely loved the atmospheric world building and found family element. I could perfectly picture the setting with its snowy, cold surroundings! I also enjoyed the mystery, it created a lot of tension and helped move the story forward.
Although it’s categorized as a gothic fantasy with some mystery and romance elements, for me it felt mostly like a gothic mystery. The fantasy aspects were there but could’ve been built upon more-there were things that could’ve had more explanation in terms of how the Hotel worked especially once things become revealed. And the romance was meh, I didn’t totally believe it and feel like Ana went from hate to love way too fast. And the spicy scene felt like it came out of nowhere. I wasn’t expecting it and was slightly thrown but it wasn’t terrible, I’ve definitely read worse, I just typically don’t enjoy books with spice for the most part unless I know it’s coming 😂
I found the dialogue a bit unnatural and choppy (like the constant decision to not use contractions; ie it is instead of it’s or should have instead of should’ve). It made every conversation feel robotic. Also why did the FMC have so many nicknames (It’s two but still her name is short enough as it is!!)? I hated every time Bahar called her Angie 🙄
The twist was a fun surprise towards the end and I didn’t see most of it coming! I do think the ending was rushed though-I needed more answers! It felt so abrupt and I wished we would’ve gotten more answers in terms of the fantasy elements (which is why is said earlier that it felt more appropriate to be labeled as a gothic mystery).
My final gripe was how annoying it was having the characters constantly avoiding revealing things with each other. Those conversations got dragged on only to add nothing extra to the tension or character development. I was over it in the last third, at that point either don’t allude to things at all or share the secrets already-PUT UP OR SHUT UP!!
Overall there were things that could’ve worked better had the book been just a bit longer and had more time to marinate. But it was still an enjoyable story and I look forward to reading whatever Bells writes next!
Thank you to NetGalley and Quill & Crow for the earc.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I walked into Once Upon a Song not knowing much about it and was so pleasantly surprised!
When Ana’s dream to become a singer comes true and she lands a job at the high-class Hotel de Neige, she must prove to the other performers that she belongs. But Ana soon finds that the hotel is far more sinister than she once thought and her colleagues hold a secret about the last singer close to their chests. Ana must learn what happened to him as she navigates the halls of Hotel de Neige but is unravelling the secret worth sacrificing the new home she has made for herself?
At its heart Once Upon a Song is a story of belonging and loneliness. The concept is deeply gothic and fun, the characters charming even when they keep their secrets and the writing style was clear and compelling. I really enjoyed my time reading Once Upon a Song.
One of my favourite things about this novel was Ana’s voice and her journey towards belonging, and separately, her interactions with the love interest, Dimitri. Ana’s loneliness especially was really heart-wrenching and her confidence warming. Her scenes with Dimitri came with Ana’s conflicting emotions, and they were written really well.
I’m really glad that I had a chance to read this book.
I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
When Ana’s dream to become a singer comes true and she lands a job at the high-class Hotel de Neige, she must prove to the other performers that she belongs. But Ana soon finds that the hotel is far more sinister than she once thought and her colleagues hold a secret about the last singer close to their chests. Ana must learn what happened to him as she navigates the halls of Hotel de Neige but is unravelling the secret worth sacrificing the new home she has made for herself?
At its heart Once Upon a Song is a story of belonging and loneliness. The concept is deeply gothic and fun, the characters charming even when they keep their secrets and the writing style was clear and compelling. I really enjoyed my time reading Once Upon a Song.
One of my favourite things about this novel was Ana’s voice and her journey towards belonging, and separately, her interactions with the love interest, Dimitri. Ana’s loneliness especially was really heart-wrenching and her confidence warming. Her scenes with Dimitri came with Ana’s conflicting emotions, and they were written really well.
I’m really glad that I had a chance to read this book.
I received an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
December 1, 2025
Ana's lifelong dream of becoming a singer finally comes true after a lonely life as a waitress in New York City when she lands the job of lead singer at the prestigious Hôtel de Neige. Initially, it appears to be everything she ever wanted. However, after experiencing spine-chilling nightmares and facing a jealous colleague, it soon becomes clear that the hotel is not what it seems.
Once Upon a Song is a captivating mix between a frosty fairytale and a gothic horror novel. It is gripping, especially during the rising action. While the final plot twist was quite obvious to me, the novel features some interesting turns I didn't expect. Ana’s nightmares are particularly well-written and very spooky, creating a genuine sense of dread that accompanies the reader throughout the story. What bothered me most was the excessive secrecy among the characters, which occasionally became tiresome and slowed the narrative. I hadn’t anticipated a romance plot, but I found it to be well done.
To sum up, this novel offers a rich atmosphere and genuine thrills, making it perfect for those looking for a fantasy, wintery romance with a dark undercurrent.
I voluntarily reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and comments are my own.
Once Upon a Song is a captivating mix between a frosty fairytale and a gothic horror novel. It is gripping, especially during the rising action. While the final plot twist was quite obvious to me, the novel features some interesting turns I didn't expect. Ana’s nightmares are particularly well-written and very spooky, creating a genuine sense of dread that accompanies the reader throughout the story. What bothered me most was the excessive secrecy among the characters, which occasionally became tiresome and slowed the narrative. I hadn’t anticipated a romance plot, but I found it to be well done.
To sum up, this novel offers a rich atmosphere and genuine thrills, making it perfect for those looking for a fantasy, wintery romance with a dark undercurrent.
I voluntarily reviewed an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and comments are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4☆
Ana is an orphan with little memory of her past who finds solace in singing and believes her dreams are finally coming true when she lands a job as a singer at the mysterious Hotel de Neige. What initially feels like a fairytale quickly turns into a nightmare as she ignores warnings, acts on emotion, and is forced to confront the hotel’s dark reality. While the romance introduces magical intrigue, it feels shallow and strained by manipulation, deceit, and conflicting motivations, making the couple difficult to root for. The story is fast-paced and engaging, with constant suspense, strong gothic fairytale elements, and an immersive winter setting brought to life through vivid, atmospheric descriptions. Despite some miniscule criticisms and a reveal that feels underdeveloped, the novel shows impressive promise for a debut and hints at a strong future for the author’s storytelling.
RELATIONSHIPS & CHARACTERS -
Ana - An orphan who has a vague memory of her past besides constantly running away from her foster homes has only music to rely on. Singing has always been her passion and transports her to the only happiness she knows. Determined to get a job other than waitressing, she auditions to be the singer at the Hotel de Neige, where she is given the job under less-than-favorable and questionable circumstances. She thinks that something is finally going her way and her fairytale dreams are coming true, but reality turns out to be more of a nightmare than she was prepared for. Ana initially is defensive about her situation and blatantly ignores the warnings around her. While the other characters are frustratingly vague and elusive, it likely would have benefitted Ana to put some of her pride aside and use some factual thinking instead of ruling with emotions. Ana does have a lot of character growth, and takes more authority over the story as she learns through the traumatic events happening at the hotel.
For the relationship, I was not too convinced with Ana and the love interest. It was seemingly based on physical attraction and another magical element, and I do not believe the characters navigated their feelings or the relationship in the best way. They do not seem to be the best for each other because their personal motivations continuously overshadowed love, and manipulation and deceit were prominent. They were fine in the end, just not exactly a couple to root for.
ENGAGEMENT & ENJOYMENT -
This is a very quick read, notably read in one sitting for me, that will keep you entertained and interested the entire time. Suspense shrouds the entire hotel and the obscureness of reality keeps you guessing as to what is really going on. As mentioned, there were some parts of the story that were annoying and there are some personal preferences that I can nitpick, but overall I had a fantastic time reading this. Especially since this is a debut, there is incredible promise for future enthralling, indulgent stories within the mysterious gothic fairytale genre.
ATMOSPHERE & SETTING -
The atmosphere of this story is stunning. A winter’s dream brought into vivid detail with lavish descriptions of icy scenery and glacial fantasy, the frosty world of the Hotel de Neige is a wonderland in itself, despite the horrors within. The alluring portrayal of eternal winter with gothic elements riddled with secrecy covering a dangerous past and a cryptically threatening present is a magical aesthetic, atmosphere, and setting. The interior design as well clearly had a lot of thought put into it to make it as enchanting and cautionary as possible. Considering this is the author’s debut, I am very excited to see how her prose develops in her next novels since there is such a strong starting point.
DEVELOPMENT & PLOT -
The story moves at a constant pace and the progression of it all never dulls. There are always new reveals or strange occurrences to keep the reader engaged and guessing as to what is really happening in this hotel. Again, while many of the warnings pronounced by the other characters are exasperating and infuriating with their ambiguousness, they do add to the gothic feel and keep the mystery relevant. There were also a few moments in the story, particularly with chapter changes, where the writing abruptly shifted from its previous setting to a possible nightmare/illusion/hallucination, and it took a little while to regain an understanding of what was going on and to decipher what was actually happening, which in theory could be an impressive element to include, but due to its infrequency, the impact was lost. Smoother transitions will certainly be improved upon as the author continues to write. The reveal of the hotel seemed to come out of nowhere, and possibly with more experience, hints could be left throughout the story to allude to something like this, though knowledge of the original tale helps. Since it felt rather incidental and not planned all the way through, the impact was personally lost on me, though it can still be appreciated.
This is truly an incredible debut and I will be picking up her next work.
Thank you Nadine Bells, Quill and Crow Publishing House, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for my thoughts and review!
Ana is an orphan with little memory of her past who finds solace in singing and believes her dreams are finally coming true when she lands a job as a singer at the mysterious Hotel de Neige. What initially feels like a fairytale quickly turns into a nightmare as she ignores warnings, acts on emotion, and is forced to confront the hotel’s dark reality. While the romance introduces magical intrigue, it feels shallow and strained by manipulation, deceit, and conflicting motivations, making the couple difficult to root for. The story is fast-paced and engaging, with constant suspense, strong gothic fairytale elements, and an immersive winter setting brought to life through vivid, atmospheric descriptions. Despite some miniscule criticisms and a reveal that feels underdeveloped, the novel shows impressive promise for a debut and hints at a strong future for the author’s storytelling.
RELATIONSHIPS & CHARACTERS -
Ana - An orphan who has a vague memory of her past besides constantly running away from her foster homes has only music to rely on. Singing has always been her passion and transports her to the only happiness she knows. Determined to get a job other than waitressing, she auditions to be the singer at the Hotel de Neige, where she is given the job under less-than-favorable and questionable circumstances. She thinks that something is finally going her way and her fairytale dreams are coming true, but reality turns out to be more of a nightmare than she was prepared for. Ana initially is defensive about her situation and blatantly ignores the warnings around her. While the other characters are frustratingly vague and elusive, it likely would have benefitted Ana to put some of her pride aside and use some factual thinking instead of ruling with emotions. Ana does have a lot of character growth, and takes more authority over the story as she learns through the traumatic events happening at the hotel.
For the relationship, I was not too convinced with Ana and the love interest. It was seemingly based on physical attraction and another magical element, and I do not believe the characters navigated their feelings or the relationship in the best way. They do not seem to be the best for each other because their personal motivations continuously overshadowed love, and manipulation and deceit were prominent. They were fine in the end, just not exactly a couple to root for.
ENGAGEMENT & ENJOYMENT -
This is a very quick read, notably read in one sitting for me, that will keep you entertained and interested the entire time. Suspense shrouds the entire hotel and the obscureness of reality keeps you guessing as to what is really going on. As mentioned, there were some parts of the story that were annoying and there are some personal preferences that I can nitpick, but overall I had a fantastic time reading this. Especially since this is a debut, there is incredible promise for future enthralling, indulgent stories within the mysterious gothic fairytale genre.
ATMOSPHERE & SETTING -
The atmosphere of this story is stunning. A winter’s dream brought into vivid detail with lavish descriptions of icy scenery and glacial fantasy, the frosty world of the Hotel de Neige is a wonderland in itself, despite the horrors within. The alluring portrayal of eternal winter with gothic elements riddled with secrecy covering a dangerous past and a cryptically threatening present is a magical aesthetic, atmosphere, and setting. The interior design as well clearly had a lot of thought put into it to make it as enchanting and cautionary as possible. Considering this is the author’s debut, I am very excited to see how her prose develops in her next novels since there is such a strong starting point.
DEVELOPMENT & PLOT -
The story moves at a constant pace and the progression of it all never dulls. There are always new reveals or strange occurrences to keep the reader engaged and guessing as to what is really happening in this hotel. Again, while many of the warnings pronounced by the other characters are exasperating and infuriating with their ambiguousness, they do add to the gothic feel and keep the mystery relevant. There were also a few moments in the story, particularly with chapter changes, where the writing abruptly shifted from its previous setting to a possible nightmare/illusion/hallucination, and it took a little while to regain an understanding of what was going on and to decipher what was actually happening, which in theory could be an impressive element to include, but due to its infrequency, the impact was lost. Smoother transitions will certainly be improved upon as the author continues to write. The reveal of the hotel seemed to come out of nowhere, and possibly with more experience, hints could be left throughout the story to allude to something like this, though knowledge of the original tale helps. Since it felt rather incidental and not planned all the way through, the impact was personally lost on me, though it can still be appreciated.
This is truly an incredible debut and I will be picking up her next work.
Thank you Nadine Bells, Quill and Crow Publishing House, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for my thoughts and review!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I think the highest compliment I can give this book is this: I started it last night. I tried to go to bed at midnight. I stared at the ceiling for like 40 minutes thinking about it, and then sat up to read one more chapter. The same thing happened at like 1:40, 2:40, and 3:40 until my eyes would literally not stay open. Then, I'm pretty sure once I fell asleep I dreamed theories.
Thankfully, my dreams were not as vivid or terrifying as Ana's nightmares and I didn't sleepwalk.
This is a gothic fairytale retelling that gave me the vibe of the Anastasia movie (including characters named Ana and Dimitri) combined with a bit of The Phantom of the Opera. The whole story has the atmosphere of the Once Upon A December scene in Anastasia, and I had moments where I was almost singing it in my head while reading.
Our main character Ana has been living in New York for several years trying to make it as a singer when she gets the opportunity to audition for the Hôtel de Neige in upstate New York. Ana, an orphan who spent her childhood in foster homes since she was found outside in a blizzard at age 6 with no memory of her past life, is hopeful that this job will finally give her a home to call her own.
Originally, Ana thinks she failed at the audition but then she is told by a member of the panel that she is their choice, based on an order that came "from the top."
Ana is drawn into life at the hotel and with all the other employees, but there is clearly something weird going on. Everyone hates the manager, Dimitri, who she feels drawn to for some reason; and the prima ballerina she has to perform with for some reason wants her gone. On top of that, she has nightmares that bring her to places in the hotel that were part of the nightmares and the feeling that she recognizes people, places, and things that she shouldn't.
This did a really good job of holding a perfect level of magical intrigue and suspense. The vivid depictions of this magical winter wonderland are enthralling, and the addition of actual guests at the hotel helps add to the suspense since no one who works at the hotel will actually acknowledge what is going on. The romance in this is secondary and, while it is sweet, there is a twist in here that makes it not work as well for me as it could have. That said, with the romance being more of a secondary storyline (or honest not even really a storyline at all), the part of its resolution that I didn't enjoy didn't take away from the story for me. There isn't really an epilogue, and the way that the story ends works really well.
This is more fairytale than gothic, but if you like either of those or if, like me, you were REALLY into Anastasia then this is the book for you.
Thank you to Nadine Bells, Quill & Crow Publishing, and NetGalley for the arc in exchange or an honest review.
Thankfully, my dreams were not as vivid or terrifying as Ana's nightmares and I didn't sleepwalk.
This is a gothic fairytale retelling that gave me the vibe of the Anastasia movie (including characters named Ana and Dimitri) combined with a bit of The Phantom of the Opera. The whole story has the atmosphere of the Once Upon A December scene in Anastasia, and I had moments where I was almost singing it in my head while reading.
Our main character Ana has been living in New York for several years trying to make it as a singer when she gets the opportunity to audition for the Hôtel de Neige in upstate New York. Ana, an orphan who spent her childhood in foster homes since she was found outside in a blizzard at age 6 with no memory of her past life, is hopeful that this job will finally give her a home to call her own.
Originally, Ana thinks she failed at the audition but then she is told by a member of the panel that she is their choice, based on an order that came "from the top."
Ana is drawn into life at the hotel and with all the other employees, but there is clearly something weird going on. Everyone hates the manager, Dimitri, who she feels drawn to for some reason; and the prima ballerina she has to perform with for some reason wants her gone. On top of that, she has nightmares that bring her to places in the hotel that were part of the nightmares and the feeling that she recognizes people, places, and things that she shouldn't.
This did a really good job of holding a perfect level of magical intrigue and suspense. The vivid depictions of this magical winter wonderland are enthralling, and the addition of actual guests at the hotel helps add to the suspense since no one who works at the hotel will actually acknowledge what is going on. The romance in this is secondary and, while it is sweet, there is a twist in here that makes it not work as well for me as it could have. That said, with the romance being more of a secondary storyline (or honest not even really a storyline at all), the part of its resolution that I didn't enjoy didn't take away from the story for me. There isn't really an epilogue, and the way that the story ends works really well.
This is more fairytale than gothic, but if you like either of those or if, like me, you were REALLY into Anastasia then this is the book for you.
Thank you to Nadine Bells, Quill & Crow Publishing, and NetGalley for the arc in exchange or an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I want to thank Netgallery and the author for providing me with an ARC copy of this book for an honest review.
Although the book is described as a romantasy / fantasy book, I would say it’s more mystery. It does have an element of fantasy to it, but the overall concept is the mystery of the hotel and the secrets it hides.
I really did enjoy this book. It’s not too long, but I believe it’s the perfect length for the story. I feel like if it were any longer, it would have been far too much.
We first meet our FMC, Ana, who has an audition to be a singer for the prestigious Hotel de Neige. Unfortunately, Ana was late to the auditions due to a breakdown in her taxi and almost missed her shot, until our MMC, this sexy and mysterious Russian character, Dimitri, steps in to help her. Ana successfully passes the auditions and is given the job, but during her stay, she soon recovers ass is not what it seems. Whilst the hotel is grand and prestigious, there is a haunting mystery to it that ties its residents’ fates to the hotel, and Ana’s life may be in danger.
The main premise of the book is discovering who Ana is, her navigating through her new life at Hotel de Neige and with her newfound family, and uncovering the secrets of the hotel. There is a little bit of romance to the story between our MCs, and there is one spice scene, but I would rate it a 1/5 on the spice meter. Their relationship was very cute, and I enjoyed it, but it’s not the main focus of the book, which I actually enjoyed. It had a nice balance of romance and plot. Given the whole premise of the book, I feel that too much romance would have ruined it.
The story is nicely paced, in terms of it kept me turning pages and wanting to know what happens and what the secrets are. It’s hauntingly beautiful, it’s moody with a slight element of paranormal/fantasy mystery to it. Overall, the author has done a very good job, and I would recommend it to people to add to their TBR.
I want to thank Netgallery and the author for providing me with an ARC copy of this book for an honest review.
Although the book is described as a romantasy / fantasy book, I would say it’s more mystery. It does have an element of fantasy to it, but the overall concept is the mystery of the hotel and the secrets it hides.
I really did enjoy this book. It’s not too long, but I believe it’s the perfect length for the story. I feel like if it were any longer, it would have been far too much.
We first meet our FMC, Ana, who has an audition to be a singer for the prestigious Hotel de Neige. Unfortunately, Ana was late to the auditions due to a breakdown in her taxi and almost missed her shot, until our MMC, this sexy and mysterious Russian character, Dimitri, steps in to help her. Ana successfully passes the auditions and is given the job, but during her stay, she soon recovers ass is not what it seems. Whilst the hotel is grand and prestigious, there is a haunting mystery to it that ties its residents’ fates to the hotel, and Ana’s life may be in danger.
The main premise of the book is discovering who Ana is, her navigating through her new life at Hotel de Neige and with her newfound family, and uncovering the secrets of the hotel. There is a little bit of romance to the story between our MCs, and there is one spice scene, but I would rate it a 1/5 on the spice meter. Their relationship was very cute, and I enjoyed it, but it’s not the main focus of the book, which I actually enjoyed. It had a nice balance of romance and plot. Given the whole premise of the book, I feel that too much romance would have ruined it.
The story is nicely paced, in terms of it kept me turning pages and wanting to know what happens and what the secrets are. It’s hauntingly beautiful, it’s moody with a slight element of paranormal/fantasy mystery to it. Overall, the author has done a very good job, and I would recommend it to people to add to their TBR.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Overall rating: 5/5 Stars
Once Upon a Song by Nadine Bells
This book completely swept me away. From the very first pages, Once Upon a Song pulls you into the haunting, icy glamour of the Hôtel de Neige, a setting that feels equal parts fairytale and Gothic nightmare. The atmosphere is stunning and immersive, and I was hooked immediately.
Ana is a protagonist you can’t help but root for. Her longing to belong, paired with her unsettling nightmares and eerie experiences within the hotel, creates a constant sense of tension. The hotel itself feels alive, and the cast of characters surrounding Ana adds both warmth and unease. Some offer her the found family she’s always wanted, while others, especially Hedwig, the hotel’s chilling prima ballerina, make it clear that danger lurks beneath the beauty.
There’s also a subtle romantic thread between Ana and Dimitri, the mysterious hotel manager. While I enjoyed their dynamic, the romance is very light and not the main focus of the story. This novel is far more about Ana’s self-discovery and her confrontation with the shadows of her past than it is about romantic payoff.
The pacing kept me turning pages, and the writing is beautiful and atmospheric throughout. If you’re looking for high spice, this isn’t the book for you (spice level: 2/5). But if you love moody settings, paranormal mystery, found family, and stories that linger with you long after you finish, I can’t recommend this one enough.
A haunting, magical, and unforgettable read.
I received and advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Once Upon a Song by Nadine Bells
This book completely swept me away. From the very first pages, Once Upon a Song pulls you into the haunting, icy glamour of the Hôtel de Neige, a setting that feels equal parts fairytale and Gothic nightmare. The atmosphere is stunning and immersive, and I was hooked immediately.
Ana is a protagonist you can’t help but root for. Her longing to belong, paired with her unsettling nightmares and eerie experiences within the hotel, creates a constant sense of tension. The hotel itself feels alive, and the cast of characters surrounding Ana adds both warmth and unease. Some offer her the found family she’s always wanted, while others, especially Hedwig, the hotel’s chilling prima ballerina, make it clear that danger lurks beneath the beauty.
There’s also a subtle romantic thread between Ana and Dimitri, the mysterious hotel manager. While I enjoyed their dynamic, the romance is very light and not the main focus of the story. This novel is far more about Ana’s self-discovery and her confrontation with the shadows of her past than it is about romantic payoff.
The pacing kept me turning pages, and the writing is beautiful and atmospheric throughout. If you’re looking for high spice, this isn’t the book for you (spice level: 2/5). But if you love moody settings, paranormal mystery, found family, and stories that linger with you long after you finish, I can’t recommend this one enough.
A haunting, magical, and unforgettable read.
I received and advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
The plot of this book felt like a fairytale in all the best possible ways. The snowy-hotel setting, the mysterious owner, stranger employees and secrets lurking around the hallways all combined to make an intriguing read.
The pacing of the narrative was just right, with the exposition quickly setting the scene and backstory before delivering the narrative hook, introducing the antagonists and providing the first of many questions to solve. I did have an inkling of who the main villain would be, but that's to no detriment of the story or the writing.
The characters were well-rounded, the relationships believable but I always question love stories that happen too quickly. That would be one of my critiques: true love takes longer than a month and I always prefer my storylines to be as believable as possible, even when supernatural elements are involved.
The narrative flowed well, the dialogue was natural and the climax was exciting. I did reach the final couple of chapters and wonder if I would be left with questions, but the falling action satisfied those quite neatly.
On the whole, the writing was engaging, exciting and enjoyable; there were occasions where I felt information had been dumped rather than woven into the narrative, but this was infrequent. I enjoyed the twist at the end of the story; I had one or two theories but could not be definitive in my predictions, which was refreshing as this avoids cliches or predictability.
The pacing of the narrative was just right, with the exposition quickly setting the scene and backstory before delivering the narrative hook, introducing the antagonists and providing the first of many questions to solve. I did have an inkling of who the main villain would be, but that's to no detriment of the story or the writing.
The characters were well-rounded, the relationships believable but I always question love stories that happen too quickly. That would be one of my critiques: true love takes longer than a month and I always prefer my storylines to be as believable as possible, even when supernatural elements are involved.
The narrative flowed well, the dialogue was natural and the climax was exciting. I did reach the final couple of chapters and wonder if I would be left with questions, but the falling action satisfied those quite neatly.
On the whole, the writing was engaging, exciting and enjoyable; there were occasions where I felt information had been dumped rather than woven into the narrative, but this was infrequent. I enjoyed the twist at the end of the story; I had one or two theories but could not be definitive in my predictions, which was refreshing as this avoids cliches or predictability.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Ana is a lonely waitress, travelling to a mysterious hotel in hopes of auditioning to be their new singer. When she obtains the role, she views it as a chance to finally change her circumstances. When she moves into Hotel de Neige, she finds herself in what she believes to be a fairytale, but quickly realizes that both the property and people working there hold secrets. From her first night there, Ana begins having vivid nightmares, which only increases her suspicions that there is more than meets the eye.
As she finds a home in the Hotel, she befriends some of the staff members, and catches the eye of the hotel manager, but not everyone is as welcoming. One of the ballerinas is hostile from the beginning, making vague threats without providing any explanations, and Ana keeps seeing a phantom in white, both in her dreams, and in dark corners of the building. The longer she stays, the less things make sense, and the secrets she ultimately uncovers could change everything.
I received an early copy of this book from NetGalley and really enjoyed it. The plot feels like a dark fairytale, an orphan searching for her place in the world, uncovering secrets that are best left buried. The setting of the story is flawless, allowing readers to picture themselves in the rooms along with Ana, and the plot moved smoothly, with no gaps or lulls that would lose readers along the way. The ending was unexpected, and I can’t wait to see what the author writes next.
As she finds a home in the Hotel, she befriends some of the staff members, and catches the eye of the hotel manager, but not everyone is as welcoming. One of the ballerinas is hostile from the beginning, making vague threats without providing any explanations, and Ana keeps seeing a phantom in white, both in her dreams, and in dark corners of the building. The longer she stays, the less things make sense, and the secrets she ultimately uncovers could change everything.
I received an early copy of this book from NetGalley and really enjoyed it. The plot feels like a dark fairytale, an orphan searching for her place in the world, uncovering secrets that are best left buried. The setting of the story is flawless, allowing readers to picture themselves in the rooms along with Ana, and the plot moved smoothly, with no gaps or lulls that would lose readers along the way. The ending was unexpected, and I can’t wait to see what the author writes next.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
3.5 rounded up to 4 stars, as I really got into it when I saw where it was going. I enjoy fairytale retellings, and while I didn't vibe with a few elements of the book - I primarily read Horror, Dark Fantasy, and mystery, so this is a lighter departure - I did really appreciate it as a Snow Queen story and a Gothic Fantasy Mystery with a fun reveal.
It reminded me of a stage play for kids version and a few live action films I've seen of this, one in particular (possibly the 2005 version dir. Julian Gibbs, if that's the one Patrick Stewart is in), but for adults, with a romantasy subplot (x1 sex scene: fade to blur/fade to black). I actually enjoyed that part, I'm not a big romance reader but I do love the specific dynamic here, so that pleased me.
I think other reviewers have mentioned they wished the characters had more depth to them, and I agree in some cases, but also, it's a novella and there isn't space to explore all of the characters we're introduced to; and it is a comparatively large cast for such a short book.
If you're looking for a quick, lightweight and entertaining Gothic read with mystery, mysterious deaths, curses, a bit of romance, lost/found family themes, and a modern setting, this is one to look out for and pre-order from your local store or library.
I received an ARC directly from Quill & Crow, and am leaving an honest review.
It reminded me of a stage play for kids version and a few live action films I've seen of this, one in particular (possibly the 2005 version dir. Julian Gibbs, if that's the one Patrick Stewart is in), but for adults, with a romantasy subplot (x1 sex scene: fade to blur/fade to black). I actually enjoyed that part, I'm not a big romance reader but I do love the specific dynamic here, so that pleased me.
I think other reviewers have mentioned they wished the characters had more depth to them, and I agree in some cases, but also, it's a novella and there isn't space to explore all of the characters we're introduced to; and it is a comparatively large cast for such a short book.
If you're looking for a quick, lightweight and entertaining Gothic read with mystery, mysterious deaths, curses, a bit of romance, lost/found family themes, and a modern setting, this is one to look out for and pre-order from your local store or library.
I received an ARC directly from Quill & Crow, and am leaving an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Overall: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice: 🌶️ (one intimate scene from what I remember)
Content Warnings: small mentions of blood, death & violence (not too graphic)
At first glance, gorgeous cover and intriguing plot. Upon reading, this gave gothic fairytale in the best way possible!
I know it has a fantasy tag, but it definitely leans more into mystery than anything else. The descriptive details for every single setting, and throughout the entire book, were so immersive that I could easily see this being adapted into a movie! Like, I was constantly suspicious of everyone, and everything, because of how well the tone was set.
It starts off slowly but gradually picks up pace as more of the mystery is revealed (to the reader and Ana, our main character). There’s a lot of characters, but each one is so distinct in their personalities. Final note (hehe, get it?), I loved how all the puzzle pieces made sense at the end, and it didn’t feel like there were any missing or unexplained bits!
I can’t wait to see what else this author comes out with! Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for this arc!! <3
Spice: 🌶️ (one intimate scene from what I remember)
Content Warnings: small mentions of blood, death & violence (not too graphic)
At first glance, gorgeous cover and intriguing plot. Upon reading, this gave gothic fairytale in the best way possible!
I know it has a fantasy tag, but it definitely leans more into mystery than anything else. The descriptive details for every single setting, and throughout the entire book, were so immersive that I could easily see this being adapted into a movie! Like, I was constantly suspicious of everyone, and everything, because of how well the tone was set.
It starts off slowly but gradually picks up pace as more of the mystery is revealed (to the reader and Ana, our main character). There’s a lot of characters, but each one is so distinct in their personalities. Final note (hehe, get it?), I loved how all the puzzle pieces made sense at the end, and it didn’t feel like there were any missing or unexplained bits!
I can’t wait to see what else this author comes out with! Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for this arc!! <3
December 16, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Quill & Crow Publishing House for the ARC.
Plot 4.25/5
Characters 4/5
Ending 4/5
Interest 4.5/5
Overall 4/5
-This story was so magically beautiful but also so mysterious. It is short and simple but there are so many elements which makes it so great. I can feel a sort of Anastasia retelling which I really love. The mysterious hotel remained very eery and mysterious right up until the end which was much appreciated.
-I have to admit that the characters sometimes irritated me. We knew that the hotel was mysterious and there were lots of secrets at play in the story, but I feel like the characters often showed that they were hiding something from Ana. Other than that, they were fine. I liked the relationship with Dimitri although I still don’t understand why no one likes him.
-I would have liked a more bittersweet ending for this book instead of the miracle happily ever after. I am satisfied with how things go and the plot twists were great, despite being sort of predictable. If the ending were a bit longer I feel like it could have been more emotional and impactful for me.
Plot 4.25/5
Characters 4/5
Ending 4/5
Interest 4.5/5
Overall 4/5
-This story was so magically beautiful but also so mysterious. It is short and simple but there are so many elements which makes it so great. I can feel a sort of Anastasia retelling which I really love. The mysterious hotel remained very eery and mysterious right up until the end which was much appreciated.
-I have to admit that the characters sometimes irritated me. We knew that the hotel was mysterious and there were lots of secrets at play in the story, but I feel like the characters often showed that they were hiding something from Ana. Other than that, they were fine. I liked the relationship with Dimitri although I still don’t understand why no one likes him.
-I would have liked a more bittersweet ending for this book instead of the miracle happily ever after. I am satisfied with how things go and the plot twists were great, despite being sort of predictable. If the ending were a bit longer I feel like it could have been more emotional and impactful for me.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
We meet Ana as her taxi breaks down in the snow on the way to an audition. Determined, she walks the rest of the way, only to be met with hostility upon arrival. With some help, she manages to audition—but Ana’s life has never been easy. Abandoned by her parents and raised in the foster system, she’s fought to survive and belong. This job feels like a fresh start.
After landing the role, things take a darker turn. She’s warned to leave while she can. Soon, Ana begins sleepwalking and dreaming of a terrifying woman. Something sinister lurks within the hotel, and no one will speak of it. Did Ana make the right choice by staying?
I felt for Ana, who was looking for something stable in her life and her initial fairy tale took a dark turn. A hotel in the middle of nowhere, a weird group of people and an owner that makes you want to hide each time she comes close, sounded like an interesting premise. It is chilling at times, but overall, the characters lacked depth and the interactions felt lackluster at times. I wanted a bit more. While enjoyable, it didn't fully convince me.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
After landing the role, things take a darker turn. She’s warned to leave while she can. Soon, Ana begins sleepwalking and dreaming of a terrifying woman. Something sinister lurks within the hotel, and no one will speak of it. Did Ana make the right choice by staying?
I felt for Ana, who was looking for something stable in her life and her initial fairy tale took a dark turn. A hotel in the middle of nowhere, a weird group of people and an owner that makes you want to hide each time she comes close, sounded like an interesting premise. It is chilling at times, but overall, the characters lacked depth and the interactions felt lackluster at times. I wanted a bit more. While enjoyable, it didn't fully convince me.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you NetGalley and Quill & Crow Publishing for the arc.
The author did a good job setting up and describing this frozen and mysterious hotel in the middle of nowhere, where the occupants can't seem to leave. I really liked the premise of this book because it reminded me of the song Hotel California. The way the fmc's nightmares where she was sleep walking had a perfect creepy winter land atmosphere and were very well thought out. I was excited to see why nobody could seem to leave and why the fmc had such a sense of home and deja vu for the hotel but I thought the dialogue felt clunky and awkward at times. It felt repetitive especially when Ana was trying to find out what was going on in the hotel and her co workers refused to give her any information. I was so frustrated with them that they couldn't give her anything or even try (they rather tell her to stay away from a guy and not tell her why....uhhhhh). I feel like the romance could have been expanded on, the characters could had a more depth, and more nightmares or action would helped with some of the slower tendencies of the book but overall I liked the wintery setting and the overall plot.
The author did a good job setting up and describing this frozen and mysterious hotel in the middle of nowhere, where the occupants can't seem to leave. I really liked the premise of this book because it reminded me of the song Hotel California. The way the fmc's nightmares where she was sleep walking had a perfect creepy winter land atmosphere and were very well thought out. I was excited to see why nobody could seem to leave and why the fmc had such a sense of home and deja vu for the hotel but I thought the dialogue felt clunky and awkward at times. It felt repetitive especially when Ana was trying to find out what was going on in the hotel and her co workers refused to give her any information. I was so frustrated with them that they couldn't give her anything or even try (they rather tell her to stay away from a guy and not tell her why....uhhhhh). I feel like the romance could have been expanded on, the characters could had a more depth, and more nightmares or action would helped with some of the slower tendencies of the book but overall I liked the wintery setting and the overall plot.
December 7, 2025
Once Upon a Song is a gorgeous blend of music, emotion, and fairytale charm that sweeps you away from the very first chapter. Nadine Bells crafts a story that feels both timeless and refreshingly modern, filled with lyrical writing and characters who feel like they step right off the page.
The musical elements are woven into the narrative so naturally that the entire book seems to hum with its own melody. Every scene feels vivid and immersive, from the quiet, intimate moments to the emotionally charged crescendos. The romance is tender and compelling, unfolding with the perfect balance of tension, vulnerability, and slow-burn sweetness.
What truly stands out is the heart of the story. Themes of healing, courage, self-discovery, and the transformative power of art give the book a depth that lingers long after you finish. It’s uplifting without shying away from real emotion, and magical without losing its authenticity.
If you love whimsical storytelling, stunning prose, and characters you can’t help but root for, Once Upon a Song is an absolute gem.
The musical elements are woven into the narrative so naturally that the entire book seems to hum with its own melody. Every scene feels vivid and immersive, from the quiet, intimate moments to the emotionally charged crescendos. The romance is tender and compelling, unfolding with the perfect balance of tension, vulnerability, and slow-burn sweetness.
What truly stands out is the heart of the story. Themes of healing, courage, self-discovery, and the transformative power of art give the book a depth that lingers long after you finish. It’s uplifting without shying away from real emotion, and magical without losing its authenticity.
If you love whimsical storytelling, stunning prose, and characters you can’t help but root for, Once Upon a Song is an absolute gem.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to NetGalley, Quill and Crown Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Once Upon a Song follows Ana, a lonely waitress whose life changes when she lands a coveted job as a singer at the prestigious Hôtel de Neige. At first, the hotel feels magical and full of promise—but it doesn’t take long for Ana to realize that something is deeply wrong. Beneath the beauty and enchantment lies a darkness that may put her life in danger.
This is a very atmospheric story, blending fantasy and light horror in a way that feels tailor-made for a young adult audience. The setting is the real star here: the Hôtel de Neige is eerie, seductive, and full of secrets. As a debut from a German author, the novel shows a lot of promise, especially in its mood and concept.
The story is engaging and kept me turning the pages, but I finished the book feeling like I wanted more—more answers and more resolution.
Once Upon a Song follows Ana, a lonely waitress whose life changes when she lands a coveted job as a singer at the prestigious Hôtel de Neige. At first, the hotel feels magical and full of promise—but it doesn’t take long for Ana to realize that something is deeply wrong. Beneath the beauty and enchantment lies a darkness that may put her life in danger.
This is a very atmospheric story, blending fantasy and light horror in a way that feels tailor-made for a young adult audience. The setting is the real star here: the Hôtel de Neige is eerie, seductive, and full of secrets. As a debut from a German author, the novel shows a lot of promise, especially in its mood and concept.
The story is engaging and kept me turning the pages, but I finished the book feeling like I wanted more—more answers and more resolution.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A sparkling ice castle hides many secrets beneath it's mystique. Welcome to the Hôtel de Neige. Ana, desperate for a job aside from waitressing, gets a job as their resident singer, but not all is as it seems to be. Between the musicians and unfriendly ballerina, there's the charismatic hotel manager hiding secrets and a grumpy front desk man who has no one's best interests in mind. And there are, of course, the horrors. It's not quite Hotel California; it's worse.
I didn't think this book ever quite took off. The descriptions are flat. Ana's critical thinking is stifled.
There is danger but also a man with a cool name waltzing with her and, I mean, why worry, be happy. There are also a few modern references (Tamagotchi???) that really took me out of the fantastical, gothic elements the author was trying to craft.
Thank you to Quill and Crow, Nadine Bells, and NetGalley for the ARC.
I didn't think this book ever quite took off. The descriptions are flat. Ana's critical thinking is stifled.
There is danger but also a man with a cool name waltzing with her and, I mean, why worry, be happy. There are also a few modern references (Tamagotchi???) that really took me out of the fantastical, gothic elements the author was trying to craft.
Thank you to Quill and Crow, Nadine Bells, and NetGalley for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Once Upon A Song is an upcoming contemporary novel that has some Anastasia and Phantom of the Opera vibes! I have to say I was quite intrigued by the book and could get over how well written the story was. If you are someone who enjoys mystery then this is a story that you definitely need to check out.
We are introduced to Ana who is working a dead end job as a waitress. She has always had a deep love for singing and when an audition for a job comes up she decided to try out. With a twist of luck she manages to get the job and her waitress days are finally over.
However, her arrival at Hotel de Neige is anything but ordinary. Everyone who works there hates the manager Dimitri but she seems to enjoy beibg around him. One of her co workers who is a prima ballerina is jealous of her and will do just about anything to sabatoge her career. Lastly the vivid nightmares that Ana experiences bring questions of her past life.
We are introduced to Ana who is working a dead end job as a waitress. She has always had a deep love for singing and when an audition for a job comes up she decided to try out. With a twist of luck she manages to get the job and her waitress days are finally over.
However, her arrival at Hotel de Neige is anything but ordinary. Everyone who works there hates the manager Dimitri but she seems to enjoy beibg around him. One of her co workers who is a prima ballerina is jealous of her and will do just about anything to sabatoge her career. Lastly the vivid nightmares that Ana experiences bring questions of her past life.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I just finished Once Upon a Song and Nadine Bells definitely pulled me into her world. The Hôtel de Neige is gorgeous but creepy, and the way secrets and tension build in the hotel had me hooked from the beginning of the book.
Ana’s great—she’s relatable, driven, and as the reader, you can really "feel" all of her feelings. Her journey to figure out the hotel’s mysteries while trying to find her place is really engaging, and the romance with Dimitri is cute without taking over the story.
The pacing is just right, the writing is atmospheric, and the mix of mystery, a little magic, and wintery fairytale vibes makes it a really enjoyable read overall. If you like suspenseful, moody stories with a strong FMC and a touch of romance, this one’s is a perfect read for you then!
Thank you to NetGalley, Nadine Bells, and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Ana’s great—she’s relatable, driven, and as the reader, you can really "feel" all of her feelings. Her journey to figure out the hotel’s mysteries while trying to find her place is really engaging, and the romance with Dimitri is cute without taking over the story.
The pacing is just right, the writing is atmospheric, and the mix of mystery, a little magic, and wintery fairytale vibes makes it a really enjoyable read overall. If you like suspenseful, moody stories with a strong FMC and a touch of romance, this one’s is a perfect read for you then!
Thank you to NetGalley, Nadine Bells, and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for access to this eARC! All opinions are my own.
____________
This has fantastical elements for sure, and they become more and more apparent as you read, but most of this really read as a mystery / thriller. I thought the fantastical vibes were pretty solid, some very nice language used and it often made me feel cold just reading it, but the mystery aspect was very lacking for me. The plot was fairly predictable, the villainous characters were very obvious, and I wanted the main character to honestly go off harder than she did with all of these people who were just not telling her anything for no reason. It was quite annoying to read by the end, and there wasn't much that kept me reading on. I disliked the romance and the romantic interest off the bat, but by the end that was the least of my gripes.
PUBLISHING: JANUARY 23 2026
____________
This has fantastical elements for sure, and they become more and more apparent as you read, but most of this really read as a mystery / thriller. I thought the fantastical vibes were pretty solid, some very nice language used and it often made me feel cold just reading it, but the mystery aspect was very lacking for me. The plot was fairly predictable, the villainous characters were very obvious, and I wanted the main character to honestly go off harder than she did with all of these people who were just not telling her anything for no reason. It was quite annoying to read by the end, and there wasn't much that kept me reading on. I disliked the romance and the romantic interest off the bat, but by the end that was the least of my gripes.
PUBLISHING: JANUARY 23 2026
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This book completely pulled me in with its rich atmosphere, blending horror elements with a magical and fantastical world. The writing and descriptions were vivid and immersive, making the story easy to visualize and hard to put down.
I especially appreciated the thoughtful diversity, both LGBTQ+ and racial, which felt natural and meaningful within the worldbuilding. As a Turkish reader, seeing a character of Turkish origin included was a pleasant and rare surprise in this genre. The characters particularly, Hedwig, Dimitri and Erica were compelling and memorable, and the thematic use of names added a subtle but effective layer to the story.
Overall, this was an engaging and accessible read, even as a non-native English speaker, and I would gladly read more stories set in this world.
I especially appreciated the thoughtful diversity, both LGBTQ+ and racial, which felt natural and meaningful within the worldbuilding. As a Turkish reader, seeing a character of Turkish origin included was a pleasant and rare surprise in this genre. The characters particularly, Hedwig, Dimitri and Erica were compelling and memorable, and the thematic use of names added a subtle but effective layer to the story.
Overall, this was an engaging and accessible read, even as a non-native English speaker, and I would gladly read more stories set in this world.
Read
December 28, 2025The synopsis of the book immediately caught my attention and made me curious to see where the story would go. However I felt like there was not much happening at the beginning and it was hard to stay fully invested. The story started to pick up around the 50% mark, which kept me engaged through the second half. The romance developed a little too quickly for my personal taste and I would’ve loved more buildup between the characters. Overall, I still think this was an enjoyable read with some strong moments. Even though it wasn’t entirely for me and I considered not finishing it, I’m glad I read it through to the end.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am voluntarily providing this review.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am voluntarily providing this review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to both the author and NetGalley for the ARC!
I rounded up to 3 ⭐'s, but this is a 2.75 ⭐ for me. I understand what the author was going for, but the execution just fell flat. To start on a positive note, the world-building and ambiance within the story were masterfully done; I could perfectly imagine the hotel surrounded by snow as I read. This is where my enjoyment pretty much ended.
The story is more of a winter mystery/whodunnit vibe rather than a gothic fantasy. Neither the characters nor the storyline were fleshed out enough for me to care, so I was pretty much on the cusp of DNF-ing early into it, and when things picked up and got interesting, the story ended. I think this is definitely a story that would've benefited from expansion and better pacing.
I rounded up to 3 ⭐'s, but this is a 2.75 ⭐ for me. I understand what the author was going for, but the execution just fell flat. To start on a positive note, the world-building and ambiance within the story were masterfully done; I could perfectly imagine the hotel surrounded by snow as I read. This is where my enjoyment pretty much ended.
The story is more of a winter mystery/whodunnit vibe rather than a gothic fantasy. Neither the characters nor the storyline were fleshed out enough for me to care, so I was pretty much on the cusp of DNF-ing early into it, and when things picked up and got interesting, the story ended. I think this is definitely a story that would've benefited from expansion and better pacing.
January 12, 2026
A very unusual storyline. The story started off with very disjointed characters and relationships between themselves too, the hotel staff look after an orphaned boy who likes to live on the streets, the staff take an instant dislike to the new staff member and try to give her warnings to leave the hotel immediately as she is in danger but she chooses to stay. When a staff member is found frozen dead but was alive moments before, the story begins to develop but in a very mysterious way leaving you curiously wanting to read more.
After a dinner date with the hotel manager and receiving a gift from him meant as a belated Christmas gift does the storyline finally begin to flow and reveal the true mystery.
After a dinner date with the hotel manager and receiving a gift from him meant as a belated Christmas gift does the storyline finally begin to flow and reveal the true mystery.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Sadly very let down by this! I picked this up based on the synopsis but it totally fell flat for me. It took me a while to get through this because I just kept losing interest. The characters did not feel fully flushed out, their interactions with each other felt awkward. The dialogue was very basic or cliché. The romance was extremely rushed and forced in this, and there were definitely some loose ends in the plot. Also very slow paced at the start, and then everything was revealed in the last 5% of the book with an extremely abrupt ending. Overall, just did not work for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and Quill& Crow Publishing House for and ARC copy in exchange for my honest review
Thank you to NetGalley and Quill& Crow Publishing House for and ARC copy in exchange for my honest review
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This read is so magical, I demolished it in about 4 hours. You’re immediately engulfed into the mystery after just a few pages. I really enjoyed how immersed I felt as the fantasy elements don’t become glaringly obviously until a good way into the book. I enjoyed the twists and turns it took, I didn’t predict any of them until a few moments before! The plot and some of the characters could have benefited from another hundred or two pages of writing, and I felt the romance was a little cliche; but still enjoyable. Fantastic debut novel! Thank you for the eARC! I’ll be following the authors journey warmly :)
November 28, 2025
The perfect read as the weather gets chillier.
This setting absolutely gripped me and I don't think I've read a debut this good in a while. I genuinely wish this would've been longer, as it feels like there's so much more to explore in all the characters, the hotel and the past of it all.
Absolutely adored this, and it makes me excited for winter to come, and I'm sad I had to leave Hôtel de Niege so quickly.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for this free ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
This setting absolutely gripped me and I don't think I've read a debut this good in a while. I genuinely wish this would've been longer, as it feels like there's so much more to explore in all the characters, the hotel and the past of it all.
Absolutely adored this, and it makes me excited for winter to come, and I'm sad I had to leave Hôtel de Niege so quickly.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for this free ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
January 8, 2026
This book is absolutely beautiful. A strange hotel in the middle of nowhere, constant snow and storms encouraging guests to remain inside... where something strange is clearly going on. Sign me up!
Initially I thought that this tale was to be a 'Phantom of the Opera' retelling, and there's certainly nods to that story (and the musical) there, but then the action takes a turn expected directions. Suddenly protagonist Ana is lost in the hallways of the Hotel, nobody is telling her what's going on, and there's a mystery involving her unknown family. Is anybody on her side, and what is the handsome Hotel owner actually up to?
I finished 'Once Upon a Song' in two days because I was simply swept up in its dance. Reminded of 'Hill House', Cat Scully's excellent 'Below the Grand Hotel' and with a touch of David Lynchian weirdness, this could so easily have been a simple retelling, but instead placed its feet firmly and told the story as its own.
Poor confused Ana is likeable, with her distress absolutely understandable (as well as her reasoning to stay at the Hotel and not just get out!). Her life once through that front door seems to be otherworldly, yet she is able to live her dream here - so why should she leave? And for that matter, why should I?
Horror tropes such as lack of phone signal - being cut off from the outside world entirely - are handled deftly and seem entirely reasonable in context. The snippets of history told by other characters are enticing without giving much away, and the mystery moves forward with a firm hand on the rudder. Romantic aspects don't take over (to my great relief), and the action finally reaches a point where it's impossible to put the book down. I was also immensely glad that the ending is spot on for satisfaction and resolution.
My one niggle is that the name of the Hotel is mentioned on virtually every page, which became a little jarring - as if over-using a character's name. Perhaps that's just to underline its constant presence, but it felt unnecessary to me.
A gorgeous wintry gothic adventure that I am so glad to have found, and the perfect read for a snowy evening. Absolutely recommended.
I was kindly sent an early copy of this book by the publisher, but the above opinions are entirely my own.
Initially I thought that this tale was to be a 'Phantom of the Opera' retelling, and there's certainly nods to that story (and the musical) there, but then the action takes a turn expected directions. Suddenly protagonist Ana is lost in the hallways of the Hotel, nobody is telling her what's going on, and there's a mystery involving her unknown family. Is anybody on her side, and what is the handsome Hotel owner actually up to?
I finished 'Once Upon a Song' in two days because I was simply swept up in its dance. Reminded of 'Hill House', Cat Scully's excellent 'Below the Grand Hotel' and with a touch of David Lynchian weirdness, this could so easily have been a simple retelling, but instead placed its feet firmly and told the story as its own.
Poor confused Ana is likeable, with her distress absolutely understandable (as well as her reasoning to stay at the Hotel and not just get out!). Her life once through that front door seems to be otherworldly, yet she is able to live her dream here - so why should she leave? And for that matter, why should I?
Horror tropes such as lack of phone signal - being cut off from the outside world entirely - are handled deftly and seem entirely reasonable in context. The snippets of history told by other characters are enticing without giving much away, and the mystery moves forward with a firm hand on the rudder. Romantic aspects don't take over (to my great relief), and the action finally reaches a point where it's impossible to put the book down. I was also immensely glad that the ending is spot on for satisfaction and resolution.
My one niggle is that the name of the Hotel is mentioned on virtually every page, which became a little jarring - as if over-using a character's name. Perhaps that's just to underline its constant presence, but it felt unnecessary to me.
A gorgeous wintry gothic adventure that I am so glad to have found, and the perfect read for a snowy evening. Absolutely recommended.
I was kindly sent an early copy of this book by the publisher, but the above opinions are entirely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Once upon a song was a wild mystical and mysterious ride. I was on the edge of my seat waiting to learn what made the hotel de neige so special but I was shocked to learn the truth of some of the occupants. Ana had tremendous growth through out the book as well did some of the other main side characters. The story was very unique which I appreciated. I felt that Nadine Bells did an amazing job progressing the story, making you feel the need to keep reading while also wrapping it all up in the perfect bow. 4.5 stars for me and can’t wait to read more from this author!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Nadine Bells ONCE UPON A SONG is a fantastic, gothic horror-fantasy. The way Bells did a Snow Queen retelling mixed with Phantom of the Opera vibes was *chefs kiss*! It truly felt like an original concept. I absolutely loved the found family, Ana was an intriguing MC, and Dimitri was such a fun love interest! The descriptive setting combined with wintery vibes was such a refreshing concept as well. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this perfectly eerie and magical book. What a great debut from Bells! Thank you to NetGalley for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews