What do you think?
Rate this book
It Happened One Murder
Only Murders in the Building gets a rom-com twist in this laugh-out-loud mystery-romance following one woman who will have to pair up with an unlikely ally to solve a murder in their quaint New Jersey beach town, perfect for fans of Jesse Q. Sutanto, Elle Cosimano, and Katherine Center.
Murder has a way of bringing people together…
Harriet Baker thought that when she left Logan Island, she was leaving for good. But after getting fired from her dream magazine job, she finds herself stuck back in the sleepy New Jersey beach town living with her eccentric mother and desperate to escape.
And her ticket out might be…murder?
When Harriet's extravagant birthday party ends with a dead body, all fingers point to Sara Allbright, the troublesome sister of none other than Nic, Harriet's short-lived fling from years ago that she's been eager to forget. And the feeling is entirely mutual. But murder makes for a good story, and when Harriet is told that she can get her old job back if she writes an article uncovering what really happened the night of her party, she readily agrees. To write her piece, Harriet will need Nic's full cooperation, and if Nic wants to clear his sister's name, he'll need Harriet's investigative skills. But working together? That's less than ideal.
As the two team up to find the real killer, they'll discover the dark underbelly of their seemingly perfect hometown, uncover long buried feelings, and maybe, just maybe, realize that they might work well together after all.
Murder has a way of bringing people together…
Harriet Baker thought that when she left Logan Island, she was leaving for good. But after getting fired from her dream magazine job, she finds herself stuck back in the sleepy New Jersey beach town living with her eccentric mother and desperate to escape.
And her ticket out might be…murder?
When Harriet's extravagant birthday party ends with a dead body, all fingers point to Sara Allbright, the troublesome sister of none other than Nic, Harriet's short-lived fling from years ago that she's been eager to forget. And the feeling is entirely mutual. But murder makes for a good story, and when Harriet is told that she can get her old job back if she writes an article uncovering what really happened the night of her party, she readily agrees. To write her piece, Harriet will need Nic's full cooperation, and if Nic wants to clear his sister's name, he'll need Harriet's investigative skills. But working together? That's less than ideal.
As the two team up to find the real killer, they'll discover the dark underbelly of their seemingly perfect hometown, uncover long buried feelings, and maybe, just maybe, realize that they might work well together after all.
401 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 26, 2026
About the author
Liz Lawson
8 books749 followersLiz Lawson is the New York Times bestselling author of The Agathas series (co-written with Kathleen Glasgow), Murder Between Friends, and The Lucky Ones. Her books have been translated into fourteen languages, been book club picks for Barnes and Noble, Target, and Read With Jenna, and been written about in national publications like The New York Times (that was a very exciting day).
She lives in the DC metro area with her family and two very bratty cats. It Happened One Murder is her adult debut (and she’s thrilled).
Visit her on TikTok and Instagram @lzlwsn or her website lizlawsonauthor.com
She lives in the DC metro area with her family and two very bratty cats. It Happened One Murder is her adult debut (and she’s thrilled).
Visit her on TikTok and Instagram @lzlwsn or her website lizlawsonauthor.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 435 reviews
July 16, 2026
I adore cozy mysteries and romance, so when I saw that this book included both, I was ecstatic and couldn’t wait to dive into it. Unfortunately, I didn’t end up enjoying it as much as I had hoped.
In terms of the mystery, I thought it was well done. I really enjoy stories where the murder victim has a lot of enemies, which was the case here. Because of this, Harriett and Nico were left with a lot of potential suspects, which helped keep me guessing throughout the story. I was genuinely surprised by who the killer ended up being, which I always appreciate.
Without giving away any spoilers, I will say that some folks may find certain components of the mystery unrealistic and perhaps a little far-fetched. However, this personally didn’t bother me, especially since the murder victim is extremely wealthy, which always makes deep and far-reaching corruption more believable to me.
Outside of the mystery itself, my biggest problem with this story was Harriett. I really wanted to like her and give her the benefit of the doubt, but she just came across as relentlessly insufferable. She is supposed to be really good at interviewing people, but there are several times when she completely ruins interviews because of her poor emotional regulation skills. There are also countless moments when she admits that she shouldn’t say or do something and acknowledges that it’s unfair, yet she does it anyway, often hurting others or causing problems for them. Then, even though she supposedly cares for Nico, she leaves him alone in a dangerous situation for her own selfish reasons. Overall, she came across as a very self-absorbed and emotionally immature character.
Also, for anyone who doesn’t have patience for rich folks who insist they aren’t like all the other rich folks, go into this prepared to be annoyed. Harriett spends a lot of time telling herself she’s different just because she had a job. Yet, and I’m sure you won’t be surprised by this, she consistently shows her privilege and proves why she is not the exception she thinks she is.
I also really struggled with the romantic relationship between Harriett and Nico. We kept being told how much physical chemistry they had, but I never actually felt that chemistry was there. While it could be described as enemies to lovers, I honestly didn’t buy or understand how they were in a relationship by the end of the book. I also genuinely don’t know why Nico liked Harriett at all. At all. I would have preferred for him to end up with Mindy. Nico 100% deserved better.
The other thing I’ll mention about their relationship is how infuriating the miscommunication was. I DESPISE constant miscommunication, especially when we are dealing with full-grown adults. Throughout the entire book, Nico and Harriett’s relationship felt like one step forward and two steps back solely because of how frequently they miscommunicated. So many of their problems and hurt feelings could have been avoided if they had just communicated like the adults they supposedly are.
With all that said, I did enjoy Nico’s character for the most part. His love and care for his family, especially his mom and sister, were heartwarming. Even though Nico was given every reason to resent his sister, he still fought so hard to get her out of jail and clear her name. I also appreciated how much he cared about his community and how he wasn’t afraid to call anyone out on their BS, especially Harriett.
All in all, this book was just okay for me. I think I would have enjoyed it so much more if Harriett’s personality hadn’t been so unlikeable, because I think that also would have fixed many of the issues I had with the romance.
If you enjoy cozy mysteries and romance, I would still say this might be worth checking out. Just be prepared for a lot of miscommunication and an FMC who may not be your favourite.
In terms of the mystery, I thought it was well done. I really enjoy stories where the murder victim has a lot of enemies, which was the case here. Because of this, Harriett and Nico were left with a lot of potential suspects, which helped keep me guessing throughout the story. I was genuinely surprised by who the killer ended up being, which I always appreciate.
Without giving away any spoilers, I will say that some folks may find certain components of the mystery unrealistic and perhaps a little far-fetched. However, this personally didn’t bother me, especially since the murder victim is extremely wealthy, which always makes deep and far-reaching corruption more believable to me.
Outside of the mystery itself, my biggest problem with this story was Harriett. I really wanted to like her and give her the benefit of the doubt, but she just came across as relentlessly insufferable. She is supposed to be really good at interviewing people, but there are several times when she completely ruins interviews because of her poor emotional regulation skills. There are also countless moments when she admits that she shouldn’t say or do something and acknowledges that it’s unfair, yet she does it anyway, often hurting others or causing problems for them. Then, even though she supposedly cares for Nico, she leaves him alone in a dangerous situation for her own selfish reasons. Overall, she came across as a very self-absorbed and emotionally immature character.
Also, for anyone who doesn’t have patience for rich folks who insist they aren’t like all the other rich folks, go into this prepared to be annoyed. Harriett spends a lot of time telling herself she’s different just because she had a job. Yet, and I’m sure you won’t be surprised by this, she consistently shows her privilege and proves why she is not the exception she thinks she is.
I also really struggled with the romantic relationship between Harriett and Nico. We kept being told how much physical chemistry they had, but I never actually felt that chemistry was there. While it could be described as enemies to lovers, I honestly didn’t buy or understand how they were in a relationship by the end of the book. I also genuinely don’t know why Nico liked Harriett at all. At all. I would have preferred for him to end up with Mindy. Nico 100% deserved better.
The other thing I’ll mention about their relationship is how infuriating the miscommunication was. I DESPISE constant miscommunication, especially when we are dealing with full-grown adults. Throughout the entire book, Nico and Harriett’s relationship felt like one step forward and two steps back solely because of how frequently they miscommunicated. So many of their problems and hurt feelings could have been avoided if they had just communicated like the adults they supposedly are.
With all that said, I did enjoy Nico’s character for the most part. His love and care for his family, especially his mom and sister, were heartwarming. Even though Nico was given every reason to resent his sister, he still fought so hard to get her out of jail and clear her name. I also appreciated how much he cared about his community and how he wasn’t afraid to call anyone out on their BS, especially Harriett.
All in all, this book was just okay for me. I think I would have enjoyed it so much more if Harriett’s personality hadn’t been so unlikeable, because I think that also would have fixed many of the issues I had with the romance.
If you enjoy cozy mysteries and romance, I would still say this might be worth checking out. Just be prepared for a lot of miscommunication and an FMC who may not be your favourite.
November 5, 2025
4,5⭐️
This book had no reason to be SO GOOD. I’m not even kidding, it brought me back to my prime where I used to read everywhere, all the time. ✊
After losing her job and having to move back home, Harriet’s mother decided to throw her a birthday party. At the unwanted birthday party, no one seems to be having a good time. Especially the Allbright family. Nic doesn’t get recognised by his long time crush. Sara, his sister, gets in a fight with the host and when he mysteriously dies, she, of course, is the one getting blamed for his murder. Nick can’t let her go to prison but what can he do alone?
The story had the perfect mix of mystery and romance. From the beginning, it had my complete attention and it never lost it. The plot was so balanced between the two categories and it kept just getting better.
I loved Nic and Harriet’s past and their personalities. Each of them were unique in their own ways. Harriet is stubborn and strong willed. Whereas Nic is calmer, mature and protective. He is afraid to be hurt again that’s why he stands his ground. It does take him more time to give in but I still had the feeling that everything happened in perfect timing.
The End (and Epilouge) were amazing. It was extremely fitting and satisfying.
Thanks to SOURCEBOOKS Landmark for providing this book via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
This book had no reason to be SO GOOD. I’m not even kidding, it brought me back to my prime where I used to read everywhere, all the time. ✊
After losing her job and having to move back home, Harriet’s mother decided to throw her a birthday party. At the unwanted birthday party, no one seems to be having a good time. Especially the Allbright family. Nic doesn’t get recognised by his long time crush. Sara, his sister, gets in a fight with the host and when he mysteriously dies, she, of course, is the one getting blamed for his murder. Nick can’t let her go to prison but what can he do alone?
The story had the perfect mix of mystery and romance. From the beginning, it had my complete attention and it never lost it. The plot was so balanced between the two categories and it kept just getting better.
I loved Nic and Harriet’s past and their personalities. Each of them were unique in their own ways. Harriet is stubborn and strong willed. Whereas Nic is calmer, mature and protective. He is afraid to be hurt again that’s why he stands his ground. It does take him more time to give in but I still had the feeling that everything happened in perfect timing.
The End (and Epilouge) were amazing. It was extremely fitting and satisfying.
Thanks to SOURCEBOOKS Landmark for providing this book via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
September 23, 2026
It Happened One Murder is a catchy title, right? That's a large part of why I chose to read this book by Liz Lawson. The synopsis also gave me cozy/romance vibes, and I've apparently been trying to insert some more romance into my reading for a while now. So here we are.
Harriet Baker is living back home with her mother and stepfather on Logan Island after being fired from her dream job. Two key things happen at the birthday party her mother insists on throwing her: she runs into an old fling she'd ghosted, and her stepfather ends up murdered. The person accused just happens to be the sister of this old fling, whose name is Nic. They will have to team up if they are to clear an innocent woman's name. They'll both have to learn to move beyond the past and work together if they're to succeed.
This was a pretty cute little mystery/romance overall. Harriet's stepfather was an awful person, so there were really plenty of potential suspects and motives. The author threw in a couple of red herrings, the first of which I sniffed out as such, but the second one admittedly got me. I was definitely surprised when I learned who the real killer was. I enjoyed Harriet and Nic as characters and their evolving relationship. The romance was present, but it definitely took a backseat to the mystery, as it should've, although I would've liked more of it. I liked best how Harriet and Nic figured out how to handle things once the murderer was identified. It was a bit of a stretch, but a fun one, in my opinion.
Themes touched upon were family loyalty, second chances, small-town secrets, corruption, truth and accountability, and the complications caused by mixing personal feelings with an investigation. The writing in the story is fast-paced, conversational, and dialogue-driven, with first-person, present-tense narration from Nic and Harriet in their own chapters. The prose is straightforward and easy to read, while the characters' inner commentary and banter keep the murder mystery light and humorous. Clues and exposition are often delivered through conversation, making the increasingly tangled plot easy to follow.
It Happened One Murder is a cozy-adjacent mystery with splashes of romance. It was a relatively quick and easy read that kept me guessing until the identity of the murderer was revealed. This is one I'd definitely recommend to cozy mystery lovers or to romance readers who maybe want to dip their toes into a slightly different genre.
Nerd Rating: 🤓🤓🤓— A light, cozy-adjacent mystery with a splash of romance.
Let’s Discuss:
Do you prefer your cozy mysteries with a little romance, or would you rather the mystery remain the sole focus?
I read a digital copy made available by Sourcebooks Landmark through NetGalley, and this review reflects my honest opinion.
Harriet Baker is living back home with her mother and stepfather on Logan Island after being fired from her dream job. Two key things happen at the birthday party her mother insists on throwing her: she runs into an old fling she'd ghosted, and her stepfather ends up murdered. The person accused just happens to be the sister of this old fling, whose name is Nic. They will have to team up if they are to clear an innocent woman's name. They'll both have to learn to move beyond the past and work together if they're to succeed.
This was a pretty cute little mystery/romance overall. Harriet's stepfather was an awful person, so there were really plenty of potential suspects and motives. The author threw in a couple of red herrings, the first of which I sniffed out as such, but the second one admittedly got me. I was definitely surprised when I learned who the real killer was. I enjoyed Harriet and Nic as characters and their evolving relationship. The romance was present, but it definitely took a backseat to the mystery, as it should've, although I would've liked more of it. I liked best how Harriet and Nic figured out how to handle things once the murderer was identified. It was a bit of a stretch, but a fun one, in my opinion.
Themes touched upon were family loyalty, second chances, small-town secrets, corruption, truth and accountability, and the complications caused by mixing personal feelings with an investigation. The writing in the story is fast-paced, conversational, and dialogue-driven, with first-person, present-tense narration from Nic and Harriet in their own chapters. The prose is straightforward and easy to read, while the characters' inner commentary and banter keep the murder mystery light and humorous. Clues and exposition are often delivered through conversation, making the increasingly tangled plot easy to follow.
It Happened One Murder is a cozy-adjacent mystery with splashes of romance. It was a relatively quick and easy read that kept me guessing until the identity of the murderer was revealed. This is one I'd definitely recommend to cozy mystery lovers or to romance readers who maybe want to dip their toes into a slightly different genre.
Nerd Rating: 🤓🤓🤓— A light, cozy-adjacent mystery with a splash of romance.
Let’s Discuss:
Do you prefer your cozy mysteries with a little romance, or would you rather the mystery remain the sole focus?
I read a digital copy made available by Sourcebooks Landmark through NetGalley, and this review reflects my honest opinion.
June 28, 2026
**3.5-stars rounded up**
After getting fired from her dream magazine job in NYC, Harriet Baker returns to her hometown, a sleepy beach town in New Jersey, to lick her wounds and recover.
Unfortunately, living with her eccentric mother and narcissistic step-father isn't necessarily a soothing environment for her. Nevertheless, Harriet won't be there for long. She just wants to keep her head down until she can return to some semblance of her former life.
Then her mother decides to throw an extravagant birthday party for her. The last thing Harriet would want, but like with everything else, her mom is like a tornado and poor Harriet just gets sucked unwilling up into the cyclone.
At the party, full of her Mom's friends and acquaintances, Harriet ends up running into her one-time fling, Nic Allbright, whose family is catering the event. She'd not forgot those short weeks with Nic, but it did take her a moment to recognize him.
That's not awkward at all...
When the party abruptly ends in murder, all eyes are looking to Nic's sister, Sara, who was the chef at the party. She knowingly left in a huff after a loud squabble with the individual who now lays dead on the beach.
Nic knows his sister is innocent and he needs to clear her name. Harriet also has a motivation to investigate the crime. She's been offered her old job back if she writes an article uncovering what really happened the night of the party. After all, True Crime is popular.
For her article, Harriet is going to need Nic's cooperation. She needs access to his sister, and if he is going to clear Sara's name, he needs Harriet's skills as an investigative reporter. But will they be able to put the past in the past, and actually work together?
It Happened One Murder is a really cute romantic Cozy Mystery. I loved the set-up of the party and how quickly Lawson got us to the murder, and hence the mystery.
I also really enjoyed Harriet's perspective, what was going on with her as far as her job and family. I also loved the beach setting. Nic was charming and compelling as a love interest as well. I liked the backstory of their time together as teens, and how differently their lives had gone since then.
While the mystery itself didn't quite knock my socks off, the likable characters and the romance more than made up for it. The banter between Harriet and Nic was great, and I appreciated that we got both of their perspectives. I think it added a lot, as far as understanding their relationship.
I would recommend this to Readers who enjoy cozy, low stakes, mysteries with a side of romance. I think Lawson balanced all the elements of this story very well and I'm excited to read more from her in the future.
Thank you so much to the publisher, SOURCEBOOKS Landmark, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This story is as cute as its cover!
After getting fired from her dream magazine job in NYC, Harriet Baker returns to her hometown, a sleepy beach town in New Jersey, to lick her wounds and recover.
Unfortunately, living with her eccentric mother and narcissistic step-father isn't necessarily a soothing environment for her. Nevertheless, Harriet won't be there for long. She just wants to keep her head down until she can return to some semblance of her former life.
Then her mother decides to throw an extravagant birthday party for her. The last thing Harriet would want, but like with everything else, her mom is like a tornado and poor Harriet just gets sucked unwilling up into the cyclone.
At the party, full of her Mom's friends and acquaintances, Harriet ends up running into her one-time fling, Nic Allbright, whose family is catering the event. She'd not forgot those short weeks with Nic, but it did take her a moment to recognize him.
That's not awkward at all...
When the party abruptly ends in murder, all eyes are looking to Nic's sister, Sara, who was the chef at the party. She knowingly left in a huff after a loud squabble with the individual who now lays dead on the beach.
Nic knows his sister is innocent and he needs to clear her name. Harriet also has a motivation to investigate the crime. She's been offered her old job back if she writes an article uncovering what really happened the night of the party. After all, True Crime is popular.
For her article, Harriet is going to need Nic's cooperation. She needs access to his sister, and if he is going to clear Sara's name, he needs Harriet's skills as an investigative reporter. But will they be able to put the past in the past, and actually work together?
It Happened One Murder is a really cute romantic Cozy Mystery. I loved the set-up of the party and how quickly Lawson got us to the murder, and hence the mystery.
I also really enjoyed Harriet's perspective, what was going on with her as far as her job and family. I also loved the beach setting. Nic was charming and compelling as a love interest as well. I liked the backstory of their time together as teens, and how differently their lives had gone since then.
While the mystery itself didn't quite knock my socks off, the likable characters and the romance more than made up for it. The banter between Harriet and Nic was great, and I appreciated that we got both of their perspectives. I think it added a lot, as far as understanding their relationship.
I would recommend this to Readers who enjoy cozy, low stakes, mysteries with a side of romance. I think Lawson balanced all the elements of this story very well and I'm excited to read more from her in the future.
Thank you so much to the publisher, SOURCEBOOKS Landmark, for providing me with a copy to read and review. This story is as cute as its cover!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
[arc review] 2.5* rounded up!
I was hopeful about this and after reading wish it was written as a single pov—and little to no romance included.
‘it happened one murder’ is a dual pov mystery / romance that follows harriet and nic as they reunite under not-so-great circumstances.
now the plot of this is good, and I enjoyed the mystery of who the killer was.
I think in the beginning, it was slightly confusing because we were introduced to so many characters that it felt like a hinderance to the flow of the story.
I didn’t really enjoy the dual pov, and at times the characters were very immature and holding grudges over a fling they had as teenagers.
for me it didn’t make sense why there was so much resentment over something that happened as teenagers (and over 2 weeks!).
it felt like it ruined the romance because they were at each others throat over something they could’ve communicated with each other about, and it would’ve been resolved a lot sooner.
and don’t get me started on the epilogue?????
overall I did enjoy the mystery and whodunnit, but the romance felt lacklustre. it would’ve been SO good as a second chance romance if there was actual history between harriet and nic—not just a two week fling that these characters should not have been hung up on for so long.
thank you source books for the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review!
I was hopeful about this and after reading wish it was written as a single pov—and little to no romance included.
‘it happened one murder’ is a dual pov mystery / romance that follows harriet and nic as they reunite under not-so-great circumstances.
now the plot of this is good, and I enjoyed the mystery of who the killer was.
I think in the beginning, it was slightly confusing because we were introduced to so many characters that it felt like a hinderance to the flow of the story.
I didn’t really enjoy the dual pov, and at times the characters were very immature and holding grudges over a fling they had as teenagers.
for me it didn’t make sense why there was so much resentment over something that happened as teenagers (and over 2 weeks!).
it felt like it ruined the romance because they were at each others throat over something they could’ve communicated with each other about, and it would’ve been resolved a lot sooner.
and don’t get me started on the epilogue?????
overall I did enjoy the mystery and whodunnit, but the romance felt lacklustre. it would’ve been SO good as a second chance romance if there was actual history between harriet and nic—not just a two week fling that these characters should not have been hung up on for so long.
thank you source books for the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review!
November 1, 2025
✨I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review ✨
I don’t think I have ever read a romance-murder-mystery before that I enjoyed as much as this! Harriet bumps into her ex Nic at her birthday party, which quickly turns into disaster when a body is found on the beach. Harriet and Nic are both connected to the murder in different ways and determined to solve the case which is quickly discarded by the police and ruining their lives. It Happened One Murder was such a fun reading experience and I struggled to put it down. Every time I thought I had figured out what happened a new twist appeared! I loved the unexpected enemies-to-lovers-who-got-a-second-chance romance and the falling in love that happened as they went on adventures and tried to solve the crime. This is a great read and my only complaint is that the knife on the cover should have a pretty white handle - if you know, you know!
I don’t think I have ever read a romance-murder-mystery before that I enjoyed as much as this! Harriet bumps into her ex Nic at her birthday party, which quickly turns into disaster when a body is found on the beach. Harriet and Nic are both connected to the murder in different ways and determined to solve the case which is quickly discarded by the police and ruining their lives. It Happened One Murder was such a fun reading experience and I struggled to put it down. Every time I thought I had figured out what happened a new twist appeared! I loved the unexpected enemies-to-lovers-who-got-a-second-chance romance and the falling in love that happened as they went on adventures and tried to solve the crime. This is a great read and my only complaint is that the knife on the cover should have a pretty white handle - if you know, you know!
Read
May 7, 2026unfortunately this book was a total miss for me. i did an immersive read with the ebook and audio and the only good part for me was i liked the narrators. the main characters were just very immature and i couldnt get invested in them separately or together, their grudge with one another over two weeks as teenagers was asinine to be quite frank. the murder mystery did nothing for me either.
November 30, 2025
From page one, this book felt like a tangled web of secrets: a sleepy beach town beneath a shiny veneer, old relationships simmering with unspoken truths, and a murder that refuses to stay buried.
Harriet Baker’s return to Logan Island isn’t just an “I’m home for a while” — it’s a collision course with her past. Losing her job, uprooting her life, and then being thrust into a murder mystery she never signed up for? That alone had me curious. But once the body drops and suspicion lands where she least expects it — on the sister of her old fling — the stakes become deeply personal.
What works wonderfully: the push-and-pull between Harriet and Nic. They have history, baggage, awkward silences, and painful misunderstandings — but also tension, curiosity, and that messy “maybe there’s still something here” energy that never quite dies. Their forced teamwork to hunt down a killer becomes a perfect metaphor for trying to rebuild trust — uncertain, fragile, and potent.
And the mystery itself? Sneaky. Just when I thought I had a handle on who the culprit might be — bam, plot twist. The author drops clues, misleads with subtle red herrings, and still manages to surprise. The small-town setting makes secrets even more dangerous, because almost everyone knows everyone.
Yes — there are moments of frustration. Sometimes the characters’ lack of communication feels like stumbling over the same old problems again. Especially in a slow-burn romance, that kind of repeated miscommunication can feel heavy.
But if you ask me: that messy tension, unresolved frictions, dark secrets under holiday-town lights, and the wild ride of trying to find truth and maybe love again — this book delivers. It’s clever, cozy, twisty, and emotionally messy in the best way.
My Verdict: A solid ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐ (5/5). A wildly fun, addictive blend of cozy-town mystery, tension-filled romance, and dark secrets — ideal if you like your rom-mystery with a side of chaos, chemistry, and “who’s the killer?” suspense.
Harriet Baker’s return to Logan Island isn’t just an “I’m home for a while” — it’s a collision course with her past. Losing her job, uprooting her life, and then being thrust into a murder mystery she never signed up for? That alone had me curious. But once the body drops and suspicion lands where she least expects it — on the sister of her old fling — the stakes become deeply personal.
What works wonderfully: the push-and-pull between Harriet and Nic. They have history, baggage, awkward silences, and painful misunderstandings — but also tension, curiosity, and that messy “maybe there’s still something here” energy that never quite dies. Their forced teamwork to hunt down a killer becomes a perfect metaphor for trying to rebuild trust — uncertain, fragile, and potent.
And the mystery itself? Sneaky. Just when I thought I had a handle on who the culprit might be — bam, plot twist. The author drops clues, misleads with subtle red herrings, and still manages to surprise. The small-town setting makes secrets even more dangerous, because almost everyone knows everyone.
Yes — there are moments of frustration. Sometimes the characters’ lack of communication feels like stumbling over the same old problems again. Especially in a slow-burn romance, that kind of repeated miscommunication can feel heavy.
But if you ask me: that messy tension, unresolved frictions, dark secrets under holiday-town lights, and the wild ride of trying to find truth and maybe love again — this book delivers. It’s clever, cozy, twisty, and emotionally messy in the best way.
My Verdict: A solid ⭐⭐⭐⭐ ⭐ (5/5). A wildly fun, addictive blend of cozy-town mystery, tension-filled romance, and dark secrets — ideal if you like your rom-mystery with a side of chaos, chemistry, and “who’s the killer?” suspense.
May 30, 2026
A cute and light little murder mystery rom com. This had a fun, summery setting and a good cast of characters, although the fmc and mc could be a little inconsistent in their feelings (of course, I don’t read much romance so maybe that’s normal?). Loved the humor and the mystery, which unfolded nicely.
October 26, 2025
What a fun read! A perfect blend of mystery and romance. An interesting plot about a murder but was there a falsely accused murderer? And was the victim actually innocent?
Really enjoyed the different characters and felt the supporting characters worked in well too! Definitely didn’t see the twist coming, making it an overall enjoyable mystery read.
Really enjoyed the different characters and felt the supporting characters worked in well too! Definitely didn’t see the twist coming, making it an overall enjoyable mystery read.
October 30, 2025
It Happened One Murder broke me out of my reading slump so quickly! I tore through this book!
Harriet is having an awful time at her own birthday party when she quite literally bumps into an ex-hookup, Nic. She's already shaken up from losing her writing job in NYC, moving back in with her mum and step-father in coastal New Jersey, and running into an ex is not helping the situation! Nic, on the other hand, is busy running his family's catering business, and finding himself in the home of his teenage sweetheart isn't where he wanted to spend his night. Harriet not recognising him is the cherry on top of an already uncomfortable situation. Then, a body is found on the beach out the front of Harriet's house, and both their worlds collide to try to find the truth of what happened.
Liz Lawson writes excellent characters. Harriet is stubborn, strong willed and not afraid to get her hands dirty. Nic is mature, loyal to fault and desperate to protect those he cares about. They have great chemistry, and the will-they-won't-they had me swooning. As for the whodunnit aspect of It Happened One Murder, I thought I had the killer picked early on, but I should have known there'd be many more twists before the final reveal! This definitely kept me on my toes, and the novel has a very satisfying outcome.
A big thanks to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for providing me with a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Harriet is having an awful time at her own birthday party when she quite literally bumps into an ex-hookup, Nic. She's already shaken up from losing her writing job in NYC, moving back in with her mum and step-father in coastal New Jersey, and running into an ex is not helping the situation! Nic, on the other hand, is busy running his family's catering business, and finding himself in the home of his teenage sweetheart isn't where he wanted to spend his night. Harriet not recognising him is the cherry on top of an already uncomfortable situation. Then, a body is found on the beach out the front of Harriet's house, and both their worlds collide to try to find the truth of what happened.
Liz Lawson writes excellent characters. Harriet is stubborn, strong willed and not afraid to get her hands dirty. Nic is mature, loyal to fault and desperate to protect those he cares about. They have great chemistry, and the will-they-won't-they had me swooning. As for the whodunnit aspect of It Happened One Murder, I thought I had the killer picked early on, but I should have known there'd be many more twists before the final reveal! This definitely kept me on my toes, and the novel has a very satisfying outcome.
A big thanks to NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for providing me with a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Did Not Finish
April 2, 2026finished 20% - I think this can be a fun murder mystery with romance on the side. The plot seems like it would be entertaining and has scope, which is what drew me to the book in the first place. I usually enjoy dramatic situational humour in books, but the delivery in this didn't click for me.
I'm a primarily character driven reader, and unfortunately, I did not connect with these characters. Their personalities and presentation felt exaggerated. The extent of the hatred between the main characters didn't add up based on the extent of their past history. Because of that the way they were handling themselves came across as immature, and I found it hard to continue reading.
The dialogues also felt a bit forced and included a liberal use of expletives, which was overdone for my taste. The book was written in dual first-person POV's and I don't usually like that - my preference for multiple character perspectives is third-person limited POV's
If you are a plot driven reader, and find the other elements to your taste - give it a try. I've seen other reviews where people enjoyed reading it for the main mystery plot and have rated the book well.
(I am not leaving a rating, as I didn't finish the book).
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review the e-arc of this novel. All opinions expressed here are my own.
I'm a primarily character driven reader, and unfortunately, I did not connect with these characters. Their personalities and presentation felt exaggerated. The extent of the hatred between the main characters didn't add up based on the extent of their past history. Because of that the way they were handling themselves came across as immature, and I found it hard to continue reading.
The dialogues also felt a bit forced and included a liberal use of expletives, which was overdone for my taste. The book was written in dual first-person POV's and I don't usually like that - my preference for multiple character perspectives is third-person limited POV's
If you are a plot driven reader, and find the other elements to your taste - give it a try. I've seen other reviews where people enjoyed reading it for the main mystery plot and have rated the book well.
(I am not leaving a rating, as I didn't finish the book).
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review the e-arc of this novel. All opinions expressed here are my own.
December 25, 2025
I had a great time reading this book! This book is a fantastic blend of romance, mystery, and a few humorous moments. From the intriguing plot to the wonderful characters, I believe the author did a fantastic job of keeping my interest. I adored the love that grew while they embarked on adventures and attempted to solve the crime, as well as the surprising enemies-to-lovers-who-got-second-chance romance. Harriet has a strong will, is obstinate, and doesn't mind getting her hands dirty. Nic is responsible, devoted, and driven to keep the people he loves safe. The couple has had me swooning, and their chemistry is amazing. Regarding It Happened One Murder's murder mystery element, I believed I had identified the murderer early on, but I should have realized there would be a lot more surprises before the big reveal! I was definitely on my toes because of this, and the novel's conclusion is rather rewarding.
This book delivers on the complicated tension, unsolved conflicts, hidden histories under holiday-town lights, and the crazy trip of attempting to find truth and possibly love again. In the best manner possible, it's witty, warm, twisted, and emotionally complicated!!!
Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher, Sourcebook Landmark, and the author for providing me with the electronic ARC copy. I really enjoyed the book!!!
This book delivers on the complicated tension, unsolved conflicts, hidden histories under holiday-town lights, and the crazy trip of attempting to find truth and possibly love again. In the best manner possible, it's witty, warm, twisted, and emotionally complicated!!!
Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher, Sourcebook Landmark, and the author for providing me with the electronic ARC copy. I really enjoyed the book!!!
Read
May 16, 2026I have really enjoyed Lawson's YA mysteries with Kathleen Glasgow! But It Happened One Murder, Lawson's debut as a romantic suspense author, wasn't a good fit for me.
The book was not old school romantic suspense based on the Gothic. Instead, it felt like a PG-13 YA mystery. The characters seemed younger than their 26 years and I think the dual his/hers romance POV did not work in a mystery plot.
How was the romance? Sporadically steamy. There was a semi-explicit second base makeout scene and then the romance part got a bit more PG. There was too much dialogue for my taste and the characters were a bit generic and hard to keep straight.
How was the mystery plot, you ask? The best part! Set on what I think was based on Long Beach Island, it kicked off with the murder of an evil land developer (one of the POV characters' stepfather) and delves into small town politics etc. That was a success and I wished the book had used older characters and stuck to that with the romance as a subplot.
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
The book was not old school romantic suspense based on the Gothic. Instead, it felt like a PG-13 YA mystery. The characters seemed younger than their 26 years and I think the dual his/hers romance POV did not work in a mystery plot.
How was the romance? Sporadically steamy. There was a semi-explicit second base makeout scene and then the romance part got a bit more PG. There was too much dialogue for my taste and the characters were a bit generic and hard to keep straight.
How was the mystery plot, you ask? The best part! Set on what I think was based on Long Beach Island, it kicked off with the murder of an evil land developer (one of the POV characters' stepfather) and delves into small town politics etc. That was a success and I wished the book had used older characters and stuck to that with the romance as a subplot.
Thanks to the publisher for providing an advance copy for review!
June 11, 2026
This was mostly fun! Harriet returns to her hometown in New Jersey, only for her stepfather to end up murdered at her birthday party, with suspicion falling on the sister of Harriet's former fling, Nic. Dun dun dun! Racing against the clock to prove her innocence, the mystery kept me invested, and I liked the fact that the victim was Harriet's wretched businessman stepfather, adding a whole other layer of juicy family drama. Bonus points that I did not guess the culprit at all.
The romance was just ok, though. It's not really a second-chance romance since Harriet and Nic only slept together once eight years ago, but it kind of felt like the book was trying to sell it as one. Like it wanted me to buy into their chemistry as if they shared some deep romantic history. I think having Nic's POV only made that worse at times, since so much emphasis was placed on his heartbreak towards Harriet and the tension between them when I wasn't fully convinced either was warranted.
(spice level: fade to black / cracked door)
The romance was just ok, though. It's not really a second-chance romance since Harriet and Nic only slept together once eight years ago, but it kind of felt like the book was trying to sell it as one. Like it wanted me to buy into their chemistry as if they shared some deep romantic history. I think having Nic's POV only made that worse at times, since so much emphasis was placed on his heartbreak towards Harriet and the tension between them when I wasn't fully convinced either was warranted.
(spice level: fade to black / cracked door)
October 29, 2025
This is a fun romance/cozy mystery that grabbed my attention and kept me reading until the end.
Harriet has returned home after being fired from her job. She's living with her mother and step father, two very annoying people.
Her mother throws Harriet a birthday party, and she finds herself face to face with a caterer, Nic, who she had a two week fling with.
Nic's sister is accused of killing Harriet's step father, but Harriet doesn't think she did it, so she convinces Nic that they should investigate and save his sister.
Things heat up with Nic and Harriet, and the two of them find the answers they've been looking for.
Harriet has returned home after being fired from her job. She's living with her mother and step father, two very annoying people.
Her mother throws Harriet a birthday party, and she finds herself face to face with a caterer, Nic, who she had a two week fling with.
Nic's sister is accused of killing Harriet's step father, but Harriet doesn't think she did it, so she convinces Nic that they should investigate and save his sister.
Things heat up with Nic and Harriet, and the two of them find the answers they've been looking for.
November 3, 2025
It Happened One Murder
I really enjoyed this book! This book is a great mix of who done it mystery, romance and a couple of funny moments. I think the author did a great job holding my attention from the interesting storyline, to the great characters. Imagine having to move back home and living with your mom, and her rich husband who throws a party, and you run into a sexy man that you don't realize is the guy you use to hook up with. Oh and her step dad is a murder, and his sister is arrested. Sound interesting?! Then I would highly recommend adding this book to your TBR!!
I really enjoyed this book! This book is a great mix of who done it mystery, romance and a couple of funny moments. I think the author did a great job holding my attention from the interesting storyline, to the great characters. Imagine having to move back home and living with your mom, and her rich husband who throws a party, and you run into a sexy man that you don't realize is the guy you use to hook up with. Oh and her step dad is a murder, and his sister is arrested. Sound interesting?! Then I would highly recommend adding this book to your TBR!!
October 25, 2025
Liz Lawson first made her mark with some really terrific YA novels, including the Agathas series (more books in that series are needed - hint hint).
Now she is delivering a fun, twisty adult mystery thriller with enough surprises to keep you reading right through the night. No spoilers here, but just know that you are going to love, love love the writing and the mystery. And the ending will leave you asking for more, that is for sure!!
Now she is delivering a fun, twisty adult mystery thriller with enough surprises to keep you reading right through the night. No spoilers here, but just know that you are going to love, love love the writing and the mystery. And the ending will leave you asking for more, that is for sure!!
November 4, 2025
I really enjoyed this book!!! Take murder mystery with humor and touch of romance and that’s what this book felt like to me. It was entertaining from start to finish. I loved the main characters and the storyline kept me guessing at who the murderer really was. I loved that there was romance, but the author used humor to keep it light hearted.
Thank you SOURCEBOOKS Landmark publishing and Netgalley for this Arc!
Thank you SOURCEBOOKS Landmark publishing and Netgalley for this Arc!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
At first the dual perspective and the present tense was a bit confusing; but when the story sucked me in I didn't notice it anymore. The story looks like a typical who-dunnit but there are a few layers that make it more than that. The romantic storyline wasn't necessary in my opinion, but many readers will disagree with me. the end is very surprising and definitely the icing on the cake.
November 3, 2025
Thanks net galley for this arc
I absolutely loved it, this is such a cozy cute murder mystery read - the twist I never saw coming.
Harriet and Nic are brilliant main characters who you get fully invested in. 5***** read for sure.
I absolutely loved it, this is such a cozy cute murder mystery read - the twist I never saw coming.
Harriet and Nic are brilliant main characters who you get fully invested in. 5***** read for sure.
October 21, 2025
It’s simple. This one from Lawson is her best. So good you won’t be able to put it down. Total must read!
November 25, 2025
I loved this! Fast-paced and voicey narration, entertaining cast of characters (particularly Harriet's mom lol), and great balance of sexual tension and how-much-actual-danger-are-we-in? tension.
October 27, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, Sourcebooks Landmark and Liz Lawson for sharing this ARC with me, in exchange for my honest review.
It Happened One Murder is a very enjoyable read. Ms. Liz's writing and world building is perfect. The flow was easy. It is truly a page-turner. Just when you think you know who did it, BAM, Ms. Liz hits you with a twist. I also liked the side characters, I feel they were integrated in very well.
So, I have a question for y'all...Do y'all tihink the victim is innocent?
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to all y'all.
It Happened One Murder is a very enjoyable read. Ms. Liz's writing and world building is perfect. The flow was easy. It is truly a page-turner. Just when you think you know who did it, BAM, Ms. Liz hits you with a twist. I also liked the side characters, I feel they were integrated in very well.
So, I have a question for y'all...Do y'all tihink the victim is innocent?
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to all y'all.
Did Not Finish
October 8, 2026DNF at 65%.
I think I have realized that romance murder mysteries are a genre that just doesn't work for me. I feel like I just spend all of my time thinking "oh boy that is a really bad decision" and it just takes me out of any of the fun of it.
I also felt like Nic and Harriet were like a bickering brother and sister duo so anytime they would talk about finding it other attractive, it just didn't work for me.
I think I have realized that romance murder mysteries are a genre that just doesn't work for me. I feel like I just spend all of my time thinking "oh boy that is a really bad decision" and it just takes me out of any of the fun of it.
I also felt like Nic and Harriet were like a bickering brother and sister duo so anytime they would talk about finding it other attractive, it just didn't work for me.
Did Not Finish
May 28, 2026silly writing
October 21, 2026
Was this a rom-com? A thriller? A cosy mystery? I don't know but whatever it was, I had a fun time with it. While it's not one that will stick with me, it was fast paced, easy to read and undoubtedly entertaining.
June 1, 2026
Loved this book- Liz Lawson’s mysteries always keep me guessing! A perfect summer who-done-it that I could not put down
July 9, 2026
3.5 stars rounded down until GoodReads can get itself together and give us half stars.
April 22, 2026
It Happened One Murder by Liz Lawson is a fast-paced YA mystery that leans heavily into a locked-room style setup, but with a modern, slightly dramatic twist.
The story follows a group of teenagers stuck together during a storm, where tensions are already high and then a murder happens. What makes it engaging is how quickly suspicion spreads. Everyone has something to hide, and the author keeps shifting your perspective, making you question each character at some point.
One of the strongest parts of the book is the pacing. It doesn’t drag and you’re constantly getting new clues, secrets, or twists, which makes it hard to put down. The atmosphere is also well done; the isolation and unease feel very real, almost like a classic whodunit but with teenage dynamics layered on top.
That said, the characters can feel a bit familiar if you’ve read a lot of YA thrillers - the popular one, the outsider, the one with secrets, etc. Some twists are predictable, but a few still manage to surprise you.
Overall, it’s a fun, easy-to-read mystery. Not overly complex, but very entertaining if you want something quick, suspenseful, and slightly dramatic without being too heavy.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
The story follows a group of teenagers stuck together during a storm, where tensions are already high and then a murder happens. What makes it engaging is how quickly suspicion spreads. Everyone has something to hide, and the author keeps shifting your perspective, making you question each character at some point.
One of the strongest parts of the book is the pacing. It doesn’t drag and you’re constantly getting new clues, secrets, or twists, which makes it hard to put down. The atmosphere is also well done; the isolation and unease feel very real, almost like a classic whodunit but with teenage dynamics layered on top.
That said, the characters can feel a bit familiar if you’ve read a lot of YA thrillers - the popular one, the outsider, the one with secrets, etc. Some twists are predictable, but a few still manage to surprise you.
Overall, it’s a fun, easy-to-read mystery. Not overly complex, but very entertaining if you want something quick, suspenseful, and slightly dramatic without being too heavy.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 435 reviews