What do you think?
Rate this book
Kill the Puckers
Not yet published
Expected 31 Mar 26Alyssa Reed has always been a problem solver and a fan of the long con. So, when the justice system fails her best friend, Alyssa takes it upon herself to set things right. And as far as Alyssa is concerned, setting things right means killing the hockey players who assaulted her friend.
There’s just a minor problem, and it’s not means or motive. It’s opportunity and access. But when Alyssa snags a date with the team’s head coach, Mark Eriksson—after stalking him for weeks, shh!—access to the team may no longer be a barrier to entry. At least, not if she can convince Mark she’s serious about him.
When hockey players start dropping like flies and Mark becomes increasingly suspicious, Alyssa has to decide if it’s just great sex that makes her want to trust Mark or if her feelings for him have outlived the long con and evolved into something more than a means to an end.
There’s just a minor problem, and it’s not means or motive. It’s opportunity and access. But when Alyssa snags a date with the team’s head coach, Mark Eriksson—after stalking him for weeks, shh!—access to the team may no longer be a barrier to entry. At least, not if she can convince Mark she’s serious about him.
When hockey players start dropping like flies and Mark becomes increasingly suspicious, Alyssa has to decide if it’s just great sex that makes her want to trust Mark or if her feelings for him have outlived the long con and evolved into something more than a means to an end.
- GenresDark RomanceSportsHockey
345 pages, Kindle Edition
Expected publication March 31, 2026
18 people are currently reading
115 people want to read
About the author
Sam Evans
4 books30 followersSam Evans has lived all over the US but currently resides in the upper midwest. She’s a software engineer by day, but letting her imagination run wild is her full-time occupation. She lives with her partner, a high-strung border collie, and an insane kelpie. She routinely drinks too much coffee and gets too little sleep.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 176 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
promising young woman with a happy end
and lots of fucking
and her bf is actually a good guy
also I can't stop listening to the playlist
and lots of fucking
and her bf is actually a good guy
also I can't stop listening to the playlist
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (4.5★)
You know how sometimes you just need junk food for the brain? Something fast, dramatic and satisfying? Yeah… this book was that for me.
The premise alone sold it: Alyssa decides that if the justice system won’t punish the hockey players who assaulted her best friend, she will. And honestly? I was there for it.
I love how loyal was Alyssa to her best friend and how committed she was to her mission. Was every situation 100% believable? Maybe not. Did I care? Absolutely not.
Enter Coach Mark. The romance definitely added some spice (thank you very much). It’s not necessarily super dark romance territory, but the dynamic worked for me and added a fun tension to the revenge plot.
If you’re expecting a heavy hockey story, though, this isn’t really it. Hockey mostly exists in the background, we do have maybe a few scenes related to it, but it doesn't take over the revenge plot.
Overall, this was fast-paced, messy and ridiculously bingeable. Exactly what I needed at the moment.
hank you to NetGalley and Super Gravity Press for the ARC.
You know how sometimes you just need junk food for the brain? Something fast, dramatic and satisfying? Yeah… this book was that for me.
The premise alone sold it: Alyssa decides that if the justice system won’t punish the hockey players who assaulted her best friend, she will. And honestly? I was there for it.
I love how loyal was Alyssa to her best friend and how committed she was to her mission. Was every situation 100% believable? Maybe not. Did I care? Absolutely not.
Enter Coach Mark. The romance definitely added some spice (thank you very much). It’s not necessarily super dark romance territory, but the dynamic worked for me and added a fun tension to the revenge plot.
If you’re expecting a heavy hockey story, though, this isn’t really it. Hockey mostly exists in the background, we do have maybe a few scenes related to it, but it doesn't take over the revenge plot.
Overall, this was fast-paced, messy and ridiculously bingeable. Exactly what I needed at the moment.
hank you to NetGalley and Super Gravity Press for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC review:
Dark rom-com might be one of my absolut favorite genres! The combination of romance (and spice), banter, dark themes, morally grey characters and action packed storyline just works for me!
Dark rom-com might be one of my absolut favorite genres! The combination of romance (and spice), banter, dark themes, morally grey characters and action packed storyline just works for me!
February 8, 2026
4.5 ⭐️ rounded
It gives me Black Sheep by Alexa Harlowe and Brynne Weaver Vibes.
I really like Alyssa trying to protect who she sees as her sister in a morally grey way, when the way we are often told is correct and just, fails them. I think most ask what if and don’t act. So, I enjoyed a story where they did.
I felt a little sorry for Mark at first. Then I didn’t. I liked that hints were dropped as the story progressed but didn’t outright say anything about Mark’s thoughts.
And the situation at the end earns Mark a Star ⭐️.
I’d read other books by Sam, I’d read more if there were others in the series.
Ps. I really like and appreciate the afterword.
It gives me Black Sheep by Alexa Harlowe and Brynne Weaver Vibes.
I really like Alyssa trying to protect who she sees as her sister in a morally grey way, when the way we are often told is correct and just, fails them. I think most ask what if and don’t act. So, I enjoyed a story where they did.
I felt a little sorry for Mark at first. Then I didn’t. I liked that hints were dropped as the story progressed but didn’t outright say anything about Mark’s thoughts.
And the situation at the end earns Mark a Star ⭐️.
I’d read other books by Sam, I’d read more if there were others in the series.
Ps. I really like and appreciate the afterword.
Review of advance copy received from Author
What a sensational read!
Alyssa is everything you could want from a strong FMC. She's smart, she's deadly and most importantly, she doesn't need a man to save her. I couldn't put this book down, the plot was incredibly strong , the characters were so real (you loved some & you HATED some) and the spice was spicy 🔥
Sam Evans, this book is a resounding triumph and you've highlighted an epidemic within sports that shouldn't exist. I applaud you and your voice 👏
Alyssa is everything you could want from a strong FMC. She's smart, she's deadly and most importantly, she doesn't need a man to save her. I couldn't put this book down, the plot was incredibly strong , the characters were so real (you loved some & you HATED some) and the spice was spicy 🔥
Sam Evans, this book is a resounding triumph and you've highlighted an epidemic within sports that shouldn't exist. I applaud you and your voice 👏
February 1, 2026
“You fell for a mark named Mark.”
Alyssa Reed has always been a problem solver and a fan of the long con. So, when the justice system fails her best friend, Alyssa takes it upon herself to set things right. And as far as Alyssa is concerned, setting things right means killing the hockey players who assaulted her friend.
Kill the Puckers was an unhinged, woman seeking rightful revenge on behalf of her best friend, dark romance that was pleasant as hell.
Alyssa was a strong FMC and I liked her character very much. She was unapologetically real and knew what needed to be done to get her best friend the justice Katie deserved. She just wanted bad men to pay and honestly I couldn’t help but root for her. Her anger was raw and real and that made her actions just that much more sweet to witness. She planned, she had help from a side character, Vaughn, and did whatever she needed to do to get the job done. She honestly thought her revenge plan would be easy enough yet she wasn’t anticipating Mark, our MMC.
Mark was an exceptional MMC and I think him and Alyssa fit so well together. They weren’t overly lovey-dovey but you could still feel their chemistry. Their relationship was enjoyable to see unfold. It had me laughing because their love language was shit talking each other (Alyssa was the queen of this). Watching Alyssa go from seeing Mark as just a means to an end to then see her falling for the mark, well… it was beautiful to read about. I do wish their romance delved a bit deeper. I feel like we just got the tip of the iceberg of the romance that AlyssaMark could’ve really been. But I do take into consideration that this book focused a bit more on the revenge than the romance.
This book easily held my interest throughout and it even had me feeling nerves while we read about each kill. I was intrigued and wondering if Alyssa was going to go through with this kill and if or when she would get caught. I think this book focused more on the revenge killing plot but the romance throughout it was definitely enough for romance readers to enjoy. Sam Evans did a remarkable job on romance, revenge and even more serious topics while also not sensationalizing sexual assault.
Overall, I give this book a 4/5 stars.
Thank you Super Gravity Press LLC for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Alyssa Reed has always been a problem solver and a fan of the long con. So, when the justice system fails her best friend, Alyssa takes it upon herself to set things right. And as far as Alyssa is concerned, setting things right means killing the hockey players who assaulted her friend.
Kill the Puckers was an unhinged, woman seeking rightful revenge on behalf of her best friend, dark romance that was pleasant as hell.
Alyssa was a strong FMC and I liked her character very much. She was unapologetically real and knew what needed to be done to get her best friend the justice Katie deserved. She just wanted bad men to pay and honestly I couldn’t help but root for her. Her anger was raw and real and that made her actions just that much more sweet to witness. She planned, she had help from a side character, Vaughn, and did whatever she needed to do to get the job done. She honestly thought her revenge plan would be easy enough yet she wasn’t anticipating Mark, our MMC.
Mark was an exceptional MMC and I think him and Alyssa fit so well together. They weren’t overly lovey-dovey but you could still feel their chemistry. Their relationship was enjoyable to see unfold. It had me laughing because their love language was shit talking each other (Alyssa was the queen of this). Watching Alyssa go from seeing Mark as just a means to an end to then see her falling for the mark, well… it was beautiful to read about. I do wish their romance delved a bit deeper. I feel like we just got the tip of the iceberg of the romance that AlyssaMark could’ve really been. But I do take into consideration that this book focused a bit more on the revenge than the romance.
This book easily held my interest throughout and it even had me feeling nerves while we read about each kill. I was intrigued and wondering if Alyssa was going to go through with this kill and if or when she would get caught. I think this book focused more on the revenge killing plot but the romance throughout it was definitely enough for romance readers to enjoy. Sam Evans did a remarkable job on romance, revenge and even more serious topics while also not sensationalizing sexual assault.
Overall, I give this book a 4/5 stars.
Thank you Super Gravity Press LLC for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC Review • KILL THE PUCKERS by Sam Evans
My second ARC of the year and WOW… this one is a full blown 10/10 obsession.
This book is sexy, thrilling, funny, razor sharp, nerve wracking, and completely impossible to put down.
My only regret?
Reading it too fast.
Alyssa Reed is a master strategist and lifelong problem solver. When the justice system fails her best friend and cousin, she takes matters into her own hands. Justice, in her mind, means eliminating the hockey players responsible for the assault permanently.
The problem isn’t motive or method. It’s access.
That problem disappears when she lands a date with Mark Eriksson, the team’s head coach, after some very deliberate maneuvering. Suddenly, the long con is in motion.
Mark and Alyssa’s chemistry is INSANE.
It practically bleeds off the page.
You know when a romance just hits, when the tension, the dialogue, the intimacy, the connection all feel electric and real? That’s this book.
Being inside Alyssa’s head, her rage, humor, and determination, makes this story feel visceral and addictive.
If you love dark romance with witty banter, laugh out loud moments, and a heroine fueled by righteous fury, this will own you.
Think
🖤 Jessica Jones
🖤 Killing Eve
🖤 Dead to Me
🖤 Santa Clarita Diet
And if you loved Lights Out or Butcher & Blackbird, you will one million percent devour this.
Feminine rage has never been hotter.
📅 Mark your calendars for March 31, 2026.
Trust me, you are going to want this one on release day.
My second ARC of the year and WOW… this one is a full blown 10/10 obsession.
This book is sexy, thrilling, funny, razor sharp, nerve wracking, and completely impossible to put down.
My only regret?
Reading it too fast.
Alyssa Reed is a master strategist and lifelong problem solver. When the justice system fails her best friend and cousin, she takes matters into her own hands. Justice, in her mind, means eliminating the hockey players responsible for the assault permanently.
The problem isn’t motive or method. It’s access.
That problem disappears when she lands a date with Mark Eriksson, the team’s head coach, after some very deliberate maneuvering. Suddenly, the long con is in motion.
Mark and Alyssa’s chemistry is INSANE.
It practically bleeds off the page.
You know when a romance just hits, when the tension, the dialogue, the intimacy, the connection all feel electric and real? That’s this book.
Being inside Alyssa’s head, her rage, humor, and determination, makes this story feel visceral and addictive.
If you love dark romance with witty banter, laugh out loud moments, and a heroine fueled by righteous fury, this will own you.
Think
🖤 Jessica Jones
🖤 Killing Eve
🖤 Dead to Me
🖤 Santa Clarita Diet
And if you loved Lights Out or Butcher & Blackbird, you will one million percent devour this.
Feminine rage has never been hotter.
📅 Mark your calendars for March 31, 2026.
Trust me, you are going to want this one on release day.
Did not finish
March 21, 2026DNF for the ARC of Kill the Puckers
I decided to DNF this book last night after putting it down a couple of times before. At first, I couldn’t quite figure out why it wasn’t working for me, but then it suddenly clicked.
For me, the story felt like it was missing a certain emotional depth.
The parts that consist of dialogue are, for about 90%, focused on the literal exchange of words, with little to no emotional impact, internal thoughts, or body language woven in. Because of that, I sometimes struggled to fully grasp what the characters were feeling, which made it harder for me to connect with them.
The plot itself is actually fun and has a lot of potential, but the execution didn’t fully draw me in. Some scenes felt a bit more descriptive than immersive, so instead of experiencing the emotions alongside the characters, it felt like I was being told what was happening from a distance.
The smut, while definitely hot, also felt a bit similar in that sense. I missed some emotional buildup or connection, which would have made those moments land stronger for me.
The writing style, with frequent use of “he said,” “she said,” and similar tags, occasionally came across as a bit repetitive, which added to the sense of distance I felt while reading.
Overall, this book just didn’t fully click for me, but I can see how it might work better for readers who enjoy more straight forward storytelling.
I decided to DNF this book last night after putting it down a couple of times before. At first, I couldn’t quite figure out why it wasn’t working for me, but then it suddenly clicked.
For me, the story felt like it was missing a certain emotional depth.
The parts that consist of dialogue are, for about 90%, focused on the literal exchange of words, with little to no emotional impact, internal thoughts, or body language woven in. Because of that, I sometimes struggled to fully grasp what the characters were feeling, which made it harder for me to connect with them.
The plot itself is actually fun and has a lot of potential, but the execution didn’t fully draw me in. Some scenes felt a bit more descriptive than immersive, so instead of experiencing the emotions alongside the characters, it felt like I was being told what was happening from a distance.
The smut, while definitely hot, also felt a bit similar in that sense. I missed some emotional buildup or connection, which would have made those moments land stronger for me.
The writing style, with frequent use of “he said,” “she said,” and similar tags, occasionally came across as a bit repetitive, which added to the sense of distance I felt while reading.
Overall, this book just didn’t fully click for me, but I can see how it might work better for readers who enjoy more straight forward storytelling.
February 15, 2026
Kill the Puckers by Sam Evans ARC Review
“You fell for a mark named Mark”
5/5 stars
Kill the Puckers was a fantastic read overall. I thoroughly enjoyed every second and found it difficult to put down. I went into this book expecting a fun, lighthearted, spicy read and while it definitely delivers it also was so emotionally engaging and powerful.
The story follows Alyssa, who takes it upon herself to get revenge on a group of hockey players that assaulted her cousin when the justice system failed to deliver.
What really sets this story apart is Alyssa’s need to right a wrong. Her determination fuels the emotional core of this book and despite unaliving people she is someone you root for from the very first chapter. She’s strong, vulnerable, compassionate and determined. Watching her refuse to back down even when it would have been easier to stay quiet, gave the story real substance.
The chemistry and romance between Alyssa and Mark is intense and passionate, it never felt as if it overshadowed or took away from the main plot. Mark is a fantastic character, he’s layered, supportive and actually invested in Alyssa and what she’s fighting for. He never tries to overpower her fight or get her to stop, instead he stands beside her. The spice between the two is absolutely delicious and so well written, no notes at all.
Thank you to NetGalley and the Author for allowing me to read this as an ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
February 16, 2026
This book was SO good.
Thank you, Netgalley, for the ARC!
TW:
R*pe
Gruesome Violence (on page)
Kidnapping
Arson
Stalking
I like the “ripped from the headlines” aspect of this story, because no one should forget what those 5 players in Canada (*allegedly) did to that 20 y/o woman. Unfortunately this story starts out in a similar fashion, with all 5 being acquitted. That brings us our FMC, Dr. Reed. I loved her justice!
There were so many genuinely hilarious parts to this story, but seeing the survivor push through the terror and working to take back control of her life was beautiful, even if we only see it in small pieces.
Our MMC, Mark, seemed like a real jackass at first but I quickly grew to love their insane banter.
The best, sneakiest part of the story though? The arena where the Portland Black Bears play, is Tofana Arena. As in Giulia Tofana, the notorious poison dealer of 1600’s Italy, who worked with women all across the county to rid themselves of their abusive husbands. While it’s possible that’s incidental… I doubt it. The writing was so good and so clever!
The one thing that made this a 4.97 for me what the reference about 250 pages in that they had only been together 1.5 months when 3 players had died when it had to have been at least two months. The timing was just off.
Thank you, Netgalley, for the ARC!
TW:
R*pe
Gruesome Violence (on page)
Kidnapping
Arson
Stalking
I like the “ripped from the headlines” aspect of this story, because no one should forget what those 5 players in Canada (*allegedly) did to that 20 y/o woman. Unfortunately this story starts out in a similar fashion, with all 5 being acquitted. That brings us our FMC, Dr. Reed. I loved her justice!
There were so many genuinely hilarious parts to this story, but seeing the survivor push through the terror and working to take back control of her life was beautiful, even if we only see it in small pieces.
Our MMC, Mark, seemed like a real jackass at first but I quickly grew to love their insane banter.
The best, sneakiest part of the story though? The arena where the Portland Black Bears play, is Tofana Arena. As in Giulia Tofana, the notorious poison dealer of 1600’s Italy, who worked with women all across the county to rid themselves of their abusive husbands. While it’s possible that’s incidental… I doubt it. The writing was so good and so clever!
The one thing that made this a 4.97 for me what the reference about 250 pages in that they had only been together 1.5 months when 3 players had died when it had to have been at least two months. The timing was just off.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC Review — Spoiler Free
Kill the Puckers by Sam Evans is a dark, revenge-driven story set against a hockey backdrop — and it leans far more into plot than traditional romance.
From the opening chapters, this book establishes a high-stakes premise and maintains strong forward momentum throughout. The pacing is what hooked me; I kept reading because I genuinely needed to see how everything would unfold. The tension builds steadily, and the morally gray direction is fully committed.
While the romance is present — and there are spicy moments early on — it takes a secondary role to the larger storyline. For a book labeled “dark hockey romance,” the romantic development felt lighter than expected. The connection between the FMC and the head coach functions more as a ride-or-die partnership formed under pressure rather than a deeply explored emotional arc.
That said, I appreciated that the story didn’t sacrifice its plot intensity in favor of romance beats. This reads more like a revenge thriller with romantic elements than a romance-forward sports novel.
If you enjoy morally complex characters, escalating stakes, and dark anti-hero energy, this will keep you turning pages. Just go in knowing the plot is the true driver here. With that being said, I still really enjoy this book. It was a quick read, and it kept me engaged which is sometimes hard to do.
Thank you to the author for the ARC!
Kill the Puckers by Sam Evans is a dark, revenge-driven story set against a hockey backdrop — and it leans far more into plot than traditional romance.
From the opening chapters, this book establishes a high-stakes premise and maintains strong forward momentum throughout. The pacing is what hooked me; I kept reading because I genuinely needed to see how everything would unfold. The tension builds steadily, and the morally gray direction is fully committed.
While the romance is present — and there are spicy moments early on — it takes a secondary role to the larger storyline. For a book labeled “dark hockey romance,” the romantic development felt lighter than expected. The connection between the FMC and the head coach functions more as a ride-or-die partnership formed under pressure rather than a deeply explored emotional arc.
That said, I appreciated that the story didn’t sacrifice its plot intensity in favor of romance beats. This reads more like a revenge thriller with romantic elements than a romance-forward sports novel.
If you enjoy morally complex characters, escalating stakes, and dark anti-hero energy, this will keep you turning pages. Just go in knowing the plot is the true driver here. With that being said, I still really enjoy this book. It was a quick read, and it kept me engaged which is sometimes hard to do.
Thank you to the author for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you Super Gravity press for the ARC.
'Kill the Puckers' by Sam Evans is a dark hockey romance novel. It is a thriller filled with twists and turns. It starts off with a heavy theme and the central plot is revenge taken by FMC. It is well paced and the narrative style is mind-blowing.
The character of 'Alyssa Reed' is brave, Independent, Fierce, practical and goal driven. She is 'NOT A DAMSEL IN DISTRESS' which makes her more interesting.She was intelligent and calculative. There were scenes where I was cheering for her and was just in awe of her thinking capabilities. Her revenge plan was just perfect and to the point. She is one of the strong FMCs I have read so far and I would love to have a intelligence like her.
The chemistry between Mark and Alyssa was just terrific and the relationship between them was mature and understanding. Their First meeting till the last scene in the book I loved every moment between them.
The relationship dynamic between Alyssa and Vaughn was just amazing and I loved his character a lot. Overall this story did create a lot of awareness for me and was eye-opening. I did learn many new things and unfortunately some dark realities of society. My heart did break for the character 'Katie' and I did enjoy the whole revenge plot. I hope no one goes through such trauma but yes this is the reality of many people out there. Thank you for writing this book and creating awareness.
'Kill the Puckers' by Sam Evans is a dark hockey romance novel. It is a thriller filled with twists and turns. It starts off with a heavy theme and the central plot is revenge taken by FMC. It is well paced and the narrative style is mind-blowing.
The character of 'Alyssa Reed' is brave, Independent, Fierce, practical and goal driven. She is 'NOT A DAMSEL IN DISTRESS' which makes her more interesting.She was intelligent and calculative. There were scenes where I was cheering for her and was just in awe of her thinking capabilities. Her revenge plan was just perfect and to the point. She is one of the strong FMCs I have read so far and I would love to have a intelligence like her.
The chemistry between Mark and Alyssa was just terrific and the relationship between them was mature and understanding. Their First meeting till the last scene in the book I loved every moment between them.
The relationship dynamic between Alyssa and Vaughn was just amazing and I loved his character a lot. Overall this story did create a lot of awareness for me and was eye-opening. I did learn many new things and unfortunately some dark realities of society. My heart did break for the character 'Katie' and I did enjoy the whole revenge plot. I hope no one goes through such trauma but yes this is the reality of many people out there. Thank you for writing this book and creating awareness.
March 4, 2026
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
ARC Review: Wow, what a fantastic read and I was hooked from the first chapter!
We follow Alyssa who takes it upon herself to seek revenge when the justice system fails her cousin. If it means killing hockey players, then so be it! After stalking (sshh!) and daring the head coach Mark, they start to drop like flies (sorry not sorry!). As Mark becomes suspicious, will Alyssa’s plans come to fruition and can she trust him?
It is clear from the offset that this books does not shy away from the terrible injustice Alyssa’s cousin recieved and the lasting impact this has on her. The afterword is extremely powerful and I encourage all readers to research further.
“How many hockey-douchebags can you kill before they realise they’re an endangered species?”.
The plot is fast paced and highly entertaining. I loved the dynamic between Alyssa and Mark - their chemistry was off the charts! The fun, sarcastic dialogue between both characters really made this an enjoyable read. I also appreciated how intelligent Alyssa was and how every little detail was meticulously thought about to make it believable.
As the plot progresses it was great to see characters clocking on to what was happening and the confrontation between Alyssa and Garret was nail biting!
This book is perfect for fans of Butcher & Blackbird and Lights Out. I highly recommend.
ARC Review: Wow, what a fantastic read and I was hooked from the first chapter!
We follow Alyssa who takes it upon herself to seek revenge when the justice system fails her cousin. If it means killing hockey players, then so be it! After stalking (sshh!) and daring the head coach Mark, they start to drop like flies (sorry not sorry!). As Mark becomes suspicious, will Alyssa’s plans come to fruition and can she trust him?
It is clear from the offset that this books does not shy away from the terrible injustice Alyssa’s cousin recieved and the lasting impact this has on her. The afterword is extremely powerful and I encourage all readers to research further.
“How many hockey-douchebags can you kill before they realise they’re an endangered species?”.
The plot is fast paced and highly entertaining. I loved the dynamic between Alyssa and Mark - their chemistry was off the charts! The fun, sarcastic dialogue between both characters really made this an enjoyable read. I also appreciated how intelligent Alyssa was and how every little detail was meticulously thought about to make it believable.
As the plot progresses it was great to see characters clocking on to what was happening and the confrontation between Alyssa and Garret was nail biting!
This book is perfect for fans of Butcher & Blackbird and Lights Out. I highly recommend.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I rate this 4 and a half stars.
This book is about Alyssa's cousin Katie, who is raped by 5 hockey players.
She goes to the police, does all the things your meant to do, and it goes to court.
And they walk free.
So Alyssa sets off to right that wrong, and make them pay.
She does this in a number of creative and well planned out ways... mostly.
She begins with setting up a honey trap, with someone who works with the team so she has access...and whats better then the coach?
What she didn't expect was finding out this dude is kinda nice and she likes him. Alot.
This book has alot of spice, talk of rape, and lots of murder- but thats ok cos those puckers deserve it.
Now, this book is funny. I laughed out loud at least 3 times during the first few chapters. There was this scene where Alyssa has followed her potential in to the team to a bookstore, and what book did he have under his arm? Only one of the author's actual other books! 😂
The writing style was funny and well thought out.
If you like a dark romance with an empowered FMC who teaches those bad guys a lesson, then this is the book for you.
This book is about Alyssa's cousin Katie, who is raped by 5 hockey players.
She goes to the police, does all the things your meant to do, and it goes to court.
And they walk free.
So Alyssa sets off to right that wrong, and make them pay.
She does this in a number of creative and well planned out ways... mostly.
She begins with setting up a honey trap, with someone who works with the team so she has access...and whats better then the coach?
What she didn't expect was finding out this dude is kinda nice and she likes him. Alot.
This book has alot of spice, talk of rape, and lots of murder- but thats ok cos those puckers deserve it.
Now, this book is funny. I laughed out loud at least 3 times during the first few chapters. There was this scene where Alyssa has followed her potential in to the team to a bookstore, and what book did he have under his arm? Only one of the author's actual other books! 😂
The writing style was funny and well thought out.
If you like a dark romance with an empowered FMC who teaches those bad guys a lesson, then this is the book for you.
March 15, 2026
3.5/5 ✨
Review of Advance Copy Received from NetGalley
You know what they say...you attract more bees with honey. In this case, a honeytrap.
I love a GSD (get s**t done) woman, and our FMC Alyssa has taken GSD to another level.
After the justice system fails to convict the Black Bear players who assaulted her cousin, Alyssa takes it upon herself to find justice. How? A honeytrap, with the very available, very attractive head coach of the Black Bears. But what Alyssa didn’t think about, was what to do when she fell in love with him.
This was such a fun read, Alyssa and Mark are actually so made for each other, and I loved their chemistry. The concept of this book was so original, and it was a good change of pace to have a strong FMC in a dark romance book.
I felt the ending of this story was just a bit too predictable, however it does not take away from the overall enjoyment of finishing the book. I mean, although predictable I was still a little gagged at the 80% mark.
Tropes
~ Hockey Coach x Psychiatrist
~ Revenge Plot
~ Honey Trap
A special thank you to Sam Evans, Victory Editing, and NetGalley for this ARC.
Review of Advance Copy Received from NetGalley
You know what they say...you attract more bees with honey. In this case, a honeytrap.
I love a GSD (get s**t done) woman, and our FMC Alyssa has taken GSD to another level.
After the justice system fails to convict the Black Bear players who assaulted her cousin, Alyssa takes it upon herself to find justice. How? A honeytrap, with the very available, very attractive head coach of the Black Bears. But what Alyssa didn’t think about, was what to do when she fell in love with him.
This was such a fun read, Alyssa and Mark are actually so made for each other, and I loved their chemistry. The concept of this book was so original, and it was a good change of pace to have a strong FMC in a dark romance book.
I felt the ending of this story was just a bit too predictable, however it does not take away from the overall enjoyment of finishing the book. I mean, although predictable I was still a little gagged at the 80% mark.
Tropes
~ Hockey Coach x Psychiatrist
~ Revenge Plot
~ Honey Trap
A special thank you to Sam Evans, Victory Editing, and NetGalley for this ARC.
February 21, 2026
Kill the Puckers - Sam Evans
I love this author’s books. I love the way they write, smart and strong female main characters. I devoured this book over a weekend. The writing is phenomenal. I love how strong Katie is. I also really enjoyed Alyssa as well. And how she wanted revenge for not just Katie, but the other women as well. I think the whole family dynamic between Katie, Alyssa, their parents, and Vaughn are just so interesting. The chemistry between Alyssa and Mark was also very phenomenal. I adore books that have a good for her vibe to them and that are filled to the brim with feminine rage and power. This was such a great book. I can’t wait to read what this author writes next.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / Out of 5 Stars ⭐️
🌶️ / Spice Rating ☀️
# of Pages 🌙 345 pages
Release Date 🌟 3/31/26
Format 💫 Gifted Digital Copy
Series 🌙 Unknown/Not Applicable
Genre/Tropes ✨ dark romance, hockey romance, good for her vibes, psychiatrist FMC, feminine rage
Favorite Character ☀️ Katie & Alyssa
Favorite Line 🌟 “It’s Doctor Reed,”
“I prefer reading my porn to watching it.”
‘How many hockey-douchebags can you kill before they realize they’re an endangered species?’
I love this author’s books. I love the way they write, smart and strong female main characters. I devoured this book over a weekend. The writing is phenomenal. I love how strong Katie is. I also really enjoyed Alyssa as well. And how she wanted revenge for not just Katie, but the other women as well. I think the whole family dynamic between Katie, Alyssa, their parents, and Vaughn are just so interesting. The chemistry between Alyssa and Mark was also very phenomenal. I adore books that have a good for her vibe to them and that are filled to the brim with feminine rage and power. This was such a great book. I can’t wait to read what this author writes next.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / Out of 5 Stars ⭐️
🌶️ / Spice Rating ☀️
# of Pages 🌙 345 pages
Release Date 🌟 3/31/26
Format 💫 Gifted Digital Copy
Series 🌙 Unknown/Not Applicable
Genre/Tropes ✨ dark romance, hockey romance, good for her vibes, psychiatrist FMC, feminine rage
Favorite Character ☀️ Katie & Alyssa
Favorite Line 🌟 “It’s Doctor Reed,”
“I prefer reading my porn to watching it.”
‘How many hockey-douchebags can you kill before they realize they’re an endangered species?’
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I rated Kill The Puckers by Sam Evans ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4 stars).
Although it’s marketed as a dark hockey romance, I personally felt it leaned much more towards a thriller with romantic elements — and despite the hockey label, there isn’t actually much (if any) hockey content woven into the story itself. So if you’re going in expecting lots of on-ice action, you might be surprised.
That said, I really enjoyed the writing style. It flowed well, kept me engaged, and had enough tension to keep the pages turning. While I wouldn’t personally class it as a “dark romance,” I would definitely recommend readers check the trigger warnings beforehand, as there are themes that could be heavy for some.
One of the strongest aspects for me was the characters. I genuinely liked them and appreciated seeing their development throughout the book. Their growth felt intentional and added depth to the overall story.
I’d absolutely read a second book — especially if it continues from where this one left off. There’s definitely room for more, and I’d love to see what happens next.
Although it’s marketed as a dark hockey romance, I personally felt it leaned much more towards a thriller with romantic elements — and despite the hockey label, there isn’t actually much (if any) hockey content woven into the story itself. So if you’re going in expecting lots of on-ice action, you might be surprised.
That said, I really enjoyed the writing style. It flowed well, kept me engaged, and had enough tension to keep the pages turning. While I wouldn’t personally class it as a “dark romance,” I would definitely recommend readers check the trigger warnings beforehand, as there are themes that could be heavy for some.
One of the strongest aspects for me was the characters. I genuinely liked them and appreciated seeing their development throughout the book. Their growth felt intentional and added depth to the overall story.
I’d absolutely read a second book — especially if it continues from where this one left off. There’s definitely room for more, and I’d love to see what happens next.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC REVIEW:
☠️Fake Dating
🖤He falls first
☠️Stalking
🖤Feminine Rage
☠️Murder
"you fell for a mark named Mark"
Kill the Puckers is a dark hockey romance with comedy, murder and a lot of sex (It literally says so in the trigger warnings)
It follows the story of Alyssa Reed psychiatrist who is hell bent on getting revenge for her cousin and the only way to do that is to fake date the head coach of the hockey thats players ruined her cousins life. Only thing she did not anticipate is: falling in love.
My thoughts:
OMG!!! when I say I loved this book, i loved it so much I devoured it in under 24 hours. the sarcasm between the MFC and MMC was brilliant, the flirting was amazing and don't get me started on the sex because: DAMN!!! It had me blushing.
Sam Evens has written an extraordinary dark romance that is something you need to experience for yourselves.
Thank you netgalley, Sam Evans for the ARC!!
☠️Fake Dating
🖤He falls first
☠️Stalking
🖤Feminine Rage
☠️Murder
"you fell for a mark named Mark"
Kill the Puckers is a dark hockey romance with comedy, murder and a lot of sex (It literally says so in the trigger warnings)
It follows the story of Alyssa Reed psychiatrist who is hell bent on getting revenge for her cousin and the only way to do that is to fake date the head coach of the hockey thats players ruined her cousins life. Only thing she did not anticipate is: falling in love.
My thoughts:
OMG!!! when I say I loved this book, i loved it so much I devoured it in under 24 hours. the sarcasm between the MFC and MMC was brilliant, the flirting was amazing and don't get me started on the sex because: DAMN!!! It had me blushing.
Sam Evens has written an extraordinary dark romance that is something you need to experience for yourselves.
Thank you netgalley, Sam Evans for the ARC!!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
If you love female-revenge stories like Promising Young Women or The Mindfck Series this one is absolutely for you.
Our FMC is everything I want to be strong, unapologtically confident, and honestly just the right amount of unhinged. Love that for her 👑
When her cousin is failed by the justice system, she decides to take matters into her own hands and make the men who hurt her pay. And yes, the strategic dating of a certain hockey coach to gain access to them? Reckless, but ruthless. 👏
For everyone who speaks up despite the odds
The dedication is already devastating, but the author’s note revealing that Sam Evans was inspired by real events gives everything an added weight. The grief, fury and relentless pursuit of accountabillity it all lands with a sobering sense of reality that lingers well after the final page
Our FMC is everything I want to be strong, unapologtically confident, and honestly just the right amount of unhinged. Love that for her 👑
When her cousin is failed by the justice system, she decides to take matters into her own hands and make the men who hurt her pay. And yes, the strategic dating of a certain hockey coach to gain access to them? Reckless, but ruthless. 👏
For everyone who speaks up despite the odds
The dedication is already devastating, but the author’s note revealing that Sam Evans was inspired by real events gives everything an added weight. The grief, fury and relentless pursuit of accountabillity it all lands with a sobering sense of reality that lingers well after the final page
February 26, 2026
First, I want to thank Sam, victory editing, and NetGalley for the gift of this eARC. Now to the good stuff!!
This was a fun book and I enjoyed my time reading it. It started off with a dramatic courtroom scene and you met the feisty FMC with a mouth and sense of humor. She’s a career woman with a deep family history of trauma. The MMC is a golden retriever type but don’t get it twisted he will jump in and take care of business. This story flowed well and was descriptive displaying character connection and outlining backstories. It was comprehensive and detailed. I had lots of laughs throughout the book and could relate with the characters feelings. This book had spice deposited through and never felt over exaggerated. It’s a story of revenge and has suspenseful scenes. I LOVED the afterthought at the conclusion of this book and how it “closed open doors” so to speak. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is because I only rate 5 stars if I think it will be a reread one day. Otherwise, this is a witty and fun ride of a story and I HIGHLY recommend this read!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
This was a fun book and I enjoyed my time reading it. It started off with a dramatic courtroom scene and you met the feisty FMC with a mouth and sense of humor. She’s a career woman with a deep family history of trauma. The MMC is a golden retriever type but don’t get it twisted he will jump in and take care of business. This story flowed well and was descriptive displaying character connection and outlining backstories. It was comprehensive and detailed. I had lots of laughs throughout the book and could relate with the characters feelings. This book had spice deposited through and never felt over exaggerated. It’s a story of revenge and has suspenseful scenes. I LOVED the afterthought at the conclusion of this book and how it “closed open doors” so to speak. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is because I only rate 5 stars if I think it will be a reread one day. Otherwise, this is a witty and fun ride of a story and I HIGHLY recommend this read!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
Review of advance copy received from Author
If the justice system has ever let you down I hope you find an Alyssa in your corner 🥰
Having watched this author take this from the inception of the idea through the writing journey I was delighted to see the final product and oh boy does it deliver on every promise and so much more.
Feminine rage at its peak fury awaits you in this magnificent show of how one woman can rid the world of scumbags. Alyssa takes on the 5 hockey players who raped her cousin and walked away scot free while unexpectedly falling for the man who was only supposed to be her gateway to vengeance.
The witty banter, ingenious methods of dispatching, and the spice were next level. This is not your typical sports romance but it combines the theme of hockey and dark romance with such ease.
Having watched this author take this from the inception of the idea through the writing journey I was delighted to see the final product and oh boy does it deliver on every promise and so much more.
Feminine rage at its peak fury awaits you in this magnificent show of how one woman can rid the world of scumbags. Alyssa takes on the 5 hockey players who raped her cousin and walked away scot free while unexpectedly falling for the man who was only supposed to be her gateway to vengeance.
The witty banter, ingenious methods of dispatching, and the spice were next level. This is not your typical sports romance but it combines the theme of hockey and dark romance with such ease.
February 18, 2026
We all fell for a mark named Mark with this one 😆
This book was a hilarious dark romance. I did not know that I needed a book with this level of femme fatale in my life. It seriously hit on all the marks I was looking for from the genre. It is not super dark as far as dark romance goes, so I would say it would be good for someone who wants to bridge from thriller to the dark romance genre.
The found family and banter are everything in this book - we all know how much love me both of those things in books. Definitely read the trigger warnings as this one is loaded up with a couple things that might make the normal person pause. I truly enjoyed the vigilante justice elements especially with what is going on right now - it is very cathartic to see a woman slaying troglodytes!
4.5 🌟 2.5 🌶️
This book was a hilarious dark romance. I did not know that I needed a book with this level of femme fatale in my life. It seriously hit on all the marks I was looking for from the genre. It is not super dark as far as dark romance goes, so I would say it would be good for someone who wants to bridge from thriller to the dark romance genre.
The found family and banter are everything in this book - we all know how much love me both of those things in books. Definitely read the trigger warnings as this one is loaded up with a couple things that might make the normal person pause. I truly enjoyed the vigilante justice elements especially with what is going on right now - it is very cathartic to see a woman slaying troglodytes!
4.5 🌟 2.5 🌶️
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC provided through Netgalley.
5/5 ✨
5/5 🌶️
I absolutely loved this book!! I'm always a huge fan of women getting revenge, especially on shitty duchebros. Couple that with hot as sin sex scenes and great characters and you've got a winner!
Alyssa is who I wish I could be in life and girlfriend gets shit D O N E! I loved her relationship with both Katie and Vaughn (side note I need a Vaughn and Marjorie prequel novella please!!) and her discovering she's capable of love and long term with Mark (who I did change to Nark just to save my imagination from picturing my father in law 😬)
The story had really good pacing and I genuinely couldn't put it down. The split between the relationship scenes with Mark and Alyssa carrying out the plots was perfect. I just kept needing to read one more chapter until I was up til 4 am. I'm very very excited for readers to get their hands on this and experience the sexy satisfaction of a bad bitch getting it done (and getting down 👀🥵)
5/5 ✨
5/5 🌶️
I absolutely loved this book!! I'm always a huge fan of women getting revenge, especially on shitty duchebros. Couple that with hot as sin sex scenes and great characters and you've got a winner!
Alyssa is who I wish I could be in life and girlfriend gets shit D O N E! I loved her relationship with both Katie and Vaughn (side note I need a Vaughn and Marjorie prequel novella please!!) and her discovering she's capable of love and long term with Mark (who I did change to Nark just to save my imagination from picturing my father in law 😬)
The story had really good pacing and I genuinely couldn't put it down. The split between the relationship scenes with Mark and Alyssa carrying out the plots was perfect. I just kept needing to read one more chapter until I was up til 4 am. I'm very very excited for readers to get their hands on this and experience the sexy satisfaction of a bad bitch getting it done (and getting down 👀🥵)
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Kill the Puckers was the perfect spicy, dark romance thriller I needed in my life. Alyssa’s problem solving skills may be questionable, but it was extremely satisfying watching her work.
The pacing was on point and kept me on edge the entire time. The found family aspect supporting her mission was just as fulfilling.
Added bonus? The spice was HOT. The tension was scorching and really pulled everything together for me.
Keep in mind that although this surrounds a hockey team, this is not solely a hockey romance book. Instead, this story delivers poetic justice after the justice system failed so many women.
Sam Evans delivers a perfect dark romance thriller that taps into the feminine rage within. It was a perfect quick, spicy read.
The pacing was on point and kept me on edge the entire time. The found family aspect supporting her mission was just as fulfilling.
Added bonus? The spice was HOT. The tension was scorching and really pulled everything together for me.
Keep in mind that although this surrounds a hockey team, this is not solely a hockey romance book. Instead, this story delivers poetic justice after the justice system failed so many women.
Sam Evans delivers a perfect dark romance thriller that taps into the feminine rage within. It was a perfect quick, spicy read.
February 20, 2026
First and foremost, thank you to NetGalley for this arc! Kill the Puckers was a solid 4.5 star read for me — think Dexter meets ice hockey, and you’re already halfway there.
This book is spicy, fun, and utterly entertaining. It’s shelved as dark romance, and while the dark elements are certainly present, I’d argue it also works beautifully as a dark comedy. The two tones balance each other surprisingly well and keep the pages turning.
I genuinely enjoyed the characters, found real satisfaction in how the plot unfolded, and appreciated the author’s afterword, which added a thoughtful finishing touch to the whole experience.
If you’re looking for something that’s equal parts thrilling and fun with a generous helping of heat, this one’s worth picking up.
This book is spicy, fun, and utterly entertaining. It’s shelved as dark romance, and while the dark elements are certainly present, I’d argue it also works beautifully as a dark comedy. The two tones balance each other surprisingly well and keep the pages turning.
I genuinely enjoyed the characters, found real satisfaction in how the plot unfolded, and appreciated the author’s afterword, which added a thoughtful finishing touch to the whole experience.
If you’re looking for something that’s equal parts thrilling and fun with a generous helping of heat, this one’s worth picking up.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
"Kill the Puckers" is not your standard sports romance book. It contains a powerful message for anyone who never received the justice they deserved. We follow along the main character, Alyssa, as she systematically removes the men that assaulted her cousin from this world. Alyssa ends up righting ths wrongs of a broken system, unexpectedly falls in love with her Mark and brings her own justice to the ones who deserve it.
An absolute fantastic read that I would recommend to anyone who loves bad ass women, great storytelling, and anyone who wants to see the bad guys get what they deserve.
An absolute fantastic read that I would recommend to anyone who loves bad ass women, great storytelling, and anyone who wants to see the bad guys get what they deserve.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This story follows Alyssa's plot for revenge after her cousins 5 r*ist get found not guilty for their part in Kates attack.
We follow Alyssa she picks her mark the head coach of the Hockey team, to get closer to the 5 men. We see her plan out her revenge using intel gathered by her daddy's best friend and put all her plans into action.
I enjoyed reading about justice being served, and the working out of all the plans.
The spice was in point. The pacing was perfect.
I loved that each time one of the men was eliminated we see the chains around Kate loosen.
I loved the push and pull between Alyssa and mark, and how in the end Mark didn't care what Alyssa had done.
Thank you to Sam Evans and Netgalley for a copy of this arc to review.
We follow Alyssa she picks her mark the head coach of the Hockey team, to get closer to the 5 men. We see her plan out her revenge using intel gathered by her daddy's best friend and put all her plans into action.
I enjoyed reading about justice being served, and the working out of all the plans.
The spice was in point. The pacing was perfect.
I loved that each time one of the men was eliminated we see the chains around Kate loosen.
I loved the push and pull between Alyssa and mark, and how in the end Mark didn't care what Alyssa had done.
Thank you to Sam Evans and Netgalley for a copy of this arc to review.
February 15, 2026
Netgalley Arc read
Kill the Puckers by Sam Evans completely surprised me in the best way possible. The storyline was engaging from the start, and the writing style made it incredibly easy to dive right in. The chemistry between the FMC and MMC? Absolutely top tier. I miss Alyssa and Mark already.
I especially appreciated the unapologetically strong female lead; it’s always refreshing to see a character who owns her power without hesitation. Overall, this was a compelling dark hockey romance that delivered on tension, character dynamics, and atmosphere. I’ll definitely be keeping Sam Evans on my repeat-author list. Honestly, who can resist a well-done dark hockey romance? I need more!
Thanks to Sam Evans for writing this gem
Kill the Puckers by Sam Evans completely surprised me in the best way possible. The storyline was engaging from the start, and the writing style made it incredibly easy to dive right in. The chemistry between the FMC and MMC? Absolutely top tier. I miss Alyssa and Mark already.
I especially appreciated the unapologetically strong female lead; it’s always refreshing to see a character who owns her power without hesitation. Overall, this was a compelling dark hockey romance that delivered on tension, character dynamics, and atmosphere. I’ll definitely be keeping Sam Evans on my repeat-author list. Honestly, who can resist a well-done dark hockey romance? I need more!
Thanks to Sam Evans for writing this gem
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I was hooked from the moment I started this book! You're thrown straight in with Alyssa (FMC) looking after her cousin who's fighting a rape trial against some hockey players. They're deemed not guilty, and Alyssa takes matters into her own hands.
This was a fast paced, spicy and intense read, that I loved every minute of. You're routing for Alyssa the whole time, and the MMC Mark is incredibly hot.
This was a fast paced, spicy and intense read, that I loved every minute of. You're routing for Alyssa the whole time, and the MMC Mark is incredibly hot.
March 8, 2026
What an insanely incredible book highlighting the lengths one person would go through in order to avenge their loved ones when the justice system fails them.
I absolutely devoured this book, it was addictive going on this journey with Alyssa as she plans her best course of action. Even the side characters (other than those 5) are extremely likeable. And Mark 🥵 that man knows exactly what he wants and tells Alyssa exactly how he wants it.
I absolutely devoured this book, it was addictive going on this journey with Alyssa as she plans her best course of action. Even the side characters (other than those 5) are extremely likeable. And Mark 🥵 that man knows exactly what he wants and tells Alyssa exactly how he wants it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 176 reviews