What do you think?
Rate this book
Death by Chocolate Mystery #9
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers
The townsfolk of Eastport, Maine, know the best place to satisfy their sweet tooth is at Jacobia “Jake” Tiptree and Ellie White’s bakery, the Chocolate Moose. But some people living in the island town have more sinister appetites…
As the sun sets on summer in Eastport, local celebrations are in full swing—and Jake and Ellie have their hands full supplying the most decadent of desserts for extended family gatherings, class reunions, and other catered events. The organizers for Eastport High School’s Class of ’86 reunion thought it would be fun for former schoolmates to dress up in costume for a masquerade ball. Unfortunately, masks cannot hide old grudges borne out of teenage angst. So when Cindy Munson’s body is discovered murdered on the night of the dance, suspicion immediately falls upon Eastport High’s one-time notorious school bully, Terry Lawson.
Don attended the dance to apologize to those he harassed, only to be publicly rebuffed by Cindy. With the evidence stacked against him—Cindy’s body was found in his car—and no memory of what happened, Don is arrested. He’s more concerned about his six-year-old daughter going into child services than his own jail time. Remembering her own experiences in foster care, Jake volunteers to look after the little girl while conducting her own investigation into the night of the dance with Ellie.
But someone doesn’t want the amateur sleuths digging up past, humiliating secrets that may point to vengeful present-day motives—even if it means adding Jake and Ellie to a killer’s body count . . .
As the sun sets on summer in Eastport, local celebrations are in full swing—and Jake and Ellie have their hands full supplying the most decadent of desserts for extended family gatherings, class reunions, and other catered events. The organizers for Eastport High School’s Class of ’86 reunion thought it would be fun for former schoolmates to dress up in costume for a masquerade ball. Unfortunately, masks cannot hide old grudges borne out of teenage angst. So when Cindy Munson’s body is discovered murdered on the night of the dance, suspicion immediately falls upon Eastport High’s one-time notorious school bully, Terry Lawson.
Don attended the dance to apologize to those he harassed, only to be publicly rebuffed by Cindy. With the evidence stacked against him—Cindy’s body was found in his car—and no memory of what happened, Don is arrested. He’s more concerned about his six-year-old daughter going into child services than his own jail time. Remembering her own experiences in foster care, Jake volunteers to look after the little girl while conducting her own investigation into the night of the dance with Ellie.
But someone doesn’t want the amateur sleuths digging up past, humiliating secrets that may point to vengeful present-day motives—even if it means adding Jake and Ellie to a killer’s body count . . .
256 pages, Hardcover
Published April 28, 2026
About the author
Sarah Graves
29 books807 followersSarah Graves lives with her husband John, a musician and luthier, and their black Labrador Retriever in a house very much like the one Jacobia Tiptree is remodeling in Eastport, Maine. When she's not writing Jake's adventures, Sarah works with her husband on the house and she plays the 5-string banjo.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Librarian’s note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews
June 25, 2026
Big Thanks to Netgalley, the author, and the Publisher for the advanced copy! I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own
'Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers' is a cozy mystery written by Sarah Graves.
The story follows our two amateur detectives as they crack another small town murder with many twists and turns.
As a first time reader of the series, I've found the main lead unique as she didn't hesitate to take action and do some questionable things in order to discover new clues. The ending was filled up with drama and a turn towards the thriller kind as well.
However, there wasn't that much cozy in the book, as the murder mystery pretty much took over the plot.
The narration of the audiobook was enjoyable though.
'Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers' is a cozy mystery written by Sarah Graves.
The story follows our two amateur detectives as they crack another small town murder with many twists and turns.
As a first time reader of the series, I've found the main lead unique as she didn't hesitate to take action and do some questionable things in order to discover new clues. The ending was filled up with drama and a turn towards the thriller kind as well.
However, there wasn't that much cozy in the book, as the murder mystery pretty much took over the plot.
The narration of the audiobook was enjoyable though.
May 5, 2026
What a fun mystery! This was delightful, suspenseful, quirky, mysterious and a somewhat comical. The situations the FMC found herself in while trying to discover who murdered the victim were entertaining. I loved watching her interact with friends, laughed at the moments with Lizzie the police officer and her reluctance to marry, and giggled while she navigated taking care of a younge child unexpectedly.
The narrator did a fantastic job spinning this mystery, giving the FMC so much character and personality that you felt like you knew her. If you are looking for a cute, clean (yes I know its odd to use the words cute and clean for a murder mystery, it somehow fits), entertaining mystery, this is a great pick!
The narrator did a fantastic job spinning this mystery, giving the FMC so much character and personality that you felt like you knew her. If you are looking for a cute, clean (yes I know its odd to use the words cute and clean for a murder mystery, it somehow fits), entertaining mystery, this is a great pick!
June 6, 2026
Dollycas’s Thoughts
Jacobia “Jake” Tiptree and Ellie White own and operate the Chocolate Moose in Eastport, Maine. As the summer winds down, they are busy with their daily baking and have a special order for the Eastport High School’s Class of ’97 reunion. Formerly married, Cindy Munson and Terry Lawson both attend, and it looks like they may be getting back together, which should make their 6-year-old daughter, Ivy, very happy. But before a family reunion can take place, Cindy is murdered and found in Terry’s car. Quickly, the former high school bully, now tech-financier, finds himself firmly at the top of the police’s suspect list. This leaves poor Ivy alone with child services. Jake knows what that is like, so she volunteers to foster the child herself. She is also teaming up with Ellie to do their own investigation. Will they survive to bake up more chocolate treats? Or will this be the end of The Chocolate Moose?
The story opens with Jake’s house being unusually quiet. Her husband Wade is away working, her dad and stepmother are enjoying a rare trip, and her son Sam and his family are in Portland for some medical appointments for their youngest child, so she and their dog Fala have the place to themselves. Poor, clumsy Jake does not fare well within these pages. Red ant, wasps, centipedes, slips, falls, and faceplants, plus a dangerous gas leak, all try to take her down, but that woman perseveres. It was different to have the whole family away at the start. I was happy when Bella came home. She was a huge help with Ivy. Eastport’s chief of police, Lizzie Snow, has some struggles of her own. Will she marry retired cop, Dylan Hudson? Or will she get cold feet? What a dilemma! Ms. Graves characters are very true-to-life and relatable.
Following along with Jake and Ellie is always a good time. The mystery this time brought up things that happened back in the late 90s, and how people hold on to grievances, and how people see the same things differently. Jake was dealing with some hard memories from her childhood, which added another layer to the story. She came up with a “scheme” to have the killer reveal themselves, and boy, that didn’t go as expected. But it sure turned into an exciting and terrifying experience for everyone, and it didn’t stop there. Two chapters at the end were pretty manic. I was surprised by the assist Jake received when the situation was pretty dire.
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers is a mystery that will keep readers guessing and out of breath as the story flows quickly to the end. Entertaining characters, well-placed humor, and a well-plotted, fast-paced story held my attention from the beginning to the final page. An excellent addition to this series.
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Kensington Cozies and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Jacobia “Jake” Tiptree and Ellie White own and operate the Chocolate Moose in Eastport, Maine. As the summer winds down, they are busy with their daily baking and have a special order for the Eastport High School’s Class of ’97 reunion. Formerly married, Cindy Munson and Terry Lawson both attend, and it looks like they may be getting back together, which should make their 6-year-old daughter, Ivy, very happy. But before a family reunion can take place, Cindy is murdered and found in Terry’s car. Quickly, the former high school bully, now tech-financier, finds himself firmly at the top of the police’s suspect list. This leaves poor Ivy alone with child services. Jake knows what that is like, so she volunteers to foster the child herself. She is also teaming up with Ellie to do their own investigation. Will they survive to bake up more chocolate treats? Or will this be the end of The Chocolate Moose?
The story opens with Jake’s house being unusually quiet. Her husband Wade is away working, her dad and stepmother are enjoying a rare trip, and her son Sam and his family are in Portland for some medical appointments for their youngest child, so she and their dog Fala have the place to themselves. Poor, clumsy Jake does not fare well within these pages. Red ant, wasps, centipedes, slips, falls, and faceplants, plus a dangerous gas leak, all try to take her down, but that woman perseveres. It was different to have the whole family away at the start. I was happy when Bella came home. She was a huge help with Ivy. Eastport’s chief of police, Lizzie Snow, has some struggles of her own. Will she marry retired cop, Dylan Hudson? Or will she get cold feet? What a dilemma! Ms. Graves characters are very true-to-life and relatable.
Following along with Jake and Ellie is always a good time. The mystery this time brought up things that happened back in the late 90s, and how people hold on to grievances, and how people see the same things differently. Jake was dealing with some hard memories from her childhood, which added another layer to the story. She came up with a “scheme” to have the killer reveal themselves, and boy, that didn’t go as expected. But it sure turned into an exciting and terrifying experience for everyone, and it didn’t stop there. Two chapters at the end were pretty manic. I was surprised by the assist Jake received when the situation was pretty dire.
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers is a mystery that will keep readers guessing and out of breath as the story flows quickly to the end. Entertaining characters, well-placed humor, and a well-plotted, fast-paced story held my attention from the beginning to the final page. An excellent addition to this series.
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Kensington Cozies and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
May 16, 2026
Compared to other cozies, I found this story to be mediocre. The story moved along at a slow to medium pace. The narration was middle of the road.
I was blessed with an ALC. Thank you NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased. I did love the cover.
I was blessed with an ALC. Thank you NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own and unbiased. I did love the cover.
April 26, 2026
"Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers (Book 9 of A Death by Chocolate Mystery)" by Sarah Graves is a tiny but of a comeback in the writing of the main story for this series. However, when did Jake become the but of the slapstick comedy? Seriously, you you'd be very wasted if you too a shot every time she found herself getting hurt in this book. Especially involving fire aunts. It just kept happening that it started to feel like filler content than story building. I really think it's time to retire these characters.
Jake and Ellie get pulled into investigating the mysterious death at a high school reunion. Especially after Ellie basically volunteered Jake to foster the young daughter of the victim. Honestly, I don't know how half of Jake's family isn't jail considering none of them changed their names and the cops know of their past criminal activity but they now are letting them foster a kid. I think I am done with this series as it was one too stupid to live choice after another. Just not for me now for a few books.
Jake and Ellie get pulled into investigating the mysterious death at a high school reunion. Especially after Ellie basically volunteered Jake to foster the young daughter of the victim. Honestly, I don't know how half of Jake's family isn't jail considering none of them changed their names and the cops know of their past criminal activity but they now are letting them foster a kid. I think I am done with this series as it was one too stupid to live choice after another. Just not for me now for a few books.
May 4, 2026
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers was bad. It had a promising start but even with a cozy mystery, the main characters actions still need to be believable. And they just weren’t. She treats someone breaking into her home like it’s just a minor annoyance. Moments like that should raise stakes, increase tension and ultimately should have some sort of pay off. It didn’t. There were so many places with manufactured danger it bordered on ridiculous. And the whole slapstick physicality just didn’t land. This wasn’t a mystery. It was just a clutzy woman who dreams of being a detective and miraculously everything just falls into place.
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC
April 19, 2026
Audiobook Review — Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers
(ARC provided via NetGalley)
A cozy, small‑town mystery with plenty of charm, a dash of danger, and the irresistible comfort of Sarah Graves’ chocolate‑shop world.
Story & Atmosphere
This installment delivers exactly what fans of the series expect: a tight‑knit community, a mystery that simmers rather than shocks, and a setting so deliciously described you can practically smell the cocoa. The blend of culinary detail and crime keeps the tone light even when stakes rise, making it an easy, satisfying listen.
Characters
Graves continues to shine in her character work. The returning cast feels familiar without becoming stale, and the new faces add just enough intrigue. The relationships—friendships, frictions, and found‑family moments—give the story its warmth.
Narration
The narrator’s performance is smooth, expressive, and well‑paced. Voices are distinct without veering into caricature, and the delivery captures both the cozy charm and the moments of tension. It’s the kind of narration that enhances immersion without ever distracting from the story.
What Worked Well
Atmospheric, sensory setting that translates beautifully in audio.
Engaging narrator who brings personality to each character.
A mystery that unfolds steadily, perfect for listeners who prefer comfort over high‑octane suspense.
Strong sense of place and community, a hallmark of the series.
Overall
A warm, chocolate‑dusted cozy mystery with a narrator who makes the world feel lived‑in and inviting. Fans of the series—and cozy mystery listeners in general—will find this a delightful, comforting addition.
Recommended for listeners who enjoy culinary cozies, small‑town charm, and mysteries that pair well with a cup of tea (or a plate of ladyfingers).
(ARC provided via NetGalley)
A cozy, small‑town mystery with plenty of charm, a dash of danger, and the irresistible comfort of Sarah Graves’ chocolate‑shop world.
Story & Atmosphere
This installment delivers exactly what fans of the series expect: a tight‑knit community, a mystery that simmers rather than shocks, and a setting so deliciously described you can practically smell the cocoa. The blend of culinary detail and crime keeps the tone light even when stakes rise, making it an easy, satisfying listen.
Characters
Graves continues to shine in her character work. The returning cast feels familiar without becoming stale, and the new faces add just enough intrigue. The relationships—friendships, frictions, and found‑family moments—give the story its warmth.
Narration
The narrator’s performance is smooth, expressive, and well‑paced. Voices are distinct without veering into caricature, and the delivery captures both the cozy charm and the moments of tension. It’s the kind of narration that enhances immersion without ever distracting from the story.
What Worked Well
Atmospheric, sensory setting that translates beautifully in audio.
Engaging narrator who brings personality to each character.
A mystery that unfolds steadily, perfect for listeners who prefer comfort over high‑octane suspense.
Strong sense of place and community, a hallmark of the series.
Overall
A warm, chocolate‑dusted cozy mystery with a narrator who makes the world feel lived‑in and inviting. Fans of the series—and cozy mystery listeners in general—will find this a delightful, comforting addition.
Recommended for listeners who enjoy culinary cozies, small‑town charm, and mysteries that pair well with a cup of tea (or a plate of ladyfingers).
May 17, 2026
Love love love this series. I have been a fan of Jake and Ellie from book 1 and not just because I am a chocoholic. Jake’s home is still bursting at the seams. Jake and Ellie are still investigating aka being nosy.
Miss the husbands but they come in at the right time. So many things happening that seem like they don’t connect but that’s typical for Jake and Ellie’s life.
A new death, an old death, a wedding, and more. A good entry in a favorite series.
Happy Reading!
Miss the husbands but they come in at the right time. So many things happening that seem like they don’t connect but that’s typical for Jake and Ellie’s life.
A new death, an old death, a wedding, and more. A good entry in a favorite series.
Happy Reading!
May 3, 2026
It seems like Jake is always getting herself into situations that result in her getting serious injuries. It has gotten to the point that I don’t like reading about what she goes through in trying to find the killers. These stories are not a “cozy” reading experience for me anymore.
May 27, 2026
"Jake" Tiptree and her friend and business partner Ellie White are sleuthing again. Crazy plot turns and red herrings are the rule. Some "gymnastics" involved in their pursuit of the guilty parties seem far-fetched to me, but I guess that's what makes cozy mysteries cozy!
April 30, 2026
Well I guess the author has run out of plot ideas. The mystery was thin but the book is full of Jake doing a lot of ridiculous physical events. Also where are the other characters? The last few books have been like this. So I may be done.
May 3, 2026
I’m sorry I just can’t with this series anymore. First the weird shark attack book now this??
April 30, 2026
https://openbooksociety.com/article/d...
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I haven’t read any of the other books in the Death by Chocolate Mystery series by Sarah Graves as of yet, so this is my introduction to this author. Not sure I would recommend starting the series at book 9, but I did.
There are interesting characters in the series, and the mystery surrounding the death of Cindy Munson was well plotted. The ‘whodunit’ was not revealed until the end – which is a good thing as I truly like my cozy mysteries that way.
It is highly suggested (at least for the copy of the book I got) that the editing be reviewed:
I was in chapter 2 when Ellie and Jake were talking about Ivy when out of nowhere there are a couple of sentences with Lizzie mentioned or her speaking – what gives with that? And then for the rest of the section – seems like Jake is having a conversation with Lizzie. Turns out when I read the next section, one sentence is written again (though at least this time it is after Lizzie actually shows up in the scene). Very confusing. And when Lizzie is introduced into the scene, we come upon more redundancy. Clarity and better editing is needed. Seems that both Ellie and Jake are at the bakery but without clarification, it tends to be confusing. Took me approximately three to four times of reading all of this over to get who was in the scene and how the conversation was flowing between various characters.
And unfortunately, I cannot forget spelling errors when “grave” was most definitely meant to be “gravel”.
…”So I went ass the street to set it all up with Bridget”?
“…on a side tabl,e”
I could go on, but I won’t. Just to say – all of the editing errors definitely distracted me from enjoying the story. Maybe Kensington Cozies should hire more proofreaders? 🙂
And their attempt to be cute (one would hope) that was not cute in my opinion was when they used “vewy” in a sentence:
“But I needn’t have bothered trying to be vewy, vewy quiet; the porch light was on…”
Some of the descriptions used sure had caught my attention in a big (and good) way:
“Ack! The stool toppled one way, I tumbled the other, and while the ground was soft and there were no barberry bushes here, there were ants boiling up out of the ant hill that I’d just disturbed by landing on it. Red ants-and boy, were they mad.”
I did like the cover art – how can one go wrong with chocolate ladyfingers and a cute dog on the cover?
It is my fondest hope that by going back to the beginning of the series, I might become more empathetic to the main protagonists and that their backstories will provide the needed history for me to love (or at least like) this series (though careful editing would be very helpful).
As with any cozy mysteries, the journey to discover whodunit is what is most important, and I feel that Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers was sufficient in this regard.
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I haven’t read any of the other books in the Death by Chocolate Mystery series by Sarah Graves as of yet, so this is my introduction to this author. Not sure I would recommend starting the series at book 9, but I did.
There are interesting characters in the series, and the mystery surrounding the death of Cindy Munson was well plotted. The ‘whodunit’ was not revealed until the end – which is a good thing as I truly like my cozy mysteries that way.
It is highly suggested (at least for the copy of the book I got) that the editing be reviewed:
I was in chapter 2 when Ellie and Jake were talking about Ivy when out of nowhere there are a couple of sentences with Lizzie mentioned or her speaking – what gives with that? And then for the rest of the section – seems like Jake is having a conversation with Lizzie. Turns out when I read the next section, one sentence is written again (though at least this time it is after Lizzie actually shows up in the scene). Very confusing. And when Lizzie is introduced into the scene, we come upon more redundancy. Clarity and better editing is needed. Seems that both Ellie and Jake are at the bakery but without clarification, it tends to be confusing. Took me approximately three to four times of reading all of this over to get who was in the scene and how the conversation was flowing between various characters.
And unfortunately, I cannot forget spelling errors when “grave” was most definitely meant to be “gravel”.
…”So I went ass the street to set it all up with Bridget”?
“…on a side tabl,e”
I could go on, but I won’t. Just to say – all of the editing errors definitely distracted me from enjoying the story. Maybe Kensington Cozies should hire more proofreaders? 🙂
And their attempt to be cute (one would hope) that was not cute in my opinion was when they used “vewy” in a sentence:
“But I needn’t have bothered trying to be vewy, vewy quiet; the porch light was on…”
Some of the descriptions used sure had caught my attention in a big (and good) way:
“Ack! The stool toppled one way, I tumbled the other, and while the ground was soft and there were no barberry bushes here, there were ants boiling up out of the ant hill that I’d just disturbed by landing on it. Red ants-and boy, were they mad.”
I did like the cover art – how can one go wrong with chocolate ladyfingers and a cute dog on the cover?
It is my fondest hope that by going back to the beginning of the series, I might become more empathetic to the main protagonists and that their backstories will provide the needed history for me to love (or at least like) this series (though careful editing would be very helpful).
As with any cozy mysteries, the journey to discover whodunit is what is most important, and I feel that Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers was sufficient in this regard.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you Netgalley for the ARC audio on this one! I was so excited when the email came through as I am a HUGE Sarah Graves fan!
If you know me, you know I’ll pick up literally ANYTHING by Sarah Graves without even reading the description—and Death by Lady Fingers was no exception. And honestly? It delivered exactly what I wanted.
This one hooked me right from the first minute of the audiobook. There’s just something about returning to Eastport, Maine that feels cozy but never boring—like you know something is about to go sideways, and you’re just waiting to see how messy it gets. (And as a local, I still get sucked right into these story lines, from 20 mins down the road. I'm not sure if that fact makes these books more magical or relatable, but regardless I love these books).
Jake and Ellie are back at it again, running the Chocolate Moose bakery and juggling what should be a fun, busy end-of-summer season. But of course, this is Eastport… so instead of just desserts and reunions, we get a full-on murder at a masquerade ball (because why not add a little drama to a class reunion?).
What I really loved here is how the story leans into past grudges and small-town history. You can feel how long people have been holding onto things, and it makes the tension so much better. Everyone has a history, everyone has an opinion, and no one is completely innocent—which makes the mystery that much more addictive.
Now—quick note on the audiobook itself. The narrator is different from what I’m used to, and I definitely noticed it at first. It took me a little bit to adjust, but once I did, I was back in it. The pacing and tone still worked, and I stayed fully invested the whole time.
Overall, this is one of those audiobooks where you hit play “just for a few minutes” and suddenly you’re way too far in to stop. Cozy mystery vibes, small-town drama, and just enough danger to keep things interesting. *
I also want to note I have loved watching Sam grow up in the series, and the love story fold out between Jake and Wade (although not a conventional traditional "love story" it is a love story none the less), and Jake finally getting rid of Victor!
If you already love Sarah Graves, you’re going to enjoy this one. And if you’re new? This is a pretty great place to start.
If you know me, you know I’ll pick up literally ANYTHING by Sarah Graves without even reading the description—and Death by Lady Fingers was no exception. And honestly? It delivered exactly what I wanted.
This one hooked me right from the first minute of the audiobook. There’s just something about returning to Eastport, Maine that feels cozy but never boring—like you know something is about to go sideways, and you’re just waiting to see how messy it gets. (And as a local, I still get sucked right into these story lines, from 20 mins down the road. I'm not sure if that fact makes these books more magical or relatable, but regardless I love these books).
Jake and Ellie are back at it again, running the Chocolate Moose bakery and juggling what should be a fun, busy end-of-summer season. But of course, this is Eastport… so instead of just desserts and reunions, we get a full-on murder at a masquerade ball (because why not add a little drama to a class reunion?).
What I really loved here is how the story leans into past grudges and small-town history. You can feel how long people have been holding onto things, and it makes the tension so much better. Everyone has a history, everyone has an opinion, and no one is completely innocent—which makes the mystery that much more addictive.
Now—quick note on the audiobook itself. The narrator is different from what I’m used to, and I definitely noticed it at first. It took me a little bit to adjust, but once I did, I was back in it. The pacing and tone still worked, and I stayed fully invested the whole time.
Overall, this is one of those audiobooks where you hit play “just for a few minutes” and suddenly you’re way too far in to stop. Cozy mystery vibes, small-town drama, and just enough danger to keep things interesting. *
I also want to note I have loved watching Sam grow up in the series, and the love story fold out between Jake and Wade (although not a conventional traditional "love story" it is a love story none the less), and Jake finally getting rid of Victor!
If you already love Sarah Graves, you’re going to enjoy this one. And if you’re new? This is a pretty great place to start.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I did enjoy this book but had to wonder how the main character was still alive, she was so accident prone she would have given Mr Bean a run for his money. This is book nine in the series and as this is my first time with the group, I have to confess it had me wondering if she is always this bad and why the medics weren't on first name terms with her, like the police. Otherwise I liked the characters, especially the big heart that had her fighting for a young girl she didn't even know. However I think from this outing I liked the side kick Ellie more than the many character Jake, she seemed the more capable of the two and the most likely to solve the case.
As for the mystery, I had no idea who was responsible and was surprised, like the main character, several times as it unfolded or exploded. There was a lot going on in the story and it did hold my interest until the very end and I would join Jake and Ellie on another mystery, I might even go back to the beginning to see how it all began.
Jacobia “Jake” and Ellie are hired to bake the deserts for a high school reunion. The problem is the night before one of the attendees was allegedly killer by her husband in the parking lot, leaving behind a six year old child, who might have witnessed it. With her mother dead and her father in custody Jake offers to take Ivy in. With flashbacks to her own childhood when her own father was accused of killing her mother, Jake and Ellie quickly insert themselves into the investigation. Can they prove Ivy's father innocent by looking into the victims past? A number of suspects keep them jumping through hoops, as social services threaten to give Ivy back to her dad or to a long term foster family. With a killer still out there neither option is good as far as Jake is concerned.
I liked the narrator. She provided some good voices for both the old and young characters and made it a fun listen.
I was given this free review copy audio book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
As for the mystery, I had no idea who was responsible and was surprised, like the main character, several times as it unfolded or exploded. There was a lot going on in the story and it did hold my interest until the very end and I would join Jake and Ellie on another mystery, I might even go back to the beginning to see how it all began.
Jacobia “Jake” and Ellie are hired to bake the deserts for a high school reunion. The problem is the night before one of the attendees was allegedly killer by her husband in the parking lot, leaving behind a six year old child, who might have witnessed it. With her mother dead and her father in custody Jake offers to take Ivy in. With flashbacks to her own childhood when her own father was accused of killing her mother, Jake and Ellie quickly insert themselves into the investigation. Can they prove Ivy's father innocent by looking into the victims past? A number of suspects keep them jumping through hoops, as social services threaten to give Ivy back to her dad or to a long term foster family. With a killer still out there neither option is good as far as Jake is concerned.
I liked the narrator. She provided some good voices for both the old and young characters and made it a fun listen.
I was given this free review copy audio book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
June 1, 2026
Well, I’ve been a regular reader to Sarah Graves mysteries for many years. I enjoyed the house repair stories and made the eventual transition to their Chocolate Moose bakery. I was eager to read this and snapped it up when it showed up on the new books shelf at the library.
Honestly, I had a hard I’ve getting into this story and found myself constantly setting it aside to work on other projects. Resolved to finish it before it needed to be returned, I have accomplished that task.
I found myself rereading parts to try to keep the timeline straight and the days in order and the conversations on track. This wasn’t the author’s best work. Why have Jake so accident prone this time, and still be able to function in wildly unlikely scenarios ? Why have so little contact with the bakery angle, why not just make them snoop sisters and be done with the idea that they can actually be making a profit at this business? Their snooping is breaking and entering, but suffer no consequences, no charges but a wink and a nod from the local law enforcement. The story line with Ivy is a bit off. While Jake relates to her situation based on her own childhood, it is Bella that Ivy establishes a closeness. How does she even think long term for this child when it is likely the elderly Bella who will be the caregiver when the next murder comes along and Jake abandons the work at the Moose to chase that comes along?
The final chapters certainly moved to a crescendo and an interesting conclusion. Interesting, but slightly hard to believe, but I guess it is a work of fiction and should leave it at that. Needless to say, I’ll likely be back again for the next installment. I seem to need to follow characters and series to the bitter end, hopefully, things improve.
Honestly, I had a hard I’ve getting into this story and found myself constantly setting it aside to work on other projects. Resolved to finish it before it needed to be returned, I have accomplished that task.
I found myself rereading parts to try to keep the timeline straight and the days in order and the conversations on track. This wasn’t the author’s best work. Why have Jake so accident prone this time, and still be able to function in wildly unlikely scenarios ? Why have so little contact with the bakery angle, why not just make them snoop sisters and be done with the idea that they can actually be making a profit at this business? Their snooping is breaking and entering, but suffer no consequences, no charges but a wink and a nod from the local law enforcement. The story line with Ivy is a bit off. While Jake relates to her situation based on her own childhood, it is Bella that Ivy establishes a closeness. How does she even think long term for this child when it is likely the elderly Bella who will be the caregiver when the next murder comes along and Jake abandons the work at the Moose to chase that comes along?
The final chapters certainly moved to a crescendo and an interesting conclusion. Interesting, but slightly hard to believe, but I guess it is a work of fiction and should leave it at that. Needless to say, I’ll likely be back again for the next installment. I seem to need to follow characters and series to the bitter end, hopefully, things improve.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I had such a good time with Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers. Listening to the audiobook, narrated by Suzie Althens, made the whole experience even more entertaining — she captured the humor, the tension, and Jake’s determined energy so well.
As per usual in this series, Jake Tiptree managed to land herself in several hilariously precarious (and often painful) situations while trying to solve the murder of a local woman. Between the bites, bruises, and near‑misses, I found myself laughing out loud more than once. And of course, Ellie was right there beside her, the perfect partner‑in‑crime‑solving and co‑owner of their beloved chocolate bakeshop.
The pacing of the story was great — it moved quickly, never dragged, and kept me engaged the whole way through. The reveal of who dun’ it came together in an exciting, satisfying conclusion that felt earned and tied up the mystery nicely.
One of my favorite parts of this series, and this book in particular, is the family aspect woven into Jake’s life. Those moments added warmth and relatability, grounding the mystery in something emotionally real. It’s that balance — humour, danger, friendship, and family — that keeps me coming back to Eastport every time.
A cozy, funny, slightly chaotic mystery with heart — and plenty of chocolate.
Thank you Kensington Books for the arc and Dreamscape Media for the alc. All thoughts expressed in this review are my own.
As per usual in this series, Jake Tiptree managed to land herself in several hilariously precarious (and often painful) situations while trying to solve the murder of a local woman. Between the bites, bruises, and near‑misses, I found myself laughing out loud more than once. And of course, Ellie was right there beside her, the perfect partner‑in‑crime‑solving and co‑owner of their beloved chocolate bakeshop.
The pacing of the story was great — it moved quickly, never dragged, and kept me engaged the whole way through. The reveal of who dun’ it came together in an exciting, satisfying conclusion that felt earned and tied up the mystery nicely.
One of my favorite parts of this series, and this book in particular, is the family aspect woven into Jake’s life. Those moments added warmth and relatability, grounding the mystery in something emotionally real. It’s that balance — humour, danger, friendship, and family — that keeps me coming back to Eastport every time.
A cozy, funny, slightly chaotic mystery with heart — and plenty of chocolate.
Thank you Kensington Books for the arc and Dreamscape Media for the alc. All thoughts expressed in this review are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I received this book as an advanced reader copy, and it was a delightfully fun read!
I don't read a lot of modern cozy mysteries, but I will definitely pick some more up after this. The story is heartwarming while also keeping you interested in the "whodunnit" aspect. The characters are likeable and you can really empathize with their fondness for the sassy little girl they are tasked to take care of. The story progression/pacing is well done and had me interested but not confused.
I really enjoyed the characters and will be picking up previous Death by Chocolate books because Jake's life sounds like a hell of a ride. Also love the bakery theme, as an avid baker myself I made me feel even closer to the characters while they were baking their treats :)
My only gripe would be that I feel like Ivy was written a little too smart or maybe I haven't been around enough children. Her dialogue just threw me off sometimes because I was like "would a six year old even know that or speak like that". Then again, I have not been around many 6 year olds and I know children can be very sassy and perceptive.
In all, the ending was a surprise and I enjoyed the twists and turns the book to get there. I enjoyed the narrator (I listened to the audiobook) and she did an amazing job expressing the characters' personalities. I think I will go pick up the first book in this series and see how Jake got to this point.
I don't read a lot of modern cozy mysteries, but I will definitely pick some more up after this. The story is heartwarming while also keeping you interested in the "whodunnit" aspect. The characters are likeable and you can really empathize with their fondness for the sassy little girl they are tasked to take care of. The story progression/pacing is well done and had me interested but not confused.
I really enjoyed the characters and will be picking up previous Death by Chocolate books because Jake's life sounds like a hell of a ride. Also love the bakery theme, as an avid baker myself I made me feel even closer to the characters while they were baking their treats :)
My only gripe would be that I feel like Ivy was written a little too smart or maybe I haven't been around enough children. Her dialogue just threw me off sometimes because I was like "would a six year old even know that or speak like that". Then again, I have not been around many 6 year olds and I know children can be very sassy and perceptive.
In all, the ending was a surprise and I enjoyed the twists and turns the book to get there. I enjoyed the narrator (I listened to the audiobook) and she did an amazing job expressing the characters' personalities. I think I will go pick up the first book in this series and see how Jake got to this point.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I grabbed this one for the Maine setting since I grew up there, not realizing it was book 9/9 in a series; I quickly found out it can stand alone Small town where everyone knows everyone, grudges that never quite die, a bakery at the center of it all and amurder tied to a class reunion.
Jake and Ellie run the Chocolate Moose and get pulled into the mess when all signs point to someone who doesn’t quite fit. There’s also a young child in the middle of it, which gives it a little more grit than your typical cozy mystery.
The narrator kept it easy with good pacing, and characters that felt natural. This is the kind of audiobook you throw on and keep moving through your day, easy to get through!
What worked for me… I didn’t feel lost coming in this late in the series. The characters feel established without needing a full history lessonn and the Maine setting? Not overdone, not touristy, just familiar. It gets a little extra toward the end, but I was entertained, so I let it ride.
If you like cozy mysteries but want a little more bite, pick this up. I finished this and immediately started book one and plan to listen to the entire series.
⭐️ 4.25 stars
Jake and Ellie run the Chocolate Moose and get pulled into the mess when all signs point to someone who doesn’t quite fit. There’s also a young child in the middle of it, which gives it a little more grit than your typical cozy mystery.
The narrator kept it easy with good pacing, and characters that felt natural. This is the kind of audiobook you throw on and keep moving through your day, easy to get through!
What worked for me… I didn’t feel lost coming in this late in the series. The characters feel established without needing a full history lessonn and the Maine setting? Not overdone, not touristy, just familiar. It gets a little extra toward the end, but I was entertained, so I let it ride.
If you like cozy mysteries but want a little more bite, pick this up. I finished this and immediately started book one and plan to listen to the entire series.
⭐️ 4.25 stars
May 1, 2026
Death by ladyfingers is my introduction to this series. The book was mostly ok and the narration (Suzie Althens) elevated the whole experience for me. I can't say the lead characters were particularly impressive or memorable (perhaps long time fans of the series may feel differently) and certain lines spoken by Ivy seemed a bit too mature or sassy for a 6-year-old child. The pace was ok, but since we knew very little about the victim and the accused, I wasn't too invested in solving the mystery. I felt like a passive observer casually watching an accident prone lady with good intentions bumble about trying to assist the police. I couldn't really believe Jake changed her mind about Ivy in a single day because none of their interactions on the first day suggested a change of heart. Moreover, the writing seemed less than coherent in a couple of places. Overall, I felt there was a lack of depth (or should I say heart?) in the story as well as the relationships...perhaps the author's heart wasn't really in the story? However, she has put together a decent cozy mystery.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the arc shared in exchange for an honest review.
Many thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the arc shared in exchange for an honest review.
May 20, 2026
4 Stars
Death by Chocolate Lady Fingers was such a fun and satisfying cozy mystery read. Honestly, you can rarely go wrong with a cozy mystery—especially when there’s a dog on the cover.
I really enjoyed the intricate plot and the wide assortment of suspects woven throughout the story. The masquerade reunion setting added an extra layer of tension and intrigue, and the investigation kept me engaged as secrets from the past slowly unraveled.
One of the standout elements for me was the atmosphere and the descriptions throughout the book. The decadent desserts were absolutely tantalizing and added so much charm to the story while balancing out the darker moments surrounding the murder investigation.
Overall, this was an engaging, cozy mystery with strong pacing, memorable characters, and plenty of twists to keep readers guessing.
Thank you, NetGalley, Dreamscape Media, and Sarah Graves (fitting name for the genre you are writing!) for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for my fair and honest review.
Death by Chocolate Lady Fingers was such a fun and satisfying cozy mystery read. Honestly, you can rarely go wrong with a cozy mystery—especially when there’s a dog on the cover.
I really enjoyed the intricate plot and the wide assortment of suspects woven throughout the story. The masquerade reunion setting added an extra layer of tension and intrigue, and the investigation kept me engaged as secrets from the past slowly unraveled.
One of the standout elements for me was the atmosphere and the descriptions throughout the book. The decadent desserts were absolutely tantalizing and added so much charm to the story while balancing out the darker moments surrounding the murder investigation.
Overall, this was an engaging, cozy mystery with strong pacing, memorable characters, and plenty of twists to keep readers guessing.
Thank you, NetGalley, Dreamscape Media, and Sarah Graves (fitting name for the genre you are writing!) for the opportunity to read this ARC in exchange for my fair and honest review.
December 21, 2025
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers was a really easy read. It’s set in Eastport, Maine, and follows Jacobia “Jake” Tiptree as she gets pulled into a murder tied to a chocolate-themed event that shakes up the town. Once things stop adding up, Jake can’t help but start digging.
Jake is the kind of main character I can see myself playing. She's practical, a little blunt, and very much led by common sense. Her friendship with Ellie is caring and fun and her back-and-forth with police chief Sam Beasley brings in a bit of tension without going overboard. Everyone feels familiar in that small-town way which makes the story real easy to get into.
The mystery moves along at a nice pace and kept me guessing without getting confusing and the chocolate theme was super fun! I haven't read any of the other books in the Death by Chocolate Mystery series yet, but I plan on it! If you’re in the mood for a cozy mystery that’s easy to read but still keeps your attention, this one’s a yummy pick!
Jake is the kind of main character I can see myself playing. She's practical, a little blunt, and very much led by common sense. Her friendship with Ellie is caring and fun and her back-and-forth with police chief Sam Beasley brings in a bit of tension without going overboard. Everyone feels familiar in that small-town way which makes the story real easy to get into.
The mystery moves along at a nice pace and kept me guessing without getting confusing and the chocolate theme was super fun! I haven't read any of the other books in the Death by Chocolate Mystery series yet, but I plan on it! If you’re in the mood for a cozy mystery that’s easy to read but still keeps your attention, this one’s a yummy pick!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers is the ninth cozy mystery in the Death by Chocolate Mystery series. Jake and Ellie are supplying the desserts for a class reunion at the high school, but when one of the attendees turns up murdered there’s no stopping Jake from getting involved. When the precocious six year old daughter for the victim in pulled into the middle of it, Jake is even more determined to solve the case while protecting Ivy. Will Jake be able to solve the case and save the day before Ivy is put into foster care?
I have read all of this series and have enjoyed it, this latest book was no different. I thought it was fast paced and easy to get pulled into. The mystery was intriguing and I found myself guessing right along with the characters. I love the characters and their relationships in this book, they really make the series. This was another good cozy mystery in this series and I look forward to seeing what comes next.
I have read all of this series and have enjoyed it, this latest book was no different. I thought it was fast paced and easy to get pulled into. The mystery was intriguing and I found myself guessing right along with the characters. I love the characters and their relationships in this book, they really make the series. This was another good cozy mystery in this series and I look forward to seeing what comes next.
June 24, 2026
Saw this on the library shelf and remembered how much I enjoyed the Home Repair Jacobia Tiptree series and thought I'd give this one a go. After getting into it I remembered that I found this series - using the same characters - was different and IMO less than interesting. The characters seem less familiar though they are supposedly the same. The plots of this series of books seem rote, like perhaps even the author is kind of tired of the same old, same old. I don't know. Maybe I'm just getting old. I like a cozy mystery as well as the next reader, but these just...aren't. I skipped all of the middle extraneous stuff and still managed to get the gist of the mystery without having to turn all those pages. That just isn't a good thing in my mind.
I'll find something else to read. Though to give Ms. Graves credit and it's a huge credit: her books are clean and completely free from offensive language. Good for her.
I'll find something else to read. Though to give Ms. Graves credit and it's a huge credit: her books are clean and completely free from offensive language. Good for her.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Jake and Ellie are back and find themselves supplying desserts for the local High School’s 40th class reunion. While they’re serving up the treats, someone else serves up the body of one of the attendees. Not only does Jake find herself sleuthing but she’s also caring for the victim’s young daughter. Can Jake and Ellie keep themselves and the child safe while tracking a killer? Not if the killer has their way in the end!
I really enjoyed this series. Jake has a heart of gold and Ellie often brings out her softener side. Together the two not only run the sweetest shop in town, they solve the murders that seem to pop up whenever they finally let themselves think it’s safe in Eastport once again. A great series!
I really enjoyed this series. Jake has a heart of gold and Ellie often brings out her softener side. Together the two not only run the sweetest shop in town, they solve the murders that seem to pop up whenever they finally let themselves think it’s safe in Eastport once again. A great series!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Jake and Ellie make delicious chocolate treats at the Chocolate Moose bakery but they also investigate crimes. They will prepare treats for the Class Reunion at Eastport High School. Cindy is found dead after attending and her ex husband becomes prime suspect. Jake will not only try to uncover the truth but also look after Cindy’s daughter who badly needs safety and stability.
Very well written and well narrated novel (I listened to the audiobook). Very good characters in this well paced novel set in Eastport, Maine. Jake will put herself and others in danger whilst investigating. Plenty of sleuthing and adventure plus lots of interactions with local creepy crawlies that bite. Enjoy finding out who did it.
Very well written and well narrated novel (I listened to the audiobook). Very good characters in this well paced novel set in Eastport, Maine. Jake will put herself and others in danger whilst investigating. Plenty of sleuthing and adventure plus lots of interactions with local creepy crawlies that bite. Enjoy finding out who did it.
April 29, 2026
Death by Chocolate Ladyfingers is a cozy mystery set in a small town environment where community events and personal histories drive the narrative forward.
The Eastport High reunion serves as a central gathering point, bringing together characters whose shared pasts create multiple layers of tension and suspicion. The investigation develops through interpersonal dynamics and local relationships.
Jake and Ellie function as both caretakers and amateur investigators, adding emotional grounding to the procedural elements of the story. The foster care subplot introduces an additional layer of responsibility within the mystery framework.
A character driven cozy mystery for readers who enjoy small town settings, culinary themes, and relationship based investigations.
The Eastport High reunion serves as a central gathering point, bringing together characters whose shared pasts create multiple layers of tension and suspicion. The investigation develops through interpersonal dynamics and local relationships.
Jake and Ellie function as both caretakers and amateur investigators, adding emotional grounding to the procedural elements of the story. The foster care subplot introduces an additional layer of responsibility within the mystery framework.
A character driven cozy mystery for readers who enjoy small town settings, culinary themes, and relationship based investigations.
April 30, 2026
Going into this blind, meaning I did not read any other books in this series/universe, this is definitely something you could read without reading the other books. There are some references to the main character's previous escapades without giving away much information about other books.
That said, I did enjoy listening to this. It was nice that I did not catch the end coming from a mile away, although I do think many things - namely breaking and entering, weren't very realistic. I also don't understand how they keep their business alive because it sounded like they don't work very much.
However, if you want a short whodunnit book, this is for you.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape media for providing me with a free audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
That said, I did enjoy listening to this. It was nice that I did not catch the end coming from a mile away, although I do think many things - namely breaking and entering, weren't very realistic. I also don't understand how they keep their business alive because it sounded like they don't work very much.
However, if you want a short whodunnit book, this is for you.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape media for providing me with a free audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
April 30, 2026
Oh my goodness, just when I think the previous book was the most exciting adventure Jake and Ellie had, the next book (this one) came along and knocked it outta the park. From car chases to creepy basements to apprehending a killer, Jake pretty much did it all in this book. And she had plenty of bug bites and various injuries to show for it too. But Jake’s heart is as big as it can be and most of this stuff she went through for the sake of one little girl who lost her mother.
I loved the satisfying outcome and the very ending was tons of fun too. Jake and Wade are in for a bumpy ride for sure and I can’t wait to read the next book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies, and my opinions are my own.
I loved the satisfying outcome and the very ending was tons of fun too. Jake and Wade are in for a bumpy ride for sure and I can’t wait to read the next book.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies, and my opinions are my own.
May 5, 2026
I have really enjoyed reading the books in the Death by Chocolate series by Sarah Graves. I have grown to love the characters and enjoy the time I spend with them as I race through the pages. Once again Jake (Jacobia) finds herself in many situations which end up being rather painful. Her internal dialogue had me chuckling though cringing at the same time. Jake and Ellie make a great team, both in the chocolate bakeshop and as amateur sleuthers. I was invested in the story from the beginning and had a fun time sifting through all the clues, twists, and turns to discover who was guilty of murder. I actually listened to the audiobook version and the narrator, Suzie Athens, does a really good job of keeping your attention by using a variety of voices for the characters. I am ready to see what crazy adventure Jake will get into next!
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Cozies for my advanced review copy. All opinions and thoughts are my own.
For more reviews, please visit my blog at: https://www.msladybugsbookreviews.com/. Over 1000 reviews posted!
Thank you to NetGalley and Kensington Cozies for my advanced review copy. All opinions and thoughts are my own.
For more reviews, please visit my blog at: https://www.msladybugsbookreviews.com/. Over 1000 reviews posted!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews