What do you think?
Rate this book
Bainbridge Island Mystery #2
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth
Bainbridge Island bookseller, aspiring author, and amateur sleuth Meg (no relation to Bill) Gates investigates the murder of a crabby food critic in New York Times bestselling author Lynn Cahoon’s latest Pacific Northwest-set mystery for fans of Kate Carlisle, Lorna Barrett, Jenn McKinlay, and Ellery Adams.
Twenty-something bookseller and sleuth Meg Gates has a solving crimes may be easier than writing. She’s been working on a guide to becoming a detective—but she’s her own worst critic. She needs a how-to in order to write her how-to!
At the Bainbridge Island writers’ group, she meets freelance food critic Lee Anderson, who invites her to join him for dinner at the Local Crab so he won’t be suspected of reviewing the place. Lee is a bit of a crab himself and intends to do a hatchet job on the eatery.
Instead, someone does a job on the critic—he’s found dead by the marina. Now Bainbridge’s culinary elite are on the suspect list.
With help from her beau, Dalton, and the Mystery Crew at Island Books, Meg dons her sleuthing cap to solve the mystery du jour—before another murder is served cold . . .
Twenty-something bookseller and sleuth Meg Gates has a solving crimes may be easier than writing. She’s been working on a guide to becoming a detective—but she’s her own worst critic. She needs a how-to in order to write her how-to!
At the Bainbridge Island writers’ group, she meets freelance food critic Lee Anderson, who invites her to join him for dinner at the Local Crab so he won’t be suspected of reviewing the place. Lee is a bit of a crab himself and intends to do a hatchet job on the eatery.
Instead, someone does a job on the critic—he’s found dead by the marina. Now Bainbridge’s culinary elite are on the suspect list.
With help from her beau, Dalton, and the Mystery Crew at Island Books, Meg dons her sleuthing cap to solve the mystery du jour—before another murder is served cold . . .
256 pages, Hardcover
Published April 28, 2026
97 people are currently reading
4941 people want to read
About the author
Lynn Cahoon
102 books2,427 followersNYT and USA Today bestselling author, Lynn Cahoon, writes the Tourist Trap, Cat Latimer, Farm-to-Fork, Kitchen Witch, Survivors' Book Club, the Haunted Life, and the Bainbridge Island cozy mystery series. No matter where the mystery is set, readers can expect a fun ride Sign up for her newsletter at www.lynncahoon.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews
March 28, 2026
Lynn Cahoon is one of the most prolific writers. She's only just begun a new series, at least her 10th, and it's on the second book already. A food critic seemingly annoys one of their restaurant owners and finds themselves murdered. Our protagonist was last seen with him. Was it a date? Was he trying to tell her something but lost the opportunity? Toss in some family dramas, new relationships, and a desire to rebuild life after a small fall, the series has all the makings of a great long-term collection. Great setting with a local bookstore, an artist arc, future writers, and former high school friends dancing around a flirtation. As to the murder, someone's got history we haven't learned yet, and it's all about uncovering the connections we don't see straightaway. Good fun!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is a great second book of the series with the Bainbridge Island setting near Seattle and likable, realistic characters in the close knit small community. Meg is busy getting her life together after a nasty breakup with work at mom's bookstore, college classes, and writing a book. She is spending time with old friends, including developing a new relationship with Dalton. After she attends a business dinner to discuss writing, Meg is thrown into a murder investigation when a food critic she met at a writers' meeting is killed. He was nasty to local restaurants with his reviews and indeed was criticizing everything when she ate with him and she walked out. There are lots of suspects that he made mad, but the mystery is not so straightforward and he was complicated. And, her mom has a new friend that ruffles the feathers of her brother and the man's daughter. So, lots going on and an interesting mystery to solve. I didn't guess who the killer was until near the person was exposed. Great read.
I received a copy for an honest review and these are my thoughts.
I received a copy for an honest review and these are my thoughts.
May 2, 2026
Dollycas’s Thoughts
Meg Gates works at her mother’s bookstore and is working on a book of her own, aptly a guide for amateur sleuths, since she and her friends have already helped solve a murder.
Meg is also the assistant to successful author Lilly Aster. Lilly suggests that Meg join a local writing group to connect with other writers and learn more about the industry. At her first meeting, she meets Lee Anderson, a freelance food writer who may write a book someday. Lee invites Meg to dinner at the Local Crab, asking her to accompany him as he reviews the restaurant. During the meal, Meg realizes Lee is determined to give the place a negative review, even before trying the food. Uncomfortable with this approach, Meg leaves before dessert is served.
A couple of days later, Meg receives a call from her Uncle Troy, the chief of police, telling her the food critic was dead and that he is compiling a list of suspects, and he didn’t want to add her to the list.
She rallies the troops, her boyfriend, Dalton, and her best friend, Natasha, and her cocker spaniel Watson to help her solve another murder mystery, before the killer decides to strike again.
Meg is juggling many responsibilities as she works to rebuild her life. She is employed at her mother’s bookstore, assists author Lilly Aster, attends a college class with plans to become a full-time student, and is writing her first book. Her relationship with Dalton is becoming more serious, and she is adjusting to changes in her family dynamics. Meg has also joined a pickleball league and, on top of everything, is investigating another murder. Her mother has started dating, which Meg manages better than her brother, Junior. Junior himself has a new romantic interest—an outgoing and independent woman who visits the bookstore to meet Meg before Junior has a chance to introduce them. Natasha also has a new man in her life, but they are taking things slowly. Aunt Melody is a standout character, always supportive of Meg, even stocking her fridge and baking breakfast muffins. The characters’ development feels realistic and relatable.
Lee Anderson had a reputation for giving harsh reviews to many of the restaurants on Bainbridge Island, and he was poised to give the Local Crab a particularly poor review. The question arises: could a negative review push a chef to commit murder? Meg and Dalton decide to visit each chef who received unfavorable reviews to investigate. They also delve into the backgrounds of other island residents to search for any connections to the deceased critic. Meg, Dalton, and Natasha each use their unique positions and relationships to gather information, then convene to share what they’ve learned and determine what should be reported to Chief Troy. When Natasha is stealthily attacked, Dalton observes something crucial that brings clarity to the case.
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is a delightful sequel to An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder. Ms. Cahoon skillfully crafts relatable characters and places them in another intriguing mystery. Life on Bainbridge Island is never dull, and with Seattle just a ferry ride away, the setting adds promise for the continuation of this series. An Enjoyable Escape!
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Kensington Cozies and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
Meg Gates works at her mother’s bookstore and is working on a book of her own, aptly a guide for amateur sleuths, since she and her friends have already helped solve a murder.
Meg is also the assistant to successful author Lilly Aster. Lilly suggests that Meg join a local writing group to connect with other writers and learn more about the industry. At her first meeting, she meets Lee Anderson, a freelance food writer who may write a book someday. Lee invites Meg to dinner at the Local Crab, asking her to accompany him as he reviews the restaurant. During the meal, Meg realizes Lee is determined to give the place a negative review, even before trying the food. Uncomfortable with this approach, Meg leaves before dessert is served.
A couple of days later, Meg receives a call from her Uncle Troy, the chief of police, telling her the food critic was dead and that he is compiling a list of suspects, and he didn’t want to add her to the list.
She rallies the troops, her boyfriend, Dalton, and her best friend, Natasha, and her cocker spaniel Watson to help her solve another murder mystery, before the killer decides to strike again.
Meg is juggling many responsibilities as she works to rebuild her life. She is employed at her mother’s bookstore, assists author Lilly Aster, attends a college class with plans to become a full-time student, and is writing her first book. Her relationship with Dalton is becoming more serious, and she is adjusting to changes in her family dynamics. Meg has also joined a pickleball league and, on top of everything, is investigating another murder. Her mother has started dating, which Meg manages better than her brother, Junior. Junior himself has a new romantic interest—an outgoing and independent woman who visits the bookstore to meet Meg before Junior has a chance to introduce them. Natasha also has a new man in her life, but they are taking things slowly. Aunt Melody is a standout character, always supportive of Meg, even stocking her fridge and baking breakfast muffins. The characters’ development feels realistic and relatable.
Lee Anderson had a reputation for giving harsh reviews to many of the restaurants on Bainbridge Island, and he was poised to give the Local Crab a particularly poor review. The question arises: could a negative review push a chef to commit murder? Meg and Dalton decide to visit each chef who received unfavorable reviews to investigate. They also delve into the backgrounds of other island residents to search for any connections to the deceased critic. Meg, Dalton, and Natasha each use their unique positions and relationships to gather information, then convene to share what they’ve learned and determine what should be reported to Chief Troy. When Natasha is stealthily attacked, Dalton observes something crucial that brings clarity to the case.
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is a delightful sequel to An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder. Ms. Cahoon skillfully crafts relatable characters and places them in another intriguing mystery. Life on Bainbridge Island is never dull, and with Seattle just a ferry ride away, the setting adds promise for the continuation of this series. An Enjoyable Escape!
I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. Thank you to Kensington Cozies and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC.
May 4, 2026
This was a fun and entertaining cozy mystery. The mystery of the murder pulled me in and was suspenseful enough to keep my attention. I loved Meg as a character and was rooting for her. There were a few twists that I didn't see coming which is always a plus! I'll be looking forward to reading more in this series!
Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
November 11, 2025
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is the Second Book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series by Lynn Cahoon.
I absolutely LOVED the first book in this new series, An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder and was excited to read the second book.
Meg has her hands filled working on her book , her two jobs and school.
She agrees to go out with a man she met at her writing group for a free meal as he is a food critic.
She ends up walking out because the man is so rude, and he turns up dead.
The characters are well written and well developed. I really love Meg and her boyfriend Dalton.
Her best friend Natasha and her dog Watson are great characters.
There is a little family drama, along with the murder mystery.
This is a multi-layered perfectly paced plot and such a great location.
Did I mention a little pickleball thrown in? Can't go wrong.
Fantastic Cozy Mystery I absolutely LOVED !
I absolutely LOVED the first book in this new series, An Amateur Sleuth’s Guide to Murder and was excited to read the second book.
Meg has her hands filled working on her book , her two jobs and school.
She agrees to go out with a man she met at her writing group for a free meal as he is a food critic.
She ends up walking out because the man is so rude, and he turns up dead.
The characters are well written and well developed. I really love Meg and her boyfriend Dalton.
Her best friend Natasha and her dog Watson are great characters.
There is a little family drama, along with the murder mystery.
This is a multi-layered perfectly paced plot and such a great location.
Did I mention a little pickleball thrown in? Can't go wrong.
Fantastic Cozy Mystery I absolutely LOVED !
November 8, 2025
After Meg walks out after telling a food critic what she thinks him, he later turns up dead. Chefs from the island all have. reasons for being angry about his reviews are all suspects. As Meg looks into who the critic was and where he was from, she notices a trend in his reviews. Second book in a new series by Lynn Cahoon.
December 2, 2025
This book features Meg Gates, who is a book seller and an amateur sleuth. She's writing a book about becoming a sleuth, and when someone from her writing group is killed, Meg does her best to find the answers and to out the murderer behind bars.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Meg Gates life is getting busy. She works part time at her mom's bookshop and as an assistant to famous local author Lilly Aster as well as going to school one day a week, writing her guide to being an amateur sleuth, and dating the lovely Dalton. She has also begun attending a local writers group where she meets newspaper man Lee Anderson who invites her to dinner to help him eat incognito while researching a critique of a Bainbridge Island fish restaurant. A week later Anderson is dead and Meg finds herself once again investigating a local murder!
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cozies, but the opinions expressed are my own. The second instalment of Lynn Cahoon's new series I thoroughly enjoyed this. Meg, Dalton, and Natasha are relatable main protagonists and the investigation as well as Meg's busy life made for a very enjoyable read. A sneak peek at the beginning of book three means there will be more to enjoy in this series before too long. Recommended.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cozies, but the opinions expressed are my own. The second instalment of Lynn Cahoon's new series I thoroughly enjoyed this. Meg, Dalton, and Natasha are relatable main protagonists and the investigation as well as Meg's busy life made for a very enjoyable read. A sneak peek at the beginning of book three means there will be more to enjoy in this series before too long. Recommended.
April 30, 2026
"Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth" is book #2 in the "Bainbridge Island Mystery" by Lynn Cahoon.
Meg Gates meets food critic Lee Anderson at a writers group and agrees to meet him for dinner at the Local Crab, thinking they will talk about writing but he turns out to be a master complainer about everything at the restaurant so she calls him out on his rude behaviour then leaves. Within days, the "critic" is found dead. Despite having an iron clad alibi, Meg is still drawn into the investigation and with the help of her boyfriend Dalton and best friend Natasha, they look to find the truth and catch a killer.
As for the murder - no surprise as to who the victim was, but figuring out the whodunit and why was a bit more complicated. So many potential suspects - restaurant chefs or perhaps an ex? Several well placed red herrings and misdirection but I did have it down to a couple of people and figured out who was responsible before the reveal.
This story was quite interesting. Chapter titles describe tips for amateur sleuth's. Meg tries to write her book while trying to solve the murder as well as maintain her work life and relationships.
The core characters are a nice mix of ages and backgrounds. Family relationships can be strained at times and changes aren't always easy to accept. Luckily for Meg she has a real keeper of a beau in Dalton! Her BFF Natasha may have some bad luck at times but she is loyal and an awesome baker. Meg's brother Junior can be a bit overbearing at times but he does mean well. Her dog Watson is an adorable scene stealer!
All the descriptions of food in the book had my taste buds drooling! A recipe is include at the end of the book as well as a sneak peak at a book from another series of Ms. Cahoon's.
Overall, an entertaining cozy read!
Meg Gates meets food critic Lee Anderson at a writers group and agrees to meet him for dinner at the Local Crab, thinking they will talk about writing but he turns out to be a master complainer about everything at the restaurant so she calls him out on his rude behaviour then leaves. Within days, the "critic" is found dead. Despite having an iron clad alibi, Meg is still drawn into the investigation and with the help of her boyfriend Dalton and best friend Natasha, they look to find the truth and catch a killer.
As for the murder - no surprise as to who the victim was, but figuring out the whodunit and why was a bit more complicated. So many potential suspects - restaurant chefs or perhaps an ex? Several well placed red herrings and misdirection but I did have it down to a couple of people and figured out who was responsible before the reveal.
This story was quite interesting. Chapter titles describe tips for amateur sleuth's. Meg tries to write her book while trying to solve the murder as well as maintain her work life and relationships.
The core characters are a nice mix of ages and backgrounds. Family relationships can be strained at times and changes aren't always easy to accept. Luckily for Meg she has a real keeper of a beau in Dalton! Her BFF Natasha may have some bad luck at times but she is loyal and an awesome baker. Meg's brother Junior can be a bit overbearing at times but he does mean well. Her dog Watson is an adorable scene stealer!
All the descriptions of food in the book had my taste buds drooling! A recipe is include at the end of the book as well as a sneak peak at a book from another series of Ms. Cahoon's.
Overall, an entertaining cozy read!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Lynn Cahoon has another winner on her hands. I really liked the concept of this series when I read the first book, but I wasn't 100% sure I was a Meg fan. Fortunately, in this book, Meg has settled down a little bit. Sure, she is incredibly busy working for her Mom at the bookstore, Lilly, working as her writer's assistant, taking classes, and working on her book, but now she is organized and has purpose! At Lilly's suggestion, she starts attending a writer's group that meets at a local restaurant on Tuesday nights. There Meg meets Lee, who is a restaurant critic for a Seattle newspaper, and since they both write nonfiction, when he asks her to go with him to a local restaurant, he is reviewing the next night to help hide his purpose she agrees. Meg soon realizes she made a mistake when he is horrid to everyone in the place, complains about everything, and is surely going to give this lovely restaurant a terrible review! Pushed to her limit before dessert can be served, Meg gets up and leaves, making sure he knows she thinks he's a jerk. A couple of days later, when Lee is found at the ferry parking lot in his car with a bullet in his head, Meg's Uncle Troy has some serious questions for her. Who wanted Lee gone? Why had he been trying to meet her? Did they have people in common, or had a restaurant owner been pushed to the limit with a bad review??? Come along as Meg works on her book, her own questions about a connection with Lee, and a desire to see justice done. Many thanks to #Netgally, #Kensingtonbooks, and the author for an opportunity to read. #ConfessionsofanAmateurSleuth #ABainbridgeIslandMystery #LynnCahoon #bookreview #bookideas #retiredreader
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.25 stars
Meg Gates is working as an author's assistant and helping in her mom's bookstore on Bainbridge Island, near Seattle. She discovered she has a knack for solving crimes and is writing a book full of tips she's learned through her sleuthing. We get to see those tips because they're the chapter headings for the story. The book can work as a standalone, but the first book besides being a fun read, gives a lot of background information on Meg and her writing goals
Meg meets a food critic at a local writing class but storms out of their dinner after he embarasses the staff and Meg with all his demands and complaints. When he's found dead, Meg becomes one of the many suspects in his death. Meg uses her own tips and adds to her sleuthing tips as she looks into Lee's death and finds not all is what it seems. Luckily she has her boyfriend and her best friend to help find the real killer.
This is a cute series with a fun premise of the main character writing a book about how to become an amateur sleuth. Meg is very busy with all her activities - she even takes up Pickleball - so there is a lot to keep the reader interested. We don't get to see as much of her on the job as the author's assistant, but there are plenty of other things going on. I really like Meg, her boyfriend, and friends. Her mom is growing on me, but I don't care for her brother at all even though it seems like he does love his sister. I was surprised by some of the reveals at the end and I look forward to the next book in the series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook from Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
Meg Gates is working as an author's assistant and helping in her mom's bookstore on Bainbridge Island, near Seattle. She discovered she has a knack for solving crimes and is writing a book full of tips she's learned through her sleuthing. We get to see those tips because they're the chapter headings for the story. The book can work as a standalone, but the first book besides being a fun read, gives a lot of background information on Meg and her writing goals
Meg meets a food critic at a local writing class but storms out of their dinner after he embarasses the staff and Meg with all his demands and complaints. When he's found dead, Meg becomes one of the many suspects in his death. Meg uses her own tips and adds to her sleuthing tips as she looks into Lee's death and finds not all is what it seems. Luckily she has her boyfriend and her best friend to help find the real killer.
This is a cute series with a fun premise of the main character writing a book about how to become an amateur sleuth. Meg is very busy with all her activities - she even takes up Pickleball - so there is a lot to keep the reader interested. We don't get to see as much of her on the job as the author's assistant, but there are plenty of other things going on. I really like Meg, her boyfriend, and friends. Her mom is growing on me, but I don't care for her brother at all even though it seems like he does love his sister. I was surprised by some of the reveals at the end and I look forward to the next book in the series.
I received an advance copy of this ebook from Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was another super fun read. I was happy to be able to pick this up right after finishing the first book to see what Meg, Dalton, and Natasha got up to this time. It was really interesting to see where the author took all of the various threads she started in the first book. Some I expected, and others were a bit of a surprise.
The mystery in this one was just as good as the last. I've been trying more to guess the culprit as I read mysteries, and this one kept me guessing the entire time. The author does a good job of sprinkling in different suspects and unraveling their motives until they find the right person. The secondary plot points also help keep things moving at a good pace without being annoying.
I'm curious to see where this series goes with a few of the long-term plot threads. Also, how many people are going to die on this seemingly tiny island? I guess tourists do bring in a new supply of "bodies."
This is shaping up to be another excellent cozy mystery series by this author. She manages to balance both the plot and character development well without either suffering for it.
A big thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an ARC. I'm rather proud to have beat the release date on this one. Here's to hoping I can continue knocking these out.
The mystery in this one was just as good as the last. I've been trying more to guess the culprit as I read mysteries, and this one kept me guessing the entire time. The author does a good job of sprinkling in different suspects and unraveling their motives until they find the right person. The secondary plot points also help keep things moving at a good pace without being annoying.
I'm curious to see where this series goes with a few of the long-term plot threads. Also, how many people are going to die on this seemingly tiny island? I guess tourists do bring in a new supply of "bodies."
This is shaping up to be another excellent cozy mystery series by this author. She manages to balance both the plot and character development well without either suffering for it.
A big thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for giving me an ARC. I'm rather proud to have beat the release date on this one. Here's to hoping I can continue knocking these out.
April 28, 2026
This is the second book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series by Lynn Cahoon. The amateur sleuth is a budding writer, bookseller & college student.
This is not my favorite series by Ms. Cahoon. I found her others to more engaging and I cared more about the characters in the other series. I am amazed at the numerous series Ms. Cahoon has in publication. If you like this series give the others a try.
The recurring characters are slowly revealing themselves to the reader. Meg Gates meets a fellow writer at the local writers’ group. She agrees to dinner with him. Her plan is to pick his brain about writing issues, techniques or methods for publishing and so forth. None of that comes to fruition before she storms out of the restaurant.
With the help of her boyfriend, Dalton, and friends called the Mystery Crew, they become involved in investigating a death of the writer she stormed out of the restaurant to get away from him.
We learn more about Meg’s family, her mother’s recent dating, and her relationship with all the members. Irene, who was a big PITA in the previous book hasn’t mellowed, yet.
Looking forward to the next installment. This book leaves you hanging or more importantly anticipating the next book.
I was given an advanced readers e-copy of the book from Netgalley. I am not required to leave a positive review. These are my own opinions.
This is not my favorite series by Ms. Cahoon. I found her others to more engaging and I cared more about the characters in the other series. I am amazed at the numerous series Ms. Cahoon has in publication. If you like this series give the others a try.
The recurring characters are slowly revealing themselves to the reader. Meg Gates meets a fellow writer at the local writers’ group. She agrees to dinner with him. Her plan is to pick his brain about writing issues, techniques or methods for publishing and so forth. None of that comes to fruition before she storms out of the restaurant.
With the help of her boyfriend, Dalton, and friends called the Mystery Crew, they become involved in investigating a death of the writer she stormed out of the restaurant to get away from him.
We learn more about Meg’s family, her mother’s recent dating, and her relationship with all the members. Irene, who was a big PITA in the previous book hasn’t mellowed, yet.
Looking forward to the next installment. This book leaves you hanging or more importantly anticipating the next book.
I was given an advanced readers e-copy of the book from Netgalley. I am not required to leave a positive review. These are my own opinions.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you NetGalley and Kensington Publishing Corp. for the opportunity to read "Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth" in exchange for my honest review.
This is the second book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series and continues with Meg Gates' plans to have a book published. As she works on her guide to being a detective she once again stumbles into a mystery.
Meg works for her mother at Island Books and she also works for L.C. Aster. Encouraged to attend writer's meetings and that is where she meets Lee Anderson. He tells Meg that he is a food critic and invites her to dinner as his "cover". When Meg realizes what type of column he really writes, she storms out of the Local Crab. Later she is classed as the mystery woman who argued with the victim.
This story combines the world of restaurants, reviews (good and bad) and murder. As well as learning what Meg's mother has been keeping as a secret, Meg continues to fend off Irene's sales pitch for cruises.
A great story and Ms. Cahoon's skill at creating characters that you care about make this a wonderful series. Looking forward to more adventures on Bainbridge Island.
This is the second book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series and continues with Meg Gates' plans to have a book published. As she works on her guide to being a detective she once again stumbles into a mystery.
Meg works for her mother at Island Books and she also works for L.C. Aster. Encouraged to attend writer's meetings and that is where she meets Lee Anderson. He tells Meg that he is a food critic and invites her to dinner as his "cover". When Meg realizes what type of column he really writes, she storms out of the Local Crab. Later she is classed as the mystery woman who argued with the victim.
This story combines the world of restaurants, reviews (good and bad) and murder. As well as learning what Meg's mother has been keeping as a secret, Meg continues to fend off Irene's sales pitch for cruises.
A great story and Ms. Cahoon's skill at creating characters that you care about make this a wonderful series. Looking forward to more adventures on Bainbridge Island.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I enjoyed this one just as much as the first book, which is always a win! I love the way this author writes and creates characters. Bainbridge Island sounds like such a lovely place and this book focuses on the restaurants there so of course I was hungry the entire time! I loved seeing the growing relationship between Dalton and Meg and how he is so sweet, keeping her on track with her book, her sleuthing and taking care of her dog! The mystery was really good and I loved the balance between that and the new things in Meg's life with her family dynamics. I also really appreciated how it showcased the balance for a starting out author, who has to balance her day job (s), along with family and friends. It's a lot and it takes real time management and perseverance to commit to it day after day and I admire that so much. The entire story was compelling and I loved the twists and the ending! I already can't wait to see what happens next for Meg.
Thanks to the publisher for an ARC; my thoughts and review are my own.
Thanks to the publisher for an ARC; my thoughts and review are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I love to read books where you not only get a great story with amazing characters but where you also learn something. This book is all that and more. You get the small town, family drama, and friends you can count on, but with a side of learning how to be a sleuth. The dynamic between the police chief and Meg makes this work too.
Meg has decided she wants to try her hand about writing a book and her decision is about being an amateur sleuth. For me, this makes an interesting take on your typical cozy mystery. It has all the things you get in one but in a different way. She is sleuthing but she uses it at plot points for her book. SO you get to see what works and what doesn't when being a sleuth. I mean I would definitely buy her book.
For those that are looking for not your typical cozy then look no more, this is it. It's funny and relatable with an interesting twist.
Let the sleuthing begin
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington for the ARC for my honest review.
Meg has decided she wants to try her hand about writing a book and her decision is about being an amateur sleuth. For me, this makes an interesting take on your typical cozy mystery. It has all the things you get in one but in a different way. She is sleuthing but she uses it at plot points for her book. SO you get to see what works and what doesn't when being a sleuth. I mean I would definitely buy her book.
For those that are looking for not your typical cozy then look no more, this is it. It's funny and relatable with an interesting twist.
Let the sleuthing begin
Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington for the ARC for my honest review.
April 30, 2026
Great book by one of my favorite writers. I did miss the first book in this series, but while there are a couple references to what happened in it, nothing that would give away the plot or that made me feel I was missing information on this one. Could be read as a stand-alone if you wanted to. The book has titles for each chapter like the list the main character (Meg) is making for the books she's currently writing, and they all seem to "match" what happens in each chapter.
Meg is navigating the post breakup world after her -insert not nice name- former fiancé cheats on her with her best friend/bridesmaid. It's an identifiable take on what happens when life throws you for a loop and you're left kind of lost in the aftermath. Meg has returned home, embraces her new life and reconnects with some old friends who help her sleuth out the mystery. Satisfying ending, but you know there's going to be another book (there'd better be) to continue the series on.
I received an advanced reader copy of this title from NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Meg is navigating the post breakup world after her -insert not nice name- former fiancé cheats on her with her best friend/bridesmaid. It's an identifiable take on what happens when life throws you for a loop and you're left kind of lost in the aftermath. Meg has returned home, embraces her new life and reconnects with some old friends who help her sleuth out the mystery. Satisfying ending, but you know there's going to be another book (there'd better be) to continue the series on.
I received an advanced reader copy of this title from NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is the second book in Lynn Cahoon's Bainbridge Island Mystery series. The atmospheric setting of the island is perfect for this mystery series. The core cast of characters draw me in with their friendships, and the well-written mystery keeps me there.
Meg is struggling with her parents' after-divorce lives, even though she is grown and on her own. This subplot appeals to me because too many grown children take the same attitudes in real life. Ms. Cahoon handled it well.
Meg is working hard to make a success of her budding writing career, while working and sleuthing. Her relatives still rally around to provide food and help out. I like the strides she is making in her personal and family relationships.
Thank you #NetGalley #KensingtonPublishing #LynnCahoon for the opportunity to read and review #ConfessionsofanAmateurSleuth. All thoughts and opinions are my own. #BainbridgeIslandMystery
Meg is struggling with her parents' after-divorce lives, even though she is grown and on her own. This subplot appeals to me because too many grown children take the same attitudes in real life. Ms. Cahoon handled it well.
Meg is working hard to make a success of her budding writing career, while working and sleuthing. Her relatives still rally around to provide food and help out. I like the strides she is making in her personal and family relationships.
Thank you #NetGalley #KensingtonPublishing #LynnCahoon for the opportunity to read and review #ConfessionsofanAmateurSleuth. All thoughts and opinions are my own. #BainbridgeIslandMystery
April 28, 2026
Meg Gates is finding her footing after her wedding debacle in the first book. She has 2 jobs, making enough to get by, a new love interest, has started writing a book,and is reconnecting with old friends. At the writers group, she meets Lee Anderson, a former resident of the island, now a food critic. He asks her to join him at an island restaurant for "cover". He is so obnoxious that Meg walks out. Good thing she has an unbreakable alibi when he is found dead in his car!
It is wonderful to see Meg blossom after playing second fiddle to her brother (who loves her under his stiff priggish manner) all her life and feeling like she was always second (or third) best. Her best friend, mom and aunt and uncle are so supportive as well as her author employer. Her boyfriend, Dalton, is her biggest fan. Even her dad seems to be softening towards her, maybe even thinking she might actually "amount to something".
I am really enjoying this series and can't wait to see what's next for Meg!
It is wonderful to see Meg blossom after playing second fiddle to her brother (who loves her under his stiff priggish manner) all her life and feeling like she was always second (or third) best. Her best friend, mom and aunt and uncle are so supportive as well as her author employer. Her boyfriend, Dalton, is her biggest fan. Even her dad seems to be softening towards her, maybe even thinking she might actually "amount to something".
I am really enjoying this series and can't wait to see what's next for Meg!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
As much as I love Lynn Cahoon's writing, I had slightly lower expectations for her newest series, A Bainbridge Island Mystery, because the premise didn't excite me, but I should have had faith in the strength Ms. Cahoon brings to every series; this one is no exception. Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth demonstrates her special talent in creating strong characters and tantalizing plots and never falls back on the trite situations that too many cozy mysteries do.
Spending time with Meg and her friends brings the warmth that I need in a cozy mystery. In her investigations, Meg uses her brain and follows the advice of those around her to avoid common pitfalls of lesser series. Once she figures out who the villain is, we can see the path that she followed to get there. I am ready to visit Bainbridge Island.
#Netgally #KensingtonPublishing #ABainbridgeIslandMystery #ConfessionsofanAmateurSleuth #LynnCahoon
Spending time with Meg and her friends brings the warmth that I need in a cozy mystery. In her investigations, Meg uses her brain and follows the advice of those around her to avoid common pitfalls of lesser series. Once she figures out who the villain is, we can see the path that she followed to get there. I am ready to visit Bainbridge Island.
#Netgally #KensingtonPublishing #ABainbridgeIslandMystery #ConfessionsofanAmateurSleuth #LynnCahoon
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Love this series! I love the small town feel and how Meg is trying to further her career and make new associates. Starting a career is hard and I'm glad its shown in the book that success doesn't come automatically like in alot of cozy books that she's working to obtain her goal.
The characters are well written and their interactions are entertaining. I love how Meg and her friends get together weekly for dinner and discuss the murder.
The only thing that I thought was alittle over the top was how both Meg and her brother couldn't get used to their mom dating, they are in their late 20's so I feel like why are they so focused an having their parents get back together especially when their dad has been remarried for a few years. The focus on that could have been less. Other then that I enjoyed everything else about the book and can't wait for the next book in the series.
The characters are well written and their interactions are entertaining. I love how Meg and her friends get together weekly for dinner and discuss the murder.
The only thing that I thought was alittle over the top was how both Meg and her brother couldn't get used to their mom dating, they are in their late 20's so I feel like why are they so focused an having their parents get back together especially when their dad has been remarried for a few years. The focus on that could have been less. Other then that I enjoyed everything else about the book and can't wait for the next book in the series.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth by Lynn Cahoon is the first A Bainbridge Island Mystery. The story leaned more toward family drama and romance than cozy mystery. Meg Gates is upset that her mother began dating and that she did not tell her. Meg’s brother, Junior, who is the apple of his father’s eye, handles the situation immaturely. Meg’s boyfriend, Dalton is too good to be true (I wish all men were like this guy). The mystery lacked excitement, featuring only basic investigation and discussion. Meg is writing a book on amateur detective work and applied her own tips during the case investigation. The narrative unfolded slowly, repeating certain elements throughout. Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is a pleasant read, though I believe its characters could be fleshed out further, especially alongside a more intricate mystery.
May 4, 2026
Thank you to Kensington Publishing for the free digital read through NetGalley and for the free book in exchange for my honest review of Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth by Lynn Cahoon.
This is the second book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series and I’m already looking forward to the next one. Meg is such a fun character to follow as she realizes that solving real life crimes might come more naturally to her than writing. What happens though when a food critic ends up dead? Well pick up this book and follow Meg along to find out who did it. I loved the small town atmosphere, all the characters and the way the author keeps you guessing until the very end. Meg especially shines in this book she’s easy to root for and fun to follow.
Overall, this was a delightful cozy mystery that I loved and would recommend to any reader especially to those who love cozy mysteries.
This is the second book in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series and I’m already looking forward to the next one. Meg is such a fun character to follow as she realizes that solving real life crimes might come more naturally to her than writing. What happens though when a food critic ends up dead? Well pick up this book and follow Meg along to find out who did it. I loved the small town atmosphere, all the characters and the way the author keeps you guessing until the very end. Meg especially shines in this book she’s easy to root for and fun to follow.
Overall, this was a delightful cozy mystery that I loved and would recommend to any reader especially to those who love cozy mysteries.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Watson... you're amazing. You have the right vibe: food, movies/home reno shows, walks, killin' it.
Otherwise, I'm not sure this series is for me, and that's okay. While I like that there is a group of friends trying to solve murders, I'm simply not able to give Meg an ounce of sympathy for ANY of her issues - mainly because I feel she manufactures a lot of them, and at her age, it doesn't work.
After the first book, I thought there were a few kinks to work out but I had hoped that being a lover of Bainbridge, I would really enjoy this series. Unfortunately it's not turning out that way. For those who love Meg and team, I wish you many more stories to solve.
Thank you to the publisher via netgalley for this book.
Otherwise, I'm not sure this series is for me, and that's okay. While I like that there is a group of friends trying to solve murders, I'm simply not able to give Meg an ounce of sympathy for ANY of her issues - mainly because I feel she manufactures a lot of them, and at her age, it doesn't work.
After the first book, I thought there were a few kinks to work out but I had hoped that being a lover of Bainbridge, I would really enjoy this series. Unfortunately it's not turning out that way. For those who love Meg and team, I wish you many more stories to solve.
Thank you to the publisher via netgalley for this book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth by Lynn Cahoon is the first book by this author I have read.
I enjoy cozy mystery books a lot and this one was very good. Meg Gates is a book seller along with an amateur sleuth. The combination of her talents mesh together well. She has a murder to solve and along with others she knows it will not be an easy murder to figure out.
It took me a bit to start to like Meg but I got to know her after a few pages in the book I think I have figured her out more the more I read.
I am looking forward to reading other books in this series.
Thank you NetGalley, Lynn Cahoon and Kensington Publishing for the copy of Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth. This is my personal review.
I enjoy cozy mystery books a lot and this one was very good. Meg Gates is a book seller along with an amateur sleuth. The combination of her talents mesh together well. She has a murder to solve and along with others she knows it will not be an easy murder to figure out.
It took me a bit to start to like Meg but I got to know her after a few pages in the book I think I have figured her out more the more I read.
I am looking forward to reading other books in this series.
Thank you NetGalley, Lynn Cahoon and Kensington Publishing for the copy of Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth. This is my personal review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Meg is working on her amateur sleuth guide book, well mostly. Her life on Bainbridge Island is keeping her busy with two jobs, and she has returned to university. Meg and Dalton are dating. Life is pretty full, so writing her book is falling to the back burner.
On the recommendation of the author Meg works for, Meg attends the local writers group where she meets Lee, a food critic for a paper in Seattle. A few days later Lee is dead.
This return to Bainbridge Island, and the window on Meg’s life was just as enjoyable as the first book. I love how the story is written. I recommend joining Meg, Dalton and family for this second Bainbridge Island mystery.
Thanks to Netgalley and Kensington for the opportunity to read this book.
On the recommendation of the author Meg works for, Meg attends the local writers group where she meets Lee, a food critic for a paper in Seattle. A few days later Lee is dead.
This return to Bainbridge Island, and the window on Meg’s life was just as enjoyable as the first book. I love how the story is written. I recommend joining Meg, Dalton and family for this second Bainbridge Island mystery.
Thanks to Netgalley and Kensington for the opportunity to read this book.
April 29, 2026
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is a cozy mystery centered on an amateur investigator operating within a close knit community setting on Bainbridge Island.
Meg Gates functions as both aspiring writer and developing sleuth, with her investigative process closely tied to her attempts to understand detective work in a structured way. The narrative balances personal development with case progression.
The island setting provides a contained environment where social and professional relationships overlap, creating a naturally focused suspect pool and steady investigative flow.
A character driven cozy mystery for readers who enjoy amateur detectives, small community settings, and lightly procedural storytelling.
Meg Gates functions as both aspiring writer and developing sleuth, with her investigative process closely tied to her attempts to understand detective work in a structured way. The narrative balances personal development with case progression.
The island setting provides a contained environment where social and professional relationships overlap, creating a naturally focused suspect pool and steady investigative flow.
A character driven cozy mystery for readers who enjoy amateur detectives, small community settings, and lightly procedural storytelling.
May 9, 2026
Confessions of an Amateur Sleuth is the second cozy mystery in the Bainbridge Island Mystery series. Meg is settling into her life in Bainbridge, but is struggling to write the book she’s trying to tackle. She joins a writers group to try and get herself over the finish line but when a body is discovered her attention is pulled in that direction. Unable to stop until she’s out the pieces together Meg is determined to figure out the truth.
This is a good second mystery in this series and I’m really loving these characters and this town. I love everything I’ve read by Lynn Cahoon and this series is no different. This mystery pulled me in and kept me guessing as the puzzle unfolded. I enjoyed this mystery and look forward to seeing what else comes in this series.
This is a good second mystery in this series and I’m really loving these characters and this town. I love everything I’ve read by Lynn Cahoon and this series is no different. This mystery pulled me in and kept me guessing as the puzzle unfolded. I enjoyed this mystery and look forward to seeing what else comes in this series.
Read
March 13, 2026I’m honestly not quite sure what to say about this one. It was an okay read, but it didn’t feel like most cozy mysteries I’ve read. While there was a mystery, a lot of the story focused on Meg’s mom and her new relationship, which I personally didn’t care.This is the second book in the series, and I haven’t read the first, but I didn’t feel lost reading it out of order.
The cover is super cute and is actually what caught my attention in the first place. Overall, I’d be willing to try another book by this author, but I’m not sure I’d continue with this particular series.
Thank you NetGalley, and Kensington Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this advanced copy.
The cover is super cute and is actually what caught my attention in the first place. Overall, I’d be willing to try another book by this author, but I’m not sure I’d continue with this particular series.
Thank you NetGalley, and Kensington Publishing for the opportunity to read and review this advanced copy.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I definitely loved this more complex book two in the Bainbridge Island mystery series. Meg is more comfortable in her role with her best selling author boss and she is finding a steady rhythm with mom until she learns, mom is finally dating after her divorce. Dalton is a calm center for her as she focuses more on writing her book and trying to find out who faked the suicide of a food critic and reporter she had picked the brain of hours before for tips on writing non-fiction. It is sure a twisty road Meg travels down but her inner Nancy Drew is on the case. The writing style of Canon flows and it is easy to invest in the few hours it takes to read this wonderful mystery.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews