What do you think?
Rate this book
The Noble Exiles #1
A Tempest of Ravens
Outlander
meets One Dark Window in this sweeping and visceral historical romantasy.
SCOTLAND 1651. THE KINGDOM IS ABLAZE WITH WAR AND WITCHES' PYRES.
Maeve MacDonnell has spent years being haunted by croaking ravens, terrifying visions, and uncanny abilities she can’t explain. She'd give anything to be free of them—or to finally control them.
After the superstitious local villagers force her out of town, an alluring stranger named Eamon comes to her aid. As their connection deepens, he encourages her to embrace her abilities. And as her power grows, so does their undeniable chemistry.
When they're ambushed by the invading English army—who are hell-bent on conquering Scotland and turning every witch to ash—Maeve and Eamon flee to the last Scottish-held castle.
Thrust into a brutal web of deceit, and besieged by enemies on all sides, Maeve must rely on her chaotic magic to survive. It could be the key to saving the kingdom and everyone she loves—but only if she can harness it in time.
Inspired by real events and perfect for fans of Rachel Gillig and Diana Gabaldon, this atmospheric historical romantasy is the first book in the Noble Exiles series.
Praise for A Tempest of
"This book was a deep witchy exorcism/therapy for my soul." - early reader review
"Like stepping into a dream you never want to leave. Enchanting, evocative, and steeped in the kind of mystical lore that lingers long after the final page." - early reader review
"E.A. Bard expertly weaves history, magic, and romance into a delightful read. She casts a spell on the reader with her clever, witty writing and appreciation for Scotland's 17th-century history. You won't regret picking up A Tempest of Ravens." - early reader review
"A Tempest of Ravens is a breath of fresh air in the historical romance genre, with a fantastical bent. With characters you can't help but relate to (and swoon over), settings that are so vivid it makes history come alive, and writing that is elegant, sharp and intentional, the care and craft reflected in this story are top-notch. I can't wait to see what Bard writes next!" - Nicole Evans, author of Blood Price
SCOTLAND 1651. THE KINGDOM IS ABLAZE WITH WAR AND WITCHES' PYRES.
Maeve MacDonnell has spent years being haunted by croaking ravens, terrifying visions, and uncanny abilities she can’t explain. She'd give anything to be free of them—or to finally control them.
After the superstitious local villagers force her out of town, an alluring stranger named Eamon comes to her aid. As their connection deepens, he encourages her to embrace her abilities. And as her power grows, so does their undeniable chemistry.
When they're ambushed by the invading English army—who are hell-bent on conquering Scotland and turning every witch to ash—Maeve and Eamon flee to the last Scottish-held castle.
Thrust into a brutal web of deceit, and besieged by enemies on all sides, Maeve must rely on her chaotic magic to survive. It could be the key to saving the kingdom and everyone she loves—but only if she can harness it in time.
Inspired by real events and perfect for fans of Rachel Gillig and Diana Gabaldon, this atmospheric historical romantasy is the first book in the Noble Exiles series.
Praise for A Tempest of
"This book was a deep witchy exorcism/therapy for my soul." - early reader review
"Like stepping into a dream you never want to leave. Enchanting, evocative, and steeped in the kind of mystical lore that lingers long after the final page." - early reader review
"E.A. Bard expertly weaves history, magic, and romance into a delightful read. She casts a spell on the reader with her clever, witty writing and appreciation for Scotland's 17th-century history. You won't regret picking up A Tempest of Ravens." - early reader review
"A Tempest of Ravens is a breath of fresh air in the historical romance genre, with a fantastical bent. With characters you can't help but relate to (and swoon over), settings that are so vivid it makes history come alive, and writing that is elegant, sharp and intentional, the care and craft reflected in this story are top-notch. I can't wait to see what Bard writes next!" - Nicole Evans, author of Blood Price
401 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 24, 2025
20 people are currently reading
535 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews
Currently reading
September 11, 2025──★ ˙ 𝐏𝐫𝐞 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝 ̟ !!
I am actually so excited for this book because this is my first arc from nerd fam !! But I’ll my expectations low and see if it is successful in surprising me because historical fiction fantasy with old and complicated English is not one of my favourite things in a book…
I am actually so excited for this book because this is my first arc from nerd fam !! But I’ll my expectations low and see if it is successful in surprising me because historical fiction fantasy with old and complicated English is not one of my favourite things in a book…
November 9, 2025
The concept of this book was really intriguing. Unfortunately I was bored to tears while reading this. Even when exciting scenes were happening. It was still somehow boring. I did not feel connected to any of these characters and therefore I didn’t really believe the romance either.
It started getting very repetitive, her powers not helping or her constant “I’m cursed”. I understand but I’m over it.
Honestly It felt like the love interests barely even spoke to each other. Why should I want you two together? Have some deeper conversations please.
The only moment to move me was the cliff scene. That was well done.
Some of the reason I don’t vibe probably stems from the historical language used. They all speak so proper that the spice felt wrong.
Thank you for this arc!
It started getting very repetitive, her powers not helping or her constant “I’m cursed”. I understand but I’m over it.
Honestly It felt like the love interests barely even spoke to each other. Why should I want you two together? Have some deeper conversations please.
The only moment to move me was the cliff scene. That was well done.
Some of the reason I don’t vibe probably stems from the historical language used. They all speak so proper that the spice felt wrong.
Thank you for this arc!
August 6, 2025
Vivid, sweeping, and atmospheric. With an evocative setting, tight plot, and heroine you want to root for right away, A Tempest of Ravens hits ALL the right notes, perfect for historical fantasy lovers!
October 13, 2025
A Tempest of Ravens book one of The Noble Exiles series by E.A. Bard
Rating: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
3.75-4 stars.
I think the author coined this genre perfectly in her author’s note…A Historical Fantasy Romance. (Historical Romantasy then?) It’s being published on October 24th and it is indeed the perfect novel to read with All Hallow’s Eve looming before us.
This book hits on many levels. It’s set in 1650’s Scotland when the country was rife with war and England trying to snuff out the Scottish Highlanders. A time when people were persecuted for being different and accused witches were burned on the pyre. This setting alone really lit my synapses on fire and set the tone for something I anticipated would be a very enjoyable read. And, it was.
I have a love/hate affinity with our FMC Maeve. She’s the village outcast (I love an underdog!) with her visions and her call to ravens but she really annoyed me. A lot. She’s insecure with who she is and she’s a people pleaser (that’s not always a bad trait,) she is stubborn and determined (also not bad,) BUT she’s also a ginormous brat, she’s impatient and because of her impatience she doesn’t heed sound advice and often causes avoidable chaos. Her brothers are the only family she has and they’ve grown up trying to protect her. She ends up promised to a man from a family she’s never met from some castle that is over a weeks travel away. Before she can start her journey, the village turns on her and she’s saved by a pair of cattle raiders that intervene. Enter Eamon and Taryn. They assist her brother with escorting her to meet her betrothed and THIS is where the adventure really begins.
Although I often rolled my eyes at Maeve, these characters are written wonderfully. Eamon is a swoon worthy MMC. He’s dark and brooding but the mask fleetingly falls on occasion for Maeve. He’s got an interesting back story, he’s honorable and when he shows his vulnerability it’s breathtaking. Taryn and Brahan have got to be two of the best support characters I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading. It was easy to get emotionally invested in all of them.
The world building was on point, especially with all the historical references to the period time. The magic system was fascinating and evoked the same feelings from me that were present in Maeve, frenzied panic, fear, shock and awe . The slow burn romance was done just right, a seamless sub plot that enhanced the overall story telling. The only issues I really had (besides Maeve,) were the plot twists. They were either entirely predictable (worthy of eye rolls,) or too rushed. At about 80% in, every thing culminates very quickly and you’re given whiplash trying to keep up.
Overall, a fantastic read. I loved the historical theme, the witchcraft and magic, the found family vibes and yes, even the damn romance. I am looking forward to the next installment of this series.
Thank you to NerdFam and author E. A. Bard for the digital advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Rating: ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️
3.75-4 stars.
I think the author coined this genre perfectly in her author’s note…A Historical Fantasy Romance. (Historical Romantasy then?) It’s being published on October 24th and it is indeed the perfect novel to read with All Hallow’s Eve looming before us.
This book hits on many levels. It’s set in 1650’s Scotland when the country was rife with war and England trying to snuff out the Scottish Highlanders. A time when people were persecuted for being different and accused witches were burned on the pyre. This setting alone really lit my synapses on fire and set the tone for something I anticipated would be a very enjoyable read. And, it was.
I have a love/hate affinity with our FMC Maeve. She’s the village outcast (I love an underdog!) with her visions and her call to ravens but she really annoyed me. A lot. She’s insecure with who she is and she’s a people pleaser (that’s not always a bad trait,) she is stubborn and determined (also not bad,) BUT she’s also a ginormous brat, she’s impatient and because of her impatience she doesn’t heed sound advice and often causes avoidable chaos. Her brothers are the only family she has and they’ve grown up trying to protect her. She ends up promised to a man from a family she’s never met from some castle that is over a weeks travel away. Before she can start her journey, the village turns on her and she’s saved by a pair of cattle raiders that intervene. Enter Eamon and Taryn. They assist her brother with escorting her to meet her betrothed and THIS is where the adventure really begins.
Although I often rolled my eyes at Maeve, these characters are written wonderfully. Eamon is a swoon worthy MMC. He’s dark and brooding but the mask fleetingly falls on occasion for Maeve. He’s got an interesting back story, he’s honorable and when he shows his vulnerability it’s breathtaking. Taryn and Brahan have got to be two of the best support characters I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading. It was easy to get emotionally invested in all of them.
The world building was on point, especially with all the historical references to the period time. The magic system was fascinating and evoked the same feelings from me that were present in Maeve, frenzied panic, fear, shock and awe . The slow burn romance was done just right, a seamless sub plot that enhanced the overall story telling. The only issues I really had (besides Maeve,) were the plot twists. They were either entirely predictable (worthy of eye rolls,) or too rushed. At about 80% in, every thing culminates very quickly and you’re given whiplash trying to keep up.
Overall, a fantastic read. I loved the historical theme, the witchcraft and magic, the found family vibes and yes, even the damn romance. I am looking forward to the next installment of this series.
Thank you to NerdFam and author E. A. Bard for the digital advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
October 21, 2025
Set in 1651 Scotland, A Tempest of Ravens blends historical fiction, witchcraft, and a touch of fantasy against the haunting backdrop of war and witch hunts. The story follows Maeve MacDonnell, an outcast haunted by ravens and strange visions, whose path collides with a mysterious stranger named Eamon as danger closes in.
I went in with high hopes after seeing it compared to Outlander and One Dark Window, and while I understand those comparisons, it didn’t quite live up to them for me. The strongest part of the book is definitely the atmosphere the Scottish highlands, the tension of the time period, and the moody sense of magic were beautifully done. Maeve was an interesting main character, and I enjoyed watching her begin to step into her power. Eamon brought warmth and intrigue to the story, and their slow-burn romance was believable and well paced without overshadowing the rest of the plot.
Where it fell short for me was in the pacing and consistency. Some moments felt rushed, while others dragged with overly long descriptions. I also wished the magic and romance had been developed more evenly throughout instead of appearing in bursts. The one “spice” scene felt a little misplaced compared to the tone of the rest of the book.
Even so, I liked the overall concept and the way the ending set up the sequel it feels like Maeve’s story is just getting started. If you enjoy historical fiction with a witchy twist, moody settings, forbidden powers, and a soft slow-burn romance, this is worth picking up.
Thank you so much to E.A. Bard and The Nerd Fam for the ARC of A Tempest of Ravens in exchange of my honest review! 🐦⬛
I went in with high hopes after seeing it compared to Outlander and One Dark Window, and while I understand those comparisons, it didn’t quite live up to them for me. The strongest part of the book is definitely the atmosphere the Scottish highlands, the tension of the time period, and the moody sense of magic were beautifully done. Maeve was an interesting main character, and I enjoyed watching her begin to step into her power. Eamon brought warmth and intrigue to the story, and their slow-burn romance was believable and well paced without overshadowing the rest of the plot.
Where it fell short for me was in the pacing and consistency. Some moments felt rushed, while others dragged with overly long descriptions. I also wished the magic and romance had been developed more evenly throughout instead of appearing in bursts. The one “spice” scene felt a little misplaced compared to the tone of the rest of the book.
Even so, I liked the overall concept and the way the ending set up the sequel it feels like Maeve’s story is just getting started. If you enjoy historical fiction with a witchy twist, moody settings, forbidden powers, and a soft slow-burn romance, this is worth picking up.
Thank you so much to E.A. Bard and The Nerd Fam for the ARC of A Tempest of Ravens in exchange of my honest review! 🐦⬛
October 25, 2025
Thank you to The Nerd Fam and author E. A. Bird for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
A Tempest of Ravens is set in 1651 Scotland. This story follows Maeve, a young woman with strange powers and haunting visions she can’t control. When her village drives her out, she’s rescued by our MMC, a mysterious stranger who helps her tap into the magic she’s always feared. As war rages and the English army hunts down witches, Maeve and our MMC’s bond is tested by danger, betrayal, and growing power. It’s a gripping mix of romance, witchcraft, and survival set against a dark, dramatic backdrop.
I thoroughly enjoyed A Tempest of Ravens! It felt like such a fresh take on the fantasy genre, and I was hooked from the very beginning. I constantly wanted to know what was going to happen next.
The characters are all unique and memorable, and I especially loved the found family dynamic woven throughout the story. Maeve, our main character, did have moments where she fell into negativity and self-doubt, and at times it felt a little drawn out. But honestly, that’s part of what made her feel so real. Her insecurities and people-pleasing tendencies were relatable and added depth to her journey of growth and self-acceptance.
The world-building was another highlight for me. It was immersive yet easy to follow, and this first book did a great job setting the stage for the rest of the series.
I absolutely loved the slow-burn romance in this book. As a huge fan of those long, drawn-out connections (the kind where you’re waiting until the 90–95% mark just to see them hold hands), this story delivered exactly the kind of tension I love when reading romantasy.
Overall, A Tempest of Ravens was a captivating read full of heart, magic, and tension. I can’t wait to see where the story goes next!
A Tempest of Ravens is set in 1651 Scotland. This story follows Maeve, a young woman with strange powers and haunting visions she can’t control. When her village drives her out, she’s rescued by our MMC, a mysterious stranger who helps her tap into the magic she’s always feared. As war rages and the English army hunts down witches, Maeve and our MMC’s bond is tested by danger, betrayal, and growing power. It’s a gripping mix of romance, witchcraft, and survival set against a dark, dramatic backdrop.
I thoroughly enjoyed A Tempest of Ravens! It felt like such a fresh take on the fantasy genre, and I was hooked from the very beginning. I constantly wanted to know what was going to happen next.
The characters are all unique and memorable, and I especially loved the found family dynamic woven throughout the story. Maeve, our main character, did have moments where she fell into negativity and self-doubt, and at times it felt a little drawn out. But honestly, that’s part of what made her feel so real. Her insecurities and people-pleasing tendencies were relatable and added depth to her journey of growth and self-acceptance.
The world-building was another highlight for me. It was immersive yet easy to follow, and this first book did a great job setting the stage for the rest of the series.
I absolutely loved the slow-burn romance in this book. As a huge fan of those long, drawn-out connections (the kind where you’re waiting until the 90–95% mark just to see them hold hands), this story delivered exactly the kind of tension I love when reading romantasy.
Overall, A Tempest of Ravens was a captivating read full of heart, magic, and tension. I can’t wait to see where the story goes next!
August 21, 2025
Outlander, but witchier ✨ Aragorn, but kissier ✨ Historical romantasy with feminist self-discovery and empowerment echoing notes of Somna and Monstress, Volume 1: Awakening ✨
A Tempest of Ravens is a sweeping, immersive story set in historical Scotland. We mostly follow Maeve, the sister of a chieftain who has been blamed for ill-happenings in her village since she was a child. The villagers' prejudices and fears incite dangerous conditions for Maeve that lead her, her brothers, and a pair of handsome strangers on a journey avoiding the English, bigotry, and conflicts of their own making and histories.
With dynamic characters I was rooting for, adventure steeped in survival and history, and a slow burn romance, this debut left me wanting more from Bard!
Disclaimer: I am grateful to have been an early reader, but this review reflects my honest perspective.
A Tempest of Ravens is a sweeping, immersive story set in historical Scotland. We mostly follow Maeve, the sister of a chieftain who has been blamed for ill-happenings in her village since she was a child. The villagers' prejudices and fears incite dangerous conditions for Maeve that lead her, her brothers, and a pair of handsome strangers on a journey avoiding the English, bigotry, and conflicts of their own making and histories.
With dynamic characters I was rooting for, adventure steeped in survival and history, and a slow burn romance, this debut left me wanting more from Bard!
Disclaimer: I am grateful to have been an early reader, but this review reflects my honest perspective.
November 12, 2025
a tempest of ravens is the first book in the noble exiles series. it follows Maeve MacDonnell, who has spent years being haunted by croaking ravens terrifying visions, and uncanny abilities she can’t explain. she would do anything to be free of them or to finally control them.
after the superstitious local villagers force her out of town, an alluring stranger named Eamon comes to her aid. as their connection deepens, he encourages her to embrace her abilities. and as her power grows, so does their undeniable chemistry.
when they're ambushed by the invading English army, who are hell-bent on conquering Scotland and turning every witch to ash, Maeve and Eamon flee to the last Scottish-held castle.
thrust into a brutal web of deceit, and besieged by enemies on all sides, Maeve must rely on her chaotic magic to survive. It could be the key to saving the kingdom and everyone she loves—but only if she can harness it in time.
the historical setting with the fantasy element was so well executed!! the magic system was so intriguing and i loved how the ravens were used!! and who doesn’t love a raven familiar??🤭
i felt very connected to Maeve thanks to the amazing writing and i loved seeing her grow into her powers!! she did stress me out at times but i could also understand where she was coming from!!
Eamon is the perfect dark and broody mmc that will have you giggling at 3am🤭 i loved his backstory and his soft moments were everything🥹🤏🏻
the slow burn romance between Maeve and Eamon was SO good!! i am a slow burn romance girlie through and through and this definitely did not disappoint!!
would highly recommend and i cannot wait for the sequel!!
after the superstitious local villagers force her out of town, an alluring stranger named Eamon comes to her aid. as their connection deepens, he encourages her to embrace her abilities. and as her power grows, so does their undeniable chemistry.
when they're ambushed by the invading English army, who are hell-bent on conquering Scotland and turning every witch to ash, Maeve and Eamon flee to the last Scottish-held castle.
thrust into a brutal web of deceit, and besieged by enemies on all sides, Maeve must rely on her chaotic magic to survive. It could be the key to saving the kingdom and everyone she loves—but only if she can harness it in time.
the historical setting with the fantasy element was so well executed!! the magic system was so intriguing and i loved how the ravens were used!! and who doesn’t love a raven familiar??🤭
i felt very connected to Maeve thanks to the amazing writing and i loved seeing her grow into her powers!! she did stress me out at times but i could also understand where she was coming from!!
Eamon is the perfect dark and broody mmc that will have you giggling at 3am🤭 i loved his backstory and his soft moments were everything🥹🤏🏻
the slow burn romance between Maeve and Eamon was SO good!! i am a slow burn romance girlie through and through and this definitely did not disappoint!!
would highly recommend and i cannot wait for the sequel!!
September 26, 2025
A Tempest of Ravens is a feast for anyone who loves fantasy that feels carved from shadow and storm. What struck me most was how the ravens weren’t just omens they were companions, tormentors, and guides. Every time Maeve heard their croak or saw their wings darken the sky, I felt the magic surge in the story.
From the very first time the villagers turned on her, whispering of witchcraft, you knew the ravens were her fate. And then Eamon’s arrival rescuing her, urging her to lean into that power felt like destiny written in feather and blood. Their bond was built not on safety, but on danger and choice: she could hide her gift, or she could wield it.
The English invasion added another layer of terror, but it was in the castle where the ravens truly became her weapon. When Maeve finally accepted them, calling them in a storm of wings, it wasn’t just magic it was defiance. That moment gave me chills. It was like the whole world finally recognized her for what she was: not a victim of superstition, but a woman who owned her power.
The betrayals and twisted loyalties inside the castle stung, but the ravens never lied. They circled, croaked, warned and when she needed them, they answered. That final clash, when Maeve stood with the storm of ravens at her side, was one of the most cinematic, breathtaking endings I’ve read in a long time.
This isn’t just historical fantasy. It’s gothic, moody, and alive with black wings. It’s about owning the parts of yourself others fear and finding freedom in it.
Thank you to the nerd fam for a chance to read this beauty before its release , all thoughts and opinions are my own .
From the very first time the villagers turned on her, whispering of witchcraft, you knew the ravens were her fate. And then Eamon’s arrival rescuing her, urging her to lean into that power felt like destiny written in feather and blood. Their bond was built not on safety, but on danger and choice: she could hide her gift, or she could wield it.
The English invasion added another layer of terror, but it was in the castle where the ravens truly became her weapon. When Maeve finally accepted them, calling them in a storm of wings, it wasn’t just magic it was defiance. That moment gave me chills. It was like the whole world finally recognized her for what she was: not a victim of superstition, but a woman who owned her power.
The betrayals and twisted loyalties inside the castle stung, but the ravens never lied. They circled, croaked, warned and when she needed them, they answered. That final clash, when Maeve stood with the storm of ravens at her side, was one of the most cinematic, breathtaking endings I’ve read in a long time.
This isn’t just historical fantasy. It’s gothic, moody, and alive with black wings. It’s about owning the parts of yourself others fear and finding freedom in it.
Thank you to the nerd fam for a chance to read this beauty before its release , all thoughts and opinions are my own .
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 18, 2025
An atmospheric witchy historical romance ❤️
This book is described as outlander meets one dark window and I’d say this was a pretty accurate description.
This is a story set in Scotland during 1650s. It follows Maeve who is the sister of the MacDonnell clan Laird. Maeve has always been surrounded by bad luck and followed by Ravens which has forced her to live a sheltered life in her home. This is set in a time where suspected witches were being hunted and burned at the stake and so she has hidden away to avoid suspicion, until things change one day! And this is where the story begins.
It was a perfect blend of fantasy and history with a romantic subplot. I found the magic system interesting and although ravens are common in witch stories I feel like this was uniquely done.
There is also a lot of growth and trauma processing in this book with Maeve learning how her magic works and dealing with the events of her past.
The romance if definitely a subplot for this one but I really enjoyed the development of the relationship between the main characters, which is definitely a slow burn. It gives ‘historical romance vibes’ with elements of duals, chivalry and honour in the relationship development.
I absolutely loved the ending of this book ❤️ I’m really looking forward to seeing where their story goes next.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for the gifted eARC
This book is described as outlander meets one dark window and I’d say this was a pretty accurate description.
This is a story set in Scotland during 1650s. It follows Maeve who is the sister of the MacDonnell clan Laird. Maeve has always been surrounded by bad luck and followed by Ravens which has forced her to live a sheltered life in her home. This is set in a time where suspected witches were being hunted and burned at the stake and so she has hidden away to avoid suspicion, until things change one day! And this is where the story begins.
It was a perfect blend of fantasy and history with a romantic subplot. I found the magic system interesting and although ravens are common in witch stories I feel like this was uniquely done.
There is also a lot of growth and trauma processing in this book with Maeve learning how her magic works and dealing with the events of her past.
The romance if definitely a subplot for this one but I really enjoyed the development of the relationship between the main characters, which is definitely a slow burn. It gives ‘historical romance vibes’ with elements of duals, chivalry and honour in the relationship development.
I absolutely loved the ending of this book ❤️ I’m really looking forward to seeing where their story goes next.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for the gifted eARC
October 19, 2025
In A Tempest of Ravens, author E. A. Bard’s stunning romantasy debut, the Wars of the Three Kingdoms — or the English Civil War, as they are often collectively known in America — are raging. But in her native Scotland, Maeve MacDonnell is in danger for more personal reasons. Ever since her childhood, she has had dark, haunting visions beyond her control, and ravens mysteriously follow her everywhere she goes. The local villagers live in fear of witchcraft, and Maeve’s brothers, Aeneas and Bearuch, try to protect her. But when the local whispers grow to jeers and shouts, Maeve is saved from death by fire just in time from a mysterious man named Eamon with whom she shares an instant connection. In fear for their lives, the MacDonnell siblings escape — but lingering family tensions and Maeve’s ever-intensifying powers change their plans.
Reading this novel was such an adventure. E. A. Bard’s descriptions of the lush Scottish landscape, the intonations of the Gaelic language, and the flapping of the ravens’ wings are such that I felt completely immersed within the story. The character profiles in this story, particularly those of Maeve and Eamon, are strikingly complex and profound. This was a reading experience I truly treasured. I am so grateful to have been given an advanced reader copy of this book by NerdFam.
Reading this novel was such an adventure. E. A. Bard’s descriptions of the lush Scottish landscape, the intonations of the Gaelic language, and the flapping of the ravens’ wings are such that I felt completely immersed within the story. The character profiles in this story, particularly those of Maeve and Eamon, are strikingly complex and profound. This was a reading experience I truly treasured. I am so grateful to have been given an advanced reader copy of this book by NerdFam.
October 24, 2025
Characters: 4.50⭐️
Setting: 5.00⭐️
Plot: 4.25⭐️
Themes: 4.00⭐️
Personal enjoyment: 4.50⭐️
Emotional Impact: 4.00⭐️
Overall rating: 4.50⭐️
Scotland 1651 - England is invading the Scottish lands. Maeve MacDonnell is a young woman who has been gifted with magical abilities that she is able to control ravens and also have unsettling visions of what is to come. She is blamed for the death of her mother and everyone believes her to be a witch. She is forced to leave her village where she is sent to marry a man of questionable reputation and is sent along with cattle raiders as her escort.
I love historical fiction with magical elements. What I loved about this story is Maeve's magic. It felt earthy and steeped with the legends of the Picts of England. I loved that the story was entwined with historical fact with historical events. This didn't feel like a run of the mill romantasy. The character development was great and the world building was enough that it didn't feel like a drag. This is definitely a book for fans of Outlander.
The plot built throughout the book and definitely set up the next book in the series. It does not end on a cliffhanger.
Would I recommend this book? Absolutely yes.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for sending me an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Setting: 5.00⭐️
Plot: 4.25⭐️
Themes: 4.00⭐️
Personal enjoyment: 4.50⭐️
Emotional Impact: 4.00⭐️
Overall rating: 4.50⭐️
Scotland 1651 - England is invading the Scottish lands. Maeve MacDonnell is a young woman who has been gifted with magical abilities that she is able to control ravens and also have unsettling visions of what is to come. She is blamed for the death of her mother and everyone believes her to be a witch. She is forced to leave her village where she is sent to marry a man of questionable reputation and is sent along with cattle raiders as her escort.
I love historical fiction with magical elements. What I loved about this story is Maeve's magic. It felt earthy and steeped with the legends of the Picts of England. I loved that the story was entwined with historical fact with historical events. This didn't feel like a run of the mill romantasy. The character development was great and the world building was enough that it didn't feel like a drag. This is definitely a book for fans of Outlander.
The plot built throughout the book and definitely set up the next book in the series. It does not end on a cliffhanger.
Would I recommend this book? Absolutely yes.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for sending me an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
did-not-finish
October 22, 2025DNF at 60% -
The premise of A Tempest of Ravens immediately caught my attention, especially knowing it was inspired by real events. The strongest aspect of the book, by far, is its atmospheric setting. E.A. Bard vividly captures the rugged beauty and haunting tension of the Scottish Highlands, and I genuinely appreciated the depth of research that went into the historical detail.
However, this read more as 95% historical fiction and 5% fantasy, which left me wanting more of the magical and romantic elements that were promised. My main struggle was with the characters, who often felt emotionally inconsistent and whose reactions sometimes tipped into melodrama. Maeve, in particular, was difficult for me to connect with. The pacing also felt uneven. Some sections moved too quickly, while others lingered on description to the point of slowing momentum. I wish the magic and romance had been woven more evenly throughout the story.
Thanks so much to The Nerd Fam for the complimentary copy.
The premise of A Tempest of Ravens immediately caught my attention, especially knowing it was inspired by real events. The strongest aspect of the book, by far, is its atmospheric setting. E.A. Bard vividly captures the rugged beauty and haunting tension of the Scottish Highlands, and I genuinely appreciated the depth of research that went into the historical detail.
However, this read more as 95% historical fiction and 5% fantasy, which left me wanting more of the magical and romantic elements that were promised. My main struggle was with the characters, who often felt emotionally inconsistent and whose reactions sometimes tipped into melodrama. Maeve, in particular, was difficult for me to connect with. The pacing also felt uneven. Some sections moved too quickly, while others lingered on description to the point of slowing momentum. I wish the magic and romance had been woven more evenly throughout the story.
Thanks so much to The Nerd Fam for the complimentary copy.
October 26, 2025
Scottish setting
Witches
Historical setting
Slow burn romance
I had a lot of high hopes for this book, and while I enjoyed the vibe and the overall story idea, the execution fell a bit short for me.
I love the concept of witches, the setting in Scotland, and the background theme of war time. I like her powers of controlling ravens, and the weather. I thought that was super unique. Maeve is a likable FMC overall!
This book lost me a bit with the pacing. It felt rushed at some pivotal moments, and then other tiny arguments seemed to drag on. I feel like Maeve and the MMC were very quickly attached to each other. I would have liked to see more magic training scenes.
Again, this book wasn’t for me, but I can see why other people are really enjoying it!! I like the vibes, and the setting, and Maeve!
Thank you to The Nerd Fam and EA Bard for the eARC!
Witches
Historical setting
Slow burn romance
I had a lot of high hopes for this book, and while I enjoyed the vibe and the overall story idea, the execution fell a bit short for me.
I love the concept of witches, the setting in Scotland, and the background theme of war time. I like her powers of controlling ravens, and the weather. I thought that was super unique. Maeve is a likable FMC overall!
This book lost me a bit with the pacing. It felt rushed at some pivotal moments, and then other tiny arguments seemed to drag on. I feel like Maeve and the MMC were very quickly attached to each other. I would have liked to see more magic training scenes.
Again, this book wasn’t for me, but I can see why other people are really enjoying it!! I like the vibes, and the setting, and Maeve!
Thank you to The Nerd Fam and EA Bard for the eARC!
October 21, 2025
Thank you to The NerdFam for this gifted eARC.
I loved being in this world. This story is set in the 1600s and takes place during the war between England and Scotland. The FMC Maeve has grown up believing she is cursed with loved ones dying and the town wanting to persecute her. Maeve ends up meeting some travelers who decide to help her and her brother on a journey. In this time of War there is loss, love, friendship and maybe what Maeve believed was a curse could be a blessing.
I loved being in this world. This story is set in the 1600s and takes place during the war between England and Scotland. The FMC Maeve has grown up believing she is cursed with loved ones dying and the town wanting to persecute her. Maeve ends up meeting some travelers who decide to help her and her brother on a journey. In this time of War there is loss, love, friendship and maybe what Maeve believed was a curse could be a blessing.
October 23, 2025
The premise is stellar: Maeve, plagued by ravens and unharnessed powers, meets Eamon, the alluring stranger, just as the invading English army forces them into a besieged Scottish castle. This promised a sweeping, gritty adventure with chaotic magic and undeniable chemistry.
Sadly, the execution didn’t match the fantastic setup. The pace was uneven, the romance felt rushed, and the plot was overly reliant on familiar tropes. While it hits the historical romantasy beats, it ultimately felt undercooked. I had high hopes, but it’s only a 3-star read for me, and I wouldn’t recommend it.
Sadly, the execution didn’t match the fantastic setup. The pace was uneven, the romance felt rushed, and the plot was overly reliant on familiar tropes. While it hits the historical romantasy beats, it ultimately felt undercooked. I had high hopes, but it’s only a 3-star read for me, and I wouldn’t recommend it.
October 2, 2025
I was thrilled to receive this as an ARC, and I’ll keep this spoiler-free.
It’s been ages since I’ve read such a captivating historical fiction, especially one that blends romantasy so seamlessly. From the very first page, the author transports you straight to 1600s Scotland. You can almost feel the heather and salt air as Maeve and Eamon’s story unfolds. Maeve’s journey is powerful and authentic, reflecting both the struggles of women in that era and the lasting impact of trauma. Eamon, meanwhile, is the kind of honorable, yearning hero that stays with you long after the last page. The balance of rich history, heartfelt emotion, and lyrical prose makes this debut unforgettable. This is historical fiction at its finest, and I cannot wait for the next book in the series!
It’s been ages since I’ve read such a captivating historical fiction, especially one that blends romantasy so seamlessly. From the very first page, the author transports you straight to 1600s Scotland. You can almost feel the heather and salt air as Maeve and Eamon’s story unfolds. Maeve’s journey is powerful and authentic, reflecting both the struggles of women in that era and the lasting impact of trauma. Eamon, meanwhile, is the kind of honorable, yearning hero that stays with you long after the last page. The balance of rich history, heartfelt emotion, and lyrical prose makes this debut unforgettable. This is historical fiction at its finest, and I cannot wait for the next book in the series!
October 24, 2025
5 Stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
A Tempest of Ravens completely destroyed me! The world-building is so insanely good I really felt like I was in 1600’s Scotland!
Maeve is fierce, haunted, and messy in the best way, and her trauma hits so damn real. Her relationship with her brothers? Complicated, tense, and somehow heart-melting and I lived for it! And Eamon… slow-burn, tender, this romance gave me everything!
This book handles mental health, grief, and trauma with so much care. While also giving layered characters, high stakes, and an unforgettable romance! I can’t wait to see where this story goes next!
**I received this eARC from The Nerd Fam and the author E. A. Bard. Thank you for this opportunity! All opinions are my own and I am leaving this review voluntarily. **
A Tempest of Ravens completely destroyed me! The world-building is so insanely good I really felt like I was in 1600’s Scotland!
Maeve is fierce, haunted, and messy in the best way, and her trauma hits so damn real. Her relationship with her brothers? Complicated, tense, and somehow heart-melting and I lived for it! And Eamon… slow-burn, tender, this romance gave me everything!
This book handles mental health, grief, and trauma with so much care. While also giving layered characters, high stakes, and an unforgettable romance! I can’t wait to see where this story goes next!
**I received this eARC from The Nerd Fam and the author E. A. Bard. Thank you for this opportunity! All opinions are my own and I am leaving this review voluntarily. **
August 7, 2025
A Tempest of Ravens was such a captivating book, with an incredible setting and a main character you'll immediately fall for. The slow-burning (eeeek!) relationship, the family bonds and the thrilling action got me, but it's the main character's growth that got my heart the most. I can't wait to read whatever E.A. Bard writes next. Definitely recommending this one for romantasy fans, fans of stories with magical settings (and powers) and great casts of characters.
I got lucky enough to read an early copy of this book - this did not, in any way, affect my review.
I got lucky enough to read an early copy of this book - this did not, in any way, affect my review.
November 1, 2025
Official rating 3.25 stars
I had really high hopes for this one. A historical romantic fantasy with witches, a slightly gothic feel, & a 1600s Scotland setting. It sounded like everything I love! & while it was still an enjoyable read, it fell a little flat for me in the end.
I loved the world building & the overall atmosphere, especially the bits of history woven throughout! The magic system was fascinating too, while similar to other common witch powers, Maeve’s deep connection with the ravens was one of my favorite parts.
But the pacing & romance didn’t quite work for me. The pacing felt uneven, big, emotional moments felt rushed while smaller ones lingered a little too long. Also, the romance felt a bit too quick. The characters had an almost instant connection, but I really wanted more time to truly feel that bond develop.
Overall, it was still an enjoyable read, & I think a lot of readers will really love it! Especially those who enjoy witchy, atmospheric historical fantasies.
Thank you so much to The Nerd Fam for the gift ARC.
I had really high hopes for this one. A historical romantic fantasy with witches, a slightly gothic feel, & a 1600s Scotland setting. It sounded like everything I love! & while it was still an enjoyable read, it fell a little flat for me in the end.
I loved the world building & the overall atmosphere, especially the bits of history woven throughout! The magic system was fascinating too, while similar to other common witch powers, Maeve’s deep connection with the ravens was one of my favorite parts.
But the pacing & romance didn’t quite work for me. The pacing felt uneven, big, emotional moments felt rushed while smaller ones lingered a little too long. Also, the romance felt a bit too quick. The characters had an almost instant connection, but I really wanted more time to truly feel that bond develop.
Overall, it was still an enjoyable read, & I think a lot of readers will really love it! Especially those who enjoy witchy, atmospheric historical fantasies.
Thank you so much to The Nerd Fam for the gift ARC.
October 9, 2025
Rating: 3.25/5
This book blends Scottish history, witches, and a touch of fantasy all set in 1600s Scotland. You’ll find real historical figures woven into the narrative, a thread of witchcraft tied to ravens, and a slow-burn romance at its center.
I went into this with pretty high expectations because it was pitched as Outlander meets One Dark Window. While those are great comps, I don’t think it quite lived up to them — so if you’re planning to pick this one up, I’d recommend going in blind and letting the story stand on its own.
What I Liked:
I loved the setting — the Scottish backdrop, the moody atmosphere, and the way the tension of the time period came through. Maeve was an interesting character to follow, especially at the start, and I enjoyed seeing her begin to step into her power. The raven magic was a really unique touch. I also liked William (or Eamon) and thought his dynamic with Maeve worked well. The romance was a nice slow burn, and the ending gave a solid setup for what’s to come in the sequel.
What Didn’t Work for Me:
The pacing felt uneven — sometimes rushing through big moments, and other times lingering too long on description. The imagery wasn’t always consistent; some scenes felt vivid, while others came across underdeveloped. I also wished both the magic and the romance were carried more steadily throughout, instead of starting strong, then fading, and then coming back. The spice scene felt a little out of place with the rest of the book. And because I went in with those Outlander and One Dark Window comps in my head, my expectations were higher than what the story ultimately delivered, which left me a little underwhelmed.
Who I’d Recommend This To:
I’d recommend A Tempest of Ravens to readers who enjoy historical fiction with a hint of fantasy, witches, and slow-burn romance — especially those who like seeing real history and magic woven together.
Thank you to the Nerd Family and to E. A. Bard for the early eARC of A Tempest of Ravens in exchange for an honest review.
This book blends Scottish history, witches, and a touch of fantasy all set in 1600s Scotland. You’ll find real historical figures woven into the narrative, a thread of witchcraft tied to ravens, and a slow-burn romance at its center.
I went into this with pretty high expectations because it was pitched as Outlander meets One Dark Window. While those are great comps, I don’t think it quite lived up to them — so if you’re planning to pick this one up, I’d recommend going in blind and letting the story stand on its own.
What I Liked:
I loved the setting — the Scottish backdrop, the moody atmosphere, and the way the tension of the time period came through. Maeve was an interesting character to follow, especially at the start, and I enjoyed seeing her begin to step into her power. The raven magic was a really unique touch. I also liked William (or Eamon) and thought his dynamic with Maeve worked well. The romance was a nice slow burn, and the ending gave a solid setup for what’s to come in the sequel.
What Didn’t Work for Me:
The pacing felt uneven — sometimes rushing through big moments, and other times lingering too long on description. The imagery wasn’t always consistent; some scenes felt vivid, while others came across underdeveloped. I also wished both the magic and the romance were carried more steadily throughout, instead of starting strong, then fading, and then coming back. The spice scene felt a little out of place with the rest of the book. And because I went in with those Outlander and One Dark Window comps in my head, my expectations were higher than what the story ultimately delivered, which left me a little underwhelmed.
Who I’d Recommend This To:
I’d recommend A Tempest of Ravens to readers who enjoy historical fiction with a hint of fantasy, witches, and slow-burn romance — especially those who like seeing real history and magic woven together.
Thank you to the Nerd Family and to E. A. Bard for the early eARC of A Tempest of Ravens in exchange for an honest review.
October 23, 2025
A sweeping historical fantasy perfect to fill the hole in the wake of the Outlander Blood of my Blood season finale. The beautifully realised historical setting showed such a depth of respect and research for what was a fraught time in Scotland's history between the Jacobite rebellions and witch trials. I especially loved the FMC's complicated relationship with her brothers and the many delicious twists and turns the plot took along the way. The romance element was nicely done - I love a slowburn/yearning/pining moment.
Grateful to the author for the chance to read an advanced copy and I can't wait to a) get my hands on a physical copy and b) read the sequel!
Grateful to the author for the chance to read an advanced copy and I can't wait to a) get my hands on a physical copy and b) read the sequel!
October 30, 2025
The world had so much potential — the witchcraft, the ravens, the ancient magic — and I really liked the initial tone. Unfortunately, as the story went on, I found myself getting lost in the slower pacing and the heavy historical detail. I struggled to connect with the characters, and the dialogue didn’t always feel natural. The concept was definitely intriguing, but the execution just didn’t pull me in the way I hoped it would. Still, there’s something in the author’s imagination that makes me curious to see what they’ll create next.
November 11, 2025
This book is every bit as moody, witchy, and haunting as I hoped it would be. I loved the setting of 1600s Scotland which added rich history and conflict to the story.
Maeve’s journey absolutely broke my heart. The amount of shame she’s carried since childhood makes you want to wrap her in a hug and tell her it’s not her fault. The romance is a slowww burn, and I found myself clinging to every lingering look and quiet moment of yearning between the FMC and MMC. There is also a very sweet found family trope in this book.
In summary, this is a well paced historical fantasy romance with political intrigue and a slow burn romance with witches, ravens, and moody Scottish castles.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for this gifted eARC in exchange for an honest review!
Maeve’s journey absolutely broke my heart. The amount of shame she’s carried since childhood makes you want to wrap her in a hug and tell her it’s not her fault. The romance is a slowww burn, and I found myself clinging to every lingering look and quiet moment of yearning between the FMC and MMC. There is also a very sweet found family trope in this book.
In summary, this is a well paced historical fantasy romance with political intrigue and a slow burn romance with witches, ravens, and moody Scottish castles.
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for this gifted eARC in exchange for an honest review!
October 6, 2025
I was very excited for this read but unfortunately it fell very flat for me. It was a bad read it was just okay and toed the line of boring. And sometimes the Scottish accents on one character came off as pirate and that really took me out of the story. The healing journey and coming to find herself self was very good. But I just felt like the book as a whole lacked depth.
September 16, 2025
A Tempest of Ravens immediately drew me into Maeve's story from the very first page. The setting of this story takes place in Scotland in the 1600s. I was a huge fan of the historical accuracy that somehow fit seamlessly with the whimsical witchy side of the story. Bard was able to make her core characters complex and intriguing throughout the entirety of the novel.
This book was also packed with deep yearning and such a delicious slow burn. I found this book to be impossible to put down and it got me in the spirit for all things witchy and fall.
I was lucky enough to receive an eARC from the Nerd Fam but that did not effect my true and honest review of this book.
This book was also packed with deep yearning and such a delicious slow burn. I found this book to be impossible to put down and it got me in the spirit for all things witchy and fall.
I was lucky enough to receive an eARC from the Nerd Fam but that did not effect my true and honest review of this book.
October 22, 2025
Set in the 1650s, the Scottish clans are warring amongst themselves while the English are invading the Highlands. In a country stifled by uncertainty, fear prevails and those deemed outcasts or any way different are the victims amongst the turmoil. Deemed a witch because of her affinity with the ravens Maeve is tied to the pyre, when the most unexpected protector comes to her rescue. Featuring power, passion, and belonging this Romantic Fantasy novel travels across the Highlands.
Atmospheric and visually pleasing this novel vividly escorts you across the Highlands. The language is lush and beautifully descriptive. I'm not sure if it's because I've visited most of the places mentioned, but I loved being transported to a clear image of the Scottish Highlands.
To be honest, I loved the story and it was well described as a Historical Romantic Fantasy, but I felt too much was happening for me to get a clear focus on the purpose of the story. The research was thorough, and so accurate, but I think it's echoes and the vastness of it overpowered the fantasy aspect of the story that was so interesting. But I just struggled with it sadly.
I also had a love-hate relationship with Maeve. I could understand her hesitancy and fear as she tried to conceal and control her powers. I just found her frustratingly impatient and a bit tunnel visioned, especially when offered advice (or any help really). Saying that though, the large cast of characters were endearing, especially Eamon and Taryn - love the bard. The brooding and lightheartedness these two bring to the scene is brilliant.
________________
Favourite Quotes:
Speaking with ravens was not the done thing, especially for a lady with her reputation, and yet here she was, wishing she could not only speak with them, but bid them. Which begged the question: was it better to be cursed, or to lose all reason?
For that was the hardest part of losing someone – you lost them again each time you awoke, and remembered. And every day after was simply another day without them.
If she could just be free all of this—the villagers, the ravens, her brothers’ rivalry, her guilt…and her curse.
“Did you not hear me? I love you, but this cannot be. We cannot be.”
“Don’t you see? You are cursed and I am damned. We’re a perfect match.”
________________
🌶.5/5
I was really looking forward to this blend of history and fantasy, but it definitely leans more on historic fact than the fantastical. I loved the inclusion of witchcraft and magic I just couldn't grasp the system - even in the mentor scenes - how it all worked. Then the ending was full speed and I felt in a whirlwind not sure where everything suddenly came from.
A Tempest of Ravens is magically atmospheric, and I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys historic fiction and likes a little fantasy.
Thank you E.A. Bard and The Nerd Fam for providing me with an ARC of A Tempest of Ravens.
Atmospheric and visually pleasing this novel vividly escorts you across the Highlands. The language is lush and beautifully descriptive. I'm not sure if it's because I've visited most of the places mentioned, but I loved being transported to a clear image of the Scottish Highlands.
To be honest, I loved the story and it was well described as a Historical Romantic Fantasy, but I felt too much was happening for me to get a clear focus on the purpose of the story. The research was thorough, and so accurate, but I think it's echoes and the vastness of it overpowered the fantasy aspect of the story that was so interesting. But I just struggled with it sadly.
I also had a love-hate relationship with Maeve. I could understand her hesitancy and fear as she tried to conceal and control her powers. I just found her frustratingly impatient and a bit tunnel visioned, especially when offered advice (or any help really). Saying that though, the large cast of characters were endearing, especially Eamon and Taryn - love the bard. The brooding and lightheartedness these two bring to the scene is brilliant.
________________
Favourite Quotes:
Speaking with ravens was not the done thing, especially for a lady with her reputation, and yet here she was, wishing she could not only speak with them, but bid them. Which begged the question: was it better to be cursed, or to lose all reason?
For that was the hardest part of losing someone – you lost them again each time you awoke, and remembered. And every day after was simply another day without them.
If she could just be free all of this—the villagers, the ravens, her brothers’ rivalry, her guilt…and her curse.
“Did you not hear me? I love you, but this cannot be. We cannot be.”
“Don’t you see? You are cursed and I am damned. We’re a perfect match.”
________________
🌶.5/5
I was really looking forward to this blend of history and fantasy, but it definitely leans more on historic fact than the fantastical. I loved the inclusion of witchcraft and magic I just couldn't grasp the system - even in the mentor scenes - how it all worked. Then the ending was full speed and I felt in a whirlwind not sure where everything suddenly came from.
A Tempest of Ravens is magically atmospheric, and I would recommend it to anyone who enjoys historic fiction and likes a little fantasy.
Thank you E.A. Bard and The Nerd Fam for providing me with an ARC of A Tempest of Ravens.
October 22, 2025
This was quite an experience. It’s fantasy, but set in the real world (Scotland, 1651) so you get a mix of history and magic. I found that really interesting as I like history and fantasy. I also like that the author explains at the end what’s historically accurate and what’s not as I was wondering about that. Turns out Aemon, for example, actually died as a child in real history, but here he’s very much alive and complicated. It almost feels like she’s honouring real people by giving them a different ending.
And if you’ve seen Outlander, you’ll definitely start to recognize a few things near the end. The whole “finding the king for help” plot, Charles fleeing to the Netherlands or France, I literally thought, “Ah, yes, must be France, like I’ve seen in Outlander.” Of course, the stories go in very different directions, but that familiarity hit me right at the end.
Tone-wise, it’s quite heavy. Maeve and her brothers have been through a lot. Grief, guilt and hopelessness. There are even moments of suicidal thoughts. Not for shock value, but I feel to show how sometimes even when you want to give up, there’s still something, or someone, that pulls you back or that life can indeed change for the better even if you can’t see it at the time.
The romance is slow burn. More emotional rather than spicy (maybe one and a half sex scenes, if we’re counting). What I found a bit odd is how everyone spends most of the book accusing Maeve of witchcraft, and then suddenly, some who were vivid about it, they just… stop caring? Like, “Oh, she’s actually helping us, never mind then.” Same with the reverends. The ones against Aemon and Maeve die of the pox and that whole storyline just sort of ends. I was like, ah, so that’s that, then.
There were a couple of small timeline moments where I thought, “Wait, yesterday? There has to be at least another day in between” but in all honesty, I didn’t feel like flipping back to check. The story itself, with the misty Scottish setting, the tension of war, and the magic, kept me hooked anyway.
Also, I loved the ravens. Mainly Cormac. Bit of a prick, but aren’t all birds?
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for the gifted eARC
And if you’ve seen Outlander, you’ll definitely start to recognize a few things near the end. The whole “finding the king for help” plot, Charles fleeing to the Netherlands or France, I literally thought, “Ah, yes, must be France, like I’ve seen in Outlander.” Of course, the stories go in very different directions, but that familiarity hit me right at the end.
Tone-wise, it’s quite heavy. Maeve and her brothers have been through a lot. Grief, guilt and hopelessness. There are even moments of suicidal thoughts. Not for shock value, but I feel to show how sometimes even when you want to give up, there’s still something, or someone, that pulls you back or that life can indeed change for the better even if you can’t see it at the time.
The romance is slow burn. More emotional rather than spicy (maybe one and a half sex scenes, if we’re counting). What I found a bit odd is how everyone spends most of the book accusing Maeve of witchcraft, and then suddenly, some who were vivid about it, they just… stop caring? Like, “Oh, she’s actually helping us, never mind then.” Same with the reverends. The ones against Aemon and Maeve die of the pox and that whole storyline just sort of ends. I was like, ah, so that’s that, then.
There were a couple of small timeline moments where I thought, “Wait, yesterday? There has to be at least another day in between” but in all honesty, I didn’t feel like flipping back to check. The story itself, with the misty Scottish setting, the tension of war, and the magic, kept me hooked anyway.
Also, I loved the ravens. Mainly Cormac. Bit of a prick, but aren’t all birds?
Thank you to The Nerd Fam for the gifted eARC
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 23, 2025
I was honored to have received this as an arc so this review will be spoiler free;
It had been a while since I’ve read an incredible historical fiction novel and especially one combine romantasy elements as well. I’ve been acquainted with the author and her incredible knowledge of history as well as her prose definitely shines in this debut of hers. Instantly the author takes you to mid 1600s Scotland and immediately you’re enveloped with the landscape, feel the heather and salt on the sea breeze waft your hair as you follow two main characters, Maeve and Eamon.
I adored how she fleshed these characters out and made them so much so that they were like my own family. I was rooting for them so much so along with the other characters. Maeve’s story is remarkable, the author through Maeve’s POV shows the history of that turbulent time especially how it was for women actually but also gave Maeve such a voice as well as accurately depict PTSD especially from the 17th century viewpoint and the effect of trauma on both Maeve and Eamon. I appreciated how she balanced the tension as well as the warm moments of the story such as moments with Taryn and Brahan. and Eamon….. what else is there to say, he’s truly the Aragorn we all need and want in our lives. A true yearner and honorable gentleman that puts other love interests to shame.
I loved this book for its striking attention to historical detail, wonderful world building, incredible character development and the way I still long to go back to the highlands. This is how historical fiction ought to be written, enough for one to feel as though you yourself are living through these events through these characters. Even her language and vocabulary aren’t anachronistic and true to the period which I appreciated so much for its those attention to details that mark a great novel. Her prose is lyrical, melodic even, lulling you to a ballad drenched in heather and bitter salt breezes. I am literally
Craving for the second novel in this series to come out!!!
.
It had been a while since I’ve read an incredible historical fiction novel and especially one combine romantasy elements as well. I’ve been acquainted with the author and her incredible knowledge of history as well as her prose definitely shines in this debut of hers. Instantly the author takes you to mid 1600s Scotland and immediately you’re enveloped with the landscape, feel the heather and salt on the sea breeze waft your hair as you follow two main characters, Maeve and Eamon.
I adored how she fleshed these characters out and made them so much so that they were like my own family. I was rooting for them so much so along with the other characters. Maeve’s story is remarkable, the author through Maeve’s POV shows the history of that turbulent time especially how it was for women actually but also gave Maeve such a voice as well as accurately depict PTSD especially from the 17th century viewpoint and the effect of trauma on both Maeve and Eamon. I appreciated how she balanced the tension as well as the warm moments of the story such as moments with Taryn and Brahan. and Eamon….. what else is there to say, he’s truly the Aragorn we all need and want in our lives. A true yearner and honorable gentleman that puts other love interests to shame.
I loved this book for its striking attention to historical detail, wonderful world building, incredible character development and the way I still long to go back to the highlands. This is how historical fiction ought to be written, enough for one to feel as though you yourself are living through these events through these characters. Even her language and vocabulary aren’t anachronistic and true to the period which I appreciated so much for its those attention to details that mark a great novel. Her prose is lyrical, melodic even, lulling you to a ballad drenched in heather and bitter salt breezes. I am literally
Craving for the second novel in this series to come out!!!
.
September 29, 2025
All I knew going into this book was it took place in Scotland in the 1650s and a woman was cursed with visions and ravens. That was all I needed.
This book had my interest from the start and kept me captivated through the end.
Maeve firmly believes that she is cursed with her visions, ravens, and a long series of unfortunate events that often lead to the death of others. Her brothers do their best to protect her from the villagers that holdfast to the belief that she is a witch. The villagers do finally turn on her and she flees with two strangers and one of her brothers.
Maeve constantly battles with the darkness of her thoughts. Guilt and grief weigh her down even as she learns more about magic and what she could be capable of. She is a beautifully complex character that is brave and fierce but also vulnerable and fractured. She's been convinced that she is to blame for a lot of bad things and cannot shake the conviction that she is cursed easily. Her healing arc resonates for me because her progress is not linear.
Eamon has his own past that he grapples with and starts out as a bit of a mystery. He's protective of Maeve immediately and encourages her to embrace her gifts (and we love that). Their relationship develops slowly and is worth the wait.
The atmosphere is dark with war and all that comes with it being written onto page. The betrayals, the regrets, the deaths, the worry and concern for loved ones...
The atmosphere is also dark with the war going on inside Maeve's head.
There are cozy moments, wonderful side characters, growth, love, and many other things that shine through that darkness.
Ultimately, I really enjoyed reading this book. I will ABSOLUTELY pick up the next book and I definitely recommend this to anyone that would like an atmospheric witchy historical fantasy.
Thank you Nerdfam and E.A. Bard for the eARC. The opinions I have shared are completely my own.
This book had my interest from the start and kept me captivated through the end.
Maeve firmly believes that she is cursed with her visions, ravens, and a long series of unfortunate events that often lead to the death of others. Her brothers do their best to protect her from the villagers that holdfast to the belief that she is a witch. The villagers do finally turn on her and she flees with two strangers and one of her brothers.
Maeve constantly battles with the darkness of her thoughts. Guilt and grief weigh her down even as she learns more about magic and what she could be capable of. She is a beautifully complex character that is brave and fierce but also vulnerable and fractured. She's been convinced that she is to blame for a lot of bad things and cannot shake the conviction that she is cursed easily. Her healing arc resonates for me because her progress is not linear.
Eamon has his own past that he grapples with and starts out as a bit of a mystery. He's protective of Maeve immediately and encourages her to embrace her gifts (and we love that). Their relationship develops slowly and is worth the wait.
The atmosphere is dark with war and all that comes with it being written onto page. The betrayals, the regrets, the deaths, the worry and concern for loved ones...
The atmosphere is also dark with the war going on inside Maeve's head.
There are cozy moments, wonderful side characters, growth, love, and many other things that shine through that darkness.
Ultimately, I really enjoyed reading this book. I will ABSOLUTELY pick up the next book and I definitely recommend this to anyone that would like an atmospheric witchy historical fantasy.
Thank you Nerdfam and E.A. Bard for the eARC. The opinions I have shared are completely my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 135 reviews