What do you think?
Rate this book
Debunked by Nature: How a Vegan-Chef-Turned-Regenerative-Farmer Discovered that Mother Nature Is a Conservative
What if nature—not modern culture—held the answers we’re so desperately seeking?Mollie Engelhart was a celebrated vegan chef living in Los Angeles, running successful restaurants and championing progressive ideals. But when she left the city behind to raise her family on a regenerative farm, her carefully constructed worldview began to unravel.
In Debunked by Nature, Mollie invites you on a deeply personal and radically honest journey—from the grief of losing her best friend to the unexpected spiritual awakening sparked by motherhood. Through the soil, the seasons, and the sacred rhythms of nature, she began to question everything she once believed about food, freedom, identity, health, and even life itself.
Part memoir, part manifesto, this book challenges today’s cultural narratives through the lenses of biology, experience, and divine design. Mollie doesn’t shy away from complexity. She writes with the rawness of a mother, the conviction of a farmer, and the tenderness of someone who’s had her heart broken—and rebuilt—by the truth.
If you’ve ever felt that something is off in the world and wondered if nature might be whispering a better way, this book is for you.
In Debunked by Nature, Mollie invites you on a deeply personal and radically honest journey—from the grief of losing her best friend to the unexpected spiritual awakening sparked by motherhood. Through the soil, the seasons, and the sacred rhythms of nature, she began to question everything she once believed about food, freedom, identity, health, and even life itself.
Part memoir, part manifesto, this book challenges today’s cultural narratives through the lenses of biology, experience, and divine design. Mollie doesn’t shy away from complexity. She writes with the rawness of a mother, the conviction of a farmer, and the tenderness of someone who’s had her heart broken—and rebuilt—by the truth.
If you’ve ever felt that something is off in the world and wondered if nature might be whispering a better way, this book is for you.
158 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 26, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
January 25, 2026
They say a conservative is just a liberal who's been mugged. Mollie Engelhart is essentially a liberal vegan mugged by reality. While her transformation is mildly interesting, it's largely an exercise in coming to terms with reality. But rather than details about how her thought process changed, or how her friends reacted, we have this short (158 page) booklet, "Debunked by Nature," that's mostly just generalities that we already know. Nature is indifferent? Uh, yes, those of us who grew up in rural America knew that already, though it's a revelation to Ms Engelhart.
This could have, and maybe should have, been a long magazine or blog article. There's not enough for a book, and what's here is so general, so repetitive, and so damned preachy that it's off-putting to try and read it without grimacing. So while I applaud Ms Engelhart's change of heart, her attempt to tell us about it falls short of the promises in the book description. A strident exhortation is not very much fun to read.
This could have, and maybe should have, been a long magazine or blog article. There's not enough for a book, and what's here is so general, so repetitive, and so damned preachy that it's off-putting to try and read it without grimacing. So while I applaud Ms Engelhart's change of heart, her attempt to tell us about it falls short of the promises in the book description. A strident exhortation is not very much fun to read.
October 27, 2025
I learned of this book by reading her bio at the end of an article of one of her recent Epoch Times opinion articles. When I ordered the book the only version available was the kindle. A paperback edition is now available. I was satisfied with the kindle edition.
I found Engelhart's story engaging.. She has changed her opinion about a wide range of issues. At the heart of her transformation is the realization that the natural world has much to teach us. Agriculture and lifestyles that fight against the natural development and growth of the land and the various cycles of nature by use of chemicals or agricultural methods that focus on short term goals rather than long term regeneration ultimately harm the world and our food production. Engelhart also observes that the animal kingdom has lessons to teach modern humans about child rearing, defending territory, and food intake and production. Engelhart sees that animals play a vital role in renewing the land. They play a crucial role in the regenerative process.
Engelhart argues against vaccines because good food makes us healthy. She argues for the health benefits of unpasteurized milk.
Engelhart does not rely on scientific citations to persuade the reader. She relies on her own experience and the common sense approach of observing what nature does naturally. She argues that food production ought to work with the land, not against it.
I found Engelhart's story engaging.. She has changed her opinion about a wide range of issues. At the heart of her transformation is the realization that the natural world has much to teach us. Agriculture and lifestyles that fight against the natural development and growth of the land and the various cycles of nature by use of chemicals or agricultural methods that focus on short term goals rather than long term regeneration ultimately harm the world and our food production. Engelhart also observes that the animal kingdom has lessons to teach modern humans about child rearing, defending territory, and food intake and production. Engelhart sees that animals play a vital role in renewing the land. They play a crucial role in the regenerative process.
Engelhart argues against vaccines because good food makes us healthy. She argues for the health benefits of unpasteurized milk.
Engelhart does not rely on scientific citations to persuade the reader. She relies on her own experience and the common sense approach of observing what nature does naturally. She argues that food production ought to work with the land, not against it.
March 24, 2026
Inspiring Story on Connecting with Nature
Riveting autobiographical account of the author’s move from a less-connected life in the city to a life connected with the earth and family on a farm in California. So much about human nature was learned by this venture! It inspires the reader to begin or expand their own journey to connectedness.
Riveting autobiographical account of the author’s move from a less-connected life in the city to a life connected with the earth and family on a farm in California. So much about human nature was learned by this venture! It inspires the reader to begin or expand their own journey to connectedness.
Read
September 30, 2025Didn’t love it. Her tone comes across preachy… and I felt there were vast generalizations that aren’t supported by science. Was hoping for more on actual regenerative farming and less antivax/immigration/anti masking nonsense
December 21, 2025
Hope
Thank you for your stories. It gives me hope for going on and finding my way. No, I don’t agree with everything you have to say, but I respect what you are saying and trying to understand.
Thank you for your stories. It gives me hope for going on and finding my way. No, I don’t agree with everything you have to say, but I respect what you are saying and trying to understand.
August 10, 2026
Read it in a day, and i’m inspired to reconnect with the nature God created for us to belong in.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews