Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

I Thought It Was You

Rate this book
It looked like a running accident. Until she saw the photo.
Until the note read: I thought it was you.

Dr. Natalie Greystone has spent her life examining the dead with clinical precision and locked-down calm. But when the body of a woman turns up at the edge of the trail she used to run—similar build, similar stride—her professional distance starts to fracture.

Then the photograph arrives: grainy, off-kilter, and chilling. And scrawled in one corner are the words: I thought it was you.

As the case tightens around her, Natalie is forced to confront a tangled web of grief, jealousy, and misdirected blame: Adam, the analyst who disappeared just after the murder. Kiera, a colleague whose envy runs deeper than history. And Will, the quiet lab tech with more access than anyone realized.

Because someone mistook that girl for Natalie.
Or someone wanted her dead.
And Natalie doesn’t know which is worse.

Eerie, atmospheric, and razor-tensed, I Thought It Was You is a psychological thriller about obsession, proximity, and the quiet terror of realizing someone’s been watching you… for a very long time.

268 pages, Kindle Edition

First published July 28, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

M.S. Mills

1 book2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
22 (28%)
4 stars
17 (22%)
3 stars
18 (23%)
2 stars
15 (19%)
1 star
4 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
Profile Image for Victoria Wride.
3 reviews1 follower
August 6, 2025
I could not put this book down! Such a good story line! The author had me guessing from the beginning and I was fooled in the end. Such great details as well that I felt I was inside the book!
11 reviews
August 17, 2025
I thought it was very interesting. The book kept my attention all the way through. I had no idea who the killer was until the very end. I loved it!
Profile Image for Shalynne Morales.
26 reviews
January 1, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 STARS — ABSOLUTELY CHILLING ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 😱📸

This psychological thriller completely consumed me. What starts as a tragic running accident spirals into something far darker the moment Dr. Natalie Greystone sees the photo. Grainy. Crooked. Wrong. And then the words that stop your heart:
I thought it was you. 🖤

Natalie has built her life around emotional control and clinical distance—but this case shatters all of it. The victim looks like her. Ran the same trail. Moved the same way. And suddenly, Natalie isn’t just studying the dead… she might have been meant to join them. 👀💀

As the investigation tightens, the tension becomes unbearable. Every character feels suspicious, every interaction heavy with implication. Grief, jealousy, and obsession bleed together in the most unsettling way, making it impossible to know who can be trusted—and who’s been watching from the shadows all along. 🧠🔪

The atmosphere is eerie and suffocating, the pacing razor-tight, and the psychological unease never lets up. This is the kind of book that makes you check over your shoulder and reread sentences just to make sure you didn’t miss something important.

Mistaken identity… or calculated intent?
And which possibility is more terrifying? 😳

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A full five stars for tension, atmosphere, and a story that crawls under your skin and stays there. Highly recommend for thriller lovers who enjoy slow-burn dread and mind-twisting suspense. 🖤✨
Profile Image for Kelsey.
4 reviews
November 28, 2025
Such a good read!! Didn’t want to put this book down; wish this was a series cause it was really good.
1 review
August 19, 2025
What a great page turner!!! This books keeps you on the edge of your seat and engaged from start to finish. Highly recommend!!!
16 reviews1 follower
July 6, 2026
I was really looking forward to reading this book due to the 4.42 star rating. The author was very detailed in her writing, however, it was a no burn, for me. I struggled to even finish the book. I have read over 200 books and this was the first one that I had to force myself to finish. It felt predictable and dull
Profile Image for Milly Reads.
22 reviews
July 15, 2026
Such a great book! This thriller kept me guessing who it was and the details were amazing! Definitely will be checking out anything else by this author!
153 reviews8 followers
October 5, 2025
If you like the whole law enforcement and medical examiner type thing then this book is for you. Not many twists and turns but definitely some "no ways" and jaw dropping moments. In the end it isn't who you'd expect!
2 reviews
March 4, 2026
I really liked the plot of this book but I didn’t really care for the writing style. There were also a lot of grammar errors and I don’t know if it was just the KU edition that is like that. The plot was great though!!!!
Profile Image for Taylor Shea.
158 reviews
August 23, 2026
Maybe not quite 4stars cause you have the characters you suspect so it’s not a major surprise, but it kept you hooked the whole time waiting for what they’d discover next and trying to figure out which one did it!
309 reviews2 followers
February 3, 2026
I enjoyed this suspenseful psychological thriller and couldn’t put it down! Tense and mysterious, nothing worse than knowing that someone is following you! Well written and realistic I recommend it to those that like whodunnit type stories that are true to life. I’d read more by this author.
2 reviews
July 21, 2026
Such a slow book, started off okay and then towards the end it just dragged and dragged
I figured out who the killer was half way through, really didn’t enjoy this one
Profile Image for Andrea.
1 review
October 4, 2026
This was almost a DNF. The typos are horrendous. So so many! I have never read a book that has so many. 2 🌟 due to that.
Profile Image for Carla bookaholic.
401 reviews4 followers
August 31, 2026
I really didn’t like the writing style and the phrasing. I struggled to finish the book
11 reviews
September 19, 2025
I enjoyed this thriller! For any readers out there who are wary of thrillers it wasn’t too intense or scary. There were quite a few potential suspects which made it suspenseful. It was a fast read - I recommend it!
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews