In 1909, the crack Blue Anchor liner, the Waratah, sinks without trace, or survivors, off the coast of South Africa. In 1967, the Gemsbok, a Viscount airliner of South African Airways disappears in exactly the same place. To some it is merely an uncanny mystery. To others a tragedy. People like Ian Fairlie, captain of the weather ship Walvis Bay--whose father was the pilot.
I read this book on a whim as I found it as a free book and was intrigued by the blurb on the back. I must admit, I was underwhelmed by it. There are some major issues if you ask me. The relationship between the two main protagonists felt strange, strained, unclear, with some scenes that only left me wondering what the writer was thinking. They just did not make sense within a typical relationship.
There were some plotholes that felt really weird. The story of the ship, although strange, I could follow. The two aircraft just did not make sense, there are some big problems here that just distracted from the main story for me. If the writer had stuck to the marine element and left the aviation bits out, it would have been a better book.
The redeeming facts were the buildup to the story about the Waratah and the final bits that did contain an element of tension, excitement and surprise. I won't provide any more spoilers here. In short, I could have saved myself some time and would have been better off with another book.
A thrilling read and up to Geoffrey Jenkins' high standard but not his best story either. It combines a story of the sea, South African geography and history and a "boy's own adventure". I felt this one to be a little too fantastic. Still very enjoyable and worth a read. It certainly spurs me on to learn more about Pondoland and add it to my "bucket list".
What I appreciated about this book is the excellent research which went into the writing to make it a thoroughly credible reading experience, together with the author’s understanding of the sea, weather charts, ships, and the South African coastline, and blending it with a love story without sacrificing the historical details.
I forgot how much I enjoyed Geoffrey Jenkins. His writing style was similar to Hammond Innes and he clearly knows a great deal about sailing and the sea around South Africa. A rip roaring story of gales and search for a mystery of the past.
Much tighter plot and more fully developed characters than Grue of Ice, which I read after this, but before I added this review. I did like the “Flying Dutchman” plot combined with a real ship disappearance as the drivers of the plot.
I've had this on my bookshelves - the real ones - for years. Not quite your standard action thriller, for the real villain is the sea itself. Not quite a 4* read, but good entertainment nonetheless.
As with pretty much all of Jenkin's books, this has interesting aspects of the southern African coast and the South Atlantic, mixed with bits from WWII and treasure/mystery.
EDITORIAL REVIEW: In 1909, the crack Blue Anchor liner, the Waratah, sinks without trace, or survivors, off the coast of South Africa. In 1967, the Gemsbok, a Viscount airliner of South African Airways disappears in exactly the same place. To some it is merely an uncanny mystery. To others a tragedy. People like Ian Fairlie, captain of the weather ship Walvis Bay--whose father was the pilot of the Gemsbok and whose grandfather was the first officer of the Waratah. Ian Fairlie has sworn that he will resolve the mystery. But to do so, he must face cyclonic winds and mountainous seas, risking his ship, his life and the woman he loves... "Geoffrey Jenkins can write with a rare compelling fervour." Times Literary Supplement
Melodramatic and full of obscure boating terminology, there is nevertheless a thrilling mystery to this book. I could see this story made into a movie.