What do you think?
Rate this book
Illuminator
Helena Tefraine was abducted from her homeland alongside her teenage daughter, her two closest friends, and other women who were in the wrong chapel at the wrong time. She finds herself in Tintar, the only known country in her world where magic exists. Forced into service as a muralist for a foreign king and bound by an arranged betrothal she did not choose, Helena must also unearth buried parts of herself as she perseveres. Her new role does not just challenge her—it awakens her. As she adapts her old life's skills as an illuminator to paint an enemy's throne room, she begins to recover the divine spark within her that refused to be extinguished. A poetic return to the friendship, magic, and romance of Priestess, Illuminator is a companion novel written as a love letter to readers. This is not only a story of survival—it is a story of the soul.
398 pages, ebook
First published September 9, 2025
63 people are currently reading
417 people want to read
About the author
Kara Voorhees Reynolds
5 books238 followersKara Reynolds is a watercolorist who lives in Florida with her husband and their cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
September 9, 2025
“I am weary of all of my definitions being drawn by men’s hands. Let me paint the lines now. Give me the brush. That is not my shape.”
This is a companion novel to Priestess, it is Helena’s story and Helena’s POV for some of Priestess. It is told in dual timelines. Some chapters are Helena telling us about her past. And then other chapters are her story as she finds a home in Tintar, heals from her past traumas, and falls for Thatcher.
I had the absolute honor of beta reading this book and let me start with: move over Alric! Thatcher is my new book boyfriend!
I don’t know why I was continually blown away by KRs writing in this. It was full of beautiful imagery and wise insights. As well as poetic descriptions of place and life experiences. There is of course beautiful prose and insightful moments in Priestess, but dare I say, her writing has gotten even better?
This was just so powerfully moving. Not only to learn all that Helena has had to endure but also to actually watch her heal! I think so often in romance books we get past domestic abuse and sexual assault used as a tool to add trauma (or drama?) to our character background but then it’s just tossed aside. Hardly mentioned. Hardly affecting. Lazy character building? But not in Helena’s story. It feels real and raw. And she heals and we get to see it on page! I was so moved. Heartbroken and then put back together. The romance is part of her healing. He does not heal her with orgasms. He gives her a safe space as she heals. The space she needs, the time she needs, and when she is ready, he shows her how it should have always been for her and I melted.
Anyway, if you loved Priestess don’t skip this novella. I am just so thrilled to have discovered KR. Her writing is beautiful, empowering, and not cranking out tropey stories. Books that have moved and changed me.
This is how you write romance. I cannot wait to see what comes next.
This is a companion novel to Priestess, it is Helena’s story and Helena’s POV for some of Priestess. It is told in dual timelines. Some chapters are Helena telling us about her past. And then other chapters are her story as she finds a home in Tintar, heals from her past traumas, and falls for Thatcher.
I had the absolute honor of beta reading this book and let me start with: move over Alric! Thatcher is my new book boyfriend!
I don’t know why I was continually blown away by KRs writing in this. It was full of beautiful imagery and wise insights. As well as poetic descriptions of place and life experiences. There is of course beautiful prose and insightful moments in Priestess, but dare I say, her writing has gotten even better?
This was just so powerfully moving. Not only to learn all that Helena has had to endure but also to actually watch her heal! I think so often in romance books we get past domestic abuse and sexual assault used as a tool to add trauma (or drama?) to our character background but then it’s just tossed aside. Hardly mentioned. Hardly affecting. Lazy character building? But not in Helena’s story. It feels real and raw. And she heals and we get to see it on page! I was so moved. Heartbroken and then put back together. The romance is part of her healing. He does not heal her with orgasms. He gives her a safe space as she heals. The space she needs, the time she needs, and when she is ready, he shows her how it should have always been for her and I melted.
Anyway, if you loved Priestess don’t skip this novella. I am just so thrilled to have discovered KR. Her writing is beautiful, empowering, and not cranking out tropey stories. Books that have moved and changed me.
This is how you write romance. I cannot wait to see what comes next.
August 5, 2025
A true love letter to fans of Priestess who weren't quite ready to let these characters go just yet. Helena's story and perspective felt so natural and in line with what we learned of her in Priestess. That said, she definitely had secrets and undiscovered pieces of her history that made this story well worth reading. The portrayals of sisterhood and motherhood in this also felt so genuine and real. I absolutely adored Edie, but something about Helena's experiences just really resonated with me. Similar to Priestess this book broke my heart but then tenderly put it back together, wrapped me in a blanket, and handed me a warm mug of tea.
I'd be remiss if I didn't also comment on how swoon-worthy Thatcher was in this. His patience with Helena as she healed was so comforting to read and so, so many of my highlights/annotations while reading were of his quotes. I just ...What. A. Man.
This story, just like it's predecessor, will undoubtedly stay with me for a while and be a book a I frequently return to. I'm incredibly lucky and honored to have received an eARC for this book but I will definitely be purchasing a copy for my shelves so I always have it close on hand for future re-reads. I'm going to miss these characters and the feelings this story invoked. I will 100% read anything else this author puts out and look forward to whatever her brilliant mind comes up with in the future!
I'd be remiss if I didn't also comment on how swoon-worthy Thatcher was in this. His patience with Helena as she healed was so comforting to read and so, so many of my highlights/annotations while reading were of his quotes. I just ...What. A. Man.
This story, just like it's predecessor, will undoubtedly stay with me for a while and be a book a I frequently return to. I'm incredibly lucky and honored to have received an eARC for this book but I will definitely be purchasing a copy for my shelves so I always have it close on hand for future re-reads. I'm going to miss these characters and the feelings this story invoked. I will 100% read anything else this author puts out and look forward to whatever her brilliant mind comes up with in the future!
September 15, 2025
ugh. wow. Wow and Ouch.
This book, like priestess, did something to me. I have been stuck in such a weird slump, feeling like doing nothing, watching nothing, listening to nothing, reading nothing, and I feel like this book was a sign. Bestowed upon me by the AUTHOR HERSELF, it had to be a sign right? Feeling both stuck and excited to read this, I forced myself to read just the first chapter and then before I knew it, it was my entire reason for living this weekend.
My heart hurt so much for Helena- a proud woman, hanging on to the only thing left of her father (the only man that showed her love) which was the pride he wanted her to have. Crazy. How could she know herself when she needed to be both what her father wanted her mother to be and also what her mother-in-law wanted her son's wife to be? And once those influences were gone, what her daughter needed her to be??? There's a line somewhere later in the book where Quinn talks about how so much of a woman's life is built from the foundations of her relationships with men. It so PAINFULLY summed up Helena's whole story, from Cyrus mispronouncing her name to Caleb's response to Selwyn's proposal. This book HURRRTTT. And yet I found myself wanting to underline and highlight so many lines and passages, but I couldn't stop reading long enough to get a pen!
Beyond all of that, this was such a wonderful excuse to see my fav characters again. Was this indulgent? yes. Did it achieve feeling like a love letter to priestess fans? YES. Thank you so much Kara <3
This book, like priestess, did something to me. I have been stuck in such a weird slump, feeling like doing nothing, watching nothing, listening to nothing, reading nothing, and I feel like this book was a sign. Bestowed upon me by the AUTHOR HERSELF, it had to be a sign right? Feeling both stuck and excited to read this, I forced myself to read just the first chapter and then before I knew it, it was my entire reason for living this weekend.
My heart hurt so much for Helena- a proud woman, hanging on to the only thing left of her father (the only man that showed her love) which was the pride he wanted her to have. Crazy. How could she know herself when she needed to be both what her father wanted her mother to be and also what her mother-in-law wanted her son's wife to be? And once those influences were gone, what her daughter needed her to be??? There's a line somewhere later in the book where Quinn talks about how so much of a woman's life is built from the foundations of her relationships with men. It so PAINFULLY summed up Helena's whole story, from Cyrus mispronouncing her name to Caleb's response to Selwyn's proposal. This book HURRRTTT. And yet I found myself wanting to underline and highlight so many lines and passages, but I couldn't stop reading long enough to get a pen!
Beyond all of that, this was such a wonderful excuse to see my fav characters again. Was this indulgent? yes. Did it achieve feeling like a love letter to priestess fans? YES. Thank you so much Kara <3
November 23, 2025
Opening up this book felt like walking in to your best friend’s living room. I know this place, I know these people, and I love them. I am safe here. I can be myself here.
This is a triumph about friendship and all the ways we can show up for ourselves and each other. Mischa, Edie, River, and Quinn take care of Helena in different ways that only they can. And Helena cares for them in return by giving them understanding and safety. Like Quinn feeling like she finally had her own friends?? *sob*
Even our favorite procurer made his way into Helena’s heart by showing her friendship and patience over romantic interest. Who else thinks patience and security is hot???? ME!!
This is a silly comparison, but I loved this book for the same reason I cry every time I watch Frozen 2. I just love seeing women start to believe in their own quiet power. Helena’s revelation about letting her own grief come out into the light in the same way she uses art to illuminate certain meanings was too much for my little heart. And Caleb remained a safe place for Helena to bring her whole self to light, learn about her power, and exercise it.
Can we also talk about the celebration of different bodies woven throughout these books? Edie comparing themselves to pears?? LOVE. And they’re actual beautiful bodies over 30 winters, rather than every FMC being only 5ft tall with a teeny tiny little waist but boobs that could knock you unconscious. I’m happy for anyone whose body is actually that, but it’s hard for me to enjoy characters that I can’t relate to at all. It’s much more exciting to read about all these women with completely my different shapes who are being respected and worshipped exactly as they are.
And another thing.
Kara’s bio says she is a watercolorist, but let me tell you. This woman is a POET. Her writing IS painting with watercolors. Her words flow and dance and take you along for the ride. Reading her prose feels weightless. It’s like floating in a lazy river, or listening to live acoustic guitar, where they never really stop playing and one song seamlessly turns into the next.
I will read anything Kara writes, and I will happily live in Tintar for as long as she lets me.
This is a triumph about friendship and all the ways we can show up for ourselves and each other. Mischa, Edie, River, and Quinn take care of Helena in different ways that only they can. And Helena cares for them in return by giving them understanding and safety. Like Quinn feeling like she finally had her own friends?? *sob*
Even our favorite procurer made his way into Helena’s heart by showing her friendship and patience over romantic interest. Who else thinks patience and security is hot???? ME!!
This is a silly comparison, but I loved this book for the same reason I cry every time I watch Frozen 2. I just love seeing women start to believe in their own quiet power. Helena’s revelation about letting her own grief come out into the light in the same way she uses art to illuminate certain meanings was too much for my little heart. And Caleb remained a safe place for Helena to bring her whole self to light, learn about her power, and exercise it.
Can we also talk about the celebration of different bodies woven throughout these books? Edie comparing themselves to pears?? LOVE. And they’re actual beautiful bodies over 30 winters, rather than every FMC being only 5ft tall with a teeny tiny little waist but boobs that could knock you unconscious. I’m happy for anyone whose body is actually that, but it’s hard for me to enjoy characters that I can’t relate to at all. It’s much more exciting to read about all these women with completely my different shapes who are being respected and worshipped exactly as they are.
And another thing.
Kara’s bio says she is a watercolorist, but let me tell you. This woman is a POET. Her writing IS painting with watercolors. Her words flow and dance and take you along for the ride. Reading her prose feels weightless. It’s like floating in a lazy river, or listening to live acoustic guitar, where they never really stop playing and one song seamlessly turns into the next.
I will read anything Kara writes, and I will happily live in Tintar for as long as she lets me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 3, 2025
I have the wonderful opportunity of being part of Kara's street team and have been able to read Illuminator in advance. This is a companion novel to Priestess, which I read earlier in the year and has become one of my favourite books. Priestess buried itself into my soul and I didn't think I would find another story that resonates with me the same way but of course, Illuminator is that story. Together they are a truly unique and beautiful piece of work.
Illuminator follows Helena throughout several timelines, her previous life and building her new home in Tintar. We're introduced to so many new aspects of Helena's experiences as well as her POV of several moments in Priestess.
One of the most beautiful aspects of this book is watching Helena grow. Women's trauma is too often used distastefully in media, whether it be reduced to a plot device or shock value, but Helena's trauma is dealt with honestly and with so much sensitivity. The moments are handled with care and addressed with so much compassion, whether it be other character's reactions or Helena's internal monologue.
A large part of this growth is due to the patience and understanding that Thatcher gives Helena. I love how their relationship is written and it resonates with me on many levels. Thatcher is not the answer to Helena's healing, but he is there as unwavering support. He is trust, patience, respect.
As always, sisterhood is at the heart of this story. When I first read Priestess I remember thinking 'this book makes me love being a woman', all of these feelings came rushing back to me with Illuminator. I can think of no better example of well written female friendships, rooted in respect and non-judgement, these are women that support fiercely, are resilient in the face of adversity yet provide gentle and safe spaces. This is a story where each woman is needed, she has her own depth yet compliments her fellow sisters perfectly. I could not imagine excluding any of these characters while reading either book, I love how much care has been taken to shape them into who they are.
I cannot thank Kara enough for this story, this is not just a love letter to Priestess fans but a love letter to women - to those that love and grieve, are flawed and relatable, strong and soft, loud and quiet, to mothers and artists and everyone in between, may you always see in colour.
Illuminator follows Helena throughout several timelines, her previous life and building her new home in Tintar. We're introduced to so many new aspects of Helena's experiences as well as her POV of several moments in Priestess.
One of the most beautiful aspects of this book is watching Helena grow. Women's trauma is too often used distastefully in media, whether it be reduced to a plot device or shock value, but Helena's trauma is dealt with honestly and with so much sensitivity. The moments are handled with care and addressed with so much compassion, whether it be other character's reactions or Helena's internal monologue.
She grit her teeth. "So much of a woman's life is built in addition to foundations already laid out by the men she encounters, whether by choice or not."
[...]And I said, "I am weary of all my definitions being drawn by men's hands. Let me paint the lines now. Give me the brush. That is not my shape."
A large part of this growth is due to the patience and understanding that Thatcher gives Helena. I love how their relationship is written and it resonates with me on many levels. Thatcher is not the answer to Helena's healing, but he is there as unwavering support. He is trust, patience, respect.
"You climb too far above your station, man. You seek the moon."
The sergeant remained looking at me but replied over his shoulder, "If she is the moon, I will have to use the stars for footholds."
As always, sisterhood is at the heart of this story. When I first read Priestess I remember thinking 'this book makes me love being a woman', all of these feelings came rushing back to me with Illuminator. I can think of no better example of well written female friendships, rooted in respect and non-judgement, these are women that support fiercely, are resilient in the face of adversity yet provide gentle and safe spaces. This is a story where each woman is needed, she has her own depth yet compliments her fellow sisters perfectly. I could not imagine excluding any of these characters while reading either book, I love how much care has been taken to shape them into who they are.
"Once you bank the fires of youth, you learn there is still ash to sweep from your hearth. I did not even know that I needed friends. I always thought how lucky I was in a lover - how could I ask for more? And then it was just given to me, the lot of you, by some kinder god, I do not know."
I cannot thank Kara enough for this story, this is not just a love letter to Priestess fans but a love letter to women - to those that love and grieve, are flawed and relatable, strong and soft, loud and quiet, to mothers and artists and everyone in between, may you always see in colour.
September 10, 2025
I had the great privilege of beta reading this amazing book.
Illuminator takes place within the same timeline of Priestess, so it is best to read Priestess first. This follows the story of Helena and her courtship with Thatcher, which is filled with both tender and sensual moments. However, the author also flashes back to pivotal moments in Helena's life, opening with the birth of her daughter, Maureen.
I am an absolute fiend for the romance between Helena and Thatcher. But I was also affected by Helena's relationship with her daughter and the internal struggle she faced. Her desire to do right by her child and her fear that she was failing in that endeavor. There were so many moments in Illuminator that spoke to my experience as a mother and brought tears to my eyes.
As with Edie in Priestess, the author takes Helena on a journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance. As a woman who has been wronged by many men in her life and a survivor of SA, Helena struggles to connect with certain parts of herself, and has difficulty letting go and letting herself experience joy. Helena's path to allowing herself to trust, to love, and to be loved in return unfolded beautifully with the reader rooting for her the entire way.
Illuminator delivers the female empowerment/girl gang vibes, queer-normative world, and slow burn swoon-worthy romance that made Priestess such an enjoyable read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️! 10/10 recommend!
Illuminator takes place within the same timeline of Priestess, so it is best to read Priestess first. This follows the story of Helena and her courtship with Thatcher, which is filled with both tender and sensual moments. However, the author also flashes back to pivotal moments in Helena's life, opening with the birth of her daughter, Maureen.
I am an absolute fiend for the romance between Helena and Thatcher. But I was also affected by Helena's relationship with her daughter and the internal struggle she faced. Her desire to do right by her child and her fear that she was failing in that endeavor. There were so many moments in Illuminator that spoke to my experience as a mother and brought tears to my eyes.
As with Edie in Priestess, the author takes Helena on a journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance. As a woman who has been wronged by many men in her life and a survivor of SA, Helena struggles to connect with certain parts of herself, and has difficulty letting go and letting herself experience joy. Helena's path to allowing herself to trust, to love, and to be loved in return unfolded beautifully with the reader rooting for her the entire way.
Illuminator delivers the female empowerment/girl gang vibes, queer-normative world, and slow burn swoon-worthy romance that made Priestess such an enjoyable read.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️! 10/10 recommend!
January 14, 2026
Beautiful short arch of Helena’s story and how it wove through that from Priestess. I loved Priestess and I really enjoyed reading this novella. I didn’t give it all 5 starts because it felt hard to fully immerse myself as this was a bits of snippets and moments from her past and from parts of the previous book. But still really lovely learning about her story and her pains. It was really relatable and heartbreaking and heart mending.
3.5 stars sounded up to 4
3.5 stars sounded up to 4
December 30, 2025
Not a single thing happened in this book but it was so beautiful. I could not put it down.
November 15, 2025
** Disclaimer: I was a sensitivity reader for this book and was gifted a copy by the author. I also bought my own copy from the Crafty Bookstore, but I felt it was necessary to state that I was, in fact, given a copy as well. And not just to brag :p **
**TW: SA, graphic birth scene, financial abuse**
I am in the unique position of having seen this book roughshod, scaffolding still around the plot and themes, and then getting to read it cleaned up and out in the world. Between notes and texts sent back and forth with Kara, she worked out the story in her heart while graciously taking my feedback as a sensitivity reader. There are books about assault, but it's a little disheartening to realize that those books are often the attack and the aftermath. Books about healing are few and far between, and well-meaning authors often forget to hand the power back to the survivor. SA is a multi-faceted thing. Healing isn't linear, it usually is a lifelong endeavor, but luckily, life is long and the time between the hard days stretch out further and further the longer you live.
That is what Illuminator gives us. There is no gilding the lily, the attack happens and Helena is changed for it. But she has a support system that guides her to meals, takes care of her teenaged daughter, that catches her when she falters. There is no moment when she is made to weather the storm alone. But the narrative also doesn't treat her like she's some simpering maiden who can be cured by a good swiving. Her sexual exploration is done in stages with the most patient and understanding man alive, Thatcher. Boisterous and crass, Thatcher was an instant favorite of mine in Priestess, and getting this intimate portrait of him was such a treat.
I hope Illuminator sets the standard for these kinds of narratives. Sexuality after assault is a touchy subject, and its easy to fumble and cause real harm, but its not impossible to do it right. It just requires an open ear and heart that says, "What can I do to tell this story right?" And Kara does this in a way i never thought I'd get in this life.
For being a companion novel, Illuminator has a lot to offer its readers. As is the trend in the Gods of Tintar series, you have found family, girl gangs, communication, spice that makes your toes curl with delight, and so much more. Don't let any preconceived notions of romantasy steer you into thinking this series is a shallow romp in the hay. It isn't. Your life will change after reading these books, if not philosophically, you will have a deep appreciation for the beauty in the world because the writing truly makes me see things entirely differently.
You'd be remiss to skip Illuminator just because its a companion novel.
**TW: SA, graphic birth scene, financial abuse**
I am in the unique position of having seen this book roughshod, scaffolding still around the plot and themes, and then getting to read it cleaned up and out in the world. Between notes and texts sent back and forth with Kara, she worked out the story in her heart while graciously taking my feedback as a sensitivity reader. There are books about assault, but it's a little disheartening to realize that those books are often the attack and the aftermath. Books about healing are few and far between, and well-meaning authors often forget to hand the power back to the survivor. SA is a multi-faceted thing. Healing isn't linear, it usually is a lifelong endeavor, but luckily, life is long and the time between the hard days stretch out further and further the longer you live.
That is what Illuminator gives us. There is no gilding the lily, the attack happens and Helena is changed for it. But she has a support system that guides her to meals, takes care of her teenaged daughter, that catches her when she falters. There is no moment when she is made to weather the storm alone. But the narrative also doesn't treat her like she's some simpering maiden who can be cured by a good swiving. Her sexual exploration is done in stages with the most patient and understanding man alive, Thatcher. Boisterous and crass, Thatcher was an instant favorite of mine in Priestess, and getting this intimate portrait of him was such a treat.
I hope Illuminator sets the standard for these kinds of narratives. Sexuality after assault is a touchy subject, and its easy to fumble and cause real harm, but its not impossible to do it right. It just requires an open ear and heart that says, "What can I do to tell this story right?" And Kara does this in a way i never thought I'd get in this life.
For being a companion novel, Illuminator has a lot to offer its readers. As is the trend in the Gods of Tintar series, you have found family, girl gangs, communication, spice that makes your toes curl with delight, and so much more. Don't let any preconceived notions of romantasy steer you into thinking this series is a shallow romp in the hay. It isn't. Your life will change after reading these books, if not philosophically, you will have a deep appreciation for the beauty in the world because the writing truly makes me see things entirely differently.
You'd be remiss to skip Illuminator just because its a companion novel.
September 3, 2025
Ah this book was everything! After finishing Priestess, with how complete and fulfilling it felt, I thought I was ready to leave these lovely ladies behind in Tintar. After receiving my ARC of Illuminator, I realized how wrong I was. Even though I had read Priestess more than 8 months ago, it was comfortable to ease back into this world and these characters, and exciting to be able to dive deeply into Helena's past and her burgeoning relationship with Caleb. As no words I can write will do this book justice with how beautifully written it is, I can only say I teared up many times with Helena's descriptions of motherhood, sistership, and her lived experiences as a woman in a world which can be needlessly cruel.
What I loved:
- The sisterhood of course. These women are ride-or-die and have such deep affection for each other. To find unwavering support and love like that in a friend group is truly a gift.
- Caleb and Helena's slow burn relationship. He was able to love her as well as give her space to begin defining herself outside of her proximity to men.
- A bald MMC, it's nice to see some diversity here in this genre!
- The complete and utter feeling of peace and happiness I had after finishing the book. It made me feel proud and seen as a woman, and the book shed light on the silent struggles many women unfortunately have to deal with and overcome.
What I didn't love as much:
- If I HAD to pick something I'd say the third act miscommunication wasn't my favourite thing to happen, but I understand why it had to. This is just a me thing though as it made me anxious, but everything worked out and we got our HEA.
Easily a 5 star read - I cried and laughed and swooned and will now be excitedly awaiting the next beautiful book Kara brings into this world.
What I loved:
- The sisterhood of course. These women are ride-or-die and have such deep affection for each other. To find unwavering support and love like that in a friend group is truly a gift.
- Caleb and Helena's slow burn relationship. He was able to love her as well as give her space to begin defining herself outside of her proximity to men.
- A bald MMC, it's nice to see some diversity here in this genre!
- The complete and utter feeling of peace and happiness I had after finishing the book. It made me feel proud and seen as a woman, and the book shed light on the silent struggles many women unfortunately have to deal with and overcome.
What I didn't love as much:
- If I HAD to pick something I'd say the third act miscommunication wasn't my favourite thing to happen, but I understand why it had to. This is just a me thing though as it made me anxious, but everything worked out and we got our HEA.
Easily a 5 star read - I cried and laughed and swooned and will now be excitedly awaiting the next beautiful book Kara brings into this world.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 7, 2025
ARC Review: Illuminator (Gods of Tintar, #1.5)
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Illuminator brings us on a gorgeous journey of healing and empowerment; walking through past traumas and pain, finding strength in the bonds of sisterhood, and learning to speak our innermost desires. Kara delves into Helena's traumatic past while delighting us with details of her budding relationship with Thatcher, as well as providing new perspectives into the rest of our beloved Priestess girl gang. 🤍
Tropes/Themes: emotionally mature MMC, strong female characters, found family, motherhood, lgbtq rep, sisterhood, slow burn romance, 35+ FMC, practical magic, female agency
Thatcher is the epitome of consent, patience, humility, and healthy masculinity. Helena is his queen, and the reverence he displays for her cannot be matched. Pair this with his *unfiltered* mouth in their 🔥 scenes, and we have a 5⭐ book boyfriend here.
"I will stay in every room with you until you are done speaking. I will wait for you to find the words. I will delay until I know where your heart is, and if it does not beat with mine, then I will find your heart's rhythm. I will let you have the last word. I am told it is wise to let your wife have that." 🤍
"If she is the moon, I will have to use the stars for footholds" ✨
Illuminator will leave you laughing and crying, wishing to hold hands with the emotionally-beautiful characters in this book as they walk through their traumas. I experienced more healing reading this book than in any therapy session to date ❤️🩹 I'm encouraging all of the women and moms in my life to read this (and Priestess!).
I'm beyond thrilled to have received an ARC of Illuminator in exchange for an honest review.
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Illuminator brings us on a gorgeous journey of healing and empowerment; walking through past traumas and pain, finding strength in the bonds of sisterhood, and learning to speak our innermost desires. Kara delves into Helena's traumatic past while delighting us with details of her budding relationship with Thatcher, as well as providing new perspectives into the rest of our beloved Priestess girl gang. 🤍
Tropes/Themes: emotionally mature MMC, strong female characters, found family, motherhood, lgbtq rep, sisterhood, slow burn romance, 35+ FMC, practical magic, female agency
Thatcher is the epitome of consent, patience, humility, and healthy masculinity. Helena is his queen, and the reverence he displays for her cannot be matched. Pair this with his *unfiltered* mouth in their 🔥 scenes, and we have a 5⭐ book boyfriend here.
"I will stay in every room with you until you are done speaking. I will wait for you to find the words. I will delay until I know where your heart is, and if it does not beat with mine, then I will find your heart's rhythm. I will let you have the last word. I am told it is wise to let your wife have that." 🤍
"If she is the moon, I will have to use the stars for footholds" ✨
Illuminator will leave you laughing and crying, wishing to hold hands with the emotionally-beautiful characters in this book as they walk through their traumas. I experienced more healing reading this book than in any therapy session to date ❤️🩹 I'm encouraging all of the women and moms in my life to read this (and Priestess!).
I'm beyond thrilled to have received an ARC of Illuminator in exchange for an honest review.
September 7, 2025
My words could never adequately describe how incredible Illuminator is or how consumed I was while reading it. Amongst Kara’s many talents is her ability to write in such a vibrant and vivid way that I feel like I am enveloped by the warmth of old friends as I read. Kara’s masterful skill of describing colors literally makes me taste them (that’s probably weird but that’s the best way I can describe it).
Illuminator builds on the snippets of Helena and Thatcher’s relationship that were first introduced in Priestess. This novel provides the story from Helena’s view. It is a story of love, forgiveness, courage, and growth - most importantly, Helena’s to her self. Her relationship with Thatcher is a bonus, in my eyes. And of course, Edie and the rest of our women are there every step of the way.
Kara has said that Illuminator is a love letter to Priestess readers. I believe that in my soul because I could feel it in every word that I read. I cannot wait to continue the journey in Pilgrimess.
Illuminator builds on the snippets of Helena and Thatcher’s relationship that were first introduced in Priestess. This novel provides the story from Helena’s view. It is a story of love, forgiveness, courage, and growth - most importantly, Helena’s to her self. Her relationship with Thatcher is a bonus, in my eyes. And of course, Edie and the rest of our women are there every step of the way.
Kara has said that Illuminator is a love letter to Priestess readers. I believe that in my soul because I could feel it in every word that I read. I cannot wait to continue the journey in Pilgrimess.
August 5, 2025
I had the honour and pleasure of receiving an eARC of Illuminator.
“The best love stories have dirt under their fingernails.”
Priestess was one of my favourite reads of 2025 so far, so I was excited to revisit the world and characters of that book in its companion novella, Illuminator.
Illuminator combines a series of vignettes from Helena’s past with the story of her making a life in Tintar. We see her flourish as a woman, a mother, a lover, and a friend. Thatcher, with his filthy mouth and tender heart, woos Helena in such an intuitive, patient way. I love a morally gray MMC as much as the next person, but Thatcher’s worshipful devotion to Helena was a delight to read.
This story has some painful elements, but they’re handled with care and sensitivity. These heavier themes are balanced by excellent banter, girl gang shenanigans, and even an Alric impression by Thatcher (poor, sweet, serious Alric). There was a part that made me laugh out loud, but I won’t spoil it by sharing it here. 😉
Once again, Kara Reynolds delivers lush, lyrical prose and superb character development. There were some sections so beautifully written that I went back and read them two or three times so I could enjoy them again (and again).
All in all, Illuminator is a stunning follow up to Priestess. I’ll read anything and everything Kara Reynolds writes!
August 5, 2025
Kara knows how to write love.
sisterhood
motherhood
desire/courting , I love a slow burn 🔥
& of course self love
it is refreshing to read a book about adults finding themselves and each other.
Caleb got me giddy and Helena had me around her finger.
Helena stayed strong/brave for far too long, that poor woman needed a hug throughout the book.
sisterhood
motherhood
desire/courting , I love a slow burn 🔥
& of course self love
it is refreshing to read a book about adults finding themselves and each other.
Caleb got me giddy and Helena had me around her finger.
Helena stayed strong/brave for far too long, that poor woman needed a hug throughout the book.
January 15, 2026
This was a lovely languid story to build up the characters from The Priestess, told from Helena’s perspective (so it is mainly her backstory) and it gripped me from pretty early on.
On reflection, not a lot actually happens in terms of plot but I was gripped all the same and loved the strong female friendships that we saw in Priestess.
I will gladly read whatever Kara writes and looking forward to the next in the series!
On reflection, not a lot actually happens in terms of plot but I was gripped all the same and loved the strong female friendships that we saw in Priestess.
I will gladly read whatever Kara writes and looking forward to the next in the series!
October 9, 2025
Wow, was so excited to see a sequel to Priestess, a book that I was absolutely blown away by last year. This one was great too. Love the unique world, plot and characters. Kudos to this author for once again doing something very rare to come across, but satisfying--using her epilogue to show her characters at the end of their well-live lives so we know how the 'story really ends'.
Note: This book should be read AFTER Priestess; it is the same timeline/story told from very different points of view and will add to your enjoyment of this world. Very neat to experience. Also, the slow burn way the romances between the MCs develop--for good reasons--is a huge strength of this author. As is the found family of women of various ages, types and outlooks.
Highly recommended by me, and I'm very glad to see per author's social media that she has at least 2 more books coming in this series. Yay for future me reading!
Note: This book should be read AFTER Priestess; it is the same timeline/story told from very different points of view and will add to your enjoyment of this world. Very neat to experience. Also, the slow burn way the romances between the MCs develop--for good reasons--is a huge strength of this author. As is the found family of women of various ages, types and outlooks.
Highly recommended by me, and I'm very glad to see per author's social media that she has at least 2 more books coming in this series. Yay for future me reading!
September 27, 2025
I read Priestess earlier this year and absolutely loved it, so I knew any more books written by Reynolds would be instant purchases. Illuminator focuses on Helena’s story this time around, and it’s considered a novella, but at close to 400 pages, there’s still a lot of story here. I loved Helena’s story so incredibly much, and I’m very glad Reynolds is continuing to build out this world.
Helena’s story takes place both in various parts of her past and during Priestess's story. Everything is from Helena’s point of view, and I really enjoyed being inside her head. Helena has been through so much, and she develops and grows so much over the course of this story. I really enjoyed her character in book one, but I fell in love with her even more in this companion novel.
There are so many things I love about this book, but its depiction of female friendship, romance, and self discovery have to be my three favorites. The author focuses a lot on her female characters’ relationships with other women and their experiences as women in a society that views them as less than men. In the first novel, I loved getting to know all of these women and seeing bonds form between them, and it was the same in this second book. Helena’s romance with Caleb was also so beautiful, and he was such a wonderful MMC. The progression of their relationship felt natural and believable, and I enjoyed every minute of it. I also loved the way Helena was still growing and learning things about herself and what she wants even though she’s in her late thirties. So often we get stories of this kind of growth and discovery about very young women, and that makes sense, but not everyone figures themselves out in their early twenties. I think for many women it takes longer, especially if they’ve been through things like Helena, and it was so relatable and inspiring seeing that here.
I highly recommend Illuminator along with Priestess. I can’t wait to see what’s next from Reynolds, and I hope it’s coming soon.
Helena’s story takes place both in various parts of her past and during Priestess's story. Everything is from Helena’s point of view, and I really enjoyed being inside her head. Helena has been through so much, and she develops and grows so much over the course of this story. I really enjoyed her character in book one, but I fell in love with her even more in this companion novel.
There are so many things I love about this book, but its depiction of female friendship, romance, and self discovery have to be my three favorites. The author focuses a lot on her female characters’ relationships with other women and their experiences as women in a society that views them as less than men. In the first novel, I loved getting to know all of these women and seeing bonds form between them, and it was the same in this second book. Helena’s romance with Caleb was also so beautiful, and he was such a wonderful MMC. The progression of their relationship felt natural and believable, and I enjoyed every minute of it. I also loved the way Helena was still growing and learning things about herself and what she wants even though she’s in her late thirties. So often we get stories of this kind of growth and discovery about very young women, and that makes sense, but not everyone figures themselves out in their early twenties. I think for many women it takes longer, especially if they’ve been through things like Helena, and it was so relatable and inspiring seeing that here.
I highly recommend Illuminator along with Priestess. I can’t wait to see what’s next from Reynolds, and I hope it’s coming soon.
September 7, 2025
Kara Reynolds you genius.
So far the books in the Gods of Tintar series have been like little matryoshka dolls of love stories. Yes, both Priestess and Illuminator tell us about romantic love unfolding in unexpected and beautiful ways. But within and around those of romances are other love stories.
If Priestess was a love story about the women who came to Tintar with Edie couched within a larger romantic narrative, then Illuminator is a story of romantic love built within the scaffolding of a journey of self-love.
We see bits and pieces of Helena and Thatcher’s relationship throughout Priestess, but what really gives their story emotional resonance in Illuminator are the pasts they both bring with them. The book doesn’t start with Helena meeting Caleb; it starts with Helena meeting her daughter, Maureen. We see how Helena’s choices in Tintar are informed by her life in Eccleston—the life defined by the men who to failed her to varying degrees, even if they loved her. We see her first try to define herself against those past relationships—refusing grief, refusing companionship as a rebuke against her younger self, trying to cut out parts of herself that are anything other than a mother. And yes, we see how ultimately her happiness in Tintar doesn’t depend upon a man not failing her, but on her deliberately deciding to love herself free from the expectations put on her by others. On her seizing agency for herself in this second chance at a life. But we also see how choosing herself means embracing herself as a whole person—including inviting a man she loves and trusts into that life, alongside her. The ending is a beautiful dovetail of both the story of Helena and Caleb’s love, and the life Helena has allowed herself to build by loving herself, too.
I cried. Obviously.
So far the books in the Gods of Tintar series have been like little matryoshka dolls of love stories. Yes, both Priestess and Illuminator tell us about romantic love unfolding in unexpected and beautiful ways. But within and around those of romances are other love stories.
If Priestess was a love story about the women who came to Tintar with Edie couched within a larger romantic narrative, then Illuminator is a story of romantic love built within the scaffolding of a journey of self-love.
We see bits and pieces of Helena and Thatcher’s relationship throughout Priestess, but what really gives their story emotional resonance in Illuminator are the pasts they both bring with them. The book doesn’t start with Helena meeting Caleb; it starts with Helena meeting her daughter, Maureen. We see how Helena’s choices in Tintar are informed by her life in Eccleston—the life defined by the men who to failed her to varying degrees, even if they loved her. We see her first try to define herself against those past relationships—refusing grief, refusing companionship as a rebuke against her younger self, trying to cut out parts of herself that are anything other than a mother. And yes, we see how ultimately her happiness in Tintar doesn’t depend upon a man not failing her, but on her deliberately deciding to love herself free from the expectations put on her by others. On her seizing agency for herself in this second chance at a life. But we also see how choosing herself means embracing herself as a whole person—including inviting a man she loves and trusts into that life, alongside her. The ending is a beautiful dovetail of both the story of Helena and Caleb’s love, and the life Helena has allowed herself to build by loving herself, too.
I cried. Obviously.
September 9, 2025
Full disclosure: I loved Priestess. I stayed up all night reading it and was super depressed when there wasn't an immediate sequel. Honestly, I was super nervous about this one not being able to stand up to the first. Turns out, Reynolds just kicks ass. She delivered another great book, and I tore through my ARC in less than a day.
One thing I really crave in first person, past tense fantasy novels is something a little deeper than the surface level--I look for stories that are also about the telling. The events of the novel have already happened, and the narrator is reflecting back on them. It's pretty rare to find a fantasy novel that uses POV in a deeper way, and Reynolds blew me away.
This novel is a story, but it's also about the telling. It's about women reclaiming their voices and actively shaping their stories in the face of everything that happened to them. Especially for Helena, who has experienced more than her share of horrors, it was so so refreshing to see her story as complete and separate from Edie. She's complicated and damaged, and her telling is about reclaiming her power, moving forward, and accepting love.
Ok. So that's the nerdy portion of the review. Here's the fangirl version:
- Thatcher is the dreamiest of the dreamies and if you're looking for a love story that kind of knocks you off your feet, this is it.
- So nice to see the girl gang again.
- The writing on the sentence level is gorgeous. It has music. I found myself rereading passages that were particularly lovely. A few times, I had to put my book down because I needed to sit with some of the images.
- Edie is my girl, but Helena won by heart.
- Female friendships FTW.
I can't wait to read more by Reynolds. She's a star. I can't believe she's not more well-known. This lady can WRITE, and I'll be preordering any future book.
One thing I really crave in first person, past tense fantasy novels is something a little deeper than the surface level--I look for stories that are also about the telling. The events of the novel have already happened, and the narrator is reflecting back on them. It's pretty rare to find a fantasy novel that uses POV in a deeper way, and Reynolds blew me away.
This novel is a story, but it's also about the telling. It's about women reclaiming their voices and actively shaping their stories in the face of everything that happened to them. Especially for Helena, who has experienced more than her share of horrors, it was so so refreshing to see her story as complete and separate from Edie. She's complicated and damaged, and her telling is about reclaiming her power, moving forward, and accepting love.
Ok. So that's the nerdy portion of the review. Here's the fangirl version:
- Thatcher is the dreamiest of the dreamies and if you're looking for a love story that kind of knocks you off your feet, this is it.
- So nice to see the girl gang again.
- The writing on the sentence level is gorgeous. It has music. I found myself rereading passages that were particularly lovely. A few times, I had to put my book down because I needed to sit with some of the images.
- Edie is my girl, but Helena won by heart.
- Female friendships FTW.
I can't wait to read more by Reynolds. She's a star. I can't believe she's not more well-known. This lady can WRITE, and I'll be preordering any future book.
August 21, 2025
This novella is a love letter to Priestess readers, survivors, and all the women who were taught to put everyone else’s comfort and pleasure first.
I loved Helena in Priestess, and seeing inside her head for the full length of a book was an absolute treat. She has so many powerful emotions that she hasn’t had the luxury to process until the events of this book, a secret sassy side, and a fierce boldness she gets to discover alongside Thatcher that is just beautiful to see blossom.
Kara’s writing has an unparalleled power to make me feel. As with Priestess, Illuminator had me laughing on one page, crying the next, and ready to throw my Kindle across the room (or at Cyrus) after that. Helena’s story weaves together her past with the events of Priestess in a way that will break your heart so that you get to heal right along with her.
If you haven’t yet, I do recommend you read Priestess first so you have the weight of all the story context, and the absolute delight of getting Helena’s view on all the women in her found family. But if you can’t wait to dive into Helena and Thatcher’s relationship, I don’t blame you. Thatcher may have ruined all other fictional men for me. He’s so sensitive to everything Helena has been through, while being absolutely enamored with her. The yearning! Nevermind all the heart-stopping things he says to her. My goddess.
I loved Helena in Priestess, and seeing inside her head for the full length of a book was an absolute treat. She has so many powerful emotions that she hasn’t had the luxury to process until the events of this book, a secret sassy side, and a fierce boldness she gets to discover alongside Thatcher that is just beautiful to see blossom.
Kara’s writing has an unparalleled power to make me feel. As with Priestess, Illuminator had me laughing on one page, crying the next, and ready to throw my Kindle across the room (or at Cyrus) after that. Helena’s story weaves together her past with the events of Priestess in a way that will break your heart so that you get to heal right along with her.
If you haven’t yet, I do recommend you read Priestess first so you have the weight of all the story context, and the absolute delight of getting Helena’s view on all the women in her found family. But if you can’t wait to dive into Helena and Thatcher’s relationship, I don’t blame you. Thatcher may have ruined all other fictional men for me. He’s so sensitive to everything Helena has been through, while being absolutely enamored with her. The yearning! Nevermind all the heart-stopping things he says to her. My goddess.
August 14, 2025
Well, Kara Reynolds has done it again. As far as I’m concerned, she’s already a feminist icon, and it’s only a matter of time before the rest of the world catches on in a huge way. Illuminator somehow manages to represent femininity in all its unique forms while still maintaining the common thread that unites us as women. If you want to read a book that showcases feminine strength in all of its diverse manifestations, read priestess, illuminator, and anything else she writes.
Illuminator specifically is a stunning introspective journey of learning to speak, to take, to give, and to simply trust yourself. Helena’s story is beautiful and painfully honest in the best possible way. The book alternates between moments that quietly linger as well as moments that land like a punch to the gut. All of it balances out to leave the reader feeling like they just completed a very cathartic therapy session. It was a joy to revisit some of my favorite characters, viewing them from a different lens. Some books only disappoint in that they must come to an end. In that regard, I’m writing this review very disappointed. I’ll try to be patient, but if I’m honest, I’m already foaming at the mouth for the next one!
Illuminator specifically is a stunning introspective journey of learning to speak, to take, to give, and to simply trust yourself. Helena’s story is beautiful and painfully honest in the best possible way. The book alternates between moments that quietly linger as well as moments that land like a punch to the gut. All of it balances out to leave the reader feeling like they just completed a very cathartic therapy session. It was a joy to revisit some of my favorite characters, viewing them from a different lens. Some books only disappoint in that they must come to an end. In that regard, I’m writing this review very disappointed. I’ll try to be patient, but if I’m honest, I’m already foaming at the mouth for the next one!
August 12, 2025
ARC review:
Illuminator by Kara Reynolds
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“I am weary of all my definitions being drawn by men’s hands. Let me paint the lines now. Give me the brush. That is not my shape.”
Wow. Kara was not lying when she said that Illuminator is a long love letter to Priestess readers. In this companion book to Priestess, Kara has delivered an emotionally impactful, devastating back story for Helena, and a story of a woman finding courage and resilience through dark times. Helena possesses a quiet strength. One that was forged in the fires of motherhood and loss. One that is bolstered by her female friendships and sees her through her traumatic kidnapping and journey to Tintar, where she finds herself, forgives herself, and finally allows herself the happiness she deserves. Thatcher is every bit the perfect partner for Helena, and proof that opposites attract. He’s rough where she is soft, crude where she is refined, and ever-adoring, worshipping her as the queen she is.
Kara stepped up the romance and the spice in this book, building tension through the slow burn and writing scenes that will make your heart pound and your toes curl. Can anyone say Lady Nook? But despite this book stepping up the romance, the strongest threads woven into this story are still of female friendships, found family and healing from trauma. Three things Kara writes so well.
If you haven’t given Priestess a chance yet, I implore you to read it, and then fall headfirst into Illuminator directly after. You won’t be disappointed.
Illuminator by Kara Reynolds
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“I am weary of all my definitions being drawn by men’s hands. Let me paint the lines now. Give me the brush. That is not my shape.”
Wow. Kara was not lying when she said that Illuminator is a long love letter to Priestess readers. In this companion book to Priestess, Kara has delivered an emotionally impactful, devastating back story for Helena, and a story of a woman finding courage and resilience through dark times. Helena possesses a quiet strength. One that was forged in the fires of motherhood and loss. One that is bolstered by her female friendships and sees her through her traumatic kidnapping and journey to Tintar, where she finds herself, forgives herself, and finally allows herself the happiness she deserves. Thatcher is every bit the perfect partner for Helena, and proof that opposites attract. He’s rough where she is soft, crude where she is refined, and ever-adoring, worshipping her as the queen she is.
Kara stepped up the romance and the spice in this book, building tension through the slow burn and writing scenes that will make your heart pound and your toes curl. Can anyone say Lady Nook? But despite this book stepping up the romance, the strongest threads woven into this story are still of female friendships, found family and healing from trauma. Three things Kara writes so well.
If you haven’t given Priestess a chance yet, I implore you to read it, and then fall headfirst into Illuminator directly after. You won’t be disappointed.
August 22, 2025
✨✨ARC REVIEW✨✨
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
“The best love stories have dirt under their fingernails.”
I need the rest of this series expeditiously! (No pressure Kara but I am foaming at the mouth for the next book)
In Priestess (this is book 1.5 so it happens throughout Priestess) we get to meet Thatcher and Helena but we only get second hand knowledge of them and their story. This novella helps us understand Helena on a deeper level as we get to meet her as a young woman and we get to learn of the hardships life put her through.
The attraction between her and Thatcher had me squealing! Thatcher really is a smooth criminal with his words and the author is really raising the bar for how MMCs should be interacting with their love interest in books!
I enjoyed this book so much I read it in one sitting I could not be bothered to look away from it.
I am however, begging on my knees for a Mischa and Percy story I feel like their story is so interesting and would be such a good time to read!
I’d you are looking for an Epic Romantasy to dive into you really need to go get your hands on the Gods of Tintar series!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
“The best love stories have dirt under their fingernails.”
I need the rest of this series expeditiously! (No pressure Kara but I am foaming at the mouth for the next book)
In Priestess (this is book 1.5 so it happens throughout Priestess) we get to meet Thatcher and Helena but we only get second hand knowledge of them and their story. This novella helps us understand Helena on a deeper level as we get to meet her as a young woman and we get to learn of the hardships life put her through.
The attraction between her and Thatcher had me squealing! Thatcher really is a smooth criminal with his words and the author is really raising the bar for how MMCs should be interacting with their love interest in books!
I enjoyed this book so much I read it in one sitting I could not be bothered to look away from it.
I am however, begging on my knees for a Mischa and Percy story I feel like their story is so interesting and would be such a good time to read!
I’d you are looking for an Epic Romantasy to dive into you really need to go get your hands on the Gods of Tintar series!
August 30, 2025
I LOVED THIS BOOK! Illuminator builds off the world pre-established in Priestess so it was nice to be able to just dive right in. I loved seeing the events from Helena’s POV. It’s rare that a late 30’s mom gets to be the star of a romantasy story and it was really lovely to see her step into her power and embrace her own love story. She’s a flawed character and gets in her own way a lot, and it’s so gratifying to witness her growth. As far as the MMC, Kara Reynolds has once again written one of my favorite book boyfriends. Caleb Thatcher is THE consent king and I adore him. I also loved seeing the “girl gang” from Helena’s perspective. Dream lightleaf rotation! I will say that if you’re looking for a sweeping epic fantasy plot, this ain’t it. It’s a quiet love story that happens while the “main characters” are off doing whatever it is they get up to. Personally I think we don’t get enough of these kinds of stories. I can’t wait to read whatever Kara writes next!
January 13, 2026
3.5✨
I loved Priestess so much and was excited to be back in this world. As expected I did love Kara’s writing, characters and how she writes female friendships. I adored getting to know Helena and her backstory and spent most of the book really hooked on this however I did start to lose interest as the book went on and her and Thatcher’s romance progressed. I think he just wasn’t my kind of MMC, I found him too gushing and adoring and I also hated the miscommunication element between them towards the end. Obviously as a side timeline to Priestess, this book was more character focused and less plot heavy which maybe meant it would always fall slightly shorter to Priestess for me? I will also add that Helena’s trauma was handled with such sensitivity in this book which as a reader I appreciated.
Overall an enjoyable read to start 2026 , Priestess was one of my favourite books of 2025 and I’m excited for Pilgrimess to come out later this year!
I loved Priestess so much and was excited to be back in this world. As expected I did love Kara’s writing, characters and how she writes female friendships. I adored getting to know Helena and her backstory and spent most of the book really hooked on this however I did start to lose interest as the book went on and her and Thatcher’s romance progressed. I think he just wasn’t my kind of MMC, I found him too gushing and adoring and I also hated the miscommunication element between them towards the end. Obviously as a side timeline to Priestess, this book was more character focused and less plot heavy which maybe meant it would always fall slightly shorter to Priestess for me? I will also add that Helena’s trauma was handled with such sensitivity in this book which as a reader I appreciated.
Overall an enjoyable read to start 2026 , Priestess was one of my favourite books of 2025 and I’m excited for Pilgrimess to come out later this year!
September 16, 2025
I was so surprised to find this book, I had been going back to re-read Priestess when I saw this was to be released the following day. I’ve devoured it over the past few days and while the romance and spice made me sigh, it was the way that complex trauma was dealt with that took my breath away. This book was healing, Caleb Thatcher is the fellow you need to coax you back into your body after sexual trauma. The kindred women are the friends you need when you’re processing a life of deprivation at the hands of men. Mischa’s chat with Helena was particularly brilliant, the way she sanity checked all those strongly held and long held beliefs Helena had. Since reading Priestess I often imagined the love between Helena and Thatcher, this was such a treat, got me out of a reading slump and healed some parts of me that I thought were permanently broken.
January 12, 2026
Absolutely phenomenal
I read Priestess the week it was first released, it was shown as a new book I might be interested in, and I promptly lost myself in the story of Edie. Then I sent many a copy to dear friends. Seeing the sequel, Illuminator, I was delighted. But I knew I would want to savor it, this return to Tintar and the women there. So much of these women resonate, their story being told from each perspective, layers upon layers. And it is a delight to read. To share. To feel all those bits and pieces of coming of age, then still realizing we have growing to do. That lives are complicated, and every path is different. That sisterhood is found in unlikely places and is our most enduring relationship.
I adore the story of Helena, a young mother who does her best, and the women who walk beside her.
10/10, a fantastic start to my reading year.
I read Priestess the week it was first released, it was shown as a new book I might be interested in, and I promptly lost myself in the story of Edie. Then I sent many a copy to dear friends. Seeing the sequel, Illuminator, I was delighted. But I knew I would want to savor it, this return to Tintar and the women there. So much of these women resonate, their story being told from each perspective, layers upon layers. And it is a delight to read. To share. To feel all those bits and pieces of coming of age, then still realizing we have growing to do. That lives are complicated, and every path is different. That sisterhood is found in unlikely places and is our most enduring relationship.
I adore the story of Helena, a young mother who does her best, and the women who walk beside her.
10/10, a fantastic start to my reading year.
November 22, 2025
3.5
This book is way different from Priestess, it’s more a story of Helena overcoming trauma than anything else. And for that, I think it’s really well done and very poignant. But because a lot of the story takes place in Tintar at the same time as Priestess it just felt like I knew what was happening, so it was a much different reading experience. It’s a slower story.
I definitely love Thatcher and Helena, their relationship and love story is so different from Alric and Edie. It was nice to get their relationship from their perspective, rather than from the people around them.
I kind of hope we do not get a Perch/Mischa story, I just don’t think I can read this book for like a third time. But I really enjoyed the writing and the world-building so I hope we see more of Tintar!
This book is way different from Priestess, it’s more a story of Helena overcoming trauma than anything else. And for that, I think it’s really well done and very poignant. But because a lot of the story takes place in Tintar at the same time as Priestess it just felt like I knew what was happening, so it was a much different reading experience. It’s a slower story.
I definitely love Thatcher and Helena, their relationship and love story is so different from Alric and Edie. It was nice to get their relationship from their perspective, rather than from the people around them.
I kind of hope we do not get a Perch/Mischa story, I just don’t think I can read this book for like a third time. But I really enjoyed the writing and the world-building so I hope we see more of Tintar!
August 12, 2025
⭐️𝕣𝕒𝕥𝕚𝕟𝕘 | ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🗓️ℝ𝕖𝕝𝕖𝕒𝕤𝕖 𝕕𝕒𝕥𝕖 | TBA – but hopefully soon!
📚 ℝ𝕖𝕧𝕚𝕖𝕨:
“If she is the moon, then I will have to use the stars as footholds.” — Thatcher 🌙✨
@karaneedstoread has done it again—this time with Illuminator, a luminous, emotionally charged companion to Priestess. Told through the eyes of the lovable, chaotic, and deeply human Helena (that’s Hell-uh-nuh, please and thank you), this story is an ode to fierce girls, found family, and the healing power of burning things down—sometimes metaphorically, sometimes not. 🔥💫
It’s a book that will make you laugh, cry, highlight too many quotes, and maybe text your best friend at 2 a.m. about that scene. The emotional depth here is stunning—from heartbreak to hilarity in the turn of a page—and it’s all wrapped in the warm glow of @markwilliamsart’s gorgeous cover art. 🎨📖
While Illuminator isn’t out just yet, it is absolutely worth the wait. In the meantime, RUN, don’t walk, to pick up Priestess and get to know this world and these characters. You’ll thank me later.
I was provided an eARC as part of Kara's street team. I am honored to be part of this wonderful community!
🗓️ℝ𝕖𝕝𝕖𝕒𝕤𝕖 𝕕𝕒𝕥𝕖 | TBA – but hopefully soon!
📚 ℝ𝕖𝕧𝕚𝕖𝕨:
“If she is the moon, then I will have to use the stars as footholds.” — Thatcher 🌙✨
@karaneedstoread has done it again—this time with Illuminator, a luminous, emotionally charged companion to Priestess. Told through the eyes of the lovable, chaotic, and deeply human Helena (that’s Hell-uh-nuh, please and thank you), this story is an ode to fierce girls, found family, and the healing power of burning things down—sometimes metaphorically, sometimes not. 🔥💫
It’s a book that will make you laugh, cry, highlight too many quotes, and maybe text your best friend at 2 a.m. about that scene. The emotional depth here is stunning—from heartbreak to hilarity in the turn of a page—and it’s all wrapped in the warm glow of @markwilliamsart’s gorgeous cover art. 🎨📖
While Illuminator isn’t out just yet, it is absolutely worth the wait. In the meantime, RUN, don’t walk, to pick up Priestess and get to know this world and these characters. You’ll thank me later.
I was provided an eARC as part of Kara's street team. I am honored to be part of this wonderful community!
September 1, 2025
🕊️ARC REVIEW 🕊️
The best love stories have dirt under their fingernails
These tears? Its an honor to collect them, friend
Tropes: Sisterhood, Slow Burn, Second Chance Love
Its a rare thing to find a story which moves back and forth through a FMC history without it feeling disconnected. The pacing of this book felt purposeful and trustworthy, Helena's and Caleb's love story is crafted around a patient maturity which was refreshing in the romantasy space. The relationships between the women which is the main focus of the story are genuine, heartwarming and reflective of those kinships built on honesty and space holding. They support one another through the world changing event they experience and somehow it makes their bond stronger. The men of their lives are additions but not accessories. they are fleshed out personalities one which have their own struggles and evolutions.
I believe that is why I took my time reading Illuminator, it felt soul bearing and gave connective tissue to Priestess. There was no rush to fill in gaps with unnecessary trials or upheavals, every chapter gave you space to fall in love with the relationships between the characters. Caleb's admiration of Helena was present but gave space for her healing, Helena's metamorphose was lovely to watch because you saw a women redefining herself after a traumatic event. Caleb and Helena's style of love story is something i hope to see more of and i look forward to Kara's next venture into the world of Tintar.
The best love stories have dirt under their fingernails
These tears? Its an honor to collect them, friend
Tropes: Sisterhood, Slow Burn, Second Chance Love
Its a rare thing to find a story which moves back and forth through a FMC history without it feeling disconnected. The pacing of this book felt purposeful and trustworthy, Helena's and Caleb's love story is crafted around a patient maturity which was refreshing in the romantasy space. The relationships between the women which is the main focus of the story are genuine, heartwarming and reflective of those kinships built on honesty and space holding. They support one another through the world changing event they experience and somehow it makes their bond stronger. The men of their lives are additions but not accessories. they are fleshed out personalities one which have their own struggles and evolutions.
I believe that is why I took my time reading Illuminator, it felt soul bearing and gave connective tissue to Priestess. There was no rush to fill in gaps with unnecessary trials or upheavals, every chapter gave you space to fall in love with the relationships between the characters. Caleb's admiration of Helena was present but gave space for her healing, Helena's metamorphose was lovely to watch because you saw a women redefining herself after a traumatic event. Caleb and Helena's style of love story is something i hope to see more of and i look forward to Kara's next venture into the world of Tintar.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews