What do you think?
Rate this book
Echoes of a Silent Song
A split-time romance from an award-winning author
When a choral composer and conductor falls victim to creative block, he resorts to his fallback plan of teaching high school choir. Callum Knight's goal at Peterson High is rediscover his muse, extract himself from teaching, and get back to Boston as quickly as possible.
As the long-suffering accompanist at the high school, Peterson-native Blair Emerson has watched the revolving door of choir directors and their negative impact on her choirs over the last few years. She is less than impressed when a disheveled Callum stumbles in on his first day.
But then they discover an unsigned, unfinished, and handwritten choral composition by a clear musical genius. Blair recalls rumors of Iris, a Peterson student from the 1970s who composed music but was found dead during her senior year. Blair and Callum work to determine if the piece is hers, and the truth they uncover shakes both of them to the core.
With rhythm and flair, Amanda Wen takes readers on an unexpected journey into the depths of a small town's history in this riveting first book in the Melodies and Memories duology.
When a choral composer and conductor falls victim to creative block, he resorts to his fallback plan of teaching high school choir. Callum Knight's goal at Peterson High is rediscover his muse, extract himself from teaching, and get back to Boston as quickly as possible.
As the long-suffering accompanist at the high school, Peterson-native Blair Emerson has watched the revolving door of choir directors and their negative impact on her choirs over the last few years. She is less than impressed when a disheveled Callum stumbles in on his first day.
But then they discover an unsigned, unfinished, and handwritten choral composition by a clear musical genius. Blair recalls rumors of Iris, a Peterson student from the 1970s who composed music but was found dead during her senior year. Blair and Callum work to determine if the piece is hers, and the truth they uncover shakes both of them to the core.
With rhythm and flair, Amanda Wen takes readers on an unexpected journey into the depths of a small town's history in this riveting first book in the Melodies and Memories duology.
280 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 21, 2025
3 people are currently reading
1837 people want to read
About the author
Amanda Wen
7 books332 followersAmanda Wen’s debut novel, Roots of Wood and Stone, released to both reader and critical acclaim, including a Christy Award nomination for First Novel. She also placed first in multiple contests, including the 2017 Indiana Golden Opportunity Contest, the 2017 Phoenix Rattler Contest, and the 2016 ACFW First Impressions Contest, among others.
In addition to her writing, Amanda is an accomplished professional cellist and pianist who frequently performs with orchestras, chamber groups, and her church’s worship team, as well as serving as a choral accompanist. A lifelong denizen of the flatlands, Amanda currently lives in Kansas with her patient, loving, and hilarious husband, their three adorable Wenlets, and a snuggly Siamese cat.
In addition to her writing, Amanda is an accomplished professional cellist and pianist who frequently performs with orchestras, chamber groups, and her church’s worship team, as well as serving as a choral accompanist. A lifelong denizen of the flatlands, Amanda currently lives in Kansas with her patient, loving, and hilarious husband, their three adorable Wenlets, and a snuggly Siamese cat.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews
December 15, 2025
Echoes of a Silent Song is clearly the product of deep research, relevant experience, and incredible plotting. Amanda Wen masterfully tackles complicated relationships while effortlessly weaving details into her characters’ everyday lives.
There was honestly no way I wasn’t going to like this book. I’m an elementary ed major, but I’ve seriously considered switching to music ed several times, with a choral education concentration. Watching Callum grow into these big shoes in the high school choral program, and getting to see him and Brynn interact on a daily basis… that’s really what made this book for me. It wasn’t instalove, but rather the product of a ton of time spent together doing what they love. The faith content was on-point too!
That said, Iris’s story WRECKED me. I did not see the end revelation coming. I don’t want to give too much away, but again, Wen does a fantastic job portraying her characters. And ugh, I was SO sad when she finally died. She had so much potential!
And then the ending…
I know I’m not saying a lot, but if you hear anything, hear this: READ IT. Wen knows her craft, and this story soars. It’s an incredible read and easily a new favorite.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
There was honestly no way I wasn’t going to like this book. I’m an elementary ed major, but I’ve seriously considered switching to music ed several times, with a choral education concentration. Watching Callum grow into these big shoes in the high school choral program, and getting to see him and Brynn interact on a daily basis… that’s really what made this book for me. It wasn’t instalove, but rather the product of a ton of time spent together doing what they love. The faith content was on-point too!
That said, Iris’s story WRECKED me. I did not see the end revelation coming. I don’t want to give too much away, but again, Wen does a fantastic job portraying her characters. And ugh, I was SO sad when she finally died. She had so much potential!
And then the ending…
I know I’m not saying a lot, but if you hear anything, hear this: READ IT. Wen knows her craft, and this story soars. It’s an incredible read and easily a new favorite.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
October 20, 2025
Echos of a Silent Song is brilliant. Amanda Wen's ability to tell a story with dual timelines is remarkable. She kept me fully invested in both Blair's and Callum's story as well as Iris’. Being a retired music teacher, I was transported back to my days in the music room. Add in the additional feat of composing music and I was totally engaged, rooting for Callum to regain his muse. I loved reading how each would overcome grief and past hurts, ready to find love again.
Ms. Wen skillfully intertwines a story from the past, with the same skill a composer weaves melody and harmony together. The secrets that surround Ivy's story were heartbreaking. Ms. Wen pens a story of mental illness with grace and compassion.
The plot was meticulously built, expertly switching between story-lines. Not only does this book provide a great mystery, it is also a story of hope that God is designing a happy ending, if one just learns to open their hearts and trust in Him.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Ms. Wen skillfully intertwines a story from the past, with the same skill a composer weaves melody and harmony together. The secrets that surround Ivy's story were heartbreaking. Ms. Wen pens a story of mental illness with grace and compassion.
The plot was meticulously built, expertly switching between story-lines. Not only does this book provide a great mystery, it is also a story of hope that God is designing a happy ending, if one just learns to open their hearts and trust in Him.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 14, 2025
Thank you to the author, the publisher, and NetGalley for this #gifted book!*
Title: Echoes of a Silent Song
Author: Amanda Wen
Genre: Split Time Romance
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Synopsis: When Callum Knight arrives as Peterson High’s new choral director, Blair Emerson, the choral pianist, prepares herself for another disappointing year. With new choral directors each year for the last several, she has very low expectations. But when Callum and Blair discover an old piece of unfinished music, a mystery begins to unfold. Iris Wallingford was a student who passed away during her senior year of high school, and she was also rumored to be a musical genius. Could this piece possibly be one of hers? As Callum and Blair work together to discover the truth, their findings force them to question everything they’ve learned and to face their own music that’s stirring deep inside themselves.
Analysis: How on earth am I just discovering Amanda Wen for the first time?! I absolutely love everything about this book. It will definitely be one of my favorite books this year! I loved the characters and the depth of their individual journeys. (Well most of them anyway 😉). The way they connected with music was fascinating. I loved the romance and the mystery—Amanda writes the perfect blend. And the split time is so well done. I was amazed at the way the author put all the pieces together in the end. And the emotion she conveys—you’ll feel everything right alongside the characters. And Amanda addressed the much needed discussion of mental health: this one was really unique because it dealt with anxiety/depression in the Viet Nam and Covid eras. This book would be excellent for book club discussions! While it did rip my heart out, Amanda put it all back together in the most beautiful way. It’s an immediate 5 stars for me.
Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Title: Echoes of a Silent Song
Author: Amanda Wen
Genre: Split Time Romance
⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀
Synopsis: When Callum Knight arrives as Peterson High’s new choral director, Blair Emerson, the choral pianist, prepares herself for another disappointing year. With new choral directors each year for the last several, she has very low expectations. But when Callum and Blair discover an old piece of unfinished music, a mystery begins to unfold. Iris Wallingford was a student who passed away during her senior year of high school, and she was also rumored to be a musical genius. Could this piece possibly be one of hers? As Callum and Blair work together to discover the truth, their findings force them to question everything they’ve learned and to face their own music that’s stirring deep inside themselves.
Analysis: How on earth am I just discovering Amanda Wen for the first time?! I absolutely love everything about this book. It will definitely be one of my favorite books this year! I loved the characters and the depth of their individual journeys. (Well most of them anyway 😉). The way they connected with music was fascinating. I loved the romance and the mystery—Amanda writes the perfect blend. And the split time is so well done. I was amazed at the way the author put all the pieces together in the end. And the emotion she conveys—you’ll feel everything right alongside the characters. And Amanda addressed the much needed discussion of mental health: this one was really unique because it dealt with anxiety/depression in the Viet Nam and Covid eras. This book would be excellent for book club discussions! While it did rip my heart out, Amanda put it all back together in the most beautiful way. It’s an immediate 5 stars for me.
Star Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
October 17, 2025
I'm a HUGE fan of Amanda Wen. She's one of my auto-buy authors. But this book in particular struck a chord with me (see what I did there?).
From the opening line it had my full attention. But then when you add in a downtrodden character, a mystery from the past, and a shady answer or two in the present? You definitely have a winner.
I don't know if this will be a series or not, but whatever she writes, I am HERE for it!
~I was given a complimentary copy of this book. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.~
From the opening line it had my full attention. But then when you add in a downtrodden character, a mystery from the past, and a shady answer or two in the present? You definitely have a winner.
I don't know if this will be a series or not, but whatever she writes, I am HERE for it!
~I was given a complimentary copy of this book. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.~
October 23, 2025
1969-1970 & present day Illinois
In this start of the series, I loved the chemistry between accompanist Blair and composer/conductor Callum. Blair is devoted to the students at Peterson High School. She is tired of the revolving door of one year/term conductors. When Callum announces he only took the job because he'd lost his music making muse and had all intentions of returning to Boston when the school year ended, Blair is immediately at odds with him. Lots of fun banter between them.
When they discover a piece of music in the high school music room, they learn it could have been written by a senior named Iris. As they strive to learn more about Iris, a secondary thread set in 1969 begins. I was riveted by the historical thread. The author does a nice job of shining a light on mental illness.
Favorite quote: "So you feel like God screwed up and you got hurt, and now you don't trust him to drive the car anymore, so you're yanking the steering wheel away and relegating him to the backseat?"
My gratitude to publisher Kregel for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
In this start of the series, I loved the chemistry between accompanist Blair and composer/conductor Callum. Blair is devoted to the students at Peterson High School. She is tired of the revolving door of one year/term conductors. When Callum announces he only took the job because he'd lost his music making muse and had all intentions of returning to Boston when the school year ended, Blair is immediately at odds with him. Lots of fun banter between them.
When they discover a piece of music in the high school music room, they learn it could have been written by a senior named Iris. As they strive to learn more about Iris, a secondary thread set in 1969 begins. I was riveted by the historical thread. The author does a nice job of shining a light on mental illness.
Favorite quote: "So you feel like God screwed up and you got hurt, and now you don't trust him to drive the car anymore, so you're yanking the steering wheel away and relegating him to the backseat?"
My gratitude to publisher Kregel for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
November 2, 2025
Every page hums with something eternal … the ache of being known, the beauty of being found, the grace of being restored.
Amanda Wen writes with an tender intimacy that reaches beneath the surface, where pain and hope quietly intertwine. Echoes of a Silent Song reveals the unseen battles people carry, and the way God can turn even silence into testimony.
Callum’s search for purpose and Blair’s steadfast compassion create a harmony that feels both fragile and healing. And Iris, her voice echoes through time, reminds us that broken stories can still sing of redemption. The dual timelines flow together like melody and memory, revealing how God weaves wholeness.
This book is staying with me, whispering reminders to look deeper, listen longer, and love better. It carried me into reflection about grace, about unseen pain, about how faith sometimes looks like waiting for the next note when all we can hear is silence.
A beautiful, thoughtful, and emotionally rich novel from an author whose storytelling feels deeply personal and tenderly guided.
Perfect for readers who long for stories that stir the heart, honor truth, and trace the intertwining threads of sorrow, faith, and the kind of love that outlasts the quiet.
I received a paperback of this book from the publisher. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on writing and content, ensuring transparency and trustworthy.
Amanda Wen writes with an tender intimacy that reaches beneath the surface, where pain and hope quietly intertwine. Echoes of a Silent Song reveals the unseen battles people carry, and the way God can turn even silence into testimony.
Callum’s search for purpose and Blair’s steadfast compassion create a harmony that feels both fragile and healing. And Iris, her voice echoes through time, reminds us that broken stories can still sing of redemption. The dual timelines flow together like melody and memory, revealing how God weaves wholeness.
This book is staying with me, whispering reminders to look deeper, listen longer, and love better. It carried me into reflection about grace, about unseen pain, about how faith sometimes looks like waiting for the next note when all we can hear is silence.
A beautiful, thoughtful, and emotionally rich novel from an author whose storytelling feels deeply personal and tenderly guided.
Perfect for readers who long for stories that stir the heart, honor truth, and trace the intertwining threads of sorrow, faith, and the kind of love that outlasts the quiet.
I received a paperback of this book from the publisher. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on writing and content, ensuring transparency and trustworthy.
November 5, 2025
Wow! What a heartbreaking haunting tale of music, lost love and faith. I fell in love with the characters and the story. It broke my heart but was also filled with a hope only the Lord can give.
It is rare when I enjoy both timelines of a dual timeline story equally but I enjoyed each timeline so much. A touch of mystery just added to the whole story. Amanda Wen is such a great storyteller and always pulls me in with her storytelling. The musical aspect spoke to my love of music as well and you could tell the author's history and love for music too.
*thank you to the publisher for a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
It is rare when I enjoy both timelines of a dual timeline story equally but I enjoyed each timeline so much. A touch of mystery just added to the whole story. Amanda Wen is such a great storyteller and always pulls me in with her storytelling. The musical aspect spoke to my love of music as well and you could tell the author's history and love for music too.
*thank you to the publisher for a complimentary copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.
October 10, 2025
Echoes of a Silent Song by Amanda Wen is a masterpiece. I loved the nostalgic vibes it gave me. I was transported back to my high school years 1965-67 and my choral classes. My teacher was also my church choir leader. I also remember waiting to see which number would come up in the draft during the Vietnam era. My husband enlisted in the Navy before he could be drafted.
Ms. Wen not only evokes memories but weaves a complicated, intriguing story within the enemies-to-love romance. Blair and Callum were so believable with their pasts not quite in the past. The insight into composing music was mesmerizing. I appreciated that both Callum and Iris were composing to please God and not man.
This was not only a really good yarn, it brought out aspects of the human condition such as depression and narcissistic behavior. It showed the difference in understanding those conditions between the 70s and the present.
One thing that bothered me was a scene near the end, but I am not going to spoil the story and did not take off points.
This is an excellent, compelling story and I cannot wait for the next book in the Melodies and Memories series.
A complimentary copy was provided by Kregel on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
Ms. Wen not only evokes memories but weaves a complicated, intriguing story within the enemies-to-love romance. Blair and Callum were so believable with their pasts not quite in the past. The insight into composing music was mesmerizing. I appreciated that both Callum and Iris were composing to please God and not man.
This was not only a really good yarn, it brought out aspects of the human condition such as depression and narcissistic behavior. It showed the difference in understanding those conditions between the 70s and the present.
One thing that bothered me was a scene near the end, but I am not going to spoil the story and did not take off points.
This is an excellent, compelling story and I cannot wait for the next book in the Melodies and Memories series.
A complimentary copy was provided by Kregel on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*
November 4, 2025
I really enjoy the way Amanda Wen writes a story. She not only does a great job at writing dual timelines but captivating you in each one which I think its so important. I was captivated and wanted to know more from each time line.
The present day time line was swoon-worthy. I mean you have grumpy-sunshine Callum who you can't help but love once he warms up to you and Blair who has been hurt but has heart of gold. Both of these characters are bound together by music but also by a mystery they are trying to solve. Let me tell you that you were definitely sigh the 'happy sigh' when you are reading about them. They are great characters who are relatable and grow throughout the story.
The other timeline iin set in the late 1960's early 70's. We meet Iris who is a a musical prodigy but doesn't know it. She composes beautiful music but sadly no one gets to listen to it. I wish I could say that there was love interest in this part of the story but I can't say there was. There was a relationship but I found him to be despicable in the way he used Iris and somewhat abusive. I will not reveal his name but as you can tell I have strong feelings bout it.
I will not divulge all the details of the story but I can tell you that the author has delved into the topic of mental illness and does so with great compassion and grace. The story will captivate you and will give you a great mystery and with a culprit that I did not see coming. It is heartbreaking yet a story full of God's hope. When we trust in Him and put our faith in Him then everything just falls into place.
I received a copy of this book for review. All views expressed are my own.
The present day time line was swoon-worthy. I mean you have grumpy-sunshine Callum who you can't help but love once he warms up to you and Blair who has been hurt but has heart of gold. Both of these characters are bound together by music but also by a mystery they are trying to solve. Let me tell you that you were definitely sigh the 'happy sigh' when you are reading about them. They are great characters who are relatable and grow throughout the story.
The other timeline iin set in the late 1960's early 70's. We meet Iris who is a a musical prodigy but doesn't know it. She composes beautiful music but sadly no one gets to listen to it. I wish I could say that there was love interest in this part of the story but I can't say there was. There was a relationship but I found him to be despicable in the way he used Iris and somewhat abusive. I will not reveal his name but as you can tell I have strong feelings bout it.
I will not divulge all the details of the story but I can tell you that the author has delved into the topic of mental illness and does so with great compassion and grace. The story will captivate you and will give you a great mystery and with a culprit that I did not see coming. It is heartbreaking yet a story full of God's hope. When we trust in Him and put our faith in Him then everything just falls into place.
I received a copy of this book for review. All views expressed are my own.
October 22, 2025
This story is so beautifully woven. I loved the threads of the contemporary and historical timelines and the way they created a story impossible to put down. The enemies to more trope was perfect for the contemporary storyline and the historical mystery that brings Callum and Blair together was well written and right up my mystery loving alley. The spiritual thread was also well done, I felt for both Blair and Callum as they try to heal from past tragedies and find find hope and light again. I loved everything about this story and I can’t wait for Amanda’s next book! She is one of my must read authors, and one of the best to write dual time stories!
I received a copy of this from the publisher and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
I received a copy of this from the publisher and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
November 5, 2025
I love words. The author strung words together into sentences that kept me so engaged in the storyline. Her beautiful writing told a beautiful story.
This dual timeline story was filled with characters who loved music. They expressed themselves through writing, playing , singing and conducting their beloved musical works.
Can you imagine caring for someone so deeply that you would be willing to give up your most treasured dream so that they could avoid suffering their worst nightmare?
A mystery of musical and personal betrayal came to life. It had been carefully covered up for so very long, but honesty finally poked through with its truths to just the right people.
While reading this well written book, I was treated to a love story which was filled with faith, restoration and renewal. This was such an engaging and satisfying story. Whenever I wasn’t reading it, I was still constantly thinking about the characters. Ahh…the joy of reading!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kregel Publications through NetGalley. All thoughts expressed in this review are mine.
This dual timeline story was filled with characters who loved music. They expressed themselves through writing, playing , singing and conducting their beloved musical works.
Can you imagine caring for someone so deeply that you would be willing to give up your most treasured dream so that they could avoid suffering their worst nightmare?
A mystery of musical and personal betrayal came to life. It had been carefully covered up for so very long, but honesty finally poked through with its truths to just the right people.
While reading this well written book, I was treated to a love story which was filled with faith, restoration and renewal. This was such an engaging and satisfying story. Whenever I wasn’t reading it, I was still constantly thinking about the characters. Ahh…the joy of reading!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Kregel Publications through NetGalley. All thoughts expressed in this review are mine.
November 8, 2025
Sometimes the music drifts where least expected...
Oh, what a story! I really liked Amanda Wen's previous series, Sedgwick County Chronicles, so I was intrigued when I heard about Echoes Of A Silent Song. And I must say that I was very impressed with the first book in the Melodies And Memories duology....
Dual timeline as were her previous books, Amanda Wen really upped her game with Echoes Of A Silent Song. The tension and stakes are even higher as the story counts inexorably down to the inevitable. But even as you know what that end is, you can't help but want to know the truth. As difficult as that truth might be for our main characters.
One of the things that I really appreciated about Melodies And Memories book one is just how well the timelines are crafted. Each hint and clue is carefully layered within the story and both timelines provide equal and intertwined pieces to the overall mystery.
Echoes Of A Silent song is a mystery. It's a romance. It's a poignant tale that will make your heart soar with the music and then tug at those same heartstrings. Amanda Wen really pulls out all of the stops with this story as each of her main characters, Blair, Callum, and Iris, struggle with things that will resonate with readers. Difficult topics such as grief and depression and guilt are not shied away from in this book and I can't help but wonder where the music will flow next in Melodies And Memories....
(I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.)
Oh, what a story! I really liked Amanda Wen's previous series, Sedgwick County Chronicles, so I was intrigued when I heard about Echoes Of A Silent Song. And I must say that I was very impressed with the first book in the Melodies And Memories duology....
Dual timeline as were her previous books, Amanda Wen really upped her game with Echoes Of A Silent Song. The tension and stakes are even higher as the story counts inexorably down to the inevitable. But even as you know what that end is, you can't help but want to know the truth. As difficult as that truth might be for our main characters.
One of the things that I really appreciated about Melodies And Memories book one is just how well the timelines are crafted. Each hint and clue is carefully layered within the story and both timelines provide equal and intertwined pieces to the overall mystery.
Echoes Of A Silent song is a mystery. It's a romance. It's a poignant tale that will make your heart soar with the music and then tug at those same heartstrings. Amanda Wen really pulls out all of the stops with this story as each of her main characters, Blair, Callum, and Iris, struggle with things that will resonate with readers. Difficult topics such as grief and depression and guilt are not shied away from in this book and I can't help but wonder where the music will flow next in Melodies And Memories....
(I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.)
October 1, 2025
This book went places I did not anticipate it going- and I am a better person for having read it. This book is a cautionary tale and a wake up call to discern what love truly is- that it is not all about giving and getting but about cherishing and being cherished by another. It takes many people years to learn how to identify healthy relationships and to accurately manage mental health. This story took me on the journey of discovery in all these areas- and I pray others will read it and learn lessons vicariously so they can avoid potholes in their own lives. Additionally, the Author's Note is essential and must be read. What a wonderful, edifying resource. This entire book is a bit of heart surgery and soul searching wrapped up in a well-written story. Bravo.
Thank you to Netgalley and Independent Publishers Group for early access to Echoes of a Silent Song in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to Netgalley and Independent Publishers Group for early access to Echoes of a Silent Song in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
September 29, 2025
I absolutely loved this story! I've loved everything that Amanda Wen has written and this was no different. Because I follow the author on social media, I know that she is a musician by trade, and so this story felt a bit more personal in that the heroine of the modern story line has the same day job as the author (be sure to read the author's note for more about that!). I enjoyed the way the composers in both time lines heard the music in their heads and hearts and the music almost became a character of the story in and of itself. In the modern timeline, Blair is a high school choir accompanist and has been the only consistent adult for the choir kids as they've gone through 6 directors in 6 years. When Callum Knight shows up on the first day, late and disheveled, announcing his intentions to be there only for the year, she immediately disdains him. When they come across a handwritten composition in the school's music library, they are bound together in the mystery of the hauntingly beautiful song. In the past timeline, Iris is a bit of an "odd duck", keeping to herself and the music that she hears. When she feels seen by a classmate in her music theory class, the music swells. But her story's ending is not what you'd expect.
This book had a little bit of everything. A solid mystery, beautiful music, sweet romance, wonderful character development and a solid faith thread round out both timelines. I enjoyed how all of the main characters had an underlying faith, but it was in their trials that they learned to surrender and how sweet was that surrender. Though the past timeline in this story was 1969-1970, so it didn't feel quite "historical" to me, I love the dual timeline element to the story and the shorter distance in the timelines allow for certain justices to be made right at the end of the story. I loved how the story ended and how justice did prevail. And I loved how the author handled Iris's ending, and how Callum and Blair honored her 50 years later. All in all, this was a beautiful story and one I would strongly recommend to fans of all genres of inspirational fiction, especially those who enjoy music. Special thanks to the publisher, author and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
This book had a little bit of everything. A solid mystery, beautiful music, sweet romance, wonderful character development and a solid faith thread round out both timelines. I enjoyed how all of the main characters had an underlying faith, but it was in their trials that they learned to surrender and how sweet was that surrender. Though the past timeline in this story was 1969-1970, so it didn't feel quite "historical" to me, I love the dual timeline element to the story and the shorter distance in the timelines allow for certain justices to be made right at the end of the story. I loved how the story ended and how justice did prevail. And I loved how the author handled Iris's ending, and how Callum and Blair honored her 50 years later. All in all, this was a beautiful story and one I would strongly recommend to fans of all genres of inspirational fiction, especially those who enjoy music. Special thanks to the publisher, author and NetGalley for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
November 4, 2025
Just beautiful! Beautiful story, charming setting, lovely people!
This book is all-around, what I would call a melodiously beautiful story.
Blair and Callum are both very musically inclined, gifted people, and it was fun to see what happened when their paths crossed, and they were forced to work together.
I loved the secondary timeline happening in the '70s, and being able to also see things from Iris' point of view.
This story is all about the music, and although I am not a musically-inclined person, I do enjoy singing, and loved hearing about these pieces...could almost hear them in my head at times!
There is a mystery, dating back to the earlier timeline....they are determined to find out....WHAT really happened to Iris? And what is going on with her music?
If you enjoy a romantic and sweet story, then try this one. Be aware that there are also some difficult topics addressed (mental illness/depression, suicide, and a few other related issues)
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
This book is all-around, what I would call a melodiously beautiful story.
Blair and Callum are both very musically inclined, gifted people, and it was fun to see what happened when their paths crossed, and they were forced to work together.
I loved the secondary timeline happening in the '70s, and being able to also see things from Iris' point of view.
This story is all about the music, and although I am not a musically-inclined person, I do enjoy singing, and loved hearing about these pieces...could almost hear them in my head at times!
There is a mystery, dating back to the earlier timeline....they are determined to find out....WHAT really happened to Iris? And what is going on with her music?
If you enjoy a romantic and sweet story, then try this one. Be aware that there are also some difficult topics addressed (mental illness/depression, suicide, and a few other related issues)
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
October 29, 2025
I always enjoy the stories that Amanda Wen writes. I was immediately captivated by the beginning of Echoes of a Silent Song.
Blair Emerson couldn't recall ever praying for patience.
She must have, though.
Wow! What a story! Normally, when there are two timelines, I am more drawn to the most recent one. However, I was equally drawn to both, or if I truly had to pick, just a hair more of the historical fiction one (if you can call the late 60s historical fiction 😂).
In the present day, we meet Blair and Callum. Blair is the collaborative pianist at the high school, and Callum is the seventh music director in seven years. Blair might be a little salty, and Callum doesn't necessarily want to be there, so he might be a little bitter. However, they are both there and need to make the best of the situation, even if they both know it is only temporary.
Iris was a musical genius in the late 60s who apparently committed suicide during her senior year. When Callum and Blair stumble across some of her written music, they immediately want to learn more about Iris and her story.
Both timelines are compelling and pulled me in. I did not want to put the book down to do other things that needed to be done. This story and its timelines are masterfully woven together right up to its epic (and surprising) conclusion.
Thank you to JustReads Publicity, Kregel Publications, and the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Blair Emerson couldn't recall ever praying for patience.
She must have, though.
Wow! What a story! Normally, when there are two timelines, I am more drawn to the most recent one. However, I was equally drawn to both, or if I truly had to pick, just a hair more of the historical fiction one (if you can call the late 60s historical fiction 😂).
In the present day, we meet Blair and Callum. Blair is the collaborative pianist at the high school, and Callum is the seventh music director in seven years. Blair might be a little salty, and Callum doesn't necessarily want to be there, so he might be a little bitter. However, they are both there and need to make the best of the situation, even if they both know it is only temporary.
Iris was a musical genius in the late 60s who apparently committed suicide during her senior year. When Callum and Blair stumble across some of her written music, they immediately want to learn more about Iris and her story.
Both timelines are compelling and pulled me in. I did not want to put the book down to do other things that needed to be done. This story and its timelines are masterfully woven together right up to its epic (and surprising) conclusion.
Thank you to JustReads Publicity, Kregel Publications, and the author for the opportunity to read this book. I was not required to provide a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 30, 2025
This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the September 2025 issue of Library Journal.
Callum Knight is too young to be a washed-up composer, but ever since a personal tragedy during the pandemic, he has not written a single note. Unenthusiastically setting up a backup plan, he becomes the new choir director at Peterson High School in Illinois, where he'll work with accompanist Blair Emerson. For her part, Blair doesn't know if she can work in harmony with yet another new choir director who won't last the year. However, she and Callum hit off, and she thinks her mentor Vic Nelson, an accomplished composer in his own right, could provide the key to unlocking Callum's block.
When Callum and Blair discover an unpublished piece of musical genius in the school's archives, they delve into the 50-year-old mystery of prodigy Iris Wallingford, who died by suicide before graduating high school; Nelson may hold the key to that intrigue as well.
VERDICT: Wen ("Sedgwick County Chronicles") plays the narrative's parallel timelines perfectly, and readers will be drawn in from the first few notes, with a dramatic crescendo showing that, despite unexpected tragedy, God is still working. The novel's depiction of mental illness is sensitively handled.
Callum Knight is too young to be a washed-up composer, but ever since a personal tragedy during the pandemic, he has not written a single note. Unenthusiastically setting up a backup plan, he becomes the new choir director at Peterson High School in Illinois, where he'll work with accompanist Blair Emerson. For her part, Blair doesn't know if she can work in harmony with yet another new choir director who won't last the year. However, she and Callum hit off, and she thinks her mentor Vic Nelson, an accomplished composer in his own right, could provide the key to unlocking Callum's block.
When Callum and Blair discover an unpublished piece of musical genius in the school's archives, they delve into the 50-year-old mystery of prodigy Iris Wallingford, who died by suicide before graduating high school; Nelson may hold the key to that intrigue as well.
VERDICT: Wen ("Sedgwick County Chronicles") plays the narrative's parallel timelines perfectly, and readers will be drawn in from the first few notes, with a dramatic crescendo showing that, despite unexpected tragedy, God is still working. The novel's depiction of mental illness is sensitively handled.
October 29, 2025
The conflict between Callum and Blair was gripping right from the start and I loved the chemistry that they both tried to ignore. When they come together for the common goal of discovering who wrote an unfinished composition, the mystery that unravels fans the flames of their romance in wonderfully sweet ways. This wasn’t just a story of romance but also a page turning suspense and beautifully written inspirational message of our value in God’s eyes. While this story tackles some tough issues of mental health, it did so in a very respectful and gentle way. I definitely recommend this book.
I received this book complimentary as a participant of the JustRead reviewer tour. I was not required to give a positive review. All of the opinions I have expressed here are honest and my own.
I received this book complimentary as a participant of the JustRead reviewer tour. I was not required to give a positive review. All of the opinions I have expressed here are honest and my own.
November 25, 2025
It has been a little bit since I have read an author Wen novel, and this one was something else. First off, music is like a foreign language to me. I can't read it or make it, but I certainly do enjoy listening to it. It is a beautiful art form that is described so well in this story that I could almost hear it. Especially as this story speeds up and hits that ever-important climax.
This is a duology and both stories are connected to one another. Blair and Callum are two people who are forced to work together and do not exactly get along from the get-go. Callum sees his time as a teacher as only a place holder till he can get his creative juices flowing again. Blair on the other hand is dedicated to her job and these students and hates that Callum is only a stand in, nor does he seem to care. He is also very grumpy; she is very prickly. However, when Callum realizes that Blair just might be his muse that gets his music making going, their hidden passions for one another knocks out their animosity towards each other. I enjoyed watching their love story progress.
This is also a bittersweet mystery of a young student composer, Iris, who was said to have committed suicide in her senior year. We get inside of her head and hear her story and what was actually happening. Her story was very raw and at times painful and eye opening as well.
This was a riveting story of hurting people finding not only love again, but also the truth of the past.
I was provided a copy of this novel by the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review, and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
This is a duology and both stories are connected to one another. Blair and Callum are two people who are forced to work together and do not exactly get along from the get-go. Callum sees his time as a teacher as only a place holder till he can get his creative juices flowing again. Blair on the other hand is dedicated to her job and these students and hates that Callum is only a stand in, nor does he seem to care. He is also very grumpy; she is very prickly. However, when Callum realizes that Blair just might be his muse that gets his music making going, their hidden passions for one another knocks out their animosity towards each other. I enjoyed watching their love story progress.
This is also a bittersweet mystery of a young student composer, Iris, who was said to have committed suicide in her senior year. We get inside of her head and hear her story and what was actually happening. Her story was very raw and at times painful and eye opening as well.
This was a riveting story of hurting people finding not only love again, but also the truth of the past.
I was provided a copy of this novel by the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review, and all views and opinions are my own.
https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
October 18, 2025
"Alone. She hadn’t said that last word, but it hung in the air just as clearly as the last echoes of a final chord."
Blair loves getting to connect with students in the music department at her school. As the official accompanist, she knows what a good choir should sound like. But considering the fact that they are starting another school year with yet another new director, she isn't holding out hope that the situation will be any better for those students she cares about.
Callum doesn't want to be directing high school singers in a small Illinois town. He can put up with the job for a year, then he will go back to his actual career of conducting in a city. Since the music that he once wrote now only echoes in his head, he has to find a way to get the music back.
Iris is one of the few students who wanted to take high school music theory. But she knows that this class will be help her get the music that is in her head and heart down on a paper. An unexpected friendship helps her to feel like perhaps she isn't alone after all. But in 1969, the world was a different place - hopes and dreams could be derailed.
This dual timeline story is tinged with sadness yet still resonates with hope. I think that the author wrote in her own sweet spot as she works in a high school music department for her day job. Her expertise and understanding makes the plot believable and enjoyable.
This story connects to real life with elements of romance and mystery. Trying to determine the truth of the past is challenging. How all of the details come together makes for a beautiful story.
I did read an advanced copy of this book. I wanted to read and review it. All opinions are my own.
Blair loves getting to connect with students in the music department at her school. As the official accompanist, she knows what a good choir should sound like. But considering the fact that they are starting another school year with yet another new director, she isn't holding out hope that the situation will be any better for those students she cares about.
Callum doesn't want to be directing high school singers in a small Illinois town. He can put up with the job for a year, then he will go back to his actual career of conducting in a city. Since the music that he once wrote now only echoes in his head, he has to find a way to get the music back.
Iris is one of the few students who wanted to take high school music theory. But she knows that this class will be help her get the music that is in her head and heart down on a paper. An unexpected friendship helps her to feel like perhaps she isn't alone after all. But in 1969, the world was a different place - hopes and dreams could be derailed.
This dual timeline story is tinged with sadness yet still resonates with hope. I think that the author wrote in her own sweet spot as she works in a high school music department for her day job. Her expertise and understanding makes the plot believable and enjoyable.
This story connects to real life with elements of romance and mystery. Trying to determine the truth of the past is challenging. How all of the details come together makes for a beautiful story.
I did read an advanced copy of this book. I wanted to read and review it. All opinions are my own.
October 8, 2025
I loved how the author balanced the challenging story of Iris and the struggles she went through in the past with the present day of Callum and Blair. The present day story was a refreshing reprieve from the past story.
Even though I have no musical talent, I appreciated the story and the love of music that the characters had.
Each of the characters struggled with their own demons but continued to fight each day and to cling to their faith. Their resilience despite the tough circumstances is such an encouragement to me.
I was provided a complimentary arc. The opinions are my own.
Even though I have no musical talent, I appreciated the story and the love of music that the characters had.
Each of the characters struggled with their own demons but continued to fight each day and to cling to their faith. Their resilience despite the tough circumstances is such an encouragement to me.
I was provided a complimentary arc. The opinions are my own.
November 18, 2025
Wen gleans from her personal experience as a professional musician and choral accompanist to provide an exceptional perspective on the creative, musical mind. IMHO, this split-time novel is another “win for Wen”. Well-written and well-interwoven within two time frames, this story may seem like it stalls a bit about 60% of the way but oh, no! Keep reading!
Wen’s novels usually have sidebarred romance, however, in this particular story, the romance is necessary to the storyline. For those who enjoy women’s fiction, the romance is still not all encompassing or overdone, rather, it is coupled with mysteries and lies that keep you guessing.
Present day-Callum’s fiancé committed suicide 5 years earlier. As a popular composer, he just can not write afterward. He is blocked. So much so, he has to take a school’s choral director position to make ends meet. His accompanist, Blair, who has little hope that Callum will be there long, must try to break in another choral director. Little do they know that they will be spending the next weeks trying to figure out who wrote an unsigned, unfinished yet brilliant piece of music they find mixed in with old musical scores in the choral library.
1969/1970-I love that Wen gives us a first person perspective of Iris. Her way of looking at things, her insecurities and her ever spinning musical mind make knowing her thoughts an integral part of this story. Her world of constant pressure to impress the community, answer questions that start with “Why can’t you…” and phrases like “from the other side of the tracks…”, coupled with swapping “I know her” names, a mom who’d rather play bridge, and threats to withdraw monetary support provide the angst that drove this story to the end.
This book is suitable for teens and older with no inappropriate intimate scenes and no bad language. I received this book from the author/publisher free of charge, with no expectation of a positive review. I also purchased the paperback.
Wen’s novels usually have sidebarred romance, however, in this particular story, the romance is necessary to the storyline. For those who enjoy women’s fiction, the romance is still not all encompassing or overdone, rather, it is coupled with mysteries and lies that keep you guessing.
Present day-Callum’s fiancé committed suicide 5 years earlier. As a popular composer, he just can not write afterward. He is blocked. So much so, he has to take a school’s choral director position to make ends meet. His accompanist, Blair, who has little hope that Callum will be there long, must try to break in another choral director. Little do they know that they will be spending the next weeks trying to figure out who wrote an unsigned, unfinished yet brilliant piece of music they find mixed in with old musical scores in the choral library.
1969/1970-I love that Wen gives us a first person perspective of Iris. Her way of looking at things, her insecurities and her ever spinning musical mind make knowing her thoughts an integral part of this story. Her world of constant pressure to impress the community, answer questions that start with “Why can’t you…” and phrases like “from the other side of the tracks…”, coupled with swapping “I know her” names, a mom who’d rather play bridge, and threats to withdraw monetary support provide the angst that drove this story to the end.
This book is suitable for teens and older with no inappropriate intimate scenes and no bad language. I received this book from the author/publisher free of charge, with no expectation of a positive review. I also purchased the paperback.
December 28, 2025
This is another book I've had in my radar. This one is a dual time novel. Music is intricately woven throughout this book so my fellow musicians will love it. There is a mystery in the background as well.
The book deals with suicide as well.
4 stars
The book deals with suicide as well.
4 stars
October 31, 2025
Once again, Amanda Wen has created a dual-timeline world that I almost wanted to live in myself! (Okay, maybe just visit.) In the current day, Blair and Callan are adversaries who ought to be partnering together to help their high school choirs produce exceptional music. However, they're not quite at that level yet. Blair has been the accompanist who stayed, guiding and mentoring the high school choral singers. During that time, many directors have come and gone. And it seems that Callan will be the next in that long line to stay for awhile and then, go.
That is, until the two of them find a scrap of the most breathtaking choral music; a torn bit of music that literally transports the hearers (and performers). With a name: Iris. Who is Iris? Where's the rest of the composition? How can Blair and Callan find more of her music?
In 1969, Iris is struggling to survive high school. She lives much inside her own head, where streams of melody and harmony intrude upon her daily life. All she can do is get them scribbled down as quickly as possible. Yet while her parents' plans for her are "wife and mother," Iris dreams of "composer and musician." How she longs for this world! And finally, a guy comes along who seems to understand her dreams.
As we read and get to place these two timelines against one another, we see much disparity, yet some similarity. First, the Vietnam War. The draft. Hemlines and political leanings, and gender/professional roles which it's not always easy to step out of. And second, today. Where there's more equality in profession and service. But some problems exist in both. Mental illness, which is not always easy to treat. Suicide. Personal struggle. But we can't forget...the music. Music which fills, soars, brings joy and hope. But will that hope be enough?
Yet again, I thoroughly enjoyed and was captivated by Amanda Wen's writing. The characters were so beautifully written, as were the timelines. I adored the music (yes, even only written in story, it soars), the settings, and the mystery. I fell in love with Blair and Callan, and of course Iris. I have to admit that my heart did break a little. Wonderful book that will break your own heart too, I think.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
That is, until the two of them find a scrap of the most breathtaking choral music; a torn bit of music that literally transports the hearers (and performers). With a name: Iris. Who is Iris? Where's the rest of the composition? How can Blair and Callan find more of her music?
In 1969, Iris is struggling to survive high school. She lives much inside her own head, where streams of melody and harmony intrude upon her daily life. All she can do is get them scribbled down as quickly as possible. Yet while her parents' plans for her are "wife and mother," Iris dreams of "composer and musician." How she longs for this world! And finally, a guy comes along who seems to understand her dreams.
As we read and get to place these two timelines against one another, we see much disparity, yet some similarity. First, the Vietnam War. The draft. Hemlines and political leanings, and gender/professional roles which it's not always easy to step out of. And second, today. Where there's more equality in profession and service. But some problems exist in both. Mental illness, which is not always easy to treat. Suicide. Personal struggle. But we can't forget...the music. Music which fills, soars, brings joy and hope. But will that hope be enough?
Yet again, I thoroughly enjoyed and was captivated by Amanda Wen's writing. The characters were so beautifully written, as were the timelines. I adored the music (yes, even only written in story, it soars), the settings, and the mystery. I fell in love with Blair and Callan, and of course Iris. I have to admit that my heart did break a little. Wonderful book that will break your own heart too, I think.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
November 5, 2025
I just adore Wen’s writing. It’s just beautiful and sings to my heart. Echoes of a Silent Song was different, in a good way. The music just really stirred my soul – probably because of my deep love for music. Music is such a big part of my life, and while I’m not a composer, I can appreciate the hard work that goes into it. And Wen brings it to life in a way that I think even a non-music person could understand and appreciate.
But I think what I adored even more was the relationship between Callum and Blair. Opposites attract is one of my favorites romances to read about, and their chemistry was perfect. I could see a lot of myself in Blair – connecting with the students, being defensive of the program, and trying to act as a buffer between the students and the multiple teachers over the years. And Callum. He had high hopes – be there a year and be gone. But isn’t it grand when we make plans and God chuckles and changes things up? Callum’s broken heart just needed a good dose of Blair’s energy to perk him up a bit.
And let’s not forget the little mystery of Iris! And while I did kind of predict part the plot twist at the end, it didn’t take away from my enjoyment of learning about Iris and her journey. The way the music came alive in her head – it reminded me of when I was a kid and would make up songs. I didn’t have a piano or anything, so they were only in my head. But it was so fun and I miss being able to do that.
Echoes of a Silent Song is a beautiful, poetic story that will stirs the hearts of readers. I highly recommend adding it to your TBR list. And Wen’s other stories for that matter. They are encouraging, inspiring, and lovely to read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
But I think what I adored even more was the relationship between Callum and Blair. Opposites attract is one of my favorites romances to read about, and their chemistry was perfect. I could see a lot of myself in Blair – connecting with the students, being defensive of the program, and trying to act as a buffer between the students and the multiple teachers over the years. And Callum. He had high hopes – be there a year and be gone. But isn’t it grand when we make plans and God chuckles and changes things up? Callum’s broken heart just needed a good dose of Blair’s energy to perk him up a bit.
And let’s not forget the little mystery of Iris! And while I did kind of predict part the plot twist at the end, it didn’t take away from my enjoyment of learning about Iris and her journey. The way the music came alive in her head – it reminded me of when I was a kid and would make up songs. I didn’t have a piano or anything, so they were only in my head. But it was so fun and I miss being able to do that.
Echoes of a Silent Song is a beautiful, poetic story that will stirs the hearts of readers. I highly recommend adding it to your TBR list. And Wen’s other stories for that matter. They are encouraging, inspiring, and lovely to read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 1, 2025
I'm a huge fan of Amanda Wen's storytelling abilities, and Echoes of a Silent Song not only held up to but exceeded my expectations.
In our contemporary storyline, high school choir accompanist Blair faces a new school year with another new director. Her school hasn't been able to keep a director for more than one year for a long time, making it hard for the students to gain ground or trust those who work with them. This year looks to be the same, as disgruntled composer Callum Knight sees Peterson High as just a rung in his ladder before returning to the life he wants working with professionals in Boston.
On the first day of school, as Blair and Callum are picking out music for their concerts, they come across a faded piece of handwritten score that is so hauntingly beautiful that they must find out more about its composer. Iris Wallingford was a student set to graduate in the spring of 1970 before dying by suicide... or did she?
The historical first person storyline follows Iris through the fall of 1969 and into the fateful events of early 1970. Iris is quiet but in love with music -- and with Victor Nelson. She would do anything for Vic, and believes he feels the same way about her. But events soon unfold that leave Iris grappling with the choices they've made, for better or worse.
I loved this book for many reasons. For one, I know Amanda herself is a high school choir accompanist, so it was a joy knowing Blair's day job reflected hers (though without the mystery solving!). For another, the characters and their emotions come across real and strong, and they deal with things I know are relatable to readers because they were relatable to me. I loved the sparks of romance, the wounds that are able to be healed, and how faith is woven throughout in a natural way.
If you are a fan of dual timeline stories, I highly, highly recommend Amanda's books. The stories will touch your heart and echo across your soul. Make sure to check out Echoes of a Silent Song today!
I received my copy of the book from the author and JustReads Publicity. All thoughts in this review are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.dreamwidth.org
In our contemporary storyline, high school choir accompanist Blair faces a new school year with another new director. Her school hasn't been able to keep a director for more than one year for a long time, making it hard for the students to gain ground or trust those who work with them. This year looks to be the same, as disgruntled composer Callum Knight sees Peterson High as just a rung in his ladder before returning to the life he wants working with professionals in Boston.
On the first day of school, as Blair and Callum are picking out music for their concerts, they come across a faded piece of handwritten score that is so hauntingly beautiful that they must find out more about its composer. Iris Wallingford was a student set to graduate in the spring of 1970 before dying by suicide... or did she?
The historical first person storyline follows Iris through the fall of 1969 and into the fateful events of early 1970. Iris is quiet but in love with music -- and with Victor Nelson. She would do anything for Vic, and believes he feels the same way about her. But events soon unfold that leave Iris grappling with the choices they've made, for better or worse.
I loved this book for many reasons. For one, I know Amanda herself is a high school choir accompanist, so it was a joy knowing Blair's day job reflected hers (though without the mystery solving!). For another, the characters and their emotions come across real and strong, and they deal with things I know are relatable to readers because they were relatable to me. I loved the sparks of romance, the wounds that are able to be healed, and how faith is woven throughout in a natural way.
If you are a fan of dual timeline stories, I highly, highly recommend Amanda's books. The stories will touch your heart and echo across your soul. Make sure to check out Echoes of a Silent Song today!
I received my copy of the book from the author and JustReads Publicity. All thoughts in this review are my own.
This review originated at http://reviewsbyerin.dreamwidth.org
Read
November 5, 2025a story of music, secrets, and romance from amanda wen!
callum's inspiration for composing has been missing lately, so he's taken on the position of choir teacher at peterson high until his muse returns. of course, accompanist blair emerson's not happy to see another teacher planning to come and go from the lives of her students. they must still find a way to work together for the next year, though, and as they're digging through the choir library, they find a composition that just might change everything...
echoes of a silent song is quite the emotional story, as these characters find love and hope in unexpected places. it weaves past and present with great intrigue (and i couldn't help hoping, while getting to know iris, that the present story about her was just wrong), but also delivers great moments of trusting God, changing plans, and enjoying the beauty of music.
it's a lovely story, and i think fans of uplifting contemporary fiction are sure to love it, like i did.
(i received a complimentary copy from the author and/or publisher. i was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions i have expressed are my own.)
considerations:
—language: none
—spice: kisses only
—faith: strong themes
—content: death (via suicide or murder), toxic relationships
callum's inspiration for composing has been missing lately, so he's taken on the position of choir teacher at peterson high until his muse returns. of course, accompanist blair emerson's not happy to see another teacher planning to come and go from the lives of her students. they must still find a way to work together for the next year, though, and as they're digging through the choir library, they find a composition that just might change everything...
echoes of a silent song is quite the emotional story, as these characters find love and hope in unexpected places. it weaves past and present with great intrigue (and i couldn't help hoping, while getting to know iris, that the present story about her was just wrong), but also delivers great moments of trusting God, changing plans, and enjoying the beauty of music.
it's a lovely story, and i think fans of uplifting contemporary fiction are sure to love it, like i did.
(i received a complimentary copy from the author and/or publisher. i was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions i have expressed are my own.)
considerations:
—language: none
—spice: kisses only
—faith: strong themes
—content: death (via suicide or murder), toxic relationships
October 31, 2025
As a musician and would-be vocal music major, this story resonated with me deeply, touching me in ways no other story has.
I wanted to shake Blair for being so contentious and judgmental. And untrusting. Then again, I totally understand her reasons. Not to mention, Callum’s indifference, nay resentment at being ‘reduced’ to teaching. After all, he was a professional, not some second rate amateur.
And they had to work together.
Ms. Wen creates not only very real and believable characters, but touches on something deep and profound—how the creative process comes alive in the soul and mind of the creator, something this reader can very much relate to.
The layers of this story, the twists and turns—and especially the music—held my interest like few other stories. The added spiritual dimension gave even more meaning.
The scene in Champaign-Urbana was perfect. Sorry, [SPOILER]
The intrigue of a dual timeline was yet another layer to hold the reader’s interest. Especially when tragedy strikes.
And I gotta say, that twist at the end—totally did NOT see that coming!
Bravo, Ms. Wen! A new-to-me author, who is now one of my most favorite authors. And whose books will find their way to my TBR pile.
ROBIN’S FEATHERS NOTES
ALL | THE | FEATHERS NOTES!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
#Blogwords, Tuesday Reviews-Day, #TRD, Book Review, Echoes of a Silent Song, Amanda Wen, JustRead Publicity
I wanted to shake Blair for being so contentious and judgmental. And untrusting. Then again, I totally understand her reasons. Not to mention, Callum’s indifference, nay resentment at being ‘reduced’ to teaching. After all, he was a professional, not some second rate amateur.
And they had to work together.
Ms. Wen creates not only very real and believable characters, but touches on something deep and profound—how the creative process comes alive in the soul and mind of the creator, something this reader can very much relate to.
The layers of this story, the twists and turns—and especially the music—held my interest like few other stories. The added spiritual dimension gave even more meaning.
The scene in Champaign-Urbana was perfect. Sorry, [SPOILER]
The intrigue of a dual timeline was yet another layer to hold the reader’s interest. Especially when tragedy strikes.
And I gotta say, that twist at the end—totally did NOT see that coming!
Bravo, Ms. Wen! A new-to-me author, who is now one of my most favorite authors. And whose books will find their way to my TBR pile.
ROBIN’S FEATHERS NOTES
ALL | THE | FEATHERS NOTES!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
#Blogwords, Tuesday Reviews-Day, #TRD, Book Review, Echoes of a Silent Song, Amanda Wen, JustRead Publicity
October 15, 2025
I am definitely an Amanda Wen fan so I pre-ordered this book and was also blessed to receive an early NetGallery copy. I loved it, as I have each of her books. Echoes of a Silent Song is a split-time book, meaning it goes back and forth between present day and years ago. I always enjoy that and Amanda does a great job of not making it confusing. She is a musician herself and this book is about a high school choir director and the choir's accompanist (present day) and splits time with 2 choir members in the 70's. A very interesting read with romance and suspense woven in (bonus!). I loved the beautiful way the story showed how God works all things together for good for those who belong to him.
November 3, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. I found the characters real and relatable. I liked the dual timeline and found the stories not only making me smile, but also pulling my emotional heartstrings. I enjoyed the musical composition side of things and seeing the characters get swept away by the music in their minds. And I loved the high school setting and seeing characters inspired by the kids around them (I work in pediatric occupational therapy- so I enjoyed relating to how the characters lives can be changed by kids around then). I did feel like the ending wrapped up a little to fast, but overall this is a good read. I would definitely recommend this book and this author.
I did recieve a free e-copy of this book as part of this tour; however, all thoughts expressed above are my honest opinion.
I did recieve a free e-copy of this book as part of this tour; however, all thoughts expressed above are my honest opinion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews