What do you think?
Rate this book
A Dark Most Fair
You should know, I did it. Before you trouble yourself to read any further, you won't find an innocent woman in these pages. I am every bit as evil as they say I am. A murderer. A liar. A kinslayer. The gods, they say, save their worst punishments for those like me. Those who covet what isn't theirs. Those who slay their own blood. Those who lie about it after.I'm a woman who murdered for a man. There isn't a hell black enough for one such as me. I'm every inch a sinner. And I will get what I deserve. Soon.
- GenresDark
203 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 5, 2025
About the author
L.M. Riviere
6 books92 followersL.M. Riviere is the author of the epic fantasy series 'The Innisfail Cycle', the historical fairy tale 'A Dark Most Fair,' and the Appalachian folk horror 'A Vow For Breaking.' She has another folk horror titles due for release in 2026.
She is obsessed with hot coffee, hiking, and refusing to wear 'real pants' in public. She lives in Appalachia.
She is obsessed with hot coffee, hiking, and refusing to wear 'real pants' in public. She lives in Appalachia.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
November 4, 2025
This feels like a historical fantasy with a bit of dark fairytale spin.
It was a beautifully written tale of destruction and the consequences of youth and selfishness. It’s also set in a time where women are burned as witches and must have a good married match else be sent into the distance to be a spinster, and that misogyny is palpable on every page. It isn’t that the book is misogynistic, it just shines a light on the toxicity of it.
We follow Deidre, the eldest daughter of a king, and how she is pushed aside in favour of her more attractive and Princess-like half-sister by her father’s second wife. There are the classic tropes as you’d expect in a tale like this (although there is more nuance to it - the step-mother isn’t evil for the sake of it, though to a teenager everything is terribly unfair), along with a man to cause conflict and drama.
Deidre’s fate changes when she happens upon a magical scroll and unleashes something she (nor the reader) ever fully understands. I somewhat expected this story to dive more into that darkness - who and what she released, what they wanted and why, but this is never really delved into fully. As a young woman who has had her rights taken from her, she indulges in some selfish wishes (despite warnings) and we see the tension-fuelled fallout grow.
It’s also split into two halves, with a fairly significant time jump. I wasn’t a huge fan of that (it felt like there was a huge recap chapter catching us up with everything that had happened before we were thrown into the next part of the story) but it did keep the pacing up and the building tension that had been present throughout. Deidre’s life after the events hinted at in the prologue aren’t really shown, but we do see her unwilling return to face her past, and all the horrors of what she’s experienced.
I’m not familiar with the part of Irish history or folklore this tale is a retelling of (or inspired by), and I typically don’t like historical, so this wasn’t my exact jam. However, it was a short, quick read that had some beautiful descriptions and built an atmosphere I felt I could step into.
It was a beautifully written tale of destruction and the consequences of youth and selfishness. It’s also set in a time where women are burned as witches and must have a good married match else be sent into the distance to be a spinster, and that misogyny is palpable on every page. It isn’t that the book is misogynistic, it just shines a light on the toxicity of it.
We follow Deidre, the eldest daughter of a king, and how she is pushed aside in favour of her more attractive and Princess-like half-sister by her father’s second wife. There are the classic tropes as you’d expect in a tale like this (although there is more nuance to it - the step-mother isn’t evil for the sake of it, though to a teenager everything is terribly unfair), along with a man to cause conflict and drama.
Deidre’s fate changes when she happens upon a magical scroll and unleashes something she (nor the reader) ever fully understands. I somewhat expected this story to dive more into that darkness - who and what she released, what they wanted and why, but this is never really delved into fully. As a young woman who has had her rights taken from her, she indulges in some selfish wishes (despite warnings) and we see the tension-fuelled fallout grow.
It’s also split into two halves, with a fairly significant time jump. I wasn’t a huge fan of that (it felt like there was a huge recap chapter catching us up with everything that had happened before we were thrown into the next part of the story) but it did keep the pacing up and the building tension that had been present throughout. Deidre’s life after the events hinted at in the prologue aren’t really shown, but we do see her unwilling return to face her past, and all the horrors of what she’s experienced.
I’m not familiar with the part of Irish history or folklore this tale is a retelling of (or inspired by), and I typically don’t like historical, so this wasn’t my exact jam. However, it was a short, quick read that had some beautiful descriptions and built an atmosphere I felt I could step into.
August 26, 2025
Okay, let's talk about L.M. Riviere's newest project, "A Dark Most Fair." This was an absolute delight. It's a short novel, a retelling, and a character study. Inspired by ancient Irish history and folklore -- complete with sibling rivalry, magic scrolls, ambition, curses, injustices, and the struggle to escape the past -- told through the voice of our protagonist, the dynamic Lady Deirdre. And what a character Deirdre is... a young noble who feels her birthright has been stolen from her by her more beautiful sister and scheming stepmother -- and all the consequences that follow from her pride and resentment. Riviere completely nails this messy characterization and emotional journey, which is the heart of the novel. I couldn't stop thinking of Circe by Madeline Miller, possibly my favorite novel of the 21st century so far, while reading this: the transportive setting, the feminist themes, and a main character that you grow to love almost because of her flaws.
Aside from that, this was perfectly paced with an exceptionally resonant conclusion. Fans of Riviere's Innisfail Cycle series will find the same depth and worldbuilding that characterizes her previous storytelling.
Aside from that, this was perfectly paced with an exceptionally resonant conclusion. Fans of Riviere's Innisfail Cycle series will find the same depth and worldbuilding that characterizes her previous storytelling.
September 7, 2025
What a great short read! Review to come! 🔔
(FINAL REVIEW:)
Before going into this review, I would like everyone to know that the author reached out to me asking if I would be interested in reading and reviewing her new book in exchange for an honest review. I happy agreed and this has no influence whatsoever on my thoughts about it. Okay, with this disclaimer out of the way, on to the review! 🥰
This was a wonderfully dark Irish mythology and folklore reimagining of the murder ballad, The Twa Sisters. I was already a HUGE fan of Riviere’s work thanks to her spectacular series, The Innisfail Cycle, so when I found out she had a new short book coming out this year, I jumped at the chance to help read it and spread the word. This short book not only exceeded my expectations, but also blew me away with its dark elements and fantastic character list. 🤯
The story follows Deirdre, the horribly neglected eldest daughter of the King of Ulaid. She’s rightfully filled with rage, willful, and selfish in the fact that it’s out of her own survival in a court that her stepmother stacked against her. This has all the makings of a proper tragedy and the narration keeps you rooting for her even though she can be unlikeable at times (and again, I’m the firm believer that not all MC’s should be outright likeable, but only if they have good reasons to not be). 😢
The side characters are perfectly flawed in their own ways and help pave the way for this to be the a gripping tragedy. Deirdre’s father, in his grief over loosing her mother, has basically done next to nothing except take her stepmother’s side in it all. Her stepmother, while in her own weird way of caring, has done everything to undermine and displace Deirdre’s importance in the castle while at the same time trying to guide her in matters of statecraft. And in the center of it all, Calanthe: the naive, spoiled, and equally selfish half-sister who has been the star of the whole castle and unwilling perpetrator of the majority of Deirdre’s problems. Add in a dashing prince to the bunch and it’s the spark that lights Deirdre’s world up, and not in a good way. 🔥
Along the way, Deirdre obtains the companionship of Briar, who I think was the second most interesting character of the story. I wanted more time to understand his motives, the reasons for why he’s drawn to Deirdre and why he just can’t see to get to her at the right moment. 🤔
In the end, this was a fantastic read and I just didn’t want it to end honestly. Thank you goes out to the author, Riviere, for being so kind to reach out to me about this book and giving me the chance to review it and help promote it to others. If you are interested in a fairytale like fantasy that will grip you to the end, this should be on your radar!! ❤️
Publication date: October 5!
Overall: 4.75/5 ⭐️
(FINAL REVIEW:)
Before going into this review, I would like everyone to know that the author reached out to me asking if I would be interested in reading and reviewing her new book in exchange for an honest review. I happy agreed and this has no influence whatsoever on my thoughts about it. Okay, with this disclaimer out of the way, on to the review! 🥰
This was a wonderfully dark Irish mythology and folklore reimagining of the murder ballad, The Twa Sisters. I was already a HUGE fan of Riviere’s work thanks to her spectacular series, The Innisfail Cycle, so when I found out she had a new short book coming out this year, I jumped at the chance to help read it and spread the word. This short book not only exceeded my expectations, but also blew me away with its dark elements and fantastic character list. 🤯
The story follows Deirdre, the horribly neglected eldest daughter of the King of Ulaid. She’s rightfully filled with rage, willful, and selfish in the fact that it’s out of her own survival in a court that her stepmother stacked against her. This has all the makings of a proper tragedy and the narration keeps you rooting for her even though she can be unlikeable at times (and again, I’m the firm believer that not all MC’s should be outright likeable, but only if they have good reasons to not be). 😢
The side characters are perfectly flawed in their own ways and help pave the way for this to be the a gripping tragedy. Deirdre’s father, in his grief over loosing her mother, has basically done next to nothing except take her stepmother’s side in it all. Her stepmother, while in her own weird way of caring, has done everything to undermine and displace Deirdre’s importance in the castle while at the same time trying to guide her in matters of statecraft. And in the center of it all, Calanthe: the naive, spoiled, and equally selfish half-sister who has been the star of the whole castle and unwilling perpetrator of the majority of Deirdre’s problems. Add in a dashing prince to the bunch and it’s the spark that lights Deirdre’s world up, and not in a good way. 🔥
Along the way, Deirdre obtains the companionship of Briar, who I think was the second most interesting character of the story. I wanted more time to understand his motives, the reasons for why he’s drawn to Deirdre and why he just can’t see to get to her at the right moment. 🤔
In the end, this was a fantastic read and I just didn’t want it to end honestly. Thank you goes out to the author, Riviere, for being so kind to reach out to me about this book and giving me the chance to review it and help promote it to others. If you are interested in a fairytale like fantasy that will grip you to the end, this should be on your radar!! ❤️
Publication date: October 5!
Overall: 4.75/5 ⭐️
August 8, 2025
I've been pretty uninspired by fantasy fiction in the past few years, so I'll admit to being very hype at the chance to read a new release from L.M. Riviere since I enjoyed her Innisfail Cycle series so much. A Dark Most Fair DID NOT DISAPPOINT 👏🏼 What launches off with a murder mystery, not of who, but *how and why* (Dierdre admits to being a kinslayer in the opening lines), immediately immerses us in this rich landscape of medieval Irish clans, kingdoms, and all the gruesome trappings within, chronicling the rise and fairly epic fall of the overlooked daughter.
Dierdre is young but not stupid, and what Riviere does well is craft a character who feels truly flesh and blood. When she finds herself face-to-face with one of the Others, we agree that she might be cursed, or worse, mad. With all the horror of a Greek tragedy, we watch as her every effort to improve her life instead drives her closer to her fate. Dierdre's voice is one of a friend, and as her confidant, we feel her isolation, empathize with her desires, and cannot help but hope for a happy ending--but Riviere is too great a storyteller to let us off too easy.
A Dark Most Fair was a very rich, very fast-paced dark fairy tale that wrapped me up so tightly that I finished it in one sitting. I loved it and will keep my ears open for any mysterious bells of my own! 5 full stars from me 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Since mine is an advanced reader copy, I'll keep my lips sealed about the ending but my messages are open to anyone WHO WANTS TO DISCUSS 👀🤩
Dierdre is young but not stupid, and what Riviere does well is craft a character who feels truly flesh and blood. When she finds herself face-to-face with one of the Others, we agree that she might be cursed, or worse, mad. With all the horror of a Greek tragedy, we watch as her every effort to improve her life instead drives her closer to her fate. Dierdre's voice is one of a friend, and as her confidant, we feel her isolation, empathize with her desires, and cannot help but hope for a happy ending--but Riviere is too great a storyteller to let us off too easy.
A Dark Most Fair was a very rich, very fast-paced dark fairy tale that wrapped me up so tightly that I finished it in one sitting. I loved it and will keep my ears open for any mysterious bells of my own! 5 full stars from me 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Since mine is an advanced reader copy, I'll keep my lips sealed about the ending but my messages are open to anyone WHO WANTS TO DISCUSS 👀🤩
August 9, 2025
I had the honor of receiving an ARC for A Dark Most Fair and let me tell you I have not been able to stop thinking about it ever since. The worldbuilding? Impeccably researched and transformative. The voice? Relatable and engaging. The mood and atmosphere? Dark in all the best ways. A Dark Most Fair follows the life of the fairy tale’s villain, Deirdre. She is the first daughter of the King of Ulaidan, but demoted and outshined by her younger half-sister born after the death of her mother and remarriage of her father. Through a series of events that result in Deirdre unwittingly freeing a mysterious Other, she becomes the custodian of three wishes which direct her downfall and the destruction of her family. On a personal note, this book is for all women, girls, sisters, mothers, wives, grandmothers, and girlfriends, who have asked, “What about me?” It explores the roles females play not only within society but within family dynamics—the negotiations, compromises, and sacrifices. It investigates the sometime tenuous relationships between sisters who both adore and abhor each other. It addresses the guilt and regret that can follow for the audacity to assert herself, for the hubris to insist it is her turn. At the same time, we get to meet some amazing characters who demonstrate the kind of selfless love for others I wish we had more of in this world. L.M. Riviere has now made the list of one of my favorite authors of the year.
October 25, 2025
A short beautiful dark fairy tale that sweeps you off your feet from the confessional line at the beginning all the way to the satisfying end. I loved the moody, gritty atmosphere of ancient Ireland and believe the author captured the vibes perfectly. This book is perfect for anyone not looking for heavy world building but still wanting that feel of ancient magic and old tales blended to create something new.
August 2, 2025
I received an advance copy for review a few weeks back. I love a fairy-retelling, especially when they’re on the dark side. The author did her homework too. I googled the place and time. A lot of that checks out. If you like dark fantasy vibes from the 80’s, you’ll love this book.
August 19, 2025
I received this book as an ARC copy, and I thank the author for the opportunity.
This story is listed as retelling of an Irish folklore from the point of view of Deirdre Ap Muirdagh. I was unfamiliar with the original tale (I Googled it), but it doesn't really matter, because this story is so different from the original that the only reason I even knew it was a retelling is that I saw it listed in the email as a suggested ARC.
Before I get into the review itself, it should be noted for potential readers that the book does come with a list of trigger warnings surrounding depression, self-harm (thoughts and actual self harm) and internalised misogyny. I didn't find any of these particularly graphic until the very end, but if you're likely to be triggered, this book may not be for you.
It is a complement to the author that I finished the book in a day and a half. I simply couldn't put it down. The story had me gripped from the very first line, which a good book should do.
Deirdre is a well-formed character with a troubled past that she tries to leave behind, but which ultimately catches up to her. There's jealousy, there's a love triangle, there's a hint of magic, there's some amusing barbed banter between Deirdre, Calanthe and Hester. There's some lovely imagery in the story so the characters don't feel like they're walking around in white space and that imagery fits with the time of the original tale.
Now for the criticism;
I think it could have done with a final proofread; Mael's hair colour changes from "golden brown" (p. 85) to coppery chestnut, (p. 91) and back to just plain brown (p. 133). That definitely should have been picked up and corrected!
Whilst the dialogue itself feels natural, a lot of it is unaccompanied by action beats, so the reader gets the impression that the characters are standing still, even during arguments. This does improve towards the end of the book, where action beats become more common, but it's another example of something that could have been spotted and corrected had the book gone through a final proofread before publishing.
Finally, every chapter title page, and the empty pages preceding them are decorated with the watery background of the cover. The decoration is relevant to the story and maybe some readers would appreciate that; maybe that's the kind of thing they look for in books (along with sprayed edges), but for me, they were distracting and pulled me out of the story every time, just as I was immersed. It got to the point where I was waiting for the break instead of just following the story.
If it wasn't for those issues, I would have happily awarded this book 5 stars.
This story is listed as retelling of an Irish folklore from the point of view of Deirdre Ap Muirdagh. I was unfamiliar with the original tale (I Googled it), but it doesn't really matter, because this story is so different from the original that the only reason I even knew it was a retelling is that I saw it listed in the email as a suggested ARC.
Before I get into the review itself, it should be noted for potential readers that the book does come with a list of trigger warnings surrounding depression, self-harm (thoughts and actual self harm) and internalised misogyny. I didn't find any of these particularly graphic until the very end, but if you're likely to be triggered, this book may not be for you.
It is a complement to the author that I finished the book in a day and a half. I simply couldn't put it down. The story had me gripped from the very first line, which a good book should do.
Deirdre is a well-formed character with a troubled past that she tries to leave behind, but which ultimately catches up to her. There's jealousy, there's a love triangle, there's a hint of magic, there's some amusing barbed banter between Deirdre, Calanthe and Hester. There's some lovely imagery in the story so the characters don't feel like they're walking around in white space and that imagery fits with the time of the original tale.
Now for the criticism;
I think it could have done with a final proofread; Mael's hair colour changes from "golden brown" (p. 85) to coppery chestnut, (p. 91) and back to just plain brown (p. 133). That definitely should have been picked up and corrected!
Whilst the dialogue itself feels natural, a lot of it is unaccompanied by action beats, so the reader gets the impression that the characters are standing still, even during arguments. This does improve towards the end of the book, where action beats become more common, but it's another example of something that could have been spotted and corrected had the book gone through a final proofread before publishing.
Finally, every chapter title page, and the empty pages preceding them are decorated with the watery background of the cover. The decoration is relevant to the story and maybe some readers would appreciate that; maybe that's the kind of thing they look for in books (along with sprayed edges), but for me, they were distracting and pulled me out of the story every time, just as I was immersed. It got to the point where I was waiting for the break instead of just following the story.
If it wasn't for those issues, I would have happily awarded this book 5 stars.
September 2, 2025
The blurb for this book states:
‘You should know, I did it. Before you trouble yourself to read any further, you won't find an innocent woman in these pages. I am every bit as evil as they say I am. A murderer. A liar. A kinslayer. The gods, they say, save their worst punishments for those like me. Those who covet what isn't theirs. Those who slay their own blood. Those who lie about it after. I'm a woman who murdered for a man.
There isn't a hell black enough for one such as me. I'm every inch a sinner. And I will get what I deserve. Soon.’
Deirdre Ap Muirdagh is that woman. But she is not in any way as guilty as she believes she is.
This is a contemporary fairy tale taking place in ancient Ireland. It reminded me VERY strongly of Merida of Dunbrochs story in Brave. Both strong minded young women railing at the unfairness of the expectations placed upon them solely because of their sex and station in life. Deirdre also gets a bit of wicked stepmother action thrown in to boot. Is she head strong, stubborn and fighting like a cornered wolf to reclaim what she feels has been taken from her? YES! But she’s also young, naive and suffering her first crush and things go horribly wrong.
Did I want to smack her upside the head quite a few times for her sheer stubborn pride? Also YES! But I get where she’s coming from and sympathize.
I personally loved the story, and it ended as I hoped, (within reason).
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
‘You should know, I did it. Before you trouble yourself to read any further, you won't find an innocent woman in these pages. I am every bit as evil as they say I am. A murderer. A liar. A kinslayer. The gods, they say, save their worst punishments for those like me. Those who covet what isn't theirs. Those who slay their own blood. Those who lie about it after. I'm a woman who murdered for a man.
There isn't a hell black enough for one such as me. I'm every inch a sinner. And I will get what I deserve. Soon.’
Deirdre Ap Muirdagh is that woman. But she is not in any way as guilty as she believes she is.
This is a contemporary fairy tale taking place in ancient Ireland. It reminded me VERY strongly of Merida of Dunbrochs story in Brave. Both strong minded young women railing at the unfairness of the expectations placed upon them solely because of their sex and station in life. Deirdre also gets a bit of wicked stepmother action thrown in to boot. Is she head strong, stubborn and fighting like a cornered wolf to reclaim what she feels has been taken from her? YES! But she’s also young, naive and suffering her first crush and things go horribly wrong.
Did I want to smack her upside the head quite a few times for her sheer stubborn pride? Also YES! But I get where she’s coming from and sympathize.
I personally loved the story, and it ended as I hoped, (within reason).
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 4, 2026
I have some conflicting feelings about this story. Primarily, they're feelings of love and kinship, but also righteous indignation and disappointment.
It's amazing to me how much emotion and substance the author is able to fit into such a small book. I read an advanced copy of Riviere's A Vow for Breaking a few weeks ago and it had a similar emotional weight. Both books, though distantly separated by time and space, focus on the insurmountable nature of being a young, disenfranchised woman in a man's world.
Growing up as an older half-sister with an absent parent, the neglect and jealousy experienced by our protagonist brought back a lot of memories. The sibling dynamic was spot-on. Deirdre's ultimate acceptance of the blame, while it echos the initial book blurb, is so far away from what I wanted for this poor girl. Watching her acquiesce to the vilification hurled by frightened, ignorant fools set my teeth on edge. I won't deny that it was all done beautifully and in a way that made sense, but every sane person within the story agreed with me. It's a shame she wasn't in a better position to think of herself similarly.
The nod towards a child's capacity to be a parent's undoing was woven throughout the story with such a light hand, but it filled every inch of the page. King Matudán's cursed reign after sending Deirdre away. Hester's lack of affection leading towards the fraught relationship between Deirdre and Calanthe in the first place, and the way it led to every other event. Deirdre's love and sense of responsibility for Breccan and the results of his thievery. Having a child is like wearing your heart outside of your body, the price can be steep when they have no concept of the havoc they might wreak.
Overall another beautiful story by Riviere.
Thank you to BookSirens for the opportunity
It's amazing to me how much emotion and substance the author is able to fit into such a small book. I read an advanced copy of Riviere's A Vow for Breaking a few weeks ago and it had a similar emotional weight. Both books, though distantly separated by time and space, focus on the insurmountable nature of being a young, disenfranchised woman in a man's world.
Growing up as an older half-sister with an absent parent, the neglect and jealousy experienced by our protagonist brought back a lot of memories. The sibling dynamic was spot-on. Deirdre's ultimate acceptance of the blame, while it echos the initial book blurb, is so far away from what I wanted for this poor girl. Watching her acquiesce to the vilification hurled by frightened, ignorant fools set my teeth on edge. I won't deny that it was all done beautifully and in a way that made sense, but every sane person within the story agreed with me. It's a shame she wasn't in a better position to think of herself similarly.
The nod towards a child's capacity to be a parent's undoing was woven throughout the story with such a light hand, but it filled every inch of the page. King Matudán's cursed reign after sending Deirdre away. Hester's lack of affection leading towards the fraught relationship between Deirdre and Calanthe in the first place, and the way it led to every other event. Deirdre's love and sense of responsibility for Breccan and the results of his thievery. Having a child is like wearing your heart outside of your body, the price can be steep when they have no concept of the havoc they might wreak.
Overall another beautiful story by Riviere.
Thank you to BookSirens for the opportunity
September 29, 2025
A Dark Most Fair by LM Riviere is a hauntingly beautiful tale that weaves history, myth, and raw emotion into a tapestry of heartbreak and redemption. I was completely captivated by the atmospheric setting, which vividly brought ancient Ulaid to life. The historical details; down to the customs, architecture, and societal norms, immersed me in a world both brutal and breathtaking.
Deirdre’s journey is one of profound sorrow and resilience, and her voice is so authentic that I felt every ounce of her pain, guilt, and longing. The author masterfully blends the historical backdrop with the ethereal presence of The Others, creating a story that feels both grounded in history and touched by the supernatural. The themes of family, betrayal, and self-worth are explored with such depth that they lingered with me long after I turned the final page.
The writing is lyrical and evocative, perfectly capturing the mood of the story. I found myself completely swept away by the emotional weight of Deirdre’s choices and the haunting beauty of her world. This is not just a story it’s an experience.
Thank you to BookSirens for providing me this ARC . This is a book I’ll be thinking about for a long time, and I highly recommend it to anyone who loves historical fiction with a touch of myth and magic.
Deirdre’s journey is one of profound sorrow and resilience, and her voice is so authentic that I felt every ounce of her pain, guilt, and longing. The author masterfully blends the historical backdrop with the ethereal presence of The Others, creating a story that feels both grounded in history and touched by the supernatural. The themes of family, betrayal, and self-worth are explored with such depth that they lingered with me long after I turned the final page.
The writing is lyrical and evocative, perfectly capturing the mood of the story. I found myself completely swept away by the emotional weight of Deirdre’s choices and the haunting beauty of her world. This is not just a story it’s an experience.
Thank you to BookSirens for providing me this ARC . This is a book I’ll be thinking about for a long time, and I highly recommend it to anyone who loves historical fiction with a touch of myth and magic.
September 3, 2025
"Dark Most Fair" by LM Riviere
sᴛᴏʀʏ: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
sᴘɪᴄᴇ:
I have to start by saying this was my first read by this author so I went in blind. I knew it was dark fantasy, and being a dark reader girly, I wasn't sure at first. I was definitely down to give it a shot though and dove right in…
Overall, this was a really interesting, fast-paced read with a twisty storyline that kept me sucked in but also had me feeling a mix of emotions. Not even 10% in and I was gripping onto my seat because of the main characters and their story. From how they meet, to the backstories of them, to what happens at the end.
This book at times was easy to follow and then other times it was hard to understand. I do feel like the ending was not very clear and that it ended on a bit of a cliffhanger. This is what caused me to do 4 stars.
Bottomline: Its a fast read. And it is a good story and very plot thickened. It does have some triggers so make sure to be aware of them.
Tropes/Genre/Triggers:
-Horror
-Dark Fantasy
-Fairytales
-Historical
-Depression
-Thoughts of Self-harm
-Actions of Self-harm
-Violence
-Self-worth struggles
* I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. *
sᴛᴏʀʏ: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
sᴘɪᴄᴇ:
I have to start by saying this was my first read by this author so I went in blind. I knew it was dark fantasy, and being a dark reader girly, I wasn't sure at first. I was definitely down to give it a shot though and dove right in…
Overall, this was a really interesting, fast-paced read with a twisty storyline that kept me sucked in but also had me feeling a mix of emotions. Not even 10% in and I was gripping onto my seat because of the main characters and their story. From how they meet, to the backstories of them, to what happens at the end.
This book at times was easy to follow and then other times it was hard to understand. I do feel like the ending was not very clear and that it ended on a bit of a cliffhanger. This is what caused me to do 4 stars.
Bottomline: Its a fast read. And it is a good story and very plot thickened. It does have some triggers so make sure to be aware of them.
Tropes/Genre/Triggers:
-Horror
-Dark Fantasy
-Fairytales
-Historical
-Depression
-Thoughts of Self-harm
-Actions of Self-harm
-Violence
-Self-worth struggles
* I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. *
June 4, 2026
**Thank you BookSirens for the free ARC. I am voluntarily leaving this review.**
Uhm, all I can say is WOW. I was so excited for this book after reading A Vow For Breaking and the preview for this book at its end. I wasn't 100% sure what to expect since both books were written in first person. Would the characters be too similar? Would the plot?
Absolutely not.
Deirdre is written so well - truly, all the characters were IMO - and was someone I felt more and more for as she continued to hit challenge after challenge. The pacing of this book felt perfect to me, committing enough time to the before and after her life as a princess. The setting leaned heavily Gothic, which I very much enjoyed, and the tense scenes (think Mael, Calanthe, and Breccan) were so brutal and heartfelt. I was left in a dampened mood which, believe it or not, is what I seek when I read horror.
And the ending? It was perfectly tragic. I am so very happy to have discovered this author and plan to read everything that they put out.
Uhm, all I can say is WOW. I was so excited for this book after reading A Vow For Breaking and the preview for this book at its end. I wasn't 100% sure what to expect since both books were written in first person. Would the characters be too similar? Would the plot?
Absolutely not.
Deirdre is written so well - truly, all the characters were IMO - and was someone I felt more and more for as she continued to hit challenge after challenge. The pacing of this book felt perfect to me, committing enough time to the before and after her life as a princess. The setting leaned heavily Gothic, which I very much enjoyed, and the tense scenes (think Mael, Calanthe, and Breccan) were so brutal and heartfelt. I was left in a dampened mood which, believe it or not, is what I seek when I read horror.
And the ending? It was perfectly tragic. I am so very happy to have discovered this author and plan to read everything that they put out.
August 10, 2025
A Dark Most Fair is a refreshing, nuanced dark fairytale retelling that gives a unique take on what happens when being given three wishes goes terribly wrong. This book is perfect for T. Kingfisher readers and those who love the historical prose of Juliet Marillier. I am a huge fan of Riviere's epic fantasy trilogy, Innisfail Cycle, and A Dark Most Fair is a quick trip back into Riviere's beautiful writing and engaging characters.
Deirdre, the main character, has a relatable mix of youth and rage that often leads to disaster. I couldn't help but to feel for her, even as I wanted to shake her. Riviere also gives a look into what happens once all the wishes are gone, and what kind of woman Deirdre becomes when all she has is stripped away. The other characters are written in a way that makes you question if they are innocents or villains, landing mostly of a bit of both. I found them realistic and thought-provoking.
Deirdre, the main character, has a relatable mix of youth and rage that often leads to disaster. I couldn't help but to feel for her, even as I wanted to shake her. Riviere also gives a look into what happens once all the wishes are gone, and what kind of woman Deirdre becomes when all she has is stripped away. The other characters are written in a way that makes you question if they are innocents or villains, landing mostly of a bit of both. I found them realistic and thought-provoking.
August 26, 2025
This book is so well written and researched! I loved that it was set in ancient Ireland and is a retelling of an Irish folk tale - quite accurately. The world building is fantastic and so is the character building – leaving me wanting to know a LOT more about our mystery man.
Deirdre, our FMC, is the daughter of a king! Sadly, she is disregarded for her younger, prettier and more princess like half-sister. This basically makes up the majority of her personality for 90% of the book – but it WORKS! The story follows Deirdre and how she copes with being replaced and how she becomes tangled up with one of The Other (our mystery man). It also follows very bad decision she makes and a few times I found myself shouting at a page – WHY????
If you love a fairy-tale retelling, found family, magic, betrayal (and soooo much more) get A Dark Most Fair on to your TBR!!!
I received a free copy of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
Deirdre, our FMC, is the daughter of a king! Sadly, she is disregarded for her younger, prettier and more princess like half-sister. This basically makes up the majority of her personality for 90% of the book – but it WORKS! The story follows Deirdre and how she copes with being replaced and how she becomes tangled up with one of The Other (our mystery man). It also follows very bad decision she makes and a few times I found myself shouting at a page – WHY????
If you love a fairy-tale retelling, found family, magic, betrayal (and soooo much more) get A Dark Most Fair on to your TBR!!!
I received a free copy of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
September 18, 2025
I was privileged enough to receive an advanced reader copy at no charge. This review is an honest and unbiased opinion A Dark Most Fair.
I highly enjoyed this book! The plot was strong, detailed, and yet very easy to follow—it kept me entertained and interested from start to finish. One of my favorite aspects was the clever nods to several other fairytales. This wasn’t your typical retelling; instead, it offered a fresh concept that lightly touched on familiar elements without relying too heavily on them.
The writing style was smooth, and the language was easy to understand within context, which made the story flow effortlessly.
That said, there were a few downsides. Some of the character names were very similar, which occasionally made it difficult to keep the cast straight.
Overall, I’d definitely recommend this book to anyone looking for a dark fairytale that feels unique and different from the usual retellings. It’s a refreshing twist on a familiar genre.
I highly enjoyed this book! The plot was strong, detailed, and yet very easy to follow—it kept me entertained and interested from start to finish. One of my favorite aspects was the clever nods to several other fairytales. This wasn’t your typical retelling; instead, it offered a fresh concept that lightly touched on familiar elements without relying too heavily on them.
The writing style was smooth, and the language was easy to understand within context, which made the story flow effortlessly.
That said, there were a few downsides. Some of the character names were very similar, which occasionally made it difficult to keep the cast straight.
Overall, I’d definitely recommend this book to anyone looking for a dark fairytale that feels unique and different from the usual retellings. It’s a refreshing twist on a familiar genre.
September 29, 2025
This story swept me away to ancient Ireland, where royalty, myth, & betrayal collide! 👑☘️
We follow Deirdre, daughter of a king, whose life is marked by loss and cruelty since her mother passing. Between court rivals and a forbidden protector who watches over her, this story is dripping with danger! Think of Cinderella and her ugly stepsisters, except make it dark…🩸
The writing feels lush like you are stepping into a gothic fairytale. There’s magic, forbidden romance, found strength, and yearning that keeps you turning the pages! Your heart may break a few times along the way, but it all works out in the end…🖤
This is the first story I have read set in the Irish royal court, and it was a masterpiece. The first page will have you hooked immediately, as it sets the tone for the entire book 🔮
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️ (nothing explicit)
We follow Deirdre, daughter of a king, whose life is marked by loss and cruelty since her mother passing. Between court rivals and a forbidden protector who watches over her, this story is dripping with danger! Think of Cinderella and her ugly stepsisters, except make it dark…🩸
The writing feels lush like you are stepping into a gothic fairytale. There’s magic, forbidden romance, found strength, and yearning that keeps you turning the pages! Your heart may break a few times along the way, but it all works out in the end…🖤
This is the first story I have read set in the Irish royal court, and it was a masterpiece. The first page will have you hooked immediately, as it sets the tone for the entire book 🔮
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️ (nothing explicit)
August 9, 2025
◇◇ ARC Review◇◇
.
Rating: 4.5☆
Genre: Fantasy
.
A Dark Most Fair by L.M.Reviere
.
A Dark Most Fair by L.M.Reveiere is a short fantasy novel. The book follows the story Of Diedre and how she gets entangled with the otherworldy spirit who grants her wishes. But overcome with jealousy of her younger, fairer sister, Diedre makes some very poor choices that lead to drastic consequences and ruin her life.
.
I was hooked to the story from start to finish. I loved the fast pace and unfolding of the story. I could hardly put it down till the end.
.
I enjoyed reading this book. If you are interested in fantasy and sisterly rivalry, do give this a read.
.
Thankyou L.M.Reviere for reaching out to me and sharing this book with me.
.
I received a free copy of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
.
Rating: 4.5☆
Genre: Fantasy
.
A Dark Most Fair by L.M.Reviere
.
A Dark Most Fair by L.M.Reveiere is a short fantasy novel. The book follows the story Of Diedre and how she gets entangled with the otherworldy spirit who grants her wishes. But overcome with jealousy of her younger, fairer sister, Diedre makes some very poor choices that lead to drastic consequences and ruin her life.
.
I was hooked to the story from start to finish. I loved the fast pace and unfolding of the story. I could hardly put it down till the end.
.
I enjoyed reading this book. If you are interested in fantasy and sisterly rivalry, do give this a read.
.
Thankyou L.M.Reviere for reaching out to me and sharing this book with me.
.
I received a free copy of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
August 20, 2025
It takes a special kind of fantasy book for me to really enjoy it and I did not expect this to be one of those books. The story grabbed me right from the beginning and held on to the very end. It is a story of love and loss, family and obligations, treachery and secrets. We know there is a murder from the very beginning but what we come to find out if the how and why. The worldbuilding is fantastic and the characters feel real. I wasn't aware that this was a retelling of an Irish folk tale until I saw other reviews so I had nothing to judge it against. The fact that I was constantly sneaking a page whenever I could until it was finished is a serious complement to the author. It was a quick but engrossing read that I recommend wholeheartedly.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 24, 2026
The first thing that came to mind when I finished this book was, "Huh, dark indeed."
I had this for a while, and while I didn't remember what it was about, I later found out it was a retelling of an Irish fairy tale—so now I'm curious as to how that original tale went about for this story to have been made.
The story itself was amazing, it was enthralling. It spoke for those pushed aside, overlooked, and mistreated in favor for someone else. There was the subtle darkness that came from the magic of The Others, the subtle switches when you notice where decisions made truly affected other areas.
It also felt bittersweet—how the FMC's story went. She just couldn't catch a break, her peace of mind when it all fell around her. Time to look up the original fairy tale.
I had this for a while, and while I didn't remember what it was about, I later found out it was a retelling of an Irish fairy tale—so now I'm curious as to how that original tale went about for this story to have been made.
The story itself was amazing, it was enthralling. It spoke for those pushed aside, overlooked, and mistreated in favor for someone else. There was the subtle darkness that came from the magic of The Others, the subtle switches when you notice where decisions made truly affected other areas.
It also felt bittersweet—how the FMC's story went. She just couldn't catch a break, her peace of mind when it all fell around her. Time to look up the original fairy tale.
April 17, 2026
A dark most fair is a great read. I couldn't put it down. This book follows along the story of a princess that is forgotten by her family and the magic that finds her and changes her life forever. This book shows the true colors of people in power and what they will do to get what they want. From the moments in the castle to the moments in the small village just trying to survive you will be able to truly connect with Deirdre and understand why she make the decisions that she does. The ending took me off guard but I loved the way it ended. This story has parts of fairytales hidden in Easter eggs thru the whole story as well as Irish traditions and folklore. I definitely reccomend you pick up a copy and read it today.
August 29, 2025
A Dark Most Fair by LM Riviere is a dark historical fairytale, based on Irish mythology, that grabs your attention from page one and keeps it right until the very last page.
A quick read, I was enthralled in Diedre's tale of sisterly rivalry, pain, suffering and mistakes. Some very poor, rash decisions are made in the heat of the moment that Diedre must learn to live with. Will she ever be free? Or will they come back to haunt her?
If you enjoy fantasy, found family, strong fmc and Irish mythology, you definitely need to add A Dark Most Fair to your TBR!
Be sure to check the trigger warnings before diving in. Your mental health matters 🫶
A quick read, I was enthralled in Diedre's tale of sisterly rivalry, pain, suffering and mistakes. Some very poor, rash decisions are made in the heat of the moment that Diedre must learn to live with. Will she ever be free? Or will they come back to haunt her?
If you enjoy fantasy, found family, strong fmc and Irish mythology, you definitely need to add A Dark Most Fair to your TBR!
Be sure to check the trigger warnings before diving in. Your mental health matters 🫶
August 11, 2025
L. M. Riviere wrote this book so well, I was invested in what was happening in this world and enjoyed how the dark fantasy and the fairy tale elements were used perfectly. I enjoyed L. M. Riviere wrote this and creates the world that I was looking for. The characters were so well written and enjoyed how it was used in a historical period. It left me wanting to read more in this world and was glad I got to read this.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 1, 2025
This story was a good read. I would've liked to know more about the others and their dealings that made people so afraid and superstitious of them. I would also like to read more about Briar's story. I feel like a lot can be done in this world and the story. I definitely felt for deidre being the overlooked sibling and outshone by her younger sister. I could relate to that with my younger brother. I can also relate to being overlooked by suitors because of some of my friends being better looking than me. I look forward to other works by this author.
August 29, 2025
It’s entertaining.
This story is def not ending on a happy ending. Or one we know as happy. This doesn’t bother me…it felt like a Snow White but with extra… and missing pieces.
I liked the book as I think 3 stars are fine.
It’s a book that’s easy to read and leaves you feeling like you missed the salt in your soup. Enjoyable but missing something.
The character development was there but predictable. The ending felt lack luster
But the story has heart and you do cheer for our FMC.
This story is def not ending on a happy ending. Or one we know as happy. This doesn’t bother me…it felt like a Snow White but with extra… and missing pieces.
I liked the book as I think 3 stars are fine.
It’s a book that’s easy to read and leaves you feeling like you missed the salt in your soup. Enjoyable but missing something.
The character development was there but predictable. The ending felt lack luster
But the story has heart and you do cheer for our FMC.
September 14, 2025
A dark fantasy with fairies, witches, kings, and queens. The main character, Deidre, is the daughter of a king and an overlooked older sister. She gets granted three wishes. The wishes she makes change her life and her families forever. I really enjoyed the twisty tale. I wish she would have elaborated more on Briar's story and drew a broader picture of the ending.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 2, 2026
I haven’t been this hooked on a book in a really long time. It’s usually hard for me to get into a story, but this one pulled me in right away and I actually didn’t want to put it down. I loved the era it was set in because it made everything feel more immersive and added so much to the story. It was really well written, the pacing felt right, and nothing felt out of place. It honestly reminded me how much I enjoy reading when a book is this good.
August 1, 2025
Received an advance copy and I can’t praise this enough. It was a good and emotional journey where I wanted to scream at the main character but she was so relatable and well-built. Watching her story unfold was compelling, heartbreaking, and ultimately satisfying. The world-building was beautiful, it painted a picture of a lovely and magical ancient Irish setting.
August 10, 2025
A Dark Most Fair presents a well researched world with a lot of time and care taking to establishing key locations and characters.
The main character is as infuriating as she is tragic.
M main complaint for this book is that so much time is spent on the world building that the action feels very rushed.
The main character is as infuriating as she is tragic.
M main complaint for this book is that so much time is spent on the world building that the action feels very rushed.
August 15, 2025
I wasn’t sure what I was going to think as I first got started. I very quickly loved the FMC Dierdre. I felt her anguish and loneliness and rage. Briar’s character development was mind boggling. I really enjoyed the plot twists and would love to see their story continue!! I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews