What do you think?
Rate this book
Our Rogue Fates: A Novel
Not yet published
Expected 28 Apr 26On the hunt for hidden treasure, two former best friends turned adversaries must put the past behind them if they hope to make it home.
This enemies-to-lovers male/male romantic fantasy in the tradition of Tusk Love and Sara Raasch crackles with tension and heat.
When he isn’t training as a Warden to become half the hero his father was, Griff Sayer is in the business of breaking hearts all across the town of Mayfair, although that slows down after settling in with his current boyfriend. Griff's ex-best-friend, Mal Pryce, meanwhile, is in business with whatever or whoever puts good money in his hands. Now in their mid-20s, Griff and Mal have only exchanged scathing looks and carefully barbed jabs since the fight that sent them their separate ways years ago. But all that begins to change when an attack Mal plotted for his shady boss leaves Griff near death and their childhood friend Alys is his savior, forcing them back into each other’s orbit.
Livid at his boss, Mal makes a deal to earn his freedom and Griff’s safety. He has just four weeks to retrieve an ancient treasure from Rotrose Mire, a remote swamp known for its ghostly and beastly dangers, the same treasure Alys’s beloved father Rhun had been searching for when he disappeared for good. Armed with a map and a broken blade of Rhun’s, Mal sets off—with Alys and a reluctant and newly single Griff in tow.
Yet the explosive tension between the two men—along with the dangers of the mire pressing in around them—make for a more difficult journey than any of them could have anticipated. As Griff and Mal peel back their tough facades, and shared feelings heat up in unexpected ways as they learn to trust again, they also realize that someone—or something—seems to be following their path. Someone who doesn’t want them to succeed, no friend to their parents’ old enemies, but also no friend to would-be heroes…
Our Rogue Fates is a second-chance spicy Achillean romance with the questing spirit of Dungeons & Dragons, perfect for fans of Critical Role.
This enemies-to-lovers male/male romantic fantasy in the tradition of Tusk Love and Sara Raasch crackles with tension and heat.
When he isn’t training as a Warden to become half the hero his father was, Griff Sayer is in the business of breaking hearts all across the town of Mayfair, although that slows down after settling in with his current boyfriend. Griff's ex-best-friend, Mal Pryce, meanwhile, is in business with whatever or whoever puts good money in his hands. Now in their mid-20s, Griff and Mal have only exchanged scathing looks and carefully barbed jabs since the fight that sent them their separate ways years ago. But all that begins to change when an attack Mal plotted for his shady boss leaves Griff near death and their childhood friend Alys is his savior, forcing them back into each other’s orbit.
Livid at his boss, Mal makes a deal to earn his freedom and Griff’s safety. He has just four weeks to retrieve an ancient treasure from Rotrose Mire, a remote swamp known for its ghostly and beastly dangers, the same treasure Alys’s beloved father Rhun had been searching for when he disappeared for good. Armed with a map and a broken blade of Rhun’s, Mal sets off—with Alys and a reluctant and newly single Griff in tow.
Yet the explosive tension between the two men—along with the dangers of the mire pressing in around them—make for a more difficult journey than any of them could have anticipated. As Griff and Mal peel back their tough facades, and shared feelings heat up in unexpected ways as they learn to trust again, they also realize that someone—or something—seems to be following their path. Someone who doesn’t want them to succeed, no friend to their parents’ old enemies, but also no friend to would-be heroes…
Our Rogue Fates is a second-chance spicy Achillean romance with the questing spirit of Dungeons & Dragons, perfect for fans of Critical Role.
Kindle Edition
Expected publication April 28, 2026
34 people are currently reading
5786 people want to read
About the author
Sarah Glenn Marsh
31 books850 followersSarah Glenn Marsh has been an avid fantasy reader since the day her dad handed her a copy of The Hobbit and promised it would change her life. She believes we all deserve happy endings and is an author of books for everyone, including many young adult, middle grade, and picture book titles.
She lives in Richmond, Virginia with her family, including one sweet daughter, one slightly dull sword, and the chaos of many pets, like a turtle named Muffin who she definitely did not bring back from any haunted swamp. Our Rogue Fates is her first adult novel.
She lives in Richmond, Virginia with her family, including one sweet daughter, one slightly dull sword, and the chaos of many pets, like a turtle named Muffin who she definitely did not bring back from any haunted swamp. Our Rogue Fates is her first adult novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 174 reviews
December 3, 2025
09/07/25: This is one of those books that gets under your skin and grabs hold of you. From the first sentence I was hooked, and instantly transported to Sarah’s world that she created. I need a moment to collect my thoughts before properly reviewing, but this is a book you won’t wanna miss, and I wish I could rate it infinite stars! ✨💖✨
12/03/25:
Ok divas, I’m back! 🤣
I have read the book for a second time now in prep for the next few books in the series. I have the pleasure of being on Sarah’s Street Team, and am able to beta read the next few. In doing so, I went back to reread book one.
My dudes, It was even better the second time. Sarah has built a world that all LGBTQIA+ identifiers and allies will fall in love with. It’s inclusive on many levels and it just feels like a place you wanna crawl into and get lost in. This is a very special book about found family, second chances at love, and learning to love yourself as you are. The three main characters are such a delight and very unique. I loved Mal and Griff, and watching them go on their journey to realize they’re meant to be was such a fun ride to be on. Although, Alys may be my favorite. I just really gravitated and identified with who she is as a person and how she lives her life. She loves fiercely, and always means well, yet somehow is a magnet for trouble and chaos. That’s me 😂
I know this book isn’t out until April 2026, but add this to your want to read on Goodreads and preorder it wherever you get your books from. This is one you won’t want to miss!
Thanks again to Sarah for letting me be apart of her Street Team, and an ARC reader. This has been a magical journey so far, and big things are coming! ✨💖✨
12/03/25:
Ok divas, I’m back! 🤣
I have read the book for a second time now in prep for the next few books in the series. I have the pleasure of being on Sarah’s Street Team, and am able to beta read the next few. In doing so, I went back to reread book one.
My dudes, It was even better the second time. Sarah has built a world that all LGBTQIA+ identifiers and allies will fall in love with. It’s inclusive on many levels and it just feels like a place you wanna crawl into and get lost in. This is a very special book about found family, second chances at love, and learning to love yourself as you are. The three main characters are such a delight and very unique. I loved Mal and Griff, and watching them go on their journey to realize they’re meant to be was such a fun ride to be on. Although, Alys may be my favorite. I just really gravitated and identified with who she is as a person and how she lives her life. She loves fiercely, and always means well, yet somehow is a magnet for trouble and chaos. That’s me 😂
I know this book isn’t out until April 2026, but add this to your want to read on Goodreads and preorder it wherever you get your books from. This is one you won’t want to miss!
Thanks again to Sarah for letting me be apart of her Street Team, and an ARC reader. This has been a magical journey so far, and big things are coming! ✨💖✨
August 18, 2025
Characters to fall for. Love to fight for. Queer Storytelling for the cottagecore soul. RTC
Read
January 11, 2026*PSA TO ANYONE WANTING TO READ THIS**
* BEWARE- DO NOT READ…unless 👀*
UNLESS, you’re ready to end up sad that the world building and environments laid out on page were so expansive, descriptive and detailed you can’t even *actually* be there…
UNLESS you’re ready to be jealous of the relationship Griff & Mal come into, from friends, to enemies, to “friends” to daresay *loversss* through thick and thin, and everything in between! No *Swamp 😉 will stop them!*
UNLESS you’re ready to be sad you don’t have an emotional support *REDACTED* to talk to!
UNLESS you’re ready to be sad you aren’t gentle parented by one of the MC’s.
UNLESS you’re ready to accept the fact Our Rogue Fates will be one of your top reads to release next year! So be there or be square, or I’ll send Gossamer after you! 🖤
And if you’re not ready, well buckle up anyways for the journey you’re about to experience!
In full seriousness I personally had such an immense time reading this book, and was my first book from Sarah that I’ve had the pleasure of reading, and I cannot wait for whatever the future holds for Our Rogue Fates, the world, and the characters!
* BEWARE- DO NOT READ…unless 👀*
UNLESS, you’re ready to end up sad that the world building and environments laid out on page were so expansive, descriptive and detailed you can’t even *actually* be there…
UNLESS you’re ready to be jealous of the relationship Griff & Mal come into, from friends, to enemies, to “friends” to daresay *loversss* through thick and thin, and everything in between! No *Swamp 😉 will stop them!*
UNLESS you’re ready to be sad you don’t have an emotional support *REDACTED* to talk to!
UNLESS you’re ready to be sad you aren’t gentle parented by one of the MC’s.
UNLESS you’re ready to accept the fact Our Rogue Fates will be one of your top reads to release next year! So be there or be square, or I’ll send Gossamer after you! 🖤
And if you’re not ready, well buckle up anyways for the journey you’re about to experience!
In full seriousness I personally had such an immense time reading this book, and was my first book from Sarah that I’ve had the pleasure of reading, and I cannot wait for whatever the future holds for Our Rogue Fates, the world, and the characters!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 22, 2025
This was such a beautiful story! I loved how humor was woven throughout the story even when the characters are facing danger and challenges. Seeing Mal and Griff fall in love and work on themselves for each other was so sweet! I loved this story 🥹
September 1, 2025
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.8/5
Spice: YES 🥵🌶️🌶️
KU AUS: I'm unsure
Our Rogue Fates - @sarahmarshauthor 🩷
Out 28th of April 2026 🗡️ PreOrder Now!
This book found me on Netgalley with a calling card on the cover in the form of words of praise by Sean Astin. As a LOTR fan that's all I needed to immediately pray for a copy. The spirits of the mire were on my side when I got approved for this ARC. And by the gods look at this COVER!! Stunning 🥺 Thank you @netgalley and our beautiful author for this ARC copy!
"If the LOTR was gay" a MM, treasure hunt quest style, fantasy romance, friends to enemies to lovers, comfort decapitated heads (my fav), cozy and heavy, touch him and die, soft but grumpy, mental health and disability rep, queer normative, and some absolutely badass female characters. I was hooked from the very beginning and it definitely helps to be able to picture Aragon while reading.
The world building for this book was so immersive that I felt like I was in the story alongside the characters. I decided to read this while on my walking pad and it truly felt like I was treking the long hours at their sides. And when things started heating up I could barely keep my footing! Once it started there was no stopping these two! I don't know how they found the time since I don't think there is a moment of peace in this entire book. It keeps the adventure one of high stakes, with so much to lose. Some of the lines in this book touched my soul so deeply. It truly captured the way struggling with mental health feels, the heaviness of it even when surrounded by those you love. It was exactly what I needed to read 💙
There is something I find so moving about harsher male characters sharing their softer vulnerabilities, and both Griff and Mal and even Alys express themselves so beautifully. I adore them. My only regret is that I found such an incredible story that isn't yet released which means book two is still far away! Sarah how do I sell my soul for book two!! 🥺
Our Rogue Fates is a love letter to fans of The Lord of the Rings, especially those who were rooting for Legolas and Aragorn or Sam and Frodo to get together.
Spice: YES 🥵🌶️🌶️
KU AUS: I'm unsure
Our Rogue Fates - @sarahmarshauthor 🩷
Out 28th of April 2026 🗡️ PreOrder Now!
This book found me on Netgalley with a calling card on the cover in the form of words of praise by Sean Astin. As a LOTR fan that's all I needed to immediately pray for a copy. The spirits of the mire were on my side when I got approved for this ARC. And by the gods look at this COVER!! Stunning 🥺 Thank you @netgalley and our beautiful author for this ARC copy!
"If the LOTR was gay" a MM, treasure hunt quest style, fantasy romance, friends to enemies to lovers, comfort decapitated heads (my fav), cozy and heavy, touch him and die, soft but grumpy, mental health and disability rep, queer normative, and some absolutely badass female characters. I was hooked from the very beginning and it definitely helps to be able to picture Aragon while reading.
The world building for this book was so immersive that I felt like I was in the story alongside the characters. I decided to read this while on my walking pad and it truly felt like I was treking the long hours at their sides. And when things started heating up I could barely keep my footing! Once it started there was no stopping these two! I don't know how they found the time since I don't think there is a moment of peace in this entire book. It keeps the adventure one of high stakes, with so much to lose. Some of the lines in this book touched my soul so deeply. It truly captured the way struggling with mental health feels, the heaviness of it even when surrounded by those you love. It was exactly what I needed to read 💙
There is something I find so moving about harsher male characters sharing their softer vulnerabilities, and both Griff and Mal and even Alys express themselves so beautifully. I adore them. My only regret is that I found such an incredible story that isn't yet released which means book two is still far away! Sarah how do I sell my soul for book two!! 🥺
Our Rogue Fates is a love letter to fans of The Lord of the Rings, especially those who were rooting for Legolas and Aragorn or Sam and Frodo to get together.
September 17, 2025
What a truly beautiful story between old best friends that lost their way but have a chance to find each other in the best possible way. On the greatest adventure of there lives, a treasure hunt that is worth more then just treasure.
Griff, Mal, and Alys used to be the best of friends always together always going on adventures but they each go there separate ways after a huge falling out where words had cut so deep. Now they are all different people, have been through so much and Griff and Mal don’t know each other but sure know how to rile each other, the love they have for each other is replace by so much hurt and hate.
Mal and Alys must go on a treasure hunt and bring Griff along and as the days go one everything that was never said comes to light and Mal and Griff must come together to beat all the creatures of the forest and hopefully see how right they truly are for each other.
Our Rouge Fates had be on the edge of my seat the hole time, seemed these three were always in danger no matter what they did, my heart sang every time Mal and Griff got to have there stolen moments. I loved how there coming together wasn’t rushed but they really talked about all the betrayal of the past. Alys just wanting her friends back together really spoke to me.
This book was so unique to me, and opened my eyes to such a beautiful world made up of some horrible creatures but what always hold true is who you have in your corner when those creatures come to collect.
Griff, Mal, and Alys used to be the best of friends always together always going on adventures but they each go there separate ways after a huge falling out where words had cut so deep. Now they are all different people, have been through so much and Griff and Mal don’t know each other but sure know how to rile each other, the love they have for each other is replace by so much hurt and hate.
Mal and Alys must go on a treasure hunt and bring Griff along and as the days go one everything that was never said comes to light and Mal and Griff must come together to beat all the creatures of the forest and hopefully see how right they truly are for each other.
Our Rouge Fates had be on the edge of my seat the hole time, seemed these three were always in danger no matter what they did, my heart sang every time Mal and Griff got to have there stolen moments. I loved how there coming together wasn’t rushed but they really talked about all the betrayal of the past. Alys just wanting her friends back together really spoke to me.
This book was so unique to me, and opened my eyes to such a beautiful world made up of some horrible creatures but what always hold true is who you have in your corner when those creatures come to collect.
August 7, 2025
Across the story, Our Rogue Fates is about two friends who had a falling out that both deeply regretted, even if they buried that regret beneath harsher, louder emotions. But who eventually come together to venture on a quest with their best friend. They find forgiveness, companionship, and love along the way.
But on an even deeper level, this story is about the struggles a person can face with their own selves. Whether the struggle be the current path they are on, who they are living their lives for, or even self-acceptance. Each of the three friends have such deeply rooted and individual struggles they are left to face on this quest in-between the more physical dangers of their journey. Each of them have so much healing to endure.
Also, it's a queer normative world. I always...I get so happy and almost...releaved?...the more I see queerness in fantasy novels. I want to continue seeing more. And more. And more.
But on an even deeper level, this story is about the struggles a person can face with their own selves. Whether the struggle be the current path they are on, who they are living their lives for, or even self-acceptance. Each of the three friends have such deeply rooted and individual struggles they are left to face on this quest in-between the more physical dangers of their journey. Each of them have so much healing to endure.
Also, it's a queer normative world. I always...I get so happy and almost...releaved?...the more I see queerness in fantasy novels. I want to continue seeing more. And more. And more.
September 18, 2025
Our Rogue Fates is one of my most anticipated books of 2026, so I'm both extremely thrilled and seriously honored to have been given a chance to read it early. Normally, when I get ARCs, I like to hold them until closer to the release date, but I was far too excited to wait any longer on this one.
The story begins with Griffin being attacked and left for dead by a mysterious group of bandits. We soon learn that the attack was orchestrated by Mal, not knowing that the victim would be his ex-best friend.
Griff, Mal, and Alys all grew up together, raised by Alys' parents. Several years ago, the three had a huge fight that splintered their relationship. Griffin, the son of a famous hero, has a strong moral code and strong opinions on the immoral jobs Mal takes. In the present, learning that his actions nearly killed Griff and fearing that his fellow bandits may try to finish the job, Mal makes a bargain with his shady employer: he'll venture into a treacherous swamp to retrieve a valuable artifact for the Shadow Queen. In exchange, he'll be able to leave his dangerous employment, and they'll agree to no longer target Griff. However, his destination just happens to be the same place where Alys' father, the man who raised the three friends, died years earlier. Brought back together by this perilous trek and wanting answers about what really happened to Alys' father, the trio set off on an epic and life-changing quest.
I loved all three characters. Alys was an unexpected highlight of the book. She's a mom of three, and she loves her two best friends dearly. Mal and Griff are complicated men, each with strong opinions and feelings. All three characters undergo satisfying character development throughout the book, and their relationship as a group is a touching found family dynamic.
The romance is a friends-to-enemies-to-lovers journey. Griff is dating another man at the start of the story, but he's very aware that he has lingering feelings for Mal. Mal, however, is still very hurt and angry over their fight, and he's never considered a relationship with another man. Once they set off on their adventure, they're forced to think about what they truly want and how they actually feel. Their relationship is passionate and intense, but it also develops into a tender, protective, and healing one.
The world-building, while clearly inspired by The Lord of the Rings, is original and intricate enough to stand on its own. The politics are also a little more complicated with more shades of grey. The world is queer normative with multiple LGBTQ+ relationships and characters, too!
Our Rogue Fates is a fun and emotional queer romantasy. The three main characters have a great dynamic, and the romance between Mal and Griff had me fully invested. I'd recommend this most to readers who like books such as Can't Spell Treason Without Tea by Rebecca Thorne and The Crack at the Heart of Everything by Fiona Fenn.
* I received an advanced copy of this book for free, thanks to NetGalley & the publisher. *
The story begins with Griffin being attacked and left for dead by a mysterious group of bandits. We soon learn that the attack was orchestrated by Mal, not knowing that the victim would be his ex-best friend.
Griff, Mal, and Alys all grew up together, raised by Alys' parents. Several years ago, the three had a huge fight that splintered their relationship. Griffin, the son of a famous hero, has a strong moral code and strong opinions on the immoral jobs Mal takes. In the present, learning that his actions nearly killed Griff and fearing that his fellow bandits may try to finish the job, Mal makes a bargain with his shady employer: he'll venture into a treacherous swamp to retrieve a valuable artifact for the Shadow Queen. In exchange, he'll be able to leave his dangerous employment, and they'll agree to no longer target Griff. However, his destination just happens to be the same place where Alys' father, the man who raised the three friends, died years earlier. Brought back together by this perilous trek and wanting answers about what really happened to Alys' father, the trio set off on an epic and life-changing quest.
I loved all three characters. Alys was an unexpected highlight of the book. She's a mom of three, and she loves her two best friends dearly. Mal and Griff are complicated men, each with strong opinions and feelings. All three characters undergo satisfying character development throughout the book, and their relationship as a group is a touching found family dynamic.
The romance is a friends-to-enemies-to-lovers journey. Griff is dating another man at the start of the story, but he's very aware that he has lingering feelings for Mal. Mal, however, is still very hurt and angry over their fight, and he's never considered a relationship with another man. Once they set off on their adventure, they're forced to think about what they truly want and how they actually feel. Their relationship is passionate and intense, but it also develops into a tender, protective, and healing one.
The world-building, while clearly inspired by The Lord of the Rings, is original and intricate enough to stand on its own. The politics are also a little more complicated with more shades of grey. The world is queer normative with multiple LGBTQ+ relationships and characters, too!
Our Rogue Fates is a fun and emotional queer romantasy. The three main characters have a great dynamic, and the romance between Mal and Griff had me fully invested. I'd recommend this most to readers who like books such as Can't Spell Treason Without Tea by Rebecca Thorne and The Crack at the Heart of Everything by Fiona Fenn.
* I received an advanced copy of this book for free, thanks to NetGalley & the publisher. *
August 27, 2025
ARC REVIEW: “Who wants easy?”
This book is perfect for fans of DnD, Legends & Lattes, a Fantasy mission plot with a romance subplot, and a Trio on a treasure hunting quest. These characters have a lot of history that happens off-page, which was super interesting to see how they deal with their past actions and overcome their faults to move forward together. Overall, the story is about finding forgiveness and companionship along your journey.
“You’re my biggest dream. My castle. My world. None of it matters without you at the center.”
This book is perfect for fans of DnD, Legends & Lattes, a Fantasy mission plot with a romance subplot, and a Trio on a treasure hunting quest. These characters have a lot of history that happens off-page, which was super interesting to see how they deal with their past actions and overcome their faults to move forward together. Overall, the story is about finding forgiveness and companionship along your journey.
“You’re my biggest dream. My castle. My world. None of it matters without you at the center.”
August 29, 2025
I was one of the lucky ones to have met Griff, Mal, and Alys before they found their way onto physical pages, and it would be fair to say this story has been holding a dear place in my heart for a while now.
However, as biased as my opinion may be in some aspects, it still doesn't take much to see when a story is objectively good.
The premise is rather simple: an adventurous journey to find long-lost treasure and maybe uncover a few old secrets in the process. Yet the hardest path the main characters have to take is, of course, the one to each other. Three childhood best friends, torn apart by circumstances and a sprinkle of miscommunication and stubbornness, forced to travel and cover each other's backs once again after years of painful silence – well, sometimes killing is harder than speaking your heart, after all.
And props to Griff and Mal for succeeding in both, really. They can seem like a typical grumpy/sunshine–black/white duo at first (although the sunshine is the black one, for once), but oh you wait, they are anything but. Not every day you encounter a fantasy (anti?)hero with a concerning substance addiction, or loud enough with their sexual life (Griff baby, I will love you forever, but eight knights is where the line should be drawn).
The star of the show – the romance – is there from the very beginning, although "Our Rogue Fates" is one of those rare occasions when it starts off with the worst and only gets better from there, so don't fear any unnecessary break ups. Griff and Mal collect enough popular tropes, like enemies-to-lovers (actual enemies, mind you) or forced proximity with a dash of touch-him-and-die, and yet the plot makes them all work in its favor and not just exist for the sake of it, thanks to extensive backstory. You find yourself rooting for the characters even before they set foot outside the city, so every small step towards the climax (pun intended) feels all the more important.
And my personal favorite, of course – the secondary characters. Each and every one deserving of a book of their own, to put it lightly. But no spoilers.
With all that being said, it's incredibly confusing to find out the resemblance – or rather, the succession – to "Lord of the Rings" isn't as obvious to some. The relationships between characters, and not necessarily the romance, but friendships, familial bonds, even scenes with not-so-small bestial ensemble – the strength and softness of them, the depth; the ability to change and forgive and overcome; the world building, after all. To deny that, especially because Rouges happen to be a queer story, seems a little like a five-year-old comprehensive skills to me.
However, as biased as my opinion may be in some aspects, it still doesn't take much to see when a story is objectively good.
The premise is rather simple: an adventurous journey to find long-lost treasure and maybe uncover a few old secrets in the process. Yet the hardest path the main characters have to take is, of course, the one to each other. Three childhood best friends, torn apart by circumstances and a sprinkle of miscommunication and stubbornness, forced to travel and cover each other's backs once again after years of painful silence – well, sometimes killing is harder than speaking your heart, after all.
And props to Griff and Mal for succeeding in both, really. They can seem like a typical grumpy/sunshine–black/white duo at first (although the sunshine is the black one, for once), but oh you wait, they are anything but. Not every day you encounter a fantasy (anti?)hero with a concerning substance addiction, or loud enough with their sexual life (Griff baby, I will love you forever, but eight knights is where the line should be drawn).
The star of the show – the romance – is there from the very beginning, although "Our Rogue Fates" is one of those rare occasions when it starts off with the worst and only gets better from there, so don't fear any unnecessary break ups. Griff and Mal collect enough popular tropes, like enemies-to-lovers (actual enemies, mind you) or forced proximity with a dash of touch-him-and-die, and yet the plot makes them all work in its favor and not just exist for the sake of it, thanks to extensive backstory. You find yourself rooting for the characters even before they set foot outside the city, so every small step towards the climax (pun intended) feels all the more important.
And my personal favorite, of course – the secondary characters. Each and every one deserving of a book of their own, to put it lightly. But no spoilers.
With all that being said, it's incredibly confusing to find out the resemblance – or rather, the succession – to "Lord of the Rings" isn't as obvious to some. The relationships between characters, and not necessarily the romance, but friendships, familial bonds, even scenes with not-so-small bestial ensemble – the strength and softness of them, the depth; the ability to change and forgive and overcome; the world building, after all. To deny that, especially because Rouges happen to be a queer story, seems a little like a five-year-old comprehensive skills to me.
September 1, 2025
ARC Review of Our Rogue Fates
Omgod. Oh. My. God. This book is my most anticipated book being released in 2026 and there is good reason. This is also the first book I ever made a vibes playlist for. Granted a lot of it Mal in his feelings but that’s my speciality.
This book fits in my cozy fantasy theme I am always after though there is some high stakes/intense moments, that will keep you turning the page and rooting for Mal, Griff, and Alys.
I loved the world building. I want to go to Mayfair. I want to go to the bakery. I personally would be watching the Griff and the other people building houses 🤭. I want to visit Stormveil or like to watch from afar. Not interested in Thrallkeld, if you know you know. I would also be steering clear of the Mire.
I loved how the adventure was written. The intense moments of battle but the comfort that trio would pull through even if they really had to go through the wringer. It was a page turner trying to figure out what would happen next. Because nothing could be easy.
Mal and Griff are everything. From Friends to Enemies to Lovers. Forget dying for your love. Imagine living for them. Imagine staying. Imagine being their guiding light. Imagine being their biggest dream. I think the relationship was built beautifully. Two broken and flawed individuals realizing they could still fit back together regardless not despite of everything.
And Alys. I love her. The trio would be incomplete without her (and Leo). She balances out the two boys, a voice of reason, and a complete badass that can handle herself.
Overall this was everything I could have wanted and more. I will be thinking about this book and world for the next couple of weeks.
Thank you for the opportunity to review Our Rogue Fates as an ARC. I can’t wait to hold and read it again when it comes out in April 2026
Omgod. Oh. My. God. This book is my most anticipated book being released in 2026 and there is good reason. This is also the first book I ever made a vibes playlist for. Granted a lot of it Mal in his feelings but that’s my speciality.
This book fits in my cozy fantasy theme I am always after though there is some high stakes/intense moments, that will keep you turning the page and rooting for Mal, Griff, and Alys.
I loved the world building. I want to go to Mayfair. I want to go to the bakery. I personally would be watching the Griff and the other people building houses 🤭. I want to visit Stormveil or like to watch from afar. Not interested in Thrallkeld, if you know you know. I would also be steering clear of the Mire.
I loved how the adventure was written. The intense moments of battle but the comfort that trio would pull through even if they really had to go through the wringer. It was a page turner trying to figure out what would happen next. Because nothing could be easy.
Mal and Griff are everything. From Friends to Enemies to Lovers. Forget dying for your love. Imagine living for them. Imagine staying. Imagine being their guiding light. Imagine being their biggest dream. I think the relationship was built beautifully. Two broken and flawed individuals realizing they could still fit back together regardless not despite of everything.
And Alys. I love her. The trio would be incomplete without her (and Leo). She balances out the two boys, a voice of reason, and a complete badass that can handle herself.
Overall this was everything I could have wanted and more. I will be thinking about this book and world for the next couple of weeks.
Thank you for the opportunity to review Our Rogue Fates as an ARC. I can’t wait to hold and read it again when it comes out in April 2026
arc-to-read
August 13, 2025I received a copy of this book via NetGalley (thank you Alcove Press). All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 17, 2025
(Street Team eARC) *Very Light Spoilers* As a lifelong fantasy lover, this book was calling to me from the minute I heard about it. SGM's worldbuilding is immersive without being overwhelming; the settings, various factions, and inner-world politics are easy to comprehend, but don't detract from the main plot. The characters are easy to empathize with. They each have their own clearly defined goals and plans -- plenty of which are upended, which makes for a compelling tale, as they traverse their own emotions, along with completing the main quest at hand. Griff and Mal are reminiscent of classic fantasy characters, and there are certainly familiar bits and pieces shining through -- but they're so distinctly their own, with their own struggles, feelings, and ideals. But one of my favorite parts of the book was being able to connect with other characters, too. Alys was such an unexpected joy for me; I related to her in so many ways, and saw parts of myself in her, too. I caught myself rooting for Liam's happiness. There's a whole gaggle of animal companions that made me smile, and say "Yup, that sounds just like my dog." The whole cast of characters leads this story so beautifully, and I think that's one of the primary reasons I adored it so. Because while this is a fantasy adventure story, it is also, at its heart, guided strongly by love. I can't wait to celebrate this book's release, and I hope I can return to the world of Linden soon.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 7, 2025
A heartwarming romance between our main guys amidst a trio of friends adapting to lived experiences.
A few critiques:
The storyline was hard to get into at first due to the present and background sharing feeling a little convoluted.
Mal tumbles right into sex with Griff after saying that he's never thought of another man that way... considering his wary and jaded nature that felt like a big jump. (not that I'm complaining! :P)
Griff's moral compass is a bit confusing. He's introduced as a staunch rule follower that's training to be a Warden, but he's easily swayed into a heist where they steal a mule and kill a man in the process. Only Alys is effected by the murder. Later, Griff says he wants to continue his Warden training in order to take heat off of Mal.
Lastly, the location of Griff's wound. Why was his chest being wrapped in the beginning if his wound was bisecting his beltline?
All in all, I wish I had a solid trio of friends like that! Watching them let go of their preconceived notions of what the other "should" be and instead fall in love with the scarred and lived version in front of them was a rewarding experience.
A few critiques:
The storyline was hard to get into at first due to the present and background sharing feeling a little convoluted.
Mal tumbles right into sex with Griff after saying that he's never thought of another man that way... considering his wary and jaded nature that felt like a big jump. (not that I'm complaining! :P)
Griff's moral compass is a bit confusing. He's introduced as a staunch rule follower that's training to be a Warden, but he's easily swayed into a heist where they steal a mule and kill a man in the process. Only Alys is effected by the murder. Later, Griff says he wants to continue his Warden training in order to take heat off of Mal.
Lastly, the location of Griff's wound. Why was his chest being wrapped in the beginning if his wound was bisecting his beltline?
All in all, I wish I had a solid trio of friends like that! Watching them let go of their preconceived notions of what the other "should" be and instead fall in love with the scarred and lived version in front of them was a rewarding experience.
August 24, 2025
★★★★★ I devoured this book and loved every minute
This was such a fun, emotional ride. Our Rogue Fates has everything I love in a fantasy: a rich, eerie setting (Rotrose Mire is basically its own character), a treasure hunt full of danger and magic, and two ex-best-friends with ridiculous chemistry trying not to kill each other—or fall back in love.
Griff and Mal are messy and complicated in the best way. Their banter made me laugh, their tension made me yell at the pages, and their slow-burn romance had me fully invested. I also really appreciated how the story explored grief, loyalty, and second chances without ever feeling heavy-handed.
Sarah Glenn Marsh’s writing is vivid and sharp, and the pacing kept me hooked from start to finish. I didn’t want it to end, and now I need everyone I know to read it so we can scream about it together.
If you’re into queer fantasy with heart, heat, and haunted swamps—this one’s a must.
This was such a fun, emotional ride. Our Rogue Fates has everything I love in a fantasy: a rich, eerie setting (Rotrose Mire is basically its own character), a treasure hunt full of danger and magic, and two ex-best-friends with ridiculous chemistry trying not to kill each other—or fall back in love.
Griff and Mal are messy and complicated in the best way. Their banter made me laugh, their tension made me yell at the pages, and their slow-burn romance had me fully invested. I also really appreciated how the story explored grief, loyalty, and second chances without ever feeling heavy-handed.
Sarah Glenn Marsh’s writing is vivid and sharp, and the pacing kept me hooked from start to finish. I didn’t want it to end, and now I need everyone I know to read it so we can scream about it together.
If you’re into queer fantasy with heart, heat, and haunted swamps—this one’s a must.
September 1, 2025
There is so much to love about this book. Not only was there an immediate hook into the plot itself, but it took no time at all to fall in love with the characters. I’m pretty sure I imprinted on Mal 2.5 seconds into reading his first chapter. There’s an impressive array of side characters (love seeing strong female leads) but the true stars of this book are Griff and Mal. The pining, oh my goodness. I loved every second of their romance, and can see so much potential for future adventures and books. The prose was beautifully written, the romance heartbreakingly tender, and the characters bruised in ways that make them relatable. Too often in fantasy stories it’s easy to lose track of the people and care more about the adventure— not so with this. Our Rogue Fates was a lovely blend of plot and character based story and I will absolutely be back for anything more the author writes.
October 14, 2025
Friends to enemies! enemies to lovers! LBGTQIA! kissing!?! I'll have what she's having
The plot to this book is overall very cute and the themes of redemption and friendship are so sweet. I love books about forgiveness even though they inevitably make me ugly cry. The characters in the book are men with big feelings and that's not all that's big - JK I'm so sorry. But on that note, personally, I enjoyed the romance more than the adventure/fantasy elements but hey I'm just a girl. Thank you to the author and Netgalley for sending me this book to review, it was a fun read!
The plot to this book is overall very cute and the themes of redemption and friendship are so sweet. I love books about forgiveness even though they inevitably make me ugly cry. The characters in the book are men with big feelings and that's not all that's big - JK I'm so sorry. But on that note, personally, I enjoyed the romance more than the adventure/fantasy elements but hey I'm just a girl. Thank you to the author and Netgalley for sending me this book to review, it was a fun read!
August 27, 2025
I loved this book! Friends to enemies to lovers through an adventure to find treasure.
I loved the sweet moments between Mal and Griff, and Alys was the perfect side character to accompany them.
The world building was great, though I would’ve loved to see more from this world, I feel like we saw different kinds of enemies but it would’ve been cool to see more of other kinds too!
Overall a very enjoyable read!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC!
I loved the sweet moments between Mal and Griff, and Alys was the perfect side character to accompany them.
The world building was great, though I would’ve loved to see more from this world, I feel like we saw different kinds of enemies but it would’ve been cool to see more of other kinds too!
Overall a very enjoyable read!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC!
Read
August 21, 2025I genuinely thought I was going to like this. Not because of the lord of the rings marketing, but just because it seemed like something I would enjoy, but that was not the case.
I don't like DNFing books in general, much less ARCs, but I honestly am not invested at all. I will be upfront and say that I didn't get very far into Our Rogue Fates, so if it sounds interesting to you give it a chance, it might be a good for for you.
My main problems are: I don't feel connected to the characters, positively or otherwise, which is a thing I always look for in a book and the language for some reason bothered me, I guess I'm just not a fan of the author's writing style. Those are the two main reasons.
I still have a lot of time to finish it, so I might eventually try it again, but I'll put it down for now.
I don't like DNFing books in general, much less ARCs, but I honestly am not invested at all. I will be upfront and say that I didn't get very far into Our Rogue Fates, so if it sounds interesting to you give it a chance, it might be a good for for you.
My main problems are: I don't feel connected to the characters, positively or otherwise, which is a thing I always look for in a book and the language for some reason bothered me, I guess I'm just not a fan of the author's writing style. Those are the two main reasons.
I still have a lot of time to finish it, so I might eventually try it again, but I'll put it down for now.
November 5, 2025
I was provided an ARC copy of this, but my opinions are my own. This is a MM romantasy, and as soon as I read it, knew that this would become one of my favorite books of 2025. Griff, Mal, Alys and the rest of the cast are all characters that became friends once I finished reading the book. No spoilers of course, but this is the story of Griff and Mal, childhood friends who had a serious misunderstanding and now hide their feelings for each other under the guise of fighting every chance they get. When they get roped into a quest by their mutual friend, Alys, Griff and Mal realize that sometimes, second chances are needed to get to a HEA.
I really enjoyed this, and I hope you do too! It doesn't release until April 2026, so mark your calendars. :)
I really enjoyed this, and I hope you do too! It doesn't release until April 2026, so mark your calendars. :)
September 8, 2025
2⭐
I guess... (Side note: justice for my boy Liam)
I'm not sure how to feel about this one... I'll admit, there are some steamy scenes, but I just don't really get the chemistry between the two MC's. I like the world building, but there are a lot of expositional bits that I was sort of overwhelmed with. For example, you're not only getting the backstory of the characters, but you're also getting backstory of the world and its lore; it's a lot to digest all at once.
I think my biggest nitpick with this work is the writing style. I'm sorry, but if I'm reading a work that is meant to be fantasy - existing in a fantastical, non-realistic, type of world - I don't really know if they'd still use words like "ex" or "boyfriend", maybe "once-lover" or "partner", something that reinforces the fantasy world. (Don't even get me started on me spiraling of the inclusion of the word "underwear" in this book...) To that point, I'd also say that a lot of the dialogue and the situations run a little too contemporary; I'm not saying it has to be like George R.R. Martin, but just some word and phrase changes would have kept me engaged, rather than feeling like this was meant to be a romance that they shoe-horned into the fantasy genre, not an actual romantasy.
I wish I could say I liked this one more; I had very high hopes based on the blurb and the cover art being so gorgeous. Sadly, I just don't think this one is for me. But, I am a harsh critic, I'll admit, so if you're feeling adventurous: give this one a shot.
Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an ARC of this novel!
I guess... (Side note: justice for my boy Liam)
I'm not sure how to feel about this one... I'll admit, there are some steamy scenes, but I just don't really get the chemistry between the two MC's. I like the world building, but there are a lot of expositional bits that I was sort of overwhelmed with. For example, you're not only getting the backstory of the characters, but you're also getting backstory of the world and its lore; it's a lot to digest all at once.
I think my biggest nitpick with this work is the writing style. I'm sorry, but if I'm reading a work that is meant to be fantasy - existing in a fantastical, non-realistic, type of world - I don't really know if they'd still use words like "ex" or "boyfriend", maybe "once-lover" or "partner", something that reinforces the fantasy world. (Don't even get me started on me spiraling of the inclusion of the word "underwear" in this book...) To that point, I'd also say that a lot of the dialogue and the situations run a little too contemporary; I'm not saying it has to be like George R.R. Martin, but just some word and phrase changes would have kept me engaged, rather than feeling like this was meant to be a romance that they shoe-horned into the fantasy genre, not an actual romantasy.
I wish I could say I liked this one more; I had very high hopes based on the blurb and the cover art being so gorgeous. Sadly, I just don't think this one is for me. But, I am a harsh critic, I'll admit, so if you're feeling adventurous: give this one a shot.
Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove Press for an ARC of this novel!
August 15, 2025
Gay Lord of the Rings?? Sign me up! From the characters to the scenery to the adventure to the love for dogs, this one had it all!
September 29, 2025
Review to come but amazing
January 8, 2026
I absolutely loved this book. It made me feel the way I felt as a kid reading fantasy novels. It was silly and funny, but also had emotional depth, complex characters, and a well-handled touch of adult topics such as addiction and self harm. I did not get bored once reading this book, which is rare for me.
I thoroughly enjoyed the fantasy elements, laughing out loud at some of the shenanigans of the Rogues crew. This is not a book to be taken too seriously- the characters are morally grey and this is fantasy, after all.
Perfect for queers who like DND and emotionally constipated men of ambiguous moral standards. There is a huge character arc for both MCs, with lots of emotional growth to be enjoyed.
Technically speaking, the author’s writing style is great. Easy to read, engaging, and with the perfect amount of description to keep the imagination flowing. I can tell the author wrote this book with passion and real life experience behind her.
(I received this book for free as an advanced copy, in exchange for an honest review)
I thoroughly enjoyed the fantasy elements, laughing out loud at some of the shenanigans of the Rogues crew. This is not a book to be taken too seriously- the characters are morally grey and this is fantasy, after all.
Perfect for queers who like DND and emotionally constipated men of ambiguous moral standards. There is a huge character arc for both MCs, with lots of emotional growth to be enjoyed.
Technically speaking, the author’s writing style is great. Easy to read, engaging, and with the perfect amount of description to keep the imagination flowing. I can tell the author wrote this book with passion and real life experience behind her.
(I received this book for free as an advanced copy, in exchange for an honest review)
October 5, 2025
Mal and Griff were best friends who grew up together years ago but one falling out has caused them to not speak for years. After Griff nearly dies from an attack planed by Mal's boss, Mal makes a deal to hunt for a treasure to free both Griff and himself from his boss' attention. So the two, along with their other old friend Alys, set off into Rotrose Mire on a quest for this treasure.
I do have to start by saying justice for Liam, he just wanted to live with his hot boyfriend and his dog and Mal messed that all up. Too bad Griff's heart always belonged to Mal.
I really enjoyed that this story had a lot of humor throughout. Mal, Griff and Alys all have a little bit of silliness to them. The banter among the three were great and fun to read. Mal and Griff had some great chemistry and it was a pleasure to watch them work on their communication as the story unfolded.
It appears that this quest was doomed from the start for the gang as everything seemed to go wrong that could. There was a lot of action and the story had a fast pace. There was also quite a bit of really nice spice. These guys don't let the environment or a few wounds slow them down.
Also, shout out to Little Griff/Prancer, the real MVP of the quest!
Spicy, fun and sweet this book was a lot of fun and I really recommend it for anyone who loves fantasy and adventure!
Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I do have to start by saying justice for Liam, he just wanted to live with his hot boyfriend and his dog and Mal messed that all up. Too bad Griff's heart always belonged to Mal.
I really enjoyed that this story had a lot of humor throughout. Mal, Griff and Alys all have a little bit of silliness to them. The banter among the three were great and fun to read. Mal and Griff had some great chemistry and it was a pleasure to watch them work on their communication as the story unfolded.
It appears that this quest was doomed from the start for the gang as everything seemed to go wrong that could. There was a lot of action and the story had a fast pace. There was also quite a bit of really nice spice. These guys don't let the environment or a few wounds slow them down.
Also, shout out to Little Griff/Prancer, the real MVP of the quest!
Spicy, fun and sweet this book was a lot of fun and I really recommend it for anyone who loves fantasy and adventure!
Thank you NetGalley and Alcove Press for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 16, 2025
Thank you so much to the author and the publisher, Alcove Press, for sharing an ARC of this book with me on NetGalley!!!
“He had figured out how to survive in the dark a long time ago. Alone”
“Who knows? Out in the Mire, you might even find out whether I’d die for you”
I loved it!!! Incredibly sweet, intense, action driven, magical and hopeful !!! Hidden treasures, fighting for their lives and dealing with the worst kind of monsters to protect those they love. That’s the kind of main characters we love in books. And Griff and Mal are no exception. I loved loved loved their story. I loved the way it started. I loved the way it grew. And the way they both did. But most of all, I loved them. I loved Griff and his unending hope for a love that he feels is unrequited. I loved Mal and his deep and unrelenting sense of unworthiness towards others. HSI sense of being cursed. And his love for Griff regardless of how hard he tries to deny it. Well, there are some truths that only forced proximity is going to reveal. And when they find themselves on a hunt for a treasure … closed quarters are intense and spicy !!! I enjoyed this book so so much !!! And I’m so glad I had a chance to read it !!!
“Bet I can make you forget your own name … But you’re always going to remember mine”
“Tell me all those pretty words tomorrow, too. Stay with me, no matter how much it hurts”
“He had figured out how to survive in the dark a long time ago. Alone”
“Who knows? Out in the Mire, you might even find out whether I’d die for you”
I loved it!!! Incredibly sweet, intense, action driven, magical and hopeful !!! Hidden treasures, fighting for their lives and dealing with the worst kind of monsters to protect those they love. That’s the kind of main characters we love in books. And Griff and Mal are no exception. I loved loved loved their story. I loved the way it started. I loved the way it grew. And the way they both did. But most of all, I loved them. I loved Griff and his unending hope for a love that he feels is unrequited. I loved Mal and his deep and unrelenting sense of unworthiness towards others. HSI sense of being cursed. And his love for Griff regardless of how hard he tries to deny it. Well, there are some truths that only forced proximity is going to reveal. And when they find themselves on a hunt for a treasure … closed quarters are intense and spicy !!! I enjoyed this book so so much !!! And I’m so glad I had a chance to read it !!!
“Bet I can make you forget your own name … But you’re always going to remember mine”
“Tell me all those pretty words tomorrow, too. Stay with me, no matter how much it hurts”
September 12, 2025
Sarah Glenn Marsh’s Our Rogue Fates offers readers a lush blend of queer romantasy, heroic questing, and emotional reckoning. Set in a richly imagined world, the story centres on Griff Sayer and Mal Pryce — once best friends, now adversaries — who are forced back into each other's lives when a shared dangerous quest and a missing treasure destabilize the past they tried to leave behind.
One of the novel’s greatest strengths lies in its emotional core. Griff, who is training as a Warden and holds his father’s heroic legacy over his head; Mal, working dangerous odd jobs for gain; and their mutual friend Alys — all carry scars from betrayal, guilt, and loss. As the plot unfolds, Marsh allows these personalities to come apart and be patched together in compelling ways. The “enemies‐to‐lovers” arc feels earned: the tension between Griff and Mal is frequently raw, and their journey forces them to confront what went wrong, both in external threats and internal expectations.
The world‐building also largely succeeds. The swampy Rotrose Mire, cursed relics, haunted woods, and shady boss plots deliver enough fantasy adventure to satisfy those who enjoy a journey as much as the romance. Marsh paints vivid landscapes and perilous threats, which raise the stakes beyond simply romantic tension. The book also benefits from its queer‐normative setting, where LGBTQ+ identities are integrated into the world without being the only thing defining the characters.
That said, there are a few areas where the novel falls just short of perfection. The pacing, especially early on, can feel uneven: much time is spent circling past misunderstandings and emotional grudges before the plot fully gets underway. For some readers, this may make the early chapters drag. Relatedly, while Griff and Mal’s conflict is credible, sometimes their misunderstandings feel more like missed opportunities for communication than deep thematic conflict — the “why didn’t you say that earlier?” frustration is hard to shake.
Also, while the supporting cast is strong in concept, a few secondary characters (beyond Alys in particular) don’t always break free of trope: allies and enemies are sometimes a bit too easily categorized, and some motivations—especially from antagonistic forces—could have been more developed to lend more moral ambiguity. Given how much Marsh leans into the “shades of grey” elements, this is a missed opportunity in spots.
Conclusion: Our Rogue Fates is a thoroughly enjoyable read, especially for fans of romantic fantasy with emotional complexity and adventure. Its portrayal of friendship, hurt, and reconciliation is powerful, and the romantic arc of Griff and Mal is compelling. While the pacing and under‐used potential for richer moral ambiguity hold it back from being truly outstanding, it more than makes up for those flaws with heart, atmosphere, and satisfying growth. Four stars.
One of the novel’s greatest strengths lies in its emotional core. Griff, who is training as a Warden and holds his father’s heroic legacy over his head; Mal, working dangerous odd jobs for gain; and their mutual friend Alys — all carry scars from betrayal, guilt, and loss. As the plot unfolds, Marsh allows these personalities to come apart and be patched together in compelling ways. The “enemies‐to‐lovers” arc feels earned: the tension between Griff and Mal is frequently raw, and their journey forces them to confront what went wrong, both in external threats and internal expectations.
The world‐building also largely succeeds. The swampy Rotrose Mire, cursed relics, haunted woods, and shady boss plots deliver enough fantasy adventure to satisfy those who enjoy a journey as much as the romance. Marsh paints vivid landscapes and perilous threats, which raise the stakes beyond simply romantic tension. The book also benefits from its queer‐normative setting, where LGBTQ+ identities are integrated into the world without being the only thing defining the characters.
That said, there are a few areas where the novel falls just short of perfection. The pacing, especially early on, can feel uneven: much time is spent circling past misunderstandings and emotional grudges before the plot fully gets underway. For some readers, this may make the early chapters drag. Relatedly, while Griff and Mal’s conflict is credible, sometimes their misunderstandings feel more like missed opportunities for communication than deep thematic conflict — the “why didn’t you say that earlier?” frustration is hard to shake.
Also, while the supporting cast is strong in concept, a few secondary characters (beyond Alys in particular) don’t always break free of trope: allies and enemies are sometimes a bit too easily categorized, and some motivations—especially from antagonistic forces—could have been more developed to lend more moral ambiguity. Given how much Marsh leans into the “shades of grey” elements, this is a missed opportunity in spots.
Conclusion: Our Rogue Fates is a thoroughly enjoyable read, especially for fans of romantic fantasy with emotional complexity and adventure. Its portrayal of friendship, hurt, and reconciliation is powerful, and the romantic arc of Griff and Mal is compelling. While the pacing and under‐used potential for richer moral ambiguity hold it back from being truly outstanding, it more than makes up for those flaws with heart, atmosphere, and satisfying growth. Four stars.
October 15, 2025
I loved loved loved this book so much. The characters were so real and so raw, and so were the relationships. This book deals with addiction, guilt, and trauma in such a raw and honest way that makes you connect with the characters in a personal level. None of them are perfect, and that is the whole point!! Growth and new beginnings are huge themes in this story, and by the end of it, you can see how much the characters have grown and changed, both together and as individuals.
This book had all the makings of a classic fantasy and so much more. It felt like stepping into a much loved DND campaign and I felt like I was right there along with our main trio. Their misadventures in the mire were so fun to experience as a reader. A lot of it had a nostalgic feel, and that is what made this such a good story.
This is easily going to be one of my top books of 2026, so
I highly recommend everyone put this on their tbr! It will absolutely not disappoint!
As always, thank you to the author for providing this arc!
This book had all the makings of a classic fantasy and so much more. It felt like stepping into a much loved DND campaign and I felt like I was right there along with our main trio. Their misadventures in the mire were so fun to experience as a reader. A lot of it had a nostalgic feel, and that is what made this such a good story.
This is easily going to be one of my top books of 2026, so
I highly recommend everyone put this on their tbr! It will absolutely not disappoint!
As always, thank you to the author for providing this arc!
August 30, 2025
The most stabbings and revenants I've read in a cozy romance, but it so works. The world building was so interesting, and I want to know more about the elves, the Wardens, the Shadow Queen, all of it. I would read a dozen spin-offs to absorb this world. The character growth of and between Mal and Griff was so real and so satisfying. There were moments that felt rushed, but nothing took away from the overall delight I had in reading this book. I will definitely be recommending this book to others as it is heartwarming, engaging, and leaves so much more to be explored. Thank you NetGalley for allowing me to review this book as an ARC reader!
October 28, 2025
"Our Rogue Fates" was such a fun and steamy read. I had the honor of acquiring an advanced reader copy ahead of release.
Mal took the place of my favorite character right off the bat, and I enjoyed following his journey through the Mire with Griff and Alys. Mal and Griff were very nuanced and felt like real people - it was both wonderful and horrible watching them stumble through their trauma and budding relationship. The supporting characters had some depth to them to make them stand out - Alys, Wynnie, and Liam were certainly memorable for their actions and how they impacted the story as a whole. There were times that I wish we spent more time with Alys exploring her history and character arc, but what we did get to see was lovely.
The world is unique and has a lot more to explore than just what we see with the trio's journey. I'm hoping more stories will be told in this world one day! I'd love to learn more about the other races, as well as the Shadow Queen and her forces.
All in all, a very enjoyable read!
Mal took the place of my favorite character right off the bat, and I enjoyed following his journey through the Mire with Griff and Alys. Mal and Griff were very nuanced and felt like real people - it was both wonderful and horrible watching them stumble through their trauma and budding relationship. The supporting characters had some depth to them to make them stand out - Alys, Wynnie, and Liam were certainly memorable for their actions and how they impacted the story as a whole. There were times that I wish we spent more time with Alys exploring her history and character arc, but what we did get to see was lovely.
The world is unique and has a lot more to explore than just what we see with the trio's journey. I'm hoping more stories will be told in this world one day! I'd love to learn more about the other races, as well as the Shadow Queen and her forces.
All in all, a very enjoyable read!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 174 reviews