Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

When The Stranger Calls

Rate this book
WHEN THE STRANGER CALLS
She thought the worst had already happened. She was wrong.

Twenty-year-old Hollis Johnson has spent the last four years cleaning up after her mother's collapse. Babysitting for neighbors pays the bills, and pretending everything is fine has become second nature.

But when her phone rings late one night and a distorted voice says, "You deserve better," Hollis starts to realize someone is watching. Her mom has been getting the same calls. Maybe for years. And now, the caller wants Hollis too.

Grant Hawthorne is the perfect single dad. Polite. Grieving. A little too available. What really happened to his wife? And why does he always show up when Hollis needs help?

As neighbors go missing and secrets pile up, Hollis will have to decide who to trust before the next call is the last.

A slow-burn psychological thriller with small-town tension, dark romance, and a final reveal that changes everything.

ARC copies available now.
If you're a reviewer, blogger, or bookstagrammer interested in an early copy, request here: salemhurleybooks@gmail
Digital delivery. No pressure to review, but no spoilers either.

168 pages, ebook

First published August 3, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Salem Hurley

13 books31 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
25 (69%)
4 stars
8 (22%)
3 stars
1 (2%)
2 stars
2 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews
Profile Image for Heather Greer.
201 reviews15 followers
August 5, 2025
Omg, what did I just read? This was a quick, on the edge of your seat, addictive book! I love psychological thrillers and most of the time I can guess what will happen at the end. But not this one. I DID NOT see this one coming. I thought I had it all figured out and then my jaw hit the floor. Great job Salem! You really kept me in suspense and can’t wait to read more of your books!
329 reviews14 followers
August 16, 2025
"When The Stranger Calls" by Salem Hurley is a gripping and haunting novel that masterfully blends elements of psychological suspense and slow-burn romance. The story follows Hollis Johnson, a 20-year-old who has spent years cleaning up after her mother's collapse, and her life takes a dark turn when she starts receiving mysterious and threatening phone calls.

Key Themes:

• Obsession and Control: The novel explores the themes of obsession and control, keeping readers on the edge of their seats with its tense and suspenseful plot.
• Psychological Suspense: Hurley's writing style is atmospheric and engaging, making it easy to become invested in Hollis's story and the dark secrets that unfold.
• Romantic Tension: The slow-burn romance adds an extra layer of complexity to the story, keeping readers guessing about the characters' motivations and relationships.

What to Expect:

• A haunting and suspenseful plot with unexpected twists and turns
• Complex characters with deep backstories and motivations
• A blend of psychological suspense and romance that keeps readers engaged

Rating: 4.5/5 stars

If you enjoy authors like A.R. Torre, Lisa Jewell, or Minka Kent, you'll likely appreciate Salem Hurley's writing style and the themes explored in "When The Stranger Calls". This novel is perfect for fans of psychological thrillers and suspenseful stories with a touch of romance
Profile Image for Scout Yarbrough.
8 reviews
August 7, 2025
Do you like psychological horror? Do you enjoy plot twists that will make you scream and rethink everything you’ve done in life? Well… that might be an overreaction, but it’ll make you reread to find out the holes you missed.
Well look no further than Salem Hurley’s “When the Stranger Calls”. I picked it up and literally could not put it down until I finished it. It has some calm before the storm moments, full of suspense, but nothing gory. I’m talking to you, you over there who doesn’t like to read all the bloody parts. There’s just enough to build your imagination and mess with your mind.
You know what you should do? Get this book and read it. Don’t let me be alone in the ending, I screamed, I had to reread it and process what I read. So I think you should too lol.
And as the lovely Salem said “the villain never thinks they’re the villain”.
Profile Image for Crystal .
509 reviews42 followers
September 24, 2025
When the Stranger Calls was everything I love in a psychological thriller.. that tension, eerie atmosphere, and twists that had me questioning everyone.
Hollis’s story pulled me in right away. Between caring for her mom, navigating the unsettling phone calls, and being drawn toward the too-perfect neighbor, I couldn’t stop turning the pages. The small-town paranoia, the creeping dread, and the way the romance threaded through all the danger made this impossible to put down.

Salem Hurley delivers once again. Every book I’ve read from her has been fantastic, and this one just cements why she will be an auto-buy for me. If you love dark, twisty thrillers with emotional depth and an ending that leaves you reeling, this one’s for you.
Profile Image for Rhiannon Cheyenne .
579 reviews16 followers
August 24, 2025
When the Stranger Calls - Salem Hurley

I love psychological thrillers and just thrillers in general. I was on the edge of my seat the entire time reading this book. My jaw dropped when I read the ending. I also really enjoyed the authors note at the end of the book where the author says that the villain never thinks they’re the villain and I think that really encompasses the phone caller in this book. I need to read more books like this. I really enjoyed this author’s writing and I hope they write more thrillers.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / Out of 5 Stars ⭐️

Format 💫 Gifted Digital Copy

Series 🌙 Unknown/Not Applicable

Genre/Tropes ✨ psychological thriller, thriller, horror, suspense, slow burn romance, obsession, romantic tension
Profile Image for Lauren Head.
830 reviews26 followers
October 18, 2025
This book was fast-paced, gripping, and completely addictive! I love psychological thrillers, and usually, I can predict the ending… but not this time. I did not see that twist coming. Just when I thought I had it all figured out, the story completely floored me. Amazing job, Salem! You kept me on edge the entire time, and I can’t wait to read more of your work!
Profile Image for Mattie Riley.
264 reviews20 followers
October 26, 2025
Salem, you have absolutely done it AGAIN. First thriller I've read in a while, and by you, and holy hell was I absolutely IN IT. It was the perfect amount of suspenseful, the perfect amount of sweet, and a whole lot of WTF. The ending???? Baffled, I tell you. Absolutely baffled and satisfied. I absolutely loved it!
Profile Image for Rian Eidson ~ Literary Luna Moth.
77 reviews4 followers
December 16, 2025
Quick, surprising story

Cue Cardi B sound bit “that’s suspicious…that’s weird” 😂 cause that’s all that was running through my head the whole time I was reading this book. I thought I knew how it would turn it out, I should have never assumed I knew anything cause I was dead wrong.
Profile Image for Emily C.
1 review
August 8, 2025
I’ll give this 3.5 stars. It was a fun and easy read, and the MMC’s children were so sweet. It’s still in editing, and it does need quite a bit more of that. I’m going to read it again when it’s fully complete and see if my mind changes at all.
Profile Image for Amanda.
90 reviews2 followers
August 9, 2025
Oh this is one of another greqt books from this author. it had me like oh damn I cant believe it. I had a sinking suspicion and turns out I was right. love independent woman. such a great book I want more from her.
Profile Image for Harley.
648 reviews26 followers
October 9, 2025
Well let’s just call this a m!ndfuck of sorts shall we

I love salems books I swear but that ending. Yeah umm Hollis you got some splaining to do or maybe not because I don’t want to be an accomplice

But this was very interesting and very you didn’t see that coming

Highly recommend
Profile Image for Lindsey.
1 review
August 28, 2025
Same day finished, LOVED IT!❤️ The suspense but also the plot twist like what? 👀🤭
Profile Image for Syn Daye.
Author 2 books18 followers
August 15, 2025
I want to give this more stars. All I have to say is @salem_hurley WTF was that??

This story is well written, and you can feel the pull between Hollis and Grant. It feels natural, normal even, despite the age difference. He is her rock in life, especially when her alcoholic mother certainly doesn't offer a stable foundation.

The mystery caller affects her mother deeply and pushes her towards sobriety. All the while, the neighbourhood is experiencing 2 seemingly random and unexplained murders. The police look to Grant. Hollis can't help but wonder if she can or should trust him. She knows he was questioned regarding his wife's death. Did he actually kill Jill? Is she safe? Are the kids?

Salem leads you down a garden path full of hope, longing,and love...and a cliff, which she flings you right over. Run, don't walk, to get this book.
Profile Image for thriftlibreads.
229 reviews2 followers
March 5, 2026
I did not see that twist coming! Let alone the events in the future! What?! I for sure thought it was going to be someone else behind it all. It was the perfect short read.
Profile Image for Sabrina Bright.
254 reviews2 followers
January 8, 2026
Wow!

This was a fast easy and enjoyable read. I spent some time trying to figure Out what was going on and who was responsible for everything. When the twist came at the end, I did not see it! Absolutely excellent book.
Profile Image for Caitlin.
82 reviews
August 5, 2025
Rating: 3.5 stars

This was an interesting read. Hollis, our FMC, is a young adult working as a babysitter while she navigates living with a drunken mother and fighting her attraction to the DILF next door while dodging her shady ex. The story itself is fairly simple - not a lot of characters to follow, not a ton of locations to know or memorize, and not many filler moments. We focus pretty much on the FMC and her immediate bubble of people within the small confines of maybe 3 or 4 neighbors total. This is a decently paced book; it only took a couple hours to get to the end but I didn't find my attention wandering or struggle to focus on what was happening. Could some things be fleshed out a little more? Yes. Did I feel like I was significantly missing anything? No. It's not a heavy, super intense psychological plot that will make you want to curl into your blanket and keep the lights on when you go to bed, but the twist at the end is good though not shocking once you get there. The ending was probably the creepiest part for me (the epilogues where we get to see our characters matured into their new lives). The DILF also made my hackles raise as we see more and more of him. I don't want to say much more because of spoilers so will wrap up here.

This was a palette cleanse read for me and a nice swap from the fantasy I've been immersed in lately. It was a nice read and I will be looking at more work from this author.

Warning points:
Alcoholism
Grooming
Emotional manipulation

Profile Image for Trish Wrathall.
124 reviews11 followers
October 21, 2025
The whole book, I was convinced I knew what was happening just to be smacked at the end with a truth I wasn't ready for! Holy Hannah. This is my 3rd Salem Hurley book and believe me, I am Running to read something else of hers.
Hollis broke my heart with the weight of everything she was handling.
Grant sounds like an absolute dream
Jared is your typical boyfriend for a teen determined to do what they want.
Which person is hiding a truth in plain sight? Come read and have your mind blown to smithereens!
Profile Image for Casey.
1 review1 follower
August 8, 2025
Great read! Nicely paced book that you can easily follow and like any good mystery, you are never quite sure who to let into your heart. Satisfying ending! Looking forward to reading Salem Hurley’s next one!
Profile Image for Josh Stewart.
102 reviews2 followers
January 5, 2026
eh ok read

This was more of a mystery wrapped in a love story. As a thriller reader, by the title and cover it had me intrigued, but just was ok.
Profile Image for Batty Squeaks.
101 reviews1 follower
October 12, 2026
Oh...just...wow...I did not expect that at all! Amazing story! I don't want to say too much cause damn.

Read it if you like a mystery, a twist, and a loving family!
Profile Image for Madison.
174 reviews3 followers
October 24, 2025
*I received an ARC of this and in no way has that influenced my opinion of this book*

This was an enjoyable easy read.
It was a quick, fast paced, mystery, psychological thriller.

The way this was written, gave up just enough information where you speculate who is doing the k!lls but not enough where it's a dead giveaway. I was pleasantly surprised with the ending.

I would say that this is a great little introduction into psychological thrillers for those new to the genre.
Displaying 1 - 22 of 22 reviews