What do you think?
Rate this book
The Wrong Kind of Perfect: A Picture Perfect Life, with a Perfectly Wrong Secret
252 pages, Paperback
Published September 16, 2025
3 people are currently reading
4181 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
September 16, 2025
This debut really hit me in a personal way. On the outside, Natalie has it all together. The perfect house, the hardworking husband, the image of the good mom and wife. The life she has looks secure and stable, yet it leaves her feeling empty and unseen.
I loved how the slow burn unfolded in the story. Since Natalie is still committed when she meets Will Parker, their connection builds quietly and carefully. It's undeniable, but they both know the risks and what they can't stand to lose. I liked how they didn’t just jump into each other. Instead, the pull grew over time until it was impossible to ignore.
One of my favorite parts was the writing itself. I devoured this book in one sitting. The triple POV made such a difference. Seeing into Natalie, Jason, and Will’s perspectives gave the story depth and made me feel for all three of them. None of them were villains. They were just flawed people trying to navigate life, love, and choices that don’t come easy.
The themes were strong. Marriage, motherhood, sisterhood, identity, longing. I especially felt for Natalie as she dealt with the neglect, the loneliness of being taken for granted, and having her career and passion dismissed as just a “hobby.” I also loved how Natalie and Jason didn’t just throw blame at each other. They acknowledged their mistakes and still wanted to put their kids first. The book also shows how the choices and actions we make affect not just us, but also the people we love.
And yes, the ending left me hanging. Just as I was fully immersed, it ended and I wanted book two immediately. I can’t wait to see Natalie rediscover her passion and what’s next for her journey.
I know that this book might not be for everyone, since it tackles issues that may not resonate with all readers. But these are also situations that happen in real life. If you like emotional slow-burn, forbidden romance, this debut is worth picking up.
I loved how the slow burn unfolded in the story. Since Natalie is still committed when she meets Will Parker, their connection builds quietly and carefully. It's undeniable, but they both know the risks and what they can't stand to lose. I liked how they didn’t just jump into each other. Instead, the pull grew over time until it was impossible to ignore.
One of my favorite parts was the writing itself. I devoured this book in one sitting. The triple POV made such a difference. Seeing into Natalie, Jason, and Will’s perspectives gave the story depth and made me feel for all three of them. None of them were villains. They were just flawed people trying to navigate life, love, and choices that don’t come easy.
The themes were strong. Marriage, motherhood, sisterhood, identity, longing. I especially felt for Natalie as she dealt with the neglect, the loneliness of being taken for granted, and having her career and passion dismissed as just a “hobby.” I also loved how Natalie and Jason didn’t just throw blame at each other. They acknowledged their mistakes and still wanted to put their kids first. The book also shows how the choices and actions we make affect not just us, but also the people we love.
And yes, the ending left me hanging. Just as I was fully immersed, it ended and I wanted book two immediately. I can’t wait to see Natalie rediscover her passion and what’s next for her journey.
I know that this book might not be for everyone, since it tackles issues that may not resonate with all readers. But these are also situations that happen in real life. If you like emotional slow-burn, forbidden romance, this debut is worth picking up.
September 15, 2025
"I was stuck in a loop, craving something I couldn't have and hating myself for wanting it." Thank you to the author for the ARC opportunity! Natalie(FMC) meets Will while picking up her kids from school. They are both instantly drawn to each other however, Will's daughter is bffs with Natalie's daughter. This results in Natalie feeling reluctant about her attraction to Will at first, not to mention she has a husband named Jason. The story unfolds through separate POVs from each
character(Natalie, Will and Jason). We see how Natalie and her relationship with Jason has gotten more distant due to his constant traveling for work. Jason seems to recognize their relationship is growing further apart but doesn't act on it until it's revealed what Natalie and Will have been up to while he's away. I enjoyed seeing how vulnerable and forgiving the characters were willing to be. At times it was hard to see each of them struggle the way they did. I loved reading the moments Natalie and Will spent together, plus the way he was able to spark her "hobby" again and indirectly connect her to opportunities. It was great seeing Natalie find herself in the aftermath of it all and get her happy ending after all.
character(Natalie, Will and Jason). We see how Natalie and her relationship with Jason has gotten more distant due to his constant traveling for work. Jason seems to recognize their relationship is growing further apart but doesn't act on it until it's revealed what Natalie and Will have been up to while he's away. I enjoyed seeing how vulnerable and forgiving the characters were willing to be. At times it was hard to see each of them struggle the way they did. I loved reading the moments Natalie and Will spent together, plus the way he was able to spark her "hobby" again and indirectly connect her to opportunities. It was great seeing Natalie find herself in the aftermath of it all and get her happy ending after all.
October 6, 2025
I truly loved how Jillian gave us such a deep and intimate glimpse into each character’s mindset by exploring their unique perspectives. It made the story feel layered and alive, allowing you to really connect with the characters on an emotional level. In my opinion it’s not your typical romance - it was so much more. The story felt raw, vulnerable, and profoundly moving at times, capturing the messy, beautiful complexity of real life and love.
Jillian’s portrayal of Natalie, the main character, as a stay-at-home mother was both powerful and relatable. She captures with honesty and tenderness the feeling of losing pieces of yourself in motherhood, and how isolating the journey can be—even when surrounded by a loving partner and supportive friends. That quiet loneliness, combined with the struggle to hold onto your identity, was written in a way that felt achingly real.
I believe this book will resonate with so many people, especially those who have experienced the silent sacrifices of parenthood or the search for self amid love and responsibility. It’s a story that lingers with you, not just because of the romance, but because of the truths it tells about life, vulnerability, and the resilience of the human spirit.
Jillian’s portrayal of Natalie, the main character, as a stay-at-home mother was both powerful and relatable. She captures with honesty and tenderness the feeling of losing pieces of yourself in motherhood, and how isolating the journey can be—even when surrounded by a loving partner and supportive friends. That quiet loneliness, combined with the struggle to hold onto your identity, was written in a way that felt achingly real.
I believe this book will resonate with so many people, especially those who have experienced the silent sacrifices of parenthood or the search for self amid love and responsibility. It’s a story that lingers with you, not just because of the romance, but because of the truths it tells about life, vulnerability, and the resilience of the human spirit.
October 25, 2025
I almost shelved this book the moment I realized it dealt with infidelity, a trope I usually stay far away from. But curiosity got the better of me, and I decided to give it a chance to understand what truly happens when someone crosses that line. I've always believed that nothing can ever justify cheating and I still stand by that but this story gave me a new perspective on why people make the choices they do.
The author's writing genuinely surprised me. The multiple POVs were beautifully handled, capturing each character's vulnerability and the emotional distance that builds over time. She explores, with so much depth and realism, how relationships evolve once the honeymoon phase fades how love changes, priorities shift, and how the arrival of kids can transform everything-
The storytelling was so immersive that someone who hates the infidelity trope (me ) ended up finishing it in one sitting. That says a lot about how compelling and emotionally layered the writing truly is.
The author's writing genuinely surprised me. The multiple POVs were beautifully handled, capturing each character's vulnerability and the emotional distance that builds over time. She explores, with so much depth and realism, how relationships evolve once the honeymoon phase fades how love changes, priorities shift, and how the arrival of kids can transform everything-
The storytelling was so immersive that someone who hates the infidelity trope (me ) ended up finishing it in one sitting. That says a lot about how compelling and emotionally layered the writing truly is.
September 16, 2025
This is her debut novel! I am already anxiously awaiting the next book due out in November. Thank you Jillian for having me in your arc/street team!
This book is told from the perspective of the 3 main characters. Natalie, Will and Jason.
Natalie is married to Jason. The are struggling to connect with each other. Both have had thoughts of other people outside their marriage.
Natalie and Will meet at the school pick up. Their daughters are best friends! Will feels the connection instantly. Natalie isn’t sure. She loves her husband. But is really certain that he has been cheating on her with Shannon from his workplace. Jason has had thoughts of Shannon and dinner dates that are more than business.
Natalie takes a job helping Will with his house decor. Do they cross the line? Does Jason cross the line? Can their marriage survive! You must read to find out!!
This book is told from the perspective of the 3 main characters. Natalie, Will and Jason.
Natalie is married to Jason. The are struggling to connect with each other. Both have had thoughts of other people outside their marriage.
Natalie and Will meet at the school pick up. Their daughters are best friends! Will feels the connection instantly. Natalie isn’t sure. She loves her husband. But is really certain that he has been cheating on her with Shannon from his workplace. Jason has had thoughts of Shannon and dinner dates that are more than business.
Natalie takes a job helping Will with his house decor. Do they cross the line? Does Jason cross the line? Can their marriage survive! You must read to find out!!
October 20, 2025
I didn’t realize going in that this book involved a cheating trope, which is not my thing, but the way it was handled here wasn’t so bad. The couple had clearly been unhappy for a while, and since both of them strayed in some way, it felt a little more understandable.
That said, I didn’t love how the people around them didn’t discourage the cheating, it almost felt like everyone just accepted it, which made me a bit uncomfortable. Still, the story itself was really enjoyable and easy to read.
I liked that it was told from a triple POV, it gave great insight into each character’s mindset and made it easier to understand and even forgive their choices. The characters were all likeable in their own ways, but I have to say, Natalie and Will just fit better together.
It ended on a cliffhanger, and now I can’t wait to find out what happens in the second book!
That said, I didn’t love how the people around them didn’t discourage the cheating, it almost felt like everyone just accepted it, which made me a bit uncomfortable. Still, the story itself was really enjoyable and easy to read.
I liked that it was told from a triple POV, it gave great insight into each character’s mindset and made it easier to understand and even forgive their choices. The characters were all likeable in their own ways, but I have to say, Natalie and Will just fit better together.
It ended on a cliffhanger, and now I can’t wait to find out what happens in the second book!
November 29, 2025
This book fell right in the middle of the road. The writing style is not bad at all, but I think I did not care for the story itself. Firstly, how is it everyone in these peoples lives are 100% supportive of having an affair? Where is the one person that is like, "you're married, maybe get a divorce first?" Secondly, I couldn't even sympathize with the feelings because I'm not even sure how they fell in love. It feels like there is a lot of depth missing in the characters and how their story is developing.
There is nothing bad about this book at all, but I just wish there was something deeper and that excuses weren't completely rationalized by everyone around on why it's ok to have an affair. Though it is nice to see people that are so supported and not judged for mistakes made.
There is nothing bad about this book at all, but I just wish there was something deeper and that excuses weren't completely rationalized by everyone around on why it's ok to have an affair. Though it is nice to see people that are so supported and not judged for mistakes made.
September 18, 2025
I’ll admit I wasn’t sure if I was going to be able to read this book due to the element of cheating but it was so beautifully written. Natalie and Jason had grown distant in their marriage and temptations arose on both sides. It’s like they were just going through the motions and didn’t realize how they were just drifting along. It made me evaluate my own marriage even though we don’t have those issues.
Will is a better fit for Natalie and her best friend and sister saw it. I loved how supportive they were of her and how they just wanted her to be happy. I really enjoyed the story and look forward to finding out what happens next in book 2!
Will is a better fit for Natalie and her best friend and sister saw it. I loved how supportive they were of her and how they just wanted her to be happy. I really enjoyed the story and look forward to finding out what happens next in book 2!
October 16, 2025
Thank you to Jillian Marie and Booked With The Emily’s for the opportunity to read and review this ARC!
There’s really only one word for this book…phenomenal. It’s such a dose of reality, something that makes you feel real emotion and relate to the characters while you’re reading. Natalie was so relatable for me that it felt it to my core. It was almost scary. I really enjoyed watching her navigate both relationships, and how the author gave us perspectives from everyone involved. The writing style here was just perfect for me, assuring that I will absolutely be picking up more books by this author. Overall, this was a really deep and touching read for me and I absolutely recommend it!
There’s really only one word for this book…phenomenal. It’s such a dose of reality, something that makes you feel real emotion and relate to the characters while you’re reading. Natalie was so relatable for me that it felt it to my core. It was almost scary. I really enjoyed watching her navigate both relationships, and how the author gave us perspectives from everyone involved. The writing style here was just perfect for me, assuring that I will absolutely be picking up more books by this author. Overall, this was a really deep and touching read for me and I absolutely recommend it!
December 17, 2025
Thanks for this complementary story, Happily Booked! I got to meet more of Jillian Marie's characters and was able to fall in love with yet another story ♥
TWKoP explores flawed expectations and genuine connection. Emotional, engaging, and character-driven, this book highlights that neither love nor us have to be perfect to be meaningful, that we are worthy fighting for and that we are as important as anything else.
Natalie was loosing herself with the weight of the 'perfect family' that lay on her shoulders when Will appears in her life... He’s everything she’s not supposed to want — gorgeous, magnetic, and completely off-limits. But their connection is undeniable.
TWKoP explores flawed expectations and genuine connection. Emotional, engaging, and character-driven, this book highlights that neither love nor us have to be perfect to be meaningful, that we are worthy fighting for and that we are as important as anything else.
Natalie was loosing herself with the weight of the 'perfect family' that lay on her shoulders when Will appears in her life... He’s everything she’s not supposed to want — gorgeous, magnetic, and completely off-limits. But their connection is undeniable.
November 13, 2025
The Wrong Kind of Perfect is the right kind of debut!
Natalie’s story portrayed the messy complexities of life and love. There was no hero. There was no villain. There was just raw reality. Of trudging through the trenches, getting to a crossroad and having to decide - stick with the status quo or search for your identity. Not a label to or for others. You. Your OWN label.
The Wrong Kind of Perfect wasn’t just a slow burn romance with a second chance with someone, it was also Natalie to herself.
Beautiful. Personal. Intimate.
Natalie’s story portrayed the messy complexities of life and love. There was no hero. There was no villain. There was just raw reality. Of trudging through the trenches, getting to a crossroad and having to decide - stick with the status quo or search for your identity. Not a label to or for others. You. Your OWN label.
The Wrong Kind of Perfect wasn’t just a slow burn romance with a second chance with someone, it was also Natalie to herself.
Beautiful. Personal. Intimate.
October 8, 2025
4⭐️
ARC Review!!
Thank you Love Story Pr and Jillian Marie for giving me the opportunity to receive this eARC!
Omg I was absolutely hooked with this one!!! This unhappily married woman was a trope I have never read before, which I think is why I was invested in this story. It made it very different from the romances I always read. I think the characters were pretty relatable and likable. Anddd I was so obsessed with their relationship… even though I know I really shouldn't have been.
ARC Review!!
Thank you Love Story Pr and Jillian Marie for giving me the opportunity to receive this eARC!
Omg I was absolutely hooked with this one!!! This unhappily married woman was a trope I have never read before, which I think is why I was invested in this story. It made it very different from the romances I always read. I think the characters were pretty relatable and likable. Anddd I was so obsessed with their relationship… even though I know I really shouldn't have been.
October 10, 2025
I really enjoyed this book. I thought it was a beautifully written story about the complexities of love, marriage, motherhood, identity, and real life issues. This story has three POVs which I felt was done well. I felt connected to the characters and was rooting for Natalie. I can’t wait to read book 2 to continue her story. Great debut.
Thanks to Booked with the Emilys and the author for the gifted advanced reader copy of this book.
Thanks to Booked with the Emilys and the author for the gifted advanced reader copy of this book.
November 11, 2025
Wow ! I was not expecting to be so hooked by this book. The writing is so good so real I just couldn't put it down for long. I think the multiple pov really helped in telling the story and again the writing was so well done. Each pov really added layers and understanding to story. You get a peek into why things like this can happen. Loved the characters and how things progressed slowly over time .
Thank you to the author for a copy all thoughts are my own.
Thank you to the author for a copy all thoughts are my own.
November 16, 2025
This book was definitely out of my comfort zone but was sooo worth it. Cheating tropes usually get a bad rep but I urge all readers to give this a try. It was such a deep book looking at the views from all involved. How marriage with kids and a demanding occupation can put strain on a couple. How quickly things can turn to something more than bargained for. But in the end we still get a HEA. and I'm truly happy for Natalie, she deserves the world
November 17, 2025
This story reflects life. It could be a true story. It's completely believable. A married couple grows apart. He works all the time. He's rarely home. She's on her own with the kids. Their eyes wander. It's not one sided. I love the three POVs. Being able to see all the points of view made me feel for the characters.
Thank you for the early copy of this book. This is my honest and voluntary review.
Thank you for the early copy of this book. This is my honest and voluntary review.
September 16, 2025
Arc review
This book was absolutely amazing the writing style was so perfect that the story’s flow was so perfect that it didn’t feel fast paced or to slow of a pace it was just right. The plot of the story was amazing and I loved the characters this was an absolute masterpiece and I can’t wait to see what else this author has in store for future books
This book was absolutely amazing the writing style was so perfect that the story’s flow was so perfect that it didn’t feel fast paced or to slow of a pace it was just right. The plot of the story was amazing and I loved the characters this was an absolute masterpiece and I can’t wait to see what else this author has in store for future books
December 4, 2025
This summary alone pulled me in. Natalie’s struggle between the life she built and the life she actually wants feels so real. The forbidden pull toward Will gives the story that slow-burn tension I love. It already feels like a heartfelt journey of rediscovering yourself.
September 22, 2025
What I thought was a sweet little RomCom sent me on a trip of Forbidden Romance. This book, wow. I couldn't put it down.
October 10, 2025
A beautiful mess ! You just have to read it !
October 28, 2025
It was awesome
The author's writing genuinely surprised me. The multiple POVs were beautifully handled, capturing each character's vulnerability and the emotional distance that builds over time.
The author's writing genuinely surprised me. The multiple POVs were beautifully handled, capturing each character's vulnerability and the emotional distance that builds over time.
November 30, 2025
Devoured this book! Look forward to reading the next one!
October 22, 2025
Thank you Booked with the Emilys and Jillian Marie for the gifted copy.
I struggled with this book. It started out really strong, but then I realized the whole book was going to be about infidelity. I could not relate to the FMC at all. I did not like the decisions she made and felt like she was immature. I also could not get behind the affair. It was cringey to me and not romantic.
However, I did think the writing style was good. It is fast paced and told from the different POVs, which I enjoyed. I think the author did a good job of depicting how difficult marriage can be and the struggles couples face.
If you don’t mind the cheating trope then you will probably enjoy this book. But again the whole story is about cheating. It isn’t just a portion of the book. Doing let the cute cover fool you.
2.5 stars rounded up to 3.
I struggled with this book. It started out really strong, but then I realized the whole book was going to be about infidelity. I could not relate to the FMC at all. I did not like the decisions she made and felt like she was immature. I also could not get behind the affair. It was cringey to me and not romantic.
However, I did think the writing style was good. It is fast paced and told from the different POVs, which I enjoyed. I think the author did a good job of depicting how difficult marriage can be and the struggles couples face.
If you don’t mind the cheating trope then you will probably enjoy this book. But again the whole story is about cheating. It isn’t just a portion of the book. Doing let the cute cover fool you.
2.5 stars rounded up to 3.
October 27, 2025
Great easy read 3.5 ⭐️- cheating does give me the ick but that is just my own preference
You feel sad for the mom being neglected and cheer for her as she finds herself
He definitely falls hard but you gotta love to hate annoying ex wives
I felt very surface level not a whole lot of character development
The relationship between the two younger girls are sweet
You feel sad for the mom being neglected and cheer for her as she finds herself
He definitely falls hard but you gotta love to hate annoying ex wives
I felt very surface level not a whole lot of character development
The relationship between the two younger girls are sweet
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews