What do you think?
Rate this book
Five Weeks in the Country
From the acclaimed, award-winning author of Reading Like a Writer and Lovers at the Chameleon Club, Paris, 1932 comes an utterly original novel inspired by the strange friendship between Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen and set during the summer when Dickens's family life exploded.
In the summer of 1857, when British newspapers warned of an approaching comet about to destroy the earth, an unusual-looking stranger arrived at Charles Dickens's home, Gad's Hill, in the countryside outside London. Dickens had met Hans Christian Andersen at a dinner party, a decade before, and, in a moment of desperation, had invited him to visit.
The visit did not go well. The eccentric Danish author of classic fairy tales, who barely spoke English, outstayed his welcome and alienated the Dickens household, which included nine children. Even the oblivious, obsessively self-conscious Andersen sensed the increasing tension between Dickens and his unhappy wife, Catherine, but was slow to understand—or to believe—that Dickens had fallen in love with a young actress appearing in his new play. For Andersen, those five weeks were a series of social mistakes and embarrassments but ultimately a lesson in how life's most humbling experiences can be transformed into art.
Five Weeks in the Country, a work of imaginative fiction inspired by actual events, is Francine Prose at her dazzling best.
In the summer of 1857, when British newspapers warned of an approaching comet about to destroy the earth, an unusual-looking stranger arrived at Charles Dickens's home, Gad's Hill, in the countryside outside London. Dickens had met Hans Christian Andersen at a dinner party, a decade before, and, in a moment of desperation, had invited him to visit.
The visit did not go well. The eccentric Danish author of classic fairy tales, who barely spoke English, outstayed his welcome and alienated the Dickens household, which included nine children. Even the oblivious, obsessively self-conscious Andersen sensed the increasing tension between Dickens and his unhappy wife, Catherine, but was slow to understand—or to believe—that Dickens had fallen in love with a young actress appearing in his new play. For Andersen, those five weeks were a series of social mistakes and embarrassments but ultimately a lesson in how life's most humbling experiences can be transformed into art.
Five Weeks in the Country, a work of imaginative fiction inspired by actual events, is Francine Prose at her dazzling best.
304 pages, Hardcover
First published May 5, 2026
About the author
Francine Prose
162 books895 followersFrancine Prose is the author of twenty works of fiction. Her novel A Changed Man won the Dayton Literary Peace Prize, and Blue Angel was a finalist for the National Book Award. Her most recent works of nonfiction include the highly acclaimed Anne Frank: The Book, The Life, The Afterlife, and the New York Times bestseller Reading Like a Writer. The recipient of numerous grants and honors, including a Guggenheim and a Fulbright, a Director's Fellow at the Dorothy and Lewis B. Cullman Center for Scholars and Writers at the New York Public Library, Prose is a former president of PEN American Center, and a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Her most recent book is Lovers at the Chameleon Club, Paris 1932. She lives in New York City.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews
May 14, 2026
Francine Prose sets her novel at Gad's Hill Place in Kent, spring of 1857, inside the crumbling domestic theater of Charles Dickens. A celebrity influencer, celebrated author, and, to his nine children, a father who has replaced love and warmth with a performance of it.
The children, narrating collectively, watch Father’s smile cool toward Mother Catherine. Father reads "A Christmas Carol" aloud every Christmas Eve with all his famous theatrical force, yet after the reading, he sends the family straight to bed, allowing the house to grow damp, the gravies to congeal, and the cat’s taxidermied paw to serve as Mother’s Christmas gift. He has given her the present he wanted for himself.
Into this already volatile domestic arrangement, Europe's most emotionally ungovernable fairy-tale author, Hans Christian Andersen, crashes, literally, through the front hall, collapsing on the Dickenses’ luggage before curling up on the parlor carpet land going to sleep. He arrived a day early, speaks fragmentary English, eats the children's potatoes with gusto, terrifies the dogs by fearing them, and has the servants conspiring against him by the second morning. He was supposed to stay briefly. He stays five weeks.
The children, who despise his "hopeless love for Father," recognize in his longing a grotesque mirror of their own. Both he and they are devotees vying for genuine affection.
Threading through the household chaos is the rumor that a German astronomer has calculated that a comet will destroy the earth on June 15. Father gathers the family, invokes his friend at the Royal Astronomical Society, and announces the odds against catastrophe as one in 281 million. Andersen, who as a child watched a comet from an icy hillside with his gin-sodden mother, remains unconvinced. The children, delighted to have a lever of terror to deploy against their impossible guest, do everything they can to amplify his dread.
Who is actually lying, and to whom, and is the comet hurtling toward the Dickens household astronomical or matrimonial?
Francine Prose takes a famous man at the height of his reputation and stations her camera at the spot where his halo slips.
Dickens spent his career manufacturing sentimental domesticity for a mass audience while dismantling his actual family. Prose catches him in the act.
❤️ 🇮🇱
The children, narrating collectively, watch Father’s smile cool toward Mother Catherine. Father reads "A Christmas Carol" aloud every Christmas Eve with all his famous theatrical force, yet after the reading, he sends the family straight to bed, allowing the house to grow damp, the gravies to congeal, and the cat’s taxidermied paw to serve as Mother’s Christmas gift. He has given her the present he wanted for himself.
Into this already volatile domestic arrangement, Europe's most emotionally ungovernable fairy-tale author, Hans Christian Andersen, crashes, literally, through the front hall, collapsing on the Dickenses’ luggage before curling up on the parlor carpet land going to sleep. He arrived a day early, speaks fragmentary English, eats the children's potatoes with gusto, terrifies the dogs by fearing them, and has the servants conspiring against him by the second morning. He was supposed to stay briefly. He stays five weeks.
The children, who despise his "hopeless love for Father," recognize in his longing a grotesque mirror of their own. Both he and they are devotees vying for genuine affection.
Threading through the household chaos is the rumor that a German astronomer has calculated that a comet will destroy the earth on June 15. Father gathers the family, invokes his friend at the Royal Astronomical Society, and announces the odds against catastrophe as one in 281 million. Andersen, who as a child watched a comet from an icy hillside with his gin-sodden mother, remains unconvinced. The children, delighted to have a lever of terror to deploy against their impossible guest, do everything they can to amplify his dread.
Who is actually lying, and to whom, and is the comet hurtling toward the Dickens household astronomical or matrimonial?
Francine Prose takes a famous man at the height of his reputation and stations her camera at the spot where his halo slips.
Dickens spent his career manufacturing sentimental domesticity for a mass audience while dismantling his actual family. Prose catches him in the act.
❤️ 🇮🇱
June 14, 2026
⭐⭐⭐
Thank you to Harper for the gifted copy.
📖 **Summary**
Inspired by real events, this novel imagines the infamous five week visit Hans Christian Andersen made to Charles Dickens's home in the summer of 1857. What begins as a friendly invitation quickly becomes an uncomfortable stay filled with misunderstandings, social awkwardness, family tension, and growing unhappiness as Andersen unknowingly inserts himself into a household already struggling under the weight of secrets and personal turmoil.
💭 **Review**
This was such an interesting reading experience because it is based on a real life friendship that many people may not even know existed. The idea alone immediately grabbed my attention. Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen spending five uncomfortable weeks together sounds fascinating, and honestly, it was every bit as awkward as I hoped it would be.
Hans Christian Andersen is one of the most socially awkward characters I have read in quite some time. He constantly misses social cues, misunderstands situations, and seems completely unaware of the discomfort he creates around him. There were multiple moments where I found myself cringing for him while also feeling a little sorry for him. It created a strange mix of secondhand embarrassment and sympathy that kept me invested in his story.
At the same time, Dickens is hardly the picture of charm himself. As the story unfolds, it becomes increasingly clear that many people in his household are unhappy. There is tension simmering beneath the surface from the very beginning, and the longer Andersen stays, the harder it becomes to ignore. The family dynamics were often uncomfortable, messy, and surprisingly sad.
What I appreciated most was how Francine Prose captured the emotional atmosphere of the household. There is a constant sense that everyone is pretending things are fine while quietly falling apart underneath. The relationships feel strained, resentments linger in the background, and nearly every interaction carries a layer of discomfort.
This is definitely a slower, character driven novel. Readers looking for a fast paced historical story may struggle with it. The focus here is very much on personalities, observations, conversations, and the complicated relationships between these real historical figures. For me, the strongest aspect was watching these larger than life literary figures reveal themselves as deeply flawed and very human people.
I also enjoyed the historical details woven throughout the story. The setting felt authentic, and I found myself fascinated by how much of the novel was inspired by actual events. Knowing that Andersen really overstayed his welcome made some scenes even more entertaining.
While I appreciated the writing and the historical premise, I never became completely emotionally attached to the characters. In many ways, everyone felt trapped in their own unhappiness, and that melancholy atmosphere occasionally kept me at a distance. Still, it remained a compelling look at friendship, ego, loneliness, family tension, and the stories people tell themselves about who they are.
This ended up being a thoughtful and often uncomfortable novel that offers a unique glimpse into a very unusual literary friendship.
❓ **Would I Recommend?**
Yes, especially for readers who enjoy literary historical fiction, character driven stories, and novels inspired by real people and events. If you are fascinated by authors, complicated relationships, and awkward social situations, there is plenty here to appreciate.
Thank you to Harper for the gifted copy.
📖 **Summary**
Inspired by real events, this novel imagines the infamous five week visit Hans Christian Andersen made to Charles Dickens's home in the summer of 1857. What begins as a friendly invitation quickly becomes an uncomfortable stay filled with misunderstandings, social awkwardness, family tension, and growing unhappiness as Andersen unknowingly inserts himself into a household already struggling under the weight of secrets and personal turmoil.
💭 **Review**
This was such an interesting reading experience because it is based on a real life friendship that many people may not even know existed. The idea alone immediately grabbed my attention. Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen spending five uncomfortable weeks together sounds fascinating, and honestly, it was every bit as awkward as I hoped it would be.
Hans Christian Andersen is one of the most socially awkward characters I have read in quite some time. He constantly misses social cues, misunderstands situations, and seems completely unaware of the discomfort he creates around him. There were multiple moments where I found myself cringing for him while also feeling a little sorry for him. It created a strange mix of secondhand embarrassment and sympathy that kept me invested in his story.
At the same time, Dickens is hardly the picture of charm himself. As the story unfolds, it becomes increasingly clear that many people in his household are unhappy. There is tension simmering beneath the surface from the very beginning, and the longer Andersen stays, the harder it becomes to ignore. The family dynamics were often uncomfortable, messy, and surprisingly sad.
What I appreciated most was how Francine Prose captured the emotional atmosphere of the household. There is a constant sense that everyone is pretending things are fine while quietly falling apart underneath. The relationships feel strained, resentments linger in the background, and nearly every interaction carries a layer of discomfort.
This is definitely a slower, character driven novel. Readers looking for a fast paced historical story may struggle with it. The focus here is very much on personalities, observations, conversations, and the complicated relationships between these real historical figures. For me, the strongest aspect was watching these larger than life literary figures reveal themselves as deeply flawed and very human people.
I also enjoyed the historical details woven throughout the story. The setting felt authentic, and I found myself fascinated by how much of the novel was inspired by actual events. Knowing that Andersen really overstayed his welcome made some scenes even more entertaining.
While I appreciated the writing and the historical premise, I never became completely emotionally attached to the characters. In many ways, everyone felt trapped in their own unhappiness, and that melancholy atmosphere occasionally kept me at a distance. Still, it remained a compelling look at friendship, ego, loneliness, family tension, and the stories people tell themselves about who they are.
This ended up being a thoughtful and often uncomfortable novel that offers a unique glimpse into a very unusual literary friendship.
❓ **Would I Recommend?**
Yes, especially for readers who enjoy literary historical fiction, character driven stories, and novels inspired by real people and events. If you are fascinated by authors, complicated relationships, and awkward social situations, there is plenty here to appreciate.
June 16, 2026
3.4 ⭐️
I love Francine Prose. She was the first author that I ever read who made me question how much perspective plays into truth - or at least what we believe to be true. This book is centered in that question. The book lays out the exact same events three times from three different perspectives: first, the collective consciousness of Charles Dickens’s children; second, Dickens himself, and third, Hans Christian Anderson.
What always sticks out to me about this form of writing is it reminds me how little we know about other people. We are constantly making assumptions about why people do what they do. Books like these remind us that we’re all more similar than we think. We all want to feel chosen, be loved, and generally have good intentions (even if it doesn’t look that way outwardly).
I attended an author talk about this book before reading and it was very cool to hear how much personal experience was put into this book (including the dreaded geranium incident!).
This book is weird. It’s a little slow. But the characters are so lovely to spend some time with. It’s a character study about literary masters. I’m thrilled to have finally returned to read a new Francine Prose.
I love Francine Prose. She was the first author that I ever read who made me question how much perspective plays into truth - or at least what we believe to be true. This book is centered in that question. The book lays out the exact same events three times from three different perspectives: first, the collective consciousness of Charles Dickens’s children; second, Dickens himself, and third, Hans Christian Anderson.
What always sticks out to me about this form of writing is it reminds me how little we know about other people. We are constantly making assumptions about why people do what they do. Books like these remind us that we’re all more similar than we think. We all want to feel chosen, be loved, and generally have good intentions (even if it doesn’t look that way outwardly).
I attended an author talk about this book before reading and it was very cool to hear how much personal experience was put into this book (including the dreaded geranium incident!).
This book is weird. It’s a little slow. But the characters are so lovely to spend some time with. It’s a character study about literary masters. I’m thrilled to have finally returned to read a new Francine Prose.
June 26, 2026
I wanted badly to love this. I admire Francine Prose, and am irredeemably addicted to Dickens’s novels. I already knew about Hans Christian Andersen’s overlong visit to the Dickens family, and was eager to see what a fellow Dickens aficionado and fine writer would do with it in fictional form. The first section describes the visit and the visitor in a collective voice of the 9 Dickens children: they find Andersen just weird and awkward and pushy and mostly wish he would just leave them alone. The second section is Dickens’s own, a close third person take on his extreme discomfort and dislike of Andersen, who barely speaks English, violates all the household conventions and norms, and while he admires and loves Dickens, he’s just very weird about it. This section also drags us into Dickens’s obsessive passion for the teenaged actress Nelly Ternan and through his reprehensible treatment of his poor, desperate, wretched wife. The third section gives Andersen his turn: and you know what? He is creepy, a monster of egotism, in a pathetic, wheedling, whining, way.
Yes,I know Dickens was an overbearing, controlling, demanding, egotistical jerk. Which pains me. Anderson was a jerk too, just in a different way. In fact, there wasn’t a person in this book you’d want to spend an evening with, let alone five weeks. Too little sympathy, too long, just a rather dreary exercise. I finished it, but this one goes on the donation pile. 🥺
Yes,I know Dickens was an overbearing, controlling, demanding, egotistical jerk. Which pains me. Anderson was a jerk too, just in a different way. In fact, there wasn’t a person in this book you’d want to spend an evening with, let alone five weeks. Too little sympathy, too long, just a rather dreary exercise. I finished it, but this one goes on the donation pile. 🥺
Review of advance copy received from Goodreads Giveaways
Great story. This was a Goodreads giveaway winner.
August 13, 2026
This was an interesting historical novel about the five weeks that Hans Christian Andersen spent with the family of Charlie’s Dickens in 1857. The book is told in three voices- the children, Charles Dickens, and the houseguest himself. No one comes across in a flattering light! I am fascinated that the author took this minor visit, and created a novel from it.
July 21, 2026
The nine children of Charles Dickens are worried their father doesn't love them anymore, and that he's also lost interest in their mother and in their country home. Into this time of family strain enters another burden, in the form of an awkward and demanding houseguest named Hans Christian Andersen. He's apparently a renowned author in Denmark, maybe even as famous as their father in England, but the children have never heard of him or his fairy tales. Though Andersen is a great admirer of Dickens and eager to be included in the household, nobody returns the enthusiasm as his visit drags on and on for weeks.
I was excited to see how Prose would fictionalize this true case of an intolerable houseguest. She mines a lot of humor from both real and imagined details of the situation, and that makes for some fun scenes. I was also intrigued by the potential of the POV shifts, with a section narrated by the children, then Dickens, and then finally Andersen, a structure I expected to keep revealing new surprises. But this aspect disappointed me, with too much rehashing of scenes and not enough that reframed the reader's understanding. I appreciated the portrayals of these writers and their lives, but I wanted more out of this story.
I was excited to see how Prose would fictionalize this true case of an intolerable houseguest. She mines a lot of humor from both real and imagined details of the situation, and that makes for some fun scenes. I was also intrigued by the potential of the POV shifts, with a section narrated by the children, then Dickens, and then finally Andersen, a structure I expected to keep revealing new surprises. But this aspect disappointed me, with too much rehashing of scenes and not enough that reframed the reader's understanding. I appreciated the portrayals of these writers and their lives, but I wanted more out of this story.
June 29, 2026
I think Francine Prose is not for me.
June 14, 2026
I've read far more Dickens biographies than I care to admit and so I was aware of the five-week visit Hans Christian Andersen paid to the Dickens family. This novel imagines various perspectives -- Dickens's, his wife's, his children's, Andersen's -- on the visit that was, by all accounts, wildly unsuccessful. I don't think the ending quite landed, at least not for me, but I was captivated the entire time. (And justice for poor Hans, who probably _was_ extremely difficult in ways he did not intend, but he meant well, whereas Dickens was both difficult and not a little self-serving.)
(This is really a 4.5-star novel for me, and would be five if I'd liked the ending better.)
(This is really a 4.5-star novel for me, and would be five if I'd liked the ending better.)
May 15, 2026
This book was not what I expected, but it is such a unique story with dramatic writing and I was sucked right in. I love the same events are told in 3 parts/ POVs - the children, Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen. I think the author did such a good job of taking what was known and pieces of real correspondence, and weaving a tale around it. It's also fascinating how the same events can be perceived in 3 completely differnet ways, which also really made me think during this story about the interpretation of historical events.
I love how the children’s’ POV is first because we are just in the dark as they are about what is going on. And then we see the very self-centered Charles and his take on everything, his obsessions and how they inform his actions. It's amazing that someone who is known for their societal commentary could be so self-obsessed and rude to those around him. I love the "mask off" perspective. And I in no way condone his actions, but it’s an interesting look into how a tough childhood can last in adulthood. How he had dreams and even when accomplishing them, it’s not enough, and he is always seeking more and trying to a new purpose for his life. Finally I kind of adored Hans Christian. I can see why he wrote the way he did, he still felt childish in his thoughts and honestly I enjoyed that more than Charles. To see his earnestness and how people took that as social awkwardness made me feel for him even more. And his child-like obsession with Charles was honestly so like the children at the beginning that it made for a well rounded ending.
This book was so unique!
Thanks to the publisher for a free ARC; my thoughts and review are my own.
I love how the children’s’ POV is first because we are just in the dark as they are about what is going on. And then we see the very self-centered Charles and his take on everything, his obsessions and how they inform his actions. It's amazing that someone who is known for their societal commentary could be so self-obsessed and rude to those around him. I love the "mask off" perspective. And I in no way condone his actions, but it’s an interesting look into how a tough childhood can last in adulthood. How he had dreams and even when accomplishing them, it’s not enough, and he is always seeking more and trying to a new purpose for his life. Finally I kind of adored Hans Christian. I can see why he wrote the way he did, he still felt childish in his thoughts and honestly I enjoyed that more than Charles. To see his earnestness and how people took that as social awkwardness made me feel for him even more. And his child-like obsession with Charles was honestly so like the children at the beginning that it made for a well rounded ending.
This book was so unique!
Thanks to the publisher for a free ARC; my thoughts and review are my own.
July 13, 2026
I would give four or five stars to the first and third sections. Using the 2nd person voice for the children of Charles Dickens was daring and effective. Hans Christian Andersen's version of events in 1st person was masterful in the way that his observations added to the story despite his having little to no idea of what was going on or why he was behaving so oddly. The second section, relating what Charles Dickens was going through in the 3rd person, was less inventive and dragged a bit for me as the longest chapter. It had the burden of filling in the gaps, between what the children and Andersen knew. I would have liked a section from Mrs. Dickens' point of view. But the invention of details and anecdotes was my favorite part of the book, so well woven with the historical facts and seeming totally plausible with all the wacky goings on.
July 28, 2026
The structure of this novel is well conceived, as it feels like a slow walk around a scene to observe it from various vantage points. Prose is pretty ruthless with both the writers. Their egos reach hilarious and astronomical heights as they reroute every situation back to their own careers and reputations. And what an improbable but true situation that Hans Christian Anderson comes to visit Charles dickens at his summer home. A brilliant entry point for looking at these two classic authors.
August 4, 2026
I love this author. But the premise of this book was already strange. I had a hard time staying interested.
May 11, 2026
This book initially had me despising Hans Christian Anderson, but by the end I sympathized with him entirely.
I don’t know why I’m surprised, but it turns out that Charles Dickinson was an as$.
The writing is fantastic! The book takes place in three points of views, starting with the children, then Charles Dickens, then Hans Christian Anderson. As a result, some of the information seems duplicated and redundant.
I’m not sure how to rate this book because there’s only a short afterward. I expected to see much more information about the liberties that the author took so I’m just unclear of how much of this is true.
I don’t know why I’m surprised, but it turns out that Charles Dickinson was an as$.
The writing is fantastic! The book takes place in three points of views, starting with the children, then Charles Dickens, then Hans Christian Anderson. As a result, some of the information seems duplicated and redundant.
I’m not sure how to rate this book because there’s only a short afterward. I expected to see much more information about the liberties that the author took so I’m just unclear of how much of this is true.
June 5, 2026
Set in 1887 at Gad’s Hall, beginning with the narration by one of Charles Dickens’s unnamed daughters.
Inspired by actual events, Prose’s historical is repetitive and longer than necessary.
Inspired by actual events, Prose’s historical is repetitive and longer than necessary.
June 13, 2026
I loved that this book was basically fictional but inspired by real events. The author has a great imagination and as someone who loves Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen this was a very satisfying read. The drama makes it a modern day entertainment for an easy weekend read. Loved the setting and the narration and the overall plot. I received a review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 31, 2026
In 1857, Charles Dickens made good on a promise to fellow writer Hans Christian Andersen by inviting him for a visit to his country home outside of Kent, England. The invitation came ten years after their meeting at a clandestine dinner party in London, where the two drank and talked all evening, and the invite was proffered by Dickens.
In the intervening years, much had changed for Dickens. He had lost two children, and raising the remaining nine strained his already unhappy marriage. Freely "Falling in love" with younger women became a past time for Dickens as an escape from his perpetually pregnant, recovering, or crying wife with whom he was once deeply in love. The marriage in shambles, his career in both writing and theater on the rise, and his children no longer entertaining, Dickens decided to invite Andersen to stay with the brood and their servants, along with his household-manager sister-in-law, Georgina, and his two huge dogs, for whatever desperate reason.
This is the premise for "Five Weeks In The Country," an historical fiction account of how the footloose, disheveled, and childish Andersen, hopelessly enamored of his friend, Dickens, overstays his welcome, upsets the entire household, and unwittingly becomes "a beard" for the great man, going with him to London, where the newest object of his desire, a young actress with a penchant for Lilac, lives with her scheming mother and older sisters.
The extremely eccentric, dog-fearing Andersen becomes the subject of ridicule for both the children and the servants in the house, and many mean and heartless tricks are played or acted out upon the hapless Andersen, who doesn't write a word during the five-week visit. Dickens, on the other hand, writes almost incessantly: Plays, essays, short stories, novels, it's somewhat surprising he also has the time to fall in love. This only expedites Andersen's self-loathing, even though he "Loves" both Charles Dickens, and his family. His erratic behavior culminates in the garden, where Charles Dickens loves only the Geraniums, which Andersen decides to pluck, one by one, to give to Mrs. Dickens in an effort to stop her continual weeping.
Fortunately, both Mrs. Dickens and the youngest child, a boy called "Baby" take to Mr. Andersen and his fairy tales. He does his best to cheer Mrs. Dickens, and to help Baby with his stuttering, with decent success. In the midst of it all is the threat of a Comet coming to destroy all of England.
The tale starts out in the voice of eldest daughter, Katie, then moves on to Dickens, Andersen, Letters, and the "Trail of the Comet" or the afterward.
Although the author kept my attention throughout most of the book, I can't say I enjoyed the brutal treatment and exclusion of Mr. Andersen, (a clearly disturbed character.) I found it harsh and without much quarter. It would have been interesting for me to hear from the young object of Mr. Dickens' affection, or even her fairly ruthless mother. It would have been satisfying to know that Mr. Andersen was changed by the experience, which is subtly alluded to, but nothing concrete seemed to change with him.
Although I expected more from this book, it was an interesting read that did a fair job of keeping my interest,
In the intervening years, much had changed for Dickens. He had lost two children, and raising the remaining nine strained his already unhappy marriage. Freely "Falling in love" with younger women became a past time for Dickens as an escape from his perpetually pregnant, recovering, or crying wife with whom he was once deeply in love. The marriage in shambles, his career in both writing and theater on the rise, and his children no longer entertaining, Dickens decided to invite Andersen to stay with the brood and their servants, along with his household-manager sister-in-law, Georgina, and his two huge dogs, for whatever desperate reason.
This is the premise for "Five Weeks In The Country," an historical fiction account of how the footloose, disheveled, and childish Andersen, hopelessly enamored of his friend, Dickens, overstays his welcome, upsets the entire household, and unwittingly becomes "a beard" for the great man, going with him to London, where the newest object of his desire, a young actress with a penchant for Lilac, lives with her scheming mother and older sisters.
The extremely eccentric, dog-fearing Andersen becomes the subject of ridicule for both the children and the servants in the house, and many mean and heartless tricks are played or acted out upon the hapless Andersen, who doesn't write a word during the five-week visit. Dickens, on the other hand, writes almost incessantly: Plays, essays, short stories, novels, it's somewhat surprising he also has the time to fall in love. This only expedites Andersen's self-loathing, even though he "Loves" both Charles Dickens, and his family. His erratic behavior culminates in the garden, where Charles Dickens loves only the Geraniums, which Andersen decides to pluck, one by one, to give to Mrs. Dickens in an effort to stop her continual weeping.
Fortunately, both Mrs. Dickens and the youngest child, a boy called "Baby" take to Mr. Andersen and his fairy tales. He does his best to cheer Mrs. Dickens, and to help Baby with his stuttering, with decent success. In the midst of it all is the threat of a Comet coming to destroy all of England.
The tale starts out in the voice of eldest daughter, Katie, then moves on to Dickens, Andersen, Letters, and the "Trail of the Comet" or the afterward.
Although the author kept my attention throughout most of the book, I can't say I enjoyed the brutal treatment and exclusion of Mr. Andersen, (a clearly disturbed character.) I found it harsh and without much quarter. It would have been interesting for me to hear from the young object of Mr. Dickens' affection, or even her fairly ruthless mother. It would have been satisfying to know that Mr. Andersen was changed by the experience, which is subtly alluded to, but nothing concrete seemed to change with him.
Although I expected more from this book, it was an interesting read that did a fair job of keeping my interest,
May 18, 2026
Francine Prose’s Five Weeks in the Country made me realize two things very quickly: literary geniuses can be wildly insufferable, and absolutely nobody in this book needed a five-week houseguest during a family implosion. The emotional tension here felt like sitting at a Victorian dinner table where everyone is pretending to be polite while secretly one bad comment away from throwing a roast chicken across the room.
Published by Harper, thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for the gifted ARC because this was one of the strangest, smartest, most quietly chaotic historical fiction reads I’ve picked up in a while.
Set during the summer of 1857, the story follows Hans Christian Andersen arriving at Charles Dickens’s country home just as the Dickens family is quietly unraveling behind closed doors. What follows is basically an emotionally awkward social disaster wrapped in literary history. The brilliance of this novel isn’t dramatic twists—it’s the uncomfortable intimacy of it all. Francine Prose transforms a real historical footnote into something painfully human, melancholic, and weirdly compelling.
What fascinated me most was how differently everyone experiences the same events. The children sense emotional distance and confusion. Catherine Dickens carries this lingering sadness through every room. Dickens himself feels charismatic yet deeply self-absorbed, constantly performing even inside his own home. And then there’s Andersen—earnest, lonely, socially disastrous Andersen—who somehow became the character I pitied most by the end.
“He wanted love from people who had none left to give.”
That line honestly captures the emotional atmosphere of this novel perfectly.
The writing feels rich, literary, and intentionally melancholic for the period, but underneath it all is a deeply uncomfortable story about ego, loneliness, fame, marriage, and the quiet collapse of a family while the outside world still applauds.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Have you ever read a book that completely changed how you viewed a famous historical figure?
0#FiveWeeksInTheCountry #FrancineProse #HistoricalFiction #BookReview #NetGalley #Bookstagram #HistoricalNovel #ReadersOfInstag
Published by Harper, thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for the gifted ARC because this was one of the strangest, smartest, most quietly chaotic historical fiction reads I’ve picked up in a while.
Set during the summer of 1857, the story follows Hans Christian Andersen arriving at Charles Dickens’s country home just as the Dickens family is quietly unraveling behind closed doors. What follows is basically an emotionally awkward social disaster wrapped in literary history. The brilliance of this novel isn’t dramatic twists—it’s the uncomfortable intimacy of it all. Francine Prose transforms a real historical footnote into something painfully human, melancholic, and weirdly compelling.
What fascinated me most was how differently everyone experiences the same events. The children sense emotional distance and confusion. Catherine Dickens carries this lingering sadness through every room. Dickens himself feels charismatic yet deeply self-absorbed, constantly performing even inside his own home. And then there’s Andersen—earnest, lonely, socially disastrous Andersen—who somehow became the character I pitied most by the end.
“He wanted love from people who had none left to give.”
That line honestly captures the emotional atmosphere of this novel perfectly.
The writing feels rich, literary, and intentionally melancholic for the period, but underneath it all is a deeply uncomfortable story about ego, loneliness, fame, marriage, and the quiet collapse of a family while the outside world still applauds.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Have you ever read a book that completely changed how you viewed a famous historical figure?
0#FiveWeeksInTheCountry #FrancineProse #HistoricalFiction #BookReview #NetGalley #Bookstagram #HistoricalNovel #ReadersOfInstag
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This one has such a distinct tone from the very first pages-it opens with a heaviness that immediately sets the stage, especially through the children’s voices as they sense their father pulling away. There’s something really heartbreaking about that perspective…and it carries throughout the story.
The way Hans Christian Andersen steps into Charles Dickens’ world feels awkward, and very intentional. You can feel how out of place he is, how every interaction has a bit of strain to it. It’s not a visit anyone would envy, and that tension follows him the whole time. The writing leans into that too…it has that slightly melancholic, Dickensian feel that really fits the setting and mood.
What stood out to me most was Andersen himself. There’s this sense that he’s incredibly talented, but also unsure of where he fits-like he can’t quite see what’s already within him or what’s right in front of him. Add in the language barrier and all the social missteps, and it becomes such a human story. It really taps into that feeling we all have sometimes, like we don’t quite belong-while also reminding us that we’ve all had our own wins and moments worth celebrating.
“I awoke, lit the lamp, and began to write. I felt words returning, then a sentence, then another. I knew what would happen next, and after that. Something had been found. Something had returned to me.”
That quote really captures the feeling of of struggling and then suddenly finding your way back.
There’s a lot of imagination woven in, but it’s grounded in emotion and vulnerability. Not always the easiest tone, but definitely a thoughtful and memorable read.
I’ll absolutely be picking up more from Prose-especially Anne Frank: The Book, the Life, the Afterlife, which I’ve been wanting to read.
If you love historical fiction that leans into character and emotion, this is one to pick up. It takes a real-life encounter and fills in the gaps with imagination, focusing on the emotions and tensions behind it.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I was gifted an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.
The way Hans Christian Andersen steps into Charles Dickens’ world feels awkward, and very intentional. You can feel how out of place he is, how every interaction has a bit of strain to it. It’s not a visit anyone would envy, and that tension follows him the whole time. The writing leans into that too…it has that slightly melancholic, Dickensian feel that really fits the setting and mood.
What stood out to me most was Andersen himself. There’s this sense that he’s incredibly talented, but also unsure of where he fits-like he can’t quite see what’s already within him or what’s right in front of him. Add in the language barrier and all the social missteps, and it becomes such a human story. It really taps into that feeling we all have sometimes, like we don’t quite belong-while also reminding us that we’ve all had our own wins and moments worth celebrating.
“I awoke, lit the lamp, and began to write. I felt words returning, then a sentence, then another. I knew what would happen next, and after that. Something had been found. Something had returned to me.”
That quote really captures the feeling of of struggling and then suddenly finding your way back.
There’s a lot of imagination woven in, but it’s grounded in emotion and vulnerability. Not always the easiest tone, but definitely a thoughtful and memorable read.
I’ll absolutely be picking up more from Prose-especially Anne Frank: The Book, the Life, the Afterlife, which I’ve been wanting to read.
If you love historical fiction that leans into character and emotion, this is one to pick up. It takes a real-life encounter and fills in the gaps with imagination, focusing on the emotions and tensions behind it.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I was gifted an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
In the masterful hands of Francine Prose, this novel manages to be funny but at the same time painfully sad. It's based on an invitation Charles Dickens sent to Hans Christian Andersen to come for a visit. Andersen does, arriving unannounced (his reply did not arrive) and at the crucial point in the dissolution of the Dickens family. Andersen doesn't speak English and is one of those people who simply cannot read social cues. He cannot understand why Dickens' effusive invitation is resulting in this rude, unkind treatment. The Dickens children--all nine of them--know something bad is up. Their father has moved them from their happy city life to a remote house in the country, he treats their mother cruelly, and they know that he has a lover in town. Dickens wants to be rid of all of them, but here he is with the universe's most awkward house guest.
You feel for everyone in this story but Andersen if the saddest. Brilliant but usually failing, uncomfortable but living off a string of invitations, he is someone who will not fit anywhere.
This odd historical event does not result in satisfying literature. I can't put my finger on why. Perhaps because everyone is so unhappy and can't pull themselves together enough to seek to understand this guest who wants nothing more than to love them.
Thanks to Edelweiss for a DRC of this novel.
You feel for everyone in this story but Andersen if the saddest. Brilliant but usually failing, uncomfortable but living off a string of invitations, he is someone who will not fit anywhere.
This odd historical event does not result in satisfying literature. I can't put my finger on why. Perhaps because everyone is so unhappy and can't pull themselves together enough to seek to understand this guest who wants nothing more than to love them.
Thanks to Edelweiss for a DRC of this novel.
July 12, 2026
Five Weeks in the Country — Francine Prose
A fictionalized account of the infamous five-week visit Hans Christian Andersen paid to Charles Dickens, imagining what may have unfolded behind the scenes between two literary giants.
My vibe 3/5 ⭐️:
I found this on one of those “must-read literary fiction of 2026” lists and figured I’d give it a shot. Then I started seeing some mixed reviews before I picked it up and thought, “Well… I’m committed now.”
Maybe this one was simply too niche for me.
If you’re deeply invested in Charles Dickens, Hans Christian Andersen, or Victorian literary history, I can absolutely see the appeal. For me, though, it was just… okay.
Francine Prose is undeniably a beautiful writer, and I appreciated the historical research, along with the liberties she openly acknowledges taking to bring these real people to life. But I never became fully invested in either Dickens or Andersen. Their awkwardness, melancholy, and social discomfort often made me cringe—which, to be fair, seems pretty consistent with what we know about parts of their real lives.
I’m glad I read it, but it isn’t one that’s going to stick with me. Sometimes a beautifully written book just isn’t the right fit, and that’s okay. But it did pique my interest in diving deeper into the history of Dickens and Andersen.
A fictionalized account of the infamous five-week visit Hans Christian Andersen paid to Charles Dickens, imagining what may have unfolded behind the scenes between two literary giants.
My vibe 3/5 ⭐️:
I found this on one of those “must-read literary fiction of 2026” lists and figured I’d give it a shot. Then I started seeing some mixed reviews before I picked it up and thought, “Well… I’m committed now.”
Maybe this one was simply too niche for me.
If you’re deeply invested in Charles Dickens, Hans Christian Andersen, or Victorian literary history, I can absolutely see the appeal. For me, though, it was just… okay.
Francine Prose is undeniably a beautiful writer, and I appreciated the historical research, along with the liberties she openly acknowledges taking to bring these real people to life. But I never became fully invested in either Dickens or Andersen. Their awkwardness, melancholy, and social discomfort often made me cringe—which, to be fair, seems pretty consistent with what we know about parts of their real lives.
I’m glad I read it, but it isn’t one that’s going to stick with me. Sometimes a beautifully written book just isn’t the right fit, and that’s okay. But it did pique my interest in diving deeper into the history of Dickens and Andersen.
August 10, 2026
In the spring of 1857, Hans Christian Andersen visited Charles Dickens and his family at Gad’s Hill, in the countryside of Kent. Invited for a brief stay, Andersen remained for five long weeks. The first section is narrated collectively by the nine Dickens children. The children are unhappy, feeling unloved by their father, who seems to always be distant and distracted.
The second section is narrated by Dickens himself who had invited Andersen in a moment of exuberance he now regrets. He is irritated by Andersen’s odd demeanor and intrusiveness. The visit has come at a low point in his life. He is dissatisfied with a play he is producing—although enthralled with the 17-year-old actress (the latest of many romances). The man is a major narcissist!
The third section is narrated by Andersen who was flattered to think that Dickens' invitation had been motivated by admiration from an author he idolizes. He tries to ingratiate himself, but fails. Indeed, he leaves in tears. Prose handles his character with sympathy, whose neediness is palpable. Andersen accurately details all that he has observed at Gad’s Hill in a thinly disguised fairy tale about a comet causing fear and wonder.
Prose includes a bit too much repetition in her historical novel, but it is a richly written tale.
The second section is narrated by Dickens himself who had invited Andersen in a moment of exuberance he now regrets. He is irritated by Andersen’s odd demeanor and intrusiveness. The visit has come at a low point in his life. He is dissatisfied with a play he is producing—although enthralled with the 17-year-old actress (the latest of many romances). The man is a major narcissist!
The third section is narrated by Andersen who was flattered to think that Dickens' invitation had been motivated by admiration from an author he idolizes. He tries to ingratiate himself, but fails. Indeed, he leaves in tears. Prose handles his character with sympathy, whose neediness is palpable. Andersen accurately details all that he has observed at Gad’s Hill in a thinly disguised fairy tale about a comet causing fear and wonder.
Prose includes a bit too much repetition in her historical novel, but it is a richly written tale.
July 27, 2026
Fascinating, uncomfortable, and unexpectedly revealing
Five Weeks in Summer is one of those books that sneaks up on you. On the surface, it’s a simple account of Hans Christian Andersen visiting Charles Dickens, but underneath it’s a surprisingly layered look at ego, hospitality, and the strange ways famous people can fail at being decent.
The strongest part of the book is its atmosphere — you can feel the tension in the house, the awkwardness of Andersen trying to fit in, and the quiet kindness from the few people who actually treat him like a human being ('Baby' and Dickens’s wife, especially). It’s vivid without being melodramatic.
My only real complaint is the repetition. Some sections circle the same emotional beat again and again, and Dickens’s long internal passages can get indulgent. His thoughts read as oddly selfish — not introspective so much as self‑absorbed, like he’s narrating his own greatness while ignoring the person right in front of him. Those stretches drag a bit.
Still, the book is compelling. It’s a rare look at two literary giants colliding in a very human, very imperfect way. Even with its flaws, it’s memorable, atmospheric, and worth reading.
A solid four stars.
Five Weeks in Summer is one of those books that sneaks up on you. On the surface, it’s a simple account of Hans Christian Andersen visiting Charles Dickens, but underneath it’s a surprisingly layered look at ego, hospitality, and the strange ways famous people can fail at being decent.
The strongest part of the book is its atmosphere — you can feel the tension in the house, the awkwardness of Andersen trying to fit in, and the quiet kindness from the few people who actually treat him like a human being ('Baby' and Dickens’s wife, especially). It’s vivid without being melodramatic.
My only real complaint is the repetition. Some sections circle the same emotional beat again and again, and Dickens’s long internal passages can get indulgent. His thoughts read as oddly selfish — not introspective so much as self‑absorbed, like he’s narrating his own greatness while ignoring the person right in front of him. Those stretches drag a bit.
Still, the book is compelling. It’s a rare look at two literary giants colliding in a very human, very imperfect way. Even with its flaws, it’s memorable, atmospheric, and worth reading.
A solid four stars.
May 5, 2026
Book Review - Five Weeks in the Country by Francine Prose
This was a really fascinating read for those who are historical fiction readers. This book was about the family of Charles Dickens and the time period before he left his family. The books is about a five week period of time in 1856 when the family is at their country home and Hans Christian Anderson comes to visit.
Charles Dickens and his wife had 9 children who survived into childhood. Charles and his wife Catherine did not marry for love and with Charles being away and his lack of affection (as well as having so many children and undiagnosed depression) resulted inn Catherine spending much of time in her bedroom despondent over her marriage. Hans comes to visit at a time when to eir marriage is falling apart and overstays his welcome.
The book is told from multiple points of view, Dickens children, his wife, Dickens himself and Hans Christian Anderson which I found really interesting. I had not realized that Hans was such a odd duck. Also had no idea that Dickens was really not a good person at all.
The book was well written and I enjoyed the storyline and all of the characters.
May 19, 2026
It is hilariously unsurprising that Charles Dickens would have a terrible time getting rid of an unwanted houseguest and that Hans Christian Andersen would be an unwanted houseguest.
Such is the basis of Five Weeks in the Country, and like all the most ridiculous stories, this one is mostly true.
The king of Danish fairytales really did visit the Dickens family at their home in the country and badly overstay his welcome. Prose takes this almost slapstick mashup of Victorian writers and imagines what the experience might have been like.
Dickens’ children narrate using the royal we, which is both aptly clever and well-rendered, giving voice to the perfect semi-omniscient spies. Who better to give us all the dirt on the adults of the household than the kids? It’s harder to write from this perspective than it would have been to use the servants to the same end, but Prose has pulled it off beautifully.
The book is a bit on the slow side and will likely only be of interest to Dickens enthusiasts like myself, but it’s a fun and truly original read.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
Such is the basis of Five Weeks in the Country, and like all the most ridiculous stories, this one is mostly true.
The king of Danish fairytales really did visit the Dickens family at their home in the country and badly overstay his welcome. Prose takes this almost slapstick mashup of Victorian writers and imagines what the experience might have been like.
Dickens’ children narrate using the royal we, which is both aptly clever and well-rendered, giving voice to the perfect semi-omniscient spies. Who better to give us all the dirt on the adults of the household than the kids? It’s harder to write from this perspective than it would have been to use the servants to the same end, but Prose has pulled it off beautifully.
The book is a bit on the slow side and will likely only be of interest to Dickens enthusiasts like myself, but it’s a fun and truly original read.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
June 20, 2026
Don't read this if you want to maintain warm, fuzzy feelings about Charles Dickens. For that matter, don't read any stories that address who he was as a man. However, if you want a glimpse of what that man could be like, as well as a revelatory look at who Hans Christian Anderson was, this might be just the thing for you. Neither is portrayed in a very positive way, but the story is based on evidence that is well explained both at the beginning and end of the book. I found this interesting, and written in a style that allowed each of the main characters to tell their point of view. Each part goes through the whole story from one character's perspective, with the next part going back to the beginning from a different character's perspective. This did not feel repetitive to me, but more like peeling back the layers of an onion, with each narrative providing a deeper understanding of the events. I liked this, and would say it was a solid 3.5 stars, which I'm rounding up to 4. There was nothing wrong with the story. It just isn't something I would normally read, but I thought the premise sounded interesting, and was able to access it through Netgalley.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
3 1/2 stars
Historical fiction of one of the most unusual friendships and the dilemma of what to do with a houseguest who overstays their welcome. I can't imagine two more distinctly opposite personalities than authors Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen and it is very evident when Dickens loosely invites Andersen to visit his country home. The Danish fairy tale author arrives barely speaking English and between scaring the Dickens children with his over the top pantomimes and his unlike English behavior it is not an easy visit. There is also the fact that Charles Dickens is having a not so secret affair with a much younger actress in London causing his wife and the rest of the family a lot of pain. Hans Christian Andersen sees this and is sympathetic to Mrs. Dickens and the family. I wish that Charles Dickens wasn't such an odious character and Hans Christian Andersen a buffoon but it was an interesting look at the cost of fame, large egos and the male lack of feeling towards the family left behind. My thanks to the publisher for the advance copy.
Historical fiction of one of the most unusual friendships and the dilemma of what to do with a houseguest who overstays their welcome. I can't imagine two more distinctly opposite personalities than authors Charles Dickens and Hans Christian Andersen and it is very evident when Dickens loosely invites Andersen to visit his country home. The Danish fairy tale author arrives barely speaking English and between scaring the Dickens children with his over the top pantomimes and his unlike English behavior it is not an easy visit. There is also the fact that Charles Dickens is having a not so secret affair with a much younger actress in London causing his wife and the rest of the family a lot of pain. Hans Christian Andersen sees this and is sympathetic to Mrs. Dickens and the family. I wish that Charles Dickens wasn't such an odious character and Hans Christian Andersen a buffoon but it was an interesting look at the cost of fame, large egos and the male lack of feeling towards the family left behind. My thanks to the publisher for the advance copy.
June 10, 2026
Francine Prose takes a real-life encounter between Hans Christian Andersen and Charles Dickens at his home in Gad's Hill, taking place during a tumultuous and painful period in the writer's family's life, and spins it into a riveting account. The same story is told three different times: once through the eyes of Dickens' collective children, once through Dickens' own eyes and once in a first person account by Andersen. The overlap contains inconsistencies to keep a literary sleuth busy, and the Dickens narrative is compelling--it's almost as if the Great Writer can see what a douche he is towards his wife and kids, but not completely. But Andersen's account of the experience is what I found the most endearing and gripping, which surprised me. Prose pulls off Andersen's childish ineptitude with English Victorian social custom with dexterity and heart; by the novel's conclusion, I wanted to pat the guy on the shoulders and comfort him. A wonderful tale.
June 24, 2026
Francine Prose's work of historical fiction both interested and frustrated me. Five Weeks in the Country describes Hans Christian Andersen's visit to the country home of Charles Dickens in the summer of 1857. In telling the story from different points of view, Prose employs colorful details the reader recognizes in each version. Although some incidents come off as humorous, the overall sense is pathos. I felt sad for Andersen, for Dickens' wife and children and servants; and I felt angry with Dickens. Anderson's visit coincided with the falling apart of the Dickens family.
Prose tells the story in an interesting way. Seeing London's literary scene in 1857 also interested me. What frustrated the daylights out of me was the almost total lack of dialogue. Every character had feelings and opinions about incidents during those five weeks, but they just made observations, assumptions, and judgments without checking in with each other.
Prose tells the story in an interesting way. Seeing London's literary scene in 1857 also interested me. What frustrated the daylights out of me was the almost total lack of dialogue. Every character had feelings and opinions about incidents during those five weeks, but they just made observations, assumptions, and judgments without checking in with each other.
August 5, 2026
As a former English major and a devote of Charles Dickens I was drawn to this book which describes a five week visit from Hans Christian Anderson to the Dickens family home at Gads Hill just outside of London. The book is divided into three sections which describe the Danish fairy tale author's stay from the points of view of the nine Dickens' children, Charles Dickens, and Hans Christian Anderson. The story is humorous and sad as told by all three perspectives. Anderson who has lived his life as a frequent guest of royalty and celebrity longs for a family as his childhood was fairly tragic. Dickens, the father of nine who is growing apart from his wife and turning his attention to the theatre and a particular young actress is overwhelmed by fatherhood. And, the nine children who adore their father and are puzzled by the strange non-English speaking visitor, long for their father's attention again.
I liked the story a lot.
I liked the story a lot.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 80 reviews