Roots of Darkness is a fast, spicy return to Íseldur, and while I enjoyed spending more time with Hekla “Rib Smasher,” this novella ultimately left me a bit conflicted.
Hekla remains the standout—fierce, stubborn, morally grounded, and unwilling to bend even when everyone around her underestimates her. Watching her take charge of the Bloodaxe Crew in Rey’s absence was satisfying, and I loved seeing her navigate leadership, danger, and her own vulnerabilities. That said, the short length really works against the story. The sentient mist plot feels rushed, the worldbuilding is thin, and the emotional beats don’t always have time to land. This is very much a companion piece—you’d be lost without reading the previous books.
Romance-wise… mixed feelings. The Hekla/Gunner dynamic got weird for me. Emphasizing their “brother/sister” bond immediately after Hekla reflects on not wanting to casually hook up with him anymore felt uncomfortable and unnecessary. As for Eyvind, he just didn’t work for me. Demi Winters’ love interests are starting to blur together—broody, controlling, and overly dominant—and it’s getting old. Eyvind wasn’t my favorite addition.
I’m also increasingly frustrated with Winters’ reliance on mind-speaking as a narrative shortcut. It feels like an easy way to push the plot forward rather than doing the harder work through dialogue and action.
Overall, enjoyable for Hekla fans and readers here for the spice, but narratively shallow and a bit disappointing.