My Three Hometown Firefighters

Aspen Springs #2

by Lacey Day

My best friend’s brother—Aspen Springs’ fire captain—is now just a window peep away.

Imagine my surprise…
Only a few nights ago, my new neighbor was my nameless one-night stand.
Now he’s everywhere. And so is the rest of his fire crew.

Now I’ve got three firemen showing off their hoses…
Plus a surprise pregnancy that's about to put a kink in things.

Grayson is a walking firefighter fantasy. We swore our mix-up wouldn't happen again, and again, and again.
Warren is a protective single dad with smoke-gray eyes and hands that can handle heat.
Tucker is built for sin. Something inside me ignites when he calls me Sunshine.

I thought this foursome was just a fling.
But two pink lines have changed everything.

Now all three men want to be Daddy.


My Three Hometown Firefighters is a standalone MFMM why choose romance in the “Aspen Springs” series. Get ready for small-town rom-com vibes, a one-night stand mix-up, and a smokin’ hot single dad. No swords cross, but flames combust. Ultra cozy HEA.

Genres: Why Choose, Romance, Forced Proximity, Firefighters, Found Family

318 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 4, 2025

Reviews

[Toni · Rating 4 out of 5]

Cute

KU Read
318 Pages
Small Town Romance
RH/Why Choose
Single Dad
Second Chance
Best Friends Brother
Friends-with-benefits
Surprise Pregnancy

Sugary sweet as well as spicy. Sienna has a second shot with Grayson since their trust 2 years ago but this time, both single dad Warren and best friend Tucker are in the mix too. Their dynamic shifts from a friends-with-benefits deal when they all catch feelings and an unplanned pregnancy occurs after a bout of sickness for Sienna.
The dynamic takes a familial turn, but Sienna holds off on the 'relationship' thinking that the guys don't want they and were only in it for the 'fun' that they'd originally agreed upon... But yeah nah that doesn't last and we get our sweet HEA with a baby too.

[Curvy Girl Book Nerd (Jen S) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sienna and her 3 firefighters

MY THREE HOMETOWN FIREFIGHTERS is a steamy, OTT, reverse harem, MFMM, girl gets her three firefighters romance. Sienna is a sassy girl who had a hot, anonymous, one night stand 2 years old with Grayson, her best friend's older brother. Now, she meets him as the sexy fire chief and her neighbor. Warren is a hunky single dad, and Tucker is just hot hot hot!  These hunky firefighters all want her and are willing to share if she is, and she is... but when she gets pregnant though, she panics a bit. This was a sweet and steamy romance with lots of laughs, swoons, hot chemistry, and a happy ending. I loved it.

[Maria · Rating 3 out of 5]

3 ⭐️

[Charity ♡ · Rating 3 out of 5]

this was so spicy with just the right amount of rom com! I love that it didn't break my heart but instead just built me up more and more

[Donna Ross · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sienna and Grayson met at an airport bar and connected with him, although it was just a one-night stand. They were basically like strangers meeting…but were they?

A couple of years later they run into one another under different circumstances, and he realizes when he sees her that he has really never stopped thinking about her. She used to have a crush on him, well, she still does it appears!

She runs into Warren at the charity gala and has a little flirt with him, and then runs into Tucker (literally) and he catches her. She must surely have a thing for firefighters…she’s three for three!


She’s chatting with her mom on the phone outside the venue and telling her that except for that one time, she’s not sure she even likes sex! When she turns around, all three of the men she’s been thinking about are standing there, in shock when they hear what she says! The one time comment makes Grayson feel a little better…she’d better be talking about him! Tucker volunteers to drive her home.

The next day Tucker presents the friends-with-benefits option to Grayson and Warren, and says maybe they could all three share her. So they all agree to talk with Sienna about being with them with the caveat that they won’t do anything unless it’s what she wants.

They all sign the contract. It feels surreal that they’re even thinking of trying this! But they do, and it works, for the most part. When Sienna sees the pink lines, she kind of freaks out and declares their relationship is friends only – no benefits. They don’t like it, but they’ll do what she needs.

After a while, her body says, I don’t want to be just friends! She realizes she loves them. She tells them no more friends only!!

Her love for each of them is different, but together? More than any woman could dream of! They have something beautiful and it all started from something none of them saw coming!

This was a wonderful book! If you like reading books about men and their special lady, you’re going to love this book!.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Sarah Furlow · Rating 5 out of 5]

I think it’s safe to say that this is my favorite Lacey day book to date. I loved reading about the blossoming relationship between the four of them. They drew up the plan of the contact for their arrangement of friends with benefits but then feelings started to get in the way and then a surprise pregnancy and that’s when sienna choose to pull back and just wanted to be friends after all four of them fell in love with one another and that was rule number 4. But who made sienna realize that it is okay for other people to care for you was gram, good bless her. If sienna never went to see her and gram have those words of wisdom they would still just be friends and having a baby together without knowing who the father is. The construction that they make happen for sienna, the baby and tucker and Grayson to move into warrens house to be with Sienna warmed my heart. These men were willing to do whatever grand gesture to show sienna that they were ALL in. And she finally saw and admitted that she loved them each individually. There story was truly something to read. Tucker overcame the feeling that sienna would leave like everyone always did. Grayson had been pinning for her for 2 years and Warren was overwhelmed with the affection she showed to his son Jackson and claimed that she loves him more. But the blooming of all four of them as one was amazing.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[x.o-St3fani3-o.x · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this story from Lacey! Just like her other books, I was hooked from the very first page.

Sienna, a fiery redhead, moves to Aspen Springs, Colorado, where she finds herself falling for three sexy firefighters. Grayson, the older fire chief, her friend’s older brother, and once upon a time a one-night stand. Warren, the handsome, protective single father. And Tucker,the charming jokester who adds just the right amount of levity. Of course, little Jackson, Warren’s sweet three- (almost four-) year-old son, completely stole the show.

One of the things I love most about Lacey’s writing is how she brings back characters from her other books, it makes her worlds feel so connected. The single-dad trope is one of my favorites, and Lacey nailed it here. Sienna fits so naturally into their lives, becoming an amazing stepmom figure, even though her stubborn streak made her try to push the guys away at first. I adored how patient and resilient they were, waiting for her to let her guard down.

All in all, this was a great read, and I can’t wait to see what Lacey brings us next!.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Sharon McMaster · Rating 5 out of 5]

We met the FMC Sienna in Aspen Springs previously however you don’t have to read that book to read this one. This was a great read as you have 3 different guys that all happen to be firefighters and Sienna who is a sassy redhead. Sienna had an amazing one night stand with a guy 2 years ago but has totally struck out in the bedroom since that one guy. She moves into the area and runs into her one night stand and the two other guys that make up this group. Grayson is the older one night stand guy, Warren she met at a gala and hit it off but he comes with a side package (3 year old Jackson) and Tucker who comes off as the lighthearted joker of the group. Since they are all interested and in agreement, can they make a friends with benefits thing work? Or will it implode? Does adding another little one to the mix make it better or worse in the terms of everyone’s feelings? The author does a great job of giving you the storyline, some spice, some comedy/banter and characters that you could go hang out with after work. I am loving Aspen Springs and can’t wait to read the next one!

[Kellyanne · Rating 5 out of 5]

I absolutely adored this book! The author's writing is incredibly addictive, and I was captivated by the world and story building, as well as the well-crafted characters.

This is the second book set in Aspen Springs, and the author does an incredible job of portraying each character. As you read, the characters grow, and so does your investment in the fantastic storyline.

The story follows Sienna, Grayson, Warren, and Tucker as they meet and decide to pursue a four-way relationship. The narrative explores their journey of getting to know one another, navigating their relationship, deciding to move in together, and ultimately forming a family. As expected, the three men fall in love with Sienna, and she, in turn, falls in love with them.

This is a well-written, complete story with excellent character development. It’s easy to read and understand, and is well-edited.

If you enjoy heart-warming romances that are also hot and steamy, then you will absolutely love this book.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Kerri Duffy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Another great Why Choose from Lacey Day. This is her second small-town Aspen Springs book, and it's just as wonderful as the first one.
Sienna, with her fierce independence and badass attitude, was a character I could really relate to, and her story was just so sweet.
Warren, as a single dad, just stole my heart. He was so good to her. He has a bit of a shy side, but when he was riled, get out of the way. Super hot!
Grayson was in love with her for so long, and it just went straight to my heart. The way he was so loyal and stepped up for her was everything a girl really wants in her life.
Tucker was the fun guy, and he was perfect. I loved how he had to dig deep to move forward. Love a guy who has the ability to grow and change.
This book was a little more sweet than spicy, although there was still plenty of spice. This one really just hit my heart in a big way, and I loved it. I didn't want the book to end!
Highly recommend.
Spice 4 🌶️ Rating 5 ⭐.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Tqa London · Rating 4 out of 5]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Whew, where do I even start with this one? My Three Hometown Firefighters gave me ALL the feels, and I mean all of them. Love, rage, tears, laughter… I was on an emotional rollercoaster, and I didn’t want to get off.

Grayson? Straight-up daddy vibes. Tucker? That mouth of his should come with a warning label. And Warren… my sweet, protective love. 😍 The three of them together? Absolute chaos in the best, most delicious way.

One line that really stuck with me: “These men are my family. My life. The love I never knew I would find, but somehow did. And now I’m never letting it go.” 🥹 That’s exactly what this book felt like, messy, fiery, but also full of heart.

And of course, the humor made me snort-laugh more than once especially lines like “I might be too old to drink like I did in college, but not too old for other things.” Lacey Day really knows how to balance heat, humor, and emotion.

Big thanks to Lacey Day for the ARC. I had such a blast with this one. I think I need to grab book one ASAP, and I’m already counting down to the final installment in this series.

[Samantha Carol-Ann · Rating 5 out of 5]

Let me tell ya @laceydaybooks knows how to write damn good reverse harem. The fact that it is 3 firefighters definitely helped 🥵 Also a feisty redhead is a fantastic bonus, I may not be a natural redhead but I'm still feisty redhead lol.

This book focuses on our FMC Sienna who is headstrong, independent and an overall boss ass bitch. After a wild night in Nashville 2 years ago, meeting someone and having damn good sex, she finds herself not liking sex with the exception of her mystery man from Nashville.

Enter Grayson, Tucker and Warren. After her speaking her woes to her mom on night, Tucker comes up with a plan. This plan involves all three men becoming friends with benefits with Sienna, it's supposed to be just for fun but what happens when the boys start taking care of her and treating her like she is precious?

And what happens when the most life altering thing happens between the three of them? Will they prevail or will everything crumble?

[Fiona · Rating 5 out of 5]

I enjoyed this story. Sienna has a one night stand with a man who knocked her socks off, up woke up alone. She later discovers, it’s her best friends, elder brother Grayson. Here is the firehouse captain in her local town. Now two years later, she’s faced with a proposition after three firemen here that she has never enjoyed sex besides one man who happened to be Grayson and two other of his friends, Warren, and Tucker. When they proposition her to be their friend with benefits so they can teach her to enjoy sex, but they all sign a contract that they won’t fall in love with each other, but every time they all develop feelings and then when Sienna discovers, she’s pregnant, she doesn’t expect the men to treat her the way they do. Eventually, she can’t hurt her feelings, and they all live together in a happy home environment and go onto live a happily ever after.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Dawn · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book starts off spicy, with a delayed flight and a chance meeting at an airport bar between Sienna and Grayson. Neither knew much about the other at the time, and after their one-night stand without exchanging names, Sienna moves to Aspen Springs—only to realize the man she slept with is actually her best friend Hadley’s older brother.

Fast forward two years, and Grayson—along with his fellow firefighters Warren and Tucker—overhears a conversation with Sienna that changes everything. The three men step in to help, and what begins as a casual friends-with-benefits situation quickly grows more complicated as real feelings develop. The guys fall first and hard, and Sienna has to decide if she’s willing to believe in a future with all of them.

This was a sweet small-town romance full of spice, chemistry, and heartfelt moments.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Jennifer G · Rating 3 out of 5]

A one-night stand, a single dad, and a fun-loving playboy. All firefighters. How's a girl supposed to resist?

The Good: An adorable little boy
The intimidating, scary mountain of a man who is secretly a softy
Dogs and cats
Surprise pregnancy
Feisty old ladies
The Bad: The morning disappearance after a one-night stand that's never discussed
The lack of communication
Constant tears
Surprise pregnancy

This is fluff. It's a fine reset between other books. It's the same basic story as the others in the series. The first encounter is in an airport. Childhood connection/crush with one of the men. There's a single dad. The breakdown of the men: Serious - Softy - Playboy... If you love the premise, read the other books; if you don't love it, you probably won't enjoy reading it with construction workers or with bosses either.

[Victoria Golby · Rating 5 out of 5]

Heartwarming firefighters RH romance

A heartwarming small-town RH romance, the second in Aspen Springs, with brilliant banter, tension, steamy romance, a second chance, a cute three-year-old, great character development, chemistry, romance and love.

Sienna met and shared a room with Greyson while their plane is grounded, only to realise a few weeks later that he’s her best friend, brother who she hadn’t seen for years. Though they agree to forget the night, neither can.

Two years later, when Greyson and two of his fellow firefighters, Warren and Tucker, overhear Sienna telling her mum she doesn’t enjoy s*x, apart from one time, they all want to change her mind, having all liked her from a distance for a while.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Shawna · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book is such a charming book, but also suspenseful and a page-turner. I didn't want to put the book down because I wanted to see what was going to happen between Warren and Sienna.
Grayson and Sienna know they have the hots for each other, even after two years.
Tucker is enamored by Sienna, but doesn't want to own up to his feelings. Loves to call her Sunshine and do sweet things for her.
Warren has a child and has no interests in starting up a fling when he already has a child to take care of.
The moments between each of these men and Sienna were each their own splendid story. While Lacey Day was crafting one story, in reality there's four stories in one. One for each of the guys with Sienna, and then their story all together. If you like reverse harem's, sweet HEAs, and reel you in tropes, this book is for you! What are you waiting for??

[Emma Rose · Rating 5 out of 5]

Honestly, I loved this book - I felt like I got a little more individuality from the guys in this one but I also loved Hadley and her men popping up throughout.

Sienna was a feisty and fierce FMC and I really enjoyed how her relationship developed with each of the guys. The 'them just being friends' stage wasn't too painful and them coming back together at the end was exactly what I needed. Tucker is a sweet precious baby who needs to be protected and our strong protective Grayson and swoony single-dad Warren were dream book boyfriends.

Another great read from Lacey Day, I can't wait to see who's turn it is next.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Rhiannon Cheyenne · Rating 5 out of 5]

My Three Hometown Firefighters - Lacey Day

This author has some of the most addictive writing I’ve ever seen. I love the world and story building. This author does and how they write their characters. I know when I read one of their books. I’m gonna have a good time, and this book is no exception. Sienna, Tucker, Grayson, and Warren were so fun to learn about and I love the fact that we see previous main characters from the first book as well. I can’t wait to see what else this author writes. I just know I’m gonna love it.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / Out of 5 Stars ⭐️

Format 💫 Gifted Digital Copy

Series 🌙 Aspen Springs, #2

Genre/Tropes ✨ small choose?, small town romance, cozy vibes, single dad MMC, surprise pregnancy, firefighterMMCs

[Empress_Solace · Rating 4 out of 5]

Another great book from Lacey Day! This is the second book set in Aspen Springs series.The story follows Sienna,Grayson, Warren, and Tucker as they all get into a friend's with benefits relationship together. They all sign a contract that they won’t fall in love with each other but as time goes on they all develop feelings and Sienna ends up pregnant. The three men fall in love with Sienna and she falls in love with them.I love the world and story building. I love that characters from book one in the Aspen Springs series are also in this book. I can’t wait to see what else is next in this series.This book drew me in with its engaging writing style and well crafted characters. The plot kept me hooked and the author did a wonderful job at world building. I highly recommend this book!

[Just D · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was fun, spicy, and moved at full speed, the kind of book you fly through in one sitting. The small-town setting, surprise pregnancy, and firefighter chaos made for an entertaining ride. This book brings the heat (in every way). I didn’t take it too seriously, and that’s probably the best way to enjoy it.
It’s my first time reading Lacey Day, and while this style isn’t usually my go-to, I can see why readers love these kinds of wild, steamy stories. If you’re into MFMM dynamics, cozy-but-hot vibes, and chaotic good energy, My Three Hometown Firefighters will absolutely scratch that itch.A solid cozy HEA with extra spice.

I received a free copy of this book and I am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Melinda Stacer · Rating 5 out of 5]

My Three Hometown Firefighters is the second book in Lacey Day's Aspen Springs series. This is a small town poly romance following Sienna, who runs the local animal shelter and falls for not one but three firefighters. The book is written from the four main characters' point of view, which Lacey weaves together so well. As the reader you see each person's motivation and find you are rooting for them all to come together and overcome their hang ups to happiness. 
Personally, I am not a fan of the surprise pregnancy trope that happens in so many reverse harem stories. However, with this book the pregnancy isn't truly the catalyst binding the group together, which is a refreshing take that I really liked.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Gabrielle Jenkins · Rating 4 out of 5]

This fiery romance is a true page turner, blending heat, heart, and unexpected twists. The chemistry between Grayson, Warren, Tucker, and Sienna is electric, yet balanced with genuine tenderness as they help her rediscover intimacy and pleasure. When an unplanned pregnancy sends her retreating behind emotional walls, the story takes a complex and emotional turn. The men’s steady devotion and patience shine, proving that passion and love can coexist with vulnerability. Ultimately, Sienna's realization that she’s fallen for Warren, Tucker, and Grayson transforms this friends-with-benefits fling into a powerful, unconventional love story.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Pamela Helms · Rating 2 out of 5]

DNF @57% I was SERIOUSLY loving this book. the humor and sexy time! holy crap. but then (SPOILER)





the abx and birth control...come on. three firefighters aren't going to realize that? seriously? these are teens, these are grown men. and then, she's literally still feeling like crap and you think its the right time to bang? for real? I mean, don't get me wrong, I totally kept reading it. but then the suprise pregnancy (which I really dislike as a trope ) and then not letting them come to the appointment!!!! that's one of their kids! I don't care if you THINK you can do it on your own, you can't leave them out!! while I'm sure its all going to be a HEA but it just irritates me and its a personal issue.

[Lindsey Smith · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have not read the first book in this standalone series and I don’t regret it for a second! Regardless of where you start with this series, it doesn’t matter. Lacy does an amazing job of telling you about the first book without revealing too much and ratcheting up the desire to read it as you progress into this book.
Warren, Tucker and Greyson are… everything! They’re amazing and so, absolutely sexy, it makes reading their story all the more hot and steamy.
Sienna is beautiful and a little too independent for my personal tastes when it comes to these 3 men. But, the HEA is everything!!
I loved this book!
I know you will too.

[Angi · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is the second book set in Aspen Springs, it’s also the second book I have read by Lacey Day. I love the characters in this book. She does an incredible job of portraying each one and as you read and the characters develop so does how invested you become in the book. The story line is fantastic. I love that Hadley and her guys from book one are also in and out of the story line. With each book Aspen Springs evolves and makes it easier for the reader to visualize the town. This was a great read and I am looking forward to what happens next in Aspen Sprungs.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Jessica M · Rating 4 out of 5]

Once again Lacey did a great romance novel. I couldn’t put it down. I love how all her books normalize being able to love multiple people at once but this one specifically emphasized how important it is to embrace who you are and that it’s okay to explore. I also loved the found family aspect. While yes, they all knew one another they eventually came together and became a beautiful unique family. My only less than desirable part of the book is the half way/third act “break up”. I’m not one to enjoy the angst ect that comes from it but the HEA is always worth pressing on!

ARC reviewer and so thankful for it!

[sycokittykat - Stefanie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Three firefighters and the girl they fall fo

A one night stand with stranger. Finding out weeks late that stranger was your besties brother. Discovering he isn't the only firefighter that's been crushing on her. 

This is a beautiful family that is built through perseverance, love, understanding and challenges. It isn't traditional but it's not the only family that looks like this in the small town. 

These men were determined to get her to be theirs and to have them all become a family. The family that is built is made of three firefighters, the girl who runs the animal shelter, a the little boy that never had a mother. It was absolutely beautiful. 

[Jane litherland · Rating 5 out of 5]

Three men and a baby vibes with this bliss of a read only these three fellas have all had their fill and she’s been doused plenty with their cream . They’re all a wet dream . Each one brings a different quality to the table so she is surely unable to chose . Why should she ? She has her beefcake and eating it and they’re certainly afire heating her flames of desire higher and higher ,soaring to heady heights of pleasurable release . But now who’s the daddy if you please.Grayson and Sienna and a hook up two years ago .But now there’s a an agreement drawn friends with benefits attached only feelings for each other grew and phew the heat and now there’s a cooing burbling infant to make them complete and they all want to be daddy but there’s no need to compete. They’re in this together the four of them and baby makes five. Man alive was this book hot . Thinking of the dynamics of the plot ,she’s got different personalities to hand and all fit hand to glove they’re in love with her and love to share these firefighters that can go there distance so why not give them all you’ve got ,it’s give and take and she gets a lot back . And phwoar ,I mean come on they’re stacked .

[Jelaina Jones · Rating 1 out of 5]

I am a sucker for a book with a dog. especially when it's the same breed as my dog... but for the love of all things, if you're going to say a specific breed, make sure you have it right. Because there is no such thing as a BURMESE Mountain Dog. I really do try to give authors grace when there are errors because no one is perfect, and one or two spellinv errors won't be the worst thing ever. but this is something that is SO easy to check that it drives me nuts. Not knowing what a word means or using something incorrectly or messing up something that can be googled in .02 seconds well... honestly there's no excuse. Gah.