What do you think?
Rate this book
Five: A Novel
Not yet published
Expected 5 May 26Welcome to Five—once this train has left, there’s no stopping it.
“Razor-sharp, wickedly funny, and darkly thrilling, Five asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark
Someone will die here this morning, at this suburban train station. It will happen in the next five minutes when the 7:06 to London Victoria arrives.
On a train platform, five strangers unknowingly face a chilling countdown. As the clock ticks away, we fall in love with a beautiful young man who is on the verge of gambling his life away. We pity the cantankerous old woman who has fallen to the ground yet is refusing help. We look away from the child throwing a tantrum. We judge his mother, who must surely be to blame? And we are curiously compelled by the successful and damaged businessman, orbiting around them all.
These are the candidates for this morning’s misfortune but they don’t know it. Only you know. And you, our complicit reader, will not be able to resist judging who deserves to walk away, and who deserves only five more minutes to live. Minute by minute, the train gets closer, as we delve into each of their stories to learn what brought them right here, to this moment, to this station, to the very edge of life and death.
A child, a mother, a businessman, an old woman, and a gambler—who would you choose to save? Or die?
“Razor-sharp, wickedly funny, and darkly thrilling, Five asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark
Someone will die here this morning, at this suburban train station. It will happen in the next five minutes when the 7:06 to London Victoria arrives.
On a train platform, five strangers unknowingly face a chilling countdown. As the clock ticks away, we fall in love with a beautiful young man who is on the verge of gambling his life away. We pity the cantankerous old woman who has fallen to the ground yet is refusing help. We look away from the child throwing a tantrum. We judge his mother, who must surely be to blame? And we are curiously compelled by the successful and damaged businessman, orbiting around them all.
These are the candidates for this morning’s misfortune but they don’t know it. Only you know. And you, our complicit reader, will not be able to resist judging who deserves to walk away, and who deserves only five more minutes to live. Minute by minute, the train gets closer, as we delve into each of their stories to learn what brought them right here, to this moment, to this station, to the very edge of life and death.
A child, a mother, a businessman, an old woman, and a gambler—who would you choose to save? Or die?
Kindle Edition
Expected publication May 5, 2026
9 people are currently reading
5558 people want to read
About the author
Ilona Bannister
3 books82 followersIlona Bannister is the author of three books. Her debut novel, When I Ran Away, was long-listed for the Center for Fiction's First Novel Prize in 2021.
Ilona's third book, Five, will be published in May 2026.
Born and raised on Staten Island, Ilona will always be a New Yorker at heart, but she has lived and worked in the UK for almost 20 years with her husband and sons.
Ilona's third book, Five, will be published in May 2026.
Born and raised on Staten Island, Ilona will always be a New Yorker at heart, but she has lived and worked in the UK for almost 20 years with her husband and sons.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
July 28, 2025
Ilona Bannister has written a riveting, ticking time bomb of a novel. Five is brilliant: a gripping tour de force about destiny and choice — and, yes, an oncoming train. I devoured it. You will, too.
November 22, 2025
2.5 stars.
Five strangers. A delayed subway train. An impending death.
The reader is told about the impending death right from the start. An ominous narrator prepares the reader for what is to come and the reader is left to guess which character it will be.
The narrative shifts between this main event and each of the characters lives leading up to this time. The majority of this story takes place in the characters in-depth backstories.
The main story at the underground subway station counts down time to the upcoming death and aims to make the reader feel the suspense and nervousness of the scene. Unfortunately for me, the switches to the lengthy backstories took away any sort of connection or tension felt in the main scene and made the flow choppy. The storyline was lacking the suspense needed to propel the plot forward.
The characters weren’t likeable or interesting so I had no investment in any of their lives. There was an attempt at smug humour that didn’t hit the mark for me either. The switching back to the main scene became repetitive instead of tension-filled as time was counting down.
Overall, I liked the idea of this book but the execution fell flat and I had no connection.
Thank you to the publisher for my review copy!
Expected date of publication : May 5, 2026
Five strangers. A delayed subway train. An impending death.
The reader is told about the impending death right from the start. An ominous narrator prepares the reader for what is to come and the reader is left to guess which character it will be.
The narrative shifts between this main event and each of the characters lives leading up to this time. The majority of this story takes place in the characters in-depth backstories.
The main story at the underground subway station counts down time to the upcoming death and aims to make the reader feel the suspense and nervousness of the scene. Unfortunately for me, the switches to the lengthy backstories took away any sort of connection or tension felt in the main scene and made the flow choppy. The storyline was lacking the suspense needed to propel the plot forward.
The characters weren’t likeable or interesting so I had no investment in any of their lives. There was an attempt at smug humour that didn’t hit the mark for me either. The switching back to the main scene became repetitive instead of tension-filled as time was counting down.
Overall, I liked the idea of this book but the execution fell flat and I had no connection.
Thank you to the publisher for my review copy!
Expected date of publication : May 5, 2026
October 8, 2025
ARC for review. To be published May 5, 2026.
3.5 stars
A child, his mother, an old lady, a businessman and a gambler. In just a few short minutes one of them is going to die in this train station and why?
We learn about the back stories of all five and, and this is the charm….really, it is….you’ll be kind of happy that one of them is going to die and you’ll wonder if it can be arranged for more to go down too. Sadly, though, only one bites it.
This book was a bit of hurry up and wait and a couple of the back stories were a bit too long (Mrs. Worth’s especially.). However, I’m a big fan of flawed people and there were so many here, this was enjoyable. If you read this, please DM me with your choice about who SHOULD HAVE been the one to die. I’m interested to see how yours matches up with mine. Solid writing. Recommended.
3.5 stars
A child, his mother, an old lady, a businessman and a gambler. In just a few short minutes one of them is going to die in this train station and why?
We learn about the back stories of all five and, and this is the charm….really, it is….you’ll be kind of happy that one of them is going to die and you’ll wonder if it can be arranged for more to go down too. Sadly, though, only one bites it.
This book was a bit of hurry up and wait and a couple of the back stories were a bit too long (Mrs. Worth’s especially.). However, I’m a big fan of flawed people and there were so many here, this was enjoyable. If you read this, please DM me with your choice about who SHOULD HAVE been the one to die. I’m interested to see how yours matches up with mine. Solid writing. Recommended.
October 6, 2025
What is it with books promising one thing and giving something completely different?
This book promised that of five characters, one would die within five minutes. That suggested a fast-paced thriller.
Ha! Think again.
This book was so sluggish, the characters could have walked to their destination faster than it took to get to the point.
The one rule that was supposedly set in stone (a person would die in five minutes) was nearly immediately changed. We readers are expected to "forgive this" because of a plethora of excuses that were given, one being that it's set in England.
You can't blame a whole country on poor planning for your book, honey.
Then, every time there was a sense of urgency that dared to pick up the pace, we jumped into a lengthy chapter that was the entirety of a character's backstory, including the backstory of several, if not all, of their relatives.
What? Why!
Whole chapters of backstory that had absolutely zero to do with the current plot only served to slam the brakes on the forward progress of the story. Do please refrain from doing this in future, yeah?
The characters themselves... There were some issues there too. Taking stereotypes like psychopathy, narcissism, promiscuity, and merely exaggerating them to the point of nauseum does not make intriguing character development. It definitely doesn't showcase the author's skills and creativity.
"One of them will die despite your attachment to them." What attachment? They're all complete jerks in one way or the other. There was little to like about them to begin with, and everything went downhill from there with the chapters of exposition about their entire lives from birth, if not generations before. Nope. No attachment to the characters for me.
Also, if you're going to name a few characters Medical Student and To Do List and Bad Back, maybe don't make them as prominent as the actual named characters. These three had just as much to do with the story as Sonny and "Mrs." Worth and Gideon. There was absolutely no reason not to go ahead and give them real first names.
"Let us review their positions, just this one last time." Why? You've already told us their positions. We certainly don't need to hear it again. If you feel you have to retell us this information, maybe cut out the backstory dumps so you don't think we've forgotten why we're reading the book in the first place.
This is basically two books in a row that promised a high-octane action story that fell completely flat because of heavy-handed backstory dumps and buckets and buckets of telling (the other being Handle with Care by Marybeth Mayhew Whalen). Honestly, both of these stories felt like they were very rough first drafts.
Please, authors, study up on the craft of writing. Practice, practice, practice! And find a critique group, beta readers, a decent developmental editor--somebody!--who will help you identify when you're in backstory dump territory.
Also, please, please, please stop with the telling (instead of showing) presentation. Just because you stick the story in second-person POV does not mean telling to the max (with very little showing) is appropriate or helpful.
"Perhaps you could take a poll at book club..." What an arrogant assumption to make, that readers would be taking this book to book club. Hard pass on that one.
Turned out, the only things I liked about this book were the cover and the premise.
Content: profanity, expletives, gratuitous premarital sex, Catholicism, alcohol, prescription drug abuse/addiction, gambling, psychopathic child
This book promised that of five characters, one would die within five minutes. That suggested a fast-paced thriller.
Ha! Think again.
This book was so sluggish, the characters could have walked to their destination faster than it took to get to the point.
The one rule that was supposedly set in stone (a person would die in five minutes) was nearly immediately changed. We readers are expected to "forgive this" because of a plethora of excuses that were given, one being that it's set in England.
You can't blame a whole country on poor planning for your book, honey.
Then, every time there was a sense of urgency that dared to pick up the pace, we jumped into a lengthy chapter that was the entirety of a character's backstory, including the backstory of several, if not all, of their relatives.
What? Why!
Whole chapters of backstory that had absolutely zero to do with the current plot only served to slam the brakes on the forward progress of the story. Do please refrain from doing this in future, yeah?
The characters themselves... There were some issues there too. Taking stereotypes like psychopathy, narcissism, promiscuity, and merely exaggerating them to the point of nauseum does not make intriguing character development. It definitely doesn't showcase the author's skills and creativity.
"One of them will die despite your attachment to them." What attachment? They're all complete jerks in one way or the other. There was little to like about them to begin with, and everything went downhill from there with the chapters of exposition about their entire lives from birth, if not generations before. Nope. No attachment to the characters for me.
Also, if you're going to name a few characters Medical Student and To Do List and Bad Back, maybe don't make them as prominent as the actual named characters. These three had just as much to do with the story as Sonny and "Mrs." Worth and Gideon. There was absolutely no reason not to go ahead and give them real first names.
"Let us review their positions, just this one last time." Why? You've already told us their positions. We certainly don't need to hear it again. If you feel you have to retell us this information, maybe cut out the backstory dumps so you don't think we've forgotten why we're reading the book in the first place.
This is basically two books in a row that promised a high-octane action story that fell completely flat because of heavy-handed backstory dumps and buckets and buckets of telling (the other being Handle with Care by Marybeth Mayhew Whalen). Honestly, both of these stories felt like they were very rough first drafts.
Please, authors, study up on the craft of writing. Practice, practice, practice! And find a critique group, beta readers, a decent developmental editor--somebody!--who will help you identify when you're in backstory dump territory.
Also, please, please, please stop with the telling (instead of showing) presentation. Just because you stick the story in second-person POV does not mean telling to the max (with very little showing) is appropriate or helpful.
"Perhaps you could take a poll at book club..." What an arrogant assumption to make, that readers would be taking this book to book club. Hard pass on that one.
Turned out, the only things I liked about this book were the cover and the premise.
Content: profanity, expletives, gratuitous premarital sex, Catholicism, alcohol, prescription drug abuse/addiction, gambling, psychopathic child
November 16, 2025
Five
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
August 13, 2025
This was such a well narrated witty, sharp, and fascinating story. A death will occur to one of 5 characters within minutes but as the reader, we don’t know who it is yet. Until that death arrives, we see chaos unfold on a train platform and we learn the background of the 5 characters. This book made me think and as I learned about each person, I would begin to think that surely it would be them who dies. But then I’d change my mind when I read about the next one. This was a most entertaining and enjoyable read where the book is narrated directly to us the reader.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 28, 2025
THIS BOOK! It's listed as a thriller sometimes and I have to say, it's not that. If you go in expecting that you perhaps will be disappointed. The writing is phenomenal, the narration is so unique and clever. It's the story of five lives, complicated, nuanced and all fairly extraordinary. You have to suspend belief that all of these people have ended up at this moment in time together, but who knows, maybe we are all standing on a platform with our own stories. The sense of time and place, the beauty and atmosphere in the very ordinary details are incredibly memorable.
November 16, 2025
Five
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
November 9, 2025
Five
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
By Ilona Bannister
Release Date 05/05/2026
The moment the 7:06 train heading to London Victoria arrives, someone will die. Gideon, a young boy who has caused trouble for his mother Emma since birth, has drained her energy and savings. He is brilliant and a sociopath.
Emma, Gideon’s mother, is also a sociopath—diabolical and unbothered by others' opinions—and I find her character fascinating. She is wealthy and speaks her mind freely.
Mrs. Worth is 78 and excited to visit her grandsons for the first time in years.
Sonny, 27, struggles with an online gambling addiction but possesses a charming personality that lets him get away with things others cannot.
Liam, in his mid-fifties, is attractive, wealthy, and commuting by train solely to talk to Emma.
You will dive into the 5s backgrounds and learn why and what brings them all to the platform that day. I enjoyed diving into those chapters the most.
If you’re in a book slump and need something to read that isn’t like anything you’ve read before, I highly recommend this book.
5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️S҉҉T҉҉A҉҉R҉҉S҉҉
#crownpublishing #penguinrandomhouse #ilonabannister #five#thrillerreads #5starbook #arcbook #addthistoyourTBR #2026thrillerreads #bookstragram #hashtags4ever
September 15, 2025
(I read this as an ARC; there didn't seem to be a book-version available on here...)
This was a very unusual way to tell a story, but I really enjoyed it! It's like 5 mini-stories plus an overarching narrative. I found the mix of perspectives and breaking the fourth wall to make for a very engaging read. Bannister is a great storyteller, pulling you in with the charged opening - someone is going to die, but who? - and then gradually ramping up the tension, releasing it with backstory, and ramping it up again as the backstories overlap and the moment of truth nears.
It was a fun and quick read and I wasn't entirely sure where it would go, which was delightful. I particularly enjoyed the snarky asides as the omnipotent narrator of the contemporary segments talked through who deserved to die - it made me squirmy and uncomfortable in the best possible way. This was a cool story and I'm already looking for more from Ilona Bannister!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
This was a very unusual way to tell a story, but I really enjoyed it! It's like 5 mini-stories plus an overarching narrative. I found the mix of perspectives and breaking the fourth wall to make for a very engaging read. Bannister is a great storyteller, pulling you in with the charged opening - someone is going to die, but who? - and then gradually ramping up the tension, releasing it with backstory, and ramping it up again as the backstories overlap and the moment of truth nears.
It was a fun and quick read and I wasn't entirely sure where it would go, which was delightful. I particularly enjoyed the snarky asides as the omnipotent narrator of the contemporary segments talked through who deserved to die - it made me squirmy and uncomfortable in the best possible way. This was a cool story and I'm already looking for more from Ilona Bannister!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my obligation-free review copy.
October 1, 2025
Five is the story of a child, a mother, a businessman, an old woman, and a gambler, (unrelated) waiting on a platform for a commuter train. One of them, however, is fated to die in 5 minutes when the train arrives. This novel is incredibly well crafted! Each one of their life stories has so much depth, breadth, and interest that they became real people. Outside of their lives, Ilona Banister is a master storyteller in that I felt like a physical observer waiting on the train with them. The pace of the story is perfect, it neither drug on unnecessarily nor rushed through to get to the next thought. I enjoyed the back and forth of getting to know them and moving with them to the train station. I really enjoyed how full and fleshed out they were in their pasts, presents, and futures. This is a book I’ll without a doubt read again (and again!) and recommend.
Thank you to Crown Publishing for this ARC via NetGalley!
Thank you to Crown Publishing for this ARC via NetGalley!
December 6, 2025
This novel begins with 5 people on a train station platform. In five minutes one of them will be dead. Which one will it be? The old woman, the young gambler, the businessman, the mother, or her disruptive child. I thought this would be a thriller, but it isn't; it's much more and much deeper than that.
Ilona Bannister’s writing is incredibly and precisely sharp and witty, with just enough dry sarcasm. The narrator takes us into the backstory of each character and in doing so shows us each flawed person's messy struggles, their shadows and hidden history. There is also woven through their stories a powerful thread on motherhood, of a mother’s love, absence, and sacrifice.
Five is an exceptional book of resilience and unexpected hope. I liked it, recommend it and am looking forward to reading more from Ilona Bannister.
Thank you to Juniper, HU, and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 26, 2025
Review of ‘Five’ by Ilona Bannister, due to be published on 5 May 2026 by HQ, Juniper.
A highly original, exciting concept for a novel - five passengers stand on a train platform - in 5 minutes the train will arrive and one of them (the mother, the child, the businessman, the gambler and the old lady) will lose their life, will it be an accident or intentional - only time, short as it is, will tell.
Told in a narrative style, real time events are interwoven with character backstories. We find out who they are, how their life before the events of the day feed into who they have become. On the face of it, they are one thing, but their stories show that they are not all as they appear to be to the outside world.
The cleverly written plotting and style lead you to have your assumptions about who you think should die and who actually will die. You find yourself desperate for some character flaws to be redeemed in the storytelling before the clock runs out.
The suspense is whipped up to fever pitch, with a slow drip feed of who has survived, with a glimpse at their future selves and how the events of that fateful day have shaped their life going forwards. The reveal of who dies comes late on in the book and was a fitting ending to a dramatic storyline that is entirely believable. I loved every second of it, and highly recommend.
A highly original, exciting concept for a novel - five passengers stand on a train platform - in 5 minutes the train will arrive and one of them (the mother, the child, the businessman, the gambler and the old lady) will lose their life, will it be an accident or intentional - only time, short as it is, will tell.
Told in a narrative style, real time events are interwoven with character backstories. We find out who they are, how their life before the events of the day feed into who they have become. On the face of it, they are one thing, but their stories show that they are not all as they appear to be to the outside world.
The cleverly written plotting and style lead you to have your assumptions about who you think should die and who actually will die. You find yourself desperate for some character flaws to be redeemed in the storytelling before the clock runs out.
The suspense is whipped up to fever pitch, with a slow drip feed of who has survived, with a glimpse at their future selves and how the events of that fateful day have shaped their life going forwards. The reveal of who dies comes late on in the book and was a fitting ending to a dramatic storyline that is entirely believable. I loved every second of it, and highly recommend.
November 15, 2025
My favorite line in the whole book!! “Fear has a sound. It is hard to recognize because we only hear it once or twice in our lives.” I enjoyed the book from the very beginning. It’s an easy read but keeps you on your toes at the same time.
October 28, 2025
This book was different than I thought it would be. But it was incredible. I thought it was going to be like a guess who dies at the end and I guess it was kinda that but also not really. To me this book was about love and loss and grief and life. What it is to be a mother. How people can express love in so many different ways. How even the smallest moments can drastically shape someone's life and future. And it was beautiful and heartbreaking but also healing. As someone who has suffered immense loss and has children with special needs/disabilities/neurodiverse qualities this book really hit home and I found myself sobbing more than a few times. This book was so clearly a labor of love and I would highly recommend it.
August 18, 2025
At a suburban London station, five strangers—a child, his mother, a businessman, an old woman, and a gambler—are on a collision course. In five minutes, someone dies when the 7:06 arrives.
But who?
We know one of the characters is going to die, but we don’t know which one. Bannister invites the reader into the lives of each "candidate", in that process forcing the reader to examine his or her own prejudices about who they might want to live or pick to die. The author is a thoughtful and shrewd observer of human nature, both that of her characters AND that of the reader. The reader is made complicit in judging who “deserves” to live and the minute-by-minute structure is inherently propulsive and cinematic; Bannister's character-first storytelling of ordinary lives under pressure gets a heighted analysis with the presence of a ticking clock. As I got to know each character my emotions whipsawed as to who I would "pick" to die.
In the end, I picked the wrong person, so there’s that!! Bannister is a gifted writer with some very profound insights into the human condition. I highly recommend this book and look forward to reading more of her work.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
But who?
We know one of the characters is going to die, but we don’t know which one. Bannister invites the reader into the lives of each "candidate", in that process forcing the reader to examine his or her own prejudices about who they might want to live or pick to die. The author is a thoughtful and shrewd observer of human nature, both that of her characters AND that of the reader. The reader is made complicit in judging who “deserves” to live and the minute-by-minute structure is inherently propulsive and cinematic; Bannister's character-first storytelling of ordinary lives under pressure gets a heighted analysis with the presence of a ticking clock. As I got to know each character my emotions whipsawed as to who I would "pick" to die.
In the end, I picked the wrong person, so there’s that!! Bannister is a gifted writer with some very profound insights into the human condition. I highly recommend this book and look forward to reading more of her work.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC!
August 24, 2025
Five people on a train platform, 1 will die five minutes from the start of the book. This concept just drew me in, but I found the pace to be slower than I expected.
The opening of this book is so interesting and hooks you in, but then we jump out of the action and learn more about one of the characters who may die.
This character study was clever as it made the reader feel a particular way about the character, but it also, unfortunately, jumped me out of the story that drew me in the first place.
The book then alternates between talking directly to the reader in timed sections and giving you background on each of the characters.
This is a super short book at 200 pages (for the proof copy), but some of the chapters were so long, so don't go in expecting a quick read and I think this is where I went wrong.
I would definitely read a book by this author again, I would just know to expect a slower read.
The opening of this book is so interesting and hooks you in, but then we jump out of the action and learn more about one of the characters who may die.
This character study was clever as it made the reader feel a particular way about the character, but it also, unfortunately, jumped me out of the story that drew me in the first place.
The book then alternates between talking directly to the reader in timed sections and giving you background on each of the characters.
This is a super short book at 200 pages (for the proof copy), but some of the chapters were so long, so don't go in expecting a quick read and I think this is where I went wrong.
I would definitely read a book by this author again, I would just know to expect a slower read.
October 9, 2025
Five by Ilona Bannister. Thanks to @crownbooks for the gifted Arc ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Five strangers face each other on a London subway platform. In five minutes one of them will die.
This is a very special book! It is such a unique and individual story, yet the characters and events so ordinary. We get to know each character very well, liking even the less likable ones because we see why they are how they are. I could not put this one down and highly recommend it!
“He will marvel at how extraordinary ordinary people are. So loyal to life that they demand living from everyone. Even him.”
Five comes out 5/5.
Five strangers face each other on a London subway platform. In five minutes one of them will die.
This is a very special book! It is such a unique and individual story, yet the characters and events so ordinary. We get to know each character very well, liking even the less likable ones because we see why they are how they are. I could not put this one down and highly recommend it!
“He will marvel at how extraordinary ordinary people are. So loyal to life that they demand living from everyone. Even him.”
Five comes out 5/5.
October 7, 2025
Thank you Juniper for the Galley!
Storytelling at its finest, Five follows the connective threads of all the people at a train platform during a tragedy. All of these people are complicated, most of them unlikable, and you’ll be fascinated by the question “which of these people will die?” As the narrator astutely observes, I did, in fact, have characters I wanted to live and others I was fine to throw on the tracks. A compelling read I couldn’t put down!
Storytelling at its finest, Five follows the connective threads of all the people at a train platform during a tragedy. All of these people are complicated, most of them unlikable, and you’ll be fascinated by the question “which of these people will die?” As the narrator astutely observes, I did, in fact, have characters I wanted to live and others I was fine to throw on the tracks. A compelling read I couldn’t put down!
June 19, 2025
Really enjoyed reading this. Gripping story, it kept me hooked the whole time. I also really liked the narration style!
August 10, 2025
'Five' by Ilona Bannister is a 5 star thrilling read.
Five passengers are waiting for a train, but you are told early in the book that one dies shortly. It could be Mrs Worth, an old lady who feels she failed at being a mother, Sonny, who has an addiction that is invading his whole life, Emma, the mother of the child Gideon, who displays challenging behaviour or lastly Liam, a successful businessman.
To reach the explosive conclusion you hear the stories of each character and soon find that each has a backstory that is unexpected.
I absolutely loved the characterisation in this book; when reading about each character you are taken through a range of emotions.
This book really does grip you and I wish I could read from the beginning all over again. I stayed up way past my bedtime to finish this one!
Amazing and highly recommended.
Thanks to the author, the publishers, Juniper and Theakstons Crime Writing Festival for allowing me to receive a proof of this amazing book.
Five passengers are waiting for a train, but you are told early in the book that one dies shortly. It could be Mrs Worth, an old lady who feels she failed at being a mother, Sonny, who has an addiction that is invading his whole life, Emma, the mother of the child Gideon, who displays challenging behaviour or lastly Liam, a successful businessman.
To reach the explosive conclusion you hear the stories of each character and soon find that each has a backstory that is unexpected.
I absolutely loved the characterisation in this book; when reading about each character you are taken through a range of emotions.
This book really does grip you and I wish I could read from the beginning all over again. I stayed up way past my bedtime to finish this one!
Amazing and highly recommended.
Thanks to the author, the publishers, Juniper and Theakstons Crime Writing Festival for allowing me to receive a proof of this amazing book.
July 28, 2025
Five passengers waiting for a train. Five minutes before one of them dies. Five stories of life, which would you choose to die?
This one definitely gets better as you move through the book. At times the first section felt somewhat forced, using thousands of a second breakdowns to describe decisions and actions. The book hit a gear shift when the backstories of the passengers starts. Each story is unexpected in its own way, and introduces dilemmas for the reader, challenging notions you had about each character and your opinion on them from the opening section. My particular favourite, and entirely not what I expected, was the Ms Worth storyline (loved it!)
The ending was pretty solid, but I must admit to an intense dislike to being spoken to as the reader. References to discussions I could have at book clubs, or attempts by the author to speak to the reader don’t sit well with me.
Overall, definitely worth a read!
This one definitely gets better as you move through the book. At times the first section felt somewhat forced, using thousands of a second breakdowns to describe decisions and actions. The book hit a gear shift when the backstories of the passengers starts. Each story is unexpected in its own way, and introduces dilemmas for the reader, challenging notions you had about each character and your opinion on them from the opening section. My particular favourite, and entirely not what I expected, was the Ms Worth storyline (loved it!)
The ending was pretty solid, but I must admit to an intense dislike to being spoken to as the reader. References to discussions I could have at book clubs, or attempts by the author to speak to the reader don’t sit well with me.
Overall, definitely worth a read!
October 19, 2025
2.5/5 - I went into this book expecting a thrilling story that would leave me guessing until the very last moment but ultimately this read fell flat. After a gripping first chapter I was met with a completely different writing style as each character had their own “life” story that helps us decide on whether we think they should be the one who experiences this guaranteed death. Sadly, most of these stories dragged along and a few felt a little repetitive or like they were tying to prove the same point. When we would go back to the “live” chapters at the train station, the writing felt repetitive and the breaks to speak straight to us, the reader, felt forced and continued to throw off the flow of writing. However I did appreciate the final chapter where everyone’s story came to a solid end on their present lives and we catch a glimpse of what the future holds for them after this traumatic event. Thank you to NetGalley and Crown Publishing for giving me the chance to read this e-arc!
December 12, 2025
This book took a lot of risks and in my opinion they paid off. The biggest two were the use of second person point of view, and, therefore, breaking the third wall. Some people may not be able to get past that, but it works and it enhances the story…which was obviously the whole point but I digress.
Five main characters is a lot to juggle and the author did so masterfully. I didn’t find that I needed or wanted to know any more or less than what was written which is truly a feat. Actually, I’d argue one of the side characters could have been made a main character but the story would have been longer and more complicated and it works well without that addition so it’s fine.
Altogether I loved the plot, the twists, the backgrounds, the themes, and so on and so forth.
OH I almost forgot!! The representation for ADHD here was superb!!!! I found myself thinking that Ilona Bannister did a lot of thorough research to get such an accurate portrayal. I was very impressed from both someone who has ADHD and as a therapist for mental health.
Thank you Crown Publishing and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC! My opinions are my own and I highly recommend this book for those who love psychological mysteries (I wouldn’t classify it as a typical thriller though it does maintain suspense throughout the entire story and there are twists).
Five main characters is a lot to juggle and the author did so masterfully. I didn’t find that I needed or wanted to know any more or less than what was written which is truly a feat. Actually, I’d argue one of the side characters could have been made a main character but the story would have been longer and more complicated and it works well without that addition so it’s fine.
Altogether I loved the plot, the twists, the backgrounds, the themes, and so on and so forth.
OH I almost forgot!! The representation for ADHD here was superb!!!! I found myself thinking that Ilona Bannister did a lot of thorough research to get such an accurate portrayal. I was very impressed from both someone who has ADHD and as a therapist for mental health.
Thank you Crown Publishing and NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read this ARC! My opinions are my own and I highly recommend this book for those who love psychological mysteries (I wouldn’t classify it as a typical thriller though it does maintain suspense throughout the entire story and there are twists).
October 18, 2025
Five is absolutely brilliant from beginning to end. Even the acknowledgement at the end of the book is brilliantly written. Ilona Bannister is a truly talented writer. Five strangers are all waiting for the 7:06 train to London, and we know one of them will die. We learn about each of their back stories and why they each happened to be at the station that morning. It's very uniquely written. At times, the writer speaks directly to the reader, which just draws you more into the story and turning the pages to find out what will happen and why. This was easily one of my favorite books of the year. Thanks to NetGalley and Crown for the ARC.
October 13, 2025
My perspective on this book differs from the prevailing reviews. I struggled to engage with the narrative and found it challenging to follow. The characters failed to resonate with me, leaving me feeling disconnected. Although the latter half of the book improved somewhat, "Five" by Ilona Barrista ultimately did not leave a lasting impression on me.
July 14, 2025
HaroerCollins PR were out in force at Capital Crime a couple of weeks ago, and I was happy to pick up a proof of the first title in their new Juniper imprint.
Due to be published in May 2026, Five by Ilona Bannister lets us get to know a group of people whose stories are linked by their ending up at a commuter station in time for the 7:06am service to kill one of them.
Yes, you read that correctly - while some novels are Whodunnits and some are Whydunnits, this one challenges us to work out which person dies. And, more importantly, how we feel about it.
Trigger warning, obviously, for rail accidents, but if you are able to read about that, it’s one of the cleverest literary devices you’ll come across. Highly recommended.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
📚AD-PR 🙏 Juniper
Due to be published in May 2026, Five by Ilona Bannister lets us get to know a group of people whose stories are linked by their ending up at a commuter station in time for the 7:06am service to kill one of them.
Yes, you read that correctly - while some novels are Whodunnits and some are Whydunnits, this one challenges us to work out which person dies. And, more importantly, how we feel about it.
Trigger warning, obviously, for rail accidents, but if you are able to read about that, it’s one of the cleverest literary devices you’ll come across. Highly recommended.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
📚AD-PR 🙏 Juniper
December 21, 2025
What an extremely interesting read. From the beginning you are aware that one of the main characters is going to die...but which one? Through the use of back stories we learn what brings them all to the tube station at the same time. It's a tense and gripping tale that I raced through. Ilona Bannister writes well and her clever plot is unlike any I've read before. For me 'Five: A Novel' was highly enjoyable and one I'm happy to recommend. Thank you to the publisher, author and netgalley for an ARC.
October 14, 2025
Thanks to the publisher @Ilonabannister #Ilonabannister and @netgalley #netgalley
Wow! This book was incredible!
The characters were very very well developed. The pacing and the tension was phenomenal. There were many perspectives gleaned. The book brings you completely into the life of each character. Not in the long drawn out confusing moving back and forth between characters that is seen almost all the time.
The style of writing was wonderful. The book just flowed perfectly.
The book was a very satisfying thriller and a 5+Star read for me. I hope to read more of this Author.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Wow! This book was incredible!
The characters were very very well developed. The pacing and the tension was phenomenal. There were many perspectives gleaned. The book brings you completely into the life of each character. Not in the long drawn out confusing moving back and forth between characters that is seen almost all the time.
The style of writing was wonderful. The book just flowed perfectly.
The book was a very satisfying thriller and a 5+Star read for me. I hope to read more of this Author.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
August 24, 2025
Five stars for Five! This was a really good book, and I rarely give a book 5 stars, also my first 5 star NetGalley read! The premise was cool, the writing was great, and I really felt like I not only knew the characters, but the narrator was really a character in the book too, without actually being a character.
The book starts out on a train platform and informs you that one of the people there are going to die. You don't know which one or how, but you start to watch the events play out on the tracks while also learning about each of the players involved!
Going between second and third person in the story, Ilona Bannister really pulled me into the story, where I felt she was talking to me and personally introducing me to everyone. It was meatier than a beach read, but still a page turner, and I had to find out what happened next and who it was going to be! Loved it!!!
Thank you NetGalley and Crown Publishing for an advanced reader copy. All opinions are my own.
The book starts out on a train platform and informs you that one of the people there are going to die. You don't know which one or how, but you start to watch the events play out on the tracks while also learning about each of the players involved!
Going between second and third person in the story, Ilona Bannister really pulled me into the story, where I felt she was talking to me and personally introducing me to everyone. It was meatier than a beach read, but still a page turner, and I had to find out what happened next and who it was going to be! Loved it!!!
Thank you NetGalley and Crown Publishing for an advanced reader copy. All opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews