A compelling journey through science's big breakthroughs, by an award-winning Australian science writer
Humans developed the scientific method over centuries. Its departure from what came before was that theories should be fuelled by data, not opinion. Today, the institutions that underpin democracy – the law, academia, government, journalism – all rely on its central idea: seeking facts and interrogating them through robust discussion and real-world testing. Yet in the post-truth era, public conversations can feel far from scientific.
In Prove It, Elizabeth Finkel describes how the scientific method plays out in a series of controversies, from proving the existence of Einstein’s gravitational waves to identifying the origins of Covid-19, from understanding human origins to defining consciousness. Through these tales of dispute and discovery, she breaks down the key elements of scientific thinking.
Full of politics, prejudice, obsession, heroism and eccentricity, Prove It captures the drama and excitement of scientific discovery and debate and argues compellingly that its lessons are more crucial now than ever.
Elizabeth Finkel’s latest book “Prove It – A Scientific Guide for the Post-Truth Era,” provides readers with a fascinating set of stories about how science works in some of the most contentious and controversial areas.
“What distinguishes science from conspiracy is that science rejects assertions that fail to clear the bar of evidence.”
It uncovers the truths about COVID’s origins, digs deep on whether medicine is science or art, looks at whether humans really originated in Africa, asks where the seat of our consciousness lies, and takes us to the ends of the universe to find the proofs for gravitational waves.
‘Prove It’ is, in short, brilliant, highly readable and incredibly relevant in an era where the President of the United States is shutting down scientific research, giving tyrannical powers over healthcare to an anti-vaxxer, and sacking anyone who speaks truth to power or who is insufficiently loyal.
As the disenfranchised margins of our cultures are lured by parasitic social media influencers, dazed by disinformation, and attracted to the certainties peddled by Newscorp and Far-right proxies for the corporate sector like the Advance Australia organisation, conspiracy theories are on the rise, and science is the enemy.
Vaccines, which save millions, are demonised as ‘deadly’, the science helping us understand climate is said to be a ‘hoax’, the inequities of global capital are ignored and replaced with claims of a secret ‘deep state’ and ‘global control by Jewish bankers’.
These beliefs are used by politicians on the Right to leverage their own agendas of power and influence, who wage war on science, claiming to supplant it with ‘choice’, ‘freedom from censorship’ and the primacy of ‘personal truth’ so that they, and only they can be trusted purveyors of truth.
Meanwhile, RFK Jnr is dismantling vaccine production and preparedness for the next pandemic. His delusional, anti-science dictates will cause deaths on a vast scale before he and his cronies are thrown out, and the US rediscovers science.
But where the US leads, Australia follows, so Finkel’s book couldn’t be more critical here in helping understand what science actually is and does, how it fails and how it will always self-correct.
You don’t have to ‘believe’ or trust science as the only ‘truth’, because science isn’t about proving things; science is about discovering better questions and evidence to challenge standing theory.
Truth is always conditional.
“Our health, our agriculture, our environmental safety, our ability to ameliorate and adapt to climate change, to regulate AI and to fight the next pandemic – all of these rely on our scientific system functioning as we know it must: through the generation of evidence, and rigorous testing of that evidence.”
A very readable dive into how science advances our understanding. The book uses COVID, evolution, medicine, consciousness, and gravitational waves to demonstrate how different approaches help uncover deeper truths. It is both a great review of these well documented areas and a reminder of how difficult each approach can be.
Finkel keeps the call to arms for science in the intro and epilogue. This worked well for me. Both are almost standalone essays on the current threats to science. They bookend examples that convey the need for scientific institutions. I would have appreciated a bit more on the importance of funding and the costs associated with research. This would have strengthened arguments on the role of government.
I recommend for anyone interested in how science progresses and the topics themselves.
Many years ago a conservative friend and FOX watcher asked me in all seriousness, “With all of the conflicting information on any subject, really, how is it even possible to know the truth?” Elizabeth Finkel shares the answer in this brilliant book which should be required reading for everyone. Even in this world of disinformation we find ourselves in, facts and the truth are knowable and testable. It is at our own peril that we choose instead to follow demagogues who begin with a cherished premise that speaks to our biases and cherry pick ‘facts’ to support them. Finkel, holding a PhD in biochemistry and spent 10 years as a research scientist, reacquaintes us with such fundamental tools as the Scientific Method and the truth pyramid to separate fact from propagandistic fiction. Recommended without hesitation or qualification.
Favourite Quotes: “The smaller the study, the more the gremlins of chance can muddy the results.” “Misinformation thrives in a vacuum.” “How wonderful that we have met with a paradox, now we have some hope of making progress.” — Niels Bohr “If Nobel prizes were handed out for curing life-threatening diseases in a Petri dish, then I and virtually every translational research scientist would have one.” — Jorge Caballero
This was easily one of my favourite non-fictions. The author writes with passion, consideration and satire (she called the rapid mutations of SARS a ‘viral orgy’).
The book explores five big scientific puzzles: (1) COVID-19 Origins, (2) Human Origins, (3) Evidence-Based Medicine, (4) Human Consciousness, and (5) Gravitational Waves. I particularly enjoyed the COVID-19 and gravitational waves sections. I admit that some scientific background would help but I have little to no physics background and I still survived special relativity and black holes.
The main takeaway for me was how messy science is. Even brilliant researchers change their minds. Einstein went back and forth on gravitational waves, questions around the origins of COVID-19 are still contested and human’s evolutionary origins may never be answered. But she paints it so that the uncertainty isn’t a failure of science, it’s part of the process.
Given my background in medical research, the medicine chapter (Chpt 3) was particularly confronting. It highlighted how bad research flourishes when personality, money, and politics are given more weight than the data itself. The hydroxychloroquine and vaccine controversies being the most prominent modern examples. It also led me to consider how the scalability of biological research can lead to manipulation for financial gain (e.g., lying about the effectiveness of a medication to boost sales).
The biggest takeaway is that good scientists are willing to be wrong. Theories should be tested, challenged and revied rather than boldly accepted due to reputation. The modern issue being that this healthy uncertainty is exploited by critics who expect science to deliver perfect answers.
Good stuff! This Australian author mounts a defence of the scientific method, specifically evidence-based theories. In this increasingly conspiracy-based world of ‘alternative facts’, Ms Finkel offers several examples of ‘follow the evidence’, starting with Covid-19. She also has (large) chapters on human origins, medical science, human consciousness and gravitational waves. Some of her theories and reasoning went over my head, but in all cases, she followed the science. A good book for our times. Might upgrade her to 4.5/5.
In a world where increasing misinformation and disinformation too often lead to poor decisions by institutions and individuals, this book reminds us of the usefulness of science in finding the truth. The examples of scientific issues the author describes in detail are fascinating and show the complexity of the issues, the rigorous approach to data and analysis and the breadth of debate in the scientific community.
This was a fantastic book. It is really interesting seeing the ‘thinking process’ to get to understanding some of the conundrums that we have faced. It took me back to my first philosophy courses and prompted me to pick up some of these old textbooks and re-read them. The philosophy of science and the scientific method really is like a cognitive discipline and managing our cognitive biases as best we can. This book shows the importance of this discipline to all of us.