Audiobook Review
I’m still in the mood for Christmas romances, and I’m always on the lookout for new-to-me authors and narrators. This one ticked all the boxes: Hallmark fans craving a nanny/single dad tale with a touch of Christmas magic set in London will likely eat this up. Personally, I had hoped for more.
The story and its characters left me wanting. The two main leads felt too perfect—except for Miles being an unbearable snob. Both he and Saoirse are too good-looking, too nice, too generous, and fall in love—and into bed—way too fast.
Doesn’t help that the plot feels dated, with references to specific dates and the lockdown. And as I’ve mentioned in other reviews, protection isn’t just about pregnancy prevention. Then there is the last hour of the audiobook. It couldn’t recover from the predictable third-act breakup, and I found myself speeding up the playback just to get to the end.
Much of what happens is implausible, but as a Christmas fairy tale, it works to an extent. The story does whisk you away to London during the holiday season, albeit a very posh version of it, and includes several iconic sights. However, it’s the narrators’ spirited performances that breathe some life—if not originality—into the story.
This was my first time listening to KC Sheridan and Zara Hampton Brown. KC Sheridan’s strong Irish accent was enjoyable, and I liked Zara Hampton Brown’s portrayal of a spoiled but sweet four-year-old. However, her voicing of other adult female characters in a similar style felt unsettling.
As for Shane East—this was the second audiobook in a row where he voiced the main male character, and I remain mostly… well, unimpressed, I guess. His breathy delivery is very much, “I’m performing a romance novel hero,” which seems to work for many of his fans but sadly not for me. It feels exaggerated—too much. Here, it made it hard to picture Miles as the entitled Englishman he’s meant to be. I believe a more understated performance would have suited him much better. Perhaps my reaction is influenced by my years of living, studying, and working in London, as well as my frequent visits. Can’t be helped. I’m not giving up on him yet, though, as I do enjoy his “normal” delivery.
✨ Story: 2 stars
✨ Narration: 3 stars