What do you think?
Rate this book
The Birdwatchers
A Zibby's Most Anticipated Book of Fall 2025!
From New York Times bestselling author Jacquelyn Mitchard comes a page-turning drama that explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most.
When she is convicted of a double murder, Felicity Wild, a brilliant grad student turned high-priced escort, declares, “I may not be innocent, but I’m innocent of this.”
Reenie Bigelow never doubted it. A jury may have given Felicity a life sentence, but Reenie knows that her childhood best friend is not capable of murder. And so Reenie, a journalist, decides to use her deep connections to Felicity’s past to unravel the truth.
The more she uncovers, the more Reenie is convinced that the story the prosecution told is wrong, despite the puzzling fact that Felicity said not one single word in her own defense. But there's one thing Reenie knows for certain: Felicity would never lie.
From New York Times bestselling author Jacquelyn Mitchard comes a page-turning drama that explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most.
When she is convicted of a double murder, Felicity Wild, a brilliant grad student turned high-priced escort, declares, “I may not be innocent, but I’m innocent of this.”
Reenie Bigelow never doubted it. A jury may have given Felicity a life sentence, but Reenie knows that her childhood best friend is not capable of murder. And so Reenie, a journalist, decides to use her deep connections to Felicity’s past to unravel the truth.
The more she uncovers, the more Reenie is convinced that the story the prosecution told is wrong, despite the puzzling fact that Felicity said not one single word in her own defense. But there's one thing Reenie knows for certain: Felicity would never lie.
Library Binding
First published December 9, 2025
194 people are currently reading
9427 people want to read
About the author
Jacquelyn Mitchard
68 books1,252 followersJacquelyn Mitchard’s first novel, The Deep End of the Ocean, was named by USA Today as one of the ten most influential books of the past 25 years – second only to the Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling (but second by a long shot, it must be said.)
The Deep End of the Ocean was chosen as the first novel in the book club made famous by the TV host Oprah Winfrey, and transformed into a feature film produced by and starring Michelle Pfeiffer.
Most of Mitchard’s novels have been greater or lesser bestsellers – and include The Most Wanted, A Theory of Relativity, Twelve Times Blessed, The Breakdown Lane, The Good Son, and Cage of Stars. Critics have praised them for their authentic humanity and command of story. Readers identify because they see reflected, in her characters – however extreme their circumstances – emotions they already understand.
Mitchard also has written four novels for young adults.
The first, Now You See Her, from HarperTeen, is the story of a pampered, driven young actress who fakes her own abduction.
All We Know of Heaven told the story of lifetime best friends Bridget and Maureen, who are just sixteen when a fatal crash on an icy road and a poignant case of mistaken identity divide their small Minnesota town forever.
The Midnight Twins was the first in a trilogy of teen mysteries about identical twin sisters born on New Year’s Eve – one a minute before and a minute after midnight – Meredith and Mallory Brynn learn on the night they turn thirteen that their psychic abilities will force them to intervene in dire events, although one twin can see only the future and one can see only the past. The Midnight Twins is in development as a TV series by Kaleidoscope Entertainment.
Mitchard's newest novel for adult, A Very Inconvenient Scandal, out in November 2023 from Mira/HarperCollins, is the story of an acclaimed young underwater photographer whose famed marine biologist father shatters their family by marrying her best friend., a woman 35 years his junior.
At the local coffee shop, Mitchard is best-known as the mother of Rob, Dan, Marty, Francie, Mia, Will and Atticus , as the grandma of Hank and Diana and the wife of handsome Chris Brent.
Her favorite color is periwinkle blue; her favorite holiday is Halloween; her favorite flower is freesia; her favorite word is "smite," and her second favorite is "Massachusetts"; her lucky number is 119 (anyone who can guess where that comes from wins free first editions of her novels for life). She lives in her favorite place on earth, Cape Cod, summering in a villa on the Amalfi Coast. (Guess which part of that sentence is fiction.)
Her essays have appeared in publications including the New York Times, Chicago Tribune Magazine and Reader's Digest, and are widely anthologized and used in school curricula. She has taught in MFA programs in Vermont, Ohio, and Massachusetts, and is part of the faculty at the Summer Writers Institute at Yale University. She is a member of the Tall Poppies Writers and has been a fellow at the MacDowell Colony, Yaddo, and the Ragdale Foundation.
Her pet peeves are known authors and editors who cannot and will not learn the difference between “lie” and “lay” and family signs pluralized with apostrophes.
She would love to appear on just ONE episode of any incarnation of ‘Law and Order,’ as has everyone else in America. She still is willing to play the role of a murder victim – except one found by earth-moving equipment in a landfill – though she would do that in a pinch.
Mitchard would like to have a swimming pool, because, although she lives near the ocean, she is afraid of the dark water and hates sand. She would love to have a clawfoot tub, or any tub.
She believes that stories are the ways that human beings make sense of life and that our stories will save us.
The Deep End of the Ocean was chosen as the first novel in the book club made famous by the TV host Oprah Winfrey, and transformed into a feature film produced by and starring Michelle Pfeiffer.
Most of Mitchard’s novels have been greater or lesser bestsellers – and include The Most Wanted, A Theory of Relativity, Twelve Times Blessed, The Breakdown Lane, The Good Son, and Cage of Stars. Critics have praised them for their authentic humanity and command of story. Readers identify because they see reflected, in her characters – however extreme their circumstances – emotions they already understand.
Mitchard also has written four novels for young adults.
The first, Now You See Her, from HarperTeen, is the story of a pampered, driven young actress who fakes her own abduction.
All We Know of Heaven told the story of lifetime best friends Bridget and Maureen, who are just sixteen when a fatal crash on an icy road and a poignant case of mistaken identity divide their small Minnesota town forever.
The Midnight Twins was the first in a trilogy of teen mysteries about identical twin sisters born on New Year’s Eve – one a minute before and a minute after midnight – Meredith and Mallory Brynn learn on the night they turn thirteen that their psychic abilities will force them to intervene in dire events, although one twin can see only the future and one can see only the past. The Midnight Twins is in development as a TV series by Kaleidoscope Entertainment.
Mitchard's newest novel for adult, A Very Inconvenient Scandal, out in November 2023 from Mira/HarperCollins, is the story of an acclaimed young underwater photographer whose famed marine biologist father shatters their family by marrying her best friend., a woman 35 years his junior.
At the local coffee shop, Mitchard is best-known as the mother of Rob, Dan, Marty, Francie, Mia, Will and Atticus , as the grandma of Hank and Diana and the wife of handsome Chris Brent.
Her favorite color is periwinkle blue; her favorite holiday is Halloween; her favorite flower is freesia; her favorite word is "smite," and her second favorite is "Massachusetts"; her lucky number is 119 (anyone who can guess where that comes from wins free first editions of her novels for life). She lives in her favorite place on earth, Cape Cod, summering in a villa on the Amalfi Coast. (Guess which part of that sentence is fiction.)
Her essays have appeared in publications including the New York Times, Chicago Tribune Magazine and Reader's Digest, and are widely anthologized and used in school curricula. She has taught in MFA programs in Vermont, Ohio, and Massachusetts, and is part of the faculty at the Summer Writers Institute at Yale University. She is a member of the Tall Poppies Writers and has been a fellow at the MacDowell Colony, Yaddo, and the Ragdale Foundation.
Her pet peeves are known authors and editors who cannot and will not learn the difference between “lie” and “lay” and family signs pluralized with apostrophes.
She would love to appear on just ONE episode of any incarnation of ‘Law and Order,’ as has everyone else in America. She still is willing to play the role of a murder victim – except one found by earth-moving equipment in a landfill – though she would do that in a pinch.
Mitchard would like to have a swimming pool, because, although she lives near the ocean, she is afraid of the dark water and hates sand. She would love to have a clawfoot tub, or any tub.
She believes that stories are the ways that human beings make sense of life and that our stories will save us.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 102 reviews
November 28, 2025
3.75 stars A Zibby's Most Anticipated Book of Fall 2025!
From New York Times bestselling author Jacquelyn Mitchard comes a page-turning drama that explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most.
When Felicity Wild, a high end escort is convicted of a double murder, journalist Reenie Bigelow is convinced that the prosecution's story is false. She doesn't believe her best friend growing up is capable of murder. But when Felicity refuses to speak with her and clear her name, Reenie teams up with the defense attorney, Sam to uncover the truth.
This is a slow-burn literary mystery so don't go into it expecting a legal thriller. The character development is superb and themes of female friendship, and control through money, power, and sex are beautifully threaded throughout the novel. Each chapter begins with a description of a unique species of bird, their behavior and attributes that relate to what is happening in the novel. That was my favorite part of the book.
I read the book and supplemented with the audiobook for an immersive experience. The audiobook performance by Gail Shalan is excellent. If you enjoy reading literary mysteries, this is one to add to your TBR.
Many thanks to NetGalley, HTP Books - MIRA, and Jacqueline Mitchard for the advance reader's copy in exchange for my honest review. Thank you to Harlequin Audio for the advance listening copy.📚🎧
From New York Times bestselling author Jacquelyn Mitchard comes a page-turning drama that explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most.
When Felicity Wild, a high end escort is convicted of a double murder, journalist Reenie Bigelow is convinced that the prosecution's story is false. She doesn't believe her best friend growing up is capable of murder. But when Felicity refuses to speak with her and clear her name, Reenie teams up with the defense attorney, Sam to uncover the truth.
This is a slow-burn literary mystery so don't go into it expecting a legal thriller. The character development is superb and themes of female friendship, and control through money, power, and sex are beautifully threaded throughout the novel. Each chapter begins with a description of a unique species of bird, their behavior and attributes that relate to what is happening in the novel. That was my favorite part of the book.
I read the book and supplemented with the audiobook for an immersive experience. The audiobook performance by Gail Shalan is excellent. If you enjoy reading literary mysteries, this is one to add to your TBR.
Many thanks to NetGalley, HTP Books - MIRA, and Jacqueline Mitchard for the advance reader's copy in exchange for my honest review. Thank you to Harlequin Audio for the advance listening copy.📚🎧
December 15, 2025
I am at the 60% and I just cannot anymore. It was such a chore to pick up this book every night. I am so lost on the plot, literally, lost. I have gone back and re read sections and I still haven't a clue what is going on. I also do not understand the start of each chapter with the birds.....do those references come full circle or wth?
December 12, 2025
I admit I only picked this book up at first because of the author and the beautiful book cover. My husband and I have fallen in love with watching all the different species of birds in our backyard feeders, as we live in the peace and quiet of the woods. The descriptions of the birds at the beginning of every chapter were fascinating and I began to notice a subtle tie-in to where the story was taking me. The story is of friendship with a little romance, courtroom drama, and mystery. It took me awhile to get into the story, but I kept with it because I wanted to know what happened and why. Overall I really enjoyed the book (even though I guessed who did it just past halfway 😆)
I received a complimentary copy of this book. The views and opinions expressed in this review are completely my own
I received a complimentary copy of this book. The views and opinions expressed in this review are completely my own
January 8, 2026
The best part of this book was the bird description at the start of each chapter. That apparently have nothing to do with this very drawn out, very wordy, very boring story told by an uninteresting person about another uninteresting person. That's really saying something considering the subject matter and characters. DNF after about 50%
February 19, 2026
I have read and loved every other book by Jacquelyn Mitchard. I have always found her to be a gifted writer. However, I just did not care for this one. I felt like there was so much jumping around that I couldn't keep track of what was going on. I even tried re-reading chapters. I hope others can enjoy this book, but it just wasn't for me.
December 10, 2025
The Birdwatcher by Jacquelyn Mitchard totally missed the mark for me, and I struggled to finish. This novel is all over the place, a mystery and courtroom drama with a bit of a love story and friendship saga. I still don't understand completely the title and use of bird descriptions at the beginning of each chapter; the author refers to Felicity's lifelong interest in birds and birdwatching, but that hobby plays absolutely no role in the story beyond the reference. The novel also skips any type of lead up to the romantic involvement of two main characters, I had to reread a few sections because I was sure I had missed something...I had not.
The most compelling aspect of the story was the mystery of who had murdered the two men, if not Felicity, and even though I had it figured out at the midpoint of the novel, it was interesting to find out why it was done.
Thank you to Netgalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing for the digital ARC of The Birdwatcher by Jacquelynn Mitchard. The opinions in this review are my own.
The most compelling aspect of the story was the mystery of who had murdered the two men, if not Felicity, and even though I had it figured out at the midpoint of the novel, it was interesting to find out why it was done.
Thank you to Netgalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing for the digital ARC of The Birdwatcher by Jacquelynn Mitchard. The opinions in this review are my own.
December 29, 2025
This novel confused me- I didn’t know what the author intended it to be - a mystery, a coming of age or finding one’s true path kind of book or a novel about deep friendship?
This book was so slow paced for me that I put it down many times and contemplated not finishing it. The plot strand that kept me returning was to solve the murder mystery at the center of it, but I solved it before the halfway mark based on the obvious clues- I needed to know the motive and method so I hung in for this.
It was a strange book and I did not find the characters very relatable- Reenie was a very odd character- maybe if the POV would have been from Felicity’s side of the story as an unreliable narrator- it would have made more sense? It seemed like Reenie was trying to figure herself out instead of getting to the bottom of the mystery, and she was more concerned with her love life and life rather than her friend’s trial- I didn’t think she did very much to uncover the truth. It’s a good thing that the truth practically slapped her in the face so that I could find out what really happened (I knew who did it all along).
The conclusion of the novel was better than the beginning, but I’m not sure this is a must read.
I’m also very confused about the bird descriptions- I could not understand the connection- was this related to each chapter or was this Felicity’s voice because she couldn’t think anything else? I never understood the juxtaposition of the bird description beginning each chapter, and this was frustrating as well. I could not have read this any slower and found myself rereading to try to make sense of the descriptions.
Thank you Harlequin Books Mira for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
This book was so slow paced for me that I put it down many times and contemplated not finishing it. The plot strand that kept me returning was to solve the murder mystery at the center of it, but I solved it before the halfway mark based on the obvious clues- I needed to know the motive and method so I hung in for this.
It was a strange book and I did not find the characters very relatable- Reenie was a very odd character- maybe if the POV would have been from Felicity’s side of the story as an unreliable narrator- it would have made more sense? It seemed like Reenie was trying to figure herself out instead of getting to the bottom of the mystery, and she was more concerned with her love life and life rather than her friend’s trial- I didn’t think she did very much to uncover the truth. It’s a good thing that the truth practically slapped her in the face so that I could find out what really happened (I knew who did it all along).
The conclusion of the novel was better than the beginning, but I’m not sure this is a must read.
I’m also very confused about the bird descriptions- I could not understand the connection- was this related to each chapter or was this Felicity’s voice because she couldn’t think anything else? I never understood the juxtaposition of the bird description beginning each chapter, and this was frustrating as well. I could not have read this any slower and found myself rereading to try to make sense of the descriptions.
Thank you Harlequin Books Mira for the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
January 10, 2026
What the fresh h*ll was this?? I really enjoyed many of this author’s early work, but this was … awful. Completely incomprehensible story, inconsistencies (did anyone even proofread this?) improbable scenarios that made my eyes almost roll out of my head. I finished it in hope that maybe it would make sense in the end, but nope. Skip this one.
January 2, 2026
Too many inconceivable & rushed relationships. Also was confusing/random how the protagonist referred to her parents by their first names at times and other times she referred to them as Mom & Dad -- sometimes in the same paragraph. Quotes were also frequently disjointed. Best part of the book was the little snippets about birds at the start of each chapter.
February 6, 2026
I listened to the audiobook of The Birdwatcher and it is exactly what a great audiobook should be: absorbing, emotionally sharp, and impossible to tune out. I read it while walking the dogs, doing laundry, grocery shopping and I definitely washed my whites with some darks by accident and bought the wrong brand of cereal because I was so absorbed (the dogs are okay though!).
This story sneaks up on you. What starts as a quiet, almost meditative setup turns into a deeply human mystery about grief, guilt, and the stories we tell ourselves to survive. Mitchard writes with restraint and obvious confidence – you are in the hands of a master storyteller. The author crafts steady, intelligent tension that keeps tightening.
The audiobook narration by Gail Shalan is excellent. Her voices are strong, and distinct, and the pacing is spot-on. She adds depth without overacting. This matters here because this particular novel lives in subtext. Instead, the performance amplifies the isolation, unease, and moral complexity at the heart of the book. Her work is very engrossing.
If you like character-driven suspense that respects your intelligence and lets silence do some of the work, this delivers. It is thoughtful, unsettling, and quietly devastating in the best way.
Highly recommended.
This story sneaks up on you. What starts as a quiet, almost meditative setup turns into a deeply human mystery about grief, guilt, and the stories we tell ourselves to survive. Mitchard writes with restraint and obvious confidence – you are in the hands of a master storyteller. The author crafts steady, intelligent tension that keeps tightening.
The audiobook narration by Gail Shalan is excellent. Her voices are strong, and distinct, and the pacing is spot-on. She adds depth without overacting. This matters here because this particular novel lives in subtext. Instead, the performance amplifies the isolation, unease, and moral complexity at the heart of the book. Her work is very engrossing.
If you like character-driven suspense that respects your intelligence and lets silence do some of the work, this delivers. It is thoughtful, unsettling, and quietly devastating in the best way.
Highly recommended.
January 31, 2026
When I was about 2/3 of the way through with this book I almost dnfed it. It felt like I was looking through a pinhole at the story. It was disjointed, unorganized, and I didn’t feel any connection to the characters, nor the story. Most of the book was intangible substance, not actual storyline but thoughts from the main character’s (Irene, or Reenie) head. The story line was jumbled and I had difficulty keeping a timeline in my head. The ending was abrupt, but satisfying in the sense that it mostly made sense. It had a nice ending.
Overall, three stars is probably generous.
Overall, three stars is probably generous.
February 10, 2026
a beautiful novel by a loved author. the story is of love reconcilation vulnerability and community all gathered round a murder in Wisconsin and bird watching.
January 31, 2026
I've read several of Ms Mitchard's books, and this has to be the best one of all. This novel has a very strong woman as the central character. Her best friend from childhood is another character, but she's fraught with flaws among the good merits she has. Boy, does this story weave a beautiful, complicated tale of good and evil, friendships, marriages, lawyering and much more. This is such an entertaining book.
December 29, 2025
This one’s tricky to rate. This book is, at its heart, a mystery, but around that core is an in depth story about the supposed murders’s best friend and her quest to write/solve/resolve the murder. At times that story line felt like a deviation from the real plot. However, I especially like the way the story was framed and it definitely kept me reading so…4 stars.
January 14, 2026
Mitchard has a distinctive author's voice. Think of your trusted best friend talking to you over coffee, sometimes lightly casual, sometimes deadly serious.
In The Birdwatcher, we follow Reenie Bigelow, a young woman early in her journalism career, shocked to learn that her best friend from childhood, Felicity Wild, has become a sex worker and is charged with a double murder. How does she deal with this blow and how does she use her skills as a journalist to get to the bottom of the mystery? Against all logic, Felicity refuses to talk with Reenie. Why? Did Felicity actually kill two men? How can she discover the truth? Can the truth set her friend free?
Mitchard takes us through Reenie's journey as she tries to remain objective, while fervently hoping that she can discover enough information to save her friend from the terrible fate or, if the facts go the other way, to understand why her friend did this and be able to accept it. What is the startling secret that Felicity has hidden even from Reenie?
The answers are there, and the trip to find them is a worthwhile reading experience.
In The Birdwatcher, we follow Reenie Bigelow, a young woman early in her journalism career, shocked to learn that her best friend from childhood, Felicity Wild, has become a sex worker and is charged with a double murder. How does she deal with this blow and how does she use her skills as a journalist to get to the bottom of the mystery? Against all logic, Felicity refuses to talk with Reenie. Why? Did Felicity actually kill two men? How can she discover the truth? Can the truth set her friend free?
Mitchard takes us through Reenie's journey as she tries to remain objective, while fervently hoping that she can discover enough information to save her friend from the terrible fate or, if the facts go the other way, to understand why her friend did this and be able to accept it. What is the startling secret that Felicity has hidden even from Reenie?
The answers are there, and the trip to find them is a worthwhile reading experience.
January 21, 2026
Not what I expected but in a really good way. I loved the writing and insights. Salacious at times and yet reserved. This one hooked me. The links to birds and how each bird explained at the start of the chapter then linked into the story in off beat way was well done.
January 16, 2026
A good book that overlays birds and their characteristics with a murder and life mystery and drama. What would you do to protect your children?
December 11, 2025
In Jacquelyn Mitchard's gripping novel, THE BIRDWATCHER, a suspenseful and emotionally charged narrative unfolds through the perspective of a tenacious journalist.
As she immerses herself in the harrowing double murder case of her childhood best friend, she unearths a labyrinth of hidden truths and shattered connections. The bond they once shared, fragile and complex, begins to unravel, revealing the darker undercurrents of their intertwined lives and the haunting shadows of the past.
Driven by an unwavering conviction of her friend's innocence—despite the silence that surrounds her during the trial—she embarks on a gripping quest for the truth. This narrative unfolds like a rich tapestry, intertwining themes of friendship, power, loyalty, and the hidden nuances of human relationship dynamics.
Moreover, the avian world serves not only as a backdrop but also as a poignant thematic guide throughout the story. The behavior of birds, woven seamlessly into the narrative, reflects the intricate complexities of friendship, betrayal, and unspoken secrets, offering readers a profound commentary on the nature of trust and human connection within this mesmerizing literary mystery.
About...
Felicity Wild, a former brilliant biology student who became a high-priced escort, is convicted of the double murder of two of her clients. The victims were an economics professor and a dairy salesman, both of whom had named Felicity as a beneficiary on their life insurance policies.
Reenie Bigelow, a fashion journalist with no crime reporting experience, gets permission to cover the story for her magazine and use her personal connection to Felicity to find the truth. Reenie is determined to prove her friend's innocence and clear her name.
A major point of intrigue is that Felicity, while declaring her innocence of this specific crime, refuses to say a single word in her own defense during the trial, confounding her attorney and the public.
Reenie returns to their shared hometown in Wisconsin to investigate Felicity's past and the circumstances of the murders, interviewing old acquaintances and family members.
As part of her investigation, Reenie takes a job as a bartender at "Ophelia," the strip club where Felicity worked, and uncovers details about the club's criminal underbelly and the interplay between sex, money, and power. How did her brilliant friend become involved in this industry and get caught up in a double murder?
Reenie faces opposition from her boss, Felicity's attorney, and others who don't want her to proceed. Her investigation leads to a shocking discovery that ultimately changes everything she thought she knew about her friend and their shared past.
The story builds tension around the question of why Felicity is protecting the real murderer or what secret she is hiding, culminating in a dramatic, shocking discovery that reveals the actual circumstances of the crimes.
My Thoughts...
In THE BIRDWATCHER, an intricate web of mystery envelops Felicity, whose silence during her dramatic murder trial serves as a haunting veil over a deep, buried secret. What truths is she shielding from the world, and what sacrifices is she willing to endure to protect them?
The narrative crescendos with tension as Reenie, a determined journalist, embarks on an investigative journey to peel back the layers of Felicity’s enigmatic life. It’s a quest driven by loyalty and an unshakeable belief that her friend would never deceive her.
THE BIRDWATCHER is a beautifully crafted novel, richly layered with symbolism and metaphor. The title resonates deeply within the story, as birds take center stage, intertwined with both thematic and structural elements.
Each chapter begins with an enchanting, imaginative description of a unique bird species—details that not only fascinate but also mirror the events and emotional undertones within that chapter.
From the majestic Sandhill cranes to the familiar robins and the mysterious crows, each avian metaphor serves to illuminate human behavior through the discerning eye of a birdwatcher. Reenie becomes the observer, painstakingly surveying those around her to unlock profound truths hidden beneath the surface.
Patience and observation emerge as the primary connections between the birds and the narrative, reflecting the painstaking process of uncovering mysteries. This slow-burning literary mystery invites readers to take their time, much like a dedicated birdwatcher who must remain still and silent, waiting with bated breath for the elusive beauty of nature to reveal itself.
As Reenie Bigelow delves deeper into her investigation, her journey mirrors that of a birdwatcher traversing the wild, uncovering secrets through careful observation of human actions and motivations. Felicity’s trial silence demands the same patient understanding from those around her, emphasizing the complexities that define her true motivations—challenges similar to deciphering the subtle behaviors of a wild bird.
Mitchard's portrayal of female friendship within THE BIRDWATCHER enriches the narrative’s themes, showcasing a bond so profound that it eclipses reason and external evidence. It underscores notions of unwavering loyalty, identity, and the hidden sacrifices women often bear, crafting layers of connection that bind the characters tightly together.
Key Themes...
~ Unquestioning Loyalty
~Unwavering Friendship
~ The Power of Shared History and Memory
~ The Nuances of Trust and Betrayal
~ Secrets and Protection
~ Identity and Perception
~ Contrast and Class Distinction
~ A Return to Roots
~ Small Town Secrets
The relentless drive of loyalty propels Reenie forward, compelling her to risk her career and safety in the pursuit of truth. This investigation transcends mere procedural detail; it is a profound journey back to the roots of the people and places that shaped their intertwined lives. It suggests that our deepest understanding of another often comes from a history woven over a lifetime, not solely from the cold confines of a courtroom.
The Audiobook...
I had the pleasure of listening to the spectacular audiobook. You’ll find yourself irresistibly drawn to every mention of birds and quotes intricately woven throughout the narrative. The audiobook, in particular, is a true gem, brought to life by the talented and award-winning narrator, Gail Shalan, who happens to be one of my personal favorites. I am continually amazed by her remarkable ability to breathe life into the characters with distinct, (with many unique voices), each so perfectly crafted that it feels as if you’re conversing with them directly. Her enchanting performance pulls you into the immersive story from the very first word, creating a spellbinding atmosphere. With expert pacing and rich expression, she transforms the listening experience into an exhilarating journey filled with suspense, mystery, and an ever-present intrigue that keeps you on the edge of your seat.
Recs...
For those captivated by the rich tapestry of mystery, complex female friendships, and deep-seated secrets in THE BIRTHWATCHER, I recommend exploring these compelling titles:
- The Good Son by Jacquelyn Mitchard
- None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell
- Friends and Liars by Kit Frick
- Best of Friends by Kamila Shamsie
- Sadie by Courtney Summers
- When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McLain
Each of these selections offers a unique blend of suspense and emotional depth, sure to resonate with readers who appreciate the intricacies of the human experience.
Blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: Dec 09, 2026
My Rating: 5 Stars
Dec 2025 Must-Read Books
Dec Newsletter
As she immerses herself in the harrowing double murder case of her childhood best friend, she unearths a labyrinth of hidden truths and shattered connections. The bond they once shared, fragile and complex, begins to unravel, revealing the darker undercurrents of their intertwined lives and the haunting shadows of the past.
Driven by an unwavering conviction of her friend's innocence—despite the silence that surrounds her during the trial—she embarks on a gripping quest for the truth. This narrative unfolds like a rich tapestry, intertwining themes of friendship, power, loyalty, and the hidden nuances of human relationship dynamics.
Moreover, the avian world serves not only as a backdrop but also as a poignant thematic guide throughout the story. The behavior of birds, woven seamlessly into the narrative, reflects the intricate complexities of friendship, betrayal, and unspoken secrets, offering readers a profound commentary on the nature of trust and human connection within this mesmerizing literary mystery.
About...
Felicity Wild, a former brilliant biology student who became a high-priced escort, is convicted of the double murder of two of her clients. The victims were an economics professor and a dairy salesman, both of whom had named Felicity as a beneficiary on their life insurance policies.
Reenie Bigelow, a fashion journalist with no crime reporting experience, gets permission to cover the story for her magazine and use her personal connection to Felicity to find the truth. Reenie is determined to prove her friend's innocence and clear her name.
A major point of intrigue is that Felicity, while declaring her innocence of this specific crime, refuses to say a single word in her own defense during the trial, confounding her attorney and the public.
Reenie returns to their shared hometown in Wisconsin to investigate Felicity's past and the circumstances of the murders, interviewing old acquaintances and family members.
As part of her investigation, Reenie takes a job as a bartender at "Ophelia," the strip club where Felicity worked, and uncovers details about the club's criminal underbelly and the interplay between sex, money, and power. How did her brilliant friend become involved in this industry and get caught up in a double murder?
Reenie faces opposition from her boss, Felicity's attorney, and others who don't want her to proceed. Her investigation leads to a shocking discovery that ultimately changes everything she thought she knew about her friend and their shared past.
The story builds tension around the question of why Felicity is protecting the real murderer or what secret she is hiding, culminating in a dramatic, shocking discovery that reveals the actual circumstances of the crimes.
My Thoughts...
In THE BIRDWATCHER, an intricate web of mystery envelops Felicity, whose silence during her dramatic murder trial serves as a haunting veil over a deep, buried secret. What truths is she shielding from the world, and what sacrifices is she willing to endure to protect them?
The narrative crescendos with tension as Reenie, a determined journalist, embarks on an investigative journey to peel back the layers of Felicity’s enigmatic life. It’s a quest driven by loyalty and an unshakeable belief that her friend would never deceive her.
THE BIRDWATCHER is a beautifully crafted novel, richly layered with symbolism and metaphor. The title resonates deeply within the story, as birds take center stage, intertwined with both thematic and structural elements.
Each chapter begins with an enchanting, imaginative description of a unique bird species—details that not only fascinate but also mirror the events and emotional undertones within that chapter.
From the majestic Sandhill cranes to the familiar robins and the mysterious crows, each avian metaphor serves to illuminate human behavior through the discerning eye of a birdwatcher. Reenie becomes the observer, painstakingly surveying those around her to unlock profound truths hidden beneath the surface.
Patience and observation emerge as the primary connections between the birds and the narrative, reflecting the painstaking process of uncovering mysteries. This slow-burning literary mystery invites readers to take their time, much like a dedicated birdwatcher who must remain still and silent, waiting with bated breath for the elusive beauty of nature to reveal itself.
As Reenie Bigelow delves deeper into her investigation, her journey mirrors that of a birdwatcher traversing the wild, uncovering secrets through careful observation of human actions and motivations. Felicity’s trial silence demands the same patient understanding from those around her, emphasizing the complexities that define her true motivations—challenges similar to deciphering the subtle behaviors of a wild bird.
Mitchard's portrayal of female friendship within THE BIRDWATCHER enriches the narrative’s themes, showcasing a bond so profound that it eclipses reason and external evidence. It underscores notions of unwavering loyalty, identity, and the hidden sacrifices women often bear, crafting layers of connection that bind the characters tightly together.
Key Themes...
~ Unquestioning Loyalty
~Unwavering Friendship
~ The Power of Shared History and Memory
~ The Nuances of Trust and Betrayal
~ Secrets and Protection
~ Identity and Perception
~ Contrast and Class Distinction
~ A Return to Roots
~ Small Town Secrets
The relentless drive of loyalty propels Reenie forward, compelling her to risk her career and safety in the pursuit of truth. This investigation transcends mere procedural detail; it is a profound journey back to the roots of the people and places that shaped their intertwined lives. It suggests that our deepest understanding of another often comes from a history woven over a lifetime, not solely from the cold confines of a courtroom.
The Audiobook...
I had the pleasure of listening to the spectacular audiobook. You’ll find yourself irresistibly drawn to every mention of birds and quotes intricately woven throughout the narrative. The audiobook, in particular, is a true gem, brought to life by the talented and award-winning narrator, Gail Shalan, who happens to be one of my personal favorites. I am continually amazed by her remarkable ability to breathe life into the characters with distinct, (with many unique voices), each so perfectly crafted that it feels as if you’re conversing with them directly. Her enchanting performance pulls you into the immersive story from the very first word, creating a spellbinding atmosphere. With expert pacing and rich expression, she transforms the listening experience into an exhilarating journey filled with suspense, mystery, and an ever-present intrigue that keeps you on the edge of your seat.
Recs...
For those captivated by the rich tapestry of mystery, complex female friendships, and deep-seated secrets in THE BIRTHWATCHER, I recommend exploring these compelling titles:
- The Good Son by Jacquelyn Mitchard
- None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell
- Friends and Liars by Kit Frick
- Best of Friends by Kamila Shamsie
- Sadie by Courtney Summers
- When the Stars Go Dark by Paula McLain
Each of these selections offers a unique blend of suspense and emotional depth, sure to resonate with readers who appreciate the intricacies of the human experience.
Blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: Dec 09, 2026
My Rating: 5 Stars
Dec 2025 Must-Read Books
Dec Newsletter
January 3, 2026
A slow start but worth the time to get all the connections, the players, and the story to come full circle. I enjoyed each lesson on birds that began each chapter. Reenie's best friend has been arrested for 2 murders. Felicity refuses to see Reenie. Reenie gets approval from her boss to write a story about the murders/trial for the magazine. Is she doing it to prove Felicity is innocent, to understand how her friend changed after high school, to understand the life choice is chose? Intrigue, suspense, romance, friendship, and family (the good and the bad) are all wrapped up in this engaging story.
December 22, 2025
“The Bird Watcher,” by Jacquelyn Mitchard. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ NOT A SPOILER. This is a heartbreaking book about love; the love of childhood friends now grown, of maternal love, of all consuming romantic love. it’s a book about secrets, lots of secrets. It raises questions that every parent would have to answer if their chuld(ren) didn’t grow up like the kids on Little House of the Prarie, a tv shiw I actually haven’t seen, but I think the kids were like little human obedient angels. This book’s twists and turns seem like they are the obvious turns a story might take; but they’re much more than that. It’s veey much a psychological thriller disguised as fluff. it’s absolutely NOT fluff.
January 18, 2026
Fashion journalist Reenie Bigelow covers her first murder trial involving her former high school best friend who has been accused of murdering two men in The Birdwatcher by Jacquelyn Mitchard. It's been a while since Reenie and Felicity have been close. After high school, they lost touch, and Felicity surprisingly went a dark path toward a career as an escort. Reenie is determined to exonerate her friend of these charges that she feels cannot be true.
I looked forward to this book because I thought the premise would be intriguing. Also, I've been reading the author's books since her very first book, The Deep End of the Ocean, which was Oprah's inaugural choice for her book club. Unfortunately, this book is all over the place and cannot seem to decide on an identity. I really toyed with giving this only two stars (it's probably a 2.5) but felt that there were some merits.
Each chapter opens with a description of a bird. I liked the idea of it, but it seemed gimmicky and didn't really gel with the chapters. I felt that it wasn't woven into the plot well enough that Felicity was a birdwatcher.
There were so many pieces missing in connecting the plot and unanswered questions that weren't fully developed, too. Sometimes, like other reviewers have noted, I became confused by the lack of coherence. I was waiting for answers that never came.
I feel like I'm really picking apart the book, but it detracted from my enjoyment of it. The references seemed outdated. For example, I know what Masterpiece Theater is, but do 20-somethings? I sincerely doubt it. I have two of them at home. Very little references to social media were made as well, which does not fit with this time period. Also, wouldn't it be more accurate if the main character was a blogger or podcaster? Magazines are definitely not on the upswing.
Plus, I didn't feel that the friends were that close. It seemed like Reenie and Felicity were in a friendship that was never meant to last. Ultimately, Reenie knew so little about her friend beyond the escort job that I found it hard to believe that they were like sisters. Other relationships like the three-night stand that somehow evolved into a soul-mate level love affair featured very little development and seemed totally unrealistic. A lot of events seemed sped up and inconsistent with the timeline.
When you finally find out who killed the two men that patronized Felicity, it feels like an exposition dump. The perpetrator just spills all the information without showing it. I think a flashback could have worked to show the chain of events. At that point, I was having trouble staying interested in the book and slogged through the final chapters.
I really struggled to enjoy a lot of this book. It had some strong plot points and great ideas, but I was disappointed in the book in general. I feel bad saying this, but I may pause my reading any of the author's future books.
I looked forward to this book because I thought the premise would be intriguing. Also, I've been reading the author's books since her very first book, The Deep End of the Ocean, which was Oprah's inaugural choice for her book club. Unfortunately, this book is all over the place and cannot seem to decide on an identity. I really toyed with giving this only two stars (it's probably a 2.5) but felt that there were some merits.
Each chapter opens with a description of a bird. I liked the idea of it, but it seemed gimmicky and didn't really gel with the chapters. I felt that it wasn't woven into the plot well enough that Felicity was a birdwatcher.
There were so many pieces missing in connecting the plot and unanswered questions that weren't fully developed, too. Sometimes, like other reviewers have noted, I became confused by the lack of coherence. I was waiting for answers that never came.
I feel like I'm really picking apart the book, but it detracted from my enjoyment of it. The references seemed outdated. For example, I know what Masterpiece Theater is, but do 20-somethings? I sincerely doubt it. I have two of them at home. Very little references to social media were made as well, which does not fit with this time period. Also, wouldn't it be more accurate if the main character was a blogger or podcaster? Magazines are definitely not on the upswing.
Plus, I didn't feel that the friends were that close. It seemed like Reenie and Felicity were in a friendship that was never meant to last. Ultimately, Reenie knew so little about her friend beyond the escort job that I found it hard to believe that they were like sisters. Other relationships like the three-night stand that somehow evolved into a soul-mate level love affair featured very little development and seemed totally unrealistic. A lot of events seemed sped up and inconsistent with the timeline.
When you finally find out who killed the two men that patronized Felicity, it feels like an exposition dump. The perpetrator just spills all the information without showing it. I think a flashback could have worked to show the chain of events. At that point, I was having trouble staying interested in the book and slogged through the final chapters.
I really struggled to enjoy a lot of this book. It had some strong plot points and great ideas, but I was disappointed in the book in general. I feel bad saying this, but I may pause my reading any of the author's future books.
December 9, 2025
📚 E-ARC/ALC BOOK REVIEW 📚
The Birdwatcher By Jacquelyn Mitchard
Publication Date: November 9, 2025
Book Publisher: HTP | MIRA
Audiobook Publisher: Harlequin Audio
Narrator: Gail Shahan
📚MY RATING: 4.75/5⭐
(Rounded Up To 5⭐)
Thank you @htpbooks #partner @mirabooks #htphive @htpbooks_audio and @netgalley for gifting me both the e-ARC and the ALC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
📚MY REVIEW:
The Birdwatcher, the December 9th release from Jacquelyn Mitchard, was a real genre-bender of a read -- and I loved every minute of it. This was part mystery, part romance, part contemporary fiction, part twisty thriller, and maybe even part lit fic with its beautifully lyrical prose.
Regardless of how you define its genre, it's clearly a character-driven story with endearing characters that will weave their way into your heart. The flow and the development of the story was slightly reminiscent of All The Colors of the Dark -- at least to me -- as the character arcs in the storyline were so well-done!
Though I intended to read this one as a combo of both the audiobook and e-arc, this was SUCH a perfect story for an audiobook and I found myself captivated by Gail Shahan's narration. Shahan did a phenomenal job with the different characters' voices and narrated this in a way that felt as if I was listening to a friend tell me a story. It was an easy book to listen to, as the beautiful writing and the character-driven plotlines really made for a wonderful earhole-reading experience! I can't recommend this audiobook enough!
Essentially, this is a story told by Reenie, a journalist, who returns to her hometown when her estranged childhood best friend, Felicity, is accused of a double murder. Reenie doesn't believe the prosecutor's story could possibly be accurate, so she decides to use her investigative journalism skills to dig into Felicity's past and figure out what really happened.
There are so many layers to this story and other subplots which make for such an enriching read -- but do yourself a favor and go in as blindly as you can. I became so highly invested in this story and so entertained by the personalities of these characters, that I didn't want it to end! This page-turning read explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most. If you're a fan of mixed-genre reads with character-driven storylines, don't miss this book -- and if you're a fan of audiobooks, this is a must-listen!
#TheBirdwatcher #JacquelynMitchard #HTPBooks #gifted #MiraBooks #htphive #HTPAudio #NetGalley #NetGalleyReviews #eARC #fictionalreads #mystery #womensfiction #audiobooks #booklover #bookreviews #bookrecs #bookrecommendations
The Birdwatcher By Jacquelyn Mitchard
Publication Date: November 9, 2025
Book Publisher: HTP | MIRA
Audiobook Publisher: Harlequin Audio
Narrator: Gail Shahan
📚MY RATING: 4.75/5⭐
(Rounded Up To 5⭐)
Thank you @htpbooks #partner @mirabooks #htphive @htpbooks_audio and @netgalley for gifting me both the e-ARC and the ALC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
📚MY REVIEW:
The Birdwatcher, the December 9th release from Jacquelyn Mitchard, was a real genre-bender of a read -- and I loved every minute of it. This was part mystery, part romance, part contemporary fiction, part twisty thriller, and maybe even part lit fic with its beautifully lyrical prose.
Regardless of how you define its genre, it's clearly a character-driven story with endearing characters that will weave their way into your heart. The flow and the development of the story was slightly reminiscent of All The Colors of the Dark -- at least to me -- as the character arcs in the storyline were so well-done!
Though I intended to read this one as a combo of both the audiobook and e-arc, this was SUCH a perfect story for an audiobook and I found myself captivated by Gail Shahan's narration. Shahan did a phenomenal job with the different characters' voices and narrated this in a way that felt as if I was listening to a friend tell me a story. It was an easy book to listen to, as the beautiful writing and the character-driven plotlines really made for a wonderful earhole-reading experience! I can't recommend this audiobook enough!
Essentially, this is a story told by Reenie, a journalist, who returns to her hometown when her estranged childhood best friend, Felicity, is accused of a double murder. Reenie doesn't believe the prosecutor's story could possibly be accurate, so she decides to use her investigative journalism skills to dig into Felicity's past and figure out what really happened.
There are so many layers to this story and other subplots which make for such an enriching read -- but do yourself a favor and go in as blindly as you can. I became so highly invested in this story and so entertained by the personalities of these characters, that I didn't want it to end! This page-turning read explores the beauty of female friendship; the relationship between money, power, and sex; and the very human desire to protect the ones we love most. If you're a fan of mixed-genre reads with character-driven storylines, don't miss this book -- and if you're a fan of audiobooks, this is a must-listen!
#TheBirdwatcher #JacquelynMitchard #HTPBooks #gifted #MiraBooks #htphive #HTPAudio #NetGalley #NetGalleyReviews #eARC #fictionalreads #mystery #womensfiction #audiobooks #booklover #bookreviews #bookrecs #bookrecommendations
January 5, 2026
The Birdwatcher starts with a hook that immediately pulled me in. Felicity Wild, convicted of a brutal double murder, calmly states that while she may not be innocent in life, she is innocent of this crime. From there, the story unfolds through the eyes of her childhood best friend Reenie, a journalist who never once doubts Felicity’s innocence and sets out to prove the system got it wrong.
I really enjoyed the concept of this book. It leans heavily into a true crime feel, especially as Reenie retraces Felicity’s past and questions the narrative presented at trial. The emotional core is the friendship between these two women and the deep loyalty that refuses to fade, even after a life sentence and years of silence.
One of my favorite stylistic choices was the way each chapter opens with a bird description. These moments were thoughtful and clearly chosen to reflect the themes of power, freedom, survival, and observation. As someone who has recently gotten into birdwatching, this detail really worked for me and gave the story a unique identity.
The pacing was a bit uneven at times, and I found myself wishing the story stayed more tightly focused on the investigation rather than Reenie’s personal struggles. I also wanted more direct interaction between Reenie and Felicity, since their relationship is such a driving force behind the story. Still, I appreciated the reflective, character driven approach and the questions it raises about truth, loyalty, and how well we can ever really know another person.
On audio, Gail Shalan does an excellent job. Her narration made it easy to distinguish between characters, and her steady, thoughtful delivery suited the journalistic tone of the book. I occasionally found myself wishing for a physical copy, if only to flip back through the bird facts and keep all the threads straight.
Overall, The Birdwatcher is a quiet, contemplative story that blends true crime energy with personal reflection. It may not be a high tension thriller, but it offers a thoughtful look at friendship, justice, and the stories we tell about guilt and innocence.
Thank you to NetGalley, Harlequin Audio and The Hive for the ALC.
I really enjoyed the concept of this book. It leans heavily into a true crime feel, especially as Reenie retraces Felicity’s past and questions the narrative presented at trial. The emotional core is the friendship between these two women and the deep loyalty that refuses to fade, even after a life sentence and years of silence.
One of my favorite stylistic choices was the way each chapter opens with a bird description. These moments were thoughtful and clearly chosen to reflect the themes of power, freedom, survival, and observation. As someone who has recently gotten into birdwatching, this detail really worked for me and gave the story a unique identity.
The pacing was a bit uneven at times, and I found myself wishing the story stayed more tightly focused on the investigation rather than Reenie’s personal struggles. I also wanted more direct interaction between Reenie and Felicity, since their relationship is such a driving force behind the story. Still, I appreciated the reflective, character driven approach and the questions it raises about truth, loyalty, and how well we can ever really know another person.
On audio, Gail Shalan does an excellent job. Her narration made it easy to distinguish between characters, and her steady, thoughtful delivery suited the journalistic tone of the book. I occasionally found myself wishing for a physical copy, if only to flip back through the bird facts and keep all the threads straight.
Overall, The Birdwatcher is a quiet, contemplative story that blends true crime energy with personal reflection. It may not be a high tension thriller, but it offers a thoughtful look at friendship, justice, and the stories we tell about guilt and innocence.
Thank you to NetGalley, Harlequin Audio and The Hive for the ALC.
January 11, 2026
A circuitous drama with just a hint of murder mystery.
When Reenie's childhood best friend Felicity is arrested as a suspect in a double murder and revealed as an escort, Reenie will decide to put her journalistic skills to good use. Diving deep into Felicity's past, can Reenie unravel the tangled web that lead Felicity into her work as an escort and landed her in handcuffs before it is too late and she spends the rest of her life in prison? And why is Felicity refusing to say anything in her own defense? Who is she protecting? What could possibly be worth her silence?
This was a very interesting read. As someone who does consume a lot of true crime, I really enjoyed the way this story is told through Reenie's eyes as a writer and an outside observer. Reenie, when it comes down to it, was as shocked by this revelation and trial as anyone else. However, her particular skills end up being put to very good use and through her drive and tenacity she's able to unravel the tangled web surrounding these horrific murders.
I will say it took me a little while to get into this read. I don't think I was really invested until Reenie went undercover at the club Felicity once worked at. Everything up to that point had felt a little too skippy. It was hard to keep track of where Reenie was going and what she was doing. However, once she's at the club and getting to know Felicity through the eyes of those she worked so closely with, I was finally able to sink my teeth into the story and it kept my attention all the way through to the end.
Despite the rough start, I feel like the ending was extremely satisfying and well worth the work I had to put in at the beginning to keep going.
I had the honor of listening to this read as an audiobook and was very happy to hear another book read by Ms. Shalan. She does an excellent job portraying the characters. I do wish the volume had been a little more consistent. I feel like I had to turn it way up at some points and way down at others and found highway listening all but impossible, but that could just be a me problem.
I'd love to read more from Ms. Mitchard in the future and will look for her other work!
Thank you so much to the HTP Hive, Harlequin Audio, and Mira for the advance review copy!
When Reenie's childhood best friend Felicity is arrested as a suspect in a double murder and revealed as an escort, Reenie will decide to put her journalistic skills to good use. Diving deep into Felicity's past, can Reenie unravel the tangled web that lead Felicity into her work as an escort and landed her in handcuffs before it is too late and she spends the rest of her life in prison? And why is Felicity refusing to say anything in her own defense? Who is she protecting? What could possibly be worth her silence?
This was a very interesting read. As someone who does consume a lot of true crime, I really enjoyed the way this story is told through Reenie's eyes as a writer and an outside observer. Reenie, when it comes down to it, was as shocked by this revelation and trial as anyone else. However, her particular skills end up being put to very good use and through her drive and tenacity she's able to unravel the tangled web surrounding these horrific murders.
I will say it took me a little while to get into this read. I don't think I was really invested until Reenie went undercover at the club Felicity once worked at. Everything up to that point had felt a little too skippy. It was hard to keep track of where Reenie was going and what she was doing. However, once she's at the club and getting to know Felicity through the eyes of those she worked so closely with, I was finally able to sink my teeth into the story and it kept my attention all the way through to the end.
Despite the rough start, I feel like the ending was extremely satisfying and well worth the work I had to put in at the beginning to keep going.
I had the honor of listening to this read as an audiobook and was very happy to hear another book read by Ms. Shalan. She does an excellent job portraying the characters. I do wish the volume had been a little more consistent. I feel like I had to turn it way up at some points and way down at others and found highway listening all but impossible, but that could just be a me problem.
I'd love to read more from Ms. Mitchard in the future and will look for her other work!
Thank you so much to the HTP Hive, Harlequin Audio, and Mira for the advance review copy!
February 14, 2026
3.5 stars
This was a slow, thoughtful literary mystery that leans more into relationships and psychology than courtroom drama. If you go in expecting a fast paced legal thriller, this might feel quieter than anticipated. But if you are in the mood for something reflective about loyalty, memory, and the long shadows of friendship, there is a lot to appreciate here.
At the center is Reenie, a journalist who becomes obsessed with proving her childhood best friend’s innocence after a double murder conviction. What really carried the story for me was the emotional tension between who Felicity used to be and who she has become. The silence at the heart of the trial creates a constant undercurrent of unease. It is less about shocking twists and more about peeling back layers of shared history.
I loved the recurring bird motifs and how each chapter opened with observations about a different species. Sometimes the symbolism felt subtle and effective, other times it felt a bit heavy handed, but I admired the ambition behind it. The themes of female friendship, class, control, and perception were woven carefully throughout the narrative.
Where it lost me a little was pacing. The investigation unfolds gradually and I found myself wanting a bit more momentum in the middle. I also did not always feel fully connected to Reenie as a character, even though I understood her motivations.
Overall, this is a contemplative mystery with strong thematic depth and a unique structural choice. Not a heart pounding thriller, but a layered story about what we think we know about the people we love most.
This was a slow, thoughtful literary mystery that leans more into relationships and psychology than courtroom drama. If you go in expecting a fast paced legal thriller, this might feel quieter than anticipated. But if you are in the mood for something reflective about loyalty, memory, and the long shadows of friendship, there is a lot to appreciate here.
At the center is Reenie, a journalist who becomes obsessed with proving her childhood best friend’s innocence after a double murder conviction. What really carried the story for me was the emotional tension between who Felicity used to be and who she has become. The silence at the heart of the trial creates a constant undercurrent of unease. It is less about shocking twists and more about peeling back layers of shared history.
I loved the recurring bird motifs and how each chapter opened with observations about a different species. Sometimes the symbolism felt subtle and effective, other times it felt a bit heavy handed, but I admired the ambition behind it. The themes of female friendship, class, control, and perception were woven carefully throughout the narrative.
Where it lost me a little was pacing. The investigation unfolds gradually and I found myself wanting a bit more momentum in the middle. I also did not always feel fully connected to Reenie as a character, even though I understood her motivations.
Overall, this is a contemplative mystery with strong thematic depth and a unique structural choice. Not a heart pounding thriller, but a layered story about what we think we know about the people we love most.
February 17, 2026
Honestly I really wanted to like this book, but there were too many things that really interrupted the experience for me. I thought this was going to be a crime thriller, but there was a needless romance shoved in the middle there, like her editor said "romance is really in right now, let's add something in here." People did things I wasn't convinced real people would do, despite the constant reiteration of the "if this were a novel, I wouldn't believe this, but it's a news story, and sometimes life is messy *shrug*" trope here. Except this IS a novel, and these characters were not believable! And I had a lot of trouble following timelines and conversations. A lot of the past and future bled together with the present and it was hard to keep up. I got very confused in a passage toward the end, where Mitchard says they're in Sheboygan, but they go grocery shopping on a "tropical day in one of those vivid stores that only exist in Florida," one character fully in a swimsuit and coverup. But then the next day they're still in Sheboygan? And they don't fly to Florida for another few days? It was just very hard to follow, very frustratingly NOT what I thought I was getting, and not very convincing, even with the plot twist. I don't buy into "they were just crazy" as a motive for murder. If you don't know why your character committed a murder, they're not developed enough as a character.
Very pleased that my book club agreed with me on this one. Sorry to pick a stinker, guys.
Very pleased that my book club agreed with me on this one. Sorry to pick a stinker, guys.
February 8, 2026
I almost feel bad for what I’m about to write. But this was terrible.
I started out hopeful. The poems in the beginning. The starting of each chapter with a little bird info. The lead into what was bound to be a mystery. Then came chapter 2.
Queue the insanely long irrelevant happenings, literally pages and pages droning on about a small mostly boring convo with an old college professor. I started skimming.
I kept skimming until I saw the name Felicity (the woman on trial) and just started reading those parts.
Then, this wildly random love affair between the main character (hell I just closed this book and have already forgotten her name) and Felicity’s lawyer starts. It lasts less than a week, but you’d better believe the highly unlikeable main character is going to whine about losing the love of her life for the majority of the remainder of the book.
Then you circle back around to the trial finally, and quickly you learn the verdict. Then you start to get some answers.
Also other things I hated:
-names are dropped like you’re supposed to know who they’re talking about.
-she calls her mom by her first name
-wording is weird in a lot of places, to the point I would reread a few times and give up and move on.
Why I bothered finishing this, I’ll never know. 0 stars.
I started out hopeful. The poems in the beginning. The starting of each chapter with a little bird info. The lead into what was bound to be a mystery. Then came chapter 2.
Queue the insanely long irrelevant happenings, literally pages and pages droning on about a small mostly boring convo with an old college professor. I started skimming.
I kept skimming until I saw the name Felicity (the woman on trial) and just started reading those parts.
Then, this wildly random love affair between the main character (hell I just closed this book and have already forgotten her name) and Felicity’s lawyer starts. It lasts less than a week, but you’d better believe the highly unlikeable main character is going to whine about losing the love of her life for the majority of the remainder of the book.
Then you circle back around to the trial finally, and quickly you learn the verdict. Then you start to get some answers.
Also other things I hated:
-names are dropped like you’re supposed to know who they’re talking about.
-she calls her mom by her first name
-wording is weird in a lot of places, to the point I would reread a few times and give up and move on.
Why I bothered finishing this, I’ll never know. 0 stars.
January 23, 2026
I don't typically write reviews, especially if I didn't care for the book. There were moments of this book that told a good story. A few good plot twist, even if you saw them coming a mile away. The biggest issue I have with this the "Romance".
******Spoiler warning******
I'm sorry, but you don't fall in love in love in 3 days. Them liking each other and having deep connection sure. Then she acts like a complete insane person, Jacquelyn's words not mine, and he says you know what, I want to marry that woman. I've read a lot of slow burn and romantasy that this "logic" would work in. I understand it's fiction, but this is over the top. Also probably should have switched the figures of what the life insurance and wrongful imprisonment payouts would be. A 7 figure policy for 2 elderly men, one of which was ill is a huge stretch. The twist at the end with them coming together as friends at the end is where this novel should have stopped. My inner thoughts and puzzlement of what came next for them is always more fun than they lived happily ever after, sort of. I listed to this on a whim and admit I'm not familiar with her work. All of the 5 and 4 star ratings seem to be from promotional reviews. Ok book last chapter being omitted bumps it a tier in the star department.
******Spoiler warning******
I'm sorry, but you don't fall in love in love in 3 days. Them liking each other and having deep connection sure. Then she acts like a complete insane person, Jacquelyn's words not mine, and he says you know what, I want to marry that woman. I've read a lot of slow burn and romantasy that this "logic" would work in. I understand it's fiction, but this is over the top. Also probably should have switched the figures of what the life insurance and wrongful imprisonment payouts would be. A 7 figure policy for 2 elderly men, one of which was ill is a huge stretch. The twist at the end with them coming together as friends at the end is where this novel should have stopped. My inner thoughts and puzzlement of what came next for them is always more fun than they lived happily ever after, sort of. I listed to this on a whim and admit I'm not familiar with her work. All of the 5 and 4 star ratings seem to be from promotional reviews. Ok book last chapter being omitted bumps it a tier in the star department.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 14, 2025
Many thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing | MIRA for gifting me a digital ARC of the new book by Jacquelyn Mitchard. All opinions expressed in this review are my own – 4.5 stars!
Felicity Wild and Reenie Bigelow were childhood best friends, although they grew apart as they got older. But when Felicity is on trial for a double murder, Reenie knows she didn't do it. A journalist for a woman's magazine, she convinces her boss to let her investigate for a story she will write on the case - a brilliant grad student turned high-priced escort, now charged with murder.
This is a slow-burn mystery, with an emphasis on female friendship. I really liked how each chapter begins with a description of a unique and fascinating bird and their behavior, symbolically relating it to the story. As with all Mitchard novels, the story rich in character development and those relationships are more important than the mystery of exactly how the two men died. Felicity stays silent through her defense, highlighting the mystery, but it's the characters you will be invested in. Beautiful writing.
Felicity Wild and Reenie Bigelow were childhood best friends, although they grew apart as they got older. But when Felicity is on trial for a double murder, Reenie knows she didn't do it. A journalist for a woman's magazine, she convinces her boss to let her investigate for a story she will write on the case - a brilliant grad student turned high-priced escort, now charged with murder.
This is a slow-burn mystery, with an emphasis on female friendship. I really liked how each chapter begins with a description of a unique and fascinating bird and their behavior, symbolically relating it to the story. As with all Mitchard novels, the story rich in character development and those relationships are more important than the mystery of exactly how the two men died. Felicity stays silent through her defense, highlighting the mystery, but it's the characters you will be invested in. Beautiful writing.
December 7, 2025
𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝑩𝒊𝒓𝒅𝒘𝒂𝒕𝒄𝒉𝒆𝒓 𝒃𝒚 𝑱𝒂𝒄𝒒𝒖𝒆𝒍𝒚𝒏 𝑴𝒊𝒕𝒄𝒉𝒂𝒓𝒅
𝑵𝒂𝒓𝒓𝒂𝒕𝒆𝒅 𝒃𝒚 𝑮𝒂𝒊𝒍 𝑺𝒉𝒂𝒍𝒂𝒏 by @htpbooks_audio, out December 9th.
This audiobook was a fascinating whodunit that had a deeper dive into friendship and family.
Reenie is a woman who is trying to make her way in her journalism career when she catches a scoop into which she may have inside access. Her best friend in childhood has been taken in for a double murder, and Reenie can't believe that Felicity had anything to do with it, but Felicity won't say a word in her defense, and won't see anyone. Reenie won't rest until she figures out what is really going on.
I thought this was a bit of a slow burn, in a good way. The curious nature of Felicity's silence drove much of the story, and every clue Reenie uncovered led to a conclusion that I wondered about but couldn't decide if it was it. The romantic side story filled out Reenie's story, even though I don't usually care for those additions.
Overall a solid mystery with a good narrator who brought the deeper angst out very well.
𝑵𝒂𝒓𝒓𝒂𝒕𝒆𝒅 𝒃𝒚 𝑮𝒂𝒊𝒍 𝑺𝒉𝒂𝒍𝒂𝒏 by @htpbooks_audio, out December 9th.
This audiobook was a fascinating whodunit that had a deeper dive into friendship and family.
Reenie is a woman who is trying to make her way in her journalism career when she catches a scoop into which she may have inside access. Her best friend in childhood has been taken in for a double murder, and Reenie can't believe that Felicity had anything to do with it, but Felicity won't say a word in her defense, and won't see anyone. Reenie won't rest until she figures out what is really going on.
I thought this was a bit of a slow burn, in a good way. The curious nature of Felicity's silence drove much of the story, and every clue Reenie uncovered led to a conclusion that I wondered about but couldn't decide if it was it. The romantic side story filled out Reenie's story, even though I don't usually care for those additions.
Overall a solid mystery with a good narrator who brought the deeper angst out very well.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 102 reviews