★ ★ ★ ★ ★ ★/5 stars
☄ᯓ★🏆🎧❀ 。𖦹°‧₊˚⊹♡🏀⋆ ˚。✎𓍯𓂃𓏧♡⋆⭒˚𖠋𖠋𖠋*.⋆
ARC REVIEW
This book was an absolute joy to read from start to finish. It had everything I wanted and more: the tension of dislike to lovers, the sweetness of found family, and the warmth of two people who couldn’t be more different finding comfort in each other. The setup itself already made me smile. A basketball star forced into community service at a preschool? It sounded like chaos waiting to happen, and it delivered in the funniest and most heartwarming way possible. The chemistry between Michael and Kate was undeniable, and watching their relationship shift from snarky remarks to genuine care was so satisfying to witness.
One thing that immediately made me emotional was the dedication. “This is for the softies: who find comfort in silence, who say yes when they mean no, who cry too often, love too hard, and feel too deeply... Stay soft. The world needs more hearts like yours.” That alone already set the tone for the story. I knew it was going to speak to people who feel too much, and I wasn’t wrong. This book understood the quiet struggle of wanting to please everyone but forgetting yourself in the process, and that made it hit way too close to home.
I honestly couldn’t stop laughing at myself while reading. There were so many scenes where I was like “oh no, that’s literally me.” Especially when Katie faked a fever to avoid her family because I kid you not, I was doing the same thing before reading that chapter. The timing was unreal. It felt like the author had hidden cameras somewhere, just observing and writing down my life story disguised as fiction.
Reading Katie’s point of view made me feel so proud of her. Every time she learned to stand up for herself, I wanted to cheer. “YES GIRL STAND UP FOR YOURSELF” became my internal chant. When she said “People-pleasers don’t fight every battle. Or any battle,” I wanted to give her a megaphone. I nodded so hard I swear my neck hurt. The book handled that theme with such honesty, that exhaustion of always saying yes, of always being nice, of being scared to disappoint anyone.
And can we talk about Haley? I wish I had her ability to not give a single care in the world. That girl is the definition of unbothered and I respect it deeply. Then there’s Polly, who made me laugh every single time she appeared. Her personality just bursts off the page. She’s the kind of chaotic friend you want in your corner because even her nonsense brings you peace. Also, Biko being mentioned while I was literally eating Biko? I almost choked from laughing. What are the odds?
Michael’s character really surprised me. On the surface, he’s this arrogant athlete used to fame, but underneath it all, he’s just someone tired of people’s opinions. I actually related to him when he said, “People have always had opinions about me. Maybe I don’t care or maybe I just got tired of pretending I do.” That line hit hard. It reminded me that sometimes, we build walls not because we’re cold, but because we’re tired of explaining ourselves to people who never really listen.
The banter between Kate and Michael was top-tier. The way she naturally hated on him while still secretly admiring his face was hilarious. Their height difference made every interaction even cuter, I swear I was grinning like an idiot the whole time. And the slow transition from annoyance to affection? Chef’s kiss. This book reminded me why I love the hate-to-love trope so much. The tension, the eye rolls that turn into heart eyes — it was everything.
What made this book even better was how it tied back to the author’s previous works. When Ryan and Bonbon were mentioned, I screamed. Like literally screamed. Between Then and Now supremacy forever. I missed those characters so much that I actually started talking to my book covers out of desperation before this came out. Seeing them again felt like reuniting with old friends. And can we appreciate that Kate’s a reader too? I felt so seen.
There were so many moments where I just had to pause and laugh because it all felt too real. “I’m a professional doormat and queen of awkward apologies,” Katie said, and I had to look around my room suspiciously because Miss Kyra Ysabel, are you spying on me? That line punched me in the chest. It perfectly captured how it feels to constantly apologize for existing too loudly, for being too emotional, for simply being yourself.
This part of the book made me love it even more. Katie not letting Michael help her carry her books during the early chapters was such a small thing, but it felt deeply personal. I was like, “That is so me,” because literally a few minutes before reading that scene, I was holding a huge stack of snacks and still refused help from my brothers. It’s that stubborn kind of independence that doesn’t make sense but feels right, the kind that says, “I got this,” even when your arms are about to fall off. Katie’s pride and quiet resilience reminded me so much of myself that I couldn’t stop smiling.
And the fact that Katie wears glasses? Instant connection. Bad eyesight girlies unite! There’s something about seeing yourself reflected in small details like that, the little habits, the everyday things, that makes reading so much more intimate. I felt like I was reading about a version of myself who just happened to fall in love with a basketball star. It’s comforting and hilarious all at once.
Speaking of which, we love men like Michael. Gentle, kind, respectful, and patient especially the way he slowly started understanding Katie without forcing himself into her space. He wasn’t perfect, but he was trying, and that made him even more loveable. The way he carried her bag without even asking? Absolute goals. It wasn’t about dominance; it was about care. That quiet kind of love hits different.
But the moment that shattered me was when Katie admitted it took her years to realize she’d stopped talking about her dreams. I was practically sobbing. That line hit so close to home it hurt. There’s something gut-wrenching about realizing how life, expectations, and fear can slowly silence the things you once loved. Fun fact : culinary school used to be my dream too, and just like her, I pushed it aside without even noticing when it happened. That scene made me want to go back and ask myself what I used to dream about before I forgot.
The banter between Michael and Katie remained top-tier. It’s the kind that makes you laugh one moment and melt the next. They balance each other out, her quiet sarcasm and his playful charm make every conversation feel natural and entertaining. You can feel their tension and care growing with every line, and it never feels forced. It’s exactly how I imagine two opposites slowly falling for each other would act.
And oh my gosh, I am already so excited for Haley and Richard’s book. Every time they appeared, my heart did a little jump. I can already tell it’s going to be amazing. Their dynamic is intriguing, and knowing this author, it’s going to have the same emotional depth with a dash of chaos that makes it unforgettable. I want it right now, honestly.
One of my favorite little moments was when Magnolia Heights started decorating for Christmas even though it was barely October. I laughed out loud because I literally looked at my mom at that exact moment, she was getting out our Christmas decorations too. That cozy, small-town energy was captured perfectly, and it gave the story that extra warmth that made me feel at home.
The part that truly melted my heart was when Michael helped Manong Jose. That scene was so tender and selfless that I had to stop reading for a bit. I tried not to cry, but it didn’t work. I was clutching my tablet like my life depended on it. It showed how much Michael had grown, from the arrogant athlete we met at the start to someone who genuinely cared about people beyond the spotlight.
Throughout the book, I couldn’t stop cheering, “INTROVERTS RISE!” because Katie’s thoughts were so relatable. The way she found peace in quiet moments, how she needed time to recharge, and how she showed love in subtle ways, it all felt so real. I loved how the story didn’t force her to change who she was. Instead, it celebrated her for it.
When Katie started falling for Michael, I was grinning like a fool. The moment she smiled a little too long, or when her thoughts drifted toward him, I was like, “OH MY GOD IS THIS IT? IS SHE FALLING?” It was the softest, most natural progression, and watching it unfold made my heart so full. They became each other’s comfort person, and that’s the kind of love I’ll always root for the one that feels like coming home after a long day.
MAKE THIS BOOK STOP MAKING ME BLUSH. I swear I looked like a tomato for half of it. Every time Michael did something even slightly sweet or said something soft, I had to close the book and take a deep breath like, “Get it together, girl.” The chemistry was unreal, and I don’t even know how I survived reading some of those moments without screaming. There’s something about how Kyra Ysabel writes those quiet, intimate scenes that makes your heart flutter without needing anything dramatic. It’s subtle, real, and completely swoon-worthy.
Also, I 100% agree with Katie, the Philippines in November is not the cool and breezy season our textbooks promised us. It’s just summer with one percent less heat. Reading that line made me laugh because it’s so true. I could practically feel the humidity through the page. That little detail made the story feel so real, so familiar, like it was happening right next door. The author captures everyday Filipino life in a way that makes it feel personal and nostalgic.
And can we talk about how Michael gave Katie her safe space back? That moment had me holding my breath. He didn’t take it away, didn’t intrude, he just quietly made room for her to exist again, freely. It was one of the most beautiful acts of love in the whole book. Then there’s the nickname Katie gave him… oh my gosh. I was blushing so hard I had to hide my face behind my tablet. It’s those little, tender details that make this story so special.
NBSB girlies unite! The way Michael described Katie? Absolute life goals. That scene made me giggle and cry at the same time. She’s the kind of person who doesn’t see how wonderful she is until someone finally points it out, and the way Michael did it? I melted. “Men in movies fall in love with the confident ones, the sparkly ones. The ones who walk into rooms like they own them, not the ones who pace nervously outside, then turn back because they forgot how to knock.” I had to stop reading for a moment because I HAVE DONE THAT. That line stabbed me right in the chest.
Throughout the book, I kept screaming, “The Nile is a river in Egypt!” because the denial was real. Like, come on, Katie. We can all see what’s happening here. Even I forgot how to breathe whenever Michael showed up. The tension between them was electric, but also so soft and tender. The way they looked at each other? Heaven. Pure heaven. I could practically hear the background music start playing every time their eyes met.
Then there’s that line, “I’ve always imagined myself living a simple life. Maybe it’s just the safest thing I’ve ever let myself imagine.” Girl, I felt that in my bones. It’s that quiet acceptance that sometimes we dream small because it’s safer, because failure feels too heavy. I love you, Haley, but please remember Katie isn’t made of glass. She’s strong, she’s growing, and she’s learning to take up space in her own life. Watching that growth was inspiring.
The scene where Michael checked up on her when she got sick completely melted me. It’s always the little things that make your heart ache, the care, the thoughtfulness, the way he looked out for her without making her feel helpless. And when Katie found out it was his birthday and made him a cookie cake? My heart exploded. The fact that it became his favorite among all the cakes he received made me tear up. Simple gestures, but full of meaning.
I felt Michael’s pain when he said he dreaded his birthday every year. That hit deep because I get that sometimes the day that’s supposed to be about celebration just feels heavy. And Katie saying she’s a hopeless romantic but now she’s just hopeless? That one cut me open. I’ve been there. That moment when you realize you missed your chance and can’t stop wondering “what if.” The way she longed for someone to stay, to choose her, to make her feel like she’s enough... Michael, come back please.
When she said, “You can live in the same town your whole life and still grow into a thousand versions of yourself,” I lost it. I cried for hours. That line hit something in me I didn’t even realize needed healing. Miss Kyra Ysabel, you are opening my heart and making me go absolutely insane in the best way. Their realization moments — when they finally acknowledged their feelings — felt like heaven served on a platter. We all need a Michael in our lives, seriously.
And I couldn’t agree more when Katie said that when love is unclear and feelings are messy, sugar is consistent. I literally read that with a slice of blueberry cheesecake in front of me. Relatable. She got the grand gestures she always wanted, and I just sat there whispering, “When is my turn, please?” By the time I reached Chapter 30 up to the epilogue, I looked like a puffer fish from all the crying. Miss Kyra Ysabel, you broke me and healed me all at once. I’m giving this book 6 stars. It spoke to me, destroyed me, and comforted me all in one sitting. I see myself in Katie and all the girlies in her friend group. Miss Kyra, you’ve officially stolen my heart.... and I don’t even want it back.
I would like to thank Miss Kyra Ysabel for letting me be part of the ARC readers for this book. It was such an honor to read something this beautiful before everyone else. This story meant so much to me, it made me laugh, cry, blush, and reflect all at once. Thank you for creating characters that feel like friends and emotions that feel like home. I absolutely loved this book, and I cannot wait for Haley’s story next.
In the end, I devoured this book. It was hilarious, heartfelt, and beautifully relatable. The hate-to-love trope was done perfectly, the found family aspect warmed my heart, and the bond they formed over the kids made everything even more touching. From the soft dedication to the chaotic preschool moments, this book had me smiling, laughing, and sometimes even tearing up. If nobody was gonna say it, I will. I loved this book from the very start. It reminded me that softness isn’t a weakness, it’s strength in disguise.
If you like dislike to lovers stories where bickering slowly turns into stolen glances and secret smiles, this book will make you blush nonstop. The tension between Katie and Michael is everything, full of teasing, stubbornness, and that slow, addictive shift from “I can’t stand you” to “I can’t imagine my day without you.” It’s that perfect mix of irritation and chemistry that keeps you grinning like an idiot the entire time.
If you love the he’s famous, she’s not trope, prepare to melt. Michael might be a big-time basketball star, but around Katie, he’s just a man trying to figure out his heart. The contrast between their worlds — the noise of fame versus the calm of small-town life — makes their story so much richer. Watching him fall for someone who doesn’t care about his status, only about who he is underneath it all, is both grounding and swoon-worthy.
If found family is your comfort trope, then you’re in for the warmest, most wholesome treat. The preschool kids, the friends, the community, every single one of them feels like home. You’ll find yourself wishing you could walk into their little world, surrounded by laughter, chaos, and love that doesn’t demand anything in return. It’s the kind of environment that makes you believe in people again.
And if you melt over couples who bond over kids, brace yourself. The moments where Michael and Katie connect through the preschool children are pure gold. It’s tender, funny, and heart-melting in every way. The way he learns patience, gentleness, and humility through them — and through her — will have you smiling through tears.
Basically, if you want a story that’s romantic, cozy, emotional, and laugh-out-loud funny all at once, this is the book. It’s about two opposites who find balance in each other, a found family that feels like home, and little acts of love that speak louder than grand gestures. If you’re a fan of any of these tropes, trust me — you’ll eat this book up just like I did.