What do you think?
Rate this book
The Astral Library
Listening Length: 8 hours and 50 minutes
From New York Times bestselling author Kate Quinn comes a gorgeously written fantastical adventure which poses the question: Have you ever wished you could live inside a book? Welcome to the Astral Library, where books are not just objects, but doors to new worlds, new lives, and new futures.
Alexandria “Alix” Watson has learned one lesson from her barren childhood in the foster-care system: unlike people, books will never let you down. Working three dead-end jobs to make ends meet and knowing college is a pipe dream, Alix takes nightly refuge in the high-vaulted reading room at the Boston Public Library, escaping into her favorite fantasy novels and dreaming of far-off lands. Until the day she stumbles through a hidden door and meets the Librarian: the ageless, acerbic guardian of a hidden library where the desperate and the lost escape to new lives...inside their favorite books.
The Librarian takes a dazzled Alix under her wing, but before she can escape into the pages of her new life, a shadowy enemy emerges to threaten everyone the Astral Library has ever helped protect. Aided by a dashing costume-shop owner, Alix and the Librarian flee through the Regency drawing rooms of Jane Austen to the back alleys of Sherlock Holmes and the champagne-soaked parties of The Great Gatsby as danger draws inexorably closer. But who does their enemy really wish to destroy—Alix, the Librarian, or the Library itself?
From New York Times bestselling author Kate Quinn comes a gorgeously written fantastical adventure which poses the question: Have you ever wished you could live inside a book? Welcome to the Astral Library, where books are not just objects, but doors to new worlds, new lives, and new futures.
Alexandria “Alix” Watson has learned one lesson from her barren childhood in the foster-care system: unlike people, books will never let you down. Working three dead-end jobs to make ends meet and knowing college is a pipe dream, Alix takes nightly refuge in the high-vaulted reading room at the Boston Public Library, escaping into her favorite fantasy novels and dreaming of far-off lands. Until the day she stumbles through a hidden door and meets the Librarian: the ageless, acerbic guardian of a hidden library where the desperate and the lost escape to new lives...inside their favorite books.
The Librarian takes a dazzled Alix under her wing, but before she can escape into the pages of her new life, a shadowy enemy emerges to threaten everyone the Astral Library has ever helped protect. Aided by a dashing costume-shop owner, Alix and the Librarian flee through the Regency drawing rooms of Jane Austen to the back alleys of Sherlock Holmes and the champagne-soaked parties of The Great Gatsby as danger draws inexorably closer. But who does their enemy really wish to destroy—Alix, the Librarian, or the Library itself?
9 pages, Audible Audio
First published February 17, 2026
7502 people are currently reading
213141 people want to read
About the author
Kate Quinn
38 books43.6k followers--I use Goodreads to track and rate my current reading. Most of my reads are 4 stars, meaning I enjoyed it hugely and would absolutely recommend. 5 stars is blew-my-socks-off; reserved for rare reads. 3 stars is "enjoyed it, but something fell a bit short." I very rarely rate lower because I DNF books I'm not enjoying, and don't rate books I don't finish.--
Kate Quinn is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of historical fiction. A native of southern California, she attended Boston University where she earned a Bachelor’s and Master’s degree in Classical Voice. She has written four novels in the Empress of Rome Saga, and two books in the Italian Renaissance, before turning to the 20th century with “The Alice Network”, “The Huntress,” "The Rose Code," "The Diamond Eye," and "The Briar Club." She is also a co-author in several collaborative novels including "The Phoenix Crown" with Janie Chang and "Ribbons of Scarlet" with Stephanie Dray, Laura Kamoie, Eliza Knight, Sophie Perinot, and Heather Webb. "The Astral Library," releasing in 2026, is her first foray into magical realism. Kate and her husband now live in Maryland with their two rescue dogs.
Kate Quinn is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of historical fiction. A native of southern California, she attended Boston University where she earned a Bachelor’s and Master’s degree in Classical Voice. She has written four novels in the Empress of Rome Saga, and two books in the Italian Renaissance, before turning to the 20th century with “The Alice Network”, “The Huntress,” "The Rose Code," "The Diamond Eye," and "The Briar Club." She is also a co-author in several collaborative novels including "The Phoenix Crown" with Janie Chang and "Ribbons of Scarlet" with Stephanie Dray, Laura Kamoie, Eliza Knight, Sophie Perinot, and Heather Webb. "The Astral Library," releasing in 2026, is her first foray into magical realism. Kate and her husband now live in Maryland with their two rescue dogs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 7,933 reviews
Read
March 3, 2026Update!
3/3/26: THE ASTRAL LIBRARY is an instant New York Times bestseller, debuting at #2 on the list in its first week on shelves--and #1 on the Globe & Mail in Canada! I'm so thrilled and so grateful to all you wonderful readers who made this happen. ❤️
2/17/26: THE ASTRAL LIBRARY has officially hit shelves. I'm so proud and so happy to be seeing it hit readers everywhere--I hope you enjoy it!
THE ASTRAL LIBRARY is available for early-read request on Netgalley and Edelweiss. May the odds be ever in your favor...
We finally have a cover for THE ASTRAL LIBRARY, readers--isn't it gorgeous? And I can tell you that there will be a special deluxe limited edition that will knock your socks off: sprayed decorative edges, illustrated endpapers, jacket effects, and even more. These shelf trophies will go fast, so you definitely want to pre-order here: https://www.harpercollins.com/pages/t...
3/3/26: THE ASTRAL LIBRARY is an instant New York Times bestseller, debuting at #2 on the list in its first week on shelves--and #1 on the Globe & Mail in Canada! I'm so thrilled and so grateful to all you wonderful readers who made this happen. ❤️
2/17/26: THE ASTRAL LIBRARY has officially hit shelves. I'm so proud and so happy to be seeing it hit readers everywhere--I hope you enjoy it!
THE ASTRAL LIBRARY is available for early-read request on Netgalley and Edelweiss. May the odds be ever in your favor...
We finally have a cover for THE ASTRAL LIBRARY, readers--isn't it gorgeous? And I can tell you that there will be a special deluxe limited edition that will knock your socks off: sprayed decorative edges, illustrated endpapers, jacket effects, and even more. These shelf trophies will go fast, so you definitely want to pre-order here: https://www.harpercollins.com/pages/t...
May 3, 2026
Have you ever wanted to live inside a book? Same. If you’re a fellow bookworm, you know the itch—to step through a portal an author built and wander a world where the prose does the set design, the lighting, the score, even the CGI. Kate Quinn’s latest scratches that itch in the best way. Known for her rich historicals and fierce women’s fiction, she takes a gleeful leap into fantasy—yes, with a dash of dragons—and delivers a story stuffed with Easter eggs, heart, and wonder.
Our heroine is Alexandra “Alix” (Alice) Watson, twenty-six and dealt the most lopsided hand. A childhood shuttled through foster care after her mother vanished to L.A.; college dreams traded for three jobs and mounting debt; a hacked bank account (hello, mysterious Libby); and an eviction that empties her pockets and her hope. Rock bottom sends her to the Boston Public Library—just to breathe. Instead, she finds a hidden door and tumbles into the Astral Library, a labyrinthine sanctuary run by an ageless, gloriously grumpy guardian. Here, readers can enter books—under strict rules: public-domain texts only, no rewriting the canon, and you’re never the story’s “chosen one.” There’s even a wardrobe room that outfits you to the era you’re visiting. Reader, I audibly squealed.
Quinn makes the rules feel delicious, not fussy. The council meetings hum with old-world ritual; the red-card warning system ratchets tension without killing the whimsy. And the portals! Alix sleuths in fog-soaked tunnels with Sherlock Holmes searching for the missing Sarah; rows through Huck-and-Tom swamplands; twirls at a Regency ball where Jane Eyre slips by with a knowing glance. Each chapter bows to the original authors while giving Alix just enough agency to matter. It’s catnip for lit lovers: respectful homage with propulsive stakes.
What surprised me most was the emotional core. Alix’s foster-kid armor, her money panic, the ache of being left behind—these aren’t window dressing. The Astral Library isn’t merely a playground; it’s a refuge for people who need one. As patrons arrive chased by the dangers of their real lives, the novel becomes a tender ode to chosen family and the radical safety of libraries. And when Alix suspects the rot is internal—that someone is hunting not just the patrons but the guardian herself—the book pivots from cozy adventure to clever, high-stakes heist. Saving this refuge will mean breaking a few “unbreakable” rules—and deciding what kind of heroine Alix is allowed to be.
Quinn’s craft sings: clean, vivid sentences; chapter endings that snap; clues tucked like marginalia; and playful dragon shimmer at the edges that teases a bigger mythos without overwhelming newcomers. Pacing-wise, it’s brisk but breathable—set piece, quiet beat, reveal, repeat—so you get both the dopamine of discovery and the exhale of character growth. If you’ve ever underlined Austen, argued with Holmes, or hid in a library on a bad day, this book will feel like being handed a key you’ve wanted your whole life.
Overall: Magnificent. Inventive. Unputdownable. A love letter to libraries, a playground for classic-lit fans, and a smart, emotionally generous adventure that celebrates the readers who call stacks and stories their sanctuary. Five “book-inside-a-book” stars—my early pick for one of the most delightful fantasy releases of 2026.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and William Morrow for sharing this marvelous fantasy’s digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
Our heroine is Alexandra “Alix” (Alice) Watson, twenty-six and dealt the most lopsided hand. A childhood shuttled through foster care after her mother vanished to L.A.; college dreams traded for three jobs and mounting debt; a hacked bank account (hello, mysterious Libby); and an eviction that empties her pockets and her hope. Rock bottom sends her to the Boston Public Library—just to breathe. Instead, she finds a hidden door and tumbles into the Astral Library, a labyrinthine sanctuary run by an ageless, gloriously grumpy guardian. Here, readers can enter books—under strict rules: public-domain texts only, no rewriting the canon, and you’re never the story’s “chosen one.” There’s even a wardrobe room that outfits you to the era you’re visiting. Reader, I audibly squealed.
Quinn makes the rules feel delicious, not fussy. The council meetings hum with old-world ritual; the red-card warning system ratchets tension without killing the whimsy. And the portals! Alix sleuths in fog-soaked tunnels with Sherlock Holmes searching for the missing Sarah; rows through Huck-and-Tom swamplands; twirls at a Regency ball where Jane Eyre slips by with a knowing glance. Each chapter bows to the original authors while giving Alix just enough agency to matter. It’s catnip for lit lovers: respectful homage with propulsive stakes.
What surprised me most was the emotional core. Alix’s foster-kid armor, her money panic, the ache of being left behind—these aren’t window dressing. The Astral Library isn’t merely a playground; it’s a refuge for people who need one. As patrons arrive chased by the dangers of their real lives, the novel becomes a tender ode to chosen family and the radical safety of libraries. And when Alix suspects the rot is internal—that someone is hunting not just the patrons but the guardian herself—the book pivots from cozy adventure to clever, high-stakes heist. Saving this refuge will mean breaking a few “unbreakable” rules—and deciding what kind of heroine Alix is allowed to be.
Quinn’s craft sings: clean, vivid sentences; chapter endings that snap; clues tucked like marginalia; and playful dragon shimmer at the edges that teases a bigger mythos without overwhelming newcomers. Pacing-wise, it’s brisk but breathable—set piece, quiet beat, reveal, repeat—so you get both the dopamine of discovery and the exhale of character growth. If you’ve ever underlined Austen, argued with Holmes, or hid in a library on a bad day, this book will feel like being handed a key you’ve wanted your whole life.
Overall: Magnificent. Inventive. Unputdownable. A love letter to libraries, a playground for classic-lit fans, and a smart, emotionally generous adventure that celebrates the readers who call stacks and stories their sanctuary. Five “book-inside-a-book” stars—my early pick for one of the most delightful fantasy releases of 2026.
A very huge thanks to NetGalley and William Morrow for sharing this marvelous fantasy’s digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest thoughts.
medium.com
March 3, 2026
Meh
I gave this two tries — first as an ePub ARC and then again on audio after publication — and ultimately DNF’d around chapter 11.
It’s not poorly written, and the premise is interesting. But the further I read, the more I felt like I was inside a story I’ve already experienced.
A woman discovers a mysterious library outside of reality and begins stepping in and out of books — alternate lives, alternate versions of herself, narrative spaces that mirror parts of her own story.
Whether it’s metaphorical life-path exploration like The Midnight Library or physically entering fictional worlds like A Novel Love Story, the framework felt very familiar. Not inspired by — familiar. And for me, that familiarity drained the tension. I didn’t feel like I was reading anything new.
The repetition of the FMC being a size 22 wasn’t my core issue, but it was what finally tipped me over the edge. Why do authors do this? In the same way I don’t care to hear about an FMC being a size zero, I don’t care to be beaten over the head about her size 22 either. Like it’s her only characteristic. Move on.
This will likely resonate with readers who love metaphysical, book-within-a-book self-discovery stories. It just felt too derivative for me to stay engaged.
DNF at 11 chapters.
Many thanks to William Morrow for the advanced digital copy, all thoughts are my own. 💐
⋆✴︎˚｡⋆ Connect with me on Instagram ˗ˏˋ★‿︵‧ ˚ ₊⊹
I gave this two tries — first as an ePub ARC and then again on audio after publication — and ultimately DNF’d around chapter 11.
It’s not poorly written, and the premise is interesting. But the further I read, the more I felt like I was inside a story I’ve already experienced.
A woman discovers a mysterious library outside of reality and begins stepping in and out of books — alternate lives, alternate versions of herself, narrative spaces that mirror parts of her own story.
Whether it’s metaphorical life-path exploration like The Midnight Library or physically entering fictional worlds like A Novel Love Story, the framework felt very familiar. Not inspired by — familiar. And for me, that familiarity drained the tension. I didn’t feel like I was reading anything new.
The repetition of the FMC being a size 22 wasn’t my core issue, but it was what finally tipped me over the edge. Why do authors do this? In the same way I don’t care to hear about an FMC being a size zero, I don’t care to be beaten over the head about her size 22 either. Like it’s her only characteristic. Move on.
This will likely resonate with readers who love metaphysical, book-within-a-book self-discovery stories. It just felt too derivative for me to stay engaged.
DNF at 11 chapters.
Many thanks to William Morrow for the advanced digital copy, all thoughts are my own. 💐
⋆✴︎˚｡⋆ Connect with me on Instagram ˗ˏˋ★‿︵‧ ˚ ₊⊹
April 27, 2026
We get it. Nobody likes book bans. Kate Quinn doesn't either.
The Astral Library imagines a world where broken people, the ones who rely on libraries when no one else will accept them, are transported into their favorite stories. We leap into Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, wander through the world of Sherlock Holmes, and explore other literary classics. It’s a premise full of potential.
Unfortunately, instead of letting the magic unfold naturally, Astral Library leans heavily on telling rather than showing. We're repeatedly reminded how the downfall of uptight people who don’t actually read, are somehow dictating what others are allowed to read, and in turn the message quickly becomes more lecture than narrative.
“Are you one of those book burners who wants to ban every book they don’t like, all to *save the children*? One of those people who thinks libraries are corrupting our national moral fiber?” Kate Quinn knows exactly what she’s doing here.
Our main character, Alix, abandoned and raised in foster care, finds others with similarly painful pasts: abused wives, neglected kids, and lost souls all seeking refuge. Together, they fight to save one of society’s last truly democratic institutions, the free public library.
Astral Library relies too heavily on government disputes as the antagonist, while the ability to jump into books gets taken by the wayside.
“Public institutions have to remain controversy free, Alix.”
There’s something beautiful buried in here, but the agenda keeps overshadowing the magical realism. Instead of being immersed in a story, you’re constantly being reminded what you’re supposed to think.
Oh, and yes, Florida gets a special mention too:
“The great cesspool into which all loungers and idlers are irresistibly drained,” said the Librarian, coming to a halt at the nearest corner.
“Florida?” I guessed.
I wanted to love this. I really did. But in the end, the message outweighed the magic. While the message should always be important, it ended up not being what could have been.
The Astral Library imagines a world where broken people, the ones who rely on libraries when no one else will accept them, are transported into their favorite stories. We leap into Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, wander through the world of Sherlock Holmes, and explore other literary classics. It’s a premise full of potential.
Unfortunately, instead of letting the magic unfold naturally, Astral Library leans heavily on telling rather than showing. We're repeatedly reminded how the downfall of uptight people who don’t actually read, are somehow dictating what others are allowed to read, and in turn the message quickly becomes more lecture than narrative.
“Are you one of those book burners who wants to ban every book they don’t like, all to *save the children*? One of those people who thinks libraries are corrupting our national moral fiber?” Kate Quinn knows exactly what she’s doing here.
Our main character, Alix, abandoned and raised in foster care, finds others with similarly painful pasts: abused wives, neglected kids, and lost souls all seeking refuge. Together, they fight to save one of society’s last truly democratic institutions, the free public library.
Astral Library relies too heavily on government disputes as the antagonist, while the ability to jump into books gets taken by the wayside.
“Public institutions have to remain controversy free, Alix.”
There’s something beautiful buried in here, but the agenda keeps overshadowing the magical realism. Instead of being immersed in a story, you’re constantly being reminded what you’re supposed to think.
Oh, and yes, Florida gets a special mention too:
“The great cesspool into which all loungers and idlers are irresistibly drained,” said the Librarian, coming to a halt at the nearest corner.
“Florida?” I guessed.
I wanted to love this. I really did. But in the end, the message outweighed the magic. While the message should always be important, it ended up not being what could have been.
December 24, 2025
Prior to reading this book I loved every single book Kate Quinn had written. But this? The author clearly used this book to rant and lecture about various societal and political issues. She inserted her personal opinions about gender ideology, removing age inappropriate books from elementary schools, religion, and even threw in a knock against the state of Florida . There were so many ridiculous assertions that it completely distracted from any storyline or theme. I like to be educated on diverse viewpoints but this felt like preaching on a grand scale in a condescending and mean way. And mocking religion and God? Just wow.
April 27, 2026
***HAPPY PUBLICATION DAY - DON'T MISS THIS ONE***
I have read almost all of Kate Quinn’s historical fiction novels and loved them! When I heard that she was writing a fantasy novel I was all in - with her imagination I knew I was in for a treat. Just look at that cover and printed edges!
Alix Watson had a rough childhood - her mother left when she was young and she grew up in the foster care system - moving through many homes until she was 18 and finally free.
From the blurb: “Alexandria “Alix” Watson has learned one lesson from her barren childhood in the foster-care system: unlike people, books will never let you down.”
One of Alix’s part time jobs is working in the Boston Public LIbrary. She finds so much comfort as she escapes into her fantasy novels. She enjoys interacting with the patrons and others in the library.
One day a door opens at the top of the stairs - her life will never be the same! She meets the Librarian of the Astral Library and learns how they shelter people who need a place to flee from their troubles or other threats - they can be helped to live inside one of their favorite books!
That is all I will tell you about the plot - it's more fun to discover all the adventures yourself. Alix finds out a lot about herself and how strong she is. She meets great characters from the books that she loves and ultimately helps to keep the library safe from threats!
The plot moves quickly and the writing is bold, imaginative and truly fantastic.
I can recommend this book to everyone - if you are reading this review you are one of us – a bibliophile and lover of all things book related. You are in for a treat.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss. It was my pleasure to read and review this novel!
I have read almost all of Kate Quinn’s historical fiction novels and loved them! When I heard that she was writing a fantasy novel I was all in - with her imagination I knew I was in for a treat. Just look at that cover and printed edges!
Alix Watson had a rough childhood - her mother left when she was young and she grew up in the foster care system - moving through many homes until she was 18 and finally free.
From the blurb: “Alexandria “Alix” Watson has learned one lesson from her barren childhood in the foster-care system: unlike people, books will never let you down.”
One of Alix’s part time jobs is working in the Boston Public LIbrary. She finds so much comfort as she escapes into her fantasy novels. She enjoys interacting with the patrons and others in the library.
One day a door opens at the top of the stairs - her life will never be the same! She meets the Librarian of the Astral Library and learns how they shelter people who need a place to flee from their troubles or other threats - they can be helped to live inside one of their favorite books!
That is all I will tell you about the plot - it's more fun to discover all the adventures yourself. Alix finds out a lot about herself and how strong she is. She meets great characters from the books that she loves and ultimately helps to keep the library safe from threats!
The plot moves quickly and the writing is bold, imaginative and truly fantastic.
I can recommend this book to everyone - if you are reading this review you are one of us – a bibliophile and lover of all things book related. You are in for a treat.
I received an ARC of this novel from the publisher through Edelweiss. It was my pleasure to read and review this novel!
February 19, 2026
What happened to Kate Quinn? From the queen who authored "The Rose Code" and "The Alice Network" we get THIS? I'm so disappointed.
I was originally excited to read about the premise of TAL! I could imagine the fun of it all, the adventure, even the memorable scenes and lines. And it actually started all right. The MC is a down-on-her-luck, annoying young woman with lots of potential. Once she enters the magic of the Astral library, it all goes downhill pretty fast.
There are two things that sink it, IMO. The first- and I could forgive this- is that the plot bogs down. I dnf'd at 40% (more on that soon) and nothing had really happened. She goes into Sherlock Holmes' world first, and just as I was gearing up for a fun adventure, it ended. Like a total of 10 pages. The same with Jane Eyre- she walks past a room where you-know-who is imprisoned, aaaaaand nothing. She's done with that book and on to the next!?! Then they go.... well you get the idea. There is just so much wasted potential.
I could have pushed past the the poor storytelling, hoping for a good ending, if not for the unnecessary and divisive and snarky politics she inserts in the story. She writes of a teen boy who is terrified of and escapes from his evil family because they do not believe that a 'boy can become a girl'. That's it. Not because they are abusive in any way, but because they believe in biological science over social engineering and (possibly) are religious. She takes potshots at conservative states in America- which is fine and kind of funny by itself. But when she takes the MC into an art gallery, the best in the world, where art (including literature, for that matter) could/should be the ONE thing that can unite a divided society, she handles it this way: "... I caught a glimpse of what I was fairly sure was a rendition of THE LAST SUPPER, but couldn't remember if it was Michelangelo or a Leonardo. Either way, I didn't see the point of going to visit it. Stuck at a 'dinner party' that never ends with a lot of religious types? Pass the water-into-wine, please." So. She went there. To me this feels less like the story than it does Kate Quinn telling us how she really feels.
I don't get it. Books and art are meant to be appreciated whether or not you agree with their origins. They have the power to unite us! There are so many wonderful books and paintings and statues that don't match my worldview, that I love and appreciate anyway. (The Taj Mahal, 'The Chosen' by Potok, incredible Japanese art, etc. You get the idea...) I am so disappointed that Quinn chooses to demean Christianity, rather than (ignore it OR) give it the respect that any serious religion deserves.
I'm too old- and my time is way too valuable- to waste my time on authors with small, narrow perspectives. I'm done, Kate.
Note on content- Some adult language from the FMC throughout. No sex scenes up to the 40% mark. Not much violence. Content probably ok for adults and teens.
I was originally excited to read about the premise of TAL! I could imagine the fun of it all, the adventure, even the memorable scenes and lines. And it actually started all right. The MC is a down-on-her-luck, annoying young woman with lots of potential. Once she enters the magic of the Astral library, it all goes downhill pretty fast.
There are two things that sink it, IMO. The first- and I could forgive this- is that the plot bogs down. I dnf'd at 40% (more on that soon) and nothing had really happened. She goes into Sherlock Holmes' world first, and just as I was gearing up for a fun adventure, it ended. Like a total of 10 pages. The same with Jane Eyre- she walks past a room where you-know-who is imprisoned, aaaaaand nothing. She's done with that book and on to the next!?! Then they go.... well you get the idea. There is just so much wasted potential.
I could have pushed past the the poor storytelling, hoping for a good ending, if not for the unnecessary and divisive and snarky politics she inserts in the story. She writes of a teen boy who is terrified of and escapes from his evil family because they do not believe that a 'boy can become a girl'. That's it. Not because they are abusive in any way, but because they believe in biological science over social engineering and (possibly) are religious. She takes potshots at conservative states in America- which is fine and kind of funny by itself. But when she takes the MC into an art gallery, the best in the world, where art (including literature, for that matter) could/should be the ONE thing that can unite a divided society, she handles it this way: "... I caught a glimpse of what I was fairly sure was a rendition of THE LAST SUPPER, but couldn't remember if it was Michelangelo or a Leonardo. Either way, I didn't see the point of going to visit it. Stuck at a 'dinner party' that never ends with a lot of religious types? Pass the water-into-wine, please." So. She went there. To me this feels less like the story than it does Kate Quinn telling us how she really feels.
I don't get it. Books and art are meant to be appreciated whether or not you agree with their origins. They have the power to unite us! There are so many wonderful books and paintings and statues that don't match my worldview, that I love and appreciate anyway. (The Taj Mahal, 'The Chosen' by Potok, incredible Japanese art, etc. You get the idea...) I am so disappointed that Quinn chooses to demean Christianity, rather than (ignore it OR) give it the respect that any serious religion deserves.
I'm too old- and my time is way too valuable- to waste my time on authors with small, narrow perspectives. I'm done, Kate.
Note on content- Some adult language from the FMC throughout. No sex scenes up to the 40% mark. Not much violence. Content probably ok for adults and teens.
February 26, 2026
Love the concept of libraries protecting lost souls, but I couldn’t quite get into it unfortunately. Quite different from Quinn’s historical fiction as well, and I kind of missed the suspense I felt in those books.
February 22, 2026
Every readers dream come true. I love Kate's writing and her imagination was brilliant crafting this book. I liked the characters, the flow. This would totally be my dream job!
December 16, 2025
Ew. Are all her books raging liberal like this? Had high hopes for this author but all the political undertones she kept throwing unnecessarily into this story ruined it. For example the MC throws an insult at a minor character about having a KKK meeting to a security guard she didn’t like. Then a poorly veiled reference to the Little Mermaid and Snow White recast controversy (where Quinn attempts to insult people who weren’t in favor of the recasting). Or the unnecessary feminist quips that all men are violent and war mongering. Yeah no. It was obvious Quinn used this book as a rant on various societal issues. There’s enough strife and discord in reality, I personally don’t want to see it in the books I’m reading. I read as a chance to escape that for a bit not have an authors personal opinions thrown in my face. Write a blog post or non fiction book if you have something to say. Sneaking it into your works is a manipulative way to blast your views.
A free arc was received via netgalley in exchange for an HONEST review.
A free arc was received via netgalley in exchange for an HONEST review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
⭐️ 3.5 ⭐️ Books are my portals to all the wonderful places, real or imaginary. They are my sanctuary, my world of dreams, possibilities, and a life full lived. I’ve always wished I had magical powers to transport myself inside a book and live a life full of adventures. So here is a tale that’s dreamy and whimsical—it’s an absolute gem full of surprises and warm hugs.
In The Astral Library, Kate Quinn decided to take a trip down literary historical memory lane, weaving hope with magical realism into her cozy story that will take book lovers on a literary journey through time.
The Astral Library is a sentient, hidden library (within a library!) that can open its doors from any library in the world. All of the books have opinions and are alive! It offers a sanctuary for anyone that’s looking for love, joy, hope and security. Alix Watson is a 26 year old who grew up in foster care and whose life seems to be going sideways. She’s always been a loner, carrying a low opinion of herself and struggling to get by. But she’s a dreamer like all book lovers and all she ever wanted was a different life, a different world to live in. So when she visits the Boston Public Library, she accidentally discovers the Astral Library and her world forever changes!
Stepping into the Astral Library was an escape into different literary landscapes. Think Austen, Brontë, Dickens, Conan Doyle, etc! Quinn takes you on a fun, adventurous journey where characters jump from book to book while solving a mystery that began from the moment Alix entered the library. She not only gets to book jump, but also able to transport herself through paintings! For someone who finished an art school, I appreciated that concept a lot and was pleasantly surprised by the chosen artists/paintings! I felt like I was dream walking from one world to the next. It was a lovely surprise.
For a short novel it packed on a lot—a lot of historical writers and painters, a lot of jumps through time, overuse of extended feelings of abandonment (Alix insecurities), easily prone to quick action with no in-between. I wish it explored certain worlds a bit more thoroughly but felt rushed on and off. I also wanted more emotional layers aside from Alix’s inner monologue and more from side characters. Hence why I’ve rated it much lower than I wanted to. Nevertheless, I’d still recommend this to anyone who loves the concept of time travel through history!
If you’re a fan of The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley, you’re going to love this book. It’s a book for all the dreamers with themes of found family, gender identity (light), belonging. It’s funny, it’s playful, it’s just a feel good book to have for a cozy weekend.
If you’ve had a chance to step into a book, which one would it be? Share below!
Many thanks to NetGalley, William Morrow Publisher and the author Kate Quinn for this eARC!
Publication date: February 17, 2026
In The Astral Library, Kate Quinn decided to take a trip down literary historical memory lane, weaving hope with magical realism into her cozy story that will take book lovers on a literary journey through time.
The Astral Library is a sentient, hidden library (within a library!) that can open its doors from any library in the world. All of the books have opinions and are alive! It offers a sanctuary for anyone that’s looking for love, joy, hope and security. Alix Watson is a 26 year old who grew up in foster care and whose life seems to be going sideways. She’s always been a loner, carrying a low opinion of herself and struggling to get by. But she’s a dreamer like all book lovers and all she ever wanted was a different life, a different world to live in. So when she visits the Boston Public Library, she accidentally discovers the Astral Library and her world forever changes!
Stepping into the Astral Library was an escape into different literary landscapes. Think Austen, Brontë, Dickens, Conan Doyle, etc! Quinn takes you on a fun, adventurous journey where characters jump from book to book while solving a mystery that began from the moment Alix entered the library. She not only gets to book jump, but also able to transport herself through paintings! For someone who finished an art school, I appreciated that concept a lot and was pleasantly surprised by the chosen artists/paintings! I felt like I was dream walking from one world to the next. It was a lovely surprise.
For a short novel it packed on a lot—a lot of historical writers and painters, a lot of jumps through time, overuse of extended feelings of abandonment (Alix insecurities), easily prone to quick action with no in-between. I wish it explored certain worlds a bit more thoroughly but felt rushed on and off. I also wanted more emotional layers aside from Alix’s inner monologue and more from side characters. Hence why I’ve rated it much lower than I wanted to. Nevertheless, I’d still recommend this to anyone who loves the concept of time travel through history!
If you’re a fan of The Ministry of Time by Kaliane Bradley, you’re going to love this book. It’s a book for all the dreamers with themes of found family, gender identity (light), belonging. It’s funny, it’s playful, it’s just a feel good book to have for a cozy weekend.
If you’ve had a chance to step into a book, which one would it be? Share below!
Many thanks to NetGalley, William Morrow Publisher and the author Kate Quinn for this eARC!
Publication date: February 17, 2026
April 21, 2026
In a Nutshell: A contemporary magical realism novel featuring a magical library. Starts fabulous, but after a point, turns tedious. Annoying lead character. Great world-building, poor character development, decent plot development. Too many coincidences. Too much social commentary, even though it’s for a worthy cause. Feels like YA at times, though it is an adult book with dark themes. I love this author, but I might stick to her historical fiction works now onwards. Recommended to NA readers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
I have not read much of Kate Quinn, but whatever I have read, I have loved. Her forte is historical fiction, but with this magical realism novel, she ventures into new territory. She does outstandingly well in the historical and bookish components of the book, but the rest isn't up to her usual high standard.
Bookish Yays:
📚 The Astral Library and everything within it! Such fabulous imagery! In all its wonderful features, I most loved how it allowed ghosts with unfinished TBRs to continue reading. (Book me a place, Astral Library! 🥺) I also love that the library doesn’t limit the offer of sanctuary only to books.
📚 The Librarian. Exactly as you would expect from a true-blue librarian. I loved her alternate avatar as well. Beau was also a good character, though he wasn’t fairly utilised by the plot.
📚 Everything about books and libraries and librarians and how we need them all – No bibliophile can argue with this!
📚 Many witty lines and a lot of banter.
📚 The depiction of the impact of parental abandonment and foster care on mental health and behaviour. The foster child angle is especially well-written.
📚 The epilogue. Offered a good settlement of all key subplots.
📚 The author's note – outstanding. I saw genuine glimpses of the author I love in this note.
Bookish Okays:
📖 Alix being a size 22. I loved seeing an overweight protagonist in the fantasy genre and her struggles to get a period costume in her size, but her thoughts and comments about her weight and body shape are too frequent. Why do we need to be told so many times that she is bigger than average? Equally annoying is her tendency to keep referring to Beau’s physical appeal.
📖 Alix never sounds her age, with her behaviour and speaking style creating a YA kind of feel. (It’s not a YA book, though. There are several dark topics such as suicidal ideation, domestic violence, and deaths, and also cussing.) That said, as she has lived in the foster care system for almost a decade and even now has no mature adults in her life, I guess her childishness can be pardoned. But it isn't easy, and she gets annoying quite frequently.
📖 The Astral Library’s offer of living in a book of your choice to escape your fate is very interesting, showing not just how the system works but also taking us into some of the book worlds. Of course, you will enjoy this only if you are familiar with those books, else it isn't that impactful. I was in my comfort zone with the classics (Not a surprise that I enjoyed the Pride & Prejudice content most of all!), but there were some modern fantasy worlds as well; I winged my way through these. I wish the exploration of the worlds had been more adventurous and detailed. Our visits to the books are only fleeting.
Bookish Nays:
📕 The somewhat lengthy build-up. The first quarter of the book, though the biggest and best part of the book, is mostly the foundation. The middle section gets boring and repetitive.
📕 The pretentious vocabulary sometimes used by Alix. Just doesn’t gel with her overall personality.
📕 Some developments are overly convenient, especially in how characters appear and leave at opportune moments in the plot.
📕 The romance arc. Totally not needed, and also not convincing. The couple had more friend energy.
📕 The whole Alix-as-the-Chosen-One trope. I didn’t find her a worthy Chosen One. Her instant adaption to the new role also is unconvincing.
📕 The social commentary, though relevant, is too heavy-handed. One remark was unnecessarily anti-Christian, which I don’t appreciate.
📕 The ending was OTT. The big reveal felt a bit anti-climactic to me; I was expecting something much darker. Plus, there’s a lengthy spiel by Alix about libraries and their importance. I love libraries but even then I found her speech too verbose and preachy.
Overall, I expected this book about a magic library to go much better for me. Perhaps my expectations from Kate Quinn are too high, and maybe if this were by some other author, I wouldn’t not been so disappointed. Alix’s immaturity is of course one reason for my lack of satisfaction. But I am also disappointed that after that initial adventurous foundation, it changed tracks into a social manifesto while I was still hoping for bookish adventures.
I wish I could have recommended this to YA readers, but some content isn't age-appropriate for them. Perhaps NA readers (and maybe, older YA readers) could give this a go. Then again, this novel is best experienced if you know a majority of the classic books and book worlds it refers to. Given how a majority of YA/NA readers these days don’t read the classics, they’ll not see the intricacies of those worlds nor understand the cleverness of the author’s writing choices.
Recommended, not to the usual Kate Quinn fans but to those who enjoy magical realism with a youngish protagonist who acts even younger, a whole load of social commentary, and plenty of books and libraries. As for me, I’ll stick to her historical fiction works.
2.75 stars.
My thanks to HarperCollins UK and HarperFiction for providing the DRC of “The Astral Library” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I follow the Goodreads rating policy:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ - Lifelong favourite!
⭐⭐⭐⭐ - I loved the book.
⭐⭐⭐ - I liked the book.
⭐⭐ - I found the book average.
⭐ - I hated the book.
The decimals indicate the degree of the in-between feelings.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Facebook ||
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
Twenty-six-year-old Alix, once a foster child and now juggling three dead-end jobs to barely eke out a living, usually takes refuge in her favourite place, the Boston Public Library, and dives into a fantasy novel to help her escape, at least in her thoughts. But today when she visits the library, she stumbles through a hidden door into a section she had never seen before. In this magical room filled to the brim with seemingly alive books, she bumps into The Librarian: the ageless guardian of the Astral Library, where the desperate are offered a chance to escape to new lives inside their favourite books. Alix jumps at the opportunity to leave her dreary life behind, but just when she is about to dive into her new book world, the Astral Library flags up an external threat. As the Librarian (with Alix tagging along) gears up to save the Astral Library and all those it has saved over the years, they realise that the danger is far beyond what they had initially assumed.
The story comes to us in Alix’s first-person POV.
I have not read much of Kate Quinn, but whatever I have read, I have loved. Her forte is historical fiction, but with this magical realism novel, she ventures into new territory. She does outstandingly well in the historical and bookish components of the book, but the rest isn't up to her usual high standard.
Bookish Yays:
📚 The Astral Library and everything within it! Such fabulous imagery! In all its wonderful features, I most loved how it allowed ghosts with unfinished TBRs to continue reading. (Book me a place, Astral Library! 🥺) I also love that the library doesn’t limit the offer of sanctuary only to books.
📚 The Librarian. Exactly as you would expect from a true-blue librarian. I loved her alternate avatar as well. Beau was also a good character, though he wasn’t fairly utilised by the plot.
📚 Everything about books and libraries and librarians and how we need them all – No bibliophile can argue with this!
📚 Many witty lines and a lot of banter.
📚 The depiction of the impact of parental abandonment and foster care on mental health and behaviour. The foster child angle is especially well-written.
📚 The epilogue. Offered a good settlement of all key subplots.
📚 The author's note – outstanding. I saw genuine glimpses of the author I love in this note.
Bookish Okays:
📖 Alix being a size 22. I loved seeing an overweight protagonist in the fantasy genre and her struggles to get a period costume in her size, but her thoughts and comments about her weight and body shape are too frequent. Why do we need to be told so many times that she is bigger than average? Equally annoying is her tendency to keep referring to Beau’s physical appeal.
📖 Alix never sounds her age, with her behaviour and speaking style creating a YA kind of feel. (It’s not a YA book, though. There are several dark topics such as suicidal ideation, domestic violence, and deaths, and also cussing.) That said, as she has lived in the foster care system for almost a decade and even now has no mature adults in her life, I guess her childishness can be pardoned. But it isn't easy, and she gets annoying quite frequently.
📖 The Astral Library’s offer of living in a book of your choice to escape your fate is very interesting, showing not just how the system works but also taking us into some of the book worlds. Of course, you will enjoy this only if you are familiar with those books, else it isn't that impactful. I was in my comfort zone with the classics (Not a surprise that I enjoyed the Pride & Prejudice content most of all!), but there were some modern fantasy worlds as well; I winged my way through these. I wish the exploration of the worlds had been more adventurous and detailed. Our visits to the books are only fleeting.
Bookish Nays:
📕 The somewhat lengthy build-up. The first quarter of the book, though the biggest and best part of the book, is mostly the foundation. The middle section gets boring and repetitive.
📕 The pretentious vocabulary sometimes used by Alix. Just doesn’t gel with her overall personality.
📕 Some developments are overly convenient, especially in how characters appear and leave at opportune moments in the plot.
📕 The romance arc. Totally not needed, and also not convincing. The couple had more friend energy.
📕 The whole Alix-as-the-Chosen-One trope. I didn’t find her a worthy Chosen One. Her instant adaption to the new role also is unconvincing.
📕 The social commentary, though relevant, is too heavy-handed. One remark was unnecessarily anti-Christian, which I don’t appreciate.
📕 The ending was OTT. The big reveal felt a bit anti-climactic to me; I was expecting something much darker. Plus, there’s a lengthy spiel by Alix about libraries and their importance. I love libraries but even then I found her speech too verbose and preachy.
Overall, I expected this book about a magic library to go much better for me. Perhaps my expectations from Kate Quinn are too high, and maybe if this were by some other author, I wouldn’t not been so disappointed. Alix’s immaturity is of course one reason for my lack of satisfaction. But I am also disappointed that after that initial adventurous foundation, it changed tracks into a social manifesto while I was still hoping for bookish adventures.
I wish I could have recommended this to YA readers, but some content isn't age-appropriate for them. Perhaps NA readers (and maybe, older YA readers) could give this a go. Then again, this novel is best experienced if you know a majority of the classic books and book worlds it refers to. Given how a majority of YA/NA readers these days don’t read the classics, they’ll not see the intricacies of those worlds nor understand the cleverness of the author’s writing choices.
Recommended, not to the usual Kate Quinn fans but to those who enjoy magical realism with a youngish protagonist who acts even younger, a whole load of social commentary, and plenty of books and libraries. As for me, I’ll stick to her historical fiction works.
2.75 stars.
My thanks to HarperCollins UK and HarperFiction for providing the DRC of “The Astral Library” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I follow the Goodreads rating policy:
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ - Lifelong favourite!
⭐⭐⭐⭐ - I loved the book.
⭐⭐⭐ - I liked the book.
⭐⭐ - I found the book average.
⭐ - I hated the book.
The decimals indicate the degree of the in-between feelings.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Facebook ||
March 23, 2026
please go back to historical fiction kate quinn
February 23, 2026
3.5 stars rounded to 4 for this! Kate Quinn tried a new genre with magical realism in her latest release and while i was entertained and always have fun w her books, this is likely my least fave of her books.
this was my most anticipated 2026 release so expectations were high. the plot and premise pulled me in right away—what if you could live inside a book? it kind of gave me THE BOOK OF DOORS vibes for a second (but that one is better imo!).
🎧 fab on audio bc it’s narrated by Saskia Maarleveld (as all of Kate’s are!!)
there was LOTS of love for libraries and book classics—Narnia, Jane Austen books, Agatha Christie books, Great Gatsby, etc. also lots of love for fantasy books/plots (personal fave of the author). as someone who doesn’t really read the classics or fantasy books, that lost me a bit on an emotional connection scale. also side note: i low key hate reading present day things in books lol! the author mentions The Fourth Wing and things like that a handful of times 🤷🏼♀️
i got to see her on tour for this book release and it’s evident how much fun she had while writing. this was a story she had been thinking of for awhile and used it as escapism / wrote it during the pandemic. the overall theme is very important—make sure you do your part to support and protect our libraries!!! ❤️❤️❤️👏🏼👏🏼 i have so many fond memories as a kid going to my library and making it my sanctuary and hope all kids have that option for years and years and years to come.
i think she generally set out what she wanted to do for this but it will be forgettable for me long term, especially when comparing to THE ROSE CODE or THE ALICE NETWORK (two all time faves for me!). i enjoy her historical fiction work more but applaud her for trying something new.
TLDR: a new genre for her, fun and quick (and her shortest book!) but overall not my fave.
this was my most anticipated 2026 release so expectations were high. the plot and premise pulled me in right away—what if you could live inside a book? it kind of gave me THE BOOK OF DOORS vibes for a second (but that one is better imo!).
🎧 fab on audio bc it’s narrated by Saskia Maarleveld (as all of Kate’s are!!)
there was LOTS of love for libraries and book classics—Narnia, Jane Austen books, Agatha Christie books, Great Gatsby, etc. also lots of love for fantasy books/plots (personal fave of the author). as someone who doesn’t really read the classics or fantasy books, that lost me a bit on an emotional connection scale. also side note: i low key hate reading present day things in books lol! the author mentions The Fourth Wing and things like that a handful of times 🤷🏼♀️
i got to see her on tour for this book release and it’s evident how much fun she had while writing. this was a story she had been thinking of for awhile and used it as escapism / wrote it during the pandemic. the overall theme is very important—make sure you do your part to support and protect our libraries!!! ❤️❤️❤️👏🏼👏🏼 i have so many fond memories as a kid going to my library and making it my sanctuary and hope all kids have that option for years and years and years to come.
i think she generally set out what she wanted to do for this but it will be forgettable for me long term, especially when comparing to THE ROSE CODE or THE ALICE NETWORK (two all time faves for me!). i enjoy her historical fiction work more but applaud her for trying something new.
TLDR: a new genre for her, fun and quick (and her shortest book!) but overall not my fave.
February 23, 2026
I’m sorry but this book is terrible… and I actually agree with the authors take on book banning and corporations trying to make libraries “for profit”. But it was just so cliched and in your face. She’s taken a decades/centuries/civilizations long problematic structure and over exaggerated it so much that the insidiousness almost becomes a parody of itself. This is not how you educate and change minds… this is how you build up a wall of defensiveness and scorn.
Beliefs like book banning and corporations choosing profits over everything else are ideas that have been slowly woven into cultures and ideologies over time… behind the scenes hidden in positive messaging and lies. Writing them like this just makes a normally amazing author seem childish and trite.
This book/idea had the potential to be so many things. I have seen this author intertwine AMAZING stories while seamlessly opening the readers eyes to ideas they may never have thought about, or provide new depths to ones they have. This wasn’t even a well thought out story… I’m so unbelievably disappointed.
Beliefs like book banning and corporations choosing profits over everything else are ideas that have been slowly woven into cultures and ideologies over time… behind the scenes hidden in positive messaging and lies. Writing them like this just makes a normally amazing author seem childish and trite.
This book/idea had the potential to be so many things. I have seen this author intertwine AMAZING stories while seamlessly opening the readers eyes to ideas they may never have thought about, or provide new depths to ones they have. This wasn’t even a well thought out story… I’m so unbelievably disappointed.
March 15, 2026
Kate Quinn, bestselling author of historical women's fiction — The Alice Network, The Rose Code, The Diamond Eye — makes her magical realism debut with her most recent release.
The Astral Library transforms every bookworm's fantasy into a reality.
Ever dreamed you could live inside a book? Quinn opens her newest novel with just that provocation.
Want to visit Jane Austen's Regency drawing rooms? Done.
Prefer the fog-shrouded streets of Sherlock Holmes’ London? Step right in.
Fancy a stab at swashbuckling in The Three Musketeers. En garde!
The Astral Library is an enchanting tale about a young woman who learns that the escape we crave through reading can sometimes become literal when she discovers a magical realm hidden within the Boston Public Library.
Imagine a library overseen by an ageless, brusque Librarian who offers troubled souls new lives within beloved stories.
Visitors to the Astral Library can either cozy up with a favorite book — complimentary tea and biscuits provided, of course — or, for those in need of a more permanent sanctuary, can choose to physically live inside any book in the public domain.
Action. Adventure. Romance. A dragon! The Astral Library has it all and then some.
This is a delightful read that shines a light on the important role libraries play in preserving knowledge, culture, and imagination.
Quinn has written an enchanting love letter to readers and the transformative power of stories. Bravo!
⊹₊ ˚‧︵‿₊୨ ᰔ ୧₊‿︵‧ ˚ ₊⊹
Okay, so this lifelong bookworm found herself wondering what book I would choose to inhabit if granted access to the Astral Library.
Remember, books still under copyright protection are off limits, so those in the public domain only.
I couldn't do it. I could not pick just one.
And then I realized, heck, I don't have to! I can jump around... a month here, a few weeks there.
Here are my current top 5 picks:
❤️ Definitely hanging out with Athos, Porthos, and Aramis in The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas.
❤️ King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table by Sir Thomas Malory
❤️ The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood by Howard Pyle
❤️ The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett
❤️ Heidi by Johanna Spyri
Alright, your turn: If you could step into any book world for even just a day, which would you choose?
February 19, 2026
It hurts me to rate this so low. I found the main character irritating & the fantastical elements fell flat.
December 10, 2025
4-5 stars rounded up
Have you ever wanted to live inside a book? Oh boy, I have. Eight year old Alix Watson ponders this as she enters her third foster home in six months, clutching her treasured copy of The Voyage of the Dawn
Treader. This home is not up to much either, so it’s pretty obvious to her that it’s inevitable she would want to escape into those pages and inhabit them. As a 26-year-old holding down three jobs, she does poverty maths at a grocery store and her card is declined. Sadly, things are only going to get worse for her. She heads to the Boston Public Library, which is one of her part-time jobs, but which is also her place of comfort and solitude. In order to avoid the officious security guard and head librarian Elizabeth, she steps into the Reading Room storage closet and enters… The Astral Library, with its ageless guardian of this magical space. The Astral Library chose her, there’s a first time for everything. However, something dark is lurking in its shadows threatening to destroy the library. Alix must find hidden strengths and considerable resourcefulness to vanquish this determined enemy.
First of all, the Boston Public Library sounds truly wonderful and would there were an astral library to escape into. This is Kate Quinn‘s first voyage into fantasy fiction and for me it’s a success but then I guess she’s speaking to someone who has been bookworm from the age of about five.
As you would expect this novel is so well written, it’s vivid, lively, engaging, pacey, clever, witty and funny. It’s such an imaginative and creative way of making a stand against library closures, book bans and so on. Readers leap from one book world to the next. From 221B Baker Street to Jane Austin‘s world, via Tom Sawyer, Dickens and the Three Musketeers and many more. It’s a brilliant allegory for outside attacks pulling characters inside books to the safety of its pages.
The characters are excellent. I love the whip smart repartee of Alix with an i (with many wry smiles from me) usually as a cover-up of the awful hand life, or more accurately her mother, has bequeathed her and as a result of her poverty. She grows and grows as time goes on alongside my admiration. The Astral Librarian is fabulous, Elizabeth less so and the pages are especially lively when Alix’s friend Beau Sato-Jones inhabits the pages. He’s such a colourful contrast to Alex although she does change from monotone to technicolour.
Overall, as someone who has long lived in the pages of books this strikes a chord. It drives home pertinent points in a smart and insightful way and I revel in the worlds this talented author transports me to.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to HarperCollins, HarperFiction for the much appreciated early copy in return for an honest review.
Have you ever wanted to live inside a book? Oh boy, I have. Eight year old Alix Watson ponders this as she enters her third foster home in six months, clutching her treasured copy of The Voyage of the Dawn
Treader. This home is not up to much either, so it’s pretty obvious to her that it’s inevitable she would want to escape into those pages and inhabit them. As a 26-year-old holding down three jobs, she does poverty maths at a grocery store and her card is declined. Sadly, things are only going to get worse for her. She heads to the Boston Public Library, which is one of her part-time jobs, but which is also her place of comfort and solitude. In order to avoid the officious security guard and head librarian Elizabeth, she steps into the Reading Room storage closet and enters… The Astral Library, with its ageless guardian of this magical space. The Astral Library chose her, there’s a first time for everything. However, something dark is lurking in its shadows threatening to destroy the library. Alix must find hidden strengths and considerable resourcefulness to vanquish this determined enemy.
First of all, the Boston Public Library sounds truly wonderful and would there were an astral library to escape into. This is Kate Quinn‘s first voyage into fantasy fiction and for me it’s a success but then I guess she’s speaking to someone who has been bookworm from the age of about five.
As you would expect this novel is so well written, it’s vivid, lively, engaging, pacey, clever, witty and funny. It’s such an imaginative and creative way of making a stand against library closures, book bans and so on. Readers leap from one book world to the next. From 221B Baker Street to Jane Austin‘s world, via Tom Sawyer, Dickens and the Three Musketeers and many more. It’s a brilliant allegory for outside attacks pulling characters inside books to the safety of its pages.
The characters are excellent. I love the whip smart repartee of Alix with an i (with many wry smiles from me) usually as a cover-up of the awful hand life, or more accurately her mother, has bequeathed her and as a result of her poverty. She grows and grows as time goes on alongside my admiration. The Astral Librarian is fabulous, Elizabeth less so and the pages are especially lively when Alix’s friend Beau Sato-Jones inhabits the pages. He’s such a colourful contrast to Alex although she does change from monotone to technicolour.
Overall, as someone who has long lived in the pages of books this strikes a chord. It drives home pertinent points in a smart and insightful way and I revel in the worlds this talented author transports me to.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to HarperCollins, HarperFiction for the much appreciated early copy in return for an honest review.
February 24, 2026
A whimsical nod to libraries and book dragons!🐉 Beautiful in its imaginings and shot through with symbolism The Astral Library takes readers on more than an adventure, it has important messages about protecting our libraries. The gorgeous cover art caught my eye also having read Kate Quinn's historical fiction I was curious about her testing the waters of magical realism. She dove right in and nailed it!
📚📚📚📚📚
If you've ever wondered what it would be like to step into the pages of a favorite book this one's for you. When settings are explored as direct plot points, they come across stronger from Sherlock Holmes's London to Anne Shirley's Avonlea the settings are ever changing and immersive. There exists a library that grants admission and protection to desperate patrons. A door to the Astral Library can open from any library. The moving shelves and books add charm while the ageless librarian helps patrons find the right book for them to enter and leave behind the suffering of their regular lives. These readers find homes and solace living on the periphery of classic novels. In other words, you can't enter Pride and Prejudice and marry Darcy, but you could become the cousin of a supporting character living a full life in the world Austen created.
🐉🐉🐉🐉🐉
Alix our plucky plus sized heroine grew up in foster care after being abandoned by her mother. Her life is a constant struggle; she barely swings her portion of the rent. After being asked to leave her crappy apartment by a roommate and having her identity stolen, she's at her wits end. She finds shelter at the Boston Public Library one of her three jobs, where she notices a door. It leads her to the Astral Library. While exploring the library it becomes obvious that either Alix, the librarian, or the library itself is being targeted. But why? The situation goes from annoying to dangerous.
🎩👗🎩👗🎩
The editing was fantastic! Books with this type of format can drag and lose their page turning fairy dust, but the pace stayed on point so KUDOS to the editor for keeping it streamlined. The cast of characters had genuine struggles and seeing how the library changed their lives was worthwhile. There is also a look at art and gaming which I thought was an interesting touch it worked well in the story. The light romantic thread between Alix and an up-and-coming costume designer was a sweet addition giving a sense of balance to the story and adding dimension to the characters.
🪡🧵🪡🧵🪡
Not only do libraries offer the escape provided by the books they house, but also a literal refuge asking little in return The Astral Library was a solid representation of that.
📖📖📖📖📖
*Now Available*
Thank you to William Morrow for providing an ARC via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
📚📚📚📚📚
If you've ever wondered what it would be like to step into the pages of a favorite book this one's for you. When settings are explored as direct plot points, they come across stronger from Sherlock Holmes's London to Anne Shirley's Avonlea the settings are ever changing and immersive. There exists a library that grants admission and protection to desperate patrons. A door to the Astral Library can open from any library. The moving shelves and books add charm while the ageless librarian helps patrons find the right book for them to enter and leave behind the suffering of their regular lives. These readers find homes and solace living on the periphery of classic novels. In other words, you can't enter Pride and Prejudice and marry Darcy, but you could become the cousin of a supporting character living a full life in the world Austen created.
🐉🐉🐉🐉🐉
Alix our plucky plus sized heroine grew up in foster care after being abandoned by her mother. Her life is a constant struggle; she barely swings her portion of the rent. After being asked to leave her crappy apartment by a roommate and having her identity stolen, she's at her wits end. She finds shelter at the Boston Public Library one of her three jobs, where she notices a door. It leads her to the Astral Library. While exploring the library it becomes obvious that either Alix, the librarian, or the library itself is being targeted. But why? The situation goes from annoying to dangerous.
🎩👗🎩👗🎩
The editing was fantastic! Books with this type of format can drag and lose their page turning fairy dust, but the pace stayed on point so KUDOS to the editor for keeping it streamlined. The cast of characters had genuine struggles and seeing how the library changed their lives was worthwhile. There is also a look at art and gaming which I thought was an interesting touch it worked well in the story. The light romantic thread between Alix and an up-and-coming costume designer was a sweet addition giving a sense of balance to the story and adding dimension to the characters.
🪡🧵🪡🧵🪡
Not only do libraries offer the escape provided by the books they house, but also a literal refuge asking little in return The Astral Library was a solid representation of that.
📖📖📖📖📖
*Now Available*
Thank you to William Morrow for providing an ARC via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
February 24, 2026
IG review: https://www.instagram.com/p/DVHXYGvkW...
This book was a bit of a departure from the historical fiction I have come to know and love from Quinn, but I was ready for the ride! However, I wasn’t ready for a dragon ride🙃
The pitch of this book sounded phenomenal. Alix Watson hasn’t had an easy life. But unlike people, books will never let you down. Introduce a magical realism world called The Astral Library where those that need to truly escape from their lives get transported into their favorite book.
The story started off okay for me, Alix wasn’t my favorite character ever, but I was willing to see where the story went. Ultimately, I found this book to feel half baked. Characters were very boring and felt half formed, I actively disliked the romance, but that too also felt so unfleshed out.
The story was very, very repetitive and obviously was being told as an allegory of what’s happening in the world with libraries and book banning, etc., but I felt like I was being bashed over the head repetitively with that message.
I’ve seen a lot of reviews that say this book was written for book lovers and I agree, but that felt forced to me. Like book lovers are supposed to love romance and dragons, and hate “The Man” and love twee quotes about books so let’s just put that all in one book. It got real corny real fast.
If you would have made me guess who wrote this book, never in a million years would I have guessed Kate Quinn. But maybe she’ll find a new audience with this book! A miss for me, but hopefully a hit for other readers.
Thank you so much to William Morrow for this gifted copy!!
This book was a bit of a departure from the historical fiction I have come to know and love from Quinn, but I was ready for the ride! However, I wasn’t ready for a dragon ride🙃
The pitch of this book sounded phenomenal. Alix Watson hasn’t had an easy life. But unlike people, books will never let you down. Introduce a magical realism world called The Astral Library where those that need to truly escape from their lives get transported into their favorite book.
The story started off okay for me, Alix wasn’t my favorite character ever, but I was willing to see where the story went. Ultimately, I found this book to feel half baked. Characters were very boring and felt half formed, I actively disliked the romance, but that too also felt so unfleshed out.
The story was very, very repetitive and obviously was being told as an allegory of what’s happening in the world with libraries and book banning, etc., but I felt like I was being bashed over the head repetitively with that message.
I’ve seen a lot of reviews that say this book was written for book lovers and I agree, but that felt forced to me. Like book lovers are supposed to love romance and dragons, and hate “The Man” and love twee quotes about books so let’s just put that all in one book. It got real corny real fast.
If you would have made me guess who wrote this book, never in a million years would I have guessed Kate Quinn. But maybe she’ll find a new audience with this book! A miss for me, but hopefully a hit for other readers.
Thank you so much to William Morrow for this gifted copy!!
February 18, 2026
DNF. I don’t need to be lectured to about politics in a book that’s supposed to be about magic. Not only that, the main character was SO unlikable and rude.
Kate Quinn, what on earth were you thinking?
Kate Quinn, what on earth were you thinking?
March 1, 2026
2.5⭐️
Have you ever wanted to live inside a book?
That’s the first line in the prologue. Snappy, but also a test. The less you align with that statement the less likely you will enjoy what’s to come.
Perhaps it’s heresy, but I never dreamed of living in a book. I’m a, “Nice place to visit, but wouldn’t want to live there,” kind of girlie.
The story read kind of YA. Very surfacy. While I agree with the author’s message, it was delivered with a heavy hand.
Also, the author’s choice of “escape” books felt condescending. She saved time by choosing iconic characters and books like “Pride and Prejudice” and Sherlock Holmes that needed no explanation. Surely, someone would seek asylum in a less popular, public domain story?
Caution: This was an “Anyhoo” universe. Don’t expect satisfying or well thought out resolutions to any issue. Answers were dispensed with throwaway lines from the FMC.
Positives: The story was well written. The setting and clothing beg for a cinematic rendering.
Have you ever wanted to live inside a book?
That’s the first line in the prologue. Snappy, but also a test. The less you align with that statement the less likely you will enjoy what’s to come.
Perhaps it’s heresy, but I never dreamed of living in a book. I’m a, “Nice place to visit, but wouldn’t want to live there,” kind of girlie.
The story read kind of YA. Very surfacy. While I agree with the author’s message, it was delivered with a heavy hand.
Also, the author’s choice of “escape” books felt condescending. She saved time by choosing iconic characters and books like “Pride and Prejudice” and Sherlock Holmes that needed no explanation. Surely, someone would seek asylum in a less popular, public domain story?
Caution: This was an “Anyhoo” universe. Don’t expect satisfying or well thought out resolutions to any issue. Answers were dispensed with throwaway lines from the FMC.
Positives: The story was well written. The setting and clothing beg for a cinematic rendering.
February 21, 2026
I wanted to rate this one higher just because the MAGA moms hate it so much. But I’m gonna stick true to the book review itself.
That said the rating of 3 is probably a gift because I’m a fan of the author and love her other books. Had it been written by an author I had no previous knowledge of it would have been a 2star.
Genre jumping: I actually don’t mind at all that an author wants to explore another genre… I welcome it. But they need to do it well and Quinn appears to have utilized the fantasy genre to satisfy a soap box need that she couldn’t produce in her historical fiction alley . In the same breath I appreciate all artists using their voices to champion sanity over the current regime. And for that she gets five stars but her execution of soap box diatribe fell way short and overly repetitive of what she conjured here.
The novel itself felt short and rushed (probably to get it out in time for relevance on the social issues). The novel starts strong introducing us to a down on her luck (size 22 in an attempt to attack against body shaming… which I agree with but which the author doesn’t do subtly and therefore it didnt make a point while also melting it into the story) twenty something (going on 17) female survivor of the foster care system introducing us to her library/bookish saving graces. The FMC herself never felt fully flushed out. She’s flighty and repetitive rather than someone who is drawn carefully and believable.
The premise is that Alix (FMC) escapes into a magical library realm (I was more than fine with the magical realism concept here) where she could avoid her real life tragedy and instead choose a book she loved and to swap her life with that inside a favorite novel. She would get three tries to find the right book. I found myself really thinking about what I’d choose and couldn’t wait for her travels through book worlds to begin. And here ended what I thought would be the books fantasy adventure.
What we got moving on was library bureaucracy. Alix enters the fantastical astral library world on the shirt tails of the “librarian” ( where she becomes an administrator and less so a patron/ traveler). Following this role she hops lickity split from book to book without any true adventures in the novels. What ensues is a lot of book and author name dropping and a bunch of brief introductions to the other patrons who have been saved by the tragedies of their own lives by hopping into a book world to essentially hide. None of those characters are ever developed nor are their adventures. They serve the purpose of being nothing more than their tragedies.
Then there’s a side romance. Point blank it didn’t work. Point blank the exact same character (a 29/30 yo male dress designer who owns his own shop and who specializes in historical costuming and is also gay or at least bisexual) could have played a far more believable role as Alix’s BFF because there was absolutely no real development of a romance at all. In fact the Beau Brummell character is one of the better developed characters in the novel. Alix is definitely not a deserving friend and is so self absorbed the relationship would never work.
The librarian… an ages old middle eastern? Woman is one of the better characters. Tho she’s in a coma for 1/3 -1/2 the novel so there’s that.
All in all I felt like this was a slap dash attempt to get a book out for social commentary. The fact that I totally agree with the social commentary doesn’t however make this a good book.
Of course Quinn uses her constant narrator Saskia who is always fabulous. Sold as an adult fantasy novel this is so clearly YA.
That said the rating of 3 is probably a gift because I’m a fan of the author and love her other books. Had it been written by an author I had no previous knowledge of it would have been a 2star.
Genre jumping: I actually don’t mind at all that an author wants to explore another genre… I welcome it. But they need to do it well and Quinn appears to have utilized the fantasy genre to satisfy a soap box need that she couldn’t produce in her historical fiction alley . In the same breath I appreciate all artists using their voices to champion sanity over the current regime. And for that she gets five stars but her execution of soap box diatribe fell way short and overly repetitive of what she conjured here.
The novel itself felt short and rushed (probably to get it out in time for relevance on the social issues). The novel starts strong introducing us to a down on her luck (size 22 in an attempt to attack against body shaming… which I agree with but which the author doesn’t do subtly and therefore it didnt make a point while also melting it into the story) twenty something (going on 17) female survivor of the foster care system introducing us to her library/bookish saving graces. The FMC herself never felt fully flushed out. She’s flighty and repetitive rather than someone who is drawn carefully and believable.
The premise is that Alix (FMC) escapes into a magical library realm (I was more than fine with the magical realism concept here) where she could avoid her real life tragedy and instead choose a book she loved and to swap her life with that inside a favorite novel. She would get three tries to find the right book. I found myself really thinking about what I’d choose and couldn’t wait for her travels through book worlds to begin. And here ended what I thought would be the books fantasy adventure.
What we got moving on was library bureaucracy. Alix enters the fantastical astral library world on the shirt tails of the “librarian” ( where she becomes an administrator and less so a patron/ traveler). Following this role she hops lickity split from book to book without any true adventures in the novels. What ensues is a lot of book and author name dropping and a bunch of brief introductions to the other patrons who have been saved by the tragedies of their own lives by hopping into a book world to essentially hide. None of those characters are ever developed nor are their adventures. They serve the purpose of being nothing more than their tragedies.
Then there’s a side romance. Point blank it didn’t work. Point blank the exact same character (a 29/30 yo male dress designer who owns his own shop and who specializes in historical costuming and is also gay or at least bisexual) could have played a far more believable role as Alix’s BFF because there was absolutely no real development of a romance at all. In fact the Beau Brummell character is one of the better developed characters in the novel. Alix is definitely not a deserving friend and is so self absorbed the relationship would never work.
The librarian… an ages old middle eastern? Woman is one of the better characters. Tho she’s in a coma for 1/3 -1/2 the novel so there’s that.
All in all I felt like this was a slap dash attempt to get a book out for social commentary. The fact that I totally agree with the social commentary doesn’t however make this a good book.
Of course Quinn uses her constant narrator Saskia who is always fabulous. Sold as an adult fantasy novel this is so clearly YA.
February 18, 2026
I really enjoyed this bookish romantasy by Kate Quinn, of all people. I wish there had been a bit more time in some of the books referenced , but I liked the battle to save the library and thought Alix quite a worthwhile protagonist.
January 22, 2026
This novel took me on such an emotional journey! It is amazing, unique, magical and left a huge impact on me. It is a medium paced book that is a mix of both character and plot driven. It is about a girl named Alix and how she was struggling, so she turned to books. She trusted books more than people. She ends up discovering a secret library door, where she ends up in classic books worlds. It starts off a bit on the slow side, then quickly builds up. I really loved the themes in this book and found this book to be extremely unique.
Some of the themes include a found family, stories shaping identity, and libraries and why they matter. I found the plot to be clever and I absolutely loved the magical world in the book. The characters were lovable and strongly developed! It is easy to read, magical and also comes with a slow burn romance. Overall, I give this book a strong 5 out of 5 stars rating!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kate Quinn and William Morrow for this incredible eARC of this book in exchange for my honest review and feedback. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is set to be released on February 17, 2026!
Some of the themes include a found family, stories shaping identity, and libraries and why they matter. I found the plot to be clever and I absolutely loved the magical world in the book. The characters were lovable and strongly developed! It is easy to read, magical and also comes with a slow burn romance. Overall, I give this book a strong 5 out of 5 stars rating!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Kate Quinn and William Morrow for this incredible eARC of this book in exchange for my honest review and feedback. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
This book is set to be released on February 17, 2026!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I just wish this was better. Highly recommend the Invisible Library series for a book that takes this concept and does it well. This book, while filled with self-righteous pontificating on the purpose of libraries, is a complete nothing-burger.
Also, I read an ARC, so I'm really hoping the section on page 12 that Quinn completely lifted from Pratchett gets credited in the published version - and the sweatshop joke is removed. So disappointing to see this happen with such a big name author.
Edit: having now read Jasper Fforde's The Eyre Affair, I want to rate this book even lower. How Quinn managed to make the concept of book entry so...boring...is almost more interesting than the writing itself.
Also, I read an ARC, so I'm really hoping the section on page 12 that Quinn completely lifted from Pratchett gets credited in the published version - and the sweatshop joke is removed. So disappointing to see this happen with such a big name author.
Edit: having now read Jasper Fforde's The Eyre Affair, I want to rate this book even lower. How Quinn managed to make the concept of book entry so...boring...is almost more interesting than the writing itself.
March 1, 2026
I read this book as an ARC from NetGalley and this review is based on my reading the book and is an honest reflection about the story.
My first 5 star book of the year.
I read The Astral Library as an advanced review copy from NetGalley and I am still a little breathless from the experience. This book did not just meet my expectations it wrapped itself around my book loving heart and refused to let go. Which book lover can stay away and not fall in love with an astral library. The concept gives me goosebumps and Kate spins a fine yarn.
This is the Narnia, Platform 9 and three quarters and Hogwarts all rolled into one for book lovers.
From the very first chapter there is a sense of wonder that never fades. The idea of a library that exists beyond the physical world where stories breathe and worlds wait just beyond the shelves is pure magic. Kate Quinn leans fully into that magic and trusts the reader to come along for the ride. I did and I never once wanted to step off.
At the center of the story is a protagonist who feels deeply human. There is loss here and longing and the quiet ache of someone who has survived by clinging to stories. Watching her journey unfold inside the Astral Library felt personal as if Quinn was speaking directly to anyone who has ever used books as refuge as comfort or as hope. This is not escapism for the sake of escape. This is escapism with purpose and heart.
The Astral Library itself is unforgettable. It feels alive and sacred and endlessly inviting. Every time a new doorway opened I felt that familiar thrill of discovery that only the best books give you. Quinn captures the joy of reading with such sincerity that it borders on reverence without ever becoming sentimental.
What truly elevates this novel is the emotional resonance. Beneath the whimsy is a powerful reminder of why stories matter. They preserve memory. They offer sanctuary. They connect us across time and experience. By the final pages I felt both fulfilled and devastated that it was ending which is always the sign of a five star read for me.
If I had one complaint it would be that I wanted more. More time in the library. More wandering. More pages. But perhaps that ache is exactly the point. The best books make you wish you could live inside them.
The Astral Library is a love letter to readers libraries and the quiet magic of stories themselves. It is immersive emotional and utterly enchanting. Five stars and then some.
My first 5 star book of the year.
I read The Astral Library as an advanced review copy from NetGalley and I am still a little breathless from the experience. This book did not just meet my expectations it wrapped itself around my book loving heart and refused to let go. Which book lover can stay away and not fall in love with an astral library. The concept gives me goosebumps and Kate spins a fine yarn.
This is the Narnia, Platform 9 and three quarters and Hogwarts all rolled into one for book lovers.
From the very first chapter there is a sense of wonder that never fades. The idea of a library that exists beyond the physical world where stories breathe and worlds wait just beyond the shelves is pure magic. Kate Quinn leans fully into that magic and trusts the reader to come along for the ride. I did and I never once wanted to step off.
At the center of the story is a protagonist who feels deeply human. There is loss here and longing and the quiet ache of someone who has survived by clinging to stories. Watching her journey unfold inside the Astral Library felt personal as if Quinn was speaking directly to anyone who has ever used books as refuge as comfort or as hope. This is not escapism for the sake of escape. This is escapism with purpose and heart.
The Astral Library itself is unforgettable. It feels alive and sacred and endlessly inviting. Every time a new doorway opened I felt that familiar thrill of discovery that only the best books give you. Quinn captures the joy of reading with such sincerity that it borders on reverence without ever becoming sentimental.
What truly elevates this novel is the emotional resonance. Beneath the whimsy is a powerful reminder of why stories matter. They preserve memory. They offer sanctuary. They connect us across time and experience. By the final pages I felt both fulfilled and devastated that it was ending which is always the sign of a five star read for me.
If I had one complaint it would be that I wanted more. More time in the library. More wandering. More pages. But perhaps that ache is exactly the point. The best books make you wish you could live inside them.
The Astral Library is a love letter to readers libraries and the quiet magic of stories themselves. It is immersive emotional and utterly enchanting. Five stars and then some.
Did Not Finish
March 4, 2026“The Astral Library”, by Kate Quinn
No ratings.
At 55% and I just couldn’t go on. I had it!
Such a terrific concept wasted in the development, which in my opinion was extremely boring.
The jumping into new words before we had a chance to enjoy the experience was so disappointing.
The writing was strong in the beginning, but then it seems that it was directed towards young adults (I have nothing against young adult novels and I have read some that were amazing).
Anyways… I don’t think that I should be rating this book, as it is clear enough that I’m not part of the targeted audience.
No ratings.
At 55% and I just couldn’t go on. I had it!
Such a terrific concept wasted in the development, which in my opinion was extremely boring.
The jumping into new words before we had a chance to enjoy the experience was so disappointing.
The writing was strong in the beginning, but then it seems that it was directed towards young adults (I have nothing against young adult novels and I have read some that were amazing).
Anyways… I don’t think that I should be rating this book, as it is clear enough that I’m not part of the targeted audience.
March 25, 2026
Look, I am a huge Kate Quinn fan. I have loved her older historical fiction and the foray into newer historical fiction (The Briar Club), and i will continue to read what she puts out. But this one totally missed the mark for me.
I wanted to love The Astral Library, as a book lover, who wouldn't want to live inside all to the classic and most beloved books? But there were too many storylines, the saving of people, the love story, the library politics, and a few others that detracted from each other instead of flowing well.
Above all, it was the attempt to tie it all back to real US politics that killed the whole thing for me. I read to escape all the noise in the world, why on earth would I want to read a story that is closely related to a hotly controversial political topic right now? And I found that out about 80% in. Please stop putting politics in fiction, especially a fantasy novel.
I'm sorry that I didn't like this. I am frustrated that I have to leave a 1 star review for one of my favorite authors.
Thanks to William Morrow and NetGalley for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I wanted to love The Astral Library, as a book lover, who wouldn't want to live inside all to the classic and most beloved books? But there were too many storylines, the saving of people, the love story, the library politics, and a few others that detracted from each other instead of flowing well.
Above all, it was the attempt to tie it all back to real US politics that killed the whole thing for me. I read to escape all the noise in the world, why on earth would I want to read a story that is closely related to a hotly controversial political topic right now? And I found that out about 80% in. Please stop putting politics in fiction, especially a fantasy novel.
I'm sorry that I didn't like this. I am frustrated that I have to leave a 1 star review for one of my favorite authors.
Thanks to William Morrow and NetGalley for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 19, 2026
Thank you, William Morrow, for sending me this ARC.
The beginning and the ending were really what saved this book for me. Originally, I felt pulled in and really enjoyed the storyline. I love the concept of the library, enjoyed the world(s), and even the characters.
The story fell short for me at the first plot twist. I was so excited, only for the next twist (moments later) to switch the direction very suddenly. I wish we had incorporated more of the original twist, because that was really the compelling part for me. Although the following twist was great for the plot, I feel like we could have had a little more build-up beforehand. Take away 30 pages in the middle and put them in the beginning instead.
Anyway, the concept is there, but the focus just felt scattered. It also seems longer than it needed to be. Not my favorite. Overall, a decent story, though.
Pub Date: Feb 17, 2026
As always, all thoughts are my own. 💕✨
The beginning and the ending were really what saved this book for me. Originally, I felt pulled in and really enjoyed the storyline. I love the concept of the library, enjoyed the world(s), and even the characters.
The story fell short for me at the first plot twist. I was so excited, only for the next twist (moments later) to switch the direction very suddenly. I wish we had incorporated more of the original twist, because that was really the compelling part for me. Although the following twist was great for the plot, I feel like we could have had a little more build-up beforehand. Take away 30 pages in the middle and put them in the beginning instead.
Anyway, the concept is there, but the focus just felt scattered. It also seems longer than it needed to be. Not my favorite. Overall, a decent story, though.
Pub Date: Feb 17, 2026
As always, all thoughts are my own. 💕✨
Displaying 1 - 30 of 7,933 reviews