What do you think?
Rate this book
Breaking Barriers
Quite the Pair
She’s the feisty figure skater he can’t resist. He’s the rugged former hockey player who gets under her skin. Together, they’re quite the pair.
Isla Covington is ready for a comeback. Losing both her pairs skating partner and her marriage last year crushed her, but she’s never surrendered to a challenge. She’s determined to prove everyone wrong about her reputation as a difficult ice queen and climb her way back to the top of the podium.
Wes Davidson is a notorious grump, but he’ll sacrifice anything for the people he loves. After the devastation of his divorce five years ago, Wes prefers his single life, running his business, playing hockey with his friends, and holding his family together.
Until Isla enters his life and partners with his figure skater brother.
Now, she’s sitting across from Wes at family dinners, skating in his rink, and invading his simple life. He hates that he can’t get enough of her. Isla won’t allow her intense attraction to the unfairly hot man to distract from her goal, but Wes’s smoldering glares and quiet strength test her discipline.
It isn’t long before their bickering turns to flirty banter, affection, and an irresistible heat that burns every time they’re together. When cracks begin to form in the walls they’ve built to protect themselves, Wes and Isla face the hardest decision of their lives: to open their hearts to love or continue to run from it.
QUITE THE PAIR is a spicy figure skating romance from the Breaking Barrier series, featuring grumpy x grumpy, forced proximity, dislike to love, and he falls first and harder tropes.
Isla Covington is ready for a comeback. Losing both her pairs skating partner and her marriage last year crushed her, but she’s never surrendered to a challenge. She’s determined to prove everyone wrong about her reputation as a difficult ice queen and climb her way back to the top of the podium.
Wes Davidson is a notorious grump, but he’ll sacrifice anything for the people he loves. After the devastation of his divorce five years ago, Wes prefers his single life, running his business, playing hockey with his friends, and holding his family together.
Until Isla enters his life and partners with his figure skater brother.
Now, she’s sitting across from Wes at family dinners, skating in his rink, and invading his simple life. He hates that he can’t get enough of her. Isla won’t allow her intense attraction to the unfairly hot man to distract from her goal, but Wes’s smoldering glares and quiet strength test her discipline.
It isn’t long before their bickering turns to flirty banter, affection, and an irresistible heat that burns every time they’re together. When cracks begin to form in the walls they’ve built to protect themselves, Wes and Isla face the hardest decision of their lives: to open their hearts to love or continue to run from it.
QUITE THE PAIR is a spicy figure skating romance from the Breaking Barrier series, featuring grumpy x grumpy, forced proximity, dislike to love, and he falls first and harder tropes.
309 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 26, 2026
10 people are currently reading
205 people want to read
About the author
Kathryn Kincaid
4 books67 followersKathryn Kincaid writes contemporary romance with banter, heat, and love so sweet. Her stories feature sports, mental health representation, and characters finding the love they deserve.
Kathryn lives in North Carolina. When she's not daydreaming about her next story, you can find her obsessing over book boyfriends, devouring love stories, and cheering on the Carolina Hurricanes.
Keep up on the latest on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok (@authorkathrynkincaid).
Kathryn lives in North Carolina. When she's not daydreaming about her next story, you can find her obsessing over book boyfriends, devouring love stories, and cheering on the Carolina Hurricanes.
Keep up on the latest on Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok (@authorkathrynkincaid).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 204 reviews
March 2, 2026
This was cute! My fav of the series so far!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I was given an ARC of Quite the Pair by Kathryn Kincaid, I really enjoyed this story.
Isla has moved back to her home town after her personal and professional lives both imploded, she's found herself a new skating partner but trouble brews when the guy who accidentally hit her brothers car door turns out to be the owner of the ice rink they use to train at and he is her new partners brother.
The characters were really well written, the story moved along very well and I finished this over a three night reading session. I also appreciated the trigger warnings at the front of the book.
Isla has moved back to her home town after her personal and professional lives both imploded, she's found herself a new skating partner but trouble brews when the guy who accidentally hit her brothers car door turns out to be the owner of the ice rink they use to train at and he is her new partners brother.
The characters were really well written, the story moved along very well and I finished this over a three night reading session. I also appreciated the trigger warnings at the front of the book.
January 11, 2026
This was adorable. The banter was quality, the characters real and relatable. A good sprinkle of spice- no third act break up. Really enjoyed this read. Definitely recommend
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I got this book from netgalley but this review is entirely my own opinion.
40% book progress
I am in love with these two and the side characters. Not much has happened in the relationship side of the story so far but it feels more natural and not rushed which I like in books. The books starting to show more connection between isla and wes now that they know what happened after their first meeting when they were teenagers and can move past it. Also the part when he says she was his first kiss as well, I honestly squealed!
60% book progress
My heart is breaking for brooks, I want to learn more about him and his past.
Brooks and isla's family are truly awful and dont deserve brook and isla. Especially since they ambushed her with the ex and the ex mother in law. I loved she stood her ground in what she wants in life and that is to focus on her career.
Finished
I liked the book, it was easy to follow along with. I did expect some more interactions from the ex and the parents but there wasn't any after the dinner chapter. At the skating competition, I was so sad for isla as she worked her ass off for months with Spencer, I thought they might have been some sabotage from the old skating partner to cause the fall.
Over all I think this book was cute and a good read and I am interested in see the authors other work. I really want to see a Spencer and brooks book!
40% book progress
I am in love with these two and the side characters. Not much has happened in the relationship side of the story so far but it feels more natural and not rushed which I like in books. The books starting to show more connection between isla and wes now that they know what happened after their first meeting when they were teenagers and can move past it. Also the part when he says she was his first kiss as well, I honestly squealed!
60% book progress
My heart is breaking for brooks, I want to learn more about him and his past.
Brooks and isla's family are truly awful and dont deserve brook and isla. Especially since they ambushed her with the ex and the ex mother in law. I loved she stood her ground in what she wants in life and that is to focus on her career.
Finished
I liked the book, it was easy to follow along with. I did expect some more interactions from the ex and the parents but there wasn't any after the dinner chapter. At the skating competition, I was so sad for isla as she worked her ass off for months with Spencer, I thought they might have been some sabotage from the old skating partner to cause the fall.
Over all I think this book was cute and a good read and I am interested in see the authors other work. I really want to see a Spencer and brooks book!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 26, 2026
I would like to say a big thank you to Kathryn Kincaid and Victory editing for allowing me the opportunity to read this ARC and leave my honest review.
I love hockey and figure skating romances, so when I came across this book on Netgalley I was instantly interested. Thank you so much to netgalley for providing me with this opportunity.
This book was so heartwarming and I really liked that the main characters were older and the story didn’t only focus on the figure skating and hockey storyline. I really appreciated how Kathryn wrote about other aspects of their life too. Such as caring for a parent with Dementia, becoming the primary caretaker for an extended member of the family and the impact of going through a divorce. I felt these matters were written incredibly well and very relatable.
Every time Isla and Wes interacted with each other.. I loved it!! The chemistry and the slow burn tension from the start was amazing!!🥰 I really enjoyed the pace of how their relationship progressed throughout the book and I particularly loved when they were fake dating in front of Isla ex-husband!! That scene was everything!!😍
Isla has definitely become one of my top FMC in a sports romance. She is such an icon with her comebacks and I loved her banter with Wes! I also really liked her relationship with Wes niece Thea, it felt very special to read and I loved how much warmth and understanding they gave one another.
Another great development was watching Isla gain a healthy partnership with her skating partner Spencer. I loved how he always had patience, kindness and understanding for Isla. Spencer really was a lovely and funny side character!
The ending felt a little rushed for me but the love and acceptance at the end was very sweet for all characters.
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and I would highly recommend this book to all sports romance readers!
Official rating:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4/5 stars
🌶️🌶️
I love hockey and figure skating romances, so when I came across this book on Netgalley I was instantly interested. Thank you so much to netgalley for providing me with this opportunity.
This book was so heartwarming and I really liked that the main characters were older and the story didn’t only focus on the figure skating and hockey storyline. I really appreciated how Kathryn wrote about other aspects of their life too. Such as caring for a parent with Dementia, becoming the primary caretaker for an extended member of the family and the impact of going through a divorce. I felt these matters were written incredibly well and very relatable.
Every time Isla and Wes interacted with each other.. I loved it!! The chemistry and the slow burn tension from the start was amazing!!🥰 I really enjoyed the pace of how their relationship progressed throughout the book and I particularly loved when they were fake dating in front of Isla ex-husband!! That scene was everything!!😍
Isla has definitely become one of my top FMC in a sports romance. She is such an icon with her comebacks and I loved her banter with Wes! I also really liked her relationship with Wes niece Thea, it felt very special to read and I loved how much warmth and understanding they gave one another.
Another great development was watching Isla gain a healthy partnership with her skating partner Spencer. I loved how he always had patience, kindness and understanding for Isla. Spencer really was a lovely and funny side character!
The ending felt a little rushed for me but the love and acceptance at the end was very sweet for all characters.
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and I would highly recommend this book to all sports romance readers!
Official rating:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4/5 stars
🌶️🌶️
February 26, 2026
This book was so goood!! It was exactly what I needed to read and I was in love instantly! I love the meet cute they had when they were young and the fact that they still think about it 14 years later is adorable, I love the chance that brings them back into each other lives and the dynamic that they have! The grumpy vs sassy is everything and I was so happy to read this book
February 19, 2026
After Isla split up with her iceskating partner because he couldn’t accept she didn’t reciprocate his feelings and Wes’s partner had to retire due to an injury, they decide to team up thanks to their mutual friends Maggie and Rowan (from Beyond the Court by Stef C.R.).
Isla’s first day is off to a rocky start after someone scratched the car she borrowed from her brother and that someone turns out to be the brother of her new partner and the owner of the rink where they’ll practice. But soon she finds out there’s a whole other layer to his grumpiness.
What I truly enjoyed in this story: the maturity of both MC who each went through a divorce, have to deal with family issues (taking care of a parent with dementia and setting boundaries with parents who don’t respect your choices), the found family, the respectful and open communication, the friendship, support and team work next to the romance.
Spencer (the ice skating partner) is such a bright ray of sunshine and I hope his story will follow!
Thank you @victoryeditingngc for providing this book for review consideration via @netgalley. All opinions are my own.
Isla’s first day is off to a rocky start after someone scratched the car she borrowed from her brother and that someone turns out to be the brother of her new partner and the owner of the rink where they’ll practice. But soon she finds out there’s a whole other layer to his grumpiness.
What I truly enjoyed in this story: the maturity of both MC who each went through a divorce, have to deal with family issues (taking care of a parent with dementia and setting boundaries with parents who don’t respect your choices), the found family, the respectful and open communication, the friendship, support and team work next to the romance.
Spencer (the ice skating partner) is such a bright ray of sunshine and I hope his story will follow!
Thank you @victoryeditingngc for providing this book for review consideration via @netgalley. All opinions are my own.
February 26, 2026
What To Expect:
- figure skater x former hockey player
- dislike to lovers
- grumpy x grumpy
- he falls first and harder
- divorced mc in 30s
- forced proximity
- found family
- dual pov
- open door
i ate this book up! and omg the banter? yes please! i will never say no to some good banter
i loved the characters so much! both isla and wes went through divorces and were both so mature which isnt something i have seen in a lot of books. one is usually a little less mature and needs to grow in that sense so i liked that this was different. these two were so supportive of one another and it really tugged on my heartstrings
all in all this was such a great read and i can't wait for everyone to be able to enjoy it now that it is out in the world!
thank you so much kathryn kincaid for giving me this amazing opportunity to read and review this book! 🫶🏼
- figure skater x former hockey player
- dislike to lovers
- grumpy x grumpy
- he falls first and harder
- divorced mc in 30s
- forced proximity
- found family
- dual pov
- open door
i ate this book up! and omg the banter? yes please! i will never say no to some good banter
i loved the characters so much! both isla and wes went through divorces and were both so mature which isnt something i have seen in a lot of books. one is usually a little less mature and needs to grow in that sense so i liked that this was different. these two were so supportive of one another and it really tugged on my heartstrings
all in all this was such a great read and i can't wait for everyone to be able to enjoy it now that it is out in the world!
thank you so much kathryn kincaid for giving me this amazing opportunity to read and review this book! 🫶🏼
January 4, 2026
Thank you to the author for this ARC 🫶🏻
Isla is recently divorced and as a professional ice skater, she’s got a new partner. Wes is a retired hockey player and Isla is his brother’s new partner. They had a moment as teens and never reconnected.
They start off on the wrong foot but have to be cordial at the rink. Isla’s parents are awful and Wes offers to be her fake date. They quickly learn their feelings aren’t fake.
Both of them are divorced and know that relationships can be hard to maintain. Isla is always going to put skating first but Wes is so proud of her! They support and love each other through the tough times!
These two had pretty good communication and I enjoyed their story!
Isla is recently divorced and as a professional ice skater, she’s got a new partner. Wes is a retired hockey player and Isla is his brother’s new partner. They had a moment as teens and never reconnected.
They start off on the wrong foot but have to be cordial at the rink. Isla’s parents are awful and Wes offers to be her fake date. They quickly learn their feelings aren’t fake.
Both of them are divorced and know that relationships can be hard to maintain. Isla is always going to put skating first but Wes is so proud of her! They support and love each other through the tough times!
These two had pretty good communication and I enjoyed their story!
January 6, 2026
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Victory Editing for this ARC! This one was truly magical on and off the ice ✨❄️
We follow Isla as she returns to figure skating, moves in with her brother, and pairs with a new skating partner who just so happens to be the brother of Wes, the boy she shared her first kiss with at sixteen and then lost contact with. Cue fourteen years of unresolved history and lots of tension! You’re fully immersed in both perspectives with dual POV, which makes the slow burn hit even harder.
Strong-willed MCs, a grumpy x grumpy dynamic, and just the right amount of spice made this such a fun read that I couldn’t put down. If you love skating romances with heart, heat, and dual POV storytelling, this one is a must-read.
We follow Isla as she returns to figure skating, moves in with her brother, and pairs with a new skating partner who just so happens to be the brother of Wes, the boy she shared her first kiss with at sixteen and then lost contact with. Cue fourteen years of unresolved history and lots of tension! You’re fully immersed in both perspectives with dual POV, which makes the slow burn hit even harder.
Strong-willed MCs, a grumpy x grumpy dynamic, and just the right amount of spice made this such a fun read that I couldn’t put down. If you love skating romances with heart, heat, and dual POV storytelling, this one is a must-read.
February 1, 2026
Thank you NetGalley for this ARC to review!!
I came into this read without any prior knowledge to previous books nor to the author. Overall, I liked the book and I think the story was good! At times things were rushed and I do feel that more detail could have been added if we had more time. Especially since we are training for a skating competition, more time would have made sense. I did like the characters though. Wes and Spencer are polar opposites as brothers and it worked so well.
Generally if you are looking for a light, quick, cute romance, this is a good one for you! Bonus points if you like ice sports!!
I came into this read without any prior knowledge to previous books nor to the author. Overall, I liked the book and I think the story was good! At times things were rushed and I do feel that more detail could have been added if we had more time. Especially since we are training for a skating competition, more time would have made sense. I did like the characters though. Wes and Spencer are polar opposites as brothers and it worked so well.
Generally if you are looking for a light, quick, cute romance, this is a good one for you! Bonus points if you like ice sports!!
March 3, 2026
My love for this series grows with each book! Wes and Isla are so stinking cute in their grumpy/grumpy ways I can’t even with them! I think the thing I love most about this series is how each author has done an amazing job of showing that you should never make yourself smaller to fit the mold or ideal that is forced upon you by family spouse society etc! They write in a way that’s so empowering it’s a wonderful thing to read! Do yourself a favor, get to know these ladies and their stories you won’t be disappointed!
January 15, 2026
I really enjoyed this story! It was sweet, it was spicy, and full of heart. Not only does this story have a great love story, but it also has a beautiful found family. This books showcases the importance of family and how sometimes family is not only blood. Family can just be the people who love you and will always be there for you even at your worst.
Now, back to the love story! I absolutely love Wes and Isla! They are both grumpy people who have been through tough relationships in the past. They want to protect their hearts, but they find comfort in each other. And what starts out as casual may turn into something more.
Now, back to the love story! I absolutely love Wes and Isla! They are both grumpy people who have been through tough relationships in the past. They want to protect their hearts, but they find comfort in each other. And what starts out as casual may turn into something more.
February 2, 2026
I finished this in one sitting and had such a great time with it. This short story follows Isla, a year into her divorce, as she moves back in with her brother for a new skating opportunity to only discover her new partner’s brother is Wes, her very first kiss.
Their reunion is anything but smooth, but once they reconnect, all those “what if” feelings come rushing back. Even with its shorter length, the character growth and backstory really delivered.
I also loved the spice!
Their reunion is anything but smooth, but once they reconnect, all those “what if” feelings come rushing back. Even with its shorter length, the character growth and backstory really delivered.
I also loved the spice!
February 26, 2026
4.5⭐️
I’m obsessed with Isla and Wes! This one has the best mix of forced proximity, fake dating, second chance, and found family. The characters were both grumpy at first, and I was eating up the dislike to like – the banter was top tier, and the tension was so good! I loved their dynamic and all the teasing from their brothers and his niece – the coffee shop scene – iykyk! This was perfect to read around the Olympics with the figure skating and hockey! There was also a lot of heart in the story with her Olympic dreams, their family drama, and their past relationship trauma. Overall, I loved this fast and enjoyable read, and I’m hoping Brooks book might be next!!
Thank you Kathryn Kincaid for this ARC!
I’m obsessed with Isla and Wes! This one has the best mix of forced proximity, fake dating, second chance, and found family. The characters were both grumpy at first, and I was eating up the dislike to like – the banter was top tier, and the tension was so good! I loved their dynamic and all the teasing from their brothers and his niece – the coffee shop scene – iykyk! This was perfect to read around the Olympics with the figure skating and hockey! There was also a lot of heart in the story with her Olympic dreams, their family drama, and their past relationship trauma. Overall, I loved this fast and enjoyable read, and I’m hoping Brooks book might be next!!
Thank you Kathryn Kincaid for this ARC!
January 1, 2026
✨Isla is determined to keep her paired skating career intact and is willing to do whatever it takes even if she is paired with Spencer the brother of her first kiss.
✨Wess owns a local ice rink in town and is taking care of his niece. He’s the grumpiest but is willing to get along for his brother.
The more their bickering banter continues the more the lines blur and I just love it.
✨both of them are jaded and are afraid to repeat their romantic history which I understand but I love when they become brave and communicate how they feel 🥰
⛸️Figure skater x former hockey player
⛸️Workplace
⛸️Forced proximity
⛸️Interconnected past
⛸️Grumpy x sunshine
⛸️spice
✨Wess owns a local ice rink in town and is taking care of his niece. He’s the grumpiest but is willing to get along for his brother.
The more their bickering banter continues the more the lines blur and I just love it.
✨both of them are jaded and are afraid to repeat their romantic history which I understand but I love when they become brave and communicate how they feel 🥰
⛸️Figure skater x former hockey player
⛸️Workplace
⛸️Forced proximity
⛸️Interconnected past
⛸️Grumpy x sunshine
⛸️spice
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
ARC read from netgalley
This book was a very fun read. I read it in a few hours and smiled through most of it. Wes & Isla are both easy characters to love and easy to love together. Their chemistry with each other is fairly realistic & their dynamic with their family members was easy to relate to. The storyline moved along fairly quickly, but that was part of the appeal for me, it added to the overall feel good vibe I think the author was going for. The writing of the book was strong, the plot was fun, & the spice was flirty. I'll definitely be looking into more books by Kathryn Kincaid.
This book was a very fun read. I read it in a few hours and smiled through most of it. Wes & Isla are both easy characters to love and easy to love together. Their chemistry with each other is fairly realistic & their dynamic with their family members was easy to relate to. The storyline moved along fairly quickly, but that was part of the appeal for me, it added to the overall feel good vibe I think the author was going for. The writing of the book was strong, the plot was fun, & the spice was flirty. I'll definitely be looking into more books by Kathryn Kincaid.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I was really excited to read this ice skating rom com, and I absolutely loved it. Isla is a figure skater, recently divorced from a turd of a man. She becomes partners with Spencer, a carefree and fun man. His brither, however, is so grumpy, but i loved him. The chemistry between them was so good. Loved this.
February 26, 2026
The way I loved this one!!! Oh my goodness. It was so good. I loved Wes & Isla!! From their first interaction, they had me cackling over their banter. I loved grumpy Wes, I loved Isla’s determination, I loved learning about the connections these two had, I loved the way Wes showed up for Isla even when they “hated” each other. Spencer brought lots of laughs and I loved the way he built Isla up as they worked together, and I loved seeing the dynamic between him and Wes! I also loved Thea, Wes and Spencer's niece who’s staying with Wes. This hit all the vibes, and I don’t know how to explain it other than I just loved it!!
[ARC review]
[ARC review]
Review of advance copy received from Author
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - 4 Stars
🌶 - Spice Level
Isla just got divorced recently and was dropped from her original partner pairing figure skating. She gets an opportunity to skate with another male for pairing, only to run into his grumpy brother Wes who dings her door in a parking lot before the first meeting for her new pairing. From that first meeting to even further in the book, the two of them spare with each other with all the banter and sarcasm.
Wes may be a grumpy retired hockey player, but he's a good one. He even comes as a date to her parents house for dinner only to end up ready to throw hands on her ex husband's face. When an MMC defends, but supports your dreams.. he's one of the good ones! Also, her new pairing she can finally trust has her back, full stop.
I enjoyed this story. Thank your author for the ARC!
🌶 - Spice Level
Isla just got divorced recently and was dropped from her original partner pairing figure skating. She gets an opportunity to skate with another male for pairing, only to run into his grumpy brother Wes who dings her door in a parking lot before the first meeting for her new pairing. From that first meeting to even further in the book, the two of them spare with each other with all the banter and sarcasm.
Wes may be a grumpy retired hockey player, but he's a good one. He even comes as a date to her parents house for dinner only to end up ready to throw hands on her ex husband's face. When an MMC defends, but supports your dreams.. he's one of the good ones! Also, her new pairing she can finally trust has her back, full stop.
I enjoyed this story. Thank your author for the ARC!
March 4, 2026
dislike to lovers is always a fav & I just really loved these two here. the banter was written so well and I just couldn't help falling in love with Wes and Isla. Definitely enjoyed!
March 4, 2026
Easy to read, good banter and spice.
February 3, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️ /5
I received a copy of this for my honest review.
Quite the Pair by Kathryn Kincaid is a light, spicy figure skating romance that leans hard into cozy vibes, found family, and second chances.
Isla Covington is a driven, guarded figure skater determined to rebuild her career and reputation after losing both her marriage and her skating partner. Labeled an “ice queen,” she refuses to give up on the sport she loves—especially when a new partnership offers her a fresh start.
That fresh start comes with complications in the form of Wes Davidson: a grumpy former hockey player, rink owner, and fiercely devoted family man who also happens to be her new partner’s brother—and her first teenage kiss. Wes prefers his carefully controlled life just the way it is… until Isla begins skating in his rink, joining his family for dinners, and turning his world upside down.
Isla and Wes are well-matched grumps—both bruised by past marriages, both guarded, and both clearly craving something steady and real. The thought of "what could've been" and the attraction they realized as teens is still lingering and impossible to ignore and a SPARK ensues. Their dynamic shines in the bickering-turned-flirty banter, and Wes’s quiet devotion (especially his he falls first and harder energy) is undeniably charming. The forced proximity through family dinners, the rink setting, and shared emotional baggage creates an easy, natural progression from dislike to affection.
The chemistry between Isla and Wes is undeniable. Their relationship starts with friction and sharp banter, slowly melting into flirtation, affection, and a simmering heat. One of the book’s strengths is how well their personalities match and compliment each other. They also understand each other’s walls because they’re both carrying the weight of past marriages that failed, and that shared history makes their connection feel natural and earned. I also loved Wes’s support for Isla and for defending her to her extremely insensitive family members and ex husband. Wes is just an all around green flag and I absolutely adored his character! The romance itself is sweet, spicy, and emotionally safe, making this a comforting read rather than a high-angst one.
The found family aspect is another highlight. Wes’s relationship with his niece Thea, and his figure-skater brother, Spencer, adds warmth and grounding to the story. Isla’s integration into this family—particularly through shared meals and everyday moments—reinforces the theme of healing through connection.
Now while the romance itself is sweet and engaging, I did find myself wanting more depth and character development. While we get glimpses of Isla’s and Wes’s pasts, much of that important backstory is introduced half way in the story and in small fragments. I especially wished for more detail about their first meeting, which is referenced multiple times, but the details remain vague in some ways. Considering how important that moment is to their dynamic, a clearer, more fleshed-out depiction would have strengthened the emotional payoff. I also wished to know more about Wes’s previous marriage, and his father’s dementia, his time playing hockey and why he didn’t end up accomplishing his dream of playing professionally. All of these are important to understand Wes as a character and his past and while they were very briefly touched upon, they unfortunately remain largely unexplored. Perhaps more personal memories or emotional reflection from Wes, and even Isla, could have added depth and resonance to their characters; whether it’s through more inner monologues about their personal pasts or flashback chapters. It would have made it easier to connect with the characters earlier.
In my opinion, the ending also felt somewhat rushed. The emotional resolution between Isla and Wes unfolds very quickly, with major feelings acknowledged and resolved in just a page or two. Given the slow, careful buildup throughout the book, a more fully fleshed-out conclusion would have provided a stronger sense of closure for both the characters and reader.
Overall, Quite the Pair is a sweet, figure skating romance that was a fun and easy read. It may not dive as deeply into character depth as some readers might hope, but it offers a comforting, heartfelt love story about two people reuniting and finding each other after heartbreak. If you enjoy grumpy leads, found family, and gentle second-chance romances, this book is an enjoyable read.
Thank you NetGalley, Victory Editing & Kathryn Kincaid for this ARC! This book comes out February 26th 2026!
I received a copy of this for my honest review.
Quite the Pair by Kathryn Kincaid is a light, spicy figure skating romance that leans hard into cozy vibes, found family, and second chances.
Isla Covington is a driven, guarded figure skater determined to rebuild her career and reputation after losing both her marriage and her skating partner. Labeled an “ice queen,” she refuses to give up on the sport she loves—especially when a new partnership offers her a fresh start.
That fresh start comes with complications in the form of Wes Davidson: a grumpy former hockey player, rink owner, and fiercely devoted family man who also happens to be her new partner’s brother—and her first teenage kiss. Wes prefers his carefully controlled life just the way it is… until Isla begins skating in his rink, joining his family for dinners, and turning his world upside down.
Isla and Wes are well-matched grumps—both bruised by past marriages, both guarded, and both clearly craving something steady and real. The thought of "what could've been" and the attraction they realized as teens is still lingering and impossible to ignore and a SPARK ensues. Their dynamic shines in the bickering-turned-flirty banter, and Wes’s quiet devotion (especially his he falls first and harder energy) is undeniably charming. The forced proximity through family dinners, the rink setting, and shared emotional baggage creates an easy, natural progression from dislike to affection.
The chemistry between Isla and Wes is undeniable. Their relationship starts with friction and sharp banter, slowly melting into flirtation, affection, and a simmering heat. One of the book’s strengths is how well their personalities match and compliment each other. They also understand each other’s walls because they’re both carrying the weight of past marriages that failed, and that shared history makes their connection feel natural and earned. I also loved Wes’s support for Isla and for defending her to her extremely insensitive family members and ex husband. Wes is just an all around green flag and I absolutely adored his character! The romance itself is sweet, spicy, and emotionally safe, making this a comforting read rather than a high-angst one.
The found family aspect is another highlight. Wes’s relationship with his niece Thea, and his figure-skater brother, Spencer, adds warmth and grounding to the story. Isla’s integration into this family—particularly through shared meals and everyday moments—reinforces the theme of healing through connection.
Now while the romance itself is sweet and engaging, I did find myself wanting more depth and character development. While we get glimpses of Isla’s and Wes’s pasts, much of that important backstory is introduced half way in the story and in small fragments. I especially wished for more detail about their first meeting, which is referenced multiple times, but the details remain vague in some ways. Considering how important that moment is to their dynamic, a clearer, more fleshed-out depiction would have strengthened the emotional payoff. I also wished to know more about Wes’s previous marriage, and his father’s dementia, his time playing hockey and why he didn’t end up accomplishing his dream of playing professionally. All of these are important to understand Wes as a character and his past and while they were very briefly touched upon, they unfortunately remain largely unexplored. Perhaps more personal memories or emotional reflection from Wes, and even Isla, could have added depth and resonance to their characters; whether it’s through more inner monologues about their personal pasts or flashback chapters. It would have made it easier to connect with the characters earlier.
In my opinion, the ending also felt somewhat rushed. The emotional resolution between Isla and Wes unfolds very quickly, with major feelings acknowledged and resolved in just a page or two. Given the slow, careful buildup throughout the book, a more fully fleshed-out conclusion would have provided a stronger sense of closure for both the characters and reader.
Overall, Quite the Pair is a sweet, figure skating romance that was a fun and easy read. It may not dive as deeply into character depth as some readers might hope, but it offers a comforting, heartfelt love story about two people reuniting and finding each other after heartbreak. If you enjoy grumpy leads, found family, and gentle second-chance romances, this book is an enjoyable read.
Thank you NetGalley, Victory Editing & Kathryn Kincaid for this ARC! This book comes out February 26th 2026!
February 5, 2026
•°. ❝ When I think of my future, that's what I see. You and me, Red. ❞ *࿐
✎ᝰ. ★★★★★ stars
✎ᝰ. 3/5 spice level
✎ᝰ. tropes:
𝜗𝜚 dislike to love
𝜗𝜚 grumpy x grumpy
𝜗𝜚 forced proximity
𝜗𝜚 figure skater x former hockey player
𝜗𝜚 dual POV
𝜗𝜚 he falls first and harder
˗ˏˋ ꒰ ✉︎ ꒱ ˎˊ˗
First of all, I would like to thank Victory Editing and NetGalley for providing me with the e-ARC in exchange for my honest review. Quite the Pair comes out on February 26, 2026!
I’m going to start by saying I wish this book were a thousand pages longer, because I’m not ready to say goodbye to these characters just yet. Quite the Pair is the sweetest, most beautiful, and heartwarming sports romance, with one of the most innovative takes on ice skating I have ever read. Usually in this genre, especially in pair sports like ice skating, the main couple are the partners. Kathryn Kincaid makes a brilliant and refreshing choice by making the MMC the male partner’s brother, giving us a glimpse into the reality of the sport: sometimes your true love is not your skating partner.
I devoured Isla and Wes’s romance from the start. Their chemistry is off the charts, and I found myself rooting for them from the moment they met. I love good, healthy banter, and they have it in abundance. Their personalities complement each other so well, and it is adorable watching them grow and heal together.
My favorite part of the novel was how well developed the side characters are, along with the warmth of their found family. Watching Spencer, Thea, and Brooks team up to play matchmaker and tease the main characters was incredible, and I truly hope this becomes a series so we can see more of them.
Out of everyone, Spencer was definitely my favorite. His golden retriever, cinnamon roll personality had me hooked from the start, and I loved seeing his friendship with Isla develop throughout the book. I’m absolutely in love with him, especially the scenes where he taunts Isla and Wes about their feelings. He truly has my heart, and I need a whole book about him.
If you are a fan of ice skating romance, stories about healing from past trauma and opening yourself up to love again, and the “he falls first and harder” trope, then you need to add Quite the Pair to your TBR. It’s a magical novel and, dare I say, perfect for anyone looking to get out of a reading slump, since it’s lighthearted and easy to read.
•°. ❝ Your existence challenges me to be a better man, one who deserves you. Everything I thought I knew about myself and my life has been turned on its head by you. It scares the shit out of me, but I've never felt more alive. ❞ *࿐
✎ᝰ. trigger warnings (possible spoilers): divorce, drug addiction (recovering), mental illness (dementia), challenging family circumstances, explicit content
February 28, 2026
Reading this book was a pleasure – I loved the tension between the characters, their banter, and the fact that they didn't pretend to each other to be someone they weren't.
Wes and Isla have experienced a lot of bad things in their lives. Isla's family sucks – her parents, ex-husband, and ex-mother-in-law are hopeless people who profit from other people's misfortunes and missteps, and the only things they care about are money, a good reputation, and pretending to be the perfect family. Isla's ex-ice-hockey partner was also a total jerk.
I felt so sorry for Brooksy and Isla – they didn't deserve such terrible parents, but they grew up to be wonderful people, had each other, and really got along – they would do anything for one another. My heart broke when I found out what happened in Brooksy's in the past, but he didn't give up and fought for himself. I would love to read his story too.
Isla is a woman with a sharp tongue, determined to get her way, she loves skating But behind her confident facade, behind her sharp remarks, was a woman who was insecure because the people who should have supported her were undermining her and failed her in supporting and giving her love.
After returning to the ice with Spencer, Wes's brother, who chose her as his partner, Isla regains her radiance and works hard to make it all work out. I love that she finally found her family, because Spencer, Thea, the boys' niece, and Wes simply took her in, into their circle, just like that one day, without any demands for reciprocity. "We are family Isla." And Wes... this guy is a grumpy green flag – he would do anything for his loved ones. He remembered the details, he cared about them. He remembered what tea his niece drank every night before bed and prepared it for her - I'm a fucki g puddle on the floor. He was there for her, supporting her, taking care of because her mother had just decided to go on a reality show and drop her off with her brothers. And they both were there for her. He also supported his brother wholeheartedly and wanted Isla and Spencer's on-ice partnership to work out.
And with Isla, this guy opened up, remembered every little detail they talked about with her when they were teenagers. He was charmed by her. Their paths diverged in the past, only to reconnect in a rather unpleasant situation one day. Because they were meant to be together. This guy was enchanted by her skating and the effort she put into it all and he supported her with
And I have to mention this book was steamy. There were a few spicy scenes, but they were written really well and sensitively.
I give this book a 4 star⭐️
Wes and Isla have experienced a lot of bad things in their lives. Isla's family sucks – her parents, ex-husband, and ex-mother-in-law are hopeless people who profit from other people's misfortunes and missteps, and the only things they care about are money, a good reputation, and pretending to be the perfect family. Isla's ex-ice-hockey partner was also a total jerk.
I felt so sorry for Brooksy and Isla – they didn't deserve such terrible parents, but they grew up to be wonderful people, had each other, and really got along – they would do anything for one another. My heart broke when I found out what happened in Brooksy's in the past, but he didn't give up and fought for himself. I would love to read his story too.
Isla is a woman with a sharp tongue, determined to get her way, she loves skating But behind her confident facade, behind her sharp remarks, was a woman who was insecure because the people who should have supported her were undermining her and failed her in supporting and giving her love.
After returning to the ice with Spencer, Wes's brother, who chose her as his partner, Isla regains her radiance and works hard to make it all work out. I love that she finally found her family, because Spencer, Thea, the boys' niece, and Wes simply took her in, into their circle, just like that one day, without any demands for reciprocity. "We are family Isla." And Wes... this guy is a grumpy green flag – he would do anything for his loved ones. He remembered the details, he cared about them. He remembered what tea his niece drank every night before bed and prepared it for her - I'm a fucki g puddle on the floor. He was there for her, supporting her, taking care of because her mother had just decided to go on a reality show and drop her off with her brothers. And they both were there for her. He also supported his brother wholeheartedly and wanted Isla and Spencer's on-ice partnership to work out.
And with Isla, this guy opened up, remembered every little detail they talked about with her when they were teenagers. He was charmed by her. Their paths diverged in the past, only to reconnect in a rather unpleasant situation one day. Because they were meant to be together. This guy was enchanted by her skating and the effort she put into it all and he supported her with
And I have to mention this book was steamy. There were a few spicy scenes, but they were written really well and sensitively.
I give this book a 4 star⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received a free copy of this publication for the purpose of review.
Isabella 'Isla' Covington's career seems to have hit a dead end after her divorce and subsequent split from her pairs figure skating partner. She's worried she'll never skate professionally again until she gets an offer from a very unlikely source, Spencer Davidson, whose own career was in question after his previous pairs partner retired. But when Isla moves to start practice with Spencer she realizes that Spencer's brother, Wesley, was her first kiss over a decade ago, and the scrawny boy she remembers is not who she meets in the parking lot getting coffee. Has their chemistry survived the intervening years and heartbreak, or will this be one more roadblock?
"But if I had to boil it down, I'd say it's because my soul knows peace when you're near me."
This was such, such a great read and I basically devoured it within 24 hours. Both Isla and Wes were immediately relatable. They're both older, they've both lived years and seen life, so they have a lot of experiences that drew me in. Wes has been a primary caretaker for his father with dementia alongside providing a sense of stability for their family. Isla has had to fight for her independence and ability to pursue her career and passion. I could really feel the years they've lived, which I love to see in a book.
The side characters are great here, especially Wes' family. Spencer is a constant ball of sunshine and he brings some much needed levity to both Isla and Wes. I especially enjoy that Spencer shows his genuine affection for Isla. He hugs her, they play around and goof off sometimes during practice. It feels like a healthy and authentic relationship with a good friend. I would have liked to see more of Wes' niece, Thea, as her character and role are great and I loved Isla's growing relationship with her.
The spice was really great for me, and definitely carried by Isla. I am all in on her knowing what she wants and asking for it whenever she wants it. I want to see more of that in books and it was so incredibly refreshing to see her take charge in her and Wes' encounters. That's not to say Wes doesn't have his charms, he certainly does. But God does Isla push his buttons and it's so fun to read.
I'm so glad I got a chance to read an advanced copy of this. I finished and immediately pre-ordered a signed copy because I want to have this on my shelf, and I can't wait to read more from Kathryn!
Isabella 'Isla' Covington's career seems to have hit a dead end after her divorce and subsequent split from her pairs figure skating partner. She's worried she'll never skate professionally again until she gets an offer from a very unlikely source, Spencer Davidson, whose own career was in question after his previous pairs partner retired. But when Isla moves to start practice with Spencer she realizes that Spencer's brother, Wesley, was her first kiss over a decade ago, and the scrawny boy she remembers is not who she meets in the parking lot getting coffee. Has their chemistry survived the intervening years and heartbreak, or will this be one more roadblock?
"But if I had to boil it down, I'd say it's because my soul knows peace when you're near me."
This was such, such a great read and I basically devoured it within 24 hours. Both Isla and Wes were immediately relatable. They're both older, they've both lived years and seen life, so they have a lot of experiences that drew me in. Wes has been a primary caretaker for his father with dementia alongside providing a sense of stability for their family. Isla has had to fight for her independence and ability to pursue her career and passion. I could really feel the years they've lived, which I love to see in a book.
The side characters are great here, especially Wes' family. Spencer is a constant ball of sunshine and he brings some much needed levity to both Isla and Wes. I especially enjoy that Spencer shows his genuine affection for Isla. He hugs her, they play around and goof off sometimes during practice. It feels like a healthy and authentic relationship with a good friend. I would have liked to see more of Wes' niece, Thea, as her character and role are great and I loved Isla's growing relationship with her.
The spice was really great for me, and definitely carried by Isla. I am all in on her knowing what she wants and asking for it whenever she wants it. I want to see more of that in books and it was so incredibly refreshing to see her take charge in her and Wes' encounters. That's not to say Wes doesn't have his charms, he certainly does. But God does Isla push his buttons and it's so fun to read.
I'm so glad I got a chance to read an advanced copy of this. I finished and immediately pre-ordered a signed copy because I want to have this on my shelf, and I can't wait to read more from Kathryn!
Review of advance copy received from Author
⛸️ Second Chance Romance
⛸️ Grumpy x Grumpy
⛸️ Figure Skater x Ex-Hockey Player
⛸️ Forced Proximity
Isla is going through a lot at the start of this book, not only is she navigating her life post divorce, but she’s also having to warm up to her new skating partner (and his brother).
I really admired Isla and the way she repaired her relationship with skating by having a healthy partnership with Spencer with solid communication and boundaries. I feel like this book is not only a second chance romance between Isla and Wes, but also a second chance romance for Isla and ice skating. Isla has to start over again in a sport that used to rule her existence and learn to trust Spencer (and herself), to really fall back in love with the sport that she dedicated a huge amount of her life to.
Wes and Isla started off as enemies that slowly over time, morphed into something I don’t think either one of them expected. I really enjoyed Isla and Wes together, I loved how they both developed separately in a very linear way, so when they finally gave in to each other it was ✨perfectly executed✨. They couldn’t be more different and yet at the same time they are exactly the same person. I feel like Wes is probably one of the first people to really see Isla for who she is and not immediately assume who she is based on her family name and I don’t think anyone challenges Wes more than Isla does.
Also, an important side note, Wes calling Isla “red” really made him 10x hotter which is hard to do because he’s so grumpy and confident in himself already and it’s almost not fair to all the mmcs that came before him. Alexei Volkov is still #1 but Wes is up there, speaking of past mmcs…I LOVED the little cameo we got at the rink and would read an entire book about a hockey camp run by some of our past favs.
I have found that amongst the many sports romance writers only a handful come close to writing such genuine and authentic characters as Kathryn Kincaid and it’s what brings me back to her books every time. A testament to the writing was that I really found myself wanting Isla and Wes to find their way back to each other and for Isla to fall in love with skating again (was I inspired to watch Alysa Liu’s free skate again? Yes I was).
A huge thank you to Kathryn Kincaid for allowing me to read an ARC of this book, after that Alexei Volkov cameo, I will be re-reading ‘Play your Part’ again 💅.
⛸️ Grumpy x Grumpy
⛸️ Figure Skater x Ex-Hockey Player
⛸️ Forced Proximity
Isla is going through a lot at the start of this book, not only is she navigating her life post divorce, but she’s also having to warm up to her new skating partner (and his brother).
I really admired Isla and the way she repaired her relationship with skating by having a healthy partnership with Spencer with solid communication and boundaries. I feel like this book is not only a second chance romance between Isla and Wes, but also a second chance romance for Isla and ice skating. Isla has to start over again in a sport that used to rule her existence and learn to trust Spencer (and herself), to really fall back in love with the sport that she dedicated a huge amount of her life to.
Wes and Isla started off as enemies that slowly over time, morphed into something I don’t think either one of them expected. I really enjoyed Isla and Wes together, I loved how they both developed separately in a very linear way, so when they finally gave in to each other it was ✨perfectly executed✨. They couldn’t be more different and yet at the same time they are exactly the same person. I feel like Wes is probably one of the first people to really see Isla for who she is and not immediately assume who she is based on her family name and I don’t think anyone challenges Wes more than Isla does.
Also, an important side note, Wes calling Isla “red” really made him 10x hotter which is hard to do because he’s so grumpy and confident in himself already and it’s almost not fair to all the mmcs that came before him. Alexei Volkov is still #1 but Wes is up there, speaking of past mmcs…I LOVED the little cameo we got at the rink and would read an entire book about a hockey camp run by some of our past favs.
I have found that amongst the many sports romance writers only a handful come close to writing such genuine and authentic characters as Kathryn Kincaid and it’s what brings me back to her books every time. A testament to the writing was that I really found myself wanting Isla and Wes to find their way back to each other and for Isla to fall in love with skating again (was I inspired to watch Alysa Liu’s free skate again? Yes I was).
A huge thank you to Kathryn Kincaid for allowing me to read an ARC of this book, after that Alexei Volkov cameo, I will be re-reading ‘Play your Part’ again 💅.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you to the author for an eARC of this book. These are my honest opinions.
Quite the Pair is about the media-dubbed "Ice Queen" Isla Covington who moves back to her home state of North Carolina to pair up with a new ice skating pairs partner, Spencer Davidson. Isla has had multiple life changes in a short period of time including a divorce. Wes Davidson is the owner of the rink that Isla and Spencer practice at and Spencer's protective older brother. No one is better at getting under his skin than Isla. Isla and Wes rival each other in grumpiness, but their chemistry is undeniable.
There is something very special about Kathryn's ability to inject vulnerability on-page in a way that is relatable off-page. These characters felt like real people to me. Some of my favorite authors have a way of creating wholesome characters that also have layers. These characters are still likable when we are presented with their imperfections and mistakes. This author is easily becoming a favorite of mine.
Isla has multiple conflicts in her life (recent divorce, lack of supportive parents, sordid media history, etc), but this story focused on the growth of her relationship with Wes. I found this to be very refreshing. We know that Isla has other things going on in her life, but the perspective we get to see is in this particular area of her life. We also know that Wes is a caretaker of sorts and now has taken on a role of guardian for his niece. Again, these things are touched on but are not the forefront of the story. I couldn't have asked for a better delivery.
I was able to read this book in just a few sittings as it continuously held my attention. It is hard for me to explain the giddiness I felt while reading this. The banter! The yearning! The characters acted like adults and were honest with each other. I loved the other characters in this story as well the cameos of characters from some of this author's other books.
I've been trying to put a finger on what exactly is special about this book and I've come to a conclusion. While I enjoy a comeback plot, likable characters, and fun dialogue, there is something extra that makes this combination really come together. The storytelling in this book is what distinguishes it from others for me. I really loved it.
Quite the Pair is about the media-dubbed "Ice Queen" Isla Covington who moves back to her home state of North Carolina to pair up with a new ice skating pairs partner, Spencer Davidson. Isla has had multiple life changes in a short period of time including a divorce. Wes Davidson is the owner of the rink that Isla and Spencer practice at and Spencer's protective older brother. No one is better at getting under his skin than Isla. Isla and Wes rival each other in grumpiness, but their chemistry is undeniable.
There is something very special about Kathryn's ability to inject vulnerability on-page in a way that is relatable off-page. These characters felt like real people to me. Some of my favorite authors have a way of creating wholesome characters that also have layers. These characters are still likable when we are presented with their imperfections and mistakes. This author is easily becoming a favorite of mine.
Isla has multiple conflicts in her life (recent divorce, lack of supportive parents, sordid media history, etc), but this story focused on the growth of her relationship with Wes. I found this to be very refreshing. We know that Isla has other things going on in her life, but the perspective we get to see is in this particular area of her life. We also know that Wes is a caretaker of sorts and now has taken on a role of guardian for his niece. Again, these things are touched on but are not the forefront of the story. I couldn't have asked for a better delivery.
I was able to read this book in just a few sittings as it continuously held my attention. It is hard for me to explain the giddiness I felt while reading this. The banter! The yearning! The characters acted like adults and were honest with each other. I loved the other characters in this story as well the cameos of characters from some of this author's other books.
I've been trying to put a finger on what exactly is special about this book and I've come to a conclusion. While I enjoy a comeback plot, likable characters, and fun dialogue, there is something extra that makes this combination really come together. The storytelling in this book is what distinguishes it from others for me. I really loved it.
March 1, 2026
ARC REVIEW
Isla is a driven, guarded figure skater determined to rebuild her career and reputation after losing both her marriage and her skating partner. Labeled an “ice queen,” she refuses to walk away from the sport she loves—especially when a new partnership offers her a chance at redemption.
That fresh start comes with complications in the form of Wes—a grumpy former hockey player, rink owner, and fiercely devoted family man who also happens to be her new partner’s brother… and her first teenage kiss. Wes has long viewed Isla as the privileged girl who never reached out all those years ago. Determined to protect both his heart and his brother’s, he sets firm boundaries between them.
Isla and Wes are perfectly matched in their guarded nature. Both are bruised by failed marriages, both hesitant to trust again, yet both clearly longing for something steady and real. The lingering “what could have been” from their teenage years sparks undeniable tension. What begins as friction and sharp banter slowly melts into flirtation, affection, and simmering heat. Their shared understanding of heartbreak makes their connection feel natural and earned.
The found-family element is another highlight. Wes’s relationship with his niece, Thea, and his figure-skater brother, Spencer, adds warmth and grounding to the story.
While the romance itself is sweet and engaging, I did find myself wanting more depth. Much of Isla and Wes’s backstory is introduced midway through the book and in brief fragments. Their first meeting—referenced often and clearly pivotal—remains somewhat vague, and a fuller depiction would have strengthened the emotional payoff. I also wished for more exploration of Wes’s past: his previous marriage, his father’s dementia, his hockey career, and why he never fulfilled his professional dreams. These elements are touched on but not deeply explored, and additional emotional reflection or flashbacks could have added greater resonance and earlier connection to both characters.
The ending, too, felt somewhat rushed. After a careful and steady buildup, the emotional resolution happens quickly, with major feelings acknowledged and resolved within a short span. A more fully developed conclusion would have provided a stronger sense of closure.
Overall, this is a heartfelt, tension-filled romance with compelling characters and strong chemistry—one that shines in its emotional premise but could have benefitted from deeper exploration to truly elevate its impact.
Isla is a driven, guarded figure skater determined to rebuild her career and reputation after losing both her marriage and her skating partner. Labeled an “ice queen,” she refuses to walk away from the sport she loves—especially when a new partnership offers her a chance at redemption.
That fresh start comes with complications in the form of Wes—a grumpy former hockey player, rink owner, and fiercely devoted family man who also happens to be her new partner’s brother… and her first teenage kiss. Wes has long viewed Isla as the privileged girl who never reached out all those years ago. Determined to protect both his heart and his brother’s, he sets firm boundaries between them.
Isla and Wes are perfectly matched in their guarded nature. Both are bruised by failed marriages, both hesitant to trust again, yet both clearly longing for something steady and real. The lingering “what could have been” from their teenage years sparks undeniable tension. What begins as friction and sharp banter slowly melts into flirtation, affection, and simmering heat. Their shared understanding of heartbreak makes their connection feel natural and earned.
The found-family element is another highlight. Wes’s relationship with his niece, Thea, and his figure-skater brother, Spencer, adds warmth and grounding to the story.
While the romance itself is sweet and engaging, I did find myself wanting more depth. Much of Isla and Wes’s backstory is introduced midway through the book and in brief fragments. Their first meeting—referenced often and clearly pivotal—remains somewhat vague, and a fuller depiction would have strengthened the emotional payoff. I also wished for more exploration of Wes’s past: his previous marriage, his father’s dementia, his hockey career, and why he never fulfilled his professional dreams. These elements are touched on but not deeply explored, and additional emotional reflection or flashbacks could have added greater resonance and earlier connection to both characters.
The ending, too, felt somewhat rushed. After a careful and steady buildup, the emotional resolution happens quickly, with major feelings acknowledged and resolved within a short span. A more fully developed conclusion would have provided a stronger sense of closure.
Overall, this is a heartfelt, tension-filled romance with compelling characters and strong chemistry—one that shines in its emotional premise but could have benefitted from deeper exploration to truly elevate its impact.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Kathryn Kincaid’s Quite the Pair wrecked my peaceful reading plans in the best possible way, because I picked it up for “a few pages” and suddenly it was hours later and I was emotionally invested.
Self-published, with sincere thanks to the publisher for my gifted ARC.
This is the kind of romance that sneaks up on you while pretending to be chill. It doesn’t shout. It simmers. It settles in beside you with a blanket and then casually rips open feelings you forgot you had. Reading this felt like stepping into a cold rink with warm lights overhead. You know it’s going to hurt a little, but you trust the process anyway.
Isla and Wes are both grumpy in different, deeply relatable ways, and I loved that neither of them is interested in being fixed. Isla’s drive and sharp edges felt refreshing rather than exhausting, and Wes’s quiet steadiness paired with his emotional restraint made every small crack in his armor feel earned. This isn’t a story about grand gestures. It’s about presence, patience, and choosing to stay when walking away would be easier.
The banter is smart, the tension builds slowly, and the forced proximity never feels forced. Watching their irritation turn into understanding and then into something undeniably tender was ridiculously satisfying. One line that stuck with me was, “Some walls aren’t meant to be destroyed. They’re meant to be trusted enough to step around.” That sentiment perfectly captures the heart of this book.
Reading Quite the Pair felt cozy and sharp all at once, like drinking hot coffee after coming in from the cold. I smiled, I sighed, and yes, I absolutely muttered “oh no” when Wes started falling first and harder. This landed solidly at a five-star read for me, the kind you recommend immediately and then think about later when the house is quiet.
If you love grumpy x grumpy energy, slow-burn tension, emotionally grounded romance, and characters who feel like real adults navigating real mess, this one is for you. So tell me, are you a sucker for winter romances that quietly steal your heart, or do you pretend you’re not while absolutely being one?
#QuiteThePair #KathrynKincaid #BreakingBarriersSeries #RomanceBookReview #FigureSkatingRomance #GrumpyRomance #HeFallsFirst #WinterReads #ARCReview #RomanceReaders
Self-published, with sincere thanks to the publisher for my gifted ARC.
This is the kind of romance that sneaks up on you while pretending to be chill. It doesn’t shout. It simmers. It settles in beside you with a blanket and then casually rips open feelings you forgot you had. Reading this felt like stepping into a cold rink with warm lights overhead. You know it’s going to hurt a little, but you trust the process anyway.
Isla and Wes are both grumpy in different, deeply relatable ways, and I loved that neither of them is interested in being fixed. Isla’s drive and sharp edges felt refreshing rather than exhausting, and Wes’s quiet steadiness paired with his emotional restraint made every small crack in his armor feel earned. This isn’t a story about grand gestures. It’s about presence, patience, and choosing to stay when walking away would be easier.
The banter is smart, the tension builds slowly, and the forced proximity never feels forced. Watching their irritation turn into understanding and then into something undeniably tender was ridiculously satisfying. One line that stuck with me was, “Some walls aren’t meant to be destroyed. They’re meant to be trusted enough to step around.” That sentiment perfectly captures the heart of this book.
Reading Quite the Pair felt cozy and sharp all at once, like drinking hot coffee after coming in from the cold. I smiled, I sighed, and yes, I absolutely muttered “oh no” when Wes started falling first and harder. This landed solidly at a five-star read for me, the kind you recommend immediately and then think about later when the house is quiet.
If you love grumpy x grumpy energy, slow-burn tension, emotionally grounded romance, and characters who feel like real adults navigating real mess, this one is for you. So tell me, are you a sucker for winter romances that quietly steal your heart, or do you pretend you’re not while absolutely being one?
#QuiteThePair #KathrynKincaid #BreakingBarriersSeries #RomanceBookReview #FigureSkatingRomance #GrumpyRomance #HeFallsFirst #WinterReads #ARCReview #RomanceReaders
Displaying 1 - 30 of 204 reviews